Home > Relationship > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |599 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Apr 18, 2023

Ravi Mittal is an expert on dating and relationships.
He founded QuackQuack, an online dating platform, in 2010 with just two people. Today, it has over 20 million users in India.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Apr 16, 2023Hindi
Relationship

I am having an issue that is very difficult for me to live with but living with. It is the bad luck my wife brings when she is around. We are married for 16 years & have a 15 yrs. old daughter, we are Bengalis. My marriage was an arranged marriage But once the marriage was done I found that whatever tasks I tried to do with my wife around is bound to fail Similarly, for my wife it is the same whatever she tries with me it is a failure Examples In the early years I got an opportunity to go to the USA for a long-term assignment, when my wife was in her native for childbirth I went alone & after a few months she joined me, just within 2 months of her joining my project was abruptly closed & I was sent back. This was a wakeup call & just to see how things work I send her to our native to complete her studies & in 2 years it was smooth, but again when she returned within 6 months my Kolkata project got closed & was forced transferred to Pune, I came here alone & within a few months got another job when I brought her to Pune things started going wrong, I got smart & when things will get wrong I will send her to native for some alibi & things will look up, then get her back again things will start getting wrong & again repeat... it was a challenge as my daughter’s schooling was being effected I can give 100s of example how I purposely made sure she is not around when I had to do something critical. I see a similar situation on her side if I am not around things work out but if I am around simply luck will make sure to fail. Now things have gone to the extent that I make plans that she is not there even if I go out for minor tasks like going to an ATM .. if she goes with me the ATMs will be out of order & I have to return without the cash I am a rationalist & never believe in luck or that someone can bring bad luck .. but such has been the repetition of bad lucks & failures when my wife is around that I have succumbed. About 5 years back we started talking to astrologers, palmists & all sorts of people whom I used to ridicule & they tried all their rings, tabiz, etc but nothing worked. My wife takes care more than a modern-day housewife, cooking managing the household, shopping taking the kids to school, hobbies, & she tries to put her best sincerity into it there is no complaint. In fact, she is taken as an idol among many of our relatives & friends for her behavior & ways she maintains relations with others, this has gone to such an extent that many in our family & friends are jealous of her I don’t think it will be possible to continue like this forever but she is a housewife, doing her best We belong to the middle class I simply don’t want her to dump her with people saying all sorts of things as I feel for her BUT cannot stay with her as now she just around makes me feel nervous. I have tried several times to think positively but could never convince myself We have never talked about this in-depth as I know she is helpless & there is nothing for her to change & will only be hurting her. But many times she told me when things go wrong that she is bringing me bad luck & trouble not once but always, I have simply ignored or reasoned with her the logical thing " as the project got closed due to a change in company strategy" etc, but things turning negative when she is around & turning positive when she is not there EVERYTIME for 15 years is really something I can’t convince myself. She is only unlucky for me but for others like her father, relatives & friends she is very lucky, even 2 days ago one of our neighbors called her as someone was coming to see their daughter for marriage, she went & it worked for them, they call her because she has an ideal homely look which such critical guests think “ah they have good company” & also as the neighbors’ aged mother told” since you came our work got done since you are lucky “ Now why I am writing to you is something maybe you have never heard of. One of my office colleagues ( I will tell you he is between a colleague & a friend with whom I spend a considerable amount of time usually discussing office stuff but he is more open to me on his personal issues, I am a little conservative on this front & have never talked or will like to talk about the issues with my wife) who is childless almost my wife's age. He also was in a marriage for about 10 years but his wife has been very violent, he tried his level best met a number of psychologists, etc but things have not worked. 2 months ago he decided to divorce his wife & is now working on the legal formalities. Many a time while talking I will tell him the way my wife behaves & he will really rue if his wife was like this. From my wife's side, I know her choice & this colleague will be his dream prince.( very handsome, smart, very good talker). On asking about plans after the divorce my colleague has told me that he is looking to remarry preferring divorcee/widow as he doesn’t want to have kids at this age. His ideal wife choice matches my wife. He will be looking for after his divorce gets to some stage. I clearly know that both will be a really good match & will be eternal pairs. I am sure she will not be unlucky for him. I had invited my colleague to my home for tea (with me) so that they can meet which they did, I tactically left them alone for some time but I don’t want to talk to my wife about thinking of this colleague as this will be very offensive & if she refuses our relationship may be damaged forever. Also in no way can propose my married wife to my colleague. I don’t want to talk to anyone but create a circumstance or at the most an indirect hint that they can think of to evaluate if they want to be together. Can you please help As a closing note, I will like to mention, in Dec last year I was told that I will be layedoff from my position by June 30, I immediately started searching for other jobs but nothing worked for 3 months, after completion of my daughter annual exams I send them to my native & now I have got a job in Bangalore, I will leave my family in Pune reasoning my daughter should complete her 12th from the school here but the real reason is above. I don’t have any girl in my life but if she moves out then maybe I can think. Also, my wife is among my 3 people for whom I can do anything so that they will be happy other 2 are my mother & daughter. But I am practically abusing/punishing/torturing her just because I can survive. This colleague looks like a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for everyone to be happy. The only mental block which I need to remove is my colleagues who being a gentleman will never think about my wife & my wife’s that she is in a marriage will never think. If things don’t work out between them then I am Ok with things to go as its going but that’s just spending years. I will take care of her but maybe never stay with her with some alibi & certainly will not be thinking about another girl still she is dependent on me

Ans: Dear Anonymous,

Standing in today's day and age, how can you still believe a person can be the sole reason for someone's good luck or bad? It's just a mere coincidence, whatever has happened.

Anyways, what to want to believe is up to you; coming to the part where you need assistance: you want to leave your wife and set her up with your colleague? I hope I got that right, given how messed up it is. Getting a divorce is your choice; if you aren't happy, or in your case, if you are feeling "unlucky" you might want to end a relationship but how your wife wants to live her life after the divorce is absolutely her choice. How can you, for even a second, think of setting her up with your colleague? You might think you are being generous and trying to take care of her, but it's just you soothing your own guilt.

Leave her if that's what you want; she'll be lucky for it. But don't try to guide her life in whatever direction you want it to go.

Good Luck!

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |600 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Dec 26, 2023

Relationship
Dear, I am a 44 yr old man. I have an issue for which I need some support. We are Bengalis, I am an engineer & was married in 2004. It was an arranged marriage with all those astrological compatibility etc. My wife is 5 yrs younger than me. After my marriage I found that she was very adjusting,loving & people will say that we are an ideal match even today I will also say she is the perfect wife one can have, but one thing I noticed immediately is that she is very unlucky for me. Whenever she is around there will be no success & even things that are working will go wrong. Within 1 yr of marriage, we had a daughter. When she went for delivery I got an opportunity to go to Canada, after a few months she & my daughter joined me & my project closed & I was sent back. Knowing the issue I again sent her for higher education, when she was not around, I got an opportunity to go to the USA, again when they joined me I was sent back. I can give many examples like this, many times we talked about it and met astrologers but all will say our match is perfect. We stayed in Pune. With our daughter around we continued with our family life which I will say was happy, many people will give examples of our family & ostensibly perfect partners we were. But I will tactfully avoid her in times when it was crucial like appraisal etc, & things will work. But I always felt & feared the misfortune she brings. During Covid, this avoidance could not be done & Jan 2023 I was told to leave my job by June 2023. I tried for a lot but could not get a job with her around. In May I sent her to our native & I got a job in Bengaluru. My daughter is in Class 12 in Pune so could not shift my family. In my Pune job , I had a reportee Sumit a Marathi who became somewhat like a friend or better an office tea partner. Many times at tea he would talk about his wife's misbehavior & in the discussion I would tell him how my wife behaves, but my wife had never met with Sumit. They were a childless couple & in Dec 2022 he started living separately from his wife. I being a senior never discussed any private things like family etc with him, One day in May this year out of shear frustration I told him about the bad luck my wife brings, and he responded that" many times one may bring bad luck to one person but maybe good luck to another" Before moving to Bengaluru I called him to our house for lunch since he was staying alone & was having a problem with food etc. Something in my intuition told me that he & my wife may go well, but I never told anyone. A few days later my wife told me that Sumit had sent a Facebook friend request to her & asked me if she should accept it, I said its up to her, she accepted it. My wife has a habit of sending "good morning" messages to a lot of people & I soon found she sent one to Sumit also. I had her Facebook password so could see the messenger messages also. I soon saw Sumit responding to her & they having chats. Initially, she used to tell me about the talks she is having with Sumit but now she has stopped When I moved to Bangalore in June I used to have daily calls & sometimes hot video calls also, I go to Pune every month & we used to have physical relationship but this month when I went to Pune my wife refused getting physical with the reason of she having periods, in Nov she made a purposeful fight with me so that we dont get physical. For 2 months she doesn't do the hot video calls also but regular calls are ongoing. I am in a dilemma, I am happy with my wife but she brings too much bad luck & she has understood it. If I keep quiet now I know by Dec 24 my wife will be Sumit's wife & there traits they will be very happy. But if I even now want I strongly feel that I can stop her drifting further, but I cannot decide if I should do it. Since I think that she going away from my life will stop bringing the misfortune she brings & she & Sumit will be really good partners & will be happy. But I also feel very sad about her leaving me. Please help me with how I should decide. My daughter will complete her 12th next year & I am hopeful by June next year she will be in an engg college hostel & will not be directly affected by this change of relationship.
Ans: Dear Bappa,
I'm sorry to hear that you're going through such a challenging situation. Deciding whether to confront your wife about her growing relationship with Sumit is undoubtedly a difficult and personal choice. It's important to approach this situation with empathy and open communication. Take some time to reflect on your own emotions and the impact your wife's actions are having on you. Consider both the positive and negative aspects of your relationship, as well as your own needs and desires. Choose an appropriate time to have an open and honest conversation with your wife. Avoid accusations and blame, but express your concerns and feelings. Discuss how her relationship with Sumit makes you feel and inquire about her perspective on your marriage Reflect on what you want for your future and whether you believe your marriage can overcome the challenges. Reflect on your own feelings about your marriage. Consider whether your concerns about bad luck and misfortune are based on tangible evidence or if there might be other factors influencing your perception. Consider the impact on your daughter and how decisions might affect her as well. While she may be heading to college soon, a separation or divorce can still affect her emotionally. Consider her well-being in any decisions you make.
Sometimes, people need time for personal growth and self-discovery. This doesn't necessarily mean the end of a marriage but could lead to a stronger relationship in the future. Both partners might need to work on themselves to contribute positively to the relationship It's crucial to make decisions based on your own values, priorities, and the specific dynamics of your relationship. If needed, don't hesitate to seek support from friends, family, or professionals who can provide guidance and assistance during this challenging time.

..Read more

Anu

Anu Krishna  |1617 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Jun 04, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 01, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship
Hi Anu Its been 2 years since I got married and hv a 2 month old son. My wife is a qualified engineer and I am a consultant. My wife is showing hatred and anger towards my mom and dad. She thinks that they pampering me unnecessarily since me being a single child. Also we had a plan to settle down in abroad and started working towards that plan since marriage. Because of this we failed to understand ourselves both physically and mentally. My wife got admission masters degree in foreign university which she refused to go because we did not get physically intimate then. Also she tried pursuing the masters course from online thus quitting her job. So I started trying to go and settle in abroad meanwhile concentrating on intimacy as well. But in this process she understood that she loves her work more than anything else.Thus she rejoined her job again to another department with which she did not get the job satisfaction In the course of time, i got a job offer abroad to a different country other than the one we targeted. My wife is now blaming me that i was responsible for all the mess that happened inher life. She thinks that i cunningly used her to fullfill my abroad dreams. Also since ours was a arranged marriage , i could not develop any feelings for her as she is very average looking at the beginning and now since she is showing hatred towards me and my parents , unnecessary divorse thoughts are peeping up. Please help
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I see a few gaps in what you have shared which simply means more information is needed from you.
- She refused to go abroad, then she suddenly loved her work more and then started working again and then traveled abroad for it?

