Dear Mr.Ramlingam, I m 43 and married with two kids 9 and 3. Both of us are in private jobs. We have health insurance covering family already as 5 LPA and with NCB it cover till 10 LPA now. We wish to keep aside another 20 Lac ,citing medical costs these days and we plan to have 30 lacs cover . From incomes i am in position to set aside 20 lac in MFs for unforeseen medical treatment requirement of future, while same time i have two more options ,option 2: to buy another health insurance of 10 LPA and with NCB(hopefully) the cover goes upto 20 LPA in future .Option 3 is to increase the cover on our existing policy to 15 LPA. Kindly advise which among the three option looks most prudent call ?
Ans: At 43, with two young children and a stable income, you are making the right move by planning ahead for rising healthcare costs. A future-ready medical backup of Rs. 30 lakhs is wise and needed.
Let’s now assess each of your options in detail. We will see which is more practical, economical, and reliable in the long run.
? Your Current Situation Review
– You already have a health policy of Rs. 5 lakhs.
– With No Claim Bonus (NCB), it grows to Rs. 10 lakhs.
– This is good, but may not be enough after 10–15 years.
– Healthcare costs are increasing 12–14% per year.
– You want to increase cover to Rs. 30 lakhs now.
– You can either invest Rs. 20 lakhs in mutual funds.
– Or increase or buy new health insurance.
We will now compare these three options.
? Option 1: Invest Rs. 20 lakhs in Mutual Funds
– You plan to invest Rs. 20 lakhs in mutual funds.
– This will be earmarked for future health emergencies.
– This fund will grow with time.
– You will have control and liquidity.
– But this is not a replacement for insurance.
– If a big hospitalisation comes early, this fund may not be ready.
– Medical bills can go up to Rs. 15–20 lakhs easily.
– If this happens early, you may need to break MFs with loss.
– There will be tax on redemption.
– Equity fund gains above Rs. 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%.
– Short term gains taxed at 20%.
– Debt funds taxed as per income slab.
– So this is useful only as a backup.
– Not the main health plan.
Use this fund as Plan B. Not Plan A.
? Option 2: Buy Another Policy of Rs. 10 Lakhs with NCB
– You are considering buying a separate Rs. 10 lakh policy.
– With NCB, it will grow to Rs. 20 lakhs over time.
– This gives you a combined cover of Rs. 30 lakhs in future.
– Premium will be low now, as you are young.
– It will be independent of your main policy.
– If one policy has room limit issues, you can claim the other.
– Helps if you are admitted in two different years.
– This offers better flexibility.
– No single company dependency.
– Also allows you to compare benefits later.
– But you need to manage two policies yearly.
– Extra paperwork during claims.
Still, this is a good and practical choice.
? Option 3: Increase Existing Cover to Rs. 15 Lakhs
– You can also increase your main policy to Rs. 15 lakhs.
– With NCB, it may go to Rs. 25–30 lakhs over time.
– This keeps things simple.
– One policy, one premium, one renewal, one claim process.
– But this also has risks.
– If claim is rejected for some reason, full plan fails.
– If insurer’s network weakens, you lose options.
– You are completely dependent on one provider.
– You also lose product comparison benefits.
– If premium becomes high in future, no exit option.
This may look easy but lacks flexibility and protection diversity.
? Recommended 360 Degree Strategy
The best choice is not one option. Combine smart elements from all.
– Increase current policy from Rs. 5L to Rs. 10L if premium is reasonable.
– Buy a separate Rs. 10L policy now from a reputed different insurer.
– Let both grow with NCB to Rs. 20L each.
– This gives you a Rs. 40L total cover in 5–7 years.
– No need to increase to Rs. 15L in one policy.
– It’s better to split for claim flexibility.
– Alongside, keep Rs. 10L in mutual fund for emergencies.
– Use only when both policies are insufficient.
– This hybrid approach keeps cost low and protection high.
– You gain liquidity, flexibility, and future options.
? Role of Mutual Fund as Support
– Mutual funds are best for long-term growth.
– Not ideal for immediate health expenses.
– They work well when used as a buffer.
– Keep Rs. 10–12L in hybrid or debt mutual fund.
– Avoid keeping full Rs. 20L.
– That money may be idle or taxed heavily when used.
– Instead, put remaining Rs. 8–10L in equity mutual fund.
– It can be for general goals like child education.
– Don’t make your entire health planning depend on mutual funds.
– Their value can drop just when you need money.
? Use of Regular Mutual Funds via MFD with CFP
– Don’t invest in direct mutual funds for this.
– You will miss expert review and timely advice.
– Direct plans don’t help during emotional or medical crisis.
– Regular plans through MFD with CFP give support.
– You get handholding, switching advice, and better strategy.
– For goal-based investing, personal help is more valuable than saving 0.5% fees.
– With right guidance, you’ll avoid panic selling or wrong redemption.
? Disadvantages of Index Funds in This Case
– Index funds follow market. They don’t manage risks.
– If markets fall before hospitalisation, fund value falls.
– You cannot wait in such emergencies.
– Active funds managed by experts adjust based on risk.
– Index funds can never protect downside.
– Don’t use them for emergency needs.
– They are not suitable for critical goals like health protection.
Always choose actively managed funds via Certified Financial Planner.
? Final Insights
– Health cover of Rs. 30L is necessary today.
– But don’t depend on just one tool.
– Use insurance for large cover and liquidity.
– Use mutual funds for backup and inflation hedge.
– Split cover between two insurers for safety.
– Avoid direct plans and index funds.
– Get help from Certified Financial Planner.
– Monitor medical inflation and revisit policy limits every 5 years.
– Keep nominations updated and involve spouse in policy info.
– Continue NCB to increase cover without extra cost.
By using both insurance and mutual funds wisely, you stay fully prepared.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment