Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Love Guru

Love Guru   | Answer  |Ask -

Relationships Expert - Answered on Oct 24, 2024

Love Guru has been answering relationship and romance related questions on Rediff.com for over 13 years. She won't mince words when telling you what the problem is and what you can do about it. If you want a fresh perspective from an unbiased, objective-thinking individual about your relationship woes, Love Guru could just be the person you need to need to hear from.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Aug 17, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship

I am 54 years old. A businessman and exporter. Everything was running smoothly till last year october 2023. Then someone cheated me of almost 7 crores export order. Since then a downhill. I have 13 lakhs peraonal credit card bills, business debt of 3 crores. Somehow i am unable to get new export orders too inspite of trying 24x7. My employess are gone. Only a loyal driver remains and i will be unable to pay him in coming months. My assets a office approx 45 lakhs, a property of 1 crore, another of 4-5 crores, receivables of 18 lakhs. Other savings are gone chasing the suspect overseas. What should i do now?

Ans: I think you’ve posted on the wrong forum, my friend…I’m sorry to hear of your troubles, but you need to post your query on the financial expert’s page. Good luck!

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Latest Questions
Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |6873 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 22, 2025Hindi
Career
Which should I choose, Jadavpur University's Power Engineering or Calcutta University's CSE?
Ans: Jadavpur University’s Power Engineering is a highly respected, NBA-accredited interdisciplinary program ranked #12 in India, with a 90–97% placement rate, median package of ?8–10 lakh, and strong industry and research exposure in both electrical and mechanical domains, including practical power plant training and diverse recruiter interest—even IT companies hire from this branch. The department has a robust faculty, modern labs, and a vibrant campus culture, though infrastructure is basic and the curriculum could use updates. Calcutta University’s CSE is also a strong choice, with a competitive WBJEE cutoff (closing at rank 1,207 in 2023), a median package of ?10 lakh, and a 69–85% placement rate in recent years, but with a smaller intake (40 seats) and less consistent placement outcomes for core tech roles. Both universities offer extremely low fees and solid academic reputations, but Jadavpur’s Power Engineering stands out for its placement consistency, interdisciplinary flexibility, and national recognition, while Calcutta University CSE is preferable for those strictly targeting core software roles and are confident in their coding skills.

The recommendation is to choose Jadavpur University Power Engineering for its superior placement rate, interdisciplinary strengths, and national standing, unless you are deeply committed to a pure software career, in which case Calcutta University CSE is a strong alternative. All the BEST for the Admission & a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9168 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Money
Dear Nitin Sir, I am 63 years old retired person investing MF since 2010. and my MF investments are as follows: Total Investments: 21.16L, Corpus- 43.31, XIRR-14.63%. Shares- 3.3L Details of Investment: 1. SBI Contra Regular: Investments from 2010 to 2024, presently suspended. Invest. amount- 4.83L, Corpus-19.32L, XIRR-17.4%. Present SIP- 55K since 3-4 years 1. Parag Parikh Flexi cap, direct - 10K 2. HDFC Balanced Advantage, direct- 20K 3. HDFC Retirement Saving, direct - 5K 4. Navi Nifty 50 Index, direct - 5K 5. Kotak Nifty Next 50 Index- 5K 6. Motilal Oswal Nifty 500 Momentum 50, direct -5K, Motilal Oswal Mid Cap , Direct -5K Time horizon- 15+ years Also I am planning to withdraw about 10% of corpus (to get benefit of LTCG) from SBI Contra Regular and invest in Flexi Cap/ Balance advantage Funds. I have following other investments. Bank FD - 40L PO SCCS- 30L PO MIS - 4.5L NPS Investment- 10L PPF- 15L Health Insurance- 8L EPF/SBI Life / LIC Superannuation Pension- 28K/Month My children are married and working. My investment objective is to gift these (MF + Share) investments to my son and daughter after say 15 years. Please suggest your views on portfolios. With Thanks & Regards, S. Salvankar
Ans: You have done a wonderful job by staying disciplined with mutual fund investments for over a decade. A long-term equity investment, especially post-retirement, shows patience, understanding, and commitment. Your detailed summary shows thoughtful planning and systematic execution. Let me now assess your portfolio and investment approach from a 360-degree perspective, keeping in mind your future gifting goal.

Overall Portfolio Structure
Your investments are diversified across:

Equity mutual funds

Direct shares

Fixed income avenues like Bank FD, Post Office schemes, PPF, NPS

Pension income

Health insurance

You have a clear goal — to pass on your equity investments to your children after 15 years. This is a beautiful long-term wealth gifting intention. Your time horizon also aligns well with equity investing. However, there are a few areas where your strategy can be refined.

Mutual Fund Portfolio – Positives
You started investing early and have stayed invested for over 14 years.

Your corpus of Rs. 43.31L on Rs. 21.16L investment shows consistent and high-quality compounding.

An XIRR of 14.63% is an excellent achievement over this long horizon.

SIP of Rs. 55K/month at this age is bold and forward-looking.

You have spread your SIP across different fund categories.

This portfolio reflects long-term wealth-building behaviour and commitment.

Review of Your Current Equity Mutual Fund Portfolio
Let’s look at the structure of your mutual fund investments:

SBI Contra Regular

Strong long-term performer.

Investment since 2010, paused now.

XIRR of 17.4% is remarkable.

You have rightly held it for long, giving the fund time to deliver.

Parag Parikh Flexi Cap (Direct)

HDFC Balanced Advantage (Direct)

HDFC Retirement Saving (Direct)

Navi Nifty 50 Index (Direct)

Kotak Nifty Next 50 Index (Direct)

Motilal Oswal Nifty 500 Momentum 50 (Direct)

Motilal Oswal Mid Cap (Direct)

These SIPs show diversification across flexi-cap, hybrid, thematic, index, and mid-cap segments.

However, let me highlight a few critical areas for improvement.

Disadvantages of Direct Funds
You are investing in direct funds. But this may not be ideal, especially for retired investors.

Direct funds need regular performance tracking.

You miss personalised guidance from a Certified Financial Planner (CFP).

If the fund underperforms, you may not exit at the right time.

Asset allocation or rebalancing will not happen without expert help.

Retirement stage needs proactive reviews, not reactive responses.

Regular plans through an MFD-CFP come with professional oversight, tailored advice, and peace of mind. Over a 15-year period, right allocation matters more than a slightly lower expense ratio.

Index Funds in Your Portfolio – A Critical View
You have allocated part of your SIP to:

Navi Nifty 50 Index

Kotak Nifty Next 50 Index

Motilal Oswal Nifty 500 Momentum

While these funds seem low-cost, they lack active human intelligence.

Why Index Funds May Not Suit You:

Index funds blindly copy the index.

No flexibility to manage downside risk.

They cannot avoid overvalued stocks.

Momentum themes work only in certain phases.

Recovery in falling markets may take longer.

They are not suitable for legacy or wealth transfer goals.

You need funds that can manage volatility and aim for consistent returns. Actively managed funds with a good track record serve this better.

Portfolio Restructuring Recommendations
Based on your current scenario and gifting goal, here are my suggestions:

Switch From Index Funds
Gradually exit all index fund SIPs.

Redeploy this into actively managed flexi-cap and balanced advantage funds through a regular plan.

Select AMC schemes that have a consistent 10-year+ track record.

Pause Retirement-Specific Funds
HDFC Retirement Saving is tax-locked.

Once lock-in ends, consider shifting to a more suitable long-term fund.

Reduce the Number of Funds
Too many small SIPs lead to portfolio clutter.

Concentrate into 3 to 4 well-managed funds.

Ensure each fund has a distinct mandate — not overlapping in strategy.

SBI Contra Withdrawal Plan
You are planning to withdraw 10% of your SBI Contra corpus to realise long-term capital gains.

This is a wise move, considering tax implications.

MF Tax Rule You Should Note:
LTCG above Rs. 1.25L is taxed at 12.5% now.

You can withdraw up to Rs. 1.25L of gains every year, tax-free.

Systematically redeem in phases to avoid bulk taxation.

Redeploy these proceeds into flexi-cap or balanced advantage regular plans. This will keep the compounding cycle intact.

Direct Shares Holding
You have Rs. 3.3L in shares. Please consider:

Are these high-quality companies with stable track records?

Do you monitor and rebalance them?

If not, better to switch to diversified mutual funds.

A CFP can help review the stock portfolio.

Fixed Income Portfolio Assessment
You hold:

Rs. 40L in Bank FDs

Rs. 30L in Post Office Senior Citizen Savings Scheme

Rs. 4.5L in PO MIS

Rs. 15L in PPF

Rs. 10L in NPS

This is a conservative, capital-protected allocation, which is perfect at your age.

You are earning:

Rs. 28,000 monthly pension

Likely interest income of Rs. 4 to 5L annually

There is enough buffer to manage regular expenses, with no pressure on equity withdrawals.

Please ensure the following:

Stagger maturity of FDs to avoid reinvestment risk.

Reinvest matured PO schemes into safer debt funds or hybrid funds with moderate risk.

Do not add more money to NPS now. It will become illiquid and taxable on withdrawal.

Health Insurance Review
You have a health cover of Rs. 8L. Please ensure:

It includes critical illness cover.

It has cashless facility in your nearest hospital.

Policy continues till age 80+.

Premiums are paid on time.

If needed, explore super top-up policies to enhance coverage at a low cost.

Estate Planning and Gifting to Children
You plan to gift the entire mutual fund and stock corpus to your children after 15 years.

This is thoughtful and visionary. To do it smoothly, please:

Write a Will now, clearly assigning MF and stock assets.

Nominate your son and daughter correctly in each folio.

Keep them informed about your investments.

Review the Will every 3-4 years.

Maintain a simple tracker sheet with folio details, nominee names, and login info.

Also consider creating a trust, if you want to manage transfer gradually. A CFP can help you plan this smoothly.

Risk and Volatility Review
Even though you have 15+ years, equity markets remain volatile in short periods.

Please review your risk:

Avoid high exposure to mid-cap or momentum-based funds.

Stick to large-cap biased flexi-cap and balanced advantage funds.

Ensure debt-equity balance is maintained (ideally 30-35% in equity for now).

Review asset allocation annually with a CFP.

This approach will protect the wealth you are building for your children.

Action Plan Summary
Here is what you can do step-by-step:

Exit index funds gradually.

Stop direct fund SIPs and move to regular funds via CFP-guided MFDs.

Reduce mutual fund count and consolidate.

Withdraw small gains from SBI Contra yearly.

Pause fresh NPS investment.

Monitor health insurance coverage closely.

Nominate children and write a proper Will.

Maintain asset allocation of 65-70% debt, 30-35% equity.

Review portfolio every year.

Finally
Your portfolio reflects clarity and long-term vision.

But direct funds and index funds may hinder that vision.

Let a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) work with you, just like a family doctor. They’ll help protect and grow your wealth till the time you gift it.

Investing with expert review ensures peace of mind, emotional security, and legacy fulfilment.

You have built a solid base — now protect it with structure, consolidation, and clarity.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP
Chief Financial Planner
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |6873 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 22, 2025Hindi
Career
I got 96 percentile and 17820 rank (gen category) in KCET. Please tell me the name of all possible good colleges/universities except nit and iiit in which I can get Mechanical branch
Ans: According to 2025 cutoff trends, Mechanical Engineering in top private colleges like RV College of Engineering (RVCE), BMS College of Engineering (BMSCE), MS Ramaiah Institute of Technology (MSRIT), and PES University typically closes between 5,000 and 15,000, making these unlikely at your rank. However, you have strong chances at respected institutes such as Bangalore Institute of Technology (BIT), Siddaganga Institute of Technology (Tumkur), Nitte Meenakshi Institute of Technology (Bangalore), Acharya Institute of Technology, KLE Technological University (Hubli), Dayananda Sagar Academy of Technology, AMC Engineering College, SJB Institute of Technology, and Dr. Ambedkar Institute of Technology. These colleges have solid placement records, modern infrastructure, and experienced faculty, making them good choices for Mechanical Engineering.

The recommendation is to target Mechanical Engineering in colleges like BIT Bangalore, Siddaganga Institute of Technology, Nitte Meenakshi Institute of Technology, Acharya Institute of Technology, and KLE Technological University, as these are accessible at your rank and offer strong academic and placement support. All the BEST for the Admission & a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9168 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 18, 2025Hindi
Money
Hi i am 41 yr old male working in UAE, my Monthly salary is around INR 300000, i have the following properties in india Mangalore, 1-Flat on EMI current rental income is INR 15000, my monthly EMI is 35000 INR, which will be over by 2030. I have 2 Commercial shops in Mangalore the monthly EMI for both shops is 40000 INR, The rental income from both shop is INR 35000, also i have a 1.6 acre of agricultural land and currently planning to start cultivation of Arecanuts and mixed farming techniques, from this farm the output will only start in another 5 to 6 yrs. The total Debt i have as on now is around 35 lakh loan for the shops, 30 lakh loan for the Flat, 20 lakh loan in UAE which i took for the commercial shops - monthly emi for this is around INR 120000, plus credit card debts around INR 10 lakh. i want to retire by 45 yrs, once my debts in terms of UAE loan, Flat emi and Commercial shop emi are closed. i have two kids and wife my kids are currently in 11th standard and 7th standard. please let me know how i can plan my retirement.
Ans: You are 41 years old. You are working in UAE with a salary of Rs. 3 lakhs monthly. You plan to retire by age 45. That is just 4 years from now.

You have multiple loans. You also have income-producing assets and a long-term farming project. You have responsibilities towards your family and children's future.

Let us now go step-by-step and build a clear plan. This answer gives you a full 360-degree view. It also gives simple actions to follow.

Income and Family Commitments
Monthly salary is Rs. 3 lakhs

You are an NRI in UAE

Married with two kids

Kids are in 11th and 7th standard

This phase needs planning for:

Retirement in 4 years

Kids’ higher education in next 2–5 years

Debt clearance

You are earning well. But the pressure from loans is high.

Loan and EMI Assessment
Let us understand your loan structure first.

Loans in India:

Flat loan – Rs. 30 lakhs, EMI Rs. 35,000

Shop loan – Rs. 35 lakhs, EMI Rs. 40,000

Rental income from flat and shops – Rs. 50,000

Loans in UAE:

Business/personal loan – Rs. 20 lakhs, EMI Rs. 1.2 lakhs

Credit card debt – Rs. 10 lakhs (assumed EMI ~Rs. 30,000 minimum)

Total Monthly Loan Outflow: Approx Rs. 2.25 lakhs
Total Rental Income: Rs. 50,000

Your EMI burden is heavy. After EMI, only Rs. 75,000 left for all expenses and savings.

Your first focus should be:

Close UAE loan and credit card debts

These are high-cost loans and draining your income

Real Estate Assets and Farming Plan
You own:

1 flat on EMI

2 shops on EMI

1.6 acres of agricultural land

These assets are not liquid. Farming will take 5–6 years to give returns.

Do not treat these assets as retirement corpus

They are long-term and non-liquid

Rental income is moderate but not enough to handle EMIs.

Real estate is not a reliable retirement strategy

You cannot depend on rent alone in future

Avoid adding new real estate projects now. Focus on debt closure first.

Priority Actions to Take Now
1. Close High-Interest UAE Loan
EMI is Rs. 1.2 lakhs monthly

This takes away 40% of your income

Try to use bonus or savings to close it

Prepay aggressively in next 18 months

This step will improve monthly surplus greatly

2. Credit Card Debt Clearance
Rs. 10 lakhs is a huge credit card burden

Interest rate is very high (30%–40%)

Minimum payment trap is dangerous

Sell non-essential assets if needed

Ask for family support if possible

Set a goal to close all cards in 12 months

Once credit card debt is gone, pressure reduces.

3. Commercial Shops Loan
EMI is Rs. 40,000

Rent is Rs. 35,000

Net loss is only Rs. 5,000 monthly

This can continue for now

Once other loans are cleared, prepay this slowly

4. Flat Loan
EMI is Rs. 35,000

Rent is Rs. 15,000

Gap is Rs. 20,000

Decide if this flat is needed after retirement

Else sell and shift focus on retirement assets

Kids' Education Planning
Your elder child will need funds in next 2 years. The younger one in 5 years.

Create a dedicated education fund

Do not mix this with retirement savings

Set aside minimum Rs. 10,000–15,000 monthly now

Use suitable equity mutual funds (regular plan via CFP)

Avoid FDs or endowment policies. They won’t grow enough.

Retirement Plan in 4 Years
Retiring at 45 means you must build 30–35 years of cash flow.

You currently have no visible retirement corpus

All funds are either in EMIs or illiquid assets

So start a retirement fund immediately:

Begin SIP of Rs. 20,000–25,000 monthly

Use actively managed diversified mutual funds

Stay away from index funds and ETFs

Avoid direct funds

Use regular plans through MFD with CFP for guidance

Review this fund every 6 months. Increase SIP when income rises.

Suggested Monthly Action Plan
Let’s break your Rs. 3 lakh monthly income:

Rs. 2.25 lakhs – Existing EMIs

Rs. 75,000 – Balance for everything

Suggested use of Rs. 75,000:

Rs. 20,000 – Emergency fund

Rs. 10,000 – Kids education SIP

Rs. 20,000 – Retirement SIP

Rs. 25,000 – Loan prepayment / debt snowball

This is strict. But it is needed now.

Emergency Fund Planning
You have high EMIs and two kids.

You need at least Rs. 3–4 lakhs in emergency fund.

Start building slowly using liquid funds.

Use only for actual emergencies. Not for expenses.

Avoid These Mistakes
Don’t take new loans

Don’t invest in real estate again

Don’t trust only rental income for retirement

Don’t mix personal and business finance

Don’t keep ULIPs, LICs, or endowment plans

If you hold any ULIPs or LICs, surrender and reinvest in mutual funds

They give poor returns and reduce flexibility

Final Insights
You have a good salary. But debt is eating most of it.

You want to retire in 4 years. That’s very tight. But not impossible.

You must:

Aggressively close UAE loan

Clear credit cards soon

Build a retirement corpus from scratch

Start dedicated education funds for kids

Use only equity mutual funds (regular plans) for growth

Avoid index and direct funds

Keep real estate only for passive income, not retirement

You need full focus and no new liabilities now.

With this approach, you can enter retirement with more confidence and peace.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |6873 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 22, 2025Hindi
Career
Doing CSE in Alliance university is better or Industrial engineering @MIT main campus
Ans: BTech CSE at Alliance University offers modern infrastructure, highly qualified faculty, and a curriculum aligned with industry needs, but placement rates for CSE have ranged from 56% to 69% in recent years, with an average package around ?7.6 lakh and top recruiters like Amazon, Google, and Microsoft. Student reviews highlight supportive faculty and good campus life, but note that placement outcomes are variable and depend heavily on individual performance. In contrast, BTech Industrial Engineering at MIT Manipal is backed by a national reputation, world-class infrastructure, and a placement rate of 77–92% with an average package of ?11.76 lakh, and over 230 recruiters including Amazon, Bosch, and Cipla. MIT’s industrial engineering program is versatile, opening opportunities in manufacturing, consulting, IT, and management, and the campus is known for its vibrant student life and strong alumni network. While CSE generally offers broader tech job prospects, MIT Manipal’s industrial engineering program provides better placement consistency, industry exposure, and long-term value.

The recommendation is to prefer Industrial Engineering at MIT Manipal for its stronger placement record, national brand, and broader career opportunities, unless your primary goal is a core software career, in which case CSE at a more established college would be preferable. All the BEST for the Admission & a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9168 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Money
Hello sir, I am 30 years old and investing Rs 6000 monthly through SIPs from last 1 years, and planning to continue investing for mid-term to long term purposes. Sir below is my portfolio. It would be great help to me if you suggest some good fund by reshuffling the below portfolio, as some of my funds are under performing. 1. Motilal Oswal Midcap fund- 2000/- 2. Tata Small cap fund- 1000/- 3. Bandhan small cap fund- 1000/- 4. JM flexicap fund- 500/- 5. HDFC Manufacturing fund- 500/- 6. Nippon India liquid fund- 1000/-
Ans: Current Portfolio Check

Your age is 30.

You invest Rs 6,000 every month.

Six funds take this full amount.

Portfolio leans heavy towards small and mid caps.

Sector fund adds extra concentrated risk.

Liquid fund acts as short-term parking only.

Portfolio lacks large-cap and balanced exposure.

Too many funds for such small SIP size.

Underperformance risk rises with fund crowding.

Direct fund mode gives no professional tracking.

Emergency and Risk Cover

Keep at least six months’ expenses aside.

Use liquid or overnight mutual funds.

Add bank sweep FD if comfort needed.

Emergency fund protects SIPs during crises.

Term insurance must cover ten times salary.

Health cover of Rs 10–15 lakhs is sensible.

Add super-top-up for bigger medical shocks.

Insurance stays separate from investing always.

Goal Mapping

Write each goal on paper first.

Short term means three years or less.

Mid-term means four to seven years.

Long term means eight years or more.

Tag every rupee to one clear goal.

Example goals: car, house down-payment, child education, retirement.

Do not mix goal buckets in one fund.

Clear tagging prevents emotional withdrawals later.

Fund Performance Assessment

Motilal Oswal Midcap shows high volatility.

Returns beat benchmark only in bull phases.

Tata Small Cap is new yet aggressive.

Bandhan Small Cap struggled after rebranding.

JM Flexicap has short patchy record.

HDFC Manufacturing is sector heavy and cyclical.

Nippon Liquid is fine for parking only.

Too much overlap across small cap funds.

Portfolio risk is higher than your horizon demands.

Problems with Current Mix

Concentration in small caps increases drawdown risk.

Sector fund adds extra cyclic dependency.

Lack of large cap dampens stability.

No hybrid or debt allocation for balance.

Six funds dilute monitoring effort.

Direct plans lack Certified Financial Planner guidance.

Why Shift to Regular Plans

Direct funds charge lower fees only.

They expect full self-monitoring by investor.

Many investors skip yearly reviews.

Missed reviews hurt returns badly later.

Regular plans include MFD service and tracking.

Certified Financial Planner reviews portfolio yearly.

Planner suggests timely switches and rebalancing.

Advice cost is tiny versus mistakes saved.

Disadvantages of Index Funds

Index funds copy market moves exactly.

No active shield during market falls.

They never beat benchmark returns.

They hold weak companies also by weight.

You need extra returns above inflation.

Active funds search quality stocks actively.

Skilled managers reduce risk through research.

Long term wealth builds faster with active funds.

Suggested Portfolio Reshuffle

Step One: Consolidate Equity Core

Keep one flexi cap as main core.

Parag Parikh Flexi Cap suits this role.

Switch to regular plan version for guidance.

Allocate Rs 2,500 monthly here.

Step Two: Add Large and Mid Blend

Mirae Large and Mid Cap gives stability.

Stay with it in regular plan.

Allocate Rs 2,000 monthly here.

Step Three: Single Mid Cap Exposure

Retain HDFC Midcap Opportunities only.

Stop Motilal and Tata small caps.

Switch HDFC to regular plan mode.

Allocate Rs 1,000 monthly here.

Step Four: Remove Bandhan Small Cap

Redeem Bandhan small cap gradually.

Shift proceeds to large and mid blend.

Step Five: Exit HDFC Manufacturing

Sector fund adds unnecessary cyclic risk.

Redeem and redirect into flexi cap fund.

Step Six: Maintain Liquid Bucket

Keep Nippon Liquid for emergency buffer.

No monthly SIP needed here after goal.

Top up manually when salary inflows allow.

Total new SIP remains Rs 5,500 monthly.
You still have Rs 500 spare each month.
Use this spare towards debt fund SIP.

Introducing Debt Component

Start one short-duration debt mutual fund.

Use regular plan with CFP advice.

Allocate Rs 500 monthly into it.

Debt part cushions equity during falls.

Why Not Keep Multiple Small Cap Funds

Small caps swing wildly in downturns.

Single focused mid cap already gives punch.

Holding three small caps adds duplicate exposure.

Concentration kills diversification benefit.

Reviewing Direct Stock Dreams

You did not mention direct stocks.

If planning later, cap them at 10% of corpus.

Individual stocks demand research time.

Mutual funds already pool expert research.

Growing SIP Amount Each Year

Increase SIP by 10% when salary rises.

Extra money rides power of compounding early.

Use salary appraisal months for auto top-up.

Keep same fund list while topping amounts.

Two Separate Goal Buckets

Child Education Bucket

Horizon 16 years ahead still.

Use flexi cap and mid cap mix.

Add children benefit hybrid fund later.

Tag one fund exclusively for this goal.

Retirement Bucket

Horizon more than 25 years ahead.

Use flexi cap, large and mid and mid cap.

Gradually add NPS or PPF for debt portion.

PPF as Safe Complement

Open PPF account next month.

Deposit Rs 1,000 monthly to start.

Safe, tax-free, 15-year lock fosters discipline.

Helps build debt side of retirement pool.

Systematic Transfer Plan Option

Lumpsum from redeemed funds can sit in liquid.

Use STP into chosen equity funds monthly.

This spreads market timing risk automatically.

Rebalancing Rules

Check equity versus debt mix yearly.

Equity value may surge; shift excess to debt.

In big market fall, move debt back to equity.

CFP guides these switches calmly.

Tax Considerations

Equity LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%.

STCG taxed flat 20%.

Debt fund gains taxed per income slab.

Use harvest strategy when nearing goal.

harvest means booking LTCG yearly up to limit.

This keeps tax outgo manageable.

Regular Plan Cost Myth Busting

Regular expense ratio seems higher upfront.

Cost covers yearly review and behavioural coaching.

Poor DIY choices cost much more secretly.

Consistent guided returns beat lower-cost chaos.

Monitoring Underperformance

Mark calendar for annual review date.

Compare each fund with category median.

If fund trails for three years consecutively, exit.

Replace with better fund suggested by CFP.

Behavioural Discipline Tips

Do not pause SIP during market crash.

Crash units bought cheap give future gain.

Ignore daily news noise completely.

Focus on long horizon goals only.

Celebrate small milestones to stay motivated.

Avoiding Common Mistakes

Do not start another sector fund.

Do not buy insurance cum investment schemes.

Avoid loans for consumption purchases.

Do not borrow to invest in equities.

Avoid chasing past star performers blindly.

Using Bonus and Windfalls

Put 50% of any bonus into equity funds.

30% into debt portion for balance.

20% can reward your family needs.

This splits enjoyment and discipline nicely.

Protecting Against Inflation

Equity allocation fights inflation strongly.

Debt and PPF give stability but lag inflation slightly.

Balanced mix preserves purchasing power.

Review inflation assumptions in planning yearly.

International Equity Exposure

Your portfolio lacks global diversification currently.

Add one international flexi equity fund later.

Allocate 5% of total corpus there.

Currency diversification helps risk spreading.

Liquidity Ladder

Emergency fund sits in liquid fund.

Next six months needs in short debt fund.

Long term money in equity funds.

Ladder ensures funds available when required.

Estate Planning Early

Write a simple will before investments grow bigger.

Nominate spouse in all mutual funds now.

Update nomination after any family change.

Financial Checklist Every Year

Check emergency fund size.

Review insurance coverage adequacy.

Review fund performance.

Rebalance asset allocation.

Increase SIP amounts.

Update goal amounts for inflation.

Revise will and nominations.

Cost Averaging Benefit

SIPs buy more units when markets dip.

Less units when markets rise.

This smooths purchase price long run.

Maintain uninterrupted SIP flow always.

Role of Certified Financial Planner

CFP studies your goals and risk appetite.

Designs asset allocation strategy.

Monitors fund performance quarterly.

Suggests tax efficient withdrawal later.

Provides behavioural coaching during volatility.

Helps rebalance emotions along with money.

Future Income Increase Plan

When salary grows, double debt contribution first.

Next, raise equity SIP proportionally.

Maintain expense growth slower than income growth.

This widens surplus for investing.

Cyclical Sector Risk Explanation

Manufacturing fund invests in limited factories.

Sector cycles boom and bust sharply.

Not ideal for core portfolio.

Keep such exposure only if studied deeply.

Better stick with diversified flexi cap instead.

Midcap Versus Small Cap

Midcaps are established companies still growing.

Small caps are fledgling firms with higher risk.

Midcap fund already adds growth factor.

Too much small cap exposure increases volatility.

Investor Psychology Guardrails

Set target price triggers to review, not sell.

Use planner as accountability partner.

Regular meetings maintain focus on plan.

SIP Pause Policy

Pause only if job loss emergency arises.

Resume immediately after stability returns.

Avoid switching funds due to temporary underperformance.

Systematic Withdrawal Plan Later

When goal time arrives, shift units gradually to liquid.

Use SWP for tuition or retirement cash flow.

SWP gives monthly income and tax control.

Tracking Tools

Use single app to track all regular plans.

Provide access to planner for real-time advisory.

Avoid multiple apps causing confusion.

Retirement Framework

Start separate NPS Tier I this year.

Contribute Rs 2,000 monthly alongside existing SIPs.

NPS adds discipline and extra tax benefit.

Choose 75% equity allocation inside NPS now.

Slide down equity slowly after age 45.

Child Education Framework

Estimate future fees with 8% inflation estimate.

Map required corpus to SIP calculators.

Increase child fund SIP accordingly each year.

Adapting to Rule Changes

Tax laws may change again later.

CFP remains updated and alters plan quickly.

Regular funds distribution channel relays quick changes.

Reshuffle Execution Steps

Stop SIPs in Motilal, Tata, Bandhan immediately.

Redeem existing units gradually via STP.

Redirect redemption money into Parag Flexi core.

Start new SIP of Rs 500 in debt fund.

Switch all existing funds from direct to regular.

Register with MFD who holds CFP credential.

Set review meeting date every March.

Expected Benefits after Reshuffle

Portfolio drops to four funds manageable.

Large and midcap part gives stability.

Flexi cap offers global and domestic blend.

Midcap slice retains growth potential.

Debt slice cushions shocks.

Emergency corpus stays safe.

Annual review picks any underperformance early.

What to Watch in Next Months

Track market volatility impact on midcap.

Check debt fund credit quality updates.

Monitor PPF interest announcements annually.

Increase emergency fund faster if job risk rises.

Finally

Your investing journey started well already.

Reshuffle reduces risk and boosts manageability.

Adopt regular plans with CFP guidance now.

Avoid index and direct funds shortcomings.

Keep emergency fund growth on priority.

Increase SIP amounts with income hikes.

Rebalance asset mix every year patiently.

Tag each investment to one clear goal.

Stay invested through market moods gently.

Wealth builds quietly with discipline and time.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9168 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 23, 2025Hindi
Money
Dear Sir, I m Government employee earning around 1 Lakh Permonth, I have small home around 375 sq ft. My Goverment employer who gives NPS accumulated 15 Lakh and mutual fund portfoilio value is 3.5 lakh . also I have been doing monthly SIPS from past three years started with 6k, gradually increased and wll increase like wise and now just from last month started SIP of Rs 20,000/- PM in Following Fund , Canara Robeco Small Cap = 2000, Motilal Mid cap =6500, Motilal Smal cap -3500, Quant Flexi Cap = 5000, Invesco Flexi Cap- 3000, My Goal is to have home after 6 years around 70 lakhs ( need 35 lakh for down payment in six year) and my long term goal of 15 years is to have 2 cr cash (other than Employer linked NPS). NO LOAN NOW. no debt, age 36. please advice for short term 6 years and long term 15 years 2cr goal with my investment current mutual fund.
Ans: Reviewing Your Current Financial Position
You are 36 and earn about ?1?lakh per month as a government employee.

Your NPS account holds ?15?lakh (employer?linked).

Mutual fund holdings currently stand at ?3.5?lakh.

You started monthly SIPs and have now committed ?20,000 per month across various funds.

You have no debt and aim for a home down?payment and long?term corpus goals.

First, well done on entering disciplined SIPs and having zero liabilities.

Clarifying Your Short?Term Goal (6 Years)
You plan to buy a home in six years, needing ?70?lakh overall.

Down-payment estimate: ?35?lakh in six years.

You already own a small home of 375?sq?ft, so this may be part of an upgrade or new investment.

Your SIPs and NPS earnings should support this goal if aligned strategically.

Understanding Your Long?Term Goal (15 Years)
Your long-term goal is to build a ?2?crore corpus (excluding NPS).

Time horizon aligns well with an aggressive equity stance.

You have fourteen years to compound wealth via SIPs, NPS, and portfolio growth.

Evaluating Your Existing SIP Structure
You are currently investing ?20,000 per month in equity across:

Small-cap: ?2,000

Mid-cap fund: ?6,500

Another small-cap: ?3,500

Flexi-cap (Quant): ?5,000

Another flexi-cap (Invesco): ?3,000

Strength: Growth potential through small and mid segments.
But risk: Highly concentrated in equity, no debt buffer.
You need equity diversification and safer assets for your six-year goal.

Short-Term 6-Year Strategy
Aim: Accumulate ?35?lakh for home down-payment with minimal risk.

Introduce Debt Allocation

Add aggressive hybrid or short-term debt funds.

Suggest monthly SIP of ?10,000 into debt/hybrid funds.

Protect capital against equity shocks in 6 years.

Maintain Balanced Equity Exposure

Reduce small-cap SIPs gradually to total ?5,000.

Maintain ?5,000 in mid-cap, and ?5,000 across flexi-caps.

Equity exposure remains ~50%, balanced for growth and capital protection.

Start a Liquid or Ultra-Short Fund SIP

Add ?5,000 monthly for liquidity and emergencies.

This buffer prevents needing to redeem equity during market lows.

View NPS Strategically

Your employer-linked NPS (~?15?lakh) is equity-heavy by default.

Continue contributions; it acts both as retirement savings and growth asset.

Avoid early withdrawals to retain long-term advantage.

Use Home-Specific SIP Mode

For 6-year goal, designate the debt/hybrid and part of flexi SIP.

This creates a secure bucket for your home fund.

Long-Term 15-Year ?2 Crore Strategy
Aim: Build ?2?crore corpus excluding NPS through balanced equity and hybrid allocation.

Focus on Equity for Growth

Maintain ?5k in mid-cap and ?7k in flexi-cap equity SIPs.

Keep small-cap at ?5k – enough exposure for growth without excessive risk.

Include Hybrid/Multi-Asset Funds

Add ?7k monthly in aggressive hybrid or multi-asset funds.

These funds balance equity-debt automatically and reduce volatility.

Use Debt Funds for Stability

Allocate ?6k to debt or short-term bond funds monthly.

Provides stability and income distribution over the long term.

Maintain Liquid SIPs

Keep ?2k to ?3k in liquid funds for flexibility.

Helpful for periodic rebalancing or unexpected expenses.

Consider Small Gold Exposure

Add ?2k–3k in gold ETF/funds for inflation and equity hedge.

Increases diversification without pushing beyond core allocation.

Suggested SIP Structure (Total ?40,000)
Asset Class SIP Monthly Allocation
Small-cap ?5,000
Mid-cap ?5,000
Flexi-cap Equity ?12,000
Aggressive Hybrid ?7,000
Debt Fund ?6,000
Liquid Fund ?3,000
Gold ETF ?2,000
Total ?40,000

This builds growth equity moat while improving downside buffer and goal-specific buckets.

How to Redeploy Existing Portfolio
Revisit overlapping flexi and small/mid fund overlaps.

Consolidate similar fund mandates into single high-conviction funds.

Redirect existing SIPs to align with the above structure.

Sell overlapping or underperforming schemes and reassign to target allocation over 6 to 12 months.

Lump-Sum Deployment Approach
Suppose you receive a windfall or bonus.

Do not invest large lumps entirely into equity.

Use staggered deployment: monthly or quarterly over a year.

Split 60% into equity, 20% hybrid, 20% debt/liquid for diversified entries.

Keep track of average cost and maintain goal alignment.

Why Actively Managed Funds Are Advantageous
They allow managers to exit risky sectors pre-fall.

Actively managed equity adapt to changing market outlooks.

Index funds follow benchmark blindly without defense.

Your horizon and risk capacity suit active funds combined with guided allocation.

Why Regular Plans with CFP Supervision
Regular plans offer guidance, rebalancing, and behavioral coaching.

Direct plans lack reviews and timing discipline.

CFP-backed MFDs assist in staying on target and optimizing tax.

Monitoring and Rebalancing
Review your portfolio every 6 months for drift.

If equity grows beyond 60–65%, redirect additional SIPs into debt/hybrid.

Rebalance via SIP redirection rather than lump-sum redemption.

Document proceedings for tax efficiency.

Expense and Insurance Safeguards
Ensure you have 6 months expenses in liquid funds.

Health insurance coverage is crucial—ensure minimum ?5?lakh sum assured.

No existing debt—maintain this status.

Avoid lifestyle inflation and stick to budget.

Tax Planning Considerations
Equity LTCG taxed at 12.5% on gains above ?1.25?lakh.

STCG is taxed at 20%.

Debt and hybrid fund CGT taxed as per slab.

Hybrid scheme CGT depends on equity ratio.

Annually harvest LTCG exemption by redeeming ?1.25?lakh per annum.

CFP oversight helps schedule redemptions to maximise tax benefit.

Goal Progress Tracking & Review Milestones
6 months: Check balance between equity and goal bucket allocations.

1 year: Are you on track to reach ?10?lakh toward home down-payment?

3 years: Correlate portfolio growth with ?35?lakh target.

Ongoing: Adjust SIP top-ups as your salary increases.

Risk & Contingency Management
Equity volatility can affect portfolio; hybrid/debt protects stability.

Maintain liquidity to avoid panic selling.

Rebalance portfolio before market peaks; reinvest into debt/hybrid thereafter.

Plan insurance before property acquisition: include term and health cover.

Building Flexibility and Future Enhancements
Once home down-payment target is funded, repurpose debt/hybrid SIPs toward long-term corpus.

Continue active equity SIPs with adjusted allocation for growth.

Introduce small international equity or alternative asset exposure if you prefer further diversification.

Consider a gold ETF increment if inflation risk appears higher.

Final Insights
Your disciplined SIP journey and zero debt are excellent.
The adjustments suggested help you build the six-year ?35?lakh down-payment and the fifteen-year ?2?crore corpus in a structured, low-volatility manner.
By blending growth equity, hybrid buffers, debt stability, and guided MFD planning, your strategy is both goal?aligned and resilient.

You’re on a strong path—maintain discipline, monitor progress, and adjust over time. Let me know when you'd like help with specific fund selection or setting up quarterly reviews.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |6873 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jun 23, 2025

Career
VIT integrated M.tech or B.tech CSE which one is better?
Ans: VIT Bhopal’s Integrated M.Tech in CSE (Computational and Data Science) is a five-year program with a curriculum focused on high-performance computing, machine learning, and data science, taught by 100% PhD faculty, and offers a lower annual fee than the BTech, with BTech and integrated MTech students sharing classes and faculty. Placement rates are strong (about 90%), with centralised VIT placements bringing in top recruiters like Microsoft, Infosys, Amazon, and TCS, though integrated MTech students may be eligible for fewer companies than BTech students. Amrita Nagercoil’s BTech CSE is a four-year core program with robust placements—100% in 2024, an average package of ?9.2 lakh, and 300+ recruiters including TCS, Cognizant, IBM, and Amazon—supported by experienced, PhD-qualified faculty and a curriculum designed for industry readiness. Student reviews for Amrita highlight strong academic support, modern infrastructure, and a focus on practical, application-based learning. While both programs offer strong placement support, Amrita’s BTech CSE provides broader company eligibility and a more direct, four-year path to industry roles, whereas VIT Bhopal’s integrated MTech is longer and may limit placement options compared to regular BTech.

The recommendation is to prefer BTech CSE at Amrita Nagercoil for its shorter duration, 100% placement rate, broader recruiter base, and strong academic reputation, unless you specifically want a five-year integrated program with a focus on computational and data science, in which case VIT Bhopal is a solid alternative. All the BEST for the Admission & a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x