You see the gap?
How is that since you both were not physically intimate, she had decided not to pursue her Masters abroad?
What made her suddenly love her work more?
Why does she blame you when as you say that she loves her job but she is not satisfied with it?
What makes her feel that you cunningly used her to move abroad?
Also, what is the reason that she thinks that you are being pampered by your parents?

Once you have answers to these, the problem will emerge more clearly, and that will help in finding a solution to it as well.

All the best!
Anu Krishna
Mind Coach|NLP Trainer|Author
Drop in: www.unfear.io
Reach me: Facebook: anukrish07/ AND LinkedIn: anukrishna-joyofserving/

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8867 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 06, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 06, 2025
Money
I am 33 and I have around 6.4 Lakh Invested in Axis ELSS Tax Saver Fund,3 Lakh in SBI Long Term Equity Fund, 2.2 Lakh in SBI Bluechip Fund & 1.4 Lakh in SBI Focused Equity Fund. I am also running a 30000/- monthly SIP with almost 40% of it in Smallcap segment and 20% in Gold Fund. I have a NPS Auto Choice Account of 17 Lakh with a yearly addition of 1.2 lakh. How much can all this generate by the time of my retirement?
Ans: You have a strong base already. You are only 33 years old. You have around 25 years to grow your wealth till retirement. Let us analyse your total investments and long-term potential from a 360-degree view.

We will assess every part of your portfolio, the risks, the growth potential, and how you can improve it step by step.

?

Your Present Investments in Mutual Funds

You have invested Rs. 6.4 lakh in ELSS, Rs. 3 lakh in a long-term equity fund, Rs. 2.2 lakh in a bluechip fund, and Rs. 1.4 lakh in a focused fund.

?

Your total mutual fund lumpsum investment is Rs. 13 lakh.

?

These funds are mostly equity-oriented and for long-term growth.

?

ELSS funds are locked for 3 years but give tax benefits under section 80C.

?

Your mix of ELSS, large cap and focused funds shows good diversification.

?

The focus is more towards tax saving and large cap growth.

?

This is suitable for someone with a stable income and long-term view.

?

But your fund mix should be reviewed every year.

?

Some funds may underperform over time and need replacement.

?

Active monitoring gives better results than just investing and forgetting.

?

A Certified Financial Planner can help you review and restructure if needed.

?

Continue tracking performance every 6 months to stay on track.

?

?

Your Monthly SIPs and Allocation Pattern

You are running a Rs. 30,000 SIP each month.

?

40% of it is in small cap funds.

?

20% is in gold mutual fund.

?

The rest 40% seems to be in large/multi-cap or other diversified equity funds.

?

Now let us analyse this composition:

?

40% in small cap is quite aggressive.

?

Small caps are very volatile. They can give high returns but also deep corrections.

?

Keep small cap allocation below 25% in total equity SIPs.

?

You can move some SIP amount to a balanced advantage fund.

?

Balanced funds give stability when markets are down.

?

20% in gold mutual fund is on the higher side.

?

Gold is not a compounding asset like equity.

?

Over long term, gold delivers lower return than equity.

?

Use gold only for 5-10% of total portfolio. Not more.

?

The rest 40% in equity is fine, but needs regular review.

?

Maintain SIPs in regular plans through Certified Financial Planner.

?

Direct funds give no handholding or guidance when markets fall.

?

Regular plans help you stay committed and balanced.

?

Rebalancing SIPs every 12–18 months improves returns and reduces risk.

?

?

Your National Pension System (NPS) Contribution

You have Rs. 17 lakh corpus in NPS Auto Choice.

?

You are adding Rs. 1.2 lakh per year to NPS.

?

NPS Auto Choice invests automatically in equity, debt and govt securities.

?

Your allocation will shift towards debt slowly as you age.

?

This reduces risk after age 45.

?

NPS is a good retirement asset due to long lock-in.

?

But maturity proceeds are partly taxable and partly annuity.

?

So don’t depend only on NPS for retirement.

?

Use mutual funds also to build tax-efficient corpus.

?

NPS is a supporting vehicle, not a full retirement solution.

?

?

How Much Can All These Generate Till Retirement?

Let us assume you invest for 25 more years.

?

You will add Rs. 30,000 monthly SIPs. That’s Rs. 3.6 lakh/year.

?

You will also add Rs. 1.2 lakh/year to NPS.

?

Your mutual fund lumpsum of Rs. 13 lakh continues to grow.

?

Based on long-term equity CAGR of 11% to 12%, your corpus will grow strongly.

?

In 25 years, your MF corpus alone can become several crores.

?

Your NPS corpus can also cross Rs. 1 crore to Rs. 1.5 crore.

?

Final retirement wealth can range between Rs. 3.5 crore to Rs. 5 crore or more.

?

This depends on SIP discipline, fund choice, rebalancing and staying invested.

?

Direct fund investors often lose returns due to fear and wrong decisions.

?

Regular plan investors with Certified Financial Planner stay more consistent.

?

That helps in wealth creation without panic or stopping SIPs.

?

?

Improvement Areas in Your Current Strategy

Let us now talk about areas of improvement in your plan.

?

Reduce gold fund SIP to 5% or 10%. Use rest in hybrid or flexi cap funds.

?

Reduce small cap SIP exposure to 25% or less. Add large and balanced funds.

?

Monitor ELSS performance. Don’t hold old ELSS just for tax benefit.

?

Move older ELSS units to better performing funds after 3-year lock-in.

?

Use a Certified Financial Planner for fund selection and annual review.

?

Avoid investing through apps that show direct funds without guidance.

?

Do not fall for lowest expense ratio trap.

?

Many direct funds underperform due to no tracking or correction.

?

Regular plans give you peace of mind and expert handholding.

?

Start tracking goals – like retirement, home, child’s education.

?

SIPs done without goals often get withdrawn during market dips.

?

Emergency fund must be built separately. At least 6 months of expenses.

?

Do not mix emergency savings and investments.

?

?

Taxation Awareness You Must Keep in Mind

As your investments grow, tax rules will affect your returns.

?

For equity mutual funds: LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakh/year is taxed at 12.5%.

?

STCG (less than 1 year) is taxed at 20%.

?

For debt funds: gains are taxed as per your slab.

?

NPS maturity is partly tax-free, partly annuity and taxable.

?

Gold fund redemptions are taxed as per type of asset (debt-based).

?

Plan your redemptions with tax calendar in mind.

?

Avoid frequent switches. It reduces compounding and increases tax.

?

Rebalance with minimal taxation in mind.

?

?

Long-Term Stability Recommendations

You are already doing great.

?

But to ensure success for next 25 years, follow these:

?

Stick to SIP discipline no matter what market says.

?

Review SIPs every year with Certified Financial Planner.

?

Don’t change funds just because of short-term performance.

?

Add hybrid and flexi-cap funds to reduce ups and downs.

?

Avoid investing heavily in gold for long term.

?

Shift risky allocation slowly to stable funds as you near 45.

?

Use NPS only as a support system for retirement.

?

Track your wealth growth every year without panic.

?

Focus on goals and time horizon, not only on returns.

?

Build Rs. 3 crore to Rs. 5 crore corpus slowly with consistent habits.

?

Compounding rewards patience. Not shortcuts.

?

?

Finally

You are already ahead of most investors of your age. Very disciplined.

?

But success is not about starting alone. Staying the course is more important.

?

Avoid gold fund overuse. Reduce small cap exposure slightly.

?

Add stability via hybrid and balanced equity funds.

?

Don’t switch to direct plans. They seem cheaper but may cost more emotionally.

?

Investing through regular plans with Certified Financial Planner is safer.

?

Continue current path with corrections. Retirement will be stress-free.

?

Stay consistent. Review yearly. You will reach your wealth goals peacefully.

?

Best Regards,
?
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
?
Chief Financial Planner,
?
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x