Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Should I Call Off My Wedding Due to My Fiancee's Past?

Shalini

Shalini Singh  | Answer  |Ask -

Dating Coach - Answered on Mar 21, 2025

Shalini Singh is the founder of andwemet, an online matchmaking service for urban Indians living in India and overseas. After graduating from college as a kindergarten teacher, Singh worked at various firms specialising in marketing strategy, digital marketing and public relations before finding her niche as an entrepreneur. In 2008, she founded Galvanise PR, an independent communications and public relations. In 2019, she launched andwemet.
... more
Asked by Anonymous - Mar 21, 2025Hindi
Listen
Relationship

I (30M) recently got engaged to my Fiancee (27F) & shared the Photos of our Engagement on Instagram, wherein they were noticed by an old friend of mine. He recognised my Fiancee & told me some things about her, which startled me. When she was in the Final Year of Engineering, she got an Internship Opportunity in a Reputed MNC, where my Friend was also working. At her Office, most of the Employees & Interns were Male & she was one of the very few Females. Her Manager was a Middle Aged Divorcee. He had offered her a Permanent Job at the Company, after her Internship, in exchange for Sexual Intimacy. Apparently, she had given in & everyone at her Office was aware of the Affair between her & her Boss. Initially, I assumed this to be a Rumour, but still wanted to clarify this with her, even though, I had no Proof except his word of mouth. When I Questioned her, she admitted that, it was indeed the Truth that she had slept with her Boss for her Career Growth. But she also tried to Justify herself, saying that she was a Young & Naive Fresher at that time & the Offer seemed quite Tempting as her Family was going through Financial Difficulties at that point of time. But she also went on to add her narrative that the Affair lasted for just 2 years. During that time, she also used to suffer from Sexual Harassment from other Male Colleagues, as they had assumed that she was an 'Easily Available' kind of Girl who'd sleep with anyone & she had a Hard time, resisting their Sexual Advances. Apparently, my Old Friend was also among those who were trying to Bed her. But she quit working at that Company, as soon as, she got a better offer in another Company, without having to make any Sexual Compromise & since then she'd been working hard for her Career Growth & had never done anything Immoral or Unethical again. Hearing all these things about my Fiancee & my Old Friend, disturbed me greatly. But my Fiancee didn't seem to have any Regrets as she believes that all of it was her Past, which happened more than 5 years ago & it doesn't affect her Present or our Future, in any way. She also reassured me that she would be a Loyal Wife to me after Marriage & would never Sleep with anyone else, under any circumstances. Now I am in Dilemma, whether I should Trust my Fiancee & take a Huge Leap of Faith, by going ahead with the Marriage, as planned, or should I call off the Wedding & try to find some other Woman with a Decent Character? Please advise me.

Ans: 1. Should you trust her as a person - going by what she has said, you should as she has been honest and shared everything with you

2. And if she says she does not have any regrets, more power to her - how will having regrets and feeling guilty justify.

3. We all make mistakes and she did what she did as she was 'single' she did not cheat anyone

4. As for you wanting to marry her or not is your decision...remember you both need to invest in the relationship daily and cannot/should not bring up the past even in disagreements - this is important for you to understand.

All the best in whatever decision you make.

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1622 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Oct 17, 2023

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 07, 2023Hindi
Relationship
Greetings, Anu. I am a 50-year-old married man in a relationship with a married woman 17 years my junior. She is exceptionally gorgeous and intelligent, and we were both colleagues until she changed jobs a few days ago. I had introduced her to my boss and my mentor, who work in a different organisation. After a while, I found she was constantly talking and discussing him with me, and my senoir was constantly inquiring about her whenever I went to meet him. I began to suspect, and one day I abruptly asked my partner what was up with her. She wasn't prepared for the query, and the first thing out of her mouth was the name of my senior, despite the fact that I had asked or said nothing about him. She tried to right herself and began explaining that she had received his texts complimenting her appearance and discussing her profession. I asked how often they exchanged messages, and she said once or twice a month. I begged her to desist from doing so in the future. But I tracked her and discovered that they were both online for over 14 to 18 hours every day, and their online times were almost identical to the extent of seconds, if not minutesAs she is a teacher, I asked for her weekly schedule so that I could contact her anytime she was available, which she provided. However, I discovered that both were online throughout her class hour. When I questioned her, she stated that her schedule had altered. I saw both of them online till the early hours of the morning from a different phone that had their numbers, and they had that number recorded in the other phone I was tracking them with. I started interrogating her directly one day and asked her how much time she spent chatting with him everyday, and she responded anywhere between 10 and 30 minutes, once or twice a week. I asked for her phone and discovered that all of her messages had been deleted. When I asked her what she talked about practically every day with him, she responded academics. I tried to ask her a few questions, and she gradually began to open up as she felt imprisoned after every other question she had replied. She admitted that my senior was speaking with her and that he frequently complimented her on her appearance and discussed a variety of other topics. She also argued with me about what was wrong with being online and conversing with someone. She stated that she thought my senior was a kind person. I asked her how she felt about him, and she avoided answering by chatting about unimportant stuff. I stopped communicating with her and responding to her texts. She didn't contact or text me on the first day, either, but on the third day, she began sending me love messages and beseeching me to respond. I persuaded myself into it, but she continued speaking with my senior all day and till past midnight, as I could see both online, even after she had blocked my number with another number I had taken from her good buddy. She attempted to persuade me, and I consented. I could tell that she maintained her friendship with my senior, and she frequently neglected to respond to my messages, even though she was spotted online long after I had sent them to her. I returned to her and we had a discussion about the same topic before I stopped talking to her. She did not message or phone me for two days, but on the third day she called and I had to pick up because something extremely important had to be discussed in another topicAfter that matter was discussed, I ended the call, and she began to send me love pictures and love messages again, as well as saying she wanted to talk to me and that I should not behave like this, at least with her. I agreed and dialled her number. She argued with me, accusing me of not believing her. I told her to keep away from my senior and that I shouldn't see her online with him anymore. She agreed, and I saw she wasn't online anymore, despite the fact that my senior was. This caused me to reconsider, and I discovered that she had applied for a new phone number and acquired a new phone two days prior. I asked her, and she refused, but the source from whom I learned was certain because my partner had asked her for a decent shop for mobiles as well as the network for the new phone. Madam , I had asked her several times what she talked about with him for hours every day, but she never answered, and now that she has a new phone, I know why....What should I do????
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
What you should do is to move on with your life which is getting impossible with you monitoring her every move.
Your peace of mind is gone and she isn't required to give you the explanations that you seek...she has the freedom as much as you do to speak with anyone that she chooses...so why are you so stuck on this?

Is it love and also both of you are married...(this is not to judge either of you...) but where there is no commitment, there is no reason to get possessive or demand explanations. The same goes for her as well in case she starts to stalk you and gets on your case...

So, now let her be and befriend who she wants to...there is no way that you can stop her...so simply get on with your life...there are better things to do than run around chasing someone who is chasing someone else...

All the best!

..Read more

Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |601 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Oct 22, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 20, 2024
Relationship
Hi Sir, I met my wife in a matrimonial website.Our parents discussed our profiles and then we exchanged our numbers.We met once and then remained in contact for almost 9-10 months and during this period we became friends and met 3-4 times in public places.After that we both realised that we should see each other and get married.Then our courtship period started and I told her about my past and also told her that i had sex with my sex girlfriend.She also told me that she had 2 boyfriends and never had sex with anyone.I believed her and we met couples of times during our courtship period in cafes and hotels but never had sex.We discussed almost everything during that period and she confirmed that she is a virgin.After 6 months courtship period we got married and things were going good.After 10 months of marriage I found a chat backup on her phone and it was with her ex.They were discussing sex and with those messages it was clear that they had sex multiple times and she even took an Ipill due to unprotected sex... When i confronted her she again lied and denied the allegations.When i showed her the messages she confessed that they had sex thrice. I am broke now and this lie is taking all my peace and I am overthinking about this which is impacting my work as well.Though i am trying to be normal with her but somewhere in my conscious mind i keep on thinking this.The problem is that she lied not about the virginity. One fact that from the day we decided she never cheated on me and even i am very much loyal to her. need your help sir!!!!please suggest what to do now....
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I am glad you found your person. I understand that it is difficult for you to accept that she hid something that was important for you to know, especially when you shared your past experiences honestly. Your feelings are valid. But let's just take a second to think of this from a woman's perspective- it can be difficult for women to share certain details of their lives because of how easily society will judge them harshly for the same thing that they will ignore if a man does. I suppose she was afraid you would judge her too. Nevertheless, it was not right.

There are a few things to do now- first, focus on the positives. As you mentioned, she has been very loyal and loving to you- focus on that. Let the past be in the past; it can't be changed, but it can ruin your present and future if you let it. Second, if this revelation is causing extreme turmoil in your relationship, please consider seeing a marriage counselor together, or you can also see a therapist alone. They are professionals and can help you navigate your feelings in a more structured way.

Best wishes

..Read more

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1622 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Dec 07, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 06, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship
I'm caught up in a very difficult situation. I had met a Woman through Arranged Marriage Platform, while we both were getting along quite well with each other, I told her that I'm Virgin & asked her about her Past Relationship(s) if any, she denied categorically. We got Engaged, last month (in November) & our Wedding is scheduled next Month (January). Preparations are going on, including Distribution of Invitation cards. A few days ago, a Guy contacted me, claiming to be my Fiancee's Ex Boyfriend. Initially, I didn't take him seriously as I trusted my Fiancee. But then he showed me some Photos & Videos of their Intimate Moments (as it was apparent from the Videos, she seemed to be conscious & fully aware that their intimate moments are being recorded & some of the Photos were Nude/Semi-Nude Selfies, which she'd taken & shared with her ex Boyfriend, by herself... but she had not consented to share them with anyone else). I was Shocked. The Ex Boyfriend Reassured me that he'd also moved on from her & wouldn't bother her after her Marriage, but he was feeling bitter that she'd Dumped him to Marry me & just wanted to make me aware of what kind of Woman I'd be Marrying. I confronted my Fiancee over a Phone Call & asked her to meet me personally, as there were many Questions disturbing my Heart & Mind and I wanted to demand an Explanation from her. But she refused to meet up with me & wouldn't even discuss anything related her Relationship History on Phone Call/Video Call or WhatsApp Chat. She just kept telling me that it was all in her 'Past' & Promised me that after we both get Married, she'd be a Faithful Wife, Loyal to me. I want to have an Open-Heart conversation with her to Re-evaluate our Relationship before taking any big decision further. But, since she's bluntly Refusing to open up & discuss anything about her Past with me, I am losing Trust in her. Now I am in Dilemma, whether I should blindly Trust her & go ahead with the Marriage as Planned or shall discuss the matter with our Parents & get the Marriage Cancelled, to avoid taking such a Big Risk?
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
What made the ex-bf come and disrupt things? Is this his way of getting back at his ex-gf (your soon to be wife)?
I would not trust his intentions...at the same time, now that you know, you have the right to actually talk to her and clarify things. She needs to respect your need to know; but did it occur to you that she might have not opened up with you as she has been afraid of this confrontation?

Many people have a past and it may not be pleasant and in this case, that's what it seems like...if she is hesitant, reassuring her and giving her a comfort space to open up maybe the best thing to do. She needs to know that she is safe with you to share and she may tell you everything. Now, how you use that information is left to your wisdom BUT do not judge people based on their past. Why I say this is: I do not trust the ex-bf's intentions coming to you and close to the wedding sharing information that suggests that he might be out to destroy her reputation.

Now whether you must blindly trust her or not, is something that you ask yourself. If you are willing to set things aside and hear her version of the story and then either you trust or you don't; no conditions apply. That is your choice...But when you make a choice of trusting, then DO NOT look back...

All the best!
Anu Krishna
Mind Coach|NLP Trainer|Author
Drop in: www.unfear.io
Reach me: Facebook: anukrish07/ AND LinkedIn: anukrishna-joyofserving/

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8940 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 18, 2025
Money
I recently inherited Rs 80 lakh after selling my father's ancestral property in Kerala. I deposited 40 lakhs into my mother's account so she can get a fixed income of Rs 40,000 for her expenses as she lives with her sister in Kerala. We live in Bangalore. I currently have a Rs 50 lakh home loan with 18 years pending. My wife is a teacher, and I am in sales. We have been investing Rs 15,000/month in mutual fund SIPs for the past 7 years and have a fixed deposit of 2 lakhs as an emergency fund. My goal is to retire by age 50. Should I use the lump sum to reduce my loan burden or grow my corpus through mutual funds?
Ans: You have inherited Rs 80 lakh by selling your father’s ancestral property. You’ve taken a wise and respectful step by setting aside Rs 40 lakh for your mother’s financial stability. That’s a thoughtful act of responsibility.

Now, you and your wife live in Bangalore. Your current financial structure includes:

Rs 50 lakh home loan (18 years remaining)

Rs 15,000/month in mutual fund SIPs for 7 years

Rs 2 lakh in fixed deposit as emergency fund

Rs 40 lakh remaining from inheritance

You are in sales, wife is a teacher

Goal: Retire by age 50 (we assume you're around 35–40 now)

Let us now build a 360-degree approach to guide how to use this Rs 40 lakh. Should you repay the loan or grow your corpus?

Let us analyse this from retirement, wealth building, debt management, risk, and liquidity angles.

Home Loan Situation: Let’s Understand It Clearly
Your outstanding home loan is Rs 50 lakh, and tenure left is 18 years. This is long-term debt. EMI is not mentioned, but assuming a typical rate around 8.5%, your interest outgo is massive over the years.

Most of your EMIs now go into interest, not principal. You are paying for the bank’s profit more than building your own home equity.

So, prepaying early helps most. It reduces the total interest and shortens loan duration.

But should you use the entire Rs 40 lakh? Or balance it with investments for growth?

Let’s explore both sides.

Option 1: Use Full Rs 40 Lakh to Prepay Home Loan
Pros:
Instant reduction of loan burden

EMI pressure becomes lighter

Frees up future cashflow

Guaranteed return (equal to home loan interest rate)

Gives peace of mind, reduces mental stress

Cons:
You lose liquidity

No money left for investing

No compounding opportunity

May delay your retirement corpus growth

Future inflation may hurt if investment base is too low

Verdict: Good if you hate debt and prioritise peace over growth. But not ideal for FIRE-style or early retirement goals.

Option 2: Don’t Prepay, Invest Entire Amount in Mutual Funds
Pros:
Rs 40 lakh invested in mutual funds grows faster

Long-term equity returns are 12–14% with good funds

Can create Rs 1.5–2 crore corpus in 15–17 years

Can be used for early retirement or large goals

Flexibility to redeem anytime

Cons:
Markets are volatile in short term

Need discipline and patience

You continue paying high home loan interest

Must avoid panic during market corrections

Verdict: Great for long-term wealth creation. Works well only if you’re mentally prepared for equity volatility.

Option 3: Blended Strategy – Prepay Part of Loan, Invest the Rest
This is the most balanced and strategic option.

Use Rs 15–20 lakh to prepay the home loan

This will reduce EMI duration by 5–6 years

Use Rs 2–3 lakh to top-up your emergency fund

Invest the remaining Rs 17–20 lakh in actively managed mutual funds

This approach:

Reduces your debt

Frees future cashflow

Builds your investment base

Keeps you on track for early retirement

Manages liquidity smartly

Verdict: This approach gives you flexibility, peace, and growth together. Ideal for your stage.

Emergency Fund and Risk Cover Must Be Updated
Right now, your emergency fund is Rs 2 lakh. This is not enough for a family in a metro.

Increase it to at least Rs 5 lakh

Use a combination of savings account, sweep-in FD, and liquid mutual funds

This will help in job loss, medical issue, or home repair

You should also review these:

Health Insurance
Don’t depend on employer policy alone

Take personal health insurance of Rs 10 lakh

Add a Rs 25 lakh super top-up plan

Term Insurance
Take term cover till age 60

Cover should be 10–12x your annual income

Do not take ULIP or endowment plans

Review Your Mutual Fund Portfolio
You have been investing Rs 15,000 monthly in SIPs for 7 years. That’s excellent. You already have a strong habit.

Let us now improve the structure and quality of your portfolio.

Avoid Index Funds
Index funds invest blindly. No risk control. No downside protection. They follow the market.

Cannot shift away from underperforming sectors

Crash when market crashes

No role of active fund manager

You get average returns, not better

For early retirement, you need better than average.

Use Actively Managed Funds Instead
These funds have expert management

They shift between sectors and stocks

Reduce volatility better

Create better risk-adjusted returns

Help you stay invested confidently

Invest through regular plans with help from a Certified Financial Planner-backed MFD.

Why Not Direct Funds?
Direct plans look cheap. But they don’t give support.

No portfolio review

No exit timing support

No tax harvesting

High chances of emotional mistakes

No rebalancing

Regular plans via a qualified MFD help you manage emotions, risk, and performance.

For FIRE or early retirement, these mistakes can cost you years.

Create a Fresh SIP Plan Using Lump Sum
You will have Rs 15–20 lakh available for investment.

Do this:

Start STP (Systematic Transfer Plan) from a liquid fund

Gradually invest into equity over 12–18 months

Use 4–5 high-quality funds only

Divide across:

Large and Midcap Funds (30%)

Multicap Funds (30%)

Flexicap Funds (25%)

Small Cap Funds (15%)

You can also add Balanced Advantage Fund if you want lower volatility.

Once your home loan prepayment is done, increase monthly SIP from Rs 15,000 to Rs 25,000.

Add a Rs 1,000 monthly step-up every year. This small step grows your SIP base over time.

Mutual Fund Tax Rules You Must Know
When you redeem equity funds:

LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%

STCG (held under 1 year) is taxed at 20%

For debt funds, both LTCG and STCG are taxed as per your slab

Plan redemptions smartly. Spread across financial years if needed.

Let your CFP guide you during withdrawal to save tax.

Prepare for Retirement at 50
You are already on track. With right planning, you can retire by 50.

Here’s how to make it realistic:

Build Rs 4–5 crore investment corpus

Make loan-free home a priority by 45

Build Rs 50 lakh health corpus (through insurance + savings)

Create Rs 25,000–40,000 passive income per month via mutual fund SWP

Avoid lifestyle inflation

Track net worth growth every year

Let your Certified Financial Planner assess your retirement corpus regularly.

Don’t chase high returns. Chase consistency and discipline.

Final Insights
You’ve handled your inheritance responsibly. You’re on the right track to financial independence.

Use this 360-degree plan to stay on course:

Prepay Rs 15–20 lakh from your loan

Increase emergency fund to Rs 5 lakh

Invest Rs 17–20 lakh in active mutual funds

Use regular plans through a CFP-certified MFD

Replace index and direct funds from your portfolio

Increase SIPs as EMIs go down

Review fund performance twice a year

Get term and health insurance updated

Prepare a simple will and add nominations

You’re building a future not just for comfort, but for freedom.

Plan smart. Stay consistent. And let your money work harder than you.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8940 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 18, 2025
Money
I am a huge fan of the FIRE movement. I am 28, single and I aim to retire by 45. I just received Rs 20 lakh from an LIC maturity. I earn 2.5 lakh per month, live in Pune and have an active Rs 30,000/month SIP in index funds along with a debt of Rs 40 lakh home loan with 14 years left. My parents are not dependent on me. Should I prepay a chunk of my loan or stay invested to benefit from long-term compounding? Your non-AI insights will be really helpful
Ans: You are 28, single, based in Pune. You earn Rs 2.5 lakh per month. You aim to retire by 45. That’s 17 years to go.

You just received Rs 20 lakh from an LIC maturity. You already have a Rs 40 lakh home loan with 14 years left. EMI is not mentioned, but we will assume it is manageable given your income.

You also run a monthly SIP of Rs 30,000, but in index funds.

You are serious about FIRE — Financial Independence, Retire Early. That requires not just saving aggressively, but optimising every rupee and making every money decision with purpose.

Now let us discuss in detail whether to prepay your loan or invest this Rs 20 lakh elsewhere.

A Clear Look at Your Current Scenario
Let’s quickly summarise where you stand:

Age: 28 years

Salary: Rs 2.5 lakh/month (net)

Loan: Rs 40 lakh home loan (14 years left)

Received: Rs 20 lakh from LIC maturity

SIPs: Rs 30,000/month in index funds

Dependents: None (parents independent)

Location: Pune

Goal: Retire at 45 (in 17 years)

You are in an excellent position to build long-term wealth. No financial burden. High income. Long time horizon. Focused mindset.

But let’s now dig into whether loan prepayment or long-term investing is better for you.

Understand Your Home Loan Cost
Home loans are often low-cost loans. You likely pay 8–9% interest. It also gives tax benefit under Sections 24(b) and 80C.

Still, it is a long commitment. Even at 8.5% interest, you will end up paying double the loan amount over 14 years if no prepayment is done.

So, every rupee you prepay reduces interest significantly.

But you are aiming for FIRE — so let’s assess that from a bigger perspective.

Key FIRE Movement Principles You Must Apply
FIRE is not only about retiring early. It’s about building enough assets to stop working.

It means:

Maximise savings

Invest aggressively in growth assets

Eliminate bad or unproductive debt

Control lifestyle expenses

Create passive income streams

Plan for 40–50 years of life post-retirement

Your current life aligns with this. But now we must use this Rs 20 lakh with absolute clarity.

Let’s break your options now.

Option 1: Use Entire Rs 20 Lakh to Prepay the Loan
Pros:

Immediate reduction in home loan principal

Huge interest savings in the long run

Shorter EMI tenure or lower EMI amount

Psychological benefit of reduced debt

Lower pressure if your income reduces in future

Cons:

You lose liquidity

You reduce investment corpus at young age

You miss equity compounding in early years

It slows FIRE momentum in the beginning

This is a secure choice, but not ideal for your FIRE journey. Because FIRE needs asset growth, not just debt reduction.

Now let’s look at option 2.

Option 2: Stay Invested to Build FIRE Corpus
This is more aligned with your FIRE mindset. You can:

Keep Rs 3 lakh in emergency corpus

Invest Rs 17 lakh in equity mutual funds

Let it compound for 15–17 years

If you do this, you create a strong capital base. At 12–13% CAGR (achievable with smart active funds), this amount could grow 6–8 times in 17 years.

So, Rs 17 lakh could become Rs 1.2–1.4 crore by age 45.

Compare this with interest savings of prepaying the home loan. Interest savings may be Rs 15–18 lakh over 14 years.

But compounding from equity can give you Rs 1 crore-plus growth.

FIRE needs compounding to work for you, not for the bank.

Option 3: Blend the Two – Balance Growth with Risk Reduction
This is the most strategic choice for you.

Use Rs 5 lakh to prepay part of your loan

This cuts EMI duration by 1–2 years

Use Rs 2 lakh to create emergency fund

Invest Rs 13 lakh in actively managed mutual funds

This way you:

Reduce your future liability pressure

Don’t interrupt your FIRE goal

Keep investing for long-term wealth

Build resilience and liquidity

This blended approach gives you peace of mind and future freedom.

Now let’s discuss your SIP strategy next.

Avoid Index Funds for FIRE Strategy
You are investing Rs 30,000/month in index funds. These funds are marketed as low-cost and easy.

But they are not ideal for FIRE planning. Here's why:

Problems with Index Funds:
No human fund management or stock selection

They follow the index blindly

No downside protection during crashes

No rebalancing between sectors

Poor performance in sideways markets

You need alpha generation to achieve FIRE early. Index funds don’t give that.

Actively managed mutual funds have outperformed index funds consistently across 5–10 year periods.

They help:

Beat inflation

Provide stock selection advantage

Reduce volatility through rebalancing

Adjust to changing market cycles

Replace index funds with high-quality active mutual funds.

Do not try to manage this yourself. Work with a CFP-certified MFD.

Use regular funds and not direct plans. Let’s now see why.

Why You Should Avoid Direct Funds
You might think direct funds give better returns. But there is a big trade-off.

Disadvantages of Direct Funds:
No guidance or review

No portfolio rebalancing

No behavioural support in market dips

No tax harvesting support

You may over-diversify or miss key shifts

A Certified Financial Planner-backed MFD tracks your funds, trims losses, and boosts gains.

Regular funds cost a little more, but give professional care and structure.

Your FIRE dream is too important to be left to self-guessing.

Build Your FIRE Portfolio Structure
Now that you're serious about FIRE, here’s a smart allocation:

60% in flexicap, multicap and large & midcap funds

20% in smallcap funds (long-term only)

10% in balanced advantage funds

10% in gold mutual funds (not ETFs, not FOFs)

Use SIPs + occasional lumpsums to build this mix.

Keep portfolio clean. Only 5–6 funds. Review every 6 months with your CFP.

What to Do with Your LIC Money
You got Rs 20 lakh from an LIC policy. LIC returns are low. Just 4–5%.

It is wise you didn’t reinvest in another LIC or traditional plan.

If you hold any other ULIP or endowment policy, surrender it immediately.

Invest proceeds into mutual funds. LIC and ULIPs don’t work for FIRE goals.

Protect Your FIRE Plan with Insurance
You are young and healthy. Still, protect your plan.

Take Rs 1.5 crore term insurance till age 60

Take Rs 10 lakh health cover for self

Add Rs 25 lakh top-up policy for bigger protection

These give security so that your FIRE plan is not disturbed by life events.

Do not delay this. Premiums are lowest now.

Don’t Miss These Key Planning Elements
Emergency Fund
Keep Rs 3–4 lakh in liquid funds

Don’t keep it in savings account or FD

Tax Planning
Claim 80C through PPF or SIP in ELSS

Sell equity funds smartly using capital gain limits

Spread redemptions to reduce LTCG tax

New MF Tax Rules:
LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%.
STCG taxed at 20%.

Nomination & Will
Nominate your SIPs, bank, insurance

Make a basic will. Register it.

These are part of 360-degree FIRE planning.

Finally
You are on the perfect path. You are focused, young, and capable.

Here’s what to do now:

Prepay Rs 5 lakh of your home loan

Keep Rs 2 lakh as emergency fund

Invest Rs 13 lakh in active mutual funds (via regular plan)

Replace index SIPs with active funds

Increase SIP to Rs 40,000/month from next year

Review your plan twice a year with your CFP

Your FIRE dream is not just possible — it is highly achievable.

Every rupee must work hard for you. Let professionals manage it. You focus on your life goals.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8940 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 18, 2025
Money
I just encashed Rs 18 lakh from my ESOPs. I have a Rs 52 lakh home loan and 7 lakh car loan with 16 years remaining. I earn 1.8 lakh per month. My wife earns 15 lakh pa. No kids yet. We are already investing Rs 25,000/month in equity SIPs. Would it be better to prepay part of the loan or diversify into gold funds, REITs, and hybrid mutual funds to balance my portfolio?
Ans: You are earning Rs 1.8 lakh per month. Your wife also earns Rs 15 lakh per year. Together, you have a strong income. No children yet. That gives you a big head start in planning.

You have Rs 18 lakh cash from ESOP redemption. You have:

A Rs 52 lakh home loan

A Rs 7 lakh car loan

16 years left on both

Rs 25,000 monthly SIP in equity mutual funds

Let us now build a 360-degree strategy. We will look at loan prepayment, investment options, asset allocation, and future financial freedom.

First, Understand Your Loan Structure
Let’s break down your current liabilities:

Home loan: Rs 52 lakh, likely at ~8.5% rate

Car loan: Rs 7 lakh, likely at ~9.5–11% rate

Total outstanding: Rs 59 lakh

Both loans are long tenure (16 years). That means you will pay a lot in interest over time.

Early-stage EMIs mostly go towards interest. So prepayment in the early years saves you most interest.

You are in the perfect stage to act decisively. Now let’s decide how to use the Rs 18 lakh.

Priority: Reduce Expensive, Non-Asset Loans First
The car loan is not adding any value to your wealth. It is depreciating.

Car loan interest is also not eligible for tax deduction. So, you should:

Fully repay the car loan first using your ESOP amount

This gives guaranteed savings of 10% or more per year

It also improves your credit score and cashflow

Your EMI reduces, freeing money for SIPs or other goals

Now, you are left with a home loan of Rs 52 lakh.

Second Priority: Partial Home Loan Prepayment
Home loan interest is tax-deductible, but still, it's a long burden.

If you prepay Rs 10 lakh now, you can:

Reduce total interest paid by lakhs

Reduce the loan tenure by 4–5 years

Still enjoy full 80C and 24(b) tax benefits

Create mental peace with a lighter loan

Do not try to close it entirely. But reduce principal early. That gives maximum benefit.

Keep Rs 2–3 lakh in emergency fund. You should not be cash-dry.

Building Your Emergency Corpus
Every family must keep an emergency fund ready. You and your wife are both earning.

But still, job loss or medical emergencies can disturb your plan.

Keep at least Rs 3–4 lakh in a mix of:

Sweep-in savings account

Liquid mutual funds

Short-term FD if needed

Do not invest this money in gold or long-term assets.

Your SIP Strategy – Review and Enhance
You already invest Rs 25,000 monthly in equity mutual funds. This is a good start.

You can increase it once your car loan is cleared. That frees up more cash monthly.

Structure your mutual fund SIPs this way:

35% in flexicap funds

25% in large & midcap funds

25% in multicap funds

15% in small cap funds (for long-term)

Keep 4–5 high-quality funds across AMCs. Don’t over-diversify. Don’t chase returns.

Let your SIPs run for minimum 10 years. Increase them every year by 10–15%.

Use step-up SIP feature to automate this.

Don’t stop SIPs in market falls. They work best in such times.

Should You Invest in Gold Funds?
Let’s understand the role of gold in portfolio:

Gold funds: Pros

Good hedge in inflation periods

Works well when equity struggles

Can diversify overall asset mix

Gold funds: Risks

Does not generate income

No tax benefit

Very volatile over short term

No guaranteed returns

Long flat periods

You can allocate up to 10% of your portfolio in gold funds.

But don’t treat it as a growth asset. Use it for stability, not wealth creation.

Choose gold mutual funds that actually hold physical gold. Not fund of fund models.

Avoid ETFs and direct gold unless you understand market timing.

Invest through SIPs over 5–10 years. Avoid lump sum in gold.

Should You Consider REITs?
REITs are new to Indian investors. They own commercial real estate like offices, malls.

They offer:

Regular dividend-like income

Potential capital appreciation

Diversification outside equity

But they also have some risks:

Market-linked income, not guaranteed

Office sector is under stress after COVID

High debt in some REITs

Poor liquidity in bad times

Do not allocate more than 5–7% of your portfolio in REITs.

Use monthly investments. Choose only REITs with stable rentals and strong sponsors.

Don’t buy REITs just because they give income. Look at quality of holdings.

Hybrid Mutual Funds: Should You Add?
Hybrid funds invest in a mix of equity and debt.

There are 4 types:

Aggressive Hybrid: 65–80% in equity

Balanced Advantage: Dynamically manage equity-debt

Conservative Hybrid: Mostly in debt

Arbitrage: For short-term parking

You can include hybrid funds if:

You want a smoother ride

You are close to any financial goal

You want better risk-adjusted returns

You may put 15–20% of your portfolio in hybrid funds.

Avoid hybrid funds with inconsistent track records.

Prefer actively managed hybrid funds only. Not index-based hybrid models.

Let a Certified Financial Planner pick the right ones for your needs.

Do Not Invest in Index Funds
Many investors chase index funds. They think these are safe and low-cost.

But index funds have big problems:

No flexibility to manage market crashes

Invest blindly in top 50 or 100 stocks

No risk control mechanism

Poor performance during flat or falling markets

Cannot beat inflation in sideways trends

Actively managed mutual funds do better with proper fund management.

They can shift assets across sectors and reduce downside.

Use only regular plans through CFP-certified Mutual Fund Distributors (MFDs).

Do not invest in direct plans unless you review funds monthly and have market knowledge.

Direct plans have no support. No periodic portfolio review. No tax harvesting support.

Paying 0.5–1% to an expert is worth the peace of mind.

Tax Efficiency of Mutual Funds
Use these rules for future redemptions:

Equity Mutual Fund: LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%

Equity MF STCG taxed at 20%

Debt Mutual Funds taxed as per your slab

Plan redemptions carefully. Spread over financial years when possible.

Let your MFD/CFP help with tax harvesting strategies.

Other Wealth Areas to Check
Life Insurance
Take term insurance of Rs 1–1.5 crore

Cover should be till age 60

Do not invest in ULIPs or endowment policies

Health Insurance
Take family floater of Rs 10 lakh at least

Add a Rs 25 lakh top-up cover

Use group cover from employer only as backup

Will and Nomination
Prepare a will

Nominate both mutual funds and demat accounts

Register your will for legal ease

Finally
You are doing many things right already.

You are earning well, saving, and building equity exposure.

Use this Rs 18 lakh wisely. Repay the car loan. Part-pay your home loan.

Keep some emergency cash. Then invest more in hybrid, equity, and gold funds.

Use gold funds and REITs only for diversification. Don’t depend on them for growth.

Continue SIPs through regular funds advised by CFP-led MFDs. Avoid direct and index funds.

Build portfolio reviews every 6 months. Focus on risk-adjusted growth.

You can build a strong financial future with balance and patience.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8940 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 19, 2025
Money
I am 42 yrs old, salaried with take home salary of 2.57 lacs and PF/ NPS contribution of 45k per month. Wife is working with inhand salary of 1 lacs and PF/NPS contribution of 45k. Total savings in PF/NPS is 83 lacs. I have 1 home loan of 1.32 cr with monthly emi of 60k.( Staff loan simple interest @6%) 1st OD facility of 24 lacs @ interest rate of 14%, monthly interest is 28k 2nd OD facility of 10 lacs @ interest rate of 10.5% monthly interest of 10k 1 personal loan of 30 lacs @interest rate of 10.9%, emi of 65k. Alart from NPS/PF of 83 lacs, i have equity portfolio of 1.55 cr. 2 houses, 1bhk value 85 lacs loan free 2.5bhk value of 1.8 crs, for which loan as mentioned above. My monthly expenses are largely around 50k. Request help with financial freedom planning and how to go abt paying off debt and investment in equity/mfs
Ans: You are 42, salaried, with a strong income base. Your family has two earners, a high level of PF/NPS corpus, good real estate assets, and a robust equity portfolio. But there is also a significant debt burden. Let us now take a comprehensive look at your financial life and suggest a clear path towards financial freedom.

Your Current Financial Landscape
Combined Monthly Income (In-hand): Rs 3.57 lacs (You: Rs 2.57 lacs + Spouse: Rs 1 lac)

Monthly Mandatory Deductions: Rs 90k (Both contributing Rs 45k to PF/NPS)

Monthly Household Expenses: Rs 50k (Very efficient)

Total PF/NPS Corpus: Rs 83 lacs (Excellent for age 42)

Equity Investments: Rs 1.55 crores (Strong exposure to growth assets)

Property Holdings:

1 BHK (Rs 85 lacs, no loan)

2.5 BHK (Rs 1.8 crore, Rs 1.32 crore loan at 6%)

Debt Summary:

Home Loan: Rs 1.32 crore @6% (EMI Rs 60k)

OD Facility 1: Rs 24 lacs @14% (Interest Rs 28k monthly)

OD Facility 2: Rs 10 lacs @10.5% (Interest Rs 10k monthly)

Personal Loan: Rs 30 lacs @10.9% (EMI Rs 65k)

You are doing many things right. But your high-interest liabilities are acting as a drag. Let us plan step-by-step.

Key Priorities Identified
Eliminate High-Interest Debt Fast

Retain and Grow Wealth Through Equities

Align Investments to Retirement Goal

Build Adequate Emergency Corpus

Protect Wealth Through Risk Planning

Plan for Financial Freedom Timeline

Step 1: Handling Your Debt Structure
Your total EMIs and interest payments exceed Rs 1.6 lacs monthly. This is too high.

Breakdown of Outflow on Loans:

Home Loan EMI: Rs 60k

OD Interest 1: Rs 28k

OD Interest 2: Rs 10k

Personal Loan EMI: Rs 65k
Total: Rs 1.63 lacs per month

That’s nearly 45% of total family income.

You must reduce this immediately. Not through EMI increase, but through strategic repayment using your available equity corpus.

What Should You Do Now?
Do not prepay the home loan right now. It's a staff loan at only 6%.

Target OD Loans first. These are expensive and do not reduce principal unless you repay.

Repay OD Facility 1 and 2 completely using equity portfolio.

That frees up Rs 38k per month interest instantly.

Next, prepay Personal Loan partly or fully. It has a high interest and high EMI.

This will reduce outgo by Rs 65k per month.

After this, your only active EMI will be Rs 60k on the home loan. This is manageable.

If you liquidate Rs 64 lacs from your equity corpus, your loan outgo drops from Rs 1.63 lacs to Rs 60k. Huge improvement.

But what about taxation?

Yes, equity mutual fund gains above Rs 1.25 lac annually are taxed at 12.5%. Short-term capital gains are taxed at 20%. But still, it is better to pay tax and save long-term interest.

Paying 14% interest on OD is much worse than 12.5% tax once.

Use lump sum withdrawals smartly over 2–3 quarters if you want to minimise tax.

Step 2: Emergency Corpus Creation
With so many loans, keeping Rs 10–15 lacs liquid is necessary.

Use:

Rs 5 lacs in FD

Rs 5–7 lacs in ultra-short debt mutual funds

Rs 2–3 lacs in sweep-in savings account

This will help you avoid further OD borrowings.

Step 3: Review Your Equity Portfolio
You already have Rs 1.55 crore invested. That's a very good size.

After debt clearance, you will still have around Rs 90 lacs left in equity.

Review the portfolio in terms of:

Sector diversification

Fund overlap

Risk-adjusted return

Large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap balance

Don’t just invest based on returns. Look at volatility and drawdown risks also.

Actively managed funds help manage these risks better.

Avoid Index Funds
Index funds have no downside protection. They invest blindly across index stocks.

No human intervention during market crash

High overlap with other passive funds

Not suitable for active wealth planning

Underperform during sideways markets

Stick to actively managed funds for alpha generation and risk control.

Let Certified Financial Planner–guided MFD handle fund selection and rebalancing.

Step 4: Fresh SIP Strategy Post Debt Clearance
You will save almost Rs 1 lac per month after closing loans.

Start monthly SIP of Rs 60,000–75,000 in diversified mutual funds.

Use these categories:

Large and Midcap Funds

Multicap Funds

Flexicap Funds

Small Cap only upto 15% of SIPs

Break SIPs across 4–5 fund houses. Don’t chase short-term performance. Stay invested.

Use step-up SIP feature. Increase SIP by Rs 5k every year.

Do not invest directly. Avoid direct plans.

Why Not Direct Plans?
No personalised guidance

No regular portfolio reviews

Misses rebalancing opportunities

Errors in fund switching and tax harvesting

Regular plan via CFP-led MFDs ensures professional portfolio care.

The extra 0.5–1% expense is worth the quality guidance.

Step 5: Planning for Financial Freedom
You can aim to retire or semi-retire by age 55.

That gives you 13 more earning years.

By following this path, you can build a strong corpus:

PF/NPS: Rs 83 lacs now, grows to Rs 2.5–3 crores

Equity: Rs 90 lacs now, grows to Rs 3.5–4.5 crores

Home: Loan-free 2 homes; one can generate rental income

That’s more than Rs 6–7 crore wealth in 13 years.

You can plan to stop active work by 55 and live off investments.

You need only Rs 1.2–1.5 lacs per month post-retirement, based on current lifestyle.

That’s easy to generate with SWPs from equity and PPF/NPS withdrawal strategy.

But you must stay disciplined in debt, SIPs and equity holding.

Step 6: Estate and Wealth Protection
Do not ignore these areas:

Term Insurance
Keep cover till age 60

Cover should be 10x of annual income

If you already have cover, review sufficiency

Health Insurance
Have separate health cover outside employer policy

Get family floater of Rs 10 lacs minimum

Add top-up of Rs 25 lacs for future hospitalisation

Will & Nomination
Make a will now itself

Register all nominations in mutual funds, PF, bank, demat

Step 7: Avoid These Common Mistakes
Never take OD for investment or lifestyle

Don’t delay debt clearance because markets are rising

Don’t stop SIPs during market fall

Don’t invest in direct funds unless you are full-time into finance

Don’t take advice from friends or social media posts

Your finances are too valuable to risk.

Final Insights
You have high income, great discipline, and strong assets. You only need smart structuring.

Clear high-interest loans using equity now. It gives guaranteed returns by saving interest.

Then invest systematically into mutual funds with the help of a Certified Financial Planner.

Keep growing your corpus till 55, and aim for debt-free, work-optional life.

Don’t touch your NPS/PF till retirement. Let compounding do the magic.

You are already on the right path. Just align your debt and investments strategically.

Start working with a trusted, qualified MFD who is a CFP. Let them review your portfolio quarterly.

You are well-positioned for complete financial freedom by age 55. Keep your focus.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP
Chief Financial Planner
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x