Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Investing in real estate or mutual funds: 36-year-old seeks advice with 80L savings and increasing SIP

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |6287 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 17, 2024

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Jun 24, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money

Real estate vs MF!!! Hello, I am 36yrs old, I have 40L in MFs, 40L in my company esop. Currently i am investing 50,000 INR SIP. I can increase By another 30,000 on the SIP. However, should i buy a Plot in tier 2 growing city for 50L and pay emi there or top up on MFs and continue without a plot? Please help with my dilemma!

Ans: Current Financial Position
You are 36 years old with Rs. 40 lakhs in mutual funds and Rs. 40 lakhs in company ESOPs. You are currently investing Rs. 50,000 per month through SIPs and can increase this by another Rs. 30,000 per month. You are considering buying a plot in a tier 2 city for Rs. 50 lakhs but are unsure if you should continue investing in mutual funds instead.

Evaluating Real Estate Investment
Initial Costs and Maintenance

Buying a plot involves significant upfront costs, including registration, legal fees, and possibly loan EMIs. Additionally, there are maintenance costs and property taxes, which can add up over time.

Illiquidity and Market Risks

Real estate is not a liquid investment. Selling a property can take time, especially in a tier 2 city. The property market can be unpredictable, and you might not get the expected return on investment.

Opportunity Cost

By investing in real estate, you might miss out on the higher returns that mutual funds can potentially offer. Real estate typically appreciates slower than a well-diversified mutual fund portfolio.

Benefits of Continuing with Mutual Funds
Higher Returns and Diversification

Mutual funds have historically offered higher returns compared to real estate. By continuing your SIPs, you can benefit from market growth and compound interest. Diversifying across different types of mutual funds—equity, debt, and hybrid—can reduce risk and enhance returns.

Liquidity and Flexibility

Mutual funds offer liquidity. You can easily redeem your investments when needed. This flexibility is crucial for managing financial emergencies or taking advantage of other investment opportunities.

Professional Management

Mutual funds are managed by professionals. They use their expertise to navigate market fluctuations and optimize returns. This is particularly beneficial for investors who do not have the time or knowledge to manage their investments actively.

Disadvantages of Index Funds
Limited Flexibility

Index funds track a specific index. They do not have the flexibility to adjust holdings based on market conditions. This can lead to missed opportunities during market fluctuations.

Average Performance

Index funds aim to match the index's performance. They do not strive to outperform the market. Actively managed funds, on the other hand, aim to achieve higher returns through strategic investments.

Market Dependency

Index funds are fully exposed to market risks. During market downturns, they tend to suffer as much as the index. Actively managed funds can adapt to changing conditions and mitigate risks more effectively.

Benefits of Regular Funds through MFD with CFP
Expert Guidance

Investing through a Mutual Fund Distributor (MFD) with a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) ensures expert guidance. They can help tailor your investment strategy to your specific financial goals and risk tolerance.

Regular Monitoring and Adjustments

A CFP continuously monitors your portfolio. They make necessary adjustments based on market conditions and your evolving financial needs. This proactive approach can enhance your returns and reduce risks.

Comprehensive Financial Planning

A CFP offers a 360-degree financial planning service. They consider all aspects of your financial situation, including retirement planning, tax efficiency, and wealth management. This holistic approach ensures that your investments align with your long-term goals.

Final Insights
Given your strong financial position and the potential for higher returns, continuing to invest in mutual funds is a better option. Real estate can be illiquid and involve higher costs. Mutual funds offer liquidity, professional management, and the potential for significant returns. Increase your SIP contributions to benefit from compounding and market growth. Consulting a Certified Financial Planner can provide personalized advice and ensure your investments align with your financial goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |6287 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 21, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - May 21, 2024Hindi
Money
Hi myself 36 yrs old Started mf plan very late Luckily due to organisation switch got company stocks vested to me around 85 lacs and still around 60 lacs not yet vested . With that confidence I have taken home loan of 1.2cr for 25 yrs Emi amt 1 lac per month rate of interest 8.5 Not much invested earlier in mf started late around 1.5 yrs back Was able to accumulate 5 lacs total Invested in stocks around 2 lacs Now am trying to do sip every month of 42k I earn around 2.2lacs I have 2 more loans apart from home loan Personal loan of 26k emi 4 yrs pending Gold loan yearly emi payment of 6 lacs amount. Deduction of 1 lac + 26k+ 42k = 1.68 lacs goes to emis Yearly gold I have to pay around 60k without principal I consider 1.75 lacs to fixed amt goes as cuttings. I have remaining around 40k I think Home necessities cost around 15k monthly I still have around 20 to 25k remaining As I have started very late in mf I want to increase my sip for my kids education and future retirement plans I have something in mind which am bit afraid I want to sell stocks and invest in real estate and do the rotation of money for 10 years. But i have limited knowledge after doing some research . Should I go ahead with that ? Or Should I close my home loan using my stocks and reduce to 40 lacs home loan something Invest same amount in sips ? My stocks are in US market ..should I sell or not ? Company stocks are till now going well.. How high it would jump and how much it will take for that to happen I don't know Please suggest me to some investment ideas Q1. Should I close home loan Q2. Should I invest in real estate Q3. Should I invest stocks amt in mutual funds Any better ideas and suggestions please advise ..
Ans: Evaluating Your Financial Position
Your current financial situation reflects both opportunities and challenges. You have accumulated a significant amount of company stocks and started investing in mutual funds. Your home loan and other liabilities add to your monthly financial commitments. It's essential to strategically manage your investments to ensure long-term financial stability.

Assessing the Home Loan
Paying off your home loan can provide a sense of financial relief. However, consider the opportunity cost of using your stocks for this purpose. With an interest rate of 8.5%, the cost of maintaining the home loan is relatively high. Reducing your home loan can decrease your monthly EMI, providing more cash flow for investments and other expenses. However, before deciding, consider the potential growth of your stocks. If the stocks have significant growth potential, retaining them might be more beneficial in the long run.

Evaluating Real Estate as an Investment
Investing in real estate can be tempting, but it comes with several challenges. Real estate investments require substantial capital and involve high transaction costs. They also lack liquidity compared to stocks and mutual funds. The real estate market can be unpredictable, and managing properties requires time and effort. Given these factors, real estate might not be the best option for someone seeking to simplify and strengthen their financial portfolio.

Investing in Mutual Funds
Mutual funds offer a diversified investment option that can align with your financial goals. Given your late start in mutual funds, it’s wise to increase your SIPs to build a substantial corpus over time. Actively managed funds can offer better returns due to professional management. These funds allow you to benefit from the expertise of fund managers, providing a balanced risk-return ratio.

Disadvantages of Index Funds and Direct Funds
Index funds, while low-cost, do not always outperform actively managed funds. They mirror market performance, lacking the flexibility to adapt to market changes. On the other hand, direct mutual funds require active monitoring and decision-making. Investing through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) can provide valuable insights and professional management, helping you navigate complex market conditions effectively.

Strategic Use of Stocks
Your company stocks are a significant asset. Diversifying this investment can reduce risk and enhance returns. Selling a portion of your stocks and investing in mutual funds can provide a balanced approach. This strategy diversifies your portfolio and reduces the risk associated with holding a single type of asset.

Recommendations
Reduce Home Loan: Consider partially reducing your home loan with your stocks. This will lower your EMI and interest burden, providing more cash flow for investments.

Avoid Real Estate: Given the high costs and management efforts involved, real estate might not be the best option. Focus on more liquid and manageable investments.

Increase SIPs in Mutual Funds: Boost your SIPs to build a robust financial corpus for your children’s education and retirement. Actively managed funds through a CFP can optimize your returns.

Diversify Stock Investments: Gradually sell a portion of your company stocks and diversify into mutual funds. This reduces risk and provides a balanced growth potential.

Conclusion
Your proactive approach to managing your finances is commendable. Balancing debt reduction with strategic investments can provide financial stability and growth. A diversified portfolio, professional management, and a focus on long-term goals will help secure your financial future.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |6287 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 10, 2024

Money
Hellopus I am 40 year old married female and have a 1.5 year old daughter. Currently I am drawing 1.13 lakhs monthly. I have 28 lakhs in mutual funds, 10 lakhs in ppf, 26 lakhs in epf, 25 lakhs gold,20 lakhs in lic, 2 lakhs in fd, I am investing 60000 per month in various saving schemes. Now I intend to buy a property worth 1.30 crore. Shall I wait or invest. Am I in a position where I can pay monthly emi of 75000 for next 30 years.
Ans: You've built a strong financial foundation with your savings and investments. This is impressive, considering your current financial obligations and future goals. Let's take a detailed look at your situation and assess whether you should buy the property now or wait.

You earn Rs 1.13 lakhs monthly, and have substantial investments:

Rs 28 lakhs in mutual funds.
Rs 10 lakhs in PPF.
Rs 26 lakhs in EPF.
Rs 25 lakhs in gold.
Rs 20 lakhs in LIC.
Rs 2 lakhs in FD.
You also invest Rs 60,000 per month in various saving schemes.

Monthly EMI and Financial Stability
Purchasing a property worth Rs 1.30 crore will require a significant monthly EMI. If we assume an EMI of Rs 75,000 for 30 years, let's evaluate if this fits into your current financial structure.

Income and Expenses:
Your monthly income is Rs 1.13 lakhs. Deducting Rs 75,000 for EMI, you’ll have Rs 38,000 left for other expenses and investments.

Understanding Your Expenses
Your current monthly investments total Rs 60,000. After accounting for the EMI, it’s essential to ensure your remaining income covers your living expenses, savings, and unexpected costs.

Emergency Fund
An emergency fund is vital. Ideally, you should have 6-12 months of expenses saved. With Rs 2 lakhs in FD, consider increasing this fund to cover unforeseen expenses. This ensures financial stability without disrupting your EMI payments.

Assessing Investment Allocation
Mutual Funds:
You have Rs 28 lakhs in mutual funds. Mutual funds are versatile and offer potential growth. Ensure your portfolio is diversified across equity, debt, and hybrid funds to balance risk and return.

PPF and EPF:
Your PPF and EPF balances are Rs 10 lakhs and Rs 26 lakhs respectively. These are safe, long-term investments providing assured returns. They are also excellent for retirement planning.

Gold:
Gold worth Rs 25 lakhs adds stability and acts as a hedge against inflation. However, its returns are generally lower compared to other investment options.

LIC:
With Rs 20 lakhs in LIC policies, evaluate the performance and returns. If these are investment-cum-insurance policies, consider surrendering and reinvesting the amount in mutual funds for better growth.

FD:
Your Rs 2 lakhs in FD is a good start for an emergency fund. Ensure you have sufficient liquidity for emergencies.

Cash Flow and Loan Eligibility
Given your current financial commitments, paying a Rs 75,000 EMI might strain your cash flow. It's crucial to maintain a balance between your loan repayments and daily living expenses.

Impact on Lifestyle
Evaluate how a high EMI impacts your lifestyle. You must comfortably manage your expenses, investments, and future needs without financial stress.

Benefits of Waiting
Waiting to buy the property can provide several benefits:

Increased Savings: Allow more time to save, reducing loan amount and interest paid.
Market Conditions: Property prices may stabilize or fall, offering better deals.
Financial Cushion: Build a stronger financial cushion, reducing the burden of EMI.
Power of Compounding in Mutual Funds
Investing consistently in mutual funds harnesses the power of compounding. Over time, even small investments can grow significantly. This can enhance your financial stability and provide substantial returns.

Diversification and Risk Management
Diversifying your investments across different mutual funds reduces risk. Balancing between equity, debt, and hybrid funds helps manage market volatility and provides steady returns.

Mutual Fund Categories
Equity Funds: High risk, high reward. Suitable for long-term growth.
Debt Funds: Lower risk, stable returns. Ideal for short to medium-term goals.
Hybrid Funds: Mix of equity and debt. Balanced risk and return.

Advantages of Mutual Funds
Professional Management: Managed by experts, providing better growth opportunities.
Liquidity: Easy to buy and sell, offering flexibility.
Diversification: Reduces risk by investing in a variety of assets.
Tax Benefits: Certain funds offer tax advantages under sections like 80C.
Potential Risks
Market Volatility: Equity funds are subject to market fluctuations.
Credit Risk: Debt funds carry the risk of issuer default.
Interest Rate Risk: Affects bond prices and, consequently, debt funds.
Reassessing LIC Policies
Evaluate your LIC policies. If they are investment-cum-insurance, consider surrendering them. The amount can be reinvested in mutual funds for better returns and flexibility.

Future Goals and Planning
Your financial planning should align with future goals like your daughter’s education and marriage. Ensure your investments are structured to meet these goals without straining your current finances.

Creating a Balanced Portfolio
Your portfolio should balance risk and reward. A mix of equity, debt, and hybrid funds provides growth and stability. Regularly review and adjust your portfolio to align with your goals and market conditions.

Certified Financial Planner
Engage with a Certified Financial Planner to tailor a financial strategy. They provide personalized advice, ensuring your investments align with your goals and risk tolerance.

Final Insights
Buying a property is a significant decision. Evaluate your financial stability, future goals, and current commitments before proceeding. Ensure you maintain a balance between loan repayments and living expenses. Waiting might provide better financial security and opportunities.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |6287 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 08, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 07, 2024Hindi
Money
Am 48 years. Have 13L in MF. 4L in FD. 5L in PF. Own house and a site worth 30L. Also have invested in an under construction apartment which I have paid 85% of the 77 L. This will be for possession in 2027 dec. also have around 5L in Gold. I earn around 3L per month. Need 1.2L post retirement. Presently saving 73k in MF per month.
Ans: You're 48 years old and have a diversified portfolio.

You have Rs. 13L in mutual funds, Rs. 4L in fixed deposits, and Rs. 5L in provident fund.

You own a house and a site worth Rs. 30L.

You've invested in an under-construction apartment, paying 85% of Rs. 77L.

You also hold Rs. 5L in gold.

Your monthly earnings are Rs. 3L, and you're saving Rs. 73k in mutual funds each month.

Assessing Current Investments
Mutual Funds
Mutual funds are a great way to diversify your investments.

With Rs. 13L in mutual funds, you're on the right track.

Actively managed funds tend to outperform passive ones.

They adapt to market changes quickly, benefiting from expert management.

The power of compounding works best here, as returns are reinvested, creating more wealth.

Fixed Deposits
You have Rs. 4L in fixed deposits.

FDs are low-risk but offer lower returns compared to mutual funds.

They're good for short-term goals and emergency funds.

Provident Fund
Your provident fund holds Rs. 5L.

PF is a safe investment with tax benefits, good for long-term retirement planning.

Real Estate
You own a house and a site worth Rs. 30L.

You've invested in an apartment under construction, almost paying it off.

Real estate provides tangible value but lacks liquidity and might not yield regular income post-retirement.

Gold
You have Rs. 5L in gold.

Gold is a hedge against inflation but should only be a small part of your portfolio due to its price volatility.

Monthly Savings and Expenses
You save Rs. 73k in mutual funds monthly, which is commendable.

This consistent saving habit will build significant wealth over time.

Your monthly earnings are Rs. 3L, which gives you a good capacity to save and invest.

You need Rs. 1.2L post-retirement, which is achievable with proper planning.

Evaluating Financial Goals
Retirement Planning
You aim for Rs. 1.2L per month post-retirement.

This goal is realistic given your current savings and investments.

You'll need to focus on building a corpus that generates this income sustainably.

Investment in Real Estate
The apartment you're investing in will be ready by December 2027.

This will add to your real estate assets, but consider its impact on your liquidity.

Real estate is not easily convertible to cash, which might be needed for unexpected expenses.

Strategic Investment Planning
Mutual Fund Investments
Continue your Rs. 73k monthly SIP in mutual funds.

Diversify across different categories like equity, debt, and hybrid funds.

Equity funds offer high returns but come with higher risk.

Debt funds provide stable returns with lower risk, ideal for capital preservation.

Hybrid funds balance growth and stability, suitable for medium-term goals.

Benefits of Regular Funds Through Certified Financial Planner
Investing through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) offers expert advice and personalized plans.

They help you navigate market complexities and make informed decisions.

Regular funds managed by professionals can outperform direct funds, ensuring better returns.

Power of Compounding
The power of compounding is crucial in mutual funds.

Reinvested returns generate additional returns, exponentially growing your wealth over time.

Starting early and staying consistent maximizes compounding benefits.

Risk Management and Diversification
Importance of Diversification
Diversifying your portfolio reduces risk and ensures stable returns.

Spread investments across different asset classes like equity, debt, and gold.

This protects your portfolio from market volatility and economic downturns.

Managing Risks
Equity funds carry market risks but offer high returns.

Debt funds are safer but yield lower returns.

Gold provides a hedge against inflation but can be volatile.

Balance these investments based on your risk tolerance and financial goals.

Building a Retirement Corpus
Calculating Retirement Needs
To meet your post-retirement goal of Rs. 1.2L per month, build a substantial retirement corpus.

Consider inflation and increasing medical costs.

Aim for a mix of growth-oriented and stable investments.

Investing for Retirement
Focus on equity mutual funds for growth.

Debt mutual funds and provident funds provide stability.

A diversified approach ensures consistent returns and risk management.

Regular Review and Rebalancing
Importance of Regular Reviews
Regularly review your investment portfolio to ensure alignment with goals.

Market conditions and personal circumstances change, requiring adjustments.

Rebalancing Portfolio
Rebalance your portfolio periodically to maintain the desired asset allocation.

This involves selling over-performing assets and buying under-performing ones.

It keeps your portfolio balanced and aligned with risk tolerance.

Maximizing Tax Efficiency
Tax-Advantaged Investments
Utilize tax-saving instruments like ELSS (Equity Linked Savings Scheme) for mutual funds.

They offer tax benefits under Section 80C, reducing taxable income.

Tax Planning
Plan your investments to maximize tax benefits.

Use instruments like PPF (Public Provident Fund) and NSC (National Savings Certificate).

This ensures efficient tax management and enhances returns.

Emergency Fund
Importance of Emergency Fund
An emergency fund is crucial for unforeseen expenses.

It provides financial security and peace of mind.

Building Emergency Fund
Keep at least 6 months' worth of expenses in an emergency fund.

Invest in liquid assets like debt funds or savings accounts for quick access.

This ensures you're prepared for any financial emergencies.

Final Insights
Your financial journey is on a solid path.

Diversified investments in mutual funds, real estate, and gold are commendable.

Continue your disciplined saving habit of Rs. 73k per month in mutual funds.

Focus on building a balanced portfolio to achieve your retirement goal of Rs. 1.2L per month.

Regularly review and rebalance your portfolio for optimal performance.

Utilize the power of compounding and tax-efficient investments.

Maintain an emergency fund for financial security.

With consistent effort and strategic planning, you're well-positioned for a comfortable retirement.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |6287 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 29, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 08, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
My age is 40, and gross salary is 42000, I am a father of two daughter, i live on rent with my parents and family, I am indecisive in the case whether to buy a property or to keep live on rent and start investing in Sip. However I do not pay the rent it is been borne by my father, due to some clash in understanding, after purchasing a property the liability of emi would be mine. So please suggest, Whether to keep living on rent with sip investment, or to make a permanent, place for us. Also, suggest the fund name in case of sip which can give a good growth in next 5/6 Years, As I would have liability of my elder daughter's marriage that time.
Ans: Assessing Your Situation
You are 40 years old. Your gross salary is Rs 42,000. You have two daughters. You live on rent with your parents and family. Your father bears the rent. You face a dilemma: buy a property or invest in SIPs while renting. Buying a property would mean taking on an EMI.

Financial Considerations
Buying a Property:

EMI Liability: An EMI can strain your budget.
Long-term Commitment: You need to commit to regular payments for many years.
Property Maintenance: Owning a property involves maintenance costs.
Living on Rent:

Lower Initial Cost: No need for a large down payment.
Flexibility: You can move if needed.
Investment Opportunity: Free up funds for investment in SIPs.
Advantages of SIP Investments
Regular Savings: Helps in disciplined savings.
Compounding: Benefits from the power of compounding over time.
Flexibility: You can adjust the investment amount as per your need.
Diversification: Spreads risk across various assets.
Benefits of Actively Managed Funds
Actively managed funds can be more beneficial than index funds.

Professional Management: Experts manage your investments.
Better Returns: Potential to outperform index funds.
Risk Management: Active management can mitigate risks.
Disadvantages of Index Funds
Market-Linked Returns: Performance tied to the index, with no potential for outperformance.
No Active Management: No expert adjusting your portfolio based on market conditions.
Disadvantages of Direct Funds
Direct funds might seem cost-effective but have drawbacks.

No Advisory Support: Lack of expert guidance.
Time-Consuming: Requires personal research and monitoring.
Higher Risk: Greater chance of making uninformed decisions.
Benefits of Regular Funds
Investing through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) offers many advantages.

Expert Guidance: Personalized advice from a CFP.
Stress-Free: Less time and effort needed from your side.
Potentially Higher Returns: Professional management often yields better results.
Evaluating Your Options
Investing in SIPs:

Short-Term Goals: Use SIPs to build a corpus for your daughter’s marriage.
Long-Term Benefits: SIPs can help in wealth creation over time.
Flexibility: Adjust investments as per your financial situation.
Buying a Property:

Stability: Owning a home can provide stability.
Asset Creation: A property can be a valuable asset.
Financial Burden: EMI can be a significant financial burden.
Recommendations
Considering your situation, investing in SIPs while living on rent seems more prudent. This approach provides flexibility and allows you to save for your daughter's marriage.

Suggested SIP Approach
Diversified Equity Funds: Focus on growth potential.
Regular Monitoring: Review and adjust your investments regularly.
Professional Advice: Consult a CFP for personalized fund recommendations.
Final Insights
Investing in SIPs offers flexibility and growth potential. It helps you prepare for your daughter’s marriage without the financial burden of an EMI. Consult a Certified Financial Planner for tailored advice and fund recommendations.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |6287 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 25, 2024

Listen
Money
Hi, I have 43L and I'm planning to buy a flat worth 1.4Cr. It is due completion in 2029. So I can either put in more now or at the end. I have decided to do below. Pay 10% since it's compulsion, now I have 30lacks with me. My biggest advantage now is time. So I have invested lumpsum of 20L in PPFAS Flexi cap and 10L in HDFC Balanced Fund. I have a loan sanctioned of remaining amount 1.2Cr. My question is, in 5yrs time, should I use 87L from loan and use whatever I get from these MF's or should I stay invested in MF's and use full loan amount of 1.2cr instead? My plan was to pump in additional 30k per month if I use only 87L from loan as my EMI would be less and 8-10yrs down the line, I can apply for PreClosure. What's the best way forward? Use full loan amount and pay higher emi and keep my 30L in MF intact or use partial loan amount, pump in additional sip and utilize what I get to foreclosure of loan? Other details, 30M, Monthly Exp around 50k. I am investing 35k in SIP, 50k for various plans, ULIP, insurance ROP, Assured returns etc. I consider these as debt instruments in my investments. End goal is to save enough for retirement and an additional real estate asset worth 1.5cr before retiring.
Ans: You have Rs 43 lakhs and plan to buy a flat worth Rs 1.4 crores due for completion in 2029. Here's an analysis of your options:

Current Investment Plan
1. Initial Payment:

Paid 10% (Rs 14 lakhs) upfront.
Remaining Rs 30 lakhs available.
2. Investment Allocation:

Rs 20 lakhs in PPFAS Flexi Cap Fund.
Rs 10 lakhs in HDFC Balanced Fund.
3. Loan Details:

Sanctioned loan amount: Rs 1.2 crores.
Option 1: Partial Loan and Additional SIP
1. Plan:

Use Rs 87 lakhs from the loan.
Use returns from mutual funds for the rest.
Pump in an additional Rs 30k per month as SIP.
2. Benefits:

Lower EMI, making it easier to manage monthly expenses.
Ability to invest more monthly, enhancing wealth creation.
Option to pre-close the loan in 8-10 years.
3. Considerations:

