Dear Sir/Madam,
I am considering investing in a commercial property located approximately 3-5 kilometers from the upcoming Navi Mumbai International Airport. I have identified a few commercial areas priced around Rs. 40 lakhs, offering a carpet area between 100-200 square feet. The anticipated average monthly rental yield is approximately Rs. 15,000. I plan to invest Rs. 25 lakhs of my own funds and would like to secure a bank loan for the remaining Rs. 15 lakhs. Currently, I have no existing loan liabilities and am employed in a salaried position. However, I am uncertain if this is a wise investment decision, especially since my bank EMI would exceed the expected monthly rental yield, and I may face additional expenses related to the property purchase. I would greatly appreciate your guidance on this matter. Thank you in advance for your assistance.
Ans: You have rightly thought about growing your wealth.
Investing with careful assessment is always a smart and disciplined move.
You are trying to create an extra income source, which is a wonderful financial habit.
However, your current investment plan needs careful re-evaluation.
Your concern about EMI being higher than rent is very valid.
You are already spotting possible cash flow risks at an early stage.
That shows your awareness and maturity towards financial planning.
Three cheers for this clarity at the beginning itself.
Analysis of Your Commercial Property Plan
Property near a new airport can seem attractive to many investors.
However, real estate investments have hidden risks and complexities.
Your rental yield expected is Rs. 15,000 per month.
But your EMI for Rs. 15 lakh loan will be higher than Rs. 15,000.
Thus, there will be a cash shortfall every month.
Also, maintenance charges, property taxes, brokerage fees will further eat into returns.
Finding a tenant immediately after purchase is also not guaranteed.
There could be long vacancy periods with no rent income.
Repairs, legal paperwork, society charges will cause unexpected additional expenses.
If tenant defaults, the recovery process is complicated and stressful.
Selling commercial property in future can also take a lot of time.
Real estate resale value depends on market cycles, which are not predictable.
Commercial spaces sometimes stay unsold or unrented for many months.
Hence, your investment capital will be locked and liquidity will become poor.
You will not be able to exit easily during an emergency.
Further, real estate price growth is slow and sometimes stagnant.
Even in prime locations, commercial properties carry such risks.
Thus, it is not ideal for generating safe monthly income.
Assessing Your Monthly Cash Flow Stability
You are a salaried person without any loan burden now.
Taking a new loan when EMI exceeds income from asset is risky.
It can cause high financial stress if job loss or salary cut happens.
Debt without guaranteed cash inflow weakens your financial strength.
Financial freedom comes by reducing liabilities, not by increasing EMIs unnecessarily.
Right now, you should focus on strengthening your cash flow safety.
Ensure your investments earn stable and predictable income for you.
Avoid entering into investments where outflows are bigger than inflows.
A mismatch in cash flow can derail your future financial goals.
Alternative and Safer Investment Strategy
You have a wonderful opportunity to invest Rs. 40 lakh wisely.
Instead of commercial property, choose safer and smarter options.
Invest in a diversified portfolio of debt mutual funds and hybrid mutual funds.
Opt for regular plans through a Certified Financial Planner for guided support.
Debt mutual funds provide stable returns and monthly income through SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan).
Hybrid mutual funds (Balanced Advantage Funds) can protect against inflation better.
Actively managed funds perform better than index funds in tough markets.
In index funds, you are tied to market ups and downs with no professional edge.
Hence, actively managed funds through a CFP offer better risk-managed growth.
Debt mutual funds taxation is reasonable under the new rules from April 2024.
Long-term capital gains are taxed as per income slab in debt funds.
For equity mutual funds, LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5% now.
Overall, the post-tax returns in mutual funds are attractive compared to property rentals.
Also, mutual fund portfolios are far more liquid than real estate.
You can sell or redeem easily whenever needed without heavy expenses.
Emergency Fund Creation Should be Priority
Before thinking about monthly income investments, secure an emergency fund.
Park 6 to 12 months of your expenses in liquid mutual funds.
Liquid funds are safe, low-risk, and can be withdrawn anytime within 1-2 days.
Never depend only on salary or investment income without a backup emergency fund.
Emergency funds give huge mental peace and financial confidence.
Health and Life Insurance Check
Ensure you have adequate health insurance cover for you and your family.
Minimum Rs. 10-15 lakh health cover is recommended individually.
Without health cover, one hospitalization can destroy your savings.
Also, take a pure term life insurance cover if dependents exist.
Avoid ULIP and endowment policies for insurance, they are not cost effective.
Pure term plan provides large cover at low premium, ensuring financial protection.
Retirement Planning Should Also Be Balanced
While creating monthly income now, plan for future retirement too.
Allocate some portion to long-term equity mutual funds through SIP.
This ensures you beat inflation and create a good retirement corpus.
Today’s Rs. 15,000 monthly expenses will be Rs. 50,000 after 20 years.
Hence, balancing current income needs and future corpus building is very important.
Important Risks If You Invest in Property Now
Cash flow mismatch (EMI greater than rent)
Long periods of vacancy
High transaction cost in buying and selling property
Maintenance cost, repairs, tenant-related legal issues
Property market volatility and slow appreciation
Difficulty in exiting when urgently needed funds
Poor liquidity compared to mutual funds
Simple Action Plan for You Now
Do not invest in commercial property at this stage
Invest in diversified mutual funds portfolio (Debt + Hybrid funds)
Start SWP for monthly income after proper fund selection with CFP guidance
Build emergency fund in liquid mutual funds (Rs. 4 to 6 lakh)
Take health insurance and term insurance cover without delay
Keep small allocation for long-term SIPs for retirement corpus
Review portfolio every 6-12 months with a Certified Financial Planner
Finally
Your goal of building a stable monthly income is very good.
However, investing in commercial property near airport is risky and unsuitable now.
Focus on low-risk, liquid and inflation-beating mutual funds for regular income.
Have a well-rounded 360-degree financial plan covering income, emergency, insurance, and retirement.
Your financial journey will be much safer, stronger, and stress-free.
Right strategy today will help you achieve real financial freedom tomorrow.
You are already thinking smartly, now just align execution with a structured plan.
If you wish to reach out personally, you can connect through my website mentioned below.
This platform restricts direct personal contact sharing. Hope you understand.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment