Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Can I Offset Property Loss with Equity Gain?

Milind

Milind Vadjikar  |851 Answers  |Ask -

Insurance, Stocks, MF, PF Expert - Answered on Sep 27, 2024

Milind Vadjikar is an independent MF distributor registered with Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI) and a retirement financial planning advisor registered with Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA).
He has a mechanical engineering degree from Government Engineering College, Sambhajinagar, and an MBA in international business from the Symbiosis Institute of Business Management, Pune.
With over 16 years of experience in stock investments, and over six year experience in investment guidance and support, he believes that balanced asset allocation and goal-focused disciplined investing is the key to achieving investor goals.... more
Krishna Question by Krishna on Apr 11, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money

I have Long Term Capital Loss on property but Long Term Capital Gain on equity. Can LTCG on equity can be offset against LTCL on property

Ans: Yes. Investors can set off long-term capital losses from one asset against long-term capital gains from another asset as per provisions of IT Act.
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Moneywize

Moneywize   |174 Answers  |Ask -

Financial Planner - Answered on Jun 21, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 18, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
I have long term capital loss on property but long term capital gain from investments in stocks. Can LTCG on equity offset against LTCL on property?
Ans: In India, the Income Tax Act has specific provisions for the treatment of capital gains and losses. Here’s how it generally works:

1. Same Category Set-Off: Long-term capital losses (LTCL) can only be set off against long-term capital gains (LTCG). Similarly, short-term capital losses (STCL) can only be set off against short-term capital gains (STCG) or LTCG.

2. Carry Forward of Losses: If the capital loss cannot be fully set off in the same financial year, it can be carried forward for up to eight assessment years immediately succeeding the assessment year in which the loss was first computed. However, the carried-forward losses can only be set off against long-term capital gains in subsequent years.

Specific Case: LTCL on Property and LTCG on Stocks

• Long-term capital loss (LTCL) from property: This is a loss incurred on the sale of a property held for more than 24 months.
• Long-term capital gain (LTCG) from equity investments: This refers to gains from the sale of equity shares or equity mutual funds held for more than 12 months, which are subject to specific tax rates.

According to Indian tax laws:

• Set-Off: Yes, you can set off your long-term capital losses from the sale of property against your long-term capital gains from the sale of equity investments (stocks).

Example Scenario:

• LTCL from Property: Rs 10,00,000
• LTCG from Equity Investments: Rs 8,00,000

Here’s how you can handle it:

• Offset the Rs 8,00,000 LTCG from equity investments with Rs 8,00,000 of the Rs 10,00,000 LTCL from property.
• You will have Rs 2,00,000 of LTCL remaining, which you can carry forward for up to eight assessment years.

Filing and Reporting:

• Schedule CG: You need to report these transactions in Schedule CG of your Income Tax Return (ITR).
• Carry Forward Loss: Ensure you file your tax return before the due date to be eligible to carry forward the loss.

Key Points

• Tax Rates: LTCG on equity shares and equity mutual funds exceeding Rs 1 lakh is taxed at 10% without the benefit of indexation.
• Documentation: Keep all transaction records, such as purchase price, sale price, dates, and related costs.

It is advisable to consult a tax professional or financial advisor to ensure compliance with current tax laws and to optimise your tax planning strategy.

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7493 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jan 11, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jan 10, 2025Hindi
Money
Is i can change my invest money by smart wealth builder to mutual fund...after locking in 5 years
Ans: Current Situation
You have invested in the Smart Wealth Builder.
It has a mandatory lock-in period of five years.
You wish to explore shifting to mutual funds post-lock-in.
This decision needs thoughtful evaluation of costs, benefits, and alignment with your goals.

Step 1: Evaluate the Smart Wealth Builder Policy
1. Lock-In Period Completion

Check if the mandatory five-year lock-in period is over.
Policies often penalise premature exits.
2. Charges Involved

Review surrender charges if applicable after the lock-in.
Account for fund management and administrative fees.
3. Returns Analysis

Compare the policy's actual returns with mutual fund performance.
ULIPs often give moderate returns due to higher charges.
4. Tax Benefits Consideration

Ensure the tax implications of surrendering the policy.
Tax exemptions under Section 10(10D) apply only after specific conditions.
Step 2: Why Consider Mutual Funds?
1. Better Returns Potential

Mutual funds, especially equity funds, often outperform ULIPs.
Long-term compounding generates wealth more effectively.
2. Lower Charges

ULIPs have higher charges compared to mutual funds.
Mutual funds offer a more cost-effective growth opportunity.
3. Investment Flexibility

Mutual funds allow switching across schemes without high penalties.
You can easily diversify into equity, debt, and hybrid funds.
4. Transparency and Liquidity

Mutual funds disclose fund performance regularly.
Withdrawals are easier with no long lock-in periods.
Step 3: Transitioning to Mutual Funds
1. Plan Post-Surrender Strategy

Use the surrender value to create a diversified mutual fund portfolio.
Divide funds into equity, debt, and hybrid categories for balance.
2. Start with Systematic Investments

If the surrender value is significant, use Systematic Transfer Plans (STP).
Gradually transfer money into equity funds for risk management.
3. Choose Actively Managed Funds

Actively managed funds outperform passive funds like index funds.
Certified Financial Planners can guide you on selecting suitable schemes.
4. Taxation Considerations

Equity funds have favourable tax treatment over the long term.
Long-term capital gains above Rs. 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.
Debt funds follow your income tax slab for taxation.
Step 4: Steps for a Balanced Mutual Fund Portfolio
1. Equity Funds for Growth

Invest a major portion in diversified equity mutual funds.
Choose large-cap, mid-cap, and flexi-cap funds for better returns.
2. Debt Funds for Stability

Allocate a portion to debt mutual funds for low-risk returns.
Use short-term or corporate bond funds for this purpose.
3. Hybrid Funds for Balance

Hybrid funds offer a mix of equity and debt investments.
They provide stability while giving moderate growth.
Step 5: Benefits of Regular Funds with a Certified Financial Planner
1. Professional Guidance

Regular plans come with Certified Financial Planner support.
This ensures the selection of high-performing funds tailored to your goals.
2. Better Tracking and Management

Certified Financial Planners help monitor and rebalance portfolios.
They ensure your investments align with changing market trends.
3. Avoid Direct Funds Pitfalls

Direct funds lack personalised guidance, which could lead to wrong decisions.
Regular plans, with expert advice, offer better long-term benefits.
Step 6: Secure Other Financial Aspects
1. Build Emergency Reserves

Allocate a portion of the surrender value to an emergency fund.
This ensures financial security for unexpected events.
2. Review Life Insurance Needs

If you surrender the ULIP, ensure adequate term life insurance.
Term plans provide higher coverage at a lower cost.
3. Create Education and Retirement Goals

Use mutual funds to build separate goals for your family’s future.
Equity funds are ideal for long-term goals like education and retirement.
Final Insights
Shifting from the Smart Wealth Builder to mutual funds can be rewarding.

Mutual funds offer better growth, lower costs, and greater flexibility.

Evaluate your ULIP's surrender terms carefully before transitioning.

Seek guidance from a Certified Financial Planner for an optimised strategy.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7493 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jan 11, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jan 10, 2025Hindi
Listen
Money
I am 40 years old with net savings of 3k monthly. U haven’t invested in any MF or shares till date. My daughter will turn 6 next month. I want to safeguard her future studies and teenage. I have corpus savings of 1 lakh. Where to invest
Ans: Current Financial Snapshot
Age: 40 years.
Monthly Savings: Rs. 3,000.
Corpus Savings: Rs. 1 lakh.
Daughter’s Age: 6 years next month.
Goal: Secure funds for her studies and teenage needs.
Your current savings habit is commendable. Regular investments can grow into a solid corpus.

Step 1: Define Clear Financial Goals
1. Education Costs

Focus on accumulating funds for her higher education.
Estimate the cost for undergraduate and postgraduate studies.
2. Teenage Needs

Plan for school expenses and extracurricular activities.
Allocate funds separately for these milestones.
3. Emergency Fund

Maintain Rs. 50,000 as an emergency fund.
This ensures liquidity for unexpected situations.
Step 2: Start Investing Systematically
Use a Balanced Investment Approach
1. Equity Mutual Funds

Allocate 50% of your Rs. 1 lakh corpus (Rs. 50,000).
Invest monthly Rs. 2,000 into actively managed diversified funds.
Choose large-cap, multi-cap, and hybrid funds for stability.
Advantages of Actively Managed Funds

Professional fund managers aim for higher returns.
These funds adapt to market conditions.
Investing through a Certified Financial Planner ensures expert guidance.
Avoid Direct Funds

Direct funds lack personalised advice.
Regular funds give better support through a Certified Financial Planner.
2. Debt Mutual Funds

Allocate 30% of your corpus (Rs. 30,000).
Choose short-duration or corporate bond funds.
These funds provide safety and predictable returns.
3. Balanced Funds

Invest Rs. 20,000 from the corpus into balanced or hybrid funds.
These funds combine equity growth with debt stability.
Step 3: Leverage Government Schemes
1. Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY)

Open an SSY account for your daughter.
Invest Rs. 1,000 monthly for long-term, tax-free returns.
The scheme ensures her financial security.
2. Public Provident Fund (PPF)

Allocate Rs. 1,000 monthly to PPF for steady, risk-free growth.
Use it for your daughter’s education when needed.
Step 4: Build a Long-Term Plan
1. Increase Monthly Savings

Gradually increase savings to Rs. 5,000 or more.
Allocate additional income to investments.
2. Diversify Investment Portfolio

Add gold mutual funds later for diversification.
Gold offers protection against market volatility.
3. Review Investment Progress Regularly

Review portfolio performance every six months.
Adjust funds based on market conditions and goals.
Step 5: Avoid Common Pitfalls
1. Avoid Real Estate Investments

Real estate is illiquid and requires high capital.
It doesn’t align with your immediate goals.
2. Don’t Depend Solely on Fixed Deposits

Fixed deposits have limited returns.
Mutual funds can outperform fixed deposits over the long term.
3. Avoid High-Cost Insurance Policies

Skip ULIPs or endowment plans with low returns and high charges.
Choose term insurance for life coverage and invest the rest.
Step 6: Secure Adequate Health and Life Cover
1. Health Insurance

Ensure health insurance for your family.
Coverage should include yourself, your spouse, and your daughter.
2. Term Life Insurance

Get term insurance with coverage 15-20 times your annual income.
This secures your daughter’s future in case of unforeseen events.
Final Insights
Your steady savings habit is a great start.

Investing Rs. 1 lakh and Rs. 3,000 monthly can meet your daughter’s needs.

Use equity funds for growth and government schemes for safety.

Review progress regularly with a Certified Financial Planner.

This disciplined approach ensures a bright future for your daughter.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7493 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jan 10, 2025

