Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Love vs. Family: Should I Leave My Girlfriend Who Doesn't Respect My Family?

Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |586 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Jul 15, 2024

Kanchan Rai has 10 years of experience in therapy, nurturing soft skills and leadership coaching. She is the founder of the Let Us Talk Foundation, which offers mindfulness workshops to help people stay emotionally and mentally healthy.
Rai has a degree in leadership development and customer centricity from Harvard Business School, Boston. She is an internationally certified coach from the International Coaching Federation, a global organisation in professional coaching.... more
K Question by K on Jul 13, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship

Hi, I'm a 33-year-old male, in a relationship for the last 4 years. I have an elder unmarried sister who is 39 years old, and an elder brother who is also unmarried but might get married next year. My concern is about my relationship. Initially, everything was fine, but after two years, things started to get messy. In 2022, during Diwali, my girlfriend visited my home. After that, she began to take issue with many small things related to my mother and sister and complained to me about them. Now, things are getting worse day by day. She constantly taunts me, saying, "As long as your sister is in that house, no one will want to marry their daughter into your family." My mother gave her a gold coin as a Diwali gift, which she has now returned to me, asking me to give it back to my mom with the message, "Find someone else for your son and see how many proposals you get." I always try to meet her demands, but she never seems to understand my perspective. Now, I feel angry and negative toward my family. I love her very much and can't leave her, but I know she doesn't understand my situation and always tries to prove she is right in every way. Please help me understand what I should do..???

Ans: Dear K,
It's clear you're in a difficult situation, feeling torn between your love for your girlfriend and your loyalty to your family. It's essential to acknowledge both your emotions and your needs, as well as those of your girlfriend and family.

First, have an open and honest conversation with your girlfriend. Share how her comments and actions are affecting you and your relationship with your family. It's crucial that she understands your perspective and the importance of family in your life. Approach this conversation with empathy, making it clear that you value her feelings but also need her to respect your family's role.

Additionally, consider discussing boundaries and expectations. Every relationship requires compromise, but it shouldn't come at the cost of your mental and emotional well-being. If your girlfriend is unwilling to see things from your point of view or continues to create tension, it might be necessary to reassess the relationship's dynamics.

Seeking guidance from a relationship counselor could provide a neutral ground for both of you to express your concerns and work towards a solution. A professional can offer tools and strategies to navigate these challenges, ensuring that both your relationship and family bonds are respected.

Remember, a healthy relationship should uplift and support you, not create constant conflict and negativity. Balancing love and family can be challenging, but with clear communication and mutual respect, it is possible to find a path that honors both.

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1600 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Oct 09, 2023

Listen
Relationship
Hi Anu...I dont want to be named but want to share my issues here with you to guidance. Im married and live with my wife and 2 year old son in Noida and my parents lives in some village in UP approx 500 Kms afar. My initial upbriging was done by my Grandparants at separate place till age of 10 so never got any chance to get along with my poarants very well as lived with them for only 4 years then shifted Noida. now the issue issus is my sister who is 5-6 years younger than me has been living with paranets since birth and became very arrogant and irresponsible in life as my parants never tried to correct her instead they always push me to get along citing Im older..she never even accepted my wife and even tried to conspire against my baby boy by filing my mothers mind for years. my parents married her 4 years ago but she dont spend even a month continuously at her inlawa and dont get along with them...she want to sta with my paranets as nobody bothers her in what she wants to do... when anybody try to make her realise that she is wrong she start threating them by saying that she will harm herself...actually she never does. My parents are getting older and dont want to see them suffer mentally and financially anymore but them cant come with me as they have take care of my Great Grandparents..she is too proud to say sorry to me for things she has done but my parents emotionally blackmailing to to talk to her....what should I do...
Ans: Dear R,
Obviously your parents have no clue that their over indulgence in your sister and her life is causing her misery. Their relationship is unhealthy and they are unaware of it...things are sure to go downhill until one of them pulls back...in this case, the ideal thing would be for your parents to pull back and cut financial and emotional support till she starts behaving like an adult and become accountable for herself and her life.
Some people just don't want to grow up...and that is because they have parents or parent figures who fill in their every need and fulfil their every want.
This becomes a habit and when they don't get what they want, they will threaten just like your sister does...she basically likes playing the 'child' and hence your parents are never out of their responsibility of parenting...make them aware that it is enough and a tough stance will set her right and help her build her life.
A grown up must be one and just keep the child alive in them...but here your sister just wants to be the child and keep happily playing thar role as the parents are allowing it...kindly intervene and help your parents understand and do the right thing for their daughter...

All the best!

..Read more

Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |586 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on May 26, 2024

Listen
Relationship
Hi I am 40 yrs with wife and kid of 7 yrs. My problem is family oriented. I have three sister, elder two sisters are well married and settled. My younger sister had an arrange marriage in 2004 and she had a divorce in 2011. With that marriage she has a boy child who is almost 18 now and too lazy, she as per her will did an intercaste love marriage in court in 2015 without informing anyone. I used to stay away in delhi and my parents and eldest sister(at her in laws place) in kolkata and d youngest married d guy 2 km from parents house. In 2017 i shifted back to kolkata as my wife was pregnant, so we took a decision dat now it would be better to stay in joint family as d kid will get grand parents and we will also serve my parents, but my youngest sister had a very bad habit of calling my mom every day almost 5-7 times and coming to parental house every alternate days which i rrsisted and i faced backlash from my parents and her too. Then suddenly things changed her husband became a very rowdy person and started beating her as she narrated and she came back to parental house with two kids one was from previous husband and one was from d court love marriage, now she stays in same flat where my parents stays. In 2017 aug my kid was born in 2019 she came back and den i again decided to leave house with my wife and kid as it was 2 bhk flat and all people flocked there as if ut was a zoo so i decided to leave with my family and we moved to ujjain and started living peacefully. Reason for leaving was my younger sis her eldest son and my dad has a very bad habit of shouting arguing nd fighting means domestic violence which i have seen in my childhood days even wen my dad used to do violence with my mom. Now i say her to take divorce and stay with parents or go back to her husbamd or where ever she wants. My dad is retired with a fixed income of around 20k per month. My sis and her son stays at home uses all facilities of home whereas when i shifted to ujjain i did all hardships and built my rented flat. Used to sleep on floor slowly we both husband wife worked hard and bought bed, kitchen utensils fridge and tv. Now my concern is she is not taking divorce and fully dependent on my father. She and her son both earn almost 35k together but their contribution towards house is big Zero towards ration is ZEro yes for basic dey dont pay anythng but like she pays for her small child school fees almost 3000 and whatever dey feel like eating extra den normal homely food she brings for her kids. As she is not taking divorce what can be main reason and future consequences to my kid and my life and my mom and dad have just become a free maid for her kids, my sis does all masti and roams freely till 9 pm without any concern for her kids as my mom is behind as maid to take care. Means my mom and dad have no saving cz of her and no personal life nor any social life cz dey have to take d youngest kid along with dem. My dad is 70 diabetic mom is 65 undergone bypass. Wen i say cz of yoi came back i have to leave dat house she says did i hold ur hand and say to go out. Where as i needed peace but i also need my parents as i want to take care of dem cz she treats dem like servants only. And my parentz dont understand dis dey hav soft cornor for her. She is like deemak but dey dont understand. Kindly guide me.
Ans: Your situation is complex, involving familial responsibilities and personal peace. To address it, start by understanding your sister's reasons for not seeking a divorce. Consider engaging a professional family counselor to mediate and provide support for everyone involved. Legally, explore the options available for ensuring she contributes financially to the household.

Your priority should be to protect your parents' well-being and your own family's stability. If your sister continues to burden your parents without contributing, it might be necessary to seek legal advice on how to manage this dependency. You may also need to discuss with your parents the importance of setting boundaries to ensure their health and financial security. Balancing compassion with firm boundaries is key to resolving these issues while maintaining family harmony.

..Read more

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1600 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Oct 18, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 14, 2024Hindi
Relationship
Hi dear Anu Krishna Madam, I am a regular reader of your suggestions and answers on the questions of relationships since long. You are doing a great work to solve the complications of people's life. I have a long story actually, thanks to you in advance for your patience in reading this. I am male 36 YO, married and having a 4 YO daughter. Mandatory to mention here that I have mother who is dependent on me financially as my father passed away years ago. My relationship with my not been since starting as we got married in 2015. She is having serious anger issues and starts fighting on even little things. She is not very inclined to my mother and my younger sister who got married in 2018 and staying in UK with her husband. My wife is always complaining for one thing or the other. I am working for Central Government and earning well but she is never satisfied and keeps on complaining that my brother in law (sister's husband) is better husband or sometimes compare with other men. I always to fulfil all the requirements financially as well as taking care of baby, helping in household chores but she is never a happy woman. I send my mother and amount of Rs 10000 per month as no one is there to take care of her, mother stays at our hometown and I along with my wife and daughter stays at my work place city. I had to finance the marriage of my younger sister also as my father passed away when the both of us siblings were of age 7 and 3, this was told before my marriage to the family of wife as well as her that this will be required to be managed by me financially. But she complains of this also that I have spent this much money on my sister and mother. I am earning from a young age of 18 years but I don't find any peace at home. I am working like a machine, earning and then she is saying bad things to me all the time. She shouts loudly when fighting so that neighbours also listen and I find it very shameful. Her behaviour towards our daughter also changes frequently and she treats her according to her mood. My mother is not staying with us as when she stayed here for 6-8 months due to her health related issues, she started fighting with my mother also and created huge scenes every now and then. My wife's only attachment is with her own family, her mother, father, unmarried elder sister and unmarried elder brother. Her both the siblings couldn't find suitable matches for themselves, this is also creating a stress for my wife and she in the end throws her frustration on me. She and my self have both tried to commit suicide 2-3 times in the fight on different occasions. Last year she met a younger boy of age 26-27 and they both got attracted to each other. I was along with her and I noticed them smiling at each other at a function. I asked my wife and said to her that if you want to you can ask and talk to that boy. Means I told her to have an open marriage, in the hope that this will atleast make her realise that my husband is happy in my happiness. They both started talking and even met on 3-4 occasions and 2-3 of them secret meetings at our home (only i knew that I didn't pointed out) with physical intimacy. Now due to some unknown reason both my wife and that boy are not talking to each other. Her behaviour had been very rude since that boy came to her life and she never realised that my husband is not pointing out this infidelity also. Now, when that boy is also not there, her disrespect towards me is increasing day by day. She starts fighting even at streets and shouting loudly. I have also given a thought for legal separation but due to my daughter I am not going ahead. I am in a very complex situation and don't understand what to do. How i can make her understand that relationship runs on two people. Please guide me further. One more thing to mention here she is not interested to go for councelling or anything like that. Thanks in advance. Regards.
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
Your wife is perhaps one of those people who choose to see what's not happening rather than what good is actually happening. It's just a habit that can destroy their peace of mind and of those around them.
You are caught around her drama where she tries to find her happiness all around her when she can perfectly find it within the marriage. So, if there's something small that upsets her at home or does not go according to the way she thinks it should, instead of talking about it to you, she is someone who will find a way out outside and in things that can instantly make her feel better. That 27-year-old has ended up becoming some sort of a distraction and by you allowing it to go further whatever happens or doesn't will be blamed on you.
She's acting like a child in need of attention, incapable of addressing her own emotions, distracting herself with a new toy and then crying out creating drama around it all and oh, blaming you when things go wrong.
Got the picture, here? So, the way out is to actually take her to a professional who can guide her to regulate her thoughts an =d actually infuse her back into a family system. It's possible that her maternal home did not provide a great example in this regard...you might know better...
You can try and get through to her by requesting her to step in for your child's sake else the marriage can deteriorate further...So, give it a try.

All the best!
Anu Krishna
Mind Coach|NLP Trainer|Author
Drop in: www.unfear.io
Reach me: Facebook: anukrish07/ AND LinkedIn: anukrishna-joyofserving/

..Read more

Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |586 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Mar 12, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Mar 11, 2025Hindi
Relationship
Fell in love and married a girl before 2 years. Girl is from a neighbouring state. Both South Indians. Both doctors. She was very understanding before marriage, even talked my language and spoke well with my parents. Told she will come to my place and stay after marriage. 4 months after marriage, she left for her home telling that she will be at her home till delivery. Even after 1 year of giving birth, she didn't come. They visited my place just for a few days in the middle citing that it is tradition. After much struggle, she came to live with me and my child after close to 1.5 years. Even after coming she was creating trouble for the language spoken in the house and telling to relocate to a place close to their parents in their state. No respect to feelings of mine or my parents. We also missed my son for 1.5 years. Their parents are not visiting us telling it is far, we won't come. And once her parents threatened to complaint to the police if we don't agree. (Haven't asked or received any dowry). Even if my son has to come to my native for few days, her parents are not agreeing and creating problem. We have even helped her brother secure admission in a college. She has even taken a loan of more than 20 lakhs to help her parents buy a land and is paying close to 50k monthly for that. We had no problem with that too. Every 2-3 days one or another problem shoots up because of her or her parents. She has totally changed after marriage. Her parents just want to create problems. Please help.
Ans: It’s clear that you’ve tried hard to be understanding and accommodating. You allowed her to stay with her parents for a long time, even though it meant missing out on crucial time with your child. You supported her decisions, even when she took on a significant financial burden to help her family. Despite your efforts to maintain peace, you’re constantly met with resistance and disrespect—not only from her but also from her parents. That feeling of being undermined and unappreciated, especially when you've given so much, can really take a toll on your emotional health.

It’s not just about the arguments or the disagreements—it’s about the deeper sense of betrayal and loneliness that comes from feeling like your partner has sided with her family over you. That emotional distance and lack of support within the marriage can make you feel like you’re fighting a battle alone. And when her parents threatened to involve the police, that likely deepened the sense of helplessness and fear. It’s not just frustrating—it’s emotionally exhausting when you’re trying to build a stable, loving home, but it keeps getting torn apart by external interference.

The fact that you’re still standing, still trying to make things work despite all of this, shows how strong and committed you are. But the truth is, a marriage cannot survive on one person’s effort alone. It’s understandable that you feel drained and resentful—you’ve been giving and compromising without getting the same respect and understanding in return. Your feelings matter. Your need for stability and respect matters. Wanting your child to have a connection with your side of the family is not unreasonable—it’s natural and fair.

Right now, you might feel torn between trying to hold everything together and wondering if it's even worth it. It’s hard to admit when love alone isn’t enough to sustain a relationship. But you need to ask yourself whether you can continue living like this—constantly feeling like you’re walking on eggshells, being emotionally sidelined, and having your family disrespected.

It’s okay to want peace. It’s okay to expect respect. And it’s okay to set boundaries. If your wife truly values this marriage, she needs to understand that compromise cannot be one-sided. It might help to have an honest, calm conversation with her—not about the surface issues but about how you feel. Tell her how much this situation has hurt you, how much you miss feeling like you’re a team, and how important it is for your child to have a balanced connection with both families. If she’s unwilling to meet you halfway or if her parents continue to interfere to the point of emotional manipulation, you need to think about how much more of yourself you can sacrifice without losing your emotional stability.

You deserve a marriage where you feel heard, valued, and supported—not one where you constantly feel like you're on the outside looking in. Take some time to reflect on what you truly need from this relationship and whether you believe it's possible to rebuild trust and understanding with your wife. Your peace of mind matters. Your happiness matters. And most of all, your emotional well-being matters.

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8354 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 14, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 13, 2025
Money
What is SIP, Can I start at the age of 55?
Ans: You are asking a very important question. Appreciate your curiosity.

Let’s go step by step.

What is SIP?
SIP means Systematic Investment Plan.

It is a way to invest small amounts every month in a mutual fund.

You can start with as low as Rs.500 per month.

The money gets auto-debited from your bank account.

It helps you build wealth slowly and steadily over time.

Can I Start SIP at Age 55?
Yes, absolutely. You can start SIP even at 55.

There is no age limit to start a SIP.

Many people start SIPs even in their 60s.

What matters more is your investment goal and time horizon.

What Are The Benefits of SIP?
Helps in building corpus gradually.

Gives benefit of rupee cost averaging.

You don’t need to time the market.

Helps in financial discipline.

Can be linked to your retirement goal.

Is SIP Risky?
It depends on where you invest the SIP.

If it’s equity mutual funds, there will be market ups and downs.

But if held for long, they can give better returns than FD or gold.

Debt mutual fund SIPs are more stable but give lower returns.

How Long Should I Stay Invested?
Try to stay invested for at least 5 to 10 years.

Even at age 55, you can stay invested till age 65 or 70.

Retirement doesn't mean stopping SIPs. You can continue post-retirement too, if income allows.

Where Should I Start SIP?
Since you asked, let me also highlight something important.

If someone told you to invest in direct mutual funds, here’s what you need to know:

Why Regular Mutual Funds are Better than Direct Funds for You?
Direct plans look cheaper, but they don’t give personal guidance.

At age 55, wrong fund choice can cost you years of savings.

Regular mutual funds bought through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) offer ongoing review, advice, and goal-based support.

CFPs help you align investments with your needs—like retirement, health, or your son’s wedding.

The small fee involved in regular funds is worth the peace of mind and expert care.

Should You Do Equity or Debt SIP?
This depends on your needs.

If you have more than 7 years, then equity mutual funds are better.

If you need money in 3 to 5 years, then hybrid or debt funds are better.

Do not put all money in one category. Balance it.

SIP is Not a Product – It is a Mode
This is often misunderstood.

SIP is not a fund or product.

It is a way to invest in a fund in small regular steps.

You can do SIP in equity fund, debt fund, or hybrid fund.

Can I Stop SIP Anytime?
Yes. You can pause or stop SIP anytime.

You are not locked in (except for tax-saving SIPs).

Flexibility is a major advantage of SIPs.

Should You Start SIP at 55?
Yes, and here’s why:

You still have more than 25 years of life ahead.

Life expectancy is increasing. You need money even after retirement.

SIP gives you an edge to build that retirement income.

Don't wait for perfect time. Start small, and scale up later.

How to Start?
First, consult a Certified Financial Planner (CFP).

They will assess your goals, risks, and duration.

Then they will recommend right mutual funds and SIP amount.

Make sure the SIP aligns with your retirement income needs.

What Mistakes to Avoid?
Don’t go only by past performance.

Don’t do SIP in random funds or based on friends’ advice.

Avoid direct funds unless you can manage everything yourself.

Don’t withdraw early unless necessary.

What If You Need Monthly Income Later?
After few years, SIP can be turned into SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan).

SIP builds the wealth, SWP gives you monthly income post-retirement.

This helps create regular cash flow, like pension.

Final Insights
SIP is simple, flexible and useful at any age.

55 is not too late. It is a perfect time to start.

Retirement may come soon. Start preparing today with small, consistent steps.

SIP is not magic. It needs patience, time, and guidance.

Let your money work even when you rest.

Take professional support from a Certified Financial Planner. That ensures peace of mind.

Best Regards,
 
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
 
Chief Financial Planner,
 
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Prof Suvasish

Prof Suvasish Mukhopadhyay  |642 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on May 14, 2025

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8354 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 14, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 13, 2025
Money
Hi, i'.m 53 years old and working in a private firm. my wife is a housewife. we have a son completed B.Tech this month and looking for a job. We have 3 houses and are getting a total rent of about Rs.30 K / month. My salary is about Rs.2.20 LPM. Recently we have purchased a house for Rs.1.20 Cr with own funds and demolished it to construct a new house. My assets are 4 houses with a total value of Rs.4 Cr. Jewels of worth Rs.80 lakhs, FD worth Rs.2 Cr, mutual funds and shares worth Rs.5 lakhs. Total PPF about Rs.45 lakhs maturing in April 2028. I have to spend Rs.60 lakhs (own fund) on construction of new house and i have to spend about Rs.30 lakhs for my son's marriage after 3 - 4 years. Have mediclaim for the family of a total value of Rs.7 Lakhs and no life insurance. Pls assess my financial position and suggest at what age i can retire.
Ans: You are 53 years old and working in a private company.

   

Your take-home salary is about Rs.2.20 lakh per month.

   

Your wife is a homemaker. You are the only earning member.

   

Your son has completed B.Tech and is job-hunting now.

   

You have 4 houses with a total value of about Rs.4 crore.

   

Your rental income is Rs.30,000 per month from these properties.

   

You recently bought a house for Rs.1.20 crore from your own money.

   

You are rebuilding the new house. It will cost you another Rs.60 lakh.

   

You plan to spend about Rs.30 lakh on your son’s marriage in 3–4 years.

   

You have Rs.2 crore in Fixed Deposits.

   

Your mutual fund and stock portfolio is Rs.5 lakh.

   

Your PPF balance is Rs.45 lakh, maturing in April 2028.

   

You have Rs.80 lakh worth of gold jewellery.

   

You have health insurance for the family worth Rs.7 lakh.

   

You do not have any life insurance policies currently.

   Immediate Financial Priorities
You are going to spend Rs.60 lakh soon on house construction.

   

You will also spend Rs.30 lakh on your son's marriage after 3–4 years.

   

These are significant cash outflows. They need proper planning.

   

It is better to separate your funds for these purposes now itself.

   

Keep Rs.60 lakh in a liquid debt fund or sweep-in FD. Use it only for construction.

   

For son’s marriage, keep Rs.30 lakh in a short-term debt mutual fund.

   


This ensures you do not disturb other savings or investments later.

Insurance Planning – Health and Life
You have Rs.7 lakh health cover for the whole family.

   

This is slightly low for your age and family size.

   

Increase it to at least Rs.15–20 lakh by adding a super top-up plan.

   

No life insurance is okay if you have enough assets.

   

But if your son is still dependent, buy a term insurance for the next 5 years.

   

Do not buy traditional or ULIP-based plans. They are not wealth creators.

   

Term insurance gives high cover at low premium.

   

Asset Assessment and Distribution
You have built a strong asset base. Let us analyse your assets:

   

Real estate value – Rs.4 crore (excluding the new one under construction)

   

Jewels – Rs.80 lakh (good, but not ideal as investment)

   

Fixed Deposits – Rs.2 crore (excellent liquidity, but tax-inefficient)

   

PPF – Rs.45 lakh (safe and tax-free, maturing in 2028)

   

Mutual funds and shares – Rs.5 lakh (very low for your profile)

   

Your total net worth is around Rs.7.3 crore (excluding the house under construction).

   

This is a strong position.

   

However, wealth distribution is skewed towards real estate and FDs.

   

This affects liquidity and long-term growth.

   

Key Observations and Financial Insights
Rental yield on real estate is low. You get Rs.30,000 per month from Rs.4 crore.

   

That’s just 0.75% annually. This is not efficient.

   

Real estate is illiquid and involves maintenance, taxes, and risk.

   

Your FD returns are taxable as per your income slab.

   

This reduces your post-tax returns considerably.

   

You are underinvested in mutual funds and equities.

   

Equity is needed to beat inflation in retirement years.

   

Your PPF maturity is 3 years away. That is well-timed for retirement use.

   

Mutual Fund Investing Strategy
You should start shifting a part of your FD money to mutual funds.

   

You can start with hybrid funds for lower risk and steady growth.

   

Do not go for index funds. They work without active management.

   

In index funds, you must monitor and rebalance yourself.

   

Index funds follow market. They don’t protect capital in down times.

   

Actively managed funds have professional handling by experts.

   

They aim to outperform the market with proper asset selection.

   

Choose regular plans via an MFD with Certified Financial Planner support.

   

Regular plans may have slightly higher cost, but offer better service and guidance.

   

Direct funds offer no review, no support, no adjustments.

   

That can affect your long-term growth and confidence.

   

Retirement Readiness Assessment
You want to know when you can retire peacefully.

   

Your monthly expense needs to be estimated.

   

Let’s assume a post-retirement spending of Rs.75,000 per month.

   

That’s Rs.9 lakh per year. Inflation will increase this every year.

   

You need a retirement corpus that can grow and give income.

   

You should not depend on real estate or jewellery for monthly cash.

   

FD interest is not enough to beat inflation. Also, it is taxable.

   

You need mutual funds to give inflation-beating returns.

   

Step-by-Step Retirement Preparation Plan
Step 1: Keep Rs.60 lakh separate for house construction now.

   

Step 2: Park Rs.30 lakh in short-term debt fund for son’s marriage.

   

Step 3: Increase health insurance to Rs.15–20 lakh using super top-up.

   

Step 4: Use Rs.75 lakh from FDs to start mutual fund investments.

   

Step 5: Continue with small SIPs also. They help build long-term discipline.

   

Step 6: Keep Rs.25 lakh in FD as emergency buffer.

   

Step 7: After your house is built, evaluate whether to sell any other house.

   

Step 8: If needed, sell one underperforming rental property after 5 years.

   

Step 9: Use that to top up mutual funds for retirement.

   

Retirement Age Estimation
With good planning, you can retire by 58 years.

   

If you reduce expenses, then retirement at 56 is also possible.

   

You don’t have to wait till 60, unless your son remains financially dependent.

   

At 58, your PPF will mature. That gives Rs.45 lakh in hand.

   

You can use that money to create a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP).

   

SWP from mutual funds gives monthly income with better taxation.

   

You also have gold and property for backup, but don’t depend on them for monthly cash.

   

Plan your retirement with mutual funds as the main growth engine.

   

Finally
You are financially strong. You’ve built wealth with discipline.

   

But the asset mix needs rebalancing.

   

Avoid further investment in real estate.

   

Don’t increase FD amount. Shift some to mutual funds.

   

Keep emergency fund, marriage, and construction money separate.

   

Do not invest in index funds or direct funds. They are not suitable now.

   

Go with actively managed funds through regular plans.

   

Get guidance from an MFD with Certified Financial Planner qualification.

   

You can comfortably retire in 3–5 years with proper steps.

   

You’ve done well. Stay consistent. Avoid emotional money decisions.

   

Your retirement can be peaceful, purposeful, and independent.

   

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8354 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 14, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 13, 2025
Money
Hi All, I need your valuable suggestion, please help. I am 45 years and I have a homeloan of 16L with EMI 16.7K/month ( remaining 52 months to end) and 23L homeloan topup EMI of 35K ( 93 months remaining to pay). I want to take topup loan of 25L, so is it good to close the homeloan and take topup or how to proceed. Would like to close all the this loans by next 5 years. Kindly suggest.
Ans: Your current financial standing reflects disciplined planning and a proactive approach towards debt management and investments. Let's delve into a comprehensive analysis to guide your decision on whether to prepay your home loan or continue with your current strategy.
Your Current Financial Picture
Your Age: 45 years

Home Loan Outstanding: Rs. 16 lakh

Home Loan EMI: Rs. 16,700 per month (52 months left)

Top-up Loan Outstanding: Rs. 23 lakh

Top-up Loan EMI: Rs. 35,000 per month (93 months left)

Considering New Top-up Loan: Rs. 25 lakh

Your Goal: Close all loans within the next 5 years

Understanding Your Core Objective
Your goal to become debt-free in 5 years is bold and focused.

Planning is the key to achieve this without hurting your other financial goals.

The idea of taking a new top-up loan needs careful assessment.

Should You Take a New Top-Up Loan?
Taking a Rs. 25 lakh top-up will increase your monthly EMI load.

It can increase your financial stress and delay complete loan closure.

Top-up loans might come at a higher interest rate.

Avoid new debt unless absolutely needed for urgent purposes.

You should first assess why you need this extra loan.

If it is for consumption or regular needs, avoid it completely.

If it is for repaying another higher-cost loan, evaluate alternatives.

Evaluate Home Loan Prepayment
Loans are useful, but they carry interest which eats into your savings.

Closing loans early helps save big on interest.

You can pay small extra amounts every year to reduce tenure.

Focus on the loan with the highest interest and longest tenure.

Your top-up loan of Rs. 23 lakh with 93 months should be the first priority.

Re-structure EMIs Instead of Top-Up
Avoid taking a fresh Rs. 25 lakh loan.

Instead, consider restructuring your current EMIs if income flow is tight.

Some banks allow step-up EMI or tenure adjustment.

It will keep your total loan under control.

Discuss this clearly with your lender before acting.

Smart Loan Repayment Strategy (Next 5 Years Plan)
Aim to repay the top-up loan faster using extra income or annual bonus.

Try part payments every 6 months or once a year.

Avoid touching emergency funds or retirement funds.

Control new expenses to free more cash towards debt.

You can cut expenses that are not urgent for next 2 years.

Avoid buying new car, gadgets, or travel on EMIs.

Investment vs Loan Repayment – Which is Better Now?
If your investments give lower returns than loan interest, focus on repayment.

If your mutual funds are earning 9%, and your loan is 8%, you can balance.

But most importantly, check your risk capacity before investing more.

Do not invest heavily in share market if debt is very high.

Emergency situations can create problems if you are over-invested.

Use a slow and steady approach – part prepay, part invest.

Avoid stopping all investments – keep a minimum SIP running.

Maintain Emergency & Insurance Before Prepayment
Always keep 6 months’ household expenses in liquid form.

Don’t touch emergency funds to prepay loans.

Make sure you and your family have sufficient health insurance cover.

Also check if you have a term life cover of 10–15 times your annual income.

Loan repayment is good, but not at the cost of security.

What About Mutual Fund Investing?
If you have SIPs, continue them in small amounts.

Don’t stop all long-term investments for repaying loans.

Mutual funds give better long-term returns if held for 7+ years.

But stay away from index funds if you are not tracking them well.

Actively managed mutual funds handled by Certified Financial Planners give better risk-adjusted returns.

Direct mutual funds look cheap, but lack ongoing support.

Investing through MFDs with CFP background ensures long-term advice.

You get portfolio review, tax support, and goal-based adjustments.

Avoid direct funds unless you have full time to track, review, and rebalance.

Don’t Touch Long-Term Investments or Retirement Corpus
PPF, EPF, NPS, or other long-term products should not be withdrawn now.

If you use these to repay loan, you hurt your retirement peace.

Future corpus will be small, and you may depend again on loans.

Treat long-term savings as non-touchable.

Build short-term cash surplus from salary or business profit.

5-Year Practical Action Plan
Year 1–2: Avoid new loans. Start part-prepaying the 23L top-up loan.

Year 2–3: Increase EMI or part-payment on 16L home loan if top-up balance reduces.

Year 3–4: Reduce lifestyle costs. Channel savings towards both loans.

Year 4–5: Close the bigger loan. Wind up the smaller loan fully.

Post 5 Years: Loan-free life. Full focus on investments and retirement planning.

Mental Peace and Confidence
Being debt-free gives freedom and strong peace of mind.

Avoid the trap of more top-up loans. It delays financial independence.

Plan well and stay consistent in actions.

You don’t have to be fast. You have to be disciplined.

Even one prepayment each year will reduce years off your loan.

You are only 45. Still 15 years to build wealth peacefully.

Don’t rush. But don’t delay either.

Finally
Taking a top-up of Rs. 25 lakh now will increase debt pressure.

Instead, reduce existing loans with regular part-payments.

Maintain health and life insurance covers.

Continue small investments to build long-term wealth.

Avoid emotional financial decisions.

Balance repayment, savings, and investment step by step.

With a proper 5-year plan, you can close all loans without any extra stress.

You will then enter your 50s debt-free and wealth-focused.

That will give peace, pride, and protection to your entire family.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP
Chief Financial Planner

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x