Assess the expected returns from mutual funds.
Ensure the investments outperform the loan interest rate.
Option 2: Full Loan Amount
1. Plan:

Use the full Rs 1.2 crores loan.
Keep the Rs 30 lakhs in mutual funds.
2. Benefits:

Larger loan amount may offer tax benefits.
Investments remain intact and grow over time.
Flexibility to use investment returns for other goals.
3. Considerations:

Higher EMI impacts monthly cash flow.
Loan tenure may be longer, increasing interest paid.
Comparative Analysis
1. Loan Interest vs. Investment Returns:

Compare the loan interest rate with the expected returns from mutual funds.
If mutual fund returns are higher, keeping investments intact might be beneficial.
2. Monthly Cash Flow:

Evaluate your ability to manage higher EMIs.
Consider the impact on your overall financial stability.
3. Pre-closure Option:

With lower EMIs, pre-closure of the loan becomes feasible.
Additional SIP investments can create a pre-closure fund.
Recommendations
1. Balanced Approach:

Use a mix of both options.
Opt for a partial loan and keep some investments intact.
2. Regular Review:

Monitor your mutual fund performance regularly.
Adjust investments and loan repayments based on market conditions.
3. Financial Goals:

Align your investments with long-term goals like retirement.
Diversify your portfolio to balance risk and returns.
Final Insights
Considering your goals, a balanced approach of partial loan and maintaining investments is optimal. Regularly review and adjust based on performance and market conditions.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |296 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Sep 13, 2024

Relationship
6monsth back I started talking to one of my colleague, he is attractive by his nature. Almost everyone likes him. he is intelligent, funny, etc.... In calls he used to tell me about his family, his friends, his thoughts, also about the girl (Aliya) whom he liked a lot for 6years (they belong to same village), but she rejected and told that he is her friend only. He told her that he may get feelings for her if they both remained as friends, so better stop talking. But she insisted that they both need to be friends and continue talking. I felt like may be she needed emotional support that's why she insisted. After coming to Jaipur, Aliya started talking to another man named Jitesh. But my colleague used to feel like a third wheel and started keeping distance. Then also she told that they are just friends and he need not distant himself. She always wanted him to give her the first priority. He also feared that she might get upset if he don't give her 1st priority. They used to talk a lot on phone and share everything. One day he brought her to our bay where we both used to sit and work. that day I really felt like I was a third wheel. I felt very bad.. cried for few days. And decided not to talk to him from then on because I didn't want to cry anymore. But he kept trying to have a talk with me. One day he almost cried because I was ignoring him. I couldn't see him like that and also I felt guilt about my behaviour(my intention was not to hurt him but to save my tears). I couldn't help but starting talking to him. He used to mention to me whenever he used to talk to her. and everytime I used to feel very bad. We started talking a lot after few weeks. Whenever I didn't receive proper response from him I used to become very anxious waiting for his reply and cried a lot. But when he starts talking again I used to feel normal. I never wanted to get into relationships, so everytime I used to tell him directly or indirectly about it. But still he continued to talk to me. One day he called me and said that Aliya is in love with Jitesh. He said being a friend he is very happy for her but after sometime he also said that if you also love someone I will stop talking with you also. I understand that he is little sad that he cannot talk to Aliya as he used to talk before because she is in love with someone else. We continued to talk and kept talking a lot. One day I felt like I am too much emotionally getting connected to him and felt like these long talks need to stop. So I asked him saying that I didn't get clarity. Then he opened up and proposed me. I thought for a day and I felt he is also a good person and said yes to him. Then on he became my world. Then on he started talking little less with other girls. One day Aliya called him saying that Jitesh had an incident where everyone thought he was drowned but he came back safely. She needed emotional support and asked him to come to office. She also said she that one of her colleagues didn't bring lunch and she don't have enough food to give her so she asked my colleague to prepare some food and bring it to office. At first my colleague said no thinking of me but Aliya convinced him emotionally saying that will you leave friends if you get a girlfriend and so he prepared lunch and took it to office. That day when he told me all these I felt devastated, I felt really insecured and cried a lot that is our first fight regarding her. He told me that if you say no I will stop talking to her. She again called and asked my colleague that what was my reaction for all these... he kept silent she guessed what might have happened and told that I understand how she might have felt and will not ask him to bring food to office anytime. Then on fights started increasing between us regarding her. whenever we three had a conversation i felt like thirdwheel and felt he is showing more attention towards her, more care towards her. again a fight. Like that fights started increasing. At first he used to listen to me, but after some days he started saying like my thinking is wrong. I even told him how much I cried but he didn't bothered. I never wanted to break their friendship so I never wanted to ask him to stop talking(even though he gave me that option). I only wanted him to give me my importance but I still feel he shows equal care to both of us. Then how am I different? Later on in our every fight, he started supporting her this gave me more pain. One day he said If I leave her for you, then I may leave you for someone else, that is not my character( this is contrary to what he said previously 'I will stop talking to her if i don't want to'). I cried a lot, I don't have much friends I couldn't share this with anyone.... every moment he is only coming to my thoughts and whenever fights happen due to Aliya, I get disturbed a lot... unable to concentrate on my work... not getting interest to do anything. One day out of anger I said just stop talking to her then his expressions totally changed he became hesistant , he became very sad and said I need sometime and don't know how much( his expression is contrary to what he said 'It doesn't bother me much If I don't talk to Aliya' ). He is that much emotionally connected to her. After 5mins I pinged him saying that I am feeling very guilt about the decision and ask him not to stop talking to her. I understood finally that he still thinks I am wrong and I am tired of fighting. One day when I was very emotional I told him that I will no more bring Aliya topic in our discussion and asked him to do whatever he wants. After this, Whenever Aliya calls him or he call her he used to tell me... sometimes I felt very bad... sometimes I tried to ignore as if it didn't bothered me but didn't start any argument with him. After few days he even stopped telling me if she called him or not also. When he was not telling about Aliya's conversations I thought he understood my feelings and reduced talking with her. but one time accidently my colleague's friend told about the small conversation that my colleague and Aliya had, that's how I came to know that they had a conversation but he didn't tell me. I felt very bad, really very bad... again unable to concentrate on work feel like crying all the time... I can't ask him to stop talking to her because I don't like to do so and also afraid of having negative impression on me in my colleague's mind. at the same time, I feel very very bad whenever they meet or have a call or does something together. I cannot discuss with him about this anymore. what shall i do, this is bothering me a lot and also having effect on my career, peace and life. please suggest. I am ready to correct myself if there is anything wrong from my end. And I can surely say that If i have a boy bestfriend then he would definitely not feel comfortable and will get upset.
Ans: Dear Jia,

When two people enter a relationship, both must try to make each other feel comfortable. If you are uncomfortable with your partner speaking to his friend, who is also his ex-crush, it is perfectly normal for you to voice it. And reading your question I understood that he has repeatedly mentioned that he had feelings for her, and even wanted to sever ties because staying in touch could only further ignite those feelings. I don't see how you are wrong in letting him know that you don't like their interactions. Plus, in a healthy relationship, the partner comes first. Not friends, especially not this kind of friendship.

Just understand that you are not wrong. Even if his intentions are pure and he looks at her like a friend, you have every right to express your feelings. You made no unreasonable demand. She wasn't "just" a friend; she was always more than that, and being insecure about something like that is not uncommon.

The only thing to do right now is to tell your boyfriend that you understand that the friendship is important but you deserve someone who can pick you over everything- obviously, reasonable things. See what he does. And please remember, you actually deserve someone who would pick you. This is not an ultimatum; it's the truth.

Best Wishes.

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |6287 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Sep 13, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Sep 13, 2024Hindi
Money
Sir, I wish to invest in following MF 1. Tata or UTI nifty 50 index fund . G 2. HDFC focused 30 G 3. Mahindra Manulife multicap Or Nippon multicap..G 4. Motilal Oswal mid cap. Each will have 2.5 L investment Amt. Kindly advise Thanks..
Ans: You are considering investing Rs 2.5 lakh in four different mutual funds. This includes a mix of index funds, focused funds, multi-cap funds, and mid-cap funds. I appreciate your thoughtful selection, but it’s essential to evaluate the pros and cons before proceeding.

In this analysis, I will give you a professional yet simple overview of each type of fund. Let's ensure that your choices align with your financial goals.

1. Index Funds: Pros and Cons
You’ve mentioned the Tata or UTI Nifty 50 Index Fund. Index funds, as you know, passively track an index like the Nifty 50. While this may seem like a safe option, there are some points you need to consider:

Advantages:
Low-cost option.

Simple to understand and follow as it mirrors the index.

Decent long-term growth potential.

Disadvantages:
Lack of flexibility: Index funds follow the market. If the index doesn’t perform well, neither will your investment. This limits returns compared to actively managed funds.
No risk management: Index funds cannot switch away from underperforming sectors.
Miss out on opportunities: Actively managed funds can offer superior returns by taking advantage of market opportunities.
Since actively managed funds offer better flexibility and potential for higher returns, I would recommend focusing on actively managed funds instead of index funds.

2. Focused Funds: A Balanced Approach
You’re considering investing in HDFC Focused 30 Fund. Focused funds invest in a limited number of stocks, typically around 20-30. This allows fund managers to focus on high-conviction ideas.

Advantages:
Potential for high returns: With a limited portfolio, focused funds can give significant returns if the chosen stocks perform well.

Concentration of best ideas: Fund managers can pick the top-performing companies.

Disadvantages:
Higher risk: Because the portfolio is concentrated, if a few stocks perform poorly, it can significantly impact returns.

Volatility: These funds can experience higher fluctuations due to limited diversification.

Focused funds are ideal if you’re willing to take moderate risk. They balance high returns with some risk. Since your portfolio includes emergency funds and insurance, this could be a reasonable choice.

3. Multi-Cap Funds: Balanced Exposure to Large, Mid, and Small Caps
You mentioned either the Mahindra Manulife Multicap or Nippon Multicap Fund. Multicap funds offer exposure across large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap stocks, providing diversification.

Advantages:
Diversification: These funds reduce risk by investing across the spectrum of large, mid, and small-cap stocks.

Flexibility: Fund managers can shift allocations based on market conditions.

Disadvantages:
Risk in small and mid-cap: Although these funds invest in large caps, the exposure to mid and small caps adds an element of risk.

Performance varies: Depending on market conditions, these funds can underperform if small or mid-caps don’t do well.

Multi-cap funds are an excellent choice for a balanced approach. They give you exposure to all segments of the market, allowing you to benefit from growth in different sectors. However, there’s moderate risk involved.

4. Mid-Cap Funds: High Growth, High Risk
Finally, you’ve considered investing in Motilal Oswal Mid Cap Fund. Mid-cap funds focus on mid-sized companies, which are often in the growth stage.

Advantages:
High growth potential: Mid-caps have higher growth potential compared to large caps.

Diversification across industries: Mid-cap companies come from diverse sectors, providing broader market exposure.

Disadvantages:
Higher volatility: Mid-cap stocks are more volatile than large caps. They can offer high returns but may experience significant fluctuations.

Market dependency: Mid-caps tend to underperform during market downturns, which increases risk.

Mid-cap funds are suitable if you are looking for long-term growth and are comfortable with higher risk. Since your portfolio includes a good mix of other funds, this could be a good growth-oriented addition.

Evaluating Your Overall Portfolio
Balanced diversification: Your portfolio contains a combination of mid-cap, multi-cap, and focused funds. This creates a balanced exposure across different market segments.

Risk assessment: The inclusion of mid-cap and focused funds indicates that you’re willing to take moderate to higher risks. However, avoid over-exposure to mid-caps, as they can be volatile in the short term.

Long-term growth potential: Each fund type offers strong long-term potential, especially with the exposure to mid and multi-cap segments. You’re positioned well for growth over the next 10-15 years.

Recommendations for Improvement
Here are a few suggestions to optimise your portfolio further:

Avoid over-reliance on index funds: As mentioned earlier, actively managed funds may offer better returns. You may want to replace the index fund with a large-cap fund managed by an experienced fund manager.

Review portfolio regularly: It’s essential to review and rebalance your portfolio regularly. This ensures your investments remain aligned with your goals and market conditions.

Consider goal-specific investments: While your portfolio appears diversified, it’s essential to allocate funds specifically for long-term goals like retirement or your child’s education. Make sure your investments match your risk tolerance and time horizon.

Tax Efficiency and Growth
Another critical factor is the tax efficiency of your investments. Mutual funds, especially equity-oriented ones, are tax-efficient compared to fixed deposits and other bank-based savings instruments. The long-term capital gains on equity mutual funds are taxed at 12.5% beyond Rs 1.25 lakh of gains, making them a better option for long-term wealth creation.

By investing Rs 2.5 lakh in each fund, you’re making a decent start. However, don’t forget to review tax implications annually to minimise liabilities and maximise growth.

Final Insights
In summary, your portfolio looks strong with a mix of equity funds targeting growth. However, I suggest replacing the index fund with an actively managed large-cap fund to optimise returns. Continue monitoring your investments regularly and ensure your asset allocation is aligned with your financial goals. With proper planning and regular reviews, your portfolio can help you achieve long-term financial success.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

...Read more

Sushil

Sushil Sukhwani  |549 Answers  |Ask -

Study Abroad Expert - Answered on Sep 13, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - May 23, 2024Hindi
Listen
Career
Hi sir, i have completed BE civil engineering and having 14years of work experience in underground metro constructions. Recently my wife got H1B for North Carolina. If i have to move with her what are the possibilities for work or studies. Is there any one MS course offered by NCSU for construction management? May i know the procedures to follow.
Ans: Hi,

To begin with, thank you for reaching out to us. I’m glad to hear that you and your wife are planning to move to North Carolina and that you intend to study and work there. To answer your question, given your extensive experience in underground metro constructions, you have several opportunities if you move to the USA. You could explore roles in civil engineering firms or construction companies that specialize in infrastructure projects, as your background aligns well with large-scale construction and engineering roles. You should also consider connecting with local engineering societies or professional networks to find job openings or consulting opportunities.

Regarding your interest in pursuing further studies, North Carolina State University (NCSU) offers courses in Construction Project Management, Construction Safety Management, Risk and Financial Management, Materials Management in Construction among others. I would recommend you to connect with an expert to get a better understanding of the various courses that are available in the USA and to know about the procedures to apply for the same.

For more information, you can visit our website: edwiseinternational.com
You can also follow us on Instagram: @edwiseint

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x