Money
I am 58 years old working with salary of Rs.1.0 Lac monthly. Having 2 sons age 32 years and 18 years of age. Elder son is still to marry. Monthly expenses 50K, Having PPF : Rs. 35 Lacs, Retirement amount : Rs. 10-12 Lacs, PF Rs. 11 Lacs, Emergency fund : 10 Lacs, Medical policy : 15 Lacs, Rental income : 30000 from house and shop, Property : Flat worth 90 Lac, 1 shop worth 30 Lacs, Insurance : Sanchay plus - Premium of Rs. 1.5 Lacs till 2029 and will get 130000 from 2031 onwards, HDFC Pansion plan – pansion starts from 2026 as Rs. 26000 per year, HDFC SL Crest – funds accumulated 7 Lacs, Savings : RD in post office : Rs. 14 Lacs, Bank 5 Lacs, Medical policy : 15 Lacs. No Loan. How should I invest Rs. 1.1 Crores on selling of Flat to get Rs. 1.0 Lac monthly ? What should I do to have stable income in future with funds growing ?
Ans: Your Current Financial Position
Monthly Salary: Rs. 1 lakh.
Monthly Expenses: Rs. 50,000.
PPF: Rs. 35 lakhs.
Retirement Corpus: Rs. 10-12 lakhs.
PF: Rs. 11 lakhs.
Emergency Fund: Rs. 10 lakhs.
Rental Income: Rs. 30,000 per month.
Properties: Flat worth Rs. 90 lakhs and shop worth Rs. 30 lakhs.
Insurance: Sanchay Plus with Rs. 1.5 lakh annual premium and Rs. 1.3 lakh yearly return from 2031.
HDFC Pension Plan: Pension starts in 2026 at Rs. 26,000 per year.
HDFC SL Crest: Accumulated funds of Rs. 7 lakhs.
Savings: Rs. 14 lakhs in RD and Rs. 5 lakhs in the bank.
Medical Policy: Rs. 15 lakhs.
Future Asset: Rs. 1.1 crore from selling the flat.
You wish to generate Rs. 1 lakh per month from this amount while ensuring stability and growth.

Step 1: Create a Diversified Portfolio
Allocate Funds Across Asset Classes
1. Equity Mutual Funds

Allocate 40% of Rs. 1.1 crore (around Rs. 44 lakhs).
Focus on actively managed diversified funds.
Choose funds from large-cap, flexi-cap, and hybrid categories for stability.
Actively managed funds have expert oversight for better performance.
Advantages of Regular Funds

Regular funds involve guidance from Certified Financial Planners (CFP).
You benefit from professional advice and fund selection.
This ensures efficient fund allocation for your goals.
2. Debt Mutual Funds

Allocate 30% of Rs. 1.1 crore (around Rs. 33 lakhs).
Invest in funds with low to medium risk.
Focus on short-duration or corporate bond funds for stable returns.
Debt funds provide regular income and lower tax impact than fixed deposits.
3. Monthly Income Plan (MIP) Mutual Funds

Allocate 10% of Rs. 1.1 crore (around Rs. 11 lakhs).
These funds aim for steady payouts with moderate risk.
4. Senior Citizens' Savings Scheme (SCSS)

Invest Rs. 15 lakhs (maximum allowed).
This government-backed scheme ensures safety and decent returns.
Payouts can supplement monthly income.
5. Fixed Deposits in Small Finance Banks

Allocate Rs. 10 lakhs to higher-interest FDs in small finance banks.
This ensures liquidity and risk-free returns.
Step 2: Plan Monthly Withdrawals
Combine rental income and investment returns to meet your Rs. 1 lakh goal.
Use SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan) from mutual funds.
SWP allows you to withdraw monthly while the principal grows.
Rental income (Rs. 30,000) and SCSS payouts can cover basic needs.
Step 3: Evaluate Current Insurance Plans
1. Sanchay Plus

The annual premium of Rs. 1.5 lakh continues till 2029.
Returns of Rs. 1.3 lakh per year start in 2031.
This plan should be retained due to assured future income.
2. HDFC Pension Plan

Annual pension of Rs. 26,000 starts in 2026.
Retain the plan as it supplements your income.
3. HDFC SL Crest

Current accumulated fund value is Rs. 7 lakhs.
Surrender and reinvest this amount in mutual funds.
Mutual funds offer better growth potential over time.
Step 4: Emergency and Health Security
Keep Rs. 10 lakhs emergency fund intact.
Medical insurance of Rs. 15 lakhs is sufficient.
Ensure coverage for family members, including your younger son.
Step 5: Manage Future Milestones
1. Elder Son’s Marriage

Allocate Rs. 10-15 lakhs from existing RD and bank savings.
Avoid using investment corpus for this purpose.
2. Younger Son’s Education

Start a dedicated equity mutual fund SIP.
Use the PPF corpus of Rs. 35 lakhs when needed.
Tax Implications
Equity fund LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%.
Debt fund income is taxed per your slab.
Plan withdrawals to minimise tax liabilities.
Final Insights
Your current financial position is strong.

Selling your flat and investing Rs. 1.1 crore can provide Rs. 1 lakh monthly.

Ensure disciplined withdrawals and regular review of investments.

Retain essential insurance plans for future security.

A Certified Financial Planner can assist in monitoring your portfolio.

Focus on consistent income and long-term growth.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7493 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jan 10, 2025

Money
I have arount 1500000 invested in MF through an advisor. But now advisor is not giving any services. Is this any soloution to make it direct investment. And if so is it right time to switch to direct as fund value is decresed substantially due to market.
Ans: You have Rs. 15 Lacs invested in mutual funds through an advisor.

The advisor is no longer providing services, leaving you without proper guidance.

The market downturn has reduced your portfolio value substantially.

You are considering switching to direct investments to avoid advisor dependency.

Understanding Regular and Direct Plans
Regular Plans
Regular plans include an advisor’s commission in the expense ratio.

Advisors provide portfolio monitoring and personalised guidance.

Higher expense ratio compared to direct plans.

Direct Plans
Direct plans exclude advisor commissions, reducing the expense ratio.

You need to research and manage investments independently.

Requires knowledge of markets, schemes, and portfolio management.

Impact of Market Conditions on Switching
Current Market Downtrend
Your portfolio is already under stress due to market fluctuations.

Switching now could realise losses if you redeem units for the switch.

Timing Consideration
Markets typically recover over time; wait for partial recovery.

Avoid selling at a loss unless a fund is underperforming consistently.

Disadvantages of Direct Plans
Lack of Expert Guidance
Direct plans shift the responsibility of fund selection to you.

Without market knowledge, decision-making can become challenging.

Emotional Decisions
Investors often panic and redeem during market corrections.

An advisor helps maintain discipline during market volatility.

Missed Opportunities
Advisors can identify better opportunities and schemes.

Regular plans through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) offer a structured approach.

Addressing Your Current Situation
Option 1: Stay Invested and Change Advisor
Find a new advisor with CFP credentials for better services.

Continue with regular plans under the new advisor’s guidance.

This ensures professional advice and disciplined investing.

Option 2: Gradual Switch to Direct Plans
Switch only if you have the expertise to manage your portfolio.

Use a step-by-step approach; shift one scheme at a time.

Monitor the performance of the new direct plans regularly.

Avoid rushing the process, as it may lead to mistakes.

Option 3: Consolidate and Restructure
Evaluate each mutual fund for performance over three to five years.

Exit underperforming funds gradually to avoid unnecessary losses.

Reinvest in actively managed funds with proven track records.

Tax Implications of Switching
Selling mutual funds involves capital gains tax liability.

Equity mutual funds: Long-term capital gains above Rs. 1.25 Lacs taxed at 12.5%.

Debt mutual funds: Capital gains taxed as per your income tax slab.

Consider the tax impact before redeeming or switching funds.

Recommendations for a Stable Portfolio
Diversification
Ensure a mix of equity, debt, and hybrid mutual funds for balance.

Equity funds provide growth; debt funds add stability.

Emergency Fund
Keep 6-12 months’ expenses in liquid funds or fixed deposits.

Avoid using this amount for switching investments.

Regular Monitoring
Review your portfolio performance every six months.

Rebalance to align with financial goals and risk appetite.

Final Insights
Switching to direct plans is an option but requires expertise.

Retaining regular plans with a new advisor ensures professional guidance.

Assess your financial goals and portfolio performance before making changes.

Avoid hurried decisions during a market downturn to prevent losses.

A Certified Financial Planner can help optimise your portfolio effectively.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x