Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Nikunj

Nikunj Saraf  | Answer  |Ask -

Mutual Funds Expert - Answered on Oct 06, 2022

Nikunj Saraf has more than five years of experience in financial markets and offers advice about mutual funds. He is vice president at Choice Wealth, a financial institution that offers broking, insurance, loans and government advisory services. Saraf, who is a member of the Institute Of Chartered Accountants of India, has a strong base in financial markets and wealth management.... more
Garg Question by Garg on Oct 06, 2022Hindi
Listen
Money

HALLO I AM PURSHOTTAM LAL AND MADHUBALAINVESTOR LAST 20 YEARS IN MF SCHEME.
MY COMBINED INVEST FOLLOWING MFS:

1.ADITYA BIRLA SUN LIFE FOCUSED EQUITY FUND ( SIP AMOUNT 2000)/PM/21-01-2013 TO 21-01- 2025)
LUM SUMP -25000/( WHEN MARKET WAS FALLEN )
2.AXIS BLUE CHIP FUND ( SIP AMOUNT 5000) 17/3/2020 TO 17/3/2025.
LUM SUMP = 25000 @ 34.50 ( 18/9/2020)
3.AXIS MULTI CAP FUND DIRECT PLAN 
LUM SUMP- 20000@9.39 ( DATE OF INVESTMENT 4-12-2021/26-05-2022)
4.CANRA ROBECO EQUITY TAX SAVER FUND REGULAR PLAN 
SIP AMOUNT 2000/ FROM 7-07-2011 TO 7-06-2030
5. DSP FLEXI CAP FUND (SIP AMOUNT 2500/PM) FROM 25-08-2020 TO 25-08-2030)
6.DSP TAX SAVER FUND DIRECT PLAN ( 10 YEAR COMPLETE) SIP AMOUNT 2500/COMPLETE ON 10-7-2022)
PLESE TELL ME DSP TAX SAVER FUND SELL IT OR HOLD/NEXT 5 YEARS
7. ITI VALUE FUND LUM SUMP -20000
8. ICICI PURDENTIAL HEALTHCARE EETF FUND ( LUMSUMP 10000( 1.5 YEARS AGO)
9. MAHINDRA MANULIFE BALANCEDADVVANTAGE YOGNA LUM SUMP 10000/23-12-2021
10.UTI FOCUSED EQUAITY FUND-------LUMMP- SUMP-20000 ( 25-8-2021)

PLEASE TELL ME 7 TO 10 Sr No FUNDS SELL IT OR HOLD IT OR SWITCH IT?

Ans: Hello Garg pankaj kumar. My recommendation would be to switch to better schemes of the same AMC for ICICI & UTI.

ITI & MAHINDRA MANULIFE should be redeemed and reinvested in better schemes of different AMCs.

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Hardik

Hardik Parikh  | Answer  |Ask -

Tax, Mutual Fund Expert - Answered on Apr 07, 2023

Listen
Money
Hello Sir , My Self Manoj ,I am 40 years old a salaried person , and investing in MFs Since 5.5 years I have below current ongoing investments Aditya Birla FlexiCap Fund -- 7000 p.m.(SIP) HDFC Midcap Opportunities fund ---4000 p.m.(SIP) HDFC Hybrid Equity Fund ----2000 p.m.(SIP) DSP mid cap fund ---2000 p.m.(SIP) DSP Select Focus Fund ---2000 p.m.(SIP) DSP Small Cap Fund 3000 p.m.(SIP) Kotak Equity Opportunities Fund ---2000 p.m.(SIP) SBI Blue Chip Fund -----64000 (lumpsome) SBI Small cap fund ----2000 p.m.(SIP) Nippon India small cap fund ----2000 p.m.(SIP) Invesco Small cap fund ---1000 p.m.(SIP) Tata Small cap fund ----1000 p.m.(SIP) Mahindra Unnati Emerginf Business yojana ----2000 p.m.(SIP) Tata Balanced Advantage Fund -----50000 Mirae Asset Mid cap Fund ---2000 p.m.(SIP) ICICI Flexicap fund -----70000 (lumpsome) DSP Equity and Bond Fund---- 32000 (lumpsome) DSP Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund ----23000 (lumpsome) Sundaram Emerging small cap series1---17000 (lumpsome) Sundaram Services Fund---500 p.m.(SIP) Tata Flexicap Fund ----17400 (lumpsome) Baroda BNP Paribas Flexicap Fund ----50000 (lumpsome) Icici Blue chip Fund ---400 p.m.(SIP) Edelweiss small cap fund ----2000 p.m.(SIP) Axis Flexicap Fund ----19000 (lumpsome) Sundaram Small cap fund ----98000 (lumpsome) ICICI mnc fund---- 6000 (lumpsome) Axis mid cap fund ---500 p.m.(SIP) Canara Robeco small cap fund -----1000 p.m.(SIP) BOI small cap fund ----1000 p.m.(SIP) Aditya birla multicap fund----50000 (lumpsome) Kotak Multicap fund -----25000 (lumpsome) HDFC world indexes fund of fund---10000 (lumpsome) SBI Multicap fund ---1000 p.m.(SIP) PGIM India mid cap oppportunities fund ---1000 p.m.(SIP) Axis small cap fund ----500 p.m.(SIP) Edelweiss focused equity fund ---21000 (lumpsome) UTI flexicap fund ---3000 p.m.(SIP) Quant Large cap fund ---25000 (lumpsome) IDFC mid cap fund ---25000 (lumpsome) White Oak mid cap fund ---20000 (lumpsome) Sundaram Flexicap fund ---700 (lumpsome) Canara Robeco mid cap fund ---2000 p.m.(SIP) Mahindra small cap fund---2000 p.m.(SIP) Total amount of SIP is roughly around 45k per month, Since December 2016 till the date now my investment corpus in Mutual Fund has been now 30.5 lakhs , also i have 30k invested in direct stocks in Indian equity Market. I have 3 LIC policies and 1 term insurance policy of 1 crore cover,I have Bank FDs in nationalised bank for about 27 lakhs , and 3 lakhs in PPF My Goals are 1) 2 crores for my children's marriage and education 2) 2 crores for buying home 3) 4 crores for retirement life (after 10 years) In total i want to generate 8 crores in next 10 years. Kindly suggest if i would be able to achieve the goals in next 10 years,and changes if required any Regards Manoj
Ans: Hello Manoj,

It's great to see that you've been disciplined with your investments and have built a sizable corpus already. To assess if your current investments will help you achieve your goals of 8 crores in the next 10 years, let's take a closer look at your financial situation and goals.

Current Investments:
Mutual Funds: ~30.5 lakhs
Direct stocks: 30k
LIC policies and term insurance: Not considered for investment purposes
Bank FDs: 27 lakhs
PPF: 3 lakhs
Total: ~60.5 lakhs
Monthly SIP investments: ~45k
Now let's analyze your goals:

Children's marriage and education: 2 crores
Buying a home: 2 crores
Retirement life (in 10 years): 4 crores
Total: 8 crores
Assuming an average annual return of 12% on your equity investments, here's a rough projection of your portfolio's growth:

Current investments (60.5 lakhs) in 10 years: ~1.87 crores
Monthly SIPs (45k) in 10 years: ~1.05 crores
Total: ~2.92 crores
Based on this calculation, you would not reach your goal of 8 crores in the next 10 years. However, you can consider making some changes to improve your chances:

Reassess your goals: Consider if your goals are realistic and if there's any flexibility in the amounts or timelines.
Increase your SIP investments: As your salary increases, try to increase your SIP investments to accelerate your portfolio's growth.
Rebalance your portfolio: Regularly review your portfolio to ensure it's aligned with your risk appetite and financial goals. This may involve reducing the number of funds or shifting the allocation between equity and debt.
Monitor fund performance: Keep an eye on the performance of your funds and consider replacing underperforming ones.
Remember that financial planning is an ongoing process, and it's essential to periodically review and adjust your strategy. It's also a good idea to consult with a professional financial advisor to get personalized advice for your specific situation. While it might be challenging to achieve 8 crores within 10 years, these suggestions may help you get closer to your goals.

Best regards,

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11023 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Apr 24, 2024

Listen
Money
I have following MF investments all regular growth all purchases on initial offer of ten rupees. 1) Aditya Birla Sun Life focused equity fund -1200 units 2)Dsp world gold fund -500units 3)Hdfc banking financial services fund 1200. Units 4) Hdfc defence fund 1000units 5)Hdfc flexi cap fund 50 units 6)Hdfc mid cap opportunity fund 260 units. 7) Hdfc flexi cap fund 30 units 8)Hsbc value fund 450 units 9)Hsbc elss fund 500 units 10) Kotak global innovation fund 1200units 11)Kotak international REIT fund 500 units 12) Kotak flexi cap fund 260 units 13)Nippon India low duration fund 10 14)Sbi blue chip fund 1000 units 15) Sundaram focused fund 1300 units 16)Tata mid cap growth fund 350 units 17)Uti nifty 500 value 50 index fund 18100 units (Units transfered form Uti focused equity fund) 18)Uti mid cap fund 700 Units 19)Uti flexi cap fund 1000 Units 20)Uti Master Share Units 21)Uti nifty 50 equal weight index fund (Latest offer) Sbi infrastructure fund 500 units Following funds are all regular growth from Icici prudential fund. 1) Pharma health care & diagnostic fund 800 Units 2) Manufacturing fund 4300 units 3)India opportunities fund 2200 units 4) Flexi cap fund 5000 Units 5) Housing opportunities fund 2500 units 6) Balanced advantage fund 550 units 7)Psu equity fund 2800 units Sir I want to invest in Uti S&Phousing fund and Icici transaction & logistics fund 1000 units each.. Should I make some fresh investments or invest by transferring from existing Uti fund & Icici fund I am 75 years old. No urgent need of funds. Advise how-to proceed. Redy for taking risk.
Ans: Firstly, let me commend you for your disciplined approach towards investments. Your diversified portfolio reflects a well-thought-out strategy, which is commendable at any age, let alone at 75. It's heartening to see your willingness to adapt and continue investing even at this stage of life.

Given your age and risk appetite, while you're ready to take risks, it's crucial to balance it with the need for stability and liquidity. When considering adding new funds like Uti S&P Housing Fund and ICICI Transaction & Logistics Fund, you have two options: fresh investments or transferring from existing funds.

Transferring from existing holdings might streamline your portfolio, reducing the number of funds to manage. However, this could also entail exit loads or tax implications. On the other hand, fresh investments allow you to diversify further without disturbing your existing investments.

Considering no urgent need for funds, you might explore transferring from funds that might have underperformed or align less with your current investment strategy. Still, I'd strongly recommend consulting with a Certified Financial Planner to ensure a balanced approach that caters to your evolving needs while optimizing returns. After all, life is a journey, and managing your finances is a part of that journey, requiring both wisdom and adaptability.

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11023 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Apr 28, 2025

Money
pl see my mf portfolio and advise, icici bluechip fund rs 5000/- parag flexi cap rs 5000/-, hdfc flexi cap rs 5000/-,m/o large and mid cap rs 5000/- and nippon india small cap rs 5000/-(all sip monthly )
Ans: You have selected five different mutual fund schemes.

Your SIP contribution is Rs 5000 each in all five funds.

Your total monthly SIP is Rs 25000.

Your portfolio is a mix of large cap, flexi cap, large and mid cap, and small cap funds.

This shows a healthy diversification across market capitalisations.

You have chosen a good combination of growth-oriented equity categories.

Very thoughtful and appreciable planning is visible in your fund selection.

Assessment of Asset Allocation

Your portfolio has strong exposure to large caps through the bluechip fund.

Large cap funds are generally more stable and less volatile.

Flexi cap funds offer diversification across large, mid, and small companies.

Large and mid cap category bridges the gap between stability and higher growth.

Small cap exposure can give potential high returns over the long term.

Small caps are risky but rewarding if you stay invested patiently.

Your asset allocation is balanced towards growth with moderate risk.

Diversification Analysis

You are spreading investments across different market segments.

This is a smart way to balance risk and reward.

You are not overexposed to a single market capitalisation.

Flexi cap funds automatically adjust between different sizes based on opportunities.

It reduces your need to constantly track and rebalance.

Your approach reflects a strong understanding of portfolio construction.

This will help during different market cycles.

Fund Selection Quality

All selected funds belong to reputed fund houses.

Fund houses with a strong track record are always preferable.

The selected schemes are managed by experienced fund managers.

Experienced fund managers can navigate market volatility better.

Your selection of actively managed funds is excellent.

Actively managed funds outperform index funds in India due to inefficiencies.

Index funds often just mirror the market and do not beat it.

Active funds can take advantage of opportunities and protect against downturns.

Hence your preference towards active management is well appreciated.

SIP Strategy Evaluation

You are investing Rs 25000 monthly, which is Rs 3 lakh annually.

SIP method is highly beneficial as it averages cost across market ups and downs.

SIPs encourage disciplined investing without timing the market.

Your regular SIPs will help you build substantial wealth over the years.

Continuation of SIP during market corrections will add great advantage.

You are on the right track with your consistent approach.

Risk Assessment

Small cap funds bring higher risk but also higher potential returns.

Small caps are volatile in the short term but rewarding over 7 to 10 years.

Your portfolio has limited exposure to small caps, which is prudent.

Majority of your investments are in large and flexi cap categories.

This keeps your portfolio volatility under control.

Your risk appetite seems suitable for the portfolio you have built.

Gaps or Missing Elements

One point to highlight is sector diversification within funds.

Most flexi caps and large-mid caps internally manage sector exposure.

You need not add more sector-specific funds to this portfolio.

You have rightly avoided thematic or sectoral funds which are risky.

Global diversification is missing but optional depending on your goals.

For now, it is acceptable to focus on Indian growth story.

Taxation Impact

Equity mutual fund taxation needs careful understanding.

Short-term capital gains within one year are taxed at 20%.

Long-term capital gains above Rs 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.

If you redeem after one year, you benefit from long-term tax rates.

Keep this taxation aspect in mind while planning redemptions.

SIP units are treated separately for tax based on their holding period.

Sustainability and Future Readiness

Your SIP amount of Rs 25000 monthly is good but review it yearly.

As your income or savings increase, step-up your SIP amount.

Step-up SIPs ensure that your investments match inflation and life goals.

Monitor fund performance once a year but do not churn frequently.

Give your funds enough time to perform over complete market cycles.

Importance of Investing Through Certified Financial Planner

Regular plans through MFDs with CFPs add tremendous value.

Direct plans require you to do all research, monitoring, and rebalancing.

Regular plans offer expert advice, portfolio reviews, and emotional counselling.

Investors often make mistakes like selling during market falls without guidance.

CFPs ensure discipline, goal mapping, risk profiling, and tax efficiency.

The additional cost of regular plans is very minimal compared to the benefits.

You have made the right decision to invest through an expert channel.

Additional Recommendations for Better Portfolio Health

Maintain an emergency fund separately in liquid funds or savings account.

Emergency fund should be at least six months of monthly expenses.

This ensures that SIPs are not interrupted due to cash flow issues.

Continue SIPs even during market downturns without stopping.

Avoid booking profits too early from equity funds.

Rebalancing can be done once a year to maintain original allocation.

Review your financial goals annually and align investments accordingly.

Insure yourself adequately with pure term insurance, if not already done.

Avoid mixing insurance and investments like ULIPs or endowment plans.

Final Insights

Your mutual fund portfolio is well designed with a good mix.

You have selected quality funds across different market capitalisations.

SIP mode is the right approach for steady wealth creation.

Active fund selection gives you better potential than passive index investing.

Your risk profile matches your current portfolio.

Regular monitoring with the help of a Certified Financial Planner is key.

Stay invested with patience and discipline for long-term success.

Avoid unnecessary changes based on short-term market movements.

Increase SIP amount gradually in line with income growth.

Keep separate provisions for emergencies, insurance, and short-term needs.

You are on a solid path towards achieving your financial goals.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11023 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Feb 09, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 08, 2026Hindi
Money
Hi, Am a regular reader of 'Money' section, and wanted to start by thanking you for sharing valuable insights and guidance. A common comment at the end of most of these suggestions is a recommendation to connect with a Certified Financial Planner, which is where my questions are: a) Do these CFPs charge basis a % of portfolio or hourly rate or any other basis? b) Could you please advise on a criteria for selection - is there a rating or grading information that can be viewed to decide on a particular planner? Could you share a few tips on how to make an educated choice? c) Is there a repository / directory that provides CFPs by area [e.g., I went to "FPSB India", and it did provide me with area based options, but only as a list of names. Not sure if it provides any further credentials. Are there any more such sites that helps with a brief Introduction / write-ups for CFPs before connecting with them? Thank you.
Ans: Thank you for reading the ‘Money’ section regularly and for your kind words. It is encouraging to see readers thinking deeply about advice quality and not just products. Your questions are very relevant and show a mature approach to personal finance.

» How Certified Financial Planners usually charge
– A Certified Financial Planner can operate under different models
– If the CFP is also registered as an Investment Adviser (RIA):

They may charge a fixed annual fee

Or an hourly / project-based fee

Or a combination of fixed fee plus a small percentage of assets under advice
– If the CFP is also a Mutual Fund Distributor (MFD):

They do not charge fees directly to the client

They earn performance-linked commissions from mutual funds

This commission is built into the product cost and paid by the fund house
– The key point is transparency: a good CFP clearly explains how they are compensated before engagement

» How to choose the right Certified Financial Planner
– Start with credentials, not popularity
– Check that the person is an active CFP professional and not just using the term loosely
– Important selection criteria to consider:

Years of experience in comprehensive financial planning, not just selling products

Ability to cover all areas like goal planning, tax, insurance, retirement, estate basics

Process-driven approach rather than product-driven conversations

Willingness to understand your full financial picture before suggesting solutions
– During the first interaction, observe:

Are they asking more questions than giving quick answers?

Are they explaining concepts in simple language?

Are they comfortable saying “this is not suitable for you”?
– Comfort and trust matter; financial planning is a long-term relationship

» Ratings, reviews, and public information – practical view
– Unlike doctors or hotels, CFPs do not have a universal rating or grading system
– Online reviews can help, but should not be the only filter
– Consistency of thought, clarity of communication, and ethical positioning are more important than star ratings

» Directories and where to find CFPs
– FPSB India is the primary and official body that lists Certified Financial Planners
– Their directory helps you find CFPs city-wise, which is a good starting point
– The limitation, as you noticed, is that it mainly provides names and basic details
– Beyond this:

Many CFPs maintain their own websites, blogs, or YouTube channels where their thinking is visible

Articles, interviews, and long-form content give a better sense of philosophy than a simple profile
– There is no single platform today that provides detailed write-ups and comparisons of CFPs
– Hence, shortlisting 2–3 CFPs and having an introductory discussion is often the most practical method

» How to make an educated final choice
– Prefer planners who focus on planning before products
– Avoid those who push for immediate switches or drastic actions in the first meeting
– Ask clearly:

How will my progress be reviewed year after year?

How do you handle market ups and downs with clients?
– A good CFP aims for long-term discipline and peace of mind, not short-term excitement

» Final Insights
– Your approach of understanding the advisory ecosystem before engaging is wise
– There is no “perfect” charging model; clarity, alignment, and ethics matter more
– Spend time evaluating the planner, just as they evaluate your finances
– The right Certified Financial Planner adds value not only through returns, but through structure, clarity, and confidence

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Vivek

Vivek Lala  |324 Answers  |Ask -

Tax, MF Expert - Answered on Feb 08, 2026

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x