Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Investing Dilemma: Stocks or Mutual Funds?

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8319 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 29, 2024

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
Ambikesh Question by Ambikesh on Jul 14, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money

Sir is it better to invest in stocks or investing through mutual fund sip

Ans: Assessing Direct Stock Investment
Potential for High Returns

Investing directly in stocks can offer high returns.
Stocks can outperform mutual funds over the long term.
Requires Deep Knowledge

Stock investment needs good market knowledge.
You must research and analyse individual companies.
Higher Risk

Stocks can be highly volatile.
There’s a risk of significant losses.
Time-Consuming

Monitoring stock investments requires time and effort.
You need to stay updated with market trends and news.
Benefits of Mutual Fund SIPs
Professional Management

Mutual funds are managed by professional fund managers.
They make informed decisions based on market analysis.
Diversification

Mutual funds invest in a diversified portfolio.
This reduces the risk compared to investing in individual stocks.
Convenience and Discipline

SIPs (Systematic Investment Plans) offer convenience.
They instill financial discipline by regular investments.
Lower Risk

Mutual funds spread risk across multiple stocks.
They are less volatile compared to individual stocks.
Evaluating Your Investment Style
Risk Tolerance

Assess your risk tolerance before deciding.
Stocks are high-risk, high-reward; mutual funds offer balanced risk.
Time and Knowledge

Consider the time you can dedicate to investment research.
Mutual funds require less time and knowledge.
Investment Goals

Define your financial goals and time horizon.
Mutual funds can align better with long-term goals.
Disadvantages of Direct Funds
Lack of Professional Guidance

Direct funds lack professional advice.
DIY approach might not suit everyone.
Time-Consuming

Requires constant monitoring and knowledge.
Might not be feasible for busy professionals.
Risk of Suboptimal Choices

Higher risk of choosing inappropriate funds.
Can lead to lower returns.
Benefits of Regular Funds
Professional Advice

Investing through an MFD with CFP credentials offers professional guidance.
Better fund selection and portfolio management.
Time-Saving

CFP handles the research and monitoring.
Saves you time and effort.
Optimized Returns

Expert advice leads to better investment choices.
Potentially higher returns compared to direct funds.
Final Insights
Investing in stocks can offer high returns but comes with high risk and requires time and knowledge. Mutual fund SIPs, on the other hand, offer professional management, diversification, and convenience, making them a safer and more suitable option for most investors.

Consider your risk tolerance, time, and investment goals before deciding. Consulting a Certified Financial Planner can help tailor a strategy that suits your needs and maximizes returns.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP

Chief Financial Planner

www.holisticinvestment.in
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Moneywize

Moneywize   |181 Answers  |Ask -

Financial Planner - Answered on Feb 20, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 19, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
What can give better returns in the long run? Investing in MF SIPs or investing in stock SIPs? I would like to invest Rs 60,000 each every month in stocks as well as MFs directly.
Ans: Deciding between investing in Mutual Fund Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) and Stock Systematic Investment Plans depends on various factors including your risk tolerance, investment goals, time horizon, and knowledge of the stock market.

Here are some considerations for both options:

Mutual Fund SIPs:

• Diversification: Mutual funds offer diversification across a range of stocks or other assets, reducing the risk compared to investing in individual stocks.
• Professional Management: Mutual funds are managed by professional fund managers who make investment decisions on your behalf, based on their research and expertise.
• Accessibility: Mutual funds are accessible to investors with varying levels of knowledge and experience in the stock market.
• Lower Risk: Generally, mutual funds are considered lower risk compared to individual stocks due to diversification.

Stock SIPs:

• Potential for Higher Returns: Investing directly in stocks can offer higher returns if you pick the right stocks. Some individual stocks have the potential for significant growth over time.
• Control: With stock SIPs, you have more control over your investment decisions and can choose which stocks to invest in based on your own research and analysis.
• Higher Risk: Investing directly in stocks carries higher risk compared to mutual funds due to lack of diversification. If you choose poorly performing stocks, your portfolio may suffer.
• Requires Research and Monitoring: Investing in individual stocks requires a good understanding of the companies you're investing in and regular monitoring of their performance.

Decision:

Considering your investment amount of Rs 60,000 each per month in both stocks and mutual funds, you could consider a hybrid approach:

• Allocate a portion of your investment towards mutual fund SIPs for diversification and lower risk.
• Allocate the remaining portion towards stock SIPs if you're willing to take on higher risk for potentially higher returns and have the time and knowledge to research and monitor individual stocks.

It's also advisable to consult with a financial advisor who can assess your individual financial situation and help you create a personalised investment plan tailored to your goals and risk tolerance. Additionally, past performance of investments is not indicative of future results, so make sure to consider all factors before making your decision.

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8319 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 23, 2024

Listen
Money
Sir which SIP will be best for investment?
Ans: Choosing the best SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) involves evaluating several factors to ensure it aligns with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Understanding SIP
SIP is a method of investing a fixed amount regularly in mutual funds. It offers the benefit of disciplined investing and rupee cost averaging.

Assessing Your Investment Goals
Before selecting an SIP, it's essential to define your investment goals.

Are you saving for retirement, a child's education, or buying a house?

Evaluating Risk Tolerance
Your risk tolerance determines the type of funds you should invest in.

Are you comfortable with high risk for potentially high returns, or do you prefer stability?

Time Horizon
Your investment horizon influences the type of mutual funds you should choose.

A longer time horizon allows for more aggressive investments.

Benefits of Actively Managed Funds
Actively managed funds are managed by professional fund managers who aim to outperform the market.

Advantages Over Index Funds
Higher Returns: Actively managed funds aim to beat the market index, potentially offering higher returns.

Flexibility: Fund managers can adjust the portfolio based on market conditions.

Diversification: These funds often have a diversified portfolio to mitigate risk.

Disadvantages of Index Funds
Limited Flexibility: Index funds strictly track an index, limiting flexibility.

No Outperformance: They aim to match, not outperform, the index.

Market Cap Bias: These funds are heavily weighted towards large-cap stocks, which might not always offer the best returns.

Types of Funds for SIP
Equity Funds
Equity funds invest primarily in stocks. They offer high growth potential and are suitable for long-term investments.

Large Cap Funds
These funds invest in large, well-established companies. They offer stability and moderate growth.

Mid Cap Funds
These funds invest in mid-sized companies. They have higher growth potential but come with increased risk.

Small Cap Funds
These funds focus on smaller companies. They can offer substantial returns but with higher volatility.

Debt Funds
Debt funds invest in fixed-income securities like bonds. They offer stability and regular income.

Short-Term Debt Funds
Suitable for conservative investors seeking stable returns in the short term.

Long-Term Debt Funds
Offer higher returns but with increased interest rate risk.

Hybrid Funds
Hybrid funds combine equity and debt investments. They offer a balanced approach, providing both growth potential and stability.

Balanced Advantage Funds
These funds dynamically manage the allocation between equity and debt based on market conditions.

Choosing the Right SIP
Factors to Consider
Fund Performance: Look at the fund's historical performance and compare it with benchmarks.

Expense Ratio: Lower expense ratios can improve net returns.

Fund Manager’s Track Record: A skilled and experienced fund manager can significantly impact the fund's performance.

Risk-Return Profile: Ensure the fund’s risk profile matches your risk tolerance.

Suggested Categories for SIP
Large Cap Equity Funds: For stability and moderate returns.

Mid Cap Equity Funds: For higher growth potential with moderate risk.

Small Cap Equity Funds: For aggressive growth with higher risk.

Balanced Advantage Funds: For a balanced approach between equity and debt.

Short-Term Debt Funds: For conservative investors seeking stable returns.

Consulting a Certified Financial Planner
Personalized Advice: A CFP provides tailored investment strategies based on your goals and risk profile.

Holistic Planning: They consider your entire financial situation and future needs.

Expert Guidance: Benefit from their market knowledge and experience in managing investments.

Conclusion
Choosing the best SIP depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon. Consider a mix of large, mid, and small-cap funds, along with hybrid funds, for a balanced and diversified portfolio.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8319 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 23, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - May 16, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
Should I invest in sip or stock market?
Ans: Understanding SIPs and Direct Stock Market Investment
Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs)

A SIP allows you to invest a fixed amount regularly in mutual funds. It provides disciplined investing and benefits from market volatility.

Direct Stock Market Investment

Investing directly in the stock market involves buying shares of individual companies. This requires significant market knowledge and regular monitoring.

Advantages of SIPs Over Direct Stock Market Investment
1. Professional Management

SIPs in mutual funds are managed by professional fund managers. They have expertise in selecting and managing a diversified portfolio.

2. Diversification

Mutual funds invest in a wide range of securities. This diversification reduces the risk compared to investing in individual stocks.

3. Rupee Cost Averaging

SIPs use the principle of rupee cost averaging. This means you buy more units when prices are low and fewer units when prices are high, reducing the average cost per unit.

4. Discipline and Convenience

SIPs promote disciplined investing by allowing automatic regular investments. This reduces the impact of market volatility on your investment decisions.

5. Lower Risk

SIPs in mutual funds spread risk across a diversified portfolio. Investing in individual stocks can be riskier due to the performance of specific companies.

6. Accessibility

Mutual funds offer various schemes catering to different risk appetites and financial goals. This accessibility allows investors to choose funds that align with their objectives.

Disadvantages of Direct Stock Market Investment
1. Time-Consuming

Investing directly in stocks requires constant market monitoring and analysis. It can be time-consuming and complex for individuals without market expertise.

2. Higher Risk

Investing in individual stocks involves higher risk. The performance of your investment depends on the success of specific companies, making it more volatile.

3. Emotional Decision-Making

Direct stock investments can lead to emotional decision-making. Investors may react impulsively to market fluctuations, leading to poor investment choices.

4. Lack of Diversification

Building a diversified portfolio of individual stocks requires substantial capital and knowledge. This lack of diversification increases risk.

Benefits of Regular Funds Investing Through CFP
1. Expert Guidance

Investing through regular funds with a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) provides expert guidance. They help in selecting suitable funds and managing your portfolio effectively.

2. Regular Portfolio Reviews

CFPs conduct regular portfolio reviews and adjustments. This ensures your investments remain aligned with your financial goals and market conditions.

3. Tailored Advice

CFPs offer tailored advice based on your financial situation, risk tolerance, and investment objectives. This personalized approach enhances investment outcomes.

Disadvantages of Index Funds
1. Limited Potential for Outperformance

Index funds replicate market indices and cannot outperform them. Actively managed funds aim to exceed market returns through strategic investments.

2. Inflexibility

Index funds must follow their benchmark index, limiting flexibility. Actively managed funds can adapt to changing market conditions to optimize returns.

Conclusion
Investing through SIPs in mutual funds offers numerous advantages over direct stock market investment. Professional management, diversification, rupee cost averaging, and reduced risk make SIPs a favorable choice. Additionally, investing through regular funds with a Certified Financial Planner ensures expert guidance and regular portfolio reviews. This approach aligns your investments with your financial goals, providing a balanced and disciplined investment strategy.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP

Chief Financial Planner

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8319 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 05, 2025

Money
Dear Sir, I am aged 40 years a aggressive investor I have recent corpus of 13 lac in mutual fund and doing SIP of Rs30500 monthly in following funds . Nippon small cap - 9000 , Tata small cap - 7500 , Quant Small cap - 6000 , kotak small cap - 5000 and Pgmi Flexi cap -3000 and a vision for next 22 years with step up of 10 %. I also invest in PPF of 12500 monthly and In EPF with 25000 basic salary and i will also get Rs 50 lac from various LIC policy at the age of 60 . I want to know that is my approach is right and what would be the future corpus at the age of 62 years .
Ans: You are doing a disciplined and smart job with your investments. You have a long-term horizon, a strong SIP commitment, and a clear goal in mind. That’s a big step many don’t take seriously. Let me now evaluate your approach from all angles. This will be a 360-degree review of your investment plan and future readiness.

Let us go step-by-step to understand if your approach is right and what the future looks like.

Your Current Financial Setup

You are 40 years old now.

You have a mutual fund corpus of Rs 13 lakh.

You invest Rs 30,500 monthly through SIP.

You invest in four small cap funds and one flexi cap fund.

You step up your SIP by 10% annually.

You have a PPF investment of Rs 12,500 monthly.

You contribute to EPF. Your basic salary is Rs 25,000.

You will receive Rs 50 lakh from LIC policies at age 60.

Your investment horizon is 22 years from now.

This is a solid plan and shows discipline. Now, let us evaluate it carefully with insights and suggestions.

Assessment of Mutual Fund Investments

You are investing heavily in small cap mutual funds.

Four out of five funds are from the small cap category.

Small caps give high returns, but they also carry high risk.

Over 22 years, this risk may work in your favour.

But the ride will be bumpy. There will be sharp ups and downs.

At times, you may see short-term losses. That is normal.

However, putting over 85% of SIP in small caps may be risky.

You need better diversification for stability.

Adding large cap and mid cap funds may balance the risk.

Your Flexi cap fund does help a bit, but it is still not enough.

A blend of market caps will give smoother long-term growth.

It is better to slowly bring down small cap exposure to 50%.

Increase exposure to diversified and mid-cap funds gradually.

Don’t exit small cap funds suddenly. Take a phased approach.

This change will make your portfolio strong and well-balanced.

Step-Up SIP Strategy – Strong and Effective

Increasing SIP by 10% annually is a smart idea.

This fights inflation and grows your wealth faster.

It uses your rising income to build a big corpus.

Many investors ignore step-up. You are doing it correctly.

Keep increasing the SIP without fail every year.

Even a break in step-up can delay your target.

Review your SIPs yearly and adjust as income rises.

This strategy will help you reach your target corpus faster.

Investment in PPF – A Safe Long-Term Cushion

PPF offers guaranteed, tax-free interest.

You are investing Rs 12,500 monthly in PPF.

Over 22 years, this will become a strong safe corpus.

It adds stability to your overall financial plan.

PPF is good for retirement since it is risk-free.

Keep continuing till maturity. Do not withdraw early.

Interest rate may vary, but long-term returns are good.

You also get tax exemption under Section 80C.

This risk-free asset will protect you from equity market shocks.

EPF – A Reliable Retirement Contributor

Your EPF is linked to your Rs 25,000 basic salary.

The employer also contributes monthly.

Over 22 years, this will grow into a big amount.

EPF offers fixed, tax-free returns with no market risk.

It is an excellent tool for retirement planning.

Avoid premature withdrawals from EPF.

You can withdraw after retirement for use as income.

This will be a strong pillar of your retirement security.

LIC Maturity at Age 60 – A Special Boost

You will receive Rs 50 lakh from LIC policies at age 60.

This will come at a perfect time near retirement.

You must check if these are traditional or ULIP plans.

Traditional plans offer low returns, mostly below inflation.

ULIPs carry market risk and high charges.

If these are investment-cum-insurance plans, surrendering is wise.

You can reinvest that surrender amount in mutual funds.

Use proper asset allocation while reinvesting.

For insurance needs, use only term insurance.

Reinvesting in mutual funds can make this Rs 50 lakh grow further.

Future Corpus at Age 62 – What to Expect

With SIPs, EPF, PPF and LIC money, your total savings will be huge.

Your mutual fund corpus will grow rapidly with step-up.

Your PPF and EPF will grow safely, year after year.

LIC amount will give a big boost just before retirement.

With 10% SIP step-up, your corpus can cross Rs 9 to 10 crore.

Exact figure depends on market returns, SIP discipline, and inflation.

But you are definitely on the right path to reach financial freedom.

You are preparing for retirement very well.

This kind of planning gives peace of mind and confidence.

Things You Are Doing Right – A Quick Look

Strong SIP discipline and long-term vision.

Investing in equity for long-term wealth creation.

Following step-up SIP approach.

Investing in PPF and EPF for safe returns.

Keeping investment horizon of 22 years.

Maintaining separate LIC maturity plans.

You are showing smart behaviour as an aggressive investor.

Key Improvements You Should Consider

Reduce small cap exposure to 50% slowly.

Add more mid-cap and flexi cap funds.

Avoid overlapping funds from same category.

Review performance of all funds every 6 months.

Check expense ratios and consistency of returns.

Track goal progress once a year with clear targets.

Make sure your portfolio has good asset allocation.

Don’t hold funds only based on past returns.

Always go through a Certified Financial Planner for changes.

This will make your portfolio more stable and return-oriented.

Important Taxation Insight

Long-Term Capital Gains above Rs 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.

Short-Term Capital Gains are taxed at 20%.

Plan redemptions smartly to reduce tax.

Use staggered withdrawals near retirement.

Redeem equity funds over time, not all at once.

PPF and EPF are tax-free. LIC maturity is also tax-free.

But for mutual funds, plan redemptions with tax efficiency.

This will help you protect your wealth from tax erosion.

Important Notes on Fund Types and Investments

Do not use direct mutual funds if you are not an expert.

Direct funds need self-review and research, always.

There is no handholding or guidance with direct funds.

If you miss fund underperformance, losses may happen.

Regular funds through MFD with CFP advice are safer.

CFP will do goal review, fund analysis and rebalancing.

This adds value and protects your goals from derailment.

Always go through a trusted CFP for a 360-degree plan.

Your long-term wealth deserves the right expert attention.

Finally – Our Insights for You

You are on a great track with vision and discipline.

You are investing smartly across equity and debt.

With minor changes, your plan can become stronger.

Keep focus on diversification and risk management.

Review your goals and progress yearly with expert help.

Stick to your plan even during market falls.

Continue your SIP step-up and never skip contributions.

Use professional guidance to ensure smooth journey.

Your retirement will be financially independent and stress-free.

This approach will help you lead a proud, peaceful life post-60.

Stay committed and consistent. You are doing excellent already.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x