Hello sir
I am 35 year old working woman who have taken sbi retire smart 3 years ago that is in 2022 october. I pay 5lac as premium pwr year and my fund has just increased by 1.2lac.
Now my doubt ia should i continue paying the premium for 2 more years ?
My agent is suggesting me to close sbi retire smart and start with sbi smart privilege, i am confused
Ans: You have shown very good discipline by investing Rs 5 lakh per year. Starting this journey at 32 years of age is also a strong step. You are rightly reviewing now after three years. This is the right time to check suitability.
» Nature of the product you hold
– The plan you hold is an insurance-cum-investment type.
– Such plans have high charges in the first five years.
– Mortality charges, fund management, and policy admin costs reduce returns.
– In early years, fund growth looks slow due to these deductions.
– That is why you see only Rs 1.2 lakh growth after three years.
– These products are not designed for short-term wealth creation.
– They work only if continued for long horizon like 15–20 years.
» Why returns look low now
– First three to five years mainly cover initial charges.
– Money invested is not fully allocated to growth funds.
– You may feel disappointed, but this is how ULIP-style products behave.
– Equity allocation inside the plan is also restricted by fund rules.
– They cannot take aggressive active positions like mutual funds.
– So even when markets grow, your plan return is capped.
» Difference between insurance products and pure investment
– These plans combine life cover with investment.
– But the insurance cover is not cost effective.
– A pure term insurance gives much higher cover for less premium.
– Investment inside these plans is also not flexible.
– You cannot switch easily into better performing active funds.
– There are lock-ins and surrender penalties if you exit early.
– So they do not serve either insurance or investment role fully.
» Agent’s suggestion to switch product
– Your agent is asking you to stop and take another similar product.
– Remember, every time you buy new, high charges start again.
– Surrendering now means booking loss of past three years.
– New plan will again lock you for another five years minimum.
– Agents suggest this mainly because of fresh commission benefit.
– This move will not create value for you in long term.
» Better approach for your situation
– Continue current plan only till minimum premium payment period ends.
– You mentioned two more years left. Pay these to avoid penalties.
– After five years are over, you can stop further payment.
– Let the invested money stay as paid-up and grow inside funds.
– From sixth year, you can even do partial withdrawals if needed.
– At that time, shift your new savings fully into mutual funds.
» Why mutual funds are better
– Mutual funds are transparent in charges.
– They allow you to invest monthly through SIP.
– You can select active funds across large cap, flexi cap, mid cap.
– Actively managed funds adjust strategy and beat index funds.
– Index funds only copy market and cannot protect downside.
– Mutual funds are liquid, flexible, and easy to redeem.
– You also get professional management and diversification.
– With SIP and step-up option, compounding works strongly over years.
» Insurance requirement
– Do not depend on investment plans for life cover.
– Buy a separate pure term insurance for adequate cover.
– It is cheaper and gives family security at low cost.
– Keep investment and insurance separate for better clarity.
» Taxation view
– When you surrender these plans early, tax benefits may be reversed.
– So it is better to complete minimum premium years first.
– After five years, surrender or partial withdrawals do not reverse tax benefits.
– For mutual funds, taxation is simple and more investor friendly.
– Equity funds: LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%.
– STCG taxed at 20%. Debt funds taxed as per income slab.
– Tax planning becomes easier with mutual funds compared to such products.
» Steps you can take now
– Pay premiums for two more years and complete five years.
– Do not take new insurance-cum-investment plan again.
– After five years, make policy paid-up and stop new money there.
– Start SIPs in good active mutual funds with CFP guidance.
– Take a pure term insurance for required life cover.
– Build emergency fund in liquid mutual fund or bank FD.
– Plan health insurance also separately if not already covered.
– Use mutual funds for long term wealth creation and retirement goals.
» Finally
– You started early, which is your biggest strength.
– Current plan looks slow, but charges are reason, not your mistake.
– Do not surrender now, complete two more years.
– Avoid switching to another insurance product suggested by agent.
– After lock-in, shift future savings into mutual funds.
– Keep insurance and investment separate for clarity.
– This approach will create faster wealth with flexibility.
– You will gain confidence and long-term stability by this change.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment