Can you please carefully analysis and suggest me for the below financial matter:
I have a Home Loan and Home Loan top-up which are mentioned as
Home Loan: Rs. 1660000, ROI: 7.45%, Outstanding: 1097797, EMI: Rs.16571 Last EMI Date:31-08-2032
Home Loan top-Up: Rs. 2300000, ROI: 8.0%, Outstanding: 1357928, EMI: Rs.35000 Last EMI Date:31-12-2029
I am planning to take a new loan Rs.3500000 with ROI 8.15% and tenure of 14years, for construction of the first floor and let-out for monthly rent of Rs.13000. considering my age 45 years and a monthly Salary of Rs.126420. is this a wise move? As this would benefit me once i get retired. Appreciate your suggestion on this.
Ans: You are 45 years old.
Your income is Rs.126420 per month.
You already have two loans running:
Home Loan
– Outstanding: Rs.10,97,797
– EMI: Rs.16,571
– Ends: Aug 2032
Home Loan Top-Up
– Outstanding: Rs.13,57,928
– EMI: Rs.35,000
– Ends: Dec 2029
Total EMI currently = Rs.51,571 per month
Now you want a new loan of Rs.35,00,000
– ROI: 8.15%
– Tenure: 14 years
– Expected rent: Rs.13,000 per month
1. First check — EMI impact
A 35 lakh loan for 14 years at 8.15% will have an EMI of roughly Rs.34,500 to Rs.36,000.
So your new total EMI will become:
**Current EMI 51,571
New EMI approx 35,000
= Total EMI around Rs.86,000**
This means you will spend around 68% of your salary on EMIs.
This is not safe.
A safe EMI-to-income ratio is 30% to 40%.
Anything above 50% puts you in high-risk zone.
2. Rental income vs EMI
Expected rent: Rs.13,000 per month
Difference: EMI (35,000) – Rent (13,000)
You will still pay 22,000 per month from your pocket.
And remember:
– Rent may be vacant for few months
– Repairs may come up
– Tenant issues can arise
– Property tax and maintenance also apply
So this property will not be self-sustaining.
It will continue to drain money from your salary.
3. Long-term retirement thinking
You said “benefit me when I retire”.
But you will retire at around 60.
Your new loan will end around age 59.
So for the next 14 years, you will:
– Pay heavy EMIs
– Face rental uncertainty
– Lose liquidity
– Increase financial stress
During age 45–60 you should focus on:
– Increasing retirement corpus
– Cutting debt
– Improving savings
– Building emergency fund
– Building long-term investments
A big loan now will slow your retirement preparation.
4. Risk of job loss or salary dip
You are in private sector.
Job security is uncertain.
In such cases, high EMIs become dangerous.
Banks may pressure you.
Cash flow becomes tight.
It is risky to keep EMI close to 70% of salary.
5. Real estate for rental returns is not efficient
You expect Rs.13,000 rent on a project costing 35 lakh.
This is very low yield.
In India, rental yield is around 2–3% only.
Loan interest is around 8%.
This means the property will never pay for itself.
You will always pay extra from your pocket.
6. You already have two loans
Your loans end in 2029 and 2032.
Instead of taking a new loan, the safer plan is:
– Close top-up loan early if possible
– Keep one loan instead of three
– Increase savings
– Create retirement corpus
– Reduce debt exposure
At age 45, the priority should be reducing debt, not adding more.
7. Liquidity and safety should come first
A new heavy loan reduces liquidity.
You will have less buffer for:
– Health issues
– Job change
– Emergency needs
– Child’s education
– Family events
Liquidity is more important than rental income.
Should you go ahead? — Final assessment
Based on numbers and risks:
No, this is not a wise move.
Reasons:
– EMI jumps to 86,000 per month
– 68% of salary will go in EMIs
– Rent is very low compared to EMI
– You already have 2 existing loans
– You are entering a high-risk zone
– This move weakens retirement planning
– Low rental yield gives poor long-term returns
– High debt increases stress before retirement
You should avoid taking this Rs.35 lakh loan.
Focus instead on:
– Closing existing top-up loan early
– Increasing retirement investments
– Building emergency fund
– Reducing debt burden
– Strengthening long-term financial safety
Your future will be safer with less debt and more investments, not by adding another property loan.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment