Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |183 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Mar 20, 2024

Kanchan Rai has 10 years of experience in therapy, nurturing soft skills and leadership coaching. She is the founder of the Let Us Talk Foundation, which offers mindfulness workshops to help people stay emotionally and mentally healthy.
Rai has a degree in leadership development and customer centricity from Harvard Business School, Boston. She is an internationally certified coach from the International Coaching Federation, a global organisation in professional coaching.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Feb 19, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship

Hello, I am 35 years old. Married. Not living with husband since an year, as he flirted with an office girl (this is the extent of it that I caught) and has tendency to do so. He is not emotionally aware (of himself or me) and I keep getting hurt as I am quite emotional. Also, I am not on talking terms with his parents as they had tried to sabotage our marriage in different ways on countless occasions. My husband wont agree (not that I want him to agree), but I think that's one reason of our increasing differences. I love him, but cannot find in my heart to move back with him ever again. We have a 5 year old kid, due to whom I am unable to move ahead with divorce. I am stuck in the midst, not knowing where to go next or stay in this same 'married but separated ' position forever. I'm definitely happier without the everyday petty bickering that we had when we lived together (which was turning me into a bitter and angry person, I don't want to be that). I have turned extremely distrustful of him. I do feel very lonely at times. We also went to a guidance counsellor to make the relation work some 1.5 years back, but my husband felt its a waste of money after 5 sessions, also he never invested in the emotional sorting that the counsellor mentioned our relation required. Any guidance?

Ans: It sounds like you're facing a complex and challenging situation. Here are some steps you might consider as you navigate your next steps:

Take care of yourself first and foremost. This means prioritizing your mental and emotional well-being. Consider seeking support from a therapist or counselor who can help you process your feelings, develop coping strategies, and explore your options moving forward.
Take some time to reflect on what you want for yourself and your child in the long term. Consider what kind of environment you want to create for your child, as well as what you need in terms of emotional fulfillment and stability.
If you feel comfortable, consider having an open and honest conversation with your husband about your concerns and feelings. Express how his actions have affected you and what you need from him moving forward. However, be prepared for the possibility that he may not be receptive or willing to change.
Consult with a family law attorney to understand your rights and options regarding divorce, custody, and child support. They can provide guidance tailored to your specific situation and help you navigate the legal process.
Regardless of whether you choose to stay married or pursue divorce, prioritize effective co-parenting for the well-being of your child. This may involve setting clear boundaries, communicating openly about parenting decisions, and prioritizing your child's needs above any personal conflicts.
Consider exploring alternative living arrangements or custody agreements that may better suit your needs and preferences. This could include living separately while co-parenting, or exploring shared custody arrangements that provide stability for your child while allowing you to maintain some distance from your husband.
Reach out to friends, family members, or support groups for additional support and guidance. It can be helpful to connect with others who have gone through similar experiences and can offer empathy, advice, and solidarity.
Ultimately, the decision of whether to stay married or pursue divorce is a deeply personal one that only you can make. Take your time, trust your instincts, and prioritize your own well-being and that of your child as you navigate this challenging process.

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Anu

Anu Krishna  |839 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on May 25, 2022

Listen
Relationship
Hi, me and my husband are married for 12 years now, we have a daughter. Both of us are totally different, like north and south pole. He is very extrovert, tries to be the centre of attention, always needs his social circle, his work, friends circle is all that matters to him. I am a total introvert. I don't care about having friends, I hate parties, all that matters to me is my family. First few years, he made me feel that I am a misfit in this world and I had a huge pressure to be an extrovert like him. He was always like how can this famous Mr Extrovert can have such an introvert wife, that's so shameful. I tried changing myself because I was so desperate for his love and respect. All that mattered to him was my looks, how I conducted myself in front of people and after pregnancy, all that bothered him was my weight gain. I started hating myself, believed that maybe I just don't deserve to be loved. I went into depression after pregnancy. I had to leave my job to take care of my baby, his mom who was bed ridden by then, his dad who had serious health issues. I told him, thought he would at least care then. It took him 3 years after that to even come with me to a psychiatrist. He never cared. I always thought it’s my fault, tried to patch things up but now I am tired, really tired. I feel suffocated. I am afraid of separating from him. As a person, he is good but we are totally misfit for each other. I still cannot come to terms with all the emotional abuse I went through. He didn't intend to harm me, he thought he is only helping me to improve and be better but now, I don't know what to do, I am not happy.
Ans:

Dear SN, It’s a wonder why anyone would go to such lengths to change themselves for another; especially their personalities: what makes them who they are! All in the name of saving relationships and love.

True love within a relationship doesn’t demand that the other person change themselves upside down, but it embraces who the other person is unconditionally.

And what makes you think that an extroverted person has the right to change an introverted person?

Did you try and change him to be like you? No! Then why is the reverse even being given so much importance. Also, your husband does not any right to mock you!

His world is different from yours as much as your world is different from yours. And kindly remember: Extroverts (if you want to label them), ate people who are happy with a lot of company around them, are vocal about liking being in a crowd and having a good time spending time with people.

They are not ones who poke fun at the way their spouses look, try and change them to suit their personalities.

So, who you are living with right now is a man with very poor self-esteem and huge insecurities and is blaming you for these and trying to change you will make him feel better.

Do not feed into this game; as once you begin to show that you will yield to his demands, that’s all you are going to do for life. He has to change from within!

He has to understand that what is going on within him is the cause of his misery and not you. But of course, doing something for a spouse even when you don’t like it has to be out of your own will and not forced. Now you take a call as to how you are going to deal with this in your marriage.

READ WHAT YOU HAVE WRITTEN: He didn't intend to harm me, he thought he is only helping me to improve and be better!

Do you really need help or does he? You have started to actually believe that you are at fault and that it is your problem.

Bottom line: You change only if you wish to and that too with things that don’t challenge your value systems. Never be forced into anything; period!

Either sit him down and assert this point or ask him to visit a professional to take care of his state of mind.

All the best!

..Read more

Anu

Anu Krishna  |839 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Jul 22, 2022

Listen
Relationship
Hi Anu, it's been 5 years of my marriage. From the last few months I am feeling disconnected from my husband. I ask him about it. He mentioned that he met a guy somewhere in November and had a one-night stand with him. He explained to me the initiation was from him and that he likes him. After few days of conversation with him my husband started having feelings for him. But it was for limited time period coz that guy was trying on someone else or many others (according to my husband) A few days earlier he mentioned that he is being confused if he is gay or straight. He now has feeling for another guy but he has a family and sees him as friend. My husband is continuously telling me to understand him. He needs to find him etc etc... And deep down I know he has no future with any other man. He doesn't feel any physical attraction towards me (it's what I think). I do like him. Physically also. But he doesn't. We don't have any child. He is 36, I am 34.Now I am super confused what to do. I do love him. Please help.
Ans:

Dear KS,

It’s still unfortunate largely in our country and in few other places outside of India, sexual preferences and orientation is still considered a taboo or something to shoved under the carpet.

It’s treated as an illness that will go away like a cold and fever.

Your marriage possibly comes under this confusion and hence both you and your husband are struggling.

He never got a chance to figure out which gender he leans into more maybe due to societal pressure or from family; and it has surfaced after marriage.

For you, it feels like you have been cheated and though you love him, do know that it might not be a marriage that might work especially if he chooses to root himself to his current sexual orientation.

I suggest you weigh out the pros and cons of being in this marriage and have a frank discussion with your husband.

If he has nothing to offer to you and in this marriage, you know what is to be done.

Whatever it be, do know that this has happened at the right time; just imagine the confusions if there were children in the picture.

If after the discussion, it was just something that he experimented with, I guess there might be scope to grow into the marriage.

Have that discussion and do that NOW; a lot will ease.

Yes, it perhaps might be a heartbreak, but better to MOVE either way.

Be strong and all the best!

..Read more

Anu

Anu Krishna  |839 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Aug 05, 2022

Relationship
I want to keep it anonymous.I am a 30 years old independent woman married for 5 months only.My husband and I were in same college but were not friends.He had been approaching me for getting married since 2017, but every time I had rejected his proposal, later in February, 2021 I talked to him openly and mentioned my inability to conceive if we get married.To which his response was that he really liked me and is ready to accept me with my inability.I made our families met and we got engaged.During the one year of courtship period, initial 4-5 months were peaceful, but he and I were missing a bond, yet we thought may be with time we will find it.After the initial phase as we started meeting for family functions.He started finding flaws in me. Things like, I stare at other men when I go out, I don’t give him priority, why do I talk to any male friend beyond necessity, why do I praise my senior at office parties etc.He started controlling me in these areas and used to get angry if I talk to my siblings late night.I started feeling trapped and suffocated, and always under the fear that any of my action could make my husband angry.In that anger he seemed like a very different person, someone aggressive.We started fighting, arguing over petty things.He wanted me to change but I was reluctant as those were very normal things for me and I started telling him that this relationship is not working.We are two persons with different mindset and ideologies and since we are unable to reach to a solution over any issue, let’s call it off.I tried to call this wedding off for like 6 times, but he never agreed to this stating that he loves me and he will change his attitude and will not stop me from doing anything.Whenever I tried to break up with him he'd start crying, stating things like you are my only happiness in life, and I would die without you and all.I involved my family into the matter and shared things with them.They used to call my husband to make him understand my expectations from him.In front of them my husband used to admit that he would change his behaviour.He used to stay calm for 5-6 days and then continue with the same attitude.Basically, it was an on and off behaviour from his side and because of that my behaviour was also affected.I was trying to see his positive side as he had accepted me with my inability, so he must be a good person.Somehow, after so many issues, we got married.After marriage, we went for honeymoon, but he showed a different attitude.He started insulting me that I stare at other people, including the waiter.He would fight with me aggressively, and when I cry he'd calm me down stating that this fight is my fault; had I not done this he would not have fought; had I obeyed him he would not have gotten angry. Then he used to make love to me.For 4 days this happened continuously.On the 4th day I told him I cannot stand him and bear his mind numbing torture.If he sees so many flaws in my character we must part our ways, and there is not point of staying together.He agreed but later he started apologising, asking for another chance to this marriage. I agreed.But his behaviour didn’t improve much. We used to live with his parents, he started taking active participation in local politics which used to keep him busy.He started controlling me indirectly for visiting my moms and relatives.He'd taunt me for not sharing my salary with his parents.Later I found out his work is not running smooth and he is not making enough.The issue of staring at men and shaking hands with men while greeting congratulations, was also an issue to him.He'd remain normal as long as I did things as per his wish.If I said or did anything opposite, he'd get aggressive and disrespectful towards me.Love was nowhere around. He never said I am a good looking woman. My husband rarely complimented me though I get many whenever I go out.He seemed not to be bothered about me except for the time I do something he doesn’t like.My mom also supported him. His behaviour started taking a toll on my mental condition and I started feeling uncomfortable around him.I stopped being physical as I was feeling emotionally detached.The fights had broken me, my bare minimum expectations were not fulfilled.My husband also broke relations with my family and was disrespectful to them.Initially he had promised that I will be free to visit my mom whenever I want and he will not seek my salary ever or doubt my character, but nothing turned to be true.After 4 months of torture, I came to my mom's place and told my husband that I cannot live with him.I actually feel much better without him. As soon as he knew that I am leaving him he has surrendered and is admitting that he made mistakes and doesn’t want to lose me.He says I am his only hope in life and he loves me a lot and can’t live without me.He does the same emotional drama every time I try to part ways with him.My family is pressurising me to give him another chance. But my trust is shattered beyond repair.He made my cry, he pushed me into depression.I do not respect him. He accepted me with my inability, but I feel he never liked the real me.He is not ready to admit this fact that we have not been good for each other.To me he seems like a male chauvinist, a dominating and controlling person.He stays grumpy most of the time, behaves well with others but is arrogant with family members.What do I do? I am in utter confusion, I am unable to force myself into a love-less marriage and my family and husband doesn’t understand it.(I am a government officer and my husband runs a small business)
Ans:

Dear MK,

This is a classic case of crying out, blaming the spouse for the crying and sending her on a guilt trip, promising to do better, not following through and when she walks out, crying out again.

It's cyclical and traps you within in the loop.

He really needs to work out his stuff with a professional, else this is going to be something that you have to deal with repeatedly.

To not be able to take responsibility for his actions, shifting blame onto you, acting insecure and preventing you from leading your life the way that you are used to -- like talking to your family and friends -- are all red flags.

Step up, take charge and suggest that he goes to a professional if he wants the marriage to work.

If he doesn’t and continues the same way, you know what you must do to secure yourself and your life.

All the best!

    ..Read more

    Anu

    Anu Krishna  |839 Answers  |Ask -

    Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Aug 05, 2022

    Relationship
    I want to keep it anonymous.I am a 30 years old independent woman married for 5 months only.My husband and I were in same college but were not friends.He had been approaching me for getting married since 2017, but every time I had rejected his proposal, later in February, 2021 I talked to him openly and mentioned my inability to conceive if we get married.To which his response was that he really liked me and is ready to accept me with my inability.I made our families met and we got engaged.During the one year of courtship period, initial 4-5 months were peaceful, but he and I were missing a bond, yet we thought may be with time we will find it.After the initial phase as we started meeting for family functions.He started finding flaws in me. Things like, I stare at other men when I go out, I don’t give him priority, why do I talk to any male friend beyond necessity, why do I praise my senior at office parties etc.He started controlling me in these areas and used to get angry if I talk to my siblings late night.I started feeling trapped and suffocated, and always under the fear that any of my action could make my husband angry.In that anger he seemed like a very different person, someone aggressive.We started fighting, arguing over petty things.He wanted me to change but I was reluctant as those were very normal things for me and I started telling him that this relationship is not working.We are two persons with different mindset and ideologies and since we are unable to reach to a solution over any issue, let’s call it off.I tried to call this wedding off for like 6 times, but he never agreed to this stating that he loves me and he will change his attitude and will not stop me from doing anything.Whenever I tried to break up with him he'd start crying, stating things like you are my only happiness in life, and I would die without you and all.I involved my family into the matter and shared things with them.They used to call my husband to make him understand my expectations from him.In front of them my husband used to admit that he would change his behaviour.He used to stay calm for 5-6 days and then continue with the same attitude.Basically, it was an on and off behaviour from his side and because of that my behaviour was also affected.I was trying to see his positive side as he had accepted me with my inability, so he must be a good person.Somehow, after so many issues, we got married.After marriage, we went for honeymoon, but he showed a different attitude.He started insulting me that I stare at other people, including the waiter.He would fight with me aggressively, and when I cry he'd calm me down stating that this fight is my fault; had I not done this he would not have fought; had I obeyed him he would not have gotten angry. Then he used to make love to me.For 4 days this happened continuously.On the 4th day I told him I cannot stand him and bear his mind numbing torture.If he sees so many flaws in my character we must part our ways, and there is not point of staying together.He agreed but later he started apologising, asking for another chance to this marriage. I agreed.But his behaviour didn’t improve much. We used to live with his parents, he started taking active participation in local politics which used to keep him busy.He started controlling me indirectly for visiting my moms and relatives.He'd taunt me for not sharing my salary with his parents.Later I found out his work is not running smooth and he is not making enough.The issue of staring at men and shaking hands with men while greeting congratulations, was also an issue to him.He'd remain normal as long as I did things as per his wish.If I said or did anything opposite, he'd get aggressive and disrespectful towards me.Love was nowhere around. He never said I am a good looking woman. My husband rarely complimented me though I get many whenever I go out.He seemed not to be bothered about me except for the time I do something he doesn’t like.My mom also supported him. His behaviour started taking a toll on my mental condition and I started feeling uncomfortable around him.I stopped being physical as I was feeling emotionally detached.The fights had broken me, my bare minimum expectations were not fulfilled.My husband also broke relations with my family and was disrespectful to them.Initially he had promised that I will be free to visit my mom whenever I want and he will not seek my salary ever or doubt my character, but nothing turned to be true.After 4 months of torture, I came to my mom's place and told my husband that I cannot live with him.I actually feel much better without him. As soon as he knew that I am leaving him he has surrendered and is admitting that he made mistakes and doesn’t want to lose me.He says I am his only hope in life and he loves me a lot and can’t live without me.He does the same emotional drama every time I try to part ways with him.My family is pressurising me to give him another chance. But my trust is shattered beyond repair.He made my cry, he pushed me into depression.I do not respect him. He accepted me with my inability, but I feel he never liked the real me.He is not ready to admit this fact that we have not been good for each other.To me he seems like a male chauvinist, a dominating and controlling person.He stays grumpy most of the time, behaves well with others but is arrogant with family members.What do I do? I am in utter confusion, I am unable to force myself into a love-less marriage and my family and husband doesn’t understand it.(I am a government officer and my husband runs a small business)

    ..Read more

    Anu

    Anu Krishna  |839 Answers  |Ask -

    Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Aug 05, 2022

    Relationship
    I want to keep it anonymous.I am a 30 years old independent woman married for 5 months only.My husband and I were in same college but were not friends.He had been approaching me for getting married since 2017, but every time I had rejected his proposal, later in February, 2021 I talked to him openly and mentioned my inability to conceive if we get married.To which his response was that he really liked me and is ready to accept me with my inability.I made our families met and we got engaged.During the one year of courtship period, initial 4-5 months were peaceful, but he and I were missing a bond, yet we thought may be with time we will find it.After the initial phase as we started meeting for family functions.He started finding flaws in me. Things like, I stare at other men when I go out, I don’t give him priority, why do I talk to any male friend beyond necessity, why do I praise my senior at office parties etc.He started controlling me in these areas and used to get angry if I talk to my siblings late night.I started feeling trapped and suffocated, and always under the fear that any of my action could make my husband angry.In that anger he seemed like a very different person, someone aggressive.We started fighting, arguing over petty things.He wanted me to change but I was reluctant as those were very normal things for me and I started telling him that this relationship is not working.We are two persons with different mindset and ideologies and since we are unable to reach to a solution over any issue, let’s call it off.I tried to call this wedding off for like 6 times, but he never agreed to this stating that he loves me and he will change his attitude and will not stop me from doing anything.Whenever I tried to break up with him he'd start crying, stating things like you are my only happiness in life, and I would die without you and all.I involved my family into the matter and shared things with them.They used to call my husband to make him understand my expectations from him.In front of them my husband used to admit that he would change his behaviour.He used to stay calm for 5-6 days and then continue with the same attitude.Basically, it was an on and off behaviour from his side and because of that my behaviour was also affected.I was trying to see his positive side as he had accepted me with my inability, so he must be a good person.Somehow, after so many issues, we got married.After marriage, we went for honeymoon, but he showed a different attitude.He started insulting me that I stare at other people, including the waiter.He would fight with me aggressively, and when I cry he'd calm me down stating that this fight is my fault; had I not done this he would not have fought; had I obeyed him he would not have gotten angry. Then he used to make love to me.For 4 days this happened continuously.On the 4th day I told him I cannot stand him and bear his mind numbing torture.If he sees so many flaws in my character we must part our ways, and there is not point of staying together.He agreed but later he started apologising, asking for another chance to this marriage. I agreed.But his behaviour didn’t improve much. We used to live with his parents, he started taking active participation in local politics which used to keep him busy.He started controlling me indirectly for visiting my moms and relatives.He'd taunt me for not sharing my salary with his parents.Later I found out his work is not running smooth and he is not making enough.The issue of staring at men and shaking hands with men while greeting congratulations, was also an issue to him.He'd remain normal as long as I did things as per his wish.If I said or did anything opposite, he'd get aggressive and disrespectful towards me.Love was nowhere around. He never said I am a good looking woman. My husband rarely complimented me though I get many whenever I go out.He seemed not to be bothered about me except for the time I do something he doesn’t like.My mom also supported him. His behaviour started taking a toll on my mental condition and I started feeling uncomfortable around him.I stopped being physical as I was feeling emotionally detached.The fights had broken me, my bare minimum expectations were not fulfilled.My husband also broke relations with my family and was disrespectful to them.Initially he had promised that I will be free to visit my mom whenever I want and he will not seek my salary ever or doubt my character, but nothing turned to be true.After 4 months of torture, I came to my mom's place and told my husband that I cannot live with him.I actually feel much better without him. As soon as he knew that I am leaving him he has surrendered and is admitting that he made mistakes and doesn’t want to lose me.He says I am his only hope in life and he loves me a lot and can’t live without me.He does the same emotional drama every time I try to part ways with him.My family is pressurising me to give him another chance. But my trust is shattered beyond repair.He made my cry, he pushed me into depression.I do not respect him. He accepted me with my inability, but I feel he never liked the real me.He is not ready to admit this fact that we have not been good for each other.To me he seems like a male chauvinist, a dominating and controlling person.He stays grumpy most of the time, behaves well with others but is arrogant with family members.What do I do? I am in utter confusion, I am unable to force myself into a love-less marriage and my family and husband doesn’t understand it.(I am a government officer and my husband runs a small business)
    Ans:

    Dear MK,

    This is a classic case of crying out, blaming the spouse for the crying and sending her on a guilt trip, promising to do better, not following through and when she walks out, crying out again.

