Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Ramalingam Kalirajan |10874 Answers |Ask -Follow

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 24, 2025

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 23, 2025Hindi

Hello Sir, Hope this mail finds you well ! I am a salaried person and in the high tax bracket. I have few STPs from debt fund to Equity fund. However I find that the STPs are incurring a STCG tax and need to report in my ITR. Since I am saving for my children, I plan to start STPs directly in the name of my 2 minor daughters (aged 13 & 7 yrs, they have their individual PAN / Aadhaar card/Bank Account) with my wife as guardian (she has no personal income). Will these help me avoid the STCG tax ?If I wish to continue the STP for 5-10 yrs, will Arbritage fund be better option (since it is more tax efficient) or there is some other debt fund which I can use for monthly STP into Equity fund of my minor children ? What are the advantages and disadvantages of this strategy. Please advise. Thanks.

Ans: You have asked a very thoughtful and important question.

It’s clear that you are planning with clarity and foresight.

Starting STPs for your children’s goals with tax awareness is a smart step.

Your strategy needs to be reviewed carefully from tax, structure, control, and efficiency angles.

Let’s look at it from all sides. Below is a detailed 360-degree perspective to guide you.

? Tax on STPs from Debt to Equity Fund

– STPs are treated as systematic redemption from the source fund.

– If you are using a debt fund for STP, each unit gets redeemed monthly.

– Every redemption triggers capital gain, even if automated via STP.

– As per latest rule, any capital gain from debt fund—short or long—is taxed as per slab.

– Since you are in high tax bracket, every monthly STP triggers income-taxable gain.

– Yes, this is inconvenient. But it’s how taxation works under the new rule.

? Setting Up Investments in Minor Daughters’ Name

– Children’s names in investments offer emotional attachment and tracking clarity.

– But taxation of minor’s income doesn’t work like adult income.

– As per clubbing provisions, a minor child’s income gets clubbed with parent’s income.

– If wife has no income, gains from minors' funds will be clubbed with your income.

– Even if your wife is the guardian, the income is still taxable in your hands.

– Hence, just naming the STPs in child’s PAN doesn’t remove your tax burden.

– Tax authorities look at source of funds, not just the name on the folio.

– The only exemption: if the income is from skill or talent of the minor. This doesn’t apply here.

– Therefore, this strategy won’t help you avoid STCG or slab-level tax.

? Should You Still Invest in Children’s Name?

– Yes, you can continue investing in their names for discipline and tracking.

– It will build a dedicated fund for each child’s education or marriage.

– But do not expect tax savings from it.

– You can also assign a separate folio in your own name for each child’s goal.

– That will simplify control and tax reporting for you.

– Ultimately, it’s about mental clarity, not legal tax separation.

? Arbitrage Funds as STP Source: Tax Perspective

– Arbitrage funds are equity-oriented.

– They buy and sell same stocks in different markets.

– These funds get equity tax treatment, not debt.

– So, gains after 1 year are long-term and taxed at 12.5% above Rs 1.25 lakh.

– Short-term gains (within 12 months) taxed at 20%.

– Since STPs happen monthly, each redemption is short-term in nature.

– So arbitrage STP will attract 20% STCG for the first 12 months.

– If the gain is small each month, actual tax may be minimal.

– Still, STCG is unavoidable if STP period is less than 1 year.

? Pros of Arbitrage Funds for STP

– Taxed like equity, which is lower than debt slab tax if held >1 year.

– More stable than equity, less volatile than hybrid funds.

– Gives slightly better post-tax return than savings account.

– Can act as a semi-liquid park for short-to-medium term.

– Ideal if STP is expected to last over 12 months.

– Arbitrage strategy is lower risk compared to other equity funds.

? Cons of Arbitrage Funds for STP

– Returns are not fixed. They vary between 4% to 6% generally.

– During low market volatility, even 3.5% returns happen.

– Not suitable for goals that need predictable capital.

– Returns may not beat inflation consistently.

– Redemption within 12 months means 20% tax on gains.

– Not completely tax-free as assumed by many.

? Is Arbitrage Better Than Liquid or Debt Funds for STP?

– It depends on STP period and tax bracket.

– In your case, high tax bracket makes debt fund less efficient.

– Arbitrage may offer better post-tax outcome for STPs over 12+ months.

– For STPs under 6 months, liquid funds give safety and predictability.

– Hybrid conservative funds offer balance but carry some volatility.

– There is no one-size-fits-all. Period, goal, and tax impact must be checked.

? STP vs Lump Sum: For Long-Term Goals

– STP is great when you have lump sum ready but want to reduce equity risk.

– It reduces timing risk of equity market entry.

– Useful when investing for child’s future, wedding, or college goals.

– But each STP leg still creates taxable transaction from source fund.

– If your holding period of source fund is long, tax gets lower.

– But if STP is short and frequent, tax gets reported every time.

? How to Manage STP Tax with Less Stress

– Choose source fund as equity-oriented hybrid fund, if tax is concern.

– Or use arbitrage fund if STP is for 12+ months.

– Make sure gains stay below Rs 1.25 lakh annually to avoid LTCG tax.

– Keep STP value per month moderate.

– Avoid creating multiple STPs from multiple source funds.

– File capital gain report from CAMS/KFintech every year for ITR.

– Maintain a spreadsheet to track monthly redemptions and capital gain.

– Plan STPs to align with ITR deadlines to reduce pressure.

? Use Regular Funds Through CFP-Associated MFD

– Direct plans don’t give handholding. Mistakes can be costly over years.

– Regular funds allow Certified Financial Planners to monitor and guide.

– Fund selection, asset allocation, and tax tracking becomes easier.

– You also avoid the stress of chasing returns or timing markets.

– Regular plans come with expert insights. They’re ideal for goal-based STPs.

– Especially helpful when you have minor children and long-term goals.

– Taxation, fund switch, and rebalancing needs a reliable guide.

– Choose someone with CFP credential to stay informed and aligned.

? Why Not Index Funds or ETFs for STP Target?

– Index funds do not adapt during market corrections.

– STP to index funds may not give downside protection.

– Index funds are passive and don’t manage volatility.

– Active funds with professional management adjust to changing economy.

– Active equity mutual funds suit child goals better than index funds.

– Especially when horizon is 5–10 years or more.

– ETFs also have liquidity and tracking error issues.

– Don’t use passive funds for planned goals unless supported by solid advisory.

? Better Alternatives for STP Source Fund

– Arbitrage funds: Suitable if 12+ months STP horizon is fixed.

– Ultra short duration funds: If you prefer safety over tax-efficiency.

– Conservative hybrid funds: Moderate growth, better taxation if equity heavy.

– Liquid funds: Good for 3–6 month STP where capital must stay intact.

– Choose fund based on child goal timeline, not only on tax.

? Strategic Suggestions for Your Children’s Plan

– Maintain separate SIP or STP for each child’s goal.

– Name folios clearly for tracking – “Daughter Edu 2032”, etc.

– Don’t combine funds. Keep child-wise goals separate.

– Avoid using these folios for any other personal expense.

– Review every 12 months and adjust STP amount as needed.

– Continue investing even if market fluctuates. Child’s future is priority.

– Don’t try to time the market using STP. Stick to system.

? Finally

– STP is a smart tool. But it doesn’t avoid tax.

– Investing in minor daughter’s name won’t reduce STCG burden.

– Arbitrage fund helps if you plan for 12+ months.

– Clubbing provision nullifies tax-saving intention in minor folios.

– Use STP mainly for risk reduction, not tax saving.

– Tax will happen, but can be managed smartly with proper fund choice.

– Maintain discipline, review yearly, and always align with your goal.

– With a Certified Financial Planner, your long-term strategy will stay efficient and stress-free.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.