.jpg)
Dear Sir, I am seeking a professional review of my current investment portfolio and financial planning strategy. I have been investing through a mutual fund advisor as well as independently, with the aim of achieving two key long-term financial goals: Corpus of ₹1.5 Crores over the next 8 years for my son’s higher education and other related commitments. Corpus of ₹8–10 Crores for retirement and other life goals over the long term. Current Investment Summary: Monthly SIPs through Advisor (All Regular Plans): ₹35,000 (Increasing to ₹40,000 from Oct 2025) Direct SIP (Self-invested via Groww App): ₹2,000 per month (Started from Mar 2025) Current Portfolio Value: ₹3.8 Lakhs Mutual Funds Selected by Advisor: Fund Name Monthly SIP Trust MF Small Cap Fund ₹4,000 Mirae Asset Small Cap Fund ₹5,000 Bajaj Finserv Flexi Cap Fund ₹4,000 Helios Large & Mid Cap Fund ₹4,000 HSBC Multicap Fund ₹3,000 Union Active Momentum Fund ₹5,000 Mirae Asset Nifty MidSmallcap 400 Momentum Quality Fund ₹4,000 DSP Healthcare Fund ₹2,000 Franklin India Technology Fund ₹2,000 WhiteOak Capital Banking & Financial Services Fund ₹2,000 Sundaram Multi Factor Fund ₹5,000 (starting from Oct 2025) Direct SIP (Self-selected): Mirae Asset Flexi Cap Fund – Direct Plan: ₹2,000/month (since Mar 2025) Other Investments: Started accumulating digital silver monthly via Incred App, considering long-term demand and potential returns. Questions and Clarifications: Portfolio Composition: Is the current fund selection well-diversified and appropriate for my long-term goals? Is there any overlap or excess sectoral exposure (e.g., technology, healthcare, banking)? Market Volatility Concerns: My advisor often suggests that market corrections are beneficial for long-term SIPs, as they allow me to accumulate more units at lower NAVs. While I understand the concept of rupee cost averaging and compounding, I would appreciate a second professional opinion on whether this strategy is sound in the context of my financial goals and timelines. Digital Silver Investment: What is your view on investing in digital silver through apps like Incred? Is it advisable for long-term wealth creation or should it be limited to tactical allocation? Regular vs Direct Funds: Currently, all advisor-linked investments are in regular plans. Should I consider switching to direct funds over time for better cost efficiency, especially since my investment horizon is long? Any Suggested Changes: Do you recommend any consolidation, fund switches, or changes in SIP amount allocation to better align with my goals? I would be grateful for your expert insights and recommendations. Thank you for your time and assistance.
Ans: Hi,
I appreciate your dedication towards investment and your goals. Your clarity in aspects wrt to future amount required, compounding is well appreciated. Let us go through some details one-by-one:
1. You are confused if you should go for Direct funds instead of regular ones. Well, direct funds are very much over-rated by influencers due to their less expense ratio. But direct funds provide lower return when compared to regular ones because of the discipline required, consistency and advisor guidance at each step; an advisor also checks your portfolio regularly.
2. Your current SIP through advisor in regular funds - you are investing a very good amount in SIPs, that too incremental SIP. However, the funds you mentioned are not recommended. There is very high overlapping and these funds are not good performers. It is better for you to change your advisor and go for a qualified professional such as a CFP.
3. Direct portfolio - Fund selection is not good here as well. Kindly stop this SIP and focus on investing with advisor's help.
4. Current SIP of 40k is way less to meet your 2 major goal for son's education and your retirement. You need to increase your investment to more than double to easily meet your requirements. If this is tough, increase it to your maximum savng potential now and each year.
5. Buying silver is good idea on a monthly basis. Using Incred app is not recommended. You can either go for mutual funds for these or ETFs. Recently SEBI also made it clear that such platforms are unsafe. You can check this in detail on my Insta channel.
Hence, you should work with a certified professional to guide you in a correct way with the right funds.
Consult a professional Certified Financial Planner - a CFP who can guide you with exact funds to invest in keeping in mind your age, requirements, financial goals and risk profile. A CFP periodically reviews your portfolio and suggest any amendments to be made, if required.
Let me know if you need more help.
Best Regards,
Reetika Sharma, Certified Financial Planner
https://www.instagram.com/cfpreetika/