    It's cyclical and traps you within in the loop.

    He really needs to work out his stuff with a professional, else this is going to be something that you have to deal with repeatedly.

    To not be able to take responsibility for his actions, shifting blame onto you, acting insecure and preventing you from leading your life the way that you are used to -- like talking to your family and friends -- are all red flags.

    Step up, take charge and suggest that he goes to a professional if he wants the marriage to work.

    If he doesn’t and continues the same way, you know what you must do to secure yourself and your life.

    All the best!

    ..Read more

    Latest Questions
    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Asked by Anonymous - May 09, 2024Hindi
    Listen
    Money
    I have about 40 lakhs in equity MF, 40 lakhs in pf. Currently making 1 lakh SIP per month. In hand salary is 3.25 lakh/month. I plan to purchase a house worth 1.5 Cr. I'll soon get a lump sum amount of 60 lakhs. Should I use that to pay larger upfront for the house or invest it to pay future payment from returns? I am 37 yrs old male. Monthly expense is about 1 lakh inclusive of rent.
    Ans: Here's a breakdown of your situation to help you decide whether to use the lump sum for a larger down payment or invest for future EMIs:

    Factors to Consider:

    Down Payment Impact: A larger down payment reduces your loan amount, leading to lower interest payments overall. This can save you a significant amount of money in the long run.

    Investment Potential: Investing the lump sum could potentially generate returns that help cover future EMIs. However, market performance is not guaranteed.

    Emergency Fund: Ensure you have a sufficient emergency fund after using the lump sum (ideally 3-6 months of living expenses).

    Risk Tolerance: Investing the lump sum involves market risks. Consider your comfort level with potential fluctuations.

    Here are two approaches to consider:

    Option 1: Larger Down Payment:

    Use a significant portion of the lump sum (say 40-50 lakhs) for a larger down payment. This can bring down your loan amount substantially, reducing your overall interest burden.
    Invest the remaining amount (20-30 lakhs) to potentially generate additional income or create a buffer for future expenses.
    Option 2: Invest and Pay EMIs:

    Invest the entire lump sum (60 lakhs) in a diversified portfolio to potentially generate returns that can cover future EMIs.
    This frees up your monthly income for other expenses or investments. However, market performance can impact returns.
    Here are some additional thoughts:

    Interest Rates: Compare current home loan interest rates with the potential returns you might expect from your investments.
    Debt Management: Consider your overall debt situation. A larger down payment can improve your debt-to-income ratio, potentially making you eligible for better loan terms.
    Professional Advice: Consulting a financial advisor can help you create a personalized plan considering your risk tolerance, financial goals, and investment horizon.
    Here's a quick summary of your financial situation:

    Strong Savings: With Rs. 40 lakh in MFs, Rs. 40 lakh in PF, and a Rs. 1 lakh monthly SIP, you have a solid savings foundation.
    High Income: Your in-hand salary of Rs. 3.25 lakh per month provides significant financial flexibility.
    House Purchase: Aiming for a Rs. 1.5 crore house indicates a long-term investment plan.

    Ultimately, the decision should align with your risk tolerance, financial goals, and overall financial plan. Consulting with a Certified Financial Planner can provide personalized guidance tailored to your specific circumstances, helping you make informed decisions to achieve your objectives.

    Best Regards,
    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
    Chief Financial Planner,
    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Listen
    Money
    Hi, I am 36 years old, married & have 1 child (3 year old). Me & wife have combined income from salary of 3.75 lakh post taxes. We are investing in following funds & have investment horizon of more than 15 years. Aditya BSL Pure Value - 2k DSP Value Fund - 4k HDFC Small Cap - 2K Kotak business cycle - 5k Kotak Emerging Equity fund - 2K Motilal Oswal large and Midcap - 10k Bandhan Core Equity - 2k Baroda BNP India Consumption - 3k Franklin India Prima - 4k HDFC Mid Cap Opportunity - 2k HSBC Small Cap - 5k Nippon India Flexi Cap - 7.5 SBI small cap - 4k White Oak capital Large and Mid - 7.5k ICICI prudential India opportunity -10k NPS - 15K Equity Market - 25K SGB - 15K LIC -10K. I'm looking for the same investment till next 15 years. Definitely will increase the MF amount every year. I'm looking for at least 20+ Cr corpus at the age of 55. Please guide me with the existing investment. Total Liability like Home Loan and Top up loan EMI is 42K. I want to make same EMI for Loan and future surplus amount to be invest in equity market with low risk as I'm moving towards early 40s.
    Ans: Based on your investment portfolio and financial goals, let's evaluate your current strategy. You've made a commendable effort in diversifying your investments across various mutual funds and other instruments, aiming for a substantial corpus in the next 15 years. Your commitment to increasing your mutual fund investments annually is a wise move, considering the potential for wealth accumulation over time.

    However, let's delve into a few considerations. While your investment horizon is long-term, it's prudent to periodically review your portfolio's performance and adjust it according to changing market conditions and your evolving financial situation. With increasing age and responsibilities, it's natural to prioritize stability and lower risk in your investments.

    You've mentioned a desire to maintain your current loan EMIs while directing surplus funds towards equity markets with lower risk. This approach aligns with a conservative yet growth-oriented investment strategy, balancing the need for stability with wealth creation potential. As you move towards your early 40s, this cautious approach can provide a cushion against market volatility while still capturing growth opportunities.

    While your current portfolio includes a diverse mix of actively managed mutual funds, it's important to acknowledge the disadvantages of solely relying on actively managed funds. These can include higher expense ratios and the possibility of underperformance compared to benchmark indices. However, the benefits of active management, such as the potential for outperformance and flexibility in portfolio construction, justify their inclusion in your investment strategy.

    In conclusion, your commitment to long-term wealth creation is admirable. By maintaining a disciplined approach to investing, periodically reviewing your portfolio, and balancing risk and growth opportunities, you're on track to achieve your financial goals.

    Best Regards,
    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
    Chief Financial Planner,
    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Listen
    Money
    Hi sir, greetings. Am 46 years old and have recently got a lumpsum amount of around 15 lakhs and want to invest them with a time horizon of around 15+ years. Please suggest me a portfolio for the same. In case if you suggest me to invest the amount in a split manner in the next 1-2 year duration, is it ok to leave the amount in the Savings account (have an option to get 7% per annum in one of the private sector banks) or any other suggestion in this regard please ?
    Ans: Congratulations on receiving a lump sum of 15 lakhs! It's an opportunity to strengthen your financial position and work towards your long-term goals.

    Considering your time horizon of 15+ years, you have the advantage of investing for the long term, allowing your investments to potentially grow significantly over time.

    As a Certified Financial Planner, I would recommend a diversified portfolio that balances growth potential with risk management. This could include a mix of equity, debt, and other asset classes to spread risk and capture growth opportunities.

    Leaving the entire amount in a savings account, even with a 7% interest rate, may not be the most prudent choice for long-term wealth accumulation. While it provides safety and liquidity, the returns may not outpace inflation, resulting in a loss of purchasing power over time.

    Instead, consider investing the lump sum gradually over the next 1-2 years to benefit from cost averaging and reduce the impact of market volatility. You could divide the amount into smaller portions and invest them systematically at regular intervals.

    For the portion not immediately invested, a high-yield savings account or a short-term debt fund could be considered to earn a better return than a traditional savings account while maintaining liquidity.

    Remember, investing involves risk, and it's crucial to align your investment strategy with your risk tolerance and financial goals. Regular reviews with your Certified Financial Planner can help ensure your portfolio remains on track to meet your objectives.

    Best Regards,
    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

    Chief Financial Planner,

    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Listen
    Money
    Hi this is Barath(37 yrs age-high risk appetite investor),My portfolio worth is around 4cr ,this includes 2.5cr in ppfs flexi+1.5cr in motilal micro 250 index. I have requirement for son's education after 7yrs from now(amount req 1cr) and daughter education 12 yrs from now (around2 cr).I wish to retire at my age of 45 yrs.I am also doing an sip of 5 lacks a month in both above funs 3 lacks and 2 lacks respectively.I wish to have retirement withdrawal of 2.5lacks monthly via SWP with an increase of 8%in withdrawal rate.Pls suggest how am I placed
    Ans: Hello Barath,

    You've crafted a robust portfolio, and your proactive approach to investing is commendable. With a high-risk appetite and a sizable investment worth 4 crores, you're laying a strong foundation for your financial future.

    Your investment allocation, with 2.5 crores in PPFS Flexi and 1.5 crores in Motilal Micro 250 Index, reflects a balanced strategy. However, it's important to regularly review and adjust your portfolio to align with your evolving goals and risk tolerance.

    Your foresight regarding your children's education expenses, with a requirement of 1 crore in 7 years for your son and 2 crores in 12 years for your daughter, demonstrates prudent planning. Your SIP of 5 lakhs per month split between the two funds ensures disciplined saving and investment.

    Planning for early retirement at 45 is ambitious yet achievable with careful financial planning. Your target retirement withdrawal of 2.5 lakhs monthly via SWP, with an annual increase of 8%, indicates a thoughtful approach to sustaining your lifestyle post-retirement.

    While index funds have gained popularity for their low fees and passive management, it's essential to consider the limitations they pose, such as lack of flexibility and potential underperformance during market downturns. Actively managed funds, on the other hand, offer the expertise of fund managers to navigate market fluctuations and capitalize on opportunities, potentially yielding higher returns over the long term.

    Opting for regular funds investing through an MFD with CFP credential provides the added benefit of personalized advice and guidance tailored to your financial goals and risk profile, ensuring optimal portfolio management and decision-making.

    Overall, your proactive stance towards financial planning and investment management sets a solid precedent for securing your financial future and achieving your retirement goals.

    Best Regards,

    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
    Chief Financial Planner,
    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Listen
    Money
    Hello Dev, I am 32 years old and would like to start SIP for 5k per month to create retirement corpus of 1 crore. Also would like to generate 30 lacs in another 10 years for closing housing loan. Already have three MF SIP as below. Quant active fund 1000 Quant ELSS tax saver fund 500 ICICI prudential corporate bond fund 150 Kindly suggest in which MF should I invest further and also how much should I increase the SIP amount to achieve the above goals. Thank you.
    Ans: It's great to see your proactive approach towards planning for your financial future. Your dedication to investing is commendable.
    Starting an SIP with 5k per month is a wise decision to create a retirement corpus of 1 crore. Additionally, generating 30 lakhs in 10 years to close your housing loan is a smart goal.
    Considering your existing SIPs in Quant Active Fund, Quant ELSS Tax Saver Fund, and ICICI Prudential Corporate Bond Fund, you have a good foundation. However, to diversify your portfolio and align it with your goals, you may want to consider the following suggestions:
    1. Equity-oriented funds with higher growth potential can help you achieve your long-term goals. Look into diversified equity funds or multi-cap funds for exposure to various segments of the market.
    2. Since your investment horizon is long-term, you can afford to take slightly higher risks for potentially higher returns. Adding more equity-oriented funds can help you achieve this.
    3. To generate the required amount for your housing loan closure in 10 years, you may need to increase your SIP amounts gradually. Consider reviewing your financial situation periodically and increasing your SIP contributions accordingly.
    4. As a Certified Financial Planner, I recommend staying disciplined with your investments and adhering to your financial plan. Regularly review your portfolio's performance and make adjustments as needed to stay on track towards your goals.
    By diversifying your portfolio and gradually increasing your SIP amounts, you can work towards achieving your financial objectives effectively.
    Best Regards,
    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
    Chief Financial Planner,
    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Asked by Anonymous - Mar 01, 2024Hindi
    Listen
    Money
    Hello Sir I am 34yr old. Started investing from July 2023 1.6lacs monthly in 8 funds (20k each) I want to create a portfolio of 50crore in 20yrs My funds include 2 small cap funds, 3 mid cap, 1 flexi cap and 2 large n mid cap funds How can I achieve my target. I am looking for 18-20% xirr on my investment
    Ans: Congratulations on taking proactive steps towards securing your financial future. Your commitment to investing is commendable.

    Creating a portfolio with the goal of reaching 50 crores in 20 years requires careful planning and strategy.

    With a monthly investment of 1.6 lakhs distributed across various funds, you've already laid a solid foundation. However, achieving an XIRR of 18-20% may require a slightly more aggressive approach.

    Given your portfolio composition of small-cap, mid-cap, flexi-cap, and large and mid-cap funds, you seem to have a diversified mix with exposure to different segments of the market.

    To increase the potential for higher returns, you might consider slightly increasing your allocation to small and mid-cap funds, given their historically higher growth potential over the long term.

    As a Certified Financial Planner, I advise against relying solely on direct funds. Opting for regular funds through a Certified Financial Planner can provide you with valuable insights and personalized guidance, ensuring your investments are aligned with your goals.

    While index funds have their advantages, such as lower expense ratios, they lack the potential for outperformance that actively managed funds offer, especially in dynamic market conditions.

    Regularly reviewing your portfolio's performance and making adjustments as needed is crucial to staying on track towards your goal. Additionally, maintaining a long-term perspective and avoiding reactionary decisions during market fluctuations is key.

    Keep up the disciplined approach to investing, and with time and patience, you can certainly achieve your target of 50 crores.

    Best Regards,

    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
    Chief Financial Planner,
    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Asked by Anonymous - Feb 28, 2024Hindi
    Listen
    Money
    Hi Dev, I am 29 years old and have a monthly income of 20K. I am already investing in MF and want to achieve a corpus fund of 5 crores by the age of 50 for my retirement. Please advise on how to invest
    Ans: I understand your aspirations for a secure retirement and commend you for your proactive approach to financial planning. It's wonderful to see your commitment to securing a comfortable future for yourself.

    With a monthly income of 20K, you're off to a good start. To achieve a corpus fund of 5 crores by the age of 50, it's essential to strategize your investments wisely.

    Diversification is key to mitigating risks and maximizing returns. While you're already investing in mutual funds, it's prudent to explore other avenues like equities, debt instruments, and perhaps even alternative investments.

    Considering your age and risk appetite, a balanced portfolio with a mix of equity and debt instruments would be suitable. Equity investments offer the potential for higher returns over the long term, while debt instruments provide stability and steady income.

    As a Certified Financial Planner, I recommend actively managed funds over index funds. Actively managed funds have the advantage of professional fund managers who actively select investments, aiming to outperform the market.

    Avoiding direct funds and opting for regular funds through a Certified Financial Planner can provide you with personalized guidance and ongoing support, ensuring your investments align with your financial goals.

    Remember to review and adjust your portfolio periodically to accommodate changes in your life circumstances and market conditions. And most importantly, stay disciplined and patient, as wealth accumulation is a gradual process.

    Keep up the excellent work, and you'll be well on your way to achieving your retirement goals.

    Best Regards,

    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
    Chief Financial Planner,
    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Listen
    Money
    Hello Sir, I'm 35 years old and my monthly income is 30000. I'm married. My monthly expenses is around 23-26000. I want to make atleast 50lakhs by the time I reach 55. Kindly suggest which mutual fund I should go for?
    Ans: It's commendable that you're planning for your financial future. Achieving a corpus of 50 lakhs by the time you reach 55 is a realistic goal with proper planning and disciplined investing. Given your income and expenses, investing in mutual funds can be an effective way to grow your wealth over the long term. Here's a suggested approach:
    1. Start with SIPs: Since you have a monthly surplus after expenses, consider starting Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) in mutual funds. SIPs allow you to invest a fixed amount regularly, enabling you to benefit from rupee cost averaging and the power of compounding.
    2. Choose Equity Mutual Funds: Given your long-term investment horizon of 20 years, you can afford to invest predominantly in equity mutual funds, which have the potential to deliver higher returns over the long term compared to debt funds.
    3. Diversify Your Portfolio: Opt for a diversified portfolio of equity mutual funds across different categories, such as large-cap, mid-cap, and multi-cap funds. Diversification helps spread risk and optimize returns. Choose funds with a proven track record of consistent performance and experienced fund managers.
    4. Consider ELSS Funds: Equity Linked Savings Schemes (ELSS) offer the dual benefit of potential returns and tax savings under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act. Since you're aiming for long-term wealth creation, ELSS funds can be an excellent option to consider.
    5. Regular Review: Monitor the performance of your mutual fund investments regularly and review your portfolio at least once a year. Make adjustments as needed based on changes in market conditions, fund performance, and your financial goals.
    6. Seek Professional Advice: Consider consulting with a Certified Financial Planner who can provide personalized guidance tailored to your specific financial situation and goals. They can help you create a customized investment plan and navigate the mutual fund landscape effectively.
    Remember, investing requires patience, discipline, and a long-term perspective. Stay focused on your goal of building a corpus of 50 lakhs by the time you reach 55, and with consistent investing and prudent decision-making, you can work towards achieving financial security and independence.
    Best Regards,
    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
    Chief Financial Planner,
    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Asked by Anonymous - Feb 28, 2024Hindi
    Listen
    Money
    Hi ..I am 34 year old married..my monthly income is 80k now as I am in government service. I have invested already 2lakh in equity fund and sip of 2k in canara robocop bluechip MF..how to have a capital of atleast 5 CR when I will b 50
    Ans: It's great that you're thinking about your financial future at such a young age. Building a corpus of 5 Crores by the time you turn 50 is an ambitious but achievable goal with careful planning and disciplined investing. Here's a plan to help you reach your target:

    Increase Investment Amount: Since you're already investing in equity funds and SIPs, consider increasing your investment amount gradually as your income grows. Aim to maximize your contributions towards long-term wealth creation.
    Diversify Your Portfolio: While equity funds offer the potential for high returns, diversifying your portfolio across different asset classes can help manage risk. Consider allocating a portion of your investments to debt funds, real estate, and other avenues based on your risk tolerance and financial goals.
    Review and Rebalance: Regularly review your investment portfolio and rebalance it as needed to ensure it remains aligned with your financial objectives. Monitor the performance of your funds and make adjustments based on market conditions and changes in your personal circumstances.
    Explore Other Investment Opportunities: Look for additional avenues to grow your wealth, such as investing in tax-saving instruments like ELSS funds, PPF, or NPS. These options offer tax benefits along with the potential for long-term capital appreciation.
    Seek Professional Guidance: Consider consulting with a Certified Financial Planner who can provide personalized advice tailored to your specific financial situation and goals. They can help you create a comprehensive financial plan and guide you towards achieving your target of 5 Crores by the age of 50.
    Remember, achieving your financial goals requires discipline, patience, and a long-term perspective. Stay focused on your objectives, and with the right investment strategy, you can work towards building a substantial corpus for your future.

    Best Regards,

    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

    Chief Financial Planner,

    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    Ramalingam

    Ramalingam Kalirajan  |1839 Answers  |Ask -

    Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

    Asked by Anonymous - Feb 26, 2024Hindi
    Listen
    Money
    Hello Sunilji My age is 49 and my net monthly pay is 1.6 lakhs. I need to build corpus of 50 lakhs in next years. Also have 10 lakhs cash in hand, kindly suggest any investment plan like sip or mutual funds to build my corpus.
    Ans: I commend your goal of building a corpus of 50 lakhs within the next year. It's a challenging but achievable target given your financial situation. Here's a plan to help you reach your goal:

    Firstly, let's leverage your existing cash in hand of 10 lakhs. This amount can serve as the foundation for your investment journey.

    Next, considering your monthly income of 1.6 lakhs, we can allocate a portion towards systematic investment plans (SIPs) in mutual funds.

    SIPs offer the advantage of disciplined investing, allowing you to invest a fixed amount regularly over time, regardless of market fluctuations.

    Given your investment horizon of one year, it's crucial to focus on relatively low-risk options to preserve capital while aiming for reasonable returns.

    Avoiding direct equity or high-risk investments would be prudent, as they may subject your capital to significant market volatility and potential losses.

    Instead, consider investing in debt mutual funds or balanced funds, which offer a balance of safety and potential for growth.

    While actively managed funds may have slightly higher expense ratios compared to index funds, they offer the advantage of professional fund management and potential outperformance in volatile markets.

    Regularly review your investment portfolio and make adjustments as needed to stay on track towards your goal.

    Remember, consistency and patience are key to achieving your financial objectives. Stay committed to your investment plan, and you'll be closer to building the corpus you desire.

    Best Regards,

    K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

    Chief Financial Planner,

    www.holisticinvestment.in

    ...Read more

    DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

    Close  

    You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
    Login

    A verification OTP will be sent to this
    Mobile Number / Email

    Enter OTP
    A 6 digit code has been sent to

    Resend OTP in120seconds

    Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
    Sign up

    By signing up, you agree to our
    Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

    Already have an account?

    Enter OTP
    A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

    Resend OTP in120seconds

    x