Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

I'm 30, Dual Minded, and Unsure About My Long-Term Boyfriend: Should I Break Up?

Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |713 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Oct 09, 2024

Ravi Mittal is an expert on dating and relationships.
He founded QuackQuack, an online dating platform, in 2010 with just two people. Today, it has over 20 million users in India.... more
Priya Question by Priya on Oct 08, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship

Thank you for your response. But if I break things now with my long term BF, it would be forever. I am 30 and he is 31 and he won't wait for me forever. I don't expect him to. Because the current situation and dual mind I am in, this is from almost 2 years. My long term bf knows I have no clarity and is supportive enough to let me part ways if I don't want to go ahead with the marriage. He wants to marry me and he is hopeful that things will get better if we work for it. I have taken enough time for myself and still not able to make up my mind.

Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I understand it is difficult, but you cannot keep your partner hanging like this. He has been patient and supportive of your decisions, the least you can do is come to a clear conclusion. While it is tough, you need to make a choice and stick to it. He deserves the clarity and so do you.

And just a reminder, if you are still unsure about him after two years of thinking, there must be something fundamentally wrong in the relationship; don't you think? Marriage is just another commitment; it doesn't magically sort things out. Please consider everything thoroughly before making a decision

Best Wishes.

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1778 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on May 16, 2022

Listen
Relationship
Hi Anu, I am 30 years old girl and for the past three years, I have been in relationship with a guy who is two years younger to me. He is Marwadi and his parents are not agreeing to our marriage. I have tried breaking up with the guy several times and tried moving on but he always keeps saying that his parents need some time. My BF is a genuine guy and he loves me a lot.My parents on the other hand want me to get married by the end of this year. I am really confused if I should wait for my BF or listen to my parents and get married by their choice. I am unable to understand what to do. I am really depressed. Will it be really late if I get married after 30 or is it okay to wait for my BF?Please help me out.
Ans:

Dear AY,

And is your boyfriend also really depressed like you are?

Is he also desperate to get married?

Is he afraid of talking to his parents?

Does he also want to get married and settle down?

Is there a future for the two of you?

If the answer to each is a YES, please have that ‘uncomfortable yet firm’ conversation with your boyfriend.

Being in a limbo isn’t great, so please ask him how much time he needs to talk to his parents and when he is going to talk to them and how serious is he in this relationship?

Else, it will be an endless wait and that is what seems to be getting to you, the uncertainty.

So, by getting a clear commitment on the WHEN, will eliminate this stress that is eating you away. Things will get clearer, and you will know what to do!

..Read more

Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |713 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Oct 08, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 05, 2024
Relationship
It is really difficult to explain what I am going through and my words might not completely bring that out but a piece of advice/perception might be really helpful. I am 30 years old. I have a long term boyfriend(started dating in 2012). He was the world to me till almost 2020. He was my family, my everything. I too meant the world to him. We treated each other like "I am his and he is mine". Such was the commitment and care. We never thought we could even think of marrying some one else. We are in long distance since 2017. Used to meet once in every 2 months sort of. In 2021, I met some one else and started going out with him as we were in the same city just casually believing that nothing serious has to happen between us and that I "obviously" will marry my long term boyfriend undoubtedly. But things drastically changed. I developed strong feelings for this person and met more frequently. I went with the flow despite having immense guilt that things will eventually get very complicated and all the three of us will be hurt. But I never gathered the courage to break ties with this new person as the bonding was very maturely strong between us. Nor I could break ties with my long term boyfriend as he still was "my family" and he was the only one I resorted to whenever I needed someone. The new guy belongs to a caste my family will never agree and because of this I persuaded the marriage talks with my family for my long term boyfriend. My family agreed and my marriage date is scheduled in end of November 2024. But I everyday am in dilemma as to whether should I marry my long term boyfriend as scheduled or should I take a bold step of breaking it and going for the guy I met in 2021. I told my mother about the situation but she said my father will never agree for this new guy's caste and that its too late and I should marry as scheduled. I am not able to take a decision and going with the flow and probably will get married with this dual thought and uncertainty. I have thought a lot about this, about how my life will be with both of them, but its very difficult for me to break things with my long term boyfriend even though I have no romantic feelings for him from the past 3 years. There is 0 intimacy, neither emotional nor physical. But I do care for him. I do want him in my life, whether as a husband or otherwise. I feel the way he takes care of me and thinks about me, no one else will. But the thing is I don't actually "feel" for him anything, nor do I miss him as much, we don't talk the way we used to , there's a detachment. We are in long distance and are in such different fields that we never probably will live closer location wise. There's financial disparity. I earn almost thrice as him but we probably are okay with this. We both are aware of all these problems and are still ready to marry with the "hope" that things will eventually be okay. On the other hand, the guy I met in 2021- he has a good career and location wise, we are in long distance too but way better placed and in near future, his job location might be very flexible. He earns more but has huge family obligations as his family including his two brothers are not very well off. I have probably made peace with it when I thought about considering him for marriage. I love him and we have great emotional intimacy . I feel so calm and happy around him. It's like a festival when he is around me. He too loves me a lot and is ready to take efforts to make our marriage possible given the family and caste differences. I am really very disturbed and unable to decide whether I should break the marriage as if things don't improve after marriage, I will regret it always. Preparations have started slightly and it would be a big step now. Should I just forget about the 2021 guy and marry my long term boyfriend in November hoping that things will fall in place..or.. What should I do! My long term boyfriend has also lost feelings for me but he still cares for me and he says if we work for our relationship, things will be good post marriage
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
It sounds like a difficult decision to make. But one simple thing is that you should never commit for a lifetime to a person you do not feel for; that does not mean I am asking you to leave him right away and marry the other guy. That means, you can have an open talk with your long-term BF. Tell him how you feel and let him clarify his feelings too. You can postpone the wedding to sort things out first- and think hard whether both of you want to get married at all.
Leaving one does not equate to choosing another. Choose yourself first; your happiness. You can never be happy in a relationship when you are of two minds. Please don't rush to get married to either of them.

Best Wishes.

..Read more

Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |713 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Oct 08, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 07, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship
This is an urgent situation and is really difficult to explain what I am going through and my words might not completely bring that out but a piece of advice/perception might be really helpful. I am 30 years old. I have a long term boyfriend(started dating in 2012). He was the world to me till almost 2020. He was my family, my everything. I too meant the world to him. We treated each other like "I am his and he is mine". Such was the commitment and care. We never thought we could even think of marrying some one else. We are in long distance since 2017. Used to meet once in every 2 months sort of. In 2021, I met some one else and started going out with him as we were in the same city just casually believing that nothing serious has to happen between us and that I "obviously" will marry my long term boyfriend undoubtedly. But things drastically changed. I developed strong feelings for this person and met more frequently. I went with the flow despite having immense guilt that things will eventually get very complicated and all the three of us will be hurt. But I never gathered the courage to break ties with this new person as the bonding was very maturely strong between us. Nor I could break ties with my long term boyfriend as he still was "my family" and he was the only one I resorted to whenever I needed someone. The new guy belongs to a caste my family will never agree and because of this I persuaded the marriage talks with my family for my long term boyfriend. My family agreed and my marriage date is scheduled in end of November 2024. But I everyday am in dilemma as to whether should I marry my long term boyfriend as scheduled or should I take a bold step of breaking it and going for the guy I met in 2021. I told my mother about the situation but she said my father will never agree for this new guy's caste and that its too late and I should marry as scheduled. I am not able to take a decision and going with the flow and probably will get married with this dual thought and uncertainty. I have thought a lot about this, about how my life will be with both of them, but its very difficult for me to break things with my long term boyfriend even though I have no romantic feelings for him from the past 3 years. There is 0 intimacy, neither emotional nor physical. But I do care for him. I do want him in my life, whether as a husband or otherwise. I feel the way he takes care of me and thinks about me, no one else will. But the thing is I don't actually "feel" for him anything, nor do I miss him as much, we don't talk the way we used to , there's a detachment. We are in long distance and are in such different fields that we never probably will live closer location wise. There's financial disparity. I earn almost thrice as him but we probably are okay with this. We both are aware of all these problems and are still ready to marry with the "hope" that things will eventually be okay. On the other hand, the guy I met in 2021- he has a good career and location wise, we are in long distance too but way better placed and in near future, his job location might be very flexible. He earns more but has huge family obligations as his family including his two brothers are not very well off. I have probably made peace with it when I thought about considering him for marriage. I love him and we have great emotional intimacy . I feel so calm and happy around him. It's like a festival when he is around me. He too loves me a lot and is ready to take efforts to make our marriage possible given the family and caste differences. I am really very disturbed and unable to decide whether I should break the marriage as if things don't improve after marriage, I will regret it always. Preparations have started slightly and it would be a big step now. Should I just forget about the 2021 guy and marry my long term boyfriend in November hoping that things will fall in place..or.. What should I do! My long term boyfriend has also lost feelings for me but he still cares for me and he says if we work for our relationship, things will be good post marriage
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
It sounds like a difficult decision to make. But one simple thing is that you should never commit for a lifetime to a person you do not feel for; that does not mean I am asking you to leave him right away and marry the other guy. That means, you can have an open talk with your long-term BF. Tell him how you feel and let him clarify his feelings too. You can postpone the wedding to sort things out first- and think hard whether both of you want to get married at all.
Leaving one does not equate to choosing another. Choose yourself first; your happiness. You can never be happy in a relationship when you are of two minds. Please don't rush to get married to either of them.

Best Wishes.

..Read more

Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |713 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Jan 06, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jan 03, 2025Hindi
Listen
Relationship
hi sir/maam I am 22 yrs old and my boyfriend is 28 yrs old. We both are in the same office right now and his home is very near from that. At this point, we've been in a relationship for 8 months. He is very emotional and understanding and always there for me. Nobody knows about us, only my friends do. I am not that serious but confused if i lose someone who had loved me this much. He asks about marriage but it would be intercaste so i say that parents would not approve this. My friends advice me to break up. I try to disconnect with him but as soon as I talk to him I fail to do. I feel like talking to him console him. The thing is I'll talk to my parents 2 yrs later but he asking for commitment as he is getting other marriage proposals and its the right time for him to get settle but for me, he's saying he's ready to wait only if i give commitment. My father has said once that study and become independent but never risk my self respect in this society. Should i risk my boyfriend's life by giving the commitment ? I'm confused because i think at this point im kind of girl that will adjust somehow atleast im getting a person who loves me alot, i also love him but he's more into this feeling. What should i do? Recently he's got a marriage proposal and his family is seriously asking for his answer but he was asking what i want? i asked him to consider that and directly said it will not be possible for me to commit but im still in dilemma- im losing sth imp, should i go for him?
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I understand your dilemma. All I can say is that neither one of you is wrong here. He wants commitment before he decides to wait for you, and you want some more time. Both your requirements make perfect sense. My suggestion is that if you really think that you can't commit, you should clear that to him right away, and let him decide whether or not he is okay to go on like that. It's not fair to keep him hanging nor will it be right to make a decision for him. Give him clarity of the situation and let him decide.

In case you guys decide to break up, let him move on. I understand the urge to comfort him, but doing so, you are only going to stall his moving on process.

Hope this helps.

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11090 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Mar 31, 2026

Money
I am 70 yrs old. No financial commitment right now. Retired from Bank 10 yrs ago. I am expecting around 1.00 cr from immovable property sale. Please suggest, where I can invest.
Ans: You are in a comfortable and strong position at age 70. Having no financial commitments and receiving about Rs 1 crore from property sale gives you a valuable opportunity to create stable income for life and protect capital for future medical needs and family support. This stage requires capital protection first, income second, growth third.

Below is a structured approach suitable for your age and situation.

» First Priority – Keep Emergency Medical Reserve Separate

Before investing the full amount:

– Keep about Rs 10–15 lakh in safe and liquid options
– This amount should be available immediately for health needs
– It should not be linked to market movement
– This gives peace of mind and avoids forced withdrawals later

At age 70, this step is very important.

» Second Priority – Monthly Income Planning

Your investment should generate regular income without risk to capital stability.

Suggested approach:

– Allocate around 40% into conservative mutual funds suitable for income withdrawal
– Start Systematic Withdrawal Plan (monthly income)
– Withdraw only moderate amount so capital lasts longer

This helps create pension-like income without locking money permanently.

