Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Anu

Anu Krishna  |1633 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on May 17, 2023

Anu Krishna is a mind coach and relationship expert.
The co-founder of Unfear Changemakers LLP, she has received her neuro linguistic programming training from National Federation of NeuroLinguistic Programming, USA, and her energy work specialisation from the Institute for Inner Studies, Manila.
She is an executive member of the Indian Association of Adolescent Health.... more
Asked by Anonymous - May 16, 2023Hindi
Listen
Relationship

My wife is having illegit sexual relationship with another guy. I am in different town and she is in different city. I came to know she is having sexual relationship with another person. As a man what shall i do. Please guide

Ans: Dear Anonymous,
Have a frank chat about this with your wife.
As much as you hear her side of the story, you need have the space to state yours and how this situation is making you feel. Hear her out too...
Decide for yourself what you want in your marriage now. If you are unprepared to accept this, state it to her clearly and ask her if she is willing to let the other relationship go and come back into the marriage; of course depends on whether you want that or not.
That is why before knowing what to do, you need to ask yourself: What is it that I want? What to do will follow once you know what you want.

All the best!

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1633 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Jul 15, 2021

Listen
Relationship
 Dear Madam, I have been married for 26 years having two sons.Recently I discovered that my wife was in a relationship for last 11 years.I was devastated after this new discovery.After this my wife says sorry and she will move on and break off the relationship. But to my utter dismay the same is going on.What step do I need to take in this matter?
Ans: Dear AK, time to sit down, talk and figure out if she and you want to be in this marriage.

Also, do you want to work on this marriage, do you want to continue?

Couples drift apart for various reasons and some may lead to finding a new sense of identity and thrill outside of marriage.

I guess it’s time for some reality check questions and truthfully answering them.

I am not going to pin your wife down or ask you what went wrong as this is for the two of you to talk and iron out.

Kindly take the help of a professional who can guide you both in an impartial manner, throw deep reflective questions to both of you so that it helps you reach some sort of decision.

In the meantime, understand that any connection outside of marriage happened for a reason and 11 years is a long time. To imagine that it can be broken off just like that is a good hopeful imagination.

So, it takes time and for her to understand that her marriage to you is important and that she can tactfully move away from the other connection requires some reflection on her part too.

Do support one another and it’s possible to rebuild the marriage if both of you choose to.

Create a good life!

..Read more

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1633 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Dec 12, 2023

Listen
Relationship
First of all, thanks for your answering my previous question. I am still unable to accept that a woman who has relatively happy marriage and children is getting involve with other men despite warning and claiming that he is only friend and jeopardizing her marriage. Let this kind of situation happens with me . How will I proceed when I come to know that my wife is talking and meeting to another man even after my warning for (let say) more than 5 years and saying that she has not committed adultery ? Your answer will be appreciated
Ans: Dear Samrat,
I apologize if I am incorrect. But I seem to notice that you keep asking the same question in different ways. It will help if you actually state what is bothering you.
You not willing ;to accept a woman who has relatively happy marriage and children is getting involve with other men despite warning and claiming that he is only friend and jeopardizing her marriage'? Is this about someone that you know? Or is it something that you want to know out of curiosity? If it is only a healthy debate that you seek, I suggest that there are other platforms that encourage answers and responses as a debate. You may want to ask these questions there.
If it is indeed about you having this problem with your wife, then ask so...also as Gurus, it becomes easy for us to address a person's challenge if they come straight to the point. I hope I am making sense.

Ifs and Buts in life are many...are you suspecting that your wife is in a relationship outside of marriage?
I ask because you have mentioned: How will I proceed when I come to know...does this mean that you know or you are expecting this or you have your doubts?
If you know, simply ask her...she does have the responsibility within the marriage to let you know of this.

If you don't know or are playing on your doubts due to your beliefs of: I am unable to accept that a woman getting involved despite warning...Then know that your lack of trust will kill your marriage...

So, my suggestion...do come to the point and ask your question directly. You will be able to leverage this platform better and find a path to your challenges.

All the best!

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 25, 2025Hindi
Money
I'm 28 years old. I have a Rs 22.5 lakh home loan with 28 years pending. I have been doing pre-payment of 20,000 per month and have reduced it to 20L. It will be paid off in next 5 years if I continue the pre-payment. I have 15,000-20,000 SIP which I paused for 2 years and have started again (total portfolio 4.5L). I have stocks worth 1.5L, EPF worth 1.5L. I have 4,000 per month for NPS (total 1.5L), 3203 per month Term Life Insurance. I have 6 months backup in FD and save 40,000-50,000 per month. I want to buy a plot worth 10L in next 1.5-2 years. How should I optimise to reach 1cr net worth till 35 years of age?
Ans: You have shown great commitment to savings and debt repayment. Let’s now look at a 360-degree approach to build a Rs 1 crore net worth by 35.

Your age gives you a strong advantage. But careful steps are needed. Let’s break this into simple, clear points.

Analysing Your Current Financial Position
You are 28 years old with 7 years to reach the goal.

You have a Rs 20 lakh home loan pending, aggressively being paid down.

Existing mutual funds: Rs 4.5 lakh. Stocks: Rs 1.5 lakh. EPF: Rs 1.5 lakh.

NPS balance: Rs 1.5 lakh. Term life insurance in place (good protection).

Emergency fund of 6 months in fixed deposits (well-planned).

Your savings potential is strong at Rs 40,000–50,000 per month.

Planned expense: Rs 10 lakh for a plot in 1.5–2 years.

SIPs were paused but now resumed (positive sign of financial discipline).

Prioritising Financial Goals Clearly
Goal 1: Repay the home loan in 5 years.

Goal 2: Buy a Rs 10 lakh plot in 2 years.

Goal 3: Reach Rs 1 crore net worth by age 35.

These goals are competing. Planning is needed to balance all.

Asset growth is limited if major funds are used for debt and property.

Rethinking the Plot Purchase Plan
A Rs 10 lakh plot will block wealth creation for now.

Property won’t grow fast in 5–7 years. It ties up capital.

Also, it creates maintenance costs and legal work.

Instead, you can grow faster in mutual funds over 7 years.

You may postpone the plot purchase till your net worth is stronger.

Reassess whether the plot is a need or just a want.

If mandatory, keep it below Rs 6 lakh. Fund balance into SIPs.

Plot purchase and home loan together slow down wealth creation.

Accelerating Home Loan Repayment: Pros and Cons
Prepayment reduces your loan term and interest cost.

But your loan is for 28 years, so EMIs are low.

The interest rate is likely 8%-9%, equity can beat that.

Over-prepaying may reduce long-term compounding opportunities.

Instead, repay enough to close in 7–8 years, not 5.

Free the Rs 20,000 prepayment for investments after 5–7 years.

Keep mandatory EMIs going as planned, with some prepayment buffer.

Restructuring Your Monthly Savings Allocation
Savings of Rs 40,000–50,000 can be optimised as follows:

Rs 15,000 SIP (already restarted) – continue consistently.

Increase SIP by 10% every year to beat inflation.

Rs 20,000 prepayment for home loan – continue till cleared.

Rs 5,000 NPS – long-term retirement goal (keep contributing).

Rs 4,000–5,000 to short-term debt fund or FD for plot savings.

Rs 5,000 surplus to emergency fund, top it up to 9 months.

Future bonuses or hikes – allocate 70% to SIPs, 30% to plot/loan.

Optimising Mutual Fund Portfolio
Focus on actively managed funds only, not index funds.

Index funds have no flexibility in falling markets.

They mirror the market both upwards and downwards.

Actively managed funds have experienced fund managers.

These managers shift sectors and stocks based on market conditions.

Active funds give better downside protection than index funds.

Invest in a mix of flexi cap, mid cap, and small cap funds.

These styles give you growth and some risk balance.

Stay with regular plans through a Certified Financial Planner.

Direct plans lack professional guidance and periodic reviews.

CFP-led guidance adjusts your portfolio based on your life stage.

Regular plans offer personalised service, market alerts, and handholding.

Your financial journey will be smoother with proactive adjustments.

Should You Continue With Stocks?
Your stocks of Rs 1.5 lakh may be in random sectors.

Unless you follow markets daily, move stocks to equity funds.

Equity funds give diversification and better risk management.

Active funds offer sector rotation, which stocks don’t.

Stocks may give big returns but carry bigger losses too.

Transfer stock funds to mutual funds slowly to avoid sudden taxes.

Plot Purchase: Fund Allocation Plan
If plot purchase is non-negotiable, save Rs 4,000–5,000 monthly.

Keep this money in liquid or ultra short debt funds.

Avoid equity as tenure is short (less than 2 years).

Don’t use your emergency fund for this plot.

Don’t stop SIPs to fund the plot either.

If plot can wait 5–6 years, equity can help it grow.

Otherwise, it limits your journey to Rs 1 crore.

Review of NPS and EPF Contributions
NPS is a retirement tool, not for your Rs 1 crore goal.

But it gives tax benefits. Continue Rs 4,000 monthly.

EPF is a slow-growing but safe retirement tool.

Continue EPF through your salary. Don’t withdraw early.

Retirement corpus and net worth goal should be separate.

Emergency Fund Adequacy
Your 6-month emergency fund is solid.

Slowly build it to 9 months over 2 years.

Keep it in short term debt funds or FDs.

Avoid using it for the plot or loan prepayment.

Role of Term Insurance and Health Insurance
You already have term insurance. Ensure it covers 15–20 years’ income.

Also, take Rs 10–15 lakh family floater health insurance.

Health insurance protects your net worth from sudden expenses.

Review coverage every 3–4 years as your needs change.

Tax Planning and Mutual Fund Taxation
Equity mutual funds will have LTCG tax of 12.5% beyond Rs 1.25 lakh gains.

Short-term equity fund gains are taxed at 20%.

Debt funds will be taxed as per your slab.

Tax-efficient withdrawals will help protect your net worth goal.

A Certified Financial Planner will guide you on tax harvesting.

How to Reach Rs 1 Crore in 7 Years?
Your goal needs focused equity exposure, not blocked assets.

Plot and home loan prepayments slow down corpus growth.

7-year compounding in equity funds could multiply your wealth.

SIPs of Rs 15,000–20,000 with annual step-up will help.

Windfalls like bonuses or gifts must go into equity.

Avoid new loans or liabilities till you reach Rs 1 crore.

Review your net worth every year. Adjust SIPs accordingly.

Have clear cut goals – net worth first, real estate later.

Recommended Action Plan for the Next 2 Years
Continue Rs 20,000 home loan prepayment for 2 years.

Simultaneously save Rs 5,000 monthly in a debt fund for the plot.

Maintain Rs 15,000 SIPs in active mutual funds.

Review SIPs every 6 months with a Certified Financial Planner.

Postpone the plot purchase if your financial flexibility reduces.

Direct any job increments towards SIPs first, then other goals.

After home loan repayment, divert Rs 20,000 towards SIPs.

Build your net worth mainly through equity, not property.

Possible Roadblocks and How to Manage Them
Inflation will reduce your money’s future value.

SIP increases each year will fight inflation.

Job loss or income drop is another risk. Emergency fund covers this.

Market volatility will test your patience. Stay invested.

Don’t pause SIPs again unless for emergency reasons.

Plot appreciation is slow in short term. Don't rely on it.

Emotional buying decisions on property must be avoided.

Steps to Review Your Progress
Every January, check your total investments and home loan status.

Calculate your total assets minus liabilities.

This gives your net worth figure. Aim for steady yearly growth.

Compare with your Rs 1 crore target. Adjust SIPs if needed.

Engage a Certified Financial Planner for annual reviews.

Stay flexible but disciplined in your financial behaviour.

Finally
You have great savings potential at a young age.

Your financial discipline already shows in your loan prepayment and SIP restart.

But property purchase and early loan closure will slow down wealth creation.

If you optimise your SIPs and control real estate investments, Rs 1 crore is achievable.

A balanced approach of debt repayment, disciplined investing, and moderate lifestyle can help.

Stay consistent in your SIPs, increase them yearly, and avoid unnecessary expenses.

Use a Certified Financial Planner to stay on track.

They will guide you through market changes, tax planning, and portfolio adjustments.

Avoid index funds and direct mutual funds as they lack flexibility and guidance.

Regular funds through an experienced MFD with CFP give proactive portfolio management.

Focus on long-term wealth, not short-term property.

You are on the right path. Stay consistent and patient.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 25, 2025Hindi
Money
Dear Sir/Madam,I am 30. I have 1.9L of debt that I am planning to pay back by Mar-26. I have 1 lakh of Mutual funds and 1 lakh of Stocks. I want to invest 20,000 rupees every month and want to amass atleast 50 lakhs in the near future. Kindly help. Post the 50 lakhs wants to push over into 1 crore and I have a final Target of 15 crores set for myself
Ans: Understanding Your Current Situation

You are 30 years old with high wealth creation goals.

You have Rs. 1.9 lakh in debt to be cleared by March 2026.

You already have Rs. 1 lakh in mutual funds.

You also have Rs. 1 lakh in direct stocks.

You can invest Rs. 20,000 every month.

You want to first build Rs. 50 lakh, then Rs. 1 crore.

Your final long-term goal is to reach Rs. 15 crore.

Let us break this goal into proper steps and build your plan.

Debt Repayment – Must Be a Priority

Paying off debt gives peace and mental strength.

Debt has interest. It eats into your future earnings.

Clear the Rs. 1.9 lakh as planned by March 2026.

Don’t delay this timeline unless absolutely necessary.

Avoid adding new loans or EMIs during this phase.

Until March 2026, balance investing and repayments smartly.

Use Rs. 15,000 for debt, Rs. 5,000 for investments monthly till then.

After the debt is cleared, move full Rs. 20,000 into wealth-building.

Current Investments – A Quick Review

Rs. 1 lakh in mutual funds is a good start.

Rs. 1 lakh in direct stocks shows interest in equity.

Avoid putting large sums into direct stocks now.

Stock investing without research brings high risk.

Focus more on mutual funds for long-term goals.

Mutual funds offer diversification, expertise, and better risk control.

Setting and Breaking Down Your Goals

Goal 1: Build Rs. 50 lakh corpus

This can be done over 10 to 12 years.

Rs. 20,000 SIP monthly can help reach this goal.

Avoid stopping SIP even when markets are down.

Consistency is more powerful than timing.

Goal 2: Reach Rs. 1 crore next

After reaching Rs. 50 lakh, let the money grow further.

Increase SIP amount as your income rises.

Rs. 30,000–Rs. 40,000 SIP monthly is ideal after a few years.

Goal 3: Reach Rs. 15 crore finally

This is a 25 to 30-year goal.

Needs strong discipline, patience, and guidance.

Inflation must also be beaten every year.

Avoid short-term temptation during this journey.

Monthly Investment Plan – Mutual Funds Approach

Begin with Rs. 20,000 SIP every month.

Divide SIPs across 3 to 4 actively managed mutual funds.

Include large-cap, flexi-cap, mid-cap, and hybrid fund categories.

Actively managed funds outperform in the long run.

Index funds don’t help beat the market. They just copy it.

Index funds fall equally when the market falls.

They give no downside protection or intelligent asset selection.

Go with active funds. Fund managers add value using research and market insight.

Avoid Direct Plans – Go With Regular Plans via CFP-backed MFD

Direct plans don’t offer review or behavioural support.

Investors often act emotionally in direct plans.

MFDs with CFP credentials give you full support.

They track your progress and suggest changes.

They help you align your money with your goals.

They also help you manage taxation smartly.

Even a 1% mistake in long-term investing costs lakhs.
Regular plans give handholding. That is far more valuable than low TER.

Taxation Rules for Mutual Funds – Keep in Mind

LTCG on equity mutual funds above Rs. 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%.

STCG on equity mutual funds taxed at 20%.

Debt mutual funds are taxed as per your income slab.

SIPs give tax efficiency as capital gains are taxed only on selling.

Don’t redeem SIPs unless goal is reached or real need arises.

Plan redemptions with help of your Certified Financial Planner.

Step-by-Step Wealth Creation Strategy

Step 1: Clear all your debt by March 2026

Stick to your timeline.

Don’t delay payments.

Keep Rs. 15,000 per month for repayment.

Step 2: Continue Rs. 5,000 SIP till debt is closed

Choose one active flexi-cap fund for now.

This builds your investing habit.

Step 3: After March 2026, invest full Rs. 20,000 per month

Split it into 4 mutual funds.

Review every 12 months with CFP-backed MFD.

Increase SIP by 10% every year as income grows.

Step 4: Focus only on equity mutual funds for long-term

Hybrid funds can be used for 5–7 year goals.

Avoid mixing short and long-term goals.

Step 5: Don’t invest more in direct stocks for now

Direct stocks need knowledge, research, and tracking.

Mistakes can cost your compounding journey.

Build a Safety Net First

Have emergency fund of 6 months’ expenses.

Keep it in liquid mutual funds or bank account.

Never invest emergency funds in equity.

Insurance is equally important.

Take these basic covers:

Term insurance based on income and dependents.

Health insurance of at least Rs. 5 lakh.

Personal accident cover is also useful.

Wealth creation is meaningless if risks are ignored.

Create Financial Goals and Prioritise Them

Write down short-term, medium-term, and long-term goals.

Don’t mix all goals in same mutual funds.

For example:

Emergency fund: Use liquid funds

Marriage in 7–8 years: Use hybrid funds

Retirement or financial freedom: Use equity mutual funds

Vacation in 3 years: Use short-term debt fund

This clear mapping brings peace and purpose to investing.

Things to Avoid in Your Journey

Don’t invest in real estate as an investment.

Don’t stop SIP during market corrections.

Don’t choose direct or index funds without proper support.

Don’t delay debt repayments.

Don’t forget to review portfolio every year.

Don’t jump from one scheme to another.

Avoid these mistakes and your journey becomes smooth.

Role of a Certified Financial Planner-backed MFD

Helps you create written goal-based plans.

Monitors SIPs and market behaviour.

Suggests fund switch when needed.

Keeps your emotions in control.

Updates you on tax changes and helps plan exits.

This human support is your real compounding engine.

Why Mutual Funds Work Best for You

Easy to start with small amounts.

Offer diversification, expert management, and flexibility.

Have different categories for every need.

Create wealth with discipline and goal alignment.

Can be stopped or modified anytime.

SIPs reduce risk with cost averaging.

You already have Rs. 1 lakh in mutual funds.
Build on that foundation with the right SIP strategy.

Your Investment Journey Should Look Like This

Age 30–35: Build foundation, clear debt, invest consistently.

Age 36–45: Increase SIP, review goals, avoid lifestyle inflation.

Age 46–55: Protect corpus, reduce unnecessary risks.

Age 56 onwards: Shift to withdrawal strategy and sustain corpus.

With a strong SIP, disciplined life, and guidance, Rs. 15 crore is possible.

Finally

You are starting at the right age with the right mindset.

Focus first on repaying your Rs. 1.9 lakh debt.

Invest Rs. 5,000 monthly till March 2026.

After that, go full Rs. 20,000 into SIP.

Choose actively managed mutual funds in regular plan route.

Use a Certified Financial Planner-backed MFD for full support.

Avoid index funds and direct investing traps.

Keep insurance and emergency funds in place.

Keep SIP running till your goals are reached.

Be patient, consistent, and goal-focused.

Let compounding do its magic over 25–30 years.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 24, 2025Hindi
Money
I took two loans to increase my CIBIL score and closed them within 6 months. My CIBIL score has dropped by 24 points from 761 because I closed two loan accounts within 6 months. What should I do now to increase my points?
Ans: Understanding Your Current CIBIL Drop

Your CIBIL score was 761 earlier.

You took two loans to improve it.

Closed both within 6 months.

Now, your score has dropped by 24 points.

You are concerned why this happened.

How Short-Term Loans Affected Your Score

Loan closure too early signals credit instability.

CIBIL expects longer loan tenures for score strength.

Closing quickly reduces credit age.

It hurts your score more than helping.

Loan repayment history was too short to build credit.

What CIBIL Score Really Measures

It checks repayment behaviour.

Considers credit mix and utilisation.

Monitors credit history length.

Short loans give limited data to CIBIL.

It prefers consistent repayment over time.

Steps to Rebuild Your CIBIL Score Slowly

Do not take new loans now.

Focus on credit card discipline.

Maintain low credit usage, under 30% of limit.

Pay full dues on or before due date.

Set up auto-debit for EMIs or card dues.

If You Don’t Have a Credit Card, Get One

Get a secured credit card if score is low.

Use for small purchases.

Repay full amount each month.

After 6–9 months, score will improve.

Do not apply for multiple cards.

Avoid Frequent Loan Applications

Multiple enquiries lower your score.

CIBIL flags you as “credit hungry”.

Don’t fall for personal loan offers easily.

Wait 6–9 months before fresh credit moves.

Let the Credit Age Grow

Credit age is an important factor.

Older accounts help score grow.

Never close old credit cards.

Even unused ones with zero fee are useful.

Check CIBIL Report for Errors

Download detailed CIBIL report from official site.

Check if loans are correctly reported as closed.

See if any delayed EMI or missed payment shown.

If any issue, raise dispute with CIBIL.

Build Credit Mix Carefully

Credit mix means types of credit used.

A good mix has both secured and unsecured loans.

But don’t take loan just to create a mix.

Keep your financial health more important.

Avoid These Mistakes Going Forward

Don’t close loans early without purpose.

Don’t take loans just to increase score.

Don’t miss EMI dates.

Don’t carry credit card balance forward.

Don’t max out your cards.

CIBIL Score Growth is Slow but Steady

Credit score takes time to build.

Don’t expect changes every month.

Track every quarter only.

Do not panic with 20–30 points movement.

Focus on long-term responsible behaviour.

Why Credit Score Matters Later

Better score helps in home or car loans.

You get lower interest rates.

Also helps for higher credit card limits.

Employers and landlords may check score.

Maintain 750+ for best benefits.

If You Used Direct Loans or Cards Without Guidance

Direct approach lacks credit strategy.

Always work with a Certified Financial Planner.

CFP helps manage credit and investments together.

You can align credit behaviour to long-term goals.

Rebuild With Long-Term Financial Health

Don’t chase score only.

Build savings alongside credit history.

Have Rs 1–2 lakh emergency fund.

Start SIP in mutual funds monthly.

Use 50:30:20 budget rule.

Finally

Your CIBIL score drop is temporary.

It happened due to early closure of loans.

CIBIL expects long-term repayment track.

Don’t take loans for scoring purpose again.

Instead, use credit card wisely and repay fully.

Check report, avoid new enquiries, and be patient.

You will regain score in 6–12 months steadily.

Consult a Certified Financial Planner for overall money planning.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 24, 2025Hindi
Money
Hi, My age is 37 years. Me and my wife have combined income of Rs 2.15 lakhs per month We have a home loan of Rs 44 lakhs with emi of 37000 spanned over 19 years We have arnd 20 lakhs invested in the equities market. Savings of arnd 10 lakhs in PPF and arnd 15 lakhs in PF. I have one daughter whose monthly school fees is 20000. We keep aside arnd 50000 for our expense monthly all three. Apart from it I invest in sukanya scheme monthly 12500 We have other household expenses sucha S maid 10000, electricity 8000, gas bill 2000. Within next 5 years, I want that my corpus should atleast cross 1 crore excluding PPF and PF. So what is the best strategy for that. And is it advisable that I start doing prepayment for home.loan so that I quickly finishes it.
Ans: You’re disciplined and goal-driven, and that’s a strong foundation. Let’s work through your situation carefully to help you reach Rs 1 crore in five years while managing your home loan and responsibilities genuinely.

Assessing Your Current Financial Position

Combined income is Rs 2.15 lakh per month

You pay Rs 37,000 monthly towards home loan EMI

School fee for daughter is Rs 20,000 monthly

Monthly household expenses total around Rs 50,000

You invest Rs 12,500 monthly in girls' savings scheme

You currently hold investments of Rs 20 lakh in equities

Savings include Rs 10 lakh in PPF and Rs 15 lakh in PF

You’re doing well with savings and investing consistently each month.

Clarifying Your 5-Year Rs 1 Crore Goal

You want Rs 1 crore corpus within five years

Existing equity investment and SIPs are key contributors

You seek clarity on whether home loan prepayment helps

Let's explore how to structure this roadmap.

Examining Home Loan Prepayment

Prepaying home loan feels good because you reduce interest cost. But:

ROI on home loan prepayment is equivalent to your home loan rate (~7–8%)

Your equity investments can potentially yield more (10–14%)

Prepayment locks money that could compound in markets

Unless your loan rate is significantly high, avoid prepaying aggressively

A small part—say 10% of surplus—can be used for occasional prepayments

This gives balance between debt reduction and growth investing

Prepay only if surplus remains after SIPs and emergency needs.

Strengthening Your Savings and Investments

To reach Rs 1 crore in five years, structure your monthly investments:

Continue equity SIPs every month via your advisor (likely Rs 15–18K)

Increase SIP amount gradually as income grows

Allocate any surplus (> Rs 1 lakh available monthly) into multi-cap and flexi-cap mutual funds

Do not rely on index funds—they mirror market no matter direction

Active funds have potential to outperform and adapt

Choose regular plans through a CFP-backed MFD for ongoing guidance

Avoid direct funds—they lack rebalancing and expert support

Keep invested for the next five years consistently

Additionally:

Consider top-up in girls’ savings scheme if budget allows

But don't compromise on higher-return active equity funds

Building a Goal-Based Portfolio Roadmap

Emergency Corpus

Ensure you hold 6–12 months of living expenses in liquid funds

This amount is crucial before aggressive investment

Debt-dominant Funds

Allocate a portion of savings into low-risk debt funds

These anchor portfolio stability during market corrections

Equity Funds (Core Growth)

Your primary growth driver

Split between multi-cap, flexi-cap, and mid-cap funds

Invest Rs 20–30K monthly, increasing with income

Tax-Saving and Child Goals

Leverage girls’ scheme and school fee savings

Consider a small portion in long-term equity-linked savings for tax benefit

Tracking Progress to Rs 1 Crore

Expect strong equity returns averaging 10–12% annually

This yields steady portfolio growth avoiding over-concentration

Check portfolio every quarter with your CFP

Rebalance allocations if one category exceeds or lags

Adjust SIP amount upward with bonuses or raise in income

This discipline will get you close to or beyond Rs 1 crore

When and How to Prepay the Home Loan

Prepay part of the loan if surplus remains consistently

Use bonuses or windfalls for lump-sum prepayment

That reduces loan tenure and interest outgo

But don’t drain liquidity or reduce emergency fund

Insurance and Contingency Planning

Make sure you have term life cover of at least Rs 1 crore for you and spouse

Continue girls' scheme for their future needs

Review your health insurance cover annually

Ensure you are protected against unexpected emergencies

Avoiding Common Investment Pitfalls

Don’t switch funds based on short-term performance

Avoid index funds—they offer no protection or proactive strategy

Skip direct mutual funds—they may lead to poor decisions without advisor guidance

Regular plans through MFD with CFP help control behavioural bias and improve compounding

Final Insights

Your monthly cash flow and investments are strong

Focus on building larger equity SIPs for 5-year corpus goal

Keep home loan but prepay occasionally for interest reduction

Prioritize goal-based, actively managed regular mutual funds

Strengthen health coverage and ensure adequate life cover

Review, rebalance, and grow investments yearly with your CFP

You’re already on a smart path. With systematic investing, prudent prepayment, and proper protection, Rs 1 crore is an achievable goal within five years.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Money
Hi, In FY2425 I sold some equity shares and equity mutual funds to pay for an apartment. Both the equity shares and MF were held for more than 2 years and would qualify as LTCG. The question I have is how to calculate the sale value. I know the acquired cost and I know the absolute sale, redemption value. But I also see the indexed sale value in my DP account, which is less. What is the correct method to calculate LTCG on equity and equity MF? Acquired cost - sale value or acquired cost - indexed sale value? I have paid STT during the purchase of the stocks and MFs
Ans: Understanding Your Question Correctly First

You sold equity shares and mutual funds in FY 2024-25.

Both were held for more than 1 year.

These qualify as long-term capital assets.

You sold them to fund your flat purchase.

You know the cost and the selling price.

But your DP shows indexed sale value, which is confusing.

You want to know how to correctly calculate LTCG tax.

Tax on Equity Mutual Funds and Shares – FY 2024-25 Rule

If held for more than 1 year, it is treated as long-term.

LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh per year is taxed at 12.5%.

Short-term gains (less than 1 year) taxed at 20%.

You have paid STT, so the transaction is eligible.

So you qualify for equity LTCG tax treatment.

No Indexation is Used for Equity Mutual Funds

This is the key point in your query.

Indexation is not used for equity or equity mutual funds.

Indexed sale value in DP is just shown for reference.

It is not used in your LTCG calculation.

Indexed value is only used for debt mutual funds earlier.

Now even that is removed from April 2023 onwards.

Correct Way to Calculate LTCG on Equity and Equity Mutual Funds

LTCG = Actual Sale Value – Actual Cost of Acquisition

No indexation benefit is allowed here.

Use actual purchase price, not indexed price.

Use actual redemption or sale amount, not indexed sale value.

Ignore the indexed sale value from DP.

It is not relevant under equity LTCG rules.

Example for Clarity

Suppose you bought equity MF for Rs 3 lakh.

Sold it for Rs 6 lakh after 2 years.

Your LTCG = Rs 6 lakh – Rs 3 lakh = Rs 3 lakh.

Out of Rs 3 lakh, Rs 1.25 lakh is exempt.

Balance Rs 1.75 lakh taxed at 12.5%.

Tax payable = Rs 21,875.

No indexation adjustment to cost or sale.

What You See in DP Statement – Not for Tax Filing

DP sometimes shows indexed cost or indexed sale.

It is done based on CII (Cost Inflation Index).

This is just to show gain or loss in inflation terms.

For equity shares and equity mutual funds, ignore it.

Use actual figures only for tax calculation.

How to Report in ITR

Use ITR-2 if you have capital gains.

Report sale of equity MF and shares under Capital Gains Schedule.

Select “Equity Shares or Units of Equity Mutual Funds”.

Show actual cost and actual sale proceeds.

Mention STT paid if required.

Use LTCG section and report only taxable gains.

You can adjust Rs 1.25 lakh exemption automatically.

Avoid These Common Mistakes

Don’t use indexed cost for equity funds.

Don’t consider cost inflation index values here.

Don’t rely on DP’s summary for tax calculation.

Don’t enter wrong cost in ITR.

Don’t miss reporting if LTCG is below Rs 1.25 lakh.

Still report in ITR if total income exceeds exemption.

Mutual Fund Taxation Now Is Simple

LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%.

STCG taxed at 20%.

No indexation for equity or debt mutual funds.

Tax applies only on gains, not full value.

You must report even exempt LTCG in ITR.

If You Used Direct Mutual Funds – Reconsider Future Approach

Direct funds do not provide guidance.

You handle portfolio alone without expert help.

You may miss tax-saving or rebalancing opportunities.

Regular mutual funds via Certified Financial Planner are better.

You get long-term planning and tax-efficiency.

Avoid investing in direct mode going forward.

Why Actively Managed Funds Are Better Than Index Funds

Index funds copy the index blindly.

No exit from poor performing sectors.

They fall as much as markets during corrections.

No protection or rebalancing available.

Actively managed funds beat index over 5–10 years.

Fund manager decisions give higher potential.

Use regular funds for better compounding with professional help.

What to Do With Gains After Selling

Don’t park entire money in savings account.

Keep 3–6 months expenses in liquid fund.

Reinvest balance in hybrid and diversified funds.

Use STP or SIP for reinvestment.

Don’t go for real estate or traditional policies.

Don’t use annuities or guaranteed plans.

Stay invested through mutual funds with regular monitoring.

Plan for Reinvestment Carefully

Create retirement or wealth-building goals.

Align investments to each goal and timeline.

Use SWP if monthly income is needed.

Track returns, risk and tax each year.

Make spouse co-holder or nominee.

Review portfolio with Certified Financial Planner yearly.

Finally

LTCG on equity mutual funds and shares uses actual sale and cost.

Indexed cost or indexed sale shown in DP is not used.

Ignore those figures while calculating capital gains.

Tax applies only on actual gain, not inflated numbers.

Use regular mutual funds with expert guidance for future planning.

Avoid direct and index funds to protect long-term wealth.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 26, 2025Hindi
Money
Hi Sir..hope well... I m 37 y old with spouse + 2 girl child's ( 10 & 9) ... I am completed only 2 dues each 32 k per quarterly for my ULIP base Insurance coverage 50L +50L +50L with all rider included.. Policy term 25 y & premium term 8 years... Can you advise, is this OK for coverage.. Or shall I find any Term insurance? . Shall I continue this ULIP plan.. I have Helathy policy in Star Health with 3 L only ... is this enough?. Pls advise.. Regarding investment, i am runninhywith some regular Plan Sip thru financial advisor per month 15 to 18K monthly... Needs your opinion?.
Ans: You’ve taken thoughtful steps for your family—coverage, investment, and planning. That’s a strong start. Now let’s review everything in a 360-degree way.

Reviewing Your ULIP Coverage

You hold three ULIP plans, each with Rs 50L sum assured

Premium term is 8 years; policy term is 25 years

You’ve completed only two quarters of payments

ULIPs combine insurance and market-linked returns

They come with charges—fund management, mortality, admin

These charges reduce investment growth significantly

Your early-stage payments mostly go to charges, not investments

This means low actual gain so far

Coverage Adequacy Analysis

Sum assured totals Rs 1.5 crore

That may seem high, but market ULIPs often pay low returns

Term insurance offers higher cover at low cost

Example: You may get Rs 2–3 crore cover for less premium

ULIP cover might look big but gives weak real benefit

Should You Replace ULIPs with Term Insurance?

Term insurance gives pure risk cover only

For same cost, you can get significantly higher sum assured

Funds under ULIP are underperforming compared to active mutual funds

Term plans have no investment bias, only insurance

Investors often regret early ULIPs due to poor returns and lock-in

A term plan plus separate investing is more efficient

What You Could Do

Continue ULIPs only if surrender value is low

Consider surrender after complete understanding of charges

Use the freed premium to buy term insurance

Use separate investments via actively managed mutual funds

Health Insurance Review

Your Star Health policy covers Rs 3 lakh per year only

Family of four – that’s insufficient

Costs of hospitalisation, surgeries, daycare exceed this easily

Health inflation is typically 10%+ per year

This cover will exhaust quickly

You need at least Rs 10 lakh cover for each adult, Rs 5 lakh for kids

Add top-up or super-top-up cover for full peace of mind

Your Investment Strategy

You invest Rs 15–18K monthly via regular SIPs through advisor

That’s good disciplined investing

It shows long-term goal-building

But are these actively managed funds?

Regular plan via MFD with CFP support is better

You get advice, review, and rebalancing

Make sure these SIPs match your goals: education, retirement, contingency

The Pitfall of ULIP as Investment

ULIP returns are typically moderate, ~4–6%

They fall short against inflation and market-linked gains

Charges in early years eat returns

Surrender costs may reduce fund value

Lock-in period limits liquidity and flexibility

A mixed portfolio with active mutual funds gives better results

Mutual funds can deliver 10–14% returns over long term

Building the Right Insurance & Investment Mix

Let’s structure your finances smartly:

Insurance Cover

Term insurance for you and spouse with Rs 2–3 crore each

This is affordable and ensures financial security

Health Cover

Individual health insurance for family with at least Rs 10 lakh

Add a super-top-up of Rs 10–15 lakh for emergencies

ULIP Evaluation

Review performance and charges

Decide whether to continue or surrender

Consider switching to term + active investing

Savings & Goals

Continue SIPs, focus on actively managed funds

Educate children’s school & college needs

Build contingency/emergency fund amounting to 6–12 months expenses

Long-term Goals

Education fund for two girls

Retirement corpus for you and spouse

Use active funds, not index funds or ULIPs

Why Actively Managed Regular Funds Are Better

Fund managers actively buy and sell to optimize returns

They can exit underperforming sectors

They manage risk during volatile periods

Regular plans include expert guidance and rebalancing

They match your financial timeline and risk capacity

You avoid decision paralysis and behavioural mistakes

Why Not Index Funds or Direct Plans

Index funds mimic benchmarks—they don’t outperform them

Their downside protection is limited

They continue to hold weak sectors by design

Direct funds offer no support or advice

You may panic sell or buy wrong at the wrong time

CFP-backed guidance ensures discipline and clarity

Action Plan You Can Follow

Review ULIPs: charges, terms, lock-in, projected value

Calculate surrender value after 2 years payments

Compare alternative monthly premiums in term insurance

Buy a solid term plan and stronger health cover

Continue or reallocate your SIPs with CFP support

Build goal-wise separate funds for education and retirement

Keep track and revisit your financial plan every year

Final Insights

You’ve taken steps in insurance and investing—appreciate that

ULIPs are often costly and ineffective for growth

Term insurance plus actively managed funds offer clearer benefits

Health insurance needs to be strengthened

Your SIP investments are valuable if reviewed and aligned with goals

With CFP-backed planning, you can balance risk, liquidity, and returns

Gradual shifts now can build a solid foundation for your family's future

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Money
I am 45 and have a mf sip of about 35k per month. I have about 13 lac in equity and 24 lac in mf. About 20 lac in epf. Am I 30 pc income tax Slab. After the new tax regime, is it a good idea to invest in nps (14% of basic) or should I avoid and divert the amount to mf sip??
Ans: Understanding Your Current Financial Status

You are 45 years old and in the 30% tax slab.

Your mutual fund SIP is about Rs. 35,000 per month.

You have Rs. 13 lakh in equity and Rs. 24 lakh in mutual funds.

Your EPF balance is around Rs. 20 lakh.

You are considering investing 14% of basic in NPS.

You are evaluating if this is better than increasing SIP.

Let’s analyse both choices in detail.

Understanding NPS – Features and Benefits

NPS is a retirement-focused product regulated by the government.

It has a defined structure with auto and active choice options.

60% of the corpus is tax-free at retirement.

40% has to be used to buy an annuity.

Annuity income is taxable as per your slab.

There is a lock-in till age 60.

You cannot withdraw freely like mutual funds.

You can claim deduction under section 80CCD(2).

Employer contribution is not counted in your Rs. 1.5 lakh 80C limit.

It is over and above that and reduces your taxable income.

NPS returns vary based on equity-debt allocation.

On average, long-term returns range between 8% and 10%.

New Tax Regime – Implications for NPS

In the new tax regime, most exemptions and deductions are removed.

However, employer contribution to NPS under 80CCD(2) still continues.

You can claim up to 14% of basic (for central/state govt employees).

For private sector, the limit is 10% of basic.

So, tax-saving under new regime depends on employer contribution.

Your own voluntary contribution won’t give deduction under new regime.

If you shift fully to new tax regime, personal NPS becomes tax-ineffective.

Employer contribution remains beneficial in both regimes.

In short, NPS still works if employer contributes.

Comparing Mutual Fund SIP and NPS

Liquidity:

Mutual funds offer full liquidity after one year.

You can redeem in part or fully any time.

NPS is locked till 60 years of age.

Partial withdrawal is allowed in limited cases only.

Flexibility:

In mutual funds, you can choose scheme types.

You can pause, change, or switch SIPs anytime.

NPS allows some fund manager choice but is rigid overall.

Returns:

Mutual funds, when chosen rightly, give superior long-term returns.

They offer equity diversification with active management.

You already have SIPs, which shows your discipline.

SIPs in active mutual funds beat inflation and create wealth.

Taxation:

Equity mutual funds have updated rules:

LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%.

STCG taxed at 20%.

Debt mutual funds taxed as per income slab.

NPS corpus has partial tax exemption.

But annuity income post-retirement is taxed fully.

Mutual funds offer better tax efficiency in withdrawal phase.

Goal-Based Suitability:

NPS is only for retirement goal.

You cannot use it for education, marriage, or emergencies.

Mutual funds can be mapped to multiple goals.

They offer better alignment with personal priorities.

Should You Increase SIP Instead of NPS?

Yes, based on multiple reasons:

You already have EPF for retirement.

EPF and NPS both serve the same purpose.

Adding mutual funds brings diversification to your portfolio.

Your equity allocation right now is modest.

Increasing SIPs can enhance long-term wealth creation.

SIPs give control, flexibility, and goal alignment.

You are already disciplined with Rs. 35,000 SIP.
Increasing SIP further will give more compounding advantage.

Let’s explore how to use mutual funds in a more structured way.

Mutual Fund Strategy – From Here Onwards

Segment SIPs by goals – retirement, travel, child’s education.

Use actively managed funds for all allocations.

Avoid index funds. They just copy the market.

Index funds don’t offer downside protection.

Active funds give better performance in tough markets.

You need a fund manager who adds value.

Index funds cannot switch out of bad sectors.

Active funds have flexibility and research-based management.

Also, avoid direct funds.

Why Not to Invest in Direct Funds

Direct funds lack human guidance.

No one reviews your portfolio regularly.

You may skip rebalancing and lose potential.

Investors often stop SIPs during corrections.

Direct plans can result in behavioural mistakes.

Regular plans through MFD with CFP support you better.

You get portfolio tracking, switching suggestions, and tax support.

Peace of mind is more valuable than slightly lower expense ratio.

EPF + Mutual Funds + SIP = Smart Retirement Plan

Your EPF gives stability and guaranteed corpus.

Your mutual fund SIPs offer equity growth.

You don’t need NPS if EPF is already contributing 12%.

SIPs with EPF form a better duo than EPF + NPS.

SIPs give full access before and after retirement.

EPF is taxable on interest if it crosses Rs. 2.5 lakh per year contribution.

Yet it offers safe fixed income exposure.

Use EPF as a fixed return anchor.
Use mutual funds to beat inflation.

NPS – When to Consider It Seriously

You may consider NPS if:

You are in old tax regime and claim 80CCD(1B) deduction.

Employer contributes and it reduces tax for you.

You want a dedicated product for post-60 life.

You are not planning to retire before 60.

But if you are considering early retirement or flexible planning:

NPS will not help before 60.

You cannot withdraw bulk amount without tax impact.

You will be forced to take annuity which gives low return.

Mutual funds can give you Systematic Withdrawal flexibility.

360-Degree Wealth Management Tips for You

Continue SIPs regularly.

Increase SIP every year as income rises.

Don’t exit mutual funds due to market ups and downs.

Avoid adding too many funds. 4 to 5 are enough.

Have a written goal plan with timelines and amounts.

Use liquid funds or arbitrage funds for short-term goals.

Use hybrid funds for medium term needs.

Use equity mutual funds for long-term goals like retirement.

Avoid mixing investment and insurance.

Do not forget risk protection.

Risk Management – Don't Ignore

Check your term insurance cover.

Have a health insurance outside of employer.

Cover your family with adequate sum insured.

Protecting your income is more important than saving tax.

Mutual funds and EPF grow wealth.

Insurance protects wealth and lifestyle.

Role of a CFP-backed MFD

Helps you decide SIP amount based on your goals.

Reviews SIP performance every 6 to 12 months.

Recommends fund switches when needed.

Keeps you disciplined during market corrections.

Tracks tax rules and helps optimise redemptions.

A certified financial planner sees the full picture.

Finally

NPS has its benefits but is rigid and retirement-specific.

You already have EPF, so you are covered for retirement.

Mutual fund SIPs give higher growth, flexibility, and tax control.

Instead of increasing NPS, increase SIP with goal-based planning.

Avoid direct funds and index funds. Prefer active funds with regular plans.

Use a certified financial planner for guidance and tracking.

You are already doing well. Now take the next step towards financial freedom.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 19, 2025Hindi
Money
Reposting as it was not answered in 10 days Dear Tax expert, I am 63 & have a LIC Pension plus policy for which I paid Rs. 50k premium yearly for 10 yrs. Vesting date was 5 yrs back nearly & I have been receiving Rs. 26k yearly from then. If I discontinue the policy now & take the proceeds (around 3 lakhs), can u pls explain how its taxation will be? I had not claimed that 50k premium in 80C for all those yrs since my limit was exhausted by PPF only. The 26k I get yearly as quarterly annuity is shown by me as other income in ITR.
Ans: Understanding Your LIC Pension Plus Policy Structure

You paid Rs 50,000 premium yearly for 10 years.

You did not claim tax benefit under Section 80C.

So, tax exemption does not apply on contribution.

The policy vested 5 years back.

Since then, you are getting Rs 26,000 per year.

Now you want to discontinue and take around Rs 3 lakh.

Taxation on the Annuity Received (Rs 26,000 Yearly)

Annuity received from LIC is treated as income.

It is taxed as “Income from Other Sources”.

There is no exemption on annuity.

Even though you didn’t claim 80C, tax is still applicable.

You are showing annuity in ITR. That is correct.

Continue showing it every year till policy ends.

Taxation on Withdrawal of Balance Corpus (Rs 3 Lakhs)

LIC Pension Plus is a unit-linked pension plan.

ULPPs are taxed differently from ULIPs.

If you surrender after 5 years, you can withdraw fund value.

But full withdrawal is taxable.

Taxable as per your income tax slab.

No exemption under 10(10D) since it’s a pension policy.

Even though you didn’t claim 80C, that doesn't change taxation.

Why It Is Still Fully Taxable

LIC pension plan matures or is surrendered.

Payout is treated as pension income, not life insurance.

The corpus withdrawn is not tax-free.

Even if annuity had started, lump sum balance is taxable.

Tax is calculated on entire Rs 3 lakh corpus.

How to Report in ITR

Show Rs 3 lakh as income from other sources.

Mention it in schedule OS (other sources) of ITR.

Pay tax as per your slab.

No indexation or capital gain benefit applies here.

No deduction on original premium, as 80C not used.

So you don’t reduce your cost from the 3 lakh.

Can You Reduce Your Tax in Any Way?

Only if your total income is below Rs 3 lakh.

Senior citizen basic exemption is Rs 3 lakh.

Above that, tax applies at 5%, then 20%.

You can spread income if you have flexibility.

But for surrender, amount comes in one year.

What You Can Do with the Corpus Now

Avoid reinvesting in another LIC pension plan.

Don’t go for traditional endowment or ULIPs again.

Invest the Rs 3 lakh in mutual funds.

Use SWP to get income regularly.

This gives more tax efficiency.

Long-term capital gains on equity MF are taxed only above Rs 1.25 lakh at 12.5%.

You get better flexibility and liquidity.

Avoid Index and Direct Funds Going Forward

Index funds do not beat inflation consistently.

They give average returns, no downside protection.

Actively managed funds adapt to market changes.

Direct funds are for experts only.

No guidance or review is available.

You must invest via regular funds with a Certified Financial Planner.

This gives review, rebalancing, and long-term planning.

Avoid Annuity Products Again

Annuities give low returns.

They are fully taxable as income.

No flexibility once you start.

You lose control over your own money.

MF SWP is better alternative for retirees.

Gives better return and lower tax.

Check If You Hold Any Other Investment-cum-Insurance

If you have LIC endowment, ULIP or pension plans, review them.

Surrender them if returns are poor.

Reinvest into mutual funds or hybrid funds.

Get guidance from Certified Financial Planner.

Ensure your retirement money works hard for you.

Use the Proceeds for These Financial Goals

Maintain Rs 50,000–Rs 1 lakh in liquid funds.

Keep balance in hybrid mutual funds.

Start monthly SWP of Rs 2,000–Rs 2,500.

This gives regular income and preserves capital.

Add nominee and maintain updated records.

Review portfolio every year with your spouse.

Tax Filing Guidance for Senior Citizens

Use ITR 1 if pension and interest income only.

If mutual funds are sold, use ITR 2.

Show annuity as “Other Income”.

Show surrender value as income in same head.

Keep documents like policy copy, surrender letter, bank credit proof.

Retain for 6 years for tax safety.

Final Insights

You did right by not claiming 80C if PPF limit was exhausted.

But taxation still applies on annuity and withdrawal.

LIC pension plans do not give tax-free maturity.

Surrender amount is fully taxable under your slab.

Reinvest this wisely in mutual funds now.

Avoid annuities, index funds, and direct plans.

Use Certified Financial Planner to guide future income planning.

Maintain simplicity, tax efficiency, and flexibility in retirement.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 21, 2025Hindi
Money
I have opted pension plan, which is with SBI smart retirement plus also with PNB MetLife - how far reliable these retirement plans
Ans: Evaluating Your Pension Plans with SBI & PNB MetLife

You have taken pension plans through SBI and PNB MetLife. That shows foresight and discipline. Choosing pensions for retirement is smart. Now let’s examine how effective these are.

Investment-Linked Insurance Products vs Pure Savings

Pension plans from banks or insurers combine insurance and investment.

Premiums are split between risk cover and investment component.

This means part of your money goes into insurance, not investments.

As a result, returns from these plans are often modest.

They may offer guaranteed annuity rates or bonuses.

But these returns rarely match inflation or market growth.

They often have high charges: fund management fees, mortality charges, admin costs, surrender penalties.

That reduces net return significantly.

Insurance-driven investment packages can lag behind mutual funds.

Liquidity and Flexibility Issues

Pension plans often tie your money for long terms (10–15+ years).

Withdrawals before maturity may reduce benefits.

Surrender penalties and fees may apply early.

You may lose bonuses if you withdraw early.

There is limited flexibility to shift your fund allocation commonly.

Mutual funds offer greater ease with liquidity and switching options.

Tax Treatment at Exit

Pension plans give you annuity income after maturity.

Annuity payments are taxable as per your slab each year.

There's no tax-free lump sum except a small percent.

Returns get further eroded as you pay tax later.

If you switch to mutual funds, growth is taxed as LTCG or STCG at exit.

But LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%.

While taxable, MF offers more flexibility in planning.

Comparing to Actively Managed Mutual Funds (Regular Plans)

Regular mutual funds include advisory via an MFD with CFP credentials.

They help with fund selection, rebalancing, asset allocation, risk management.

Active funds aim to beat the market.

These funds have fund managers adapting to macro trends.

Your money stays within transparent, low-cost, flexible structure.

SIPs can begin with small monthly amounts.

Example Benefits:

Better returns over long term

Lower charges with transparency

Full liquidity anytime

Portfolio adjusted for changing life goals

Where Pension Plans May Make Sense

Some folks prefer guaranteed income

In case you don’t have a major corpus to manage

Or you dislike managing investments yourself

But these feel more like forced saving

They offer limited growth for your money

Steps to Reassess These Plans Thoroughly

Get Your Policy Booklets

Check premium amounts, fund value, and maturity value estimates.

Understand fund allocation and historical returns.

Check Charges and Penalties

Look out for mortality charges, fund management fees, administration charges.

Check surrender penalties if you leave early.

Calculate Real Expected Returns

Based on current fund value and future projections minus returns.

Compare to mutual fund performance (actively managed, growth-oriented).

Analyse Liquidity and Flexibility

Can you withdraw partial amounts?

Can you alter future premiums or fund allocation?

Tax Implications

Know how withdrawals and annuities will be taxed

Compare with MF withdrawal LTCG/STCG taxation

What to Do Next – Your Action Plan

Continue if you want guaranteed annuity

But keep the amount moderate

Ensure flexibility to invest outside also

Or consider partially exiting

Surrender one plan if funds are depressed

Keep short-term plan or small premium plan

Use the freed-up money

Start SIPs in actively managed regular mutual funds

Choose diversified multi-cap, mid-cap, or hybrid equity funds

Leverage advice from MFD + CFP

Focus on retirement corpus

Aim for desired post-retirement monthly income needs

Use SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan) from MFs in retirement phase

Protect with Health, Life Insurance

Keep adequate term cover for emergencies

Include health cover for longevity

Review annually

Check fund performance

Rebalance asset allocation regularly

Adjust SIP amounts with inflation and market shifts

Why Avoid Index or Direct Plans

You asked about reliability. Let me underline two pitfalls:

Index funds only mirror the index. They do not protect in downturns. They lock you into all index stocks regardless of quality. In contrast, active funds can shift away from weak sectors.

Direct mutual funds offer no advisory support. You may not rebalance or switch when needed. You may panic and exit during corrections. An MFD backed by a CFP will guide systematically based on goals.

Building Stronger Retirement Planning

Retirement savings require flexibility, growth, and inflation-fight.

Insurance-based pension plans give stability but often lower returns.

Supplemental savings via mutual funds can help close the gap.

Use actively managed regular plans for wealth building.

Make decisions with a long-term view, adjusting as needed.

Combine disciplined savings, protection, and guided investing.

Finally

You’ve made good efforts by choosing pension plans through banks/insurers. That is commendable. But consider their limitations in return, flexibility, and costs. If your goal is solid retirement income and corpus, you should review their terms and consider reallocating some funds to actively managed mutual funds through a Certified Financial Planner and MFD.

Balancing guaranteed income with growth assets gives your portfolio stability and future growth. Be wise, stay flexible, and plan with purpose.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9339 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 03, 2025

Money
Hi expert ..I have 4 lic policy since last 7 years and paying 4.2K per month..now I am trying to stop and looking start sip in the same amount...so what's your advice...
Ans: Understanding Your Current LIC Policies

You have been paying Rs. 4,200 per month for 4 LIC policies.

These are investment-cum-insurance policies.

Most such policies offer low returns of 4% to 5% p.a.

They also come with long lock-in periods and low transparency.

Insurance is often bundled with investment in such plans.

This combination does not work well for long-term wealth creation.

Since you've been paying for 7 years, policy surrender may be viable now.

You must check surrender value for each policy before taking a step.

Ask your LIC agent or visit the branch to get this surrender value.

If the value is acceptable, you can consider surrendering and reinvesting.

Ensure no policy is term insurance. Only surrender investment-linked ones.

Do not discontinue policies that are pure term insurance.

Why Investment-Cum-Insurance Is Not Efficient

Returns are often lower than inflation-adjusted growth.

You remain underinsured in most such policies.

You get neither enough insurance nor enough return.

You lose out on compounding benefits of equity investments.

Lock-ins make liquidity difficult when you need funds.

Bonus and loyalty additions are neither guaranteed nor high.

What You Can Do Instead

Separate insurance and investments.

Take a term insurance plan of adequate cover.

For investment, consider equity mutual funds for long-term growth.

You can start with Rs. 4,200 per month as SIP.

This disciplined habit can create a large corpus in long run.

Over time, increase SIP amount as income increases.

Why Mutual Funds Are Better Option for Growth

Mutual funds offer better long-term returns than LIC plans.

You can start with small amounts like Rs. 500 or Rs. 1,000 per scheme.

You get professional fund management for your investment.

Funds are regulated, diversified and transparent.

You can invest through MFDs who are trained and certified.

Look for MFDs who also hold CFP credentials.

They offer ongoing guidance, reviews, and rebalancing.

Why You Must Choose Regular Plans Over Direct Plans

Direct plans lack personal advisory support.

No one helps you review your funds periodically.

Mistakes go unnoticed for long periods.

Switching or stopping is often delayed due to inaction.

Regular plans through CFP/MFDs provide handholding.

You gain behavioural coaching during market ups and downs.

They align investments with your goals.

Direct plans may seem cheaper but costlier in long run due to poor choices.

Avoid being penny-wise and rupee-foolish.

Why Actively Managed Funds Are Better Than Index Funds

Index funds mirror the market; they don’t beat it.

No chance of alpha or extra returns in index funds.

In falling markets, index funds fall as much as the market.

No downside protection in index investing.

Index funds may have low cost, but cost alone doesn’t build wealth.

Actively managed funds use research to select better performing stocks.

They can underweight poor sectors and overweight better ones.

This gives you better returns over long periods.

A competent fund manager backed by a research team adds value.

Choose active funds through a CFP-guided MFD.

Taxation of Mutual Funds

Mutual funds now have updated tax rules from FY 2024-25.

For equity funds:

LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakhs taxed at 12.5%.

STCG taxed at 20%.

For debt funds:

Both STCG and LTCG taxed as per your slab.

Capital gains taxed only on redemption, not during investment.

SIPs give you tax efficiency with compounding.

Things to Consider Before Surrendering LIC Policies

Check surrender value and whether loan has been taken on policies.

Ensure no loan is pending before surrender.

Ask for written calculation of surrender benefits.

Be prepared for possible surrender charges.

Some policies give loyalty additions only after 10 years or more.

Evaluate whether waiting longer gives more benefit or not.

Consult with a CFP-backed MFD before taking final call.

Review policies one-by-one, not all together.

Create an action plan with dates and steps.

Ideal Way to Build Wealth with Mutual Funds

Invest based on your goals: retirement, child education, etc.

Have a mix of large-cap, mid-cap, and hybrid funds.

Start with goal mapping with a certified financial planner.

Align SIPs with time horizon and risk capacity.

Avoid investing based on past returns alone.

Rebalance portfolio every year to control risk.

Keep SIP going even in market corrections.

That is when wealth-building actually happens.

Insurance Planning Separately

You should not ignore risk management while investing.

Check your life insurance needs first.

Take a term plan based on your income and responsibilities.

Ensure your family is financially protected in your absence.

Keep this insurance separate from your mutual funds.

Don’t bundle investment with insurance again.

Liquidity and Emergency Planning

LIC policies are illiquid. They lock your funds for decades.

Mutual funds give better liquidity.

You can pause or stop SIPs in emergencies.

You can redeem units partly as needed.

Maintain an emergency fund for 6 months of expenses.

Keep this in a liquid mutual fund or savings account.

Avoid using SIP money for short-term needs.

Role of MFDs with CFP Credential

They understand goal-based planning.

They help you map your life goals and match investments.

They handhold during market volatility and tough times.

You get unbiased advice with financial discipline.

Regular reviews help stay on track.

They protect you from emotional decisions and wrong choices.

Behavioural Advantages of Guided Investing

People often stop SIPs in market corrections.

Guided investing avoids panic-based decisions.

A disciplined investor stays for long term and wins.

Emotion is the biggest enemy of returns.

Certified financial planners help maintain focus and consistency.

Action Plan for You

Step 1: Identify which LIC policies are investment-linked.

Step 2: Get their surrender value in writing.

Step 3: Review with a CFP-backed mutual fund distributor.

Step 4: Surrender one policy at a time, if needed.

Step 5: Start SIPs in selected mutual fund schemes.

Step 6: Invest Rs. 4,200 per month for now.

Step 7: Increase SIP amount gradually every year.

Step 8: Track and review once a year with expert help.

Financial Goals You Can Plan With SIP

Retirement corpus for comfortable future.

Children’s higher education or marriage.

Building down payment for a future home.

Creating a travel or lifestyle fund.

Becoming financially independent earlier.

Mistakes to Avoid

Surrendering without understanding surrender value loss.

Repeating the same mistake of investment-cum-insurance.

Investing in direct plans without guidance.

Chasing past returns while selecting funds.

Having too many funds without purpose.

Avoiding equity due to fear of volatility.

Finally

You have taken a smart decision by evaluating your LIC policies.

Rs. 4,200 per month, when invested wisely, can grow significantly.

Mutual funds offer flexibility, growth, and diversification.

Invest through a certified financial planner with MFD license.

Avoid investing directly without guidance.

Keep your insurance and investments separate.

Reassess your financial goals and create a roadmap.

Follow that roadmap with discipline and guidance.

Wealth creation is a journey. It needs right tools and guidance.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x