Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |649 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Aug 13, 2025

Kanchan Rai has 10 years of experience in therapy, nurturing soft skills and leadership coaching. She is the founder of the Let Us Talk Foundation, which offers mindfulness workshops to help people stay emotionally and mentally healthy.
Rai has a degree in leadership development and customer centricity from Harvard Business School, Boston. She is an internationally certified coach from the International Coaching Federation, a global organisation in professional coaching.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Jun 22, 2025Hindi
Relationship

I started my small project and he asks for my money of which sometimes he does not pay back I am afraid I will have to live like this my whole life

Ans: whom are we talking about ? can you pls tell more about who "HE" is

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1762 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Dec 14, 2022

Relationship
Hello Anu,I am under severe confusion and frustration. Wanted to consult with some psychiatrist but then I got to know about you. I have an issue with my father.I'm a 29 years old working man.My family background was not good, my father was the sole bread earner in the family of 9 including my uncle and grandparents.But my father invested in his children.He gave us a good education.He sent me for IIT coaching in Kota. I couldn't clear IIT but cleared AIEEE.Today I'm earning a lot. I'm a software engineer with 7+ years of experience in IT in a big giant firm earning Rs 62 lakhs an annum. But the picture does not look like it is.My father takes all my money.Literally he does that.He has been doing it for last 7 years, every single month.He has taken my all salaries till now, 80+ months' salaries to be precise.And his modus operandi is- he knows my monthly in hand salary after deductions, which is around 3.5 lakhs now.He calls me around 25th of the month saying 'Don't use the salary. I need 4 lakhs this month. He asks me more than my salary, then says ‘okay you don't have this much, so give me as much as you can.’Earlier when my salary was Rs 85,0000, he used to ask for Rs 1 lakh.When salary became Rs 2.2 lakhs he used to ask Rs 2.5 lakhs.I keep approx Rs 15-20,000 for myself and give the remaining to him.Why do I give him all my money?Because I have this feeling that whatever I am today, it's all because of him.He went against all odds to educate us, otherwise I would have been a poor kid somewhere in my village doing farming.The sad part is, he does not use this money for himself.If he would have used it for his needs I would have been the happiest person. He gives loans to his relatives free of cost.People come to my father and request that they need money for some XYZ reason. They say you have a lot of money, your son is earning so much, so please help us. My father says okay.He calls me and says that he has given his word, now he can't step back and I will have to arrange the money. And this money never comes back.Till now nobody has returned a single penny.When I ask my father, he says ‘it's okay, you will earn more. They can take only your money, not your destiny.’I'm not exaggerating but I don't have even a RO filter in my home. I spend Rs 1,500 on water.I'm fed up with all this.I had a discussion with my father regarding this many a times that I can't keep doing this.He says What will you do with the money? Tell me the item you want, we will purchase it for you.So far I have given more than Rs 1 crore. I'm such a fool.I don't want to spoil my relationship with my father but at the same time I also want him to understand that I'm a human not a money-making machine.The problem has started now, because now he is doing the same with my younger brother as well.He recently started his job after college, and earns around Rs 55K.My father takes 50K from him and has deliberately kept him with me so that we can save on rent and he can keep the money.Till now when he was taking my money, I was not so much hurt.But now when my brother is giving money, I can't bear it. He is a small kid who does a lot of hard work and even his money is taken away.I cannot share this with anyone.I keep asking myself if I'm a bad son who thinks like this about his father.But I can see the reality which is very discouraging.I'm not able to digest the fact that this is actually happening.Please suggest what I should do.Should I tell this to someone? But then the other person will think bad about my father which I don't want.I'm lost. Please suggest me something.
Ans:

Dear RS,

If by now you haven’t figured out that you are being used for playing the role of a good son, then when is it going to dawn on you?

It feels unreal even if your father took all that money for himself without realizing that his son needs his hard-earned money to set up his life. But here, it’s going to relatives and everywhere.

And now, it’s the turn of your brother too.

There is really no need to set this example as an older brother to just bend over backwards for your father. Instead, change the role and let your brother do the same.

Take charge of your finances and share what you deem fit with your father that covers his expenses (assuming that he is retired).

This way, you will fulfil the duty of being a good son taking care of his father. Beyond this, save your money and invest it wisely and please spend on yourself.

What will you do when you marry?

You think your wife is going to support this flow transaction of money between you and your father?

And when she tries to reason out with you, either you or your father will blame her for being selfish. In fact, she will only be looking out for your wellbeing.

So, before this gets even more murkier, make a point by sitting your father down and asserting that you are taking charge of your finances and reassuring him that he will always be taken care of.

His need to please his relatives by giving away your money has to stopped.

This might be met with a lot of resistance from your father, but you know what is to be done. Else, this will grow even with your brother and get progressively worse. So, step in NOW.

All the best!

..Read more

Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |649 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Mar 21, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Mar 20, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship
Hi Sir. I have a typical.problem here. I lend.money to one of.mynfriends for his bzness..I worked as a consultant for him. I made an agreement for the money given to him. Nevertheless he didn't return the money yet..I left him now some months back. Though I asked him to give bac money but he says he has lost lot in his bzness and also says he can't return the money. Sometimes indirectly he says that because of me he has landed in loss. I don't want to go.legally but it has been lot.ot.months that he has returned money. But now I can't wait. What should I do now..pls advise. Thanks
Ans: Navigating financial matters within friendships can be challenging, especially when agreements aren't upheld as expected.

Initiate an open and honest conversation with your friend about the loan. Express your concerns and feelings without blaming or accusing. Use "I" statements to convey how his actions have impacted you personally.
Give your friend an opportunity to explain his side of the story. Listen attentively to understand his perspective and the challenges he's facing with his business. Empathize with his situation while also emphasizing the importance of fulfilling financial commitments.
Instead of dwelling on past grievances, shift the conversation toward finding a solution that works for both of you. Explore options such as renegotiating the repayment terms, setting up a payment plan, or considering alternative forms of compensation if he's unable to repay the full amount immediately.
Validate your friend's feelings and concerns about the situation, but also assert the impact his actions have had on you. Help him understand the importance of honoring agreements and maintaining trust in the relationship.
Clearly communicate your expectations moving forward. If you're unable to reach a resolution or if your friend continues to disregard the agreement, be prepared to set boundaries to protect yourself financially and emotionally. This might involve seeking legal advice or taking further action if necessary.
While it's important to address the financial issue, prioritize preserving the friendship if possible. Reassure your friend that your intention is not to harm the relationship but to find a mutually beneficial solution. Emphasize the value you place on your friendship and your desire to work through this challenge together.
Use this experience as an opportunity for personal and relational growth. Reflect on what you've learned about trust, communication, and financial boundaries in friendships. Apply these lessons to future interactions to prevent similar issues from arising.
Ultimately, finding a resolution to financial disputes within friendships requires patience, empathy, and effective communication. By approaching the situation with understanding and a willingness to collaborate, you can work toward a solution that honors both your financial needs and the integrity of your relationship.

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10975 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jan 20, 2026

Money
Hello Sir, I am 41 years old and have been investing in mutual funds and stocks for the past one and a half years. I am currently making monthly SIPs of ₹1500 each in SBI Large & Midcap Fund Direct Plan and Quant Small Cap Fund Direct Plan Growth. In addition, I also made a lump-sum investment of ₹1,50,000 in Quant Small Cap Fund Direct Plan Growth in January 2025. However, my current investment in Quant Small Cap Fund Direct Plan Growth is showing a negative return of ₹12,000. Sir, please review my portfolio and provide appropriate guidance. Sincerely, Surya Prakash Bhatnagar, Awaiting your reply. Thank you.
Ans: You have shown good intent by starting investments early and by asking for guidance at the right time. Many investors wait until losses increase before reviewing. Your awareness at this stage itself protects long-term wealth. Temporary negatives are part of equity investing, but structure and discipline decide future results.

» Your age, time horizon, and investing phase
– At 41 years, you are still in a strong accumulation phase.
– You have enough time to recover from short-term volatility.
– Equity is suitable, but risk must be controlled.
– Your investing experience is still new at one and a half years.
– Early guidance matters more than product selection.

» Understanding your current SIP structure
– You are investing Rs.1500 each in two equity funds.
– One fund focuses on large and mid-sized companies.
– The other is fully into small-cap companies.
– SIP amount is modest, but discipline is good.
– Fund mix shows growth intent but high volatility exposure.

» Review of your lump sum investment decision
– You invested Rs.1.50 lakh lump sum into a small-cap oriented fund.
– Lump sum into small caps increases timing risk.
– Small caps move sharply up and down in short periods.
– January 2025 entry exposed you to market correction risk.
– The current negative of Rs.12,000 is not unusual.

» Why small-cap funds show quick negatives
– Small-cap stocks react strongly to market sentiment.
– When markets correct, small caps fall faster than large caps.
– Recovery also takes time and tests patience.
– Short-term returns are not a measure of fund quality.
– Five to seven years is the minimum horizon for such exposure.

» Emotional impact of seeing losses early
– Seeing negative returns creates doubt and fear.
– This is common for new investors.
– Panic actions at this stage can lock losses permanently.
– Staying invested with clarity is more important now.
– Behaviour decides outcome more than returns.

» Portfolio concentration risk
– Your portfolio is heavily tilted towards one high-risk category.
– Both SIP and lump sum are into the same small-cap style.
– This creates concentration risk.
– Diversification across strategies is limited.
– Balance is needed for smoother experience.

» Large and mid-cap exposure assessment
– Large and mid-cap funds offer relative stability.
– They reduce volatility compared to pure small caps.
– This exposure is good for core portfolio.
– However, allocation size is still small.
– Core should always be stronger than satellite bets.

» Direct plans – important concern you must know
– You are investing through direct plans.
– Direct plans do not provide guidance, review, or emotional support.
– When markets fall, investors feel lost and confused.
– Wrong exits usually happen in direct plans.
– Regular plans through an MFD guided by a CFP help discipline.

» Why regular plans add long-term value
– Regular plans include professional monitoring.
– Portfolio reviews happen during market changes.
– Rebalancing guidance reduces risk.
– Emotional decision-making is controlled.
– The cost difference is small compared to mistakes avoided.

» SIP versus lump sum in volatile funds
– SIP works well in volatile categories like small caps.
– Lump sum increases regret if timing is wrong.
– Your SIP approach is better than your lump sum choice.
– Future investments should focus on systematic discipline.
– Lump sum should be used cautiously and staggered.

» Tax awareness at an early stage
– Equity mutual fund gains above Rs.1.25 lakh attract 12.5% LTCG tax.
– Short-term gains attract 20% tax.
– Early exits increase tax impact.
– Holding patiently improves post-tax outcome.
– Tax should not drive panic decisions.

» What you should do with the current negative investment
– Do not exit based on short-term loss.
– Loss is not permanent until you sell.
– The fund needs time to recover.
– Review horizon, not recent return.
– Emotional patience is required.

» Corrections are part of wealth creation
– Every long-term investor sees temporary losses.
– Markets test conviction before rewarding patience.
– One and a half years is too short to judge equity.
– Equity rewards time, not speed.
– Staying invested builds maturity.

» How to improve portfolio quality going forward
– Reduce overdependence on small-cap exposure.
– Strengthen core diversified equity allocation.
– Keep high-risk funds limited.
– Increase SIP amount gradually as income grows.
– Align investments with goals, not market noise.

» Importance of goal-based planning
– Investments should have purpose like retirement or education.
– Goal clarity improves discipline.
– Random investing increases anxiety.
– Time horizon should guide fund choice.
– Planning reduces regret.

» Emergency and safety awareness
– Ensure emergency fund is in place outside equity.
– Avoid forced withdrawals during market falls.
– Job stability cannot be assumed always.
– Liquidity safety protects long-term investments.
– Peace of mind improves decisions.

» Role of periodic review
– Portfolio should be reviewed at least once a year.
– Review is different from reacting.
– Adjustments should be data-driven.
– Professional review avoids bias.
– This is where CFP guidance helps.

» Finally
– Your negative return is a normal market phase, not a failure.
– Your SIP habit is good and should continue.
– Small-cap exposure needs patience and balance.
– Avoid panic exits and emotional decisions.
– Shift towards guided, structured investing through a CFP-led MFD.
– With discipline, time, and proper allocation, your investments can grow steadily.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10975 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jan 20, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Jan 20, 2026Hindi
Money
What is the best way to invest in silver?
Ans: You are asking a sensible question. Silver can support long-term wealth when used correctly. The method of investing matters more than the metal itself. A clear approach avoids disappointment and protects capital.

» Role of silver in a portfolio
– Silver should be treated as a support asset, not a core investment.
– It helps during inflation and uncertain economic phases.
– It adds diversification when equity markets are volatile.
– Allocation should be limited and goal-linked.
– Overexposure can increase stress due to price swings.

» Physical silver as an option
– Physical silver suits long-term holding and wealth preservation.
– It reduces behavioural mistakes as it is not traded frequently.
– It gives comfort to conservative investors.
– However, storage, safety, making charges, and liquidity issues exist.
– Best used only for small, long-term allocation.

» Silver ETFs and index-style products – key concerns
– Silver ETFs are passive products that only track prices.
– They offer no downside protection during corrections.
– Expense ratio and tracking error reduce returns over time.
– Daily price visibility increases emotional buying and selling.
– Passive exposure is risky when silver prices are already high.

» Why active decision-making matters
– Silver prices move in cycles and can stay flat for long periods.
– Actively managed strategies help control risk and timing.
– Active monitoring avoids heavy exposure at peak levels.
– This improves discipline and long-term experience.
– Passive products lack this flexibility.

» Practical way to approach silver
– Keep allocation small and intentional.
– Avoid lump sum buying at high prices.
– Use staggered investing to reduce timing risk.
– Review allocation periodically, not daily.
– Ensure silver supports your overall financial plan.

» Finally
– Silver works best as a hedge, not as a return engine.
– Method, discipline, and allocation decide success more than price.
– Balanced planning gives peace and stability.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x