» Third Priority – Stability Allocation

Another 30–35% can be placed in safe interest-oriented instruments like:

– senior citizen eligible deposit structures
– post office backed income options
– short-duration debt-oriented mutual funds

Purpose:

– predictable returns
– low volatility
– steady support income

» Fourth Priority – Growth Portion (Important Even at 70)

Even at age 70, some allocation to growth is necessary because:

– inflation reduces purchasing power
– medical costs rise every year
– life expectancy now extends beyond 85

So allocate about 20–25% into carefully selected diversified equity-oriented mutual funds through staggered investment.

This portion protects long-term wealth value.

» Avoid Investing Entire Amount in One Option

Many retirees make this mistake:

– putting full amount into deposits
– locking full amount into one scheme
– giving money for high-return private offers
– lending to relatives without structure

Diversification is the protection shield at this stage.

» Tax Efficiency Planning Is Important

Property sale creates capital gains implications.

So before investing:

– calculate capital gains tax properly
– explore legal reinvestment strategies available
– structure investments in phases instead of lump sum deployment

This preserves more of your wealth.

» Nomination and Estate Planning Must Be Updated

Since you have no commitments now:

– ensure nominee details are correct
– prepare a simple Will
– document investment structure clearly
– inform family members where records are stored

This prevents confusion later.

» Suggested Allocation Structure (Simple Model)

A balanced structure may look like:

– 10–15% emergency reserve
– 30–35% stable income options
– 40% income-support mutual funds
– 20–25% growth mutual funds

This creates:

– monthly income
– liquidity
– inflation protection
– capital safety balance

» Health Insurance Check

Even if you already have coverage:

– review whether coverage is sufficient today
– add top-up if required
– keep separate medical reserve anyway

Medical inflation is the biggest risk after retirement.

» Finally

At age 70, the goal is not maximum return. The goal is steady income, capital protection, and independence with dignity. With proper allocation of this Rs 1 crore, you can comfortably create reliable income support for the rest of your life while preserving wealth for future needs and family support.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11090 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Mar 30, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Mar 30, 2026Hindi
Money
Hi, I am 44 years old salaried having monthly income of 2 lakhs living in Gurgaon, planning to retire by 2030. we are family of 3, me wife & daughter in class 9th. Sharing below details, m i on right track & what advice would help me maximizing gains out of below portfolio. 1- Term plan of 2 crores 2- Family health cover 10 lakhs 3- 2BHK house loan free in Gurgaon having resale price of 1 cr. 5 years old property high rise. 4- 3 BHK house loan free in Gurgaon, current value 1.3 cr. 5- EPF accumulation till now 50 lakhs. 6- SIP accumulation 53 lakhs with monthly SIP of 1,07,000. mix of LC,MC &small cap. 7- OLD lic jeewan anand poly maturing in 2033 - 20 lakhs 8- PPF accumulation till now 11 lakhs 9- SSY for kid accumulation 11 lakhs. 10- Rental income 22k from 2 bhk. Booked another 3 BHK "2 cores", possession in 2028, Bank loan. current EMI is 52k, as loan is partial loan disbursed. Do not posses any inherited property or money. Is it wise to retire by age 50 with above investment. planning to repay bank loan before retirement either by selling 2 bhk & remaining by savings. Monthly expenses including school fees stands 50-60 k today.
Ans: You have built a very strong financial base by age 44. Two debt-free houses, strong SIP discipline, EPF accumulation, child education savings and protection planning show clarity and commitment. Early retirement by age 50 is possible in many cases like yours, but it needs careful adjustment in the next 5 years because your retirement horizon is long (almost 35+ years after retirement).

Below is a structured assessment and improvement roadmap.

» Your Present Financial Strength

– Term cover of Rs 2 crore is appropriate for your income level and responsibilities
– Family health cover of Rs 10 lakh is good, but can be strengthened
– Two loan-free houses worth about Rs 2.3 crore together provide stability
– EPF corpus Rs 50 lakh is a strong retirement backbone
– SIP corpus Rs 53 lakh with monthly investment Rs 1.07 lakh is excellent discipline
– Child education corpus already started through SSY Rs 11 lakh
– PPF Rs 11 lakh adds safe retirement cushion
– Rental income Rs 22,000 supports future passive income planning
– One traditional insurance maturity expected Rs 20 lakh in 2033 adds support

Overall, your base is strong for someone targeting retirement at 50.

» One Important Reality About Early Retirement

Retiring at 50 means your wealth must support:

– Household expenses for 35+ years
– Child higher education and possibly marriage
– Medical inflation
– Lifestyle inflation
– Loan closure before retirement

So the focus now should shift from accumulation only to income sustainability planning.

» Your Current Monthly Expense vs Retirement Need

Today expenses are Rs 50–60k including school fees.

After retirement:

– School fees will reduce later
– But lifestyle expenses increase with inflation
– Medical costs increase after age 55
– Travel and personal goals increase after retirement

Practically, your retirement income target should be higher than today's number.

Your rental income already supports part of this.

That is a strong advantage.

» Impact of the New 3 BHK Purchase

Booking another property worth Rs 2 crore is the only area where caution is required.

Because:

– Loan continues till retirement window
– EMI reduces SIP flexibility
– Possession in 2028 means financial pressure close to retirement year
– Real estate concentration becomes high in total portfolio

Your idea of selling 2 BHK before retirement to close the loan is sensible and practical.

This improves retirement safety significantly.

» Health Insurance Needs Immediate Upgrade

Current cover Rs 10 lakh is not sufficient for a family of three in a metro city.

Suggested improvement:

– Increase family cover to Rs 25–30 lakh using top-up structure
– This protects retirement corpus from medical shocks

This is very important before age 50.

» Education Planning for Daughter

Child is in class 9 now.

Higher education timeline:

– Only 3–5 years away

SSY corpus Rs 11 lakh is a good start.

But education costs may require additional support from:

– SIP accumulation
– LIC maturity Rs 20 lakh (2033)
– Partial EPF later if required

Plan this carefully so retirement corpus is not disturbed.

» Retirement Income Planning Strategy

Your future retirement income sources may include:

– Rental income from one house
– EPF withdrawals after retirement
– Mutual fund SWP income
– PPF maturity support
– LIC maturity amount
– Possible second property decision

Because you already have multiple income sources, retirement at 50 becomes realistic if loan closes before retirement.

» SIP Strategy – Continue Aggressively Till 2030

Your SIP of Rs 1.07 lakh is the strongest engine in your portfolio.

Maintain this for next 5 years without interruption.

Also ensure:

– Allocation remains diversified across large, mid and small companies
– Periodic portfolio review every 12 months
– Avoid stopping SIP during market corrections

This step alone can decide early retirement success.

» EPF Should Be Preserved Till Retirement

Do not withdraw EPF before retirement unless emergency arises.

EPF acts as:

– capital stability layer
– longevity protection layer
– inflation balancing support

This is your safest retirement pillar.

» LIC Policy – Keep Till Maturity

Since maturity is approaching in 2033 and value is reasonable, continue it.

It will support mid-retirement liquidity needs.

» Asset Allocation Observation

Currently your portfolio has:

– strong real estate exposure
– strong equity SIP exposure
– strong retirement accumulation through EPF
– safe allocation through PPF and SSY

This is a balanced structure already.

Only improvement required:

Increase financial asset share slightly over next 5 years.

» Is Retirement at Age 50 Possible?

Yes, possible if these conditions are followed:

– Close housing loan before retirement
– Continue SIP till 2030 without reduction
– Increase health insurance cover
– Avoid additional liabilities
– Preserve EPF till retirement stage
– Plan daughter education separately from retirement corpus

If these steps are followed, retirement at 50 becomes achievable and comfortable.

» Action Steps For Next 5 Years

– Continue SIP Rs 1.07 lakh monthly
– Increase health insurance protection
– Avoid new liabilities
– Close upcoming housing loan before retirement
– Build additional emergency fund equal to 12 months expenses
– Review portfolio once every year with a Certified Financial Planner
– Keep rental income reserved for future retirement buffer

» Finally

You are already ahead of many professionals in your age group.

Your discipline, debt-free properties and strong SIP commitment create a solid base for early retirement success. With small corrections in health protection, loan closure timing and retirement income structuring, retiring at age 50 can become a practical and safe decision instead of a risky one.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x