Can I save LTCG tax selling rural plots for an urban one?

Ans: If the construction is completed within 3 years of transfer of residential plot, you are not liable to pay tax on LTCG on transfer of plot.

Ans: Plz. Approach a tax consultant/CA because the calculation in your case will be a detailed one and, in any case, you will need CA certificate to validate the tax liability arising out of this property sale transaction.

Ans: (A). Let's first talk about F/Y 2023-24 :
You jointly sold a Property during the year for Rs.76.80 lakhs (64.80+10.00+2.00), & sold the same for Rs.100.00 lakhs.
You have jointly also purchased Property No.3 (I suppose it is Residential only), for Rs.140.00 lakhs.
You should avail exemption u/s-54 & file your ITR accordingly. Please disclose all details about sale & purchase in your ITR.
02. Now coming to the F/Y 2024-25 :
You intend to Sell Property No.2, which was acquired in 2023-24. Any Gain on Sale of it would be Short Term capital Gains & taxed accordingly.
Alternatively, you may hold this sale of property no.2 (for 2 years from its purchase) & avoid STCG
You are free to utilize the sale proceeds in a way you like, including paying off your housing Loan.
Please note to avail exemption u/s 54 only from investment in property no.3 & not 2.
Most welcome for any further clarifications. Thanks.

Ans: Your tax liability depends on several factors, including the nature of the land, how it is being sold, and how you reinvest the proceeds. Let's break it down step by step.

1. Taxation on Sale of Agricultural Land
The tax treatment of your sale depends on whether your land qualifies as a rural agricultural land or urban agricultural land under the Income Tax Act.

Rural Agricultural Land: If the land is in a rural area (outside notified municipality limits or beyond a specified population threshold), it is not considered a "capital asset" under the Income Tax Act. No capital gains tax is applicable.
Urban Agricultural Land: If the land is within a municipality or close to it, it is considered a capital asset. Capital gains tax will apply.
Since you are developing the land and selling it in small plots, tax treatment will depend on whether the sale is considered a capital gain or business income.

2. Is the Sale Taxed as Capital Gains or Business Income?
Capital Gains Tax: If you are simply selling agricultural land as a capital asset, long-term capital gains (LTCG) apply if held for more than 2 years. Otherwise, short-term capital gains (STCG) apply.
Business Income Tax: Since you are incurring costs on development (roads, electricity, etc.) and selling it in smaller plots, the tax department may treat this as a business activity rather than a capital gain transaction. In that case:
Profit from sale will be taxed as business income at slab rates instead of LTCG.
Expenses on development (electricity, roads, etc.) can be deducted from your total income.
No LTCG tax benefits will apply since it is treated as business income.
If the tax department considers it capital gains, here’s how it will be taxed:

3. If Taxed Under Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG)
LTCG Calculation:
Sale Price – Indexed Cost of Purchase – Indexed Cost of Development = LTCG
LTCG is taxed at 20% with indexation benefit.
Exemptions Available:
Section 54F: If you use full sale proceeds to buy a residential house, you can claim full exemption. However, buying a residential plot alone does not qualify for exemption unless you construct a house within 3 years.
Capital Gains Bonds (Section 54EC): You can invest up to Rs 50 lakhs in NHAI/REC bonds within 6 months to get exemption.
4. If Taxed Under Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG)
If the land is considered urban agricultural land and sold within 2 years, the gain is added to your income and taxed as per income tax slab rates.
No exemption under Section 54F or 54EC is available.
5. If Taxed as Business Income
Profits are taxed as per your income slab (which could go up to 30% plus cess).
Development costs like roads, electricity, etc., are deductible.
No LTCG exemptions apply (like 54F or 54EC).
6. What Happens if You Do Not Buy Any Property?
If considered LTCG, you will pay 20% tax with indexation on gains.
If considered business income, you will pay slab rate tax on profits.
If considered STCG, it is added to your total income and taxed at slab rates.
7. Your Case – Tax Planning Considerations
Since you are selling in plots and incurring development costs, there is a high chance that this will be treated as business income rather than LTCG.
Buying a residential plot alone does not qualify for LTCG exemption. You need to construct a house within 3 years for exemption.
If you want to reduce tax liability, consider investing in capital gain bonds (54EC) or a ready-to-move residential house (54F).
If the sale extends beyond FY 2024-25, capital gains will be split across years, allowing tax planning opportunities.
Final Thoughts
Confirm whether the land is rural or urban to determine if capital gains tax applies.
Understand how the tax department may classify your sale—as capital gains or business income.
If it's business income, reinvesting in a residential plot won’t give tax benefits.
If you want to save tax, either buy a house (not just a plot) or invest in capital gains bonds.
Let me know if you need more clarity on specific points.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment