Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

46-Year-Old Retiree with ₹1.3 Crore House: On Track to Financial Freedom?

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7922 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Feb 10, 2025Hindi
Money

Hello Sir, I m 46 retired, my wife is 41 and working and my son is.currenly 11. We live in our own house. Income and Expenses - Monthly family income: ₹1,25,000 - Monthly expenses: ₹50,000 - Loan repayment: ₹40,000 Assets 1. *Real Estate* 1. *Flat*: ₹1.3 crores 2. *Plot*: ₹35 lakhs 2. *Retirement Fund*: ₹45 lakhs 3. *Savings and FDs*: ₹35 lakhs 4. *Equity*: ₹15 lakhs 5. *Mutual Funds (MFs)*: ₹10 lakhs (via ₹15,000 SIP for 3 years) 6. *Public Provident Fund (PPF)*: ₹10 lakhs 7. *Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGB)*: ₹2.5 lakhs 8. *Physical Gold*: ₹15 lakhs Am i on the correct path to live rest of my life comfortably with financial freedom. Please help me make informed and better decisions about my investments and financial planning.

Ans: Your financial situation is strong, and you have built a solid foundation. Let's assess your current position and suggest improvements for financial security and freedom.

Current Financial Overview
Income: Rs 1,25,000 per month
Expenses: Rs 50,000 per month
Loan EMI: Rs 40,000 per month
Savings capacity: Rs 35,000 per month
Strengths in Your Financial Planning
Debt is reducing: Your loan EMI of Rs 40,000 will end in a few years, increasing your free cash flow.
Multiple asset classes: You have real estate, FDs, equity, MFs, PPF, SGBs, and gold.
Retirement Fund: Rs 45 lakhs is a good base for financial independence.
PPF and MFs: You have a disciplined approach to long-term wealth creation.
Gold Holdings: Rs 15 lakh in physical gold can be useful for future needs.
Areas That Need Improvement
Retirement Fund: Rs 45 lakh is not enough for a comfortable retirement. More growth is needed.
Loan Repayment: Rs 40,000 EMI is a significant outflow. Consider prepaying if possible.
Low Mutual Fund Allocation: Only Rs 10 lakh in MFs is low for long-term wealth creation.
Savings in FDs: Rs 35 lakh in FDs will not beat inflation. Some portion should be shifted to growth assets.
Steps to Strengthen Financial Independence
1. Optimizing Investments for Growth
Increase SIPs from Rs 15,000 to Rs 30,000 per month once EMI ends.
Equity mutual funds have the potential for higher long-term returns than FDs.
Debt mutual funds can be used for stability instead of large FDs.
Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) are better than physical gold due to tax-free maturity benefits.
2. Loan Repayment Strategy
If the loan has a high interest rate, consider prepaying partially to reduce tenure.
If the interest rate is low, focus on investing extra funds in mutual funds for higher returns.
Once EMI is over, channel Rs 40,000 towards investments for wealth creation.
3. Retirement Planning
You are 46, and your wife is 41. Your investments must generate passive income for 40+ years.
Aim for at least Rs 2-3 crore in your retirement corpus.
Increase equity mutual fund allocation to create long-term wealth.
Consider investing in dividend-paying mutual funds for post-retirement cash flow.
PPF should be continued as it provides tax-free returns and stability.
4. Managing Savings and FDs More Efficiently
FDs give low returns after tax. Convert some FDs into debt mutual funds.
Keep only 6-12 months of expenses in FDs for emergencies.
The rest should be invested in mutual funds for long-term growth.
SGBs should be continued as they offer 2.5% interest and capital appreciation.
5. Education Planning for Your Son
In 7 years, your son will go for higher education. You will need a significant corpus.
Start a separate mutual fund SIP of Rs 15,000 for his education.
Do not rely on FDs or gold for his education as they provide lower returns.
6. Creating Passive Income for Financial Freedom
After loan repayment, invest at least Rs 50,000 per month in mutual funds.
Focus on a mix of equity and debt funds to balance growth and stability.
Rental income is an option, but managing real estate has challenges.
Dividend mutual funds can provide regular income in the future.
7. Tax Efficiency
PPF: Tax-free returns, so continue investing.
Mutual Funds: Long-term capital gains above Rs 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.
FDs: Interest is taxed at your income tax slab, reducing post-tax returns.
Gold: Physical gold has capital gains tax; SGBs are tax-free if held till maturity.
8. Insurance Planning
Ensure you have adequate health insurance for your family. Rs 10-20 lakh cover is recommended.
Your wife is working. She should have a term insurance policy to cover future uncertainties.
If you have term insurance, ensure it covers at least Rs 1.5-2 crore.
Avoid ULIPs and traditional insurance policies for investment purposes.
9. Estate Planning and Will Creation
Real estate assets should have clear nominations to avoid future disputes.
Create a Will to ensure smooth asset transfer to your wife and son.
If needed, set up a Trust for your son’s future financial security.
Finally
You are on the right track but need to enhance your investments.
Increase SIPs and allocate more to equity for long-term growth.
Reduce FDs and shift funds to better investment options.
Pay off loans early to reduce financial burden.
Plan for your son’s education and your retirement separately.
Have adequate insurance and create a Will for smooth estate planning.
These steps will ensure financial security and a comfortable retired life.
Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP

Chief Financial Planner

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7922 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Apr 04, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jan 03, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
Hi Ramalingam, I am 26 earning 78k per month as salary Having investment in FD: 2.5lakh RD:2500per month (started dec 2023) SBI conta fund 2000 monthly started (dec 2023) SBI small cap:2000 per month (started nov 2023) SBI bluechip fund: 2000 per month (started nov 2023) SBI multicap fund: 2000 (started nov 2023) And started contributing in PF as well from last year, deposited 1.5lakhs Are my investments are on track or where and how much shall I invest to attain financial freedom at the age of 40-42 ? I also want to buy a car soon. Kindly suggest.
Ans: It's great to see that you've started investing at a young age and are thinking about your financial future. Here are some suggestions to help you achieve your goals:

Review Your Portfolio: Evaluate the performance of your existing investments periodically and ensure they are aligned with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Emergency Fund: Consider building an emergency fund equivalent to 3-6 months' worth of expenses. This fund will provide a financial cushion in case of unexpected expenses or loss of income.

Diversification: While it's good to have investments in mutual funds and recurring deposits (RD), consider diversifying your portfolio further. Explore other asset classes such as equity, debt, real estate, and gold to spread risk and enhance returns.

Goal-Based Investing: Define your financial goals clearly, including milestones like buying a car and achieving financial freedom by age 40-42. Allocate your investments accordingly to meet each goal within the desired timeframe.

Investing for Retirement: Since you aim to achieve financial freedom by age 40-42, focus on building a substantial retirement corpus. Consider investing in long-term wealth creation instruments like equity mutual funds, PPF (Public Provident Fund), NPS (National Pension System), and EPF (Employee Provident Fund).

Car Purchase: If you plan to buy a car soon, start setting aside a portion of your savings towards this goal. You can either save up the entire amount or consider taking a car loan, depending on your financial situation and preferences.

Budgeting: Track your income and expenses regularly to ensure you're living within your means and allocating sufficient funds towards savings and investments.

Financial Planning: Consider consulting with a financial advisor to create a comprehensive financial plan tailored to your goals, risk profile, and investment horizon. They can help you optimize your investment strategy and make informed decisions.

Remember to stay disciplined with your savings and investments, avoid impulsive spending, and continue learning about personal finance to make informed decisions. With prudent financial planning and consistent efforts, you can work towards achieving financial freedom and realizing your goals.

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7922 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 19, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - May 11, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
? rediff.com Rediff Gurus Logo Hi Jay Chandora | Sign Out HealthHealth MoneyMoney RelationshipRelationship CareesCareer Ask your questions about health, money, relationship or careers here Ask Anonymously Jay Jay 1 Questions 0 Answers 1 Gurus 0 Bookmarks These questions will be answered soon. Not Answered yet Jay Asked on - May 10, 2024 I am 31 years old and I have monthly income of 1,80,000 including wife's income after deducting all taxes and monthly expenses and EMIs. Curent Investment is going like this per month. 1. 125,000 in mutual funds in below category. And I am expecting to increase this sip by 10% annually. 65000 in small cap 35000 in mid cap 25000 in large cap 2. 8500 in PPF 3. 25000 towards buying gold coins I have a emergency funds of 11 lacs in FD which is almost 20X of monthly expenses. Also in stocks I have accumulated around 12 lacs since from last month only I increased sip amount. My goal is to get financial freedom by age of 38 with 4-5 crores. Could you please suggest if I am moving in right path.
Ans: Congratulations on your disciplined financial planning and significant progress towards your goals. You have a well-structured approach to investments, and it’s great to see your commitment to financial freedom.

Current Financial Situation
Your current monthly income is ?1,80,000. After deducting taxes, expenses, and EMIs, your investments are allocated as follows:

Mutual Funds: ?1,25,000 (increasing SIP by 10% annually)
Small Cap: ?65,000
Mid Cap: ?35,000
Large Cap: ?25,000
Public Provident Fund (PPF): ?8,500
Gold Coins: ?25,000
You have an emergency fund of ?11 lakhs in a fixed deposit, which covers 20 months of expenses. Additionally, you have ?12 lakhs in stocks.

Analyzing Your Investment Strategy
Mutual Funds
Your allocation in mutual funds is quite aggressive, with a significant focus on small and mid cap funds. While these can provide high returns, they also come with higher volatility.

Small Cap Funds: These can deliver substantial growth but are risky. Ensure you have a long-term horizon for this investment.

Mid Cap Funds: These balance growth and risk but still carry more risk compared to large cap funds.

Large Cap Funds: These provide stability and moderate returns, balancing your portfolio.

Public Provident Fund (PPF)
Your monthly contribution to PPF is ?8,500. PPF is a safe investment with tax benefits, and it should be part of a long-term strategy.

Gold Coins
Investing in gold coins can be a hedge against inflation and currency fluctuations. However, the allocation seems high. Consider diversifying within other stable asset classes.

Emergency Fund
An emergency fund of ?11 lakhs is prudent and well-maintained. It ensures liquidity and financial security in unforeseen circumstances.

Steps to Achieve Financial Freedom
Increase SIPs Gradually
You plan to increase your SIPs by 10% annually. This is a sound strategy. As your income grows, increasing your investment contributions will significantly impact your corpus growth.

Portfolio Diversification
Ensure your portfolio is diversified. Currently, there’s a heavy tilt towards small and mid cap funds. Consider increasing allocation to large cap and balanced funds to reduce risk.

Regular Monitoring and Rebalancing
Regularly review your investment portfolio. Rebalance it to align with your risk tolerance and financial goals. A diversified portfolio helps manage risk effectively.

Target Corpus Calculation
To achieve a corpus of ?4-5 crores by age 38, considering you have 7 years, your current investments and future increments should be strategically planned.

Mutual Funds Growth: With an expected annual return of 12-15%, your increasing SIPs can substantially grow your corpus.

Stock Market Investments: Your current ?12 lakhs in stocks can grow significantly with regular investments and market returns.

PPF and Gold: Continue with your PPF contributions for safety and tax benefits. Gold investments should be moderate to avoid over-concentration in one asset.

Professional Guidance
Consulting a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) can provide tailored advice. A CFP can help optimise your investment strategy, monitor performance, and adjust as needed.

Conclusion
You are on the right path with a disciplined approach to savings and investments. Increasing SIPs, diversifying your portfolio, and regular monitoring will help you achieve your goal of financial freedom by 38. Keep up the good work and stay committed to your plan.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7922 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Sep 09, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Sep 08, 2024Hindi
Money
I am 41 years old working in a Public Sector Organization. I have corpus of around 75 lacs in mutual fund and 5 lacs in NPS. I have two house properties against which my home loan outstanding is Rs 50 lacs. My net monthly income from all sources after paying EMIs is Rs around Rs 170000. My monthly SIP is around Rs 90000/-. My monthly expenses is around Rs 60000/-. I am planning to retire after 5 years. After 5 years, I would have around 2.5 cr after repaying all loans. I would earn Rs 60000/- as monthly pension and that would increase by around 5% per year due to dearness relief. I have 10 years old son. Is my planning correct. With this would I be able to lead a good life. Please suggest me
Ans: Assessing Your Current Financial Situation
You are 41 years old, employed in a public sector organisation, and have a solid financial foundation. Your Rs. 75 lakh corpus in mutual funds and Rs. 5 lakh in the National Pension Scheme (NPS) reflect your diligent savings habits. Additionally, with two house properties and a net monthly income of Rs. 1,70,000 after paying off EMIs, your financial discipline is clear.

Your current monthly SIP of Rs. 90,000 showcases your commitment to growing your investments, while your monthly expenses of Rs. 60,000 leave you with a significant surplus for further investments. You also have the ambitious goal of retiring in 5 years, with the plan of having Rs. 2.5 crore after clearing your home loan of Rs. 50 lakh. Additionally, you expect Rs. 60,000 monthly pension, which will increase annually by 5% due to dearness relief.

Given your situation and goals, let’s break down and assess each area in detail.

Loan Management and Repayment Strategy
You currently have an outstanding home loan of Rs. 50 lakh, which you aim to clear within 5 years. This aligns well with your retirement timeline and ensures that by the time you retire, you will be debt-free.

Advantages of clearing the home loan: Once your home loan is fully paid off, the burden of EMIs will be removed from your financial planning. This will significantly free up your monthly cash flow.

Focus on increasing the principal repayment: If possible, you should consider making lump-sum payments toward your home loan principal. This will reduce the overall interest burden and help you clear the loan faster. The earlier you are debt-free, the more flexible your post-retirement plans become.

Investment Growth and Corpus Management
Your existing investment portfolio, with Rs. 75 lakh in mutual funds and Rs. 5 lakh in NPS, is on track. With five more years to invest, your SIP of Rs. 90,000 is expected to grow significantly.

The benefit of actively managed funds: Your focus on actively managed funds through SIPs is a great strategy. Actively managed funds offer the potential for higher returns compared to index funds. Index funds are limited by their market-linked performance and may not adapt well to market changes. Actively managed funds, on the other hand, benefit from the fund manager's expertise in navigating market conditions, providing more growth opportunities.

Avoid direct funds: You might be tempted by direct mutual funds because they have lower expense ratios. However, regular mutual funds, when invested through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) and a Mutual Fund Distributor (MFD), provide significant advantages. You receive expert advice, portfolio reviews, and ongoing support that can lead to better overall portfolio management. This service is especially valuable as you approach retirement, where regular portfolio management becomes crucial.

Diversification of investments: It is essential to maintain a well-diversified portfolio. Given your strong SIP contributions, it is advisable to ensure a balanced mix of equity and debt funds. Equity funds will drive your portfolio growth, while debt funds will provide stability. As you approach retirement, consider gradually shifting a portion of your equity holdings to debt funds for added security.

Pension and Post-Retirement Income
You are fortunate to have a guaranteed pension of Rs. 60,000 per month, which will increase by 5% annually due to dearness relief. This stable income source will cover a significant portion of your post-retirement expenses.

Inflation-adjusted pension: The fact that your pension will grow by 5% each year is a significant advantage. It will help you keep pace with inflation, ensuring that your purchasing power remains intact as living costs rise over time.

Post-retirement withdrawals from corpus: In addition to your pension, you will need to strategically withdraw from your Rs. 2.5 crore corpus. A well-planned Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) from your mutual fund investments can provide you with a steady income stream. The SWP can be tailored to provide monthly or quarterly withdrawals, ensuring you meet your expenses without dipping too much into your principal. This way, your remaining corpus can continue to grow and support your long-term financial security.

Monthly Expenses and Surplus Allocation
Your current monthly expenses are Rs. 60,000, and after paying EMIs, you have Rs. 1,70,000 left from your net income. This provides you with a substantial surplus of Rs. 1,10,000 every month, part of which you already allocate to your SIPs.

Surplus utilisation: You are already investing Rs. 90,000 into SIPs, which is commendable. The remaining Rs. 20,000 can be utilised for increasing your emergency fund or for making occasional lump-sum investments. It’s also wise to keep a small portion of this surplus in liquid funds to handle unexpected expenses.
Planning for Your Son’s Education
Your son is currently 10 years old, and you need to plan for his higher education expenses. With education costs rising, it is important to ensure that you have a dedicated investment plan for this goal.

Education planning strategy: If you haven’t already, consider setting up a separate investment plan for your son's education. You could increase your SIP or allocate a portion of your surplus to a child education-focused mutual fund. These funds are specifically tailored to accumulate wealth for long-term education goals.

Balancing education and retirement goals: While education expenses are a priority, ensure that they don’t compromise your retirement plans. Continue to prioritise your retirement corpus while setting aside enough for your son’s education. This way, both goals can be met without straining your finances.

Retirement Timeline and Lifestyle
You have set a target to retire in five years at the age of 46. Let’s evaluate whether your corpus of Rs. 2.5 crore and monthly pension of Rs. 60,000 will allow you to maintain your current lifestyle.

Post-retirement expenses: With Rs. 60,000 as your pension, you will need to assess whether this amount, along with any income generated from your corpus, will be sufficient to cover your post-retirement expenses. Since your current monthly expenses are Rs. 60,000, your pension may cover the majority of your living costs. However, inflation will increase these costs over time, so it’s important to have an additional source of income from your investments.

Retirement lifestyle adjustment: During retirement, your expenses may change. Healthcare costs tend to rise, while some discretionary expenses may reduce. Make sure to account for rising healthcare costs and any other lifestyle changes when planning your future expenses.

Insurance and Risk Management
As you approach retirement, securing your family’s financial future through adequate insurance is crucial.

Health insurance: Ensure that you have comprehensive health insurance that covers you, your spouse, and your son. As healthcare costs rise, having adequate coverage will prevent any financial strain in case of medical emergencies.

Life insurance: You should review your life insurance coverage to ensure that it’s sufficient to provide financial security for your family in case of any unforeseen circumstances. If you have any endowment or ULIP policies, consider surrendering them and reinvesting the proceeds into mutual funds for better returns. Term insurance should be the main focus for life coverage.

Estate Planning and Will
It is important to ensure that your financial assets are smoothly transferred to your heirs without legal complications.

Will creation: Drafting a will is essential to clearly outline how your assets will be distributed. Ensure that all your assets, including your house properties, mutual funds, and other investments, are accounted for in your will.

Nomination updates: Make sure that the nominations for all your bank accounts, mutual funds, and insurance policies are up to date. This will ensure a smooth transition of assets to your beneficiaries.

Final Insights
You are on the right path with your financial planning. Your current savings, SIPs, and pension ensure a strong foundation for your retirement. Clearing your home loan and managing your investments wisely will leave you in a comfortable financial position.

Your focus should be on balancing your investment portfolio, planning for your son's education, and securing insurance for healthcare and life coverage. With careful planning, your Rs. 2.5 crore corpus and Rs. 60,000 monthly pension should allow you to lead a good life post-retirement.

By continuing to grow your investments and managing expenses, you can confidently look forward to a secure and financially stable retirement.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Latest Questions
Milind

Milind Vadjikar  |996 Answers  |Ask -

Insurance, Stocks, MF, PF Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 10, 2025Hindi
Listen
Money
I am 51 single, divorced and have one little sister who is 32. Recently I lost my job, and I am not in the mood to search for a new one. I am in the process of making arrangement to fulfill my monthly needs. I am holding the NPS which has a small corpus of 5 lacs in tier 1 and 45k in tier 2. Now I want to completely exit from the NPS. Now I must compulsorily accept the 20% withdrawal and 80% annuity. I have a few queries below. 1. Should I consider buying 100% annuity. 20% withdrawal does not make sense 2. Should I consider putting 1.5 lacs more to enhance the annuity (The corpus will become 7 lacs approx.). 3. Should I consider taking out the annuity on a yearly basis (Please explain Its pros and cons), since it offers more benefit. 4. Should I consider the Shriram life insurance. 5. Will it be safe to consider Shriram life insurance for life long future annuity. It offers the highest annuity. 6. Should I consider Annuity for Life with ROP - Subscriber will get annuity for lifetime and on death of the Subscriber, payment of annuity ceases & 100% of the purchase price will be returned to the nominee(s). The annual offer is 49,063.00 (7.01%) 7. Should I consider Annuity for Life without ROP - Subscriber will get annuity for lifetime and on death of the Subscriber, payment of annuity ceases, and no further amount will be payable. The annual offer is 58,112.00 (8.30%)
Ans: Hello;

Point wise answers to your queries as given below:

1. Yes.
2. Yes.
3. If you do monthly annuity the rate will be lower but you get monthly payouts. In yearly the rate will higher but only one shot payment per year so it depends on your preference.

4. Cannot comment on suitability of xyz firm.

5. Consider an insurer which has good capital adequacy, growing profitable business, preferably listed, reputation of the owner/group apart from decent annuity rates on offer.

6 & 7. My suggestion would be to opt for annuity for life with ROP to your nominee. Ultimately it is your call.

Please have adequate healthcare insurance cover.

Best wishes;

...Read more

Milind

Milind Vadjikar  |996 Answers  |Ask -

Insurance, Stocks, MF, PF Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Inderpaul

Inderpaul Singh  |7 Answers  |Ask -

Leadership Coach - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Career
I graduated with a BBA in 2022, and since then, I’ve been on a thrilling two-year adventure at an MNC. But guess what? I decided to resign in March 2024 because, you know, who doesn’t love a little drama at work? Now, I’ve managed to burn through all my hard-earned savings like a pro, and here I am, utterly confused about my future. Sometimes I think about leaving India—maybe for studies or just to escape and do some mindless job somewhere. Other times, I dream of retreating to the most remote corner of India and living off the grid. I’ve always been pretty good with technology, snagged a degree, and even racked up some work experience. But now? I’m completely lost on where to start over. I’ve scoured countless articles and advice columns, but they’ve been about as helpful as a chocolate teapot. I’m just looking for that life-changing advice that seems to be in short supply. Turning 24 this year!
Ans: Hello Manan,
My simple advice to you would be to get back to some job while you can continue to ponder over your long term goals/passion/pursuits.
Sitting idle (with no funds) at home won't help & it is not going to do any good to your career/life plans.
Simultaneously you can continue to do introspection & chalk out a proper plan as far your larger life goals are concerned.
Say you earnestly wish to pursue higher studies than you need to get yourself these answers 1) Why you need a higher degree in first place ? 2) Will it help you to get job/career of your choice? 3) If yes, then shortlist some relevant good courses & start exploring admit process etc. 4) Meanwhile do account for funds that will help you to time your break from the job (savings, loans etc.)
Likewise ask yourself questions for each option you have in mind & be honest in responses, that will help you to zero on your real aspiration & then do the proper detailing/planning. This may entail some compromises in short term but will certainly pave your way to achieve long term goals.

Best of Luck!

Major Inderpaul
HR Expert, Life & Relationship Coach

...Read more

Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |526 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 08, 2025
Relationship
Me and my girlfriend we both are in relationship from about last 2 years (almost). After such a long time I got to know that she had 2 relationships before me that too she didn't told I got to know it by third person she was sexually involved too (not intercourse but yes other things with one of them)... When I asked her that why you didn't told anything to me before she said she was scared that if she'll tell it to me so I'll leave her and she really did not wanted that... She was scared to loose me. And she was still in contact with that guy and when I asked her that why you were still in contact with him (it's been around 3 years they got separated) so she says that she is like that only... She can't deny anyone because of her soft hearted nature but she did not had any feelings for him. She also said that once she even went to meet him when he requested to meet and also on the same she claims that her soft hearted nature has done that she wasn't able to deny. I loved her too much but now all these things are hurting me like anything. (She is my first relationship before her i never had anyone)
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I understand that you are hurt and the complexities of the hearts might be difficult sometimes to grasp. The first reason for your sorrow, her past relationship, and the fact that she was physically intimate with them is not completely justifiable. Though I understand that you feel hurt because she did not disclose it to you, still it should not matter so much as to ruin your present relationship. And whether she will open up about such sensitive details is actually up to her. It has nothing to do with how much she loves you or trusts you. Please understand that.

Now coming to the next thing, the fact that she is still in touch with them and has even met one of them, that is slightly concerning. It would have been okay if she did that openly- please understand that I am not saying she should have asked for your permission, but rather discuss the same with you. Moreover, in a relationship, it is also important to understand how much your partner is comfortable with- goes for both men and women. If you are uncomfortable with her relationship with her exes, she should consider that. I would have said the same if the table was turned. I suggest you have a clear conversation with her and express how you feel about this situation- depending on how she reacts and how the conversation goes, you both can think about the next step.

Hope this helps.

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x