Jeevan Arogya LIC policy surrender: Will I get any money back?

Ans: Evaluating LIC Jeevan Saral Policy Surrender
Policy Overview
The LIC Jeevan Saral policy offers a sum assured with flexibility in premium payments and attractive features.

Surrender Considerations
1. Current Financial Situation
Assess your current financial situation to determine if the surrender value of the policy aligns with your immediate needs or long-term financial goals.

2. Surrender Value Calculation
Understand the surrender value of the policy, which may vary based on the duration of the policy, premiums paid, and applicable charges.

3. Investment Alternatives
Explore alternative investment options that may offer better returns or align more closely with your financial objectives.

4. Future Premium Commitments
Consider the impact of surrendering the policy on future premium commitments and the potential loss of insurance coverage.

Recommendation: Surrendering the Policy
Given the duration of the policy since 2009 and your current age, surrendering the LIC Jeevan Saral policy may be a prudent decision for the following reasons:

Limited Growth Potential: The policy's surrender value may not have grown substantially over the years, and continuing it may not offer significant benefits compared to alternative investment avenues.

Enhanced Flexibility: Surrendering the policy provides access to the accumulated cash value, offering flexibility to invest in more lucrative options or address immediate financial needs.

Cost-Benefit Analysis: Evaluate the surrender value against the premiums paid and potential returns from alternative investments to make an informed decision.

Next Steps
Contact LIC to obtain the surrender value and understand the surrender process in detail.
Consult with a certified financial planner to assess the impact of surrendering the policy on your overall financial plan and explore suitable investment alternatives.
Conclusion
Based on the assessment of your financial situation and the features of the LIC Jeevan Saral policy, surrendering the policy may be a viable option to consider. However, it's essential to conduct a thorough analysis and seek professional advice to make an informed decision aligned with your financial goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

Ans: Hello;

General Comments:
Jeevan Saral is an ideal example as to why people should not buy traditional endowment policies even for life insurance forget about investments.

It is an endowment policy that offers cover for long terms. However some people noticed that on maturity the lumpsum money they received from the policy was less than the sum of all premiums they paid during the policy period.

It was argued by LIC that as people grew older the premium allocation towards mortality risk was higher hence the people received less sum at maturity then total of premiums paid.

Matter went to Supreme court since people felt cheated. But LIC had all things mentioned in the policy document so they couldn't be indicted.

Later LIC closed this plan due to the negative publicity.

Specific comments:
Talk to your agent about this and he will process it by getting your kyc and neft details, original policy certificate and duly filled surrender form.

I believe it will have to be done only at the base branch from where your policy was issued.

Whatever money you are getting as surrender value( should be between 4-5L), consider it as God's blessing and reinvest it elsewhere.

Best wishes;

Ans: Hello;

My suggestion to you would be to surrender it as early as possible.

Even if you get your premiums back with some or nil return, it is okay.

Agent will tell you about loss because he will get impacted if you surrender the policy.

Recently IRDAI(Oct-2024)passed a diktat whereby the losses to investors surrendering their policy prematurely will be much lower then before.

Best wishes;
X: @mars_invest

Ans: You have clearly outlined your concern. Evaluating whether to surrender your LIC Jeevan Anand Plan 815 is a valid question, especially in a debt crisis. Let's assess this from a 360-degree financial planning perspective.

Policy Summary and Present Status
Policy Name: LIC Jeevan Anand (Plan 815)

Sum Assured: Rs. 8 lakhs

Annual Premium: Rs. 36,000

Policy Start Year: 2015

Maturity Year: 2040

Premiums Paid: 10 years completed

Premiums Remaining: 15 more years to go

You have paid Rs. 3.6 lakhs till date (Rs. 36,000 × 10 years)

Surrender Value Possibility at This Stage
After 10 years, policy acquires good surrender value.

You are eligible for a Guaranteed Surrender Value plus bonus value.

Usually, you can get 30% to 50% of total premiums paid.

That means, you may receive around Rs. 1.2 lakhs to Rs. 1.8 lakhs.

Bonus accumulated may add another Rs. 20,000 to Rs. 50,000

So, expected surrender value = Rs. 1.5 lakhs to Rs. 2.3 lakhs.

You must confirm exact amount from the LIC branch or online portal.

LIC agents may not give accurate surrender value details. Go to branch directly.

Is Surrendering Beneficial During Debt Pressure?
You are currently under heavy debt of Rs. 30 lakhs.

Every rupee counts in managing your debt pressure.

Rs. 2 lakhs recovery from this LIC policy can ease your situation slightly.

Also, you will stop paying Rs. 36,000 annually going forward.

That means extra Rs. 3,000 every month saved.

This saving can be used to clear smaller EMIs.

Stopping premium outflow will ease your monthly budget.

Also, LIC policies give very low returns – around 4% to 5% per year.

That’s not good enough when your loans are charging 18% or more interest.

Holding this policy makes no sense when you are paying 2x or 3x in interest.

Insurance and Investment Are Different
LIC Jeevan Anand is an investment cum insurance plan.

Such plans offer low insurance cover and low returns.

You must separate insurance and investment always.

Buy term insurance only for pure life cover.

Invest separately in instruments with better returns.

Do not mix the two goals. It creates confusion and underperformance.

Once Debts Are Cleared – Start Fresh Investment
When your loan burden is reduced, start SIPs in mutual funds.

But don’t choose direct funds on your own. They look cheaper but are risky.

Direct plans don’t guide you when market falls.

Regular plans via MFD with CFP support are more reliable.

Professional help matters more than 0.5% savings in cost.

Actively managed funds give consistent performance over time.

Index funds don’t adapt to market changes. They lack flexibility.

Actively managed funds are better in Indian markets due to volatility.

Invest in regular mutual funds through a Certified Financial Planner.

What If You Don’t Surrender the Policy?
You’ll continue paying Rs. 36,000 every year for 15 more years.

Total outflow will be Rs. 5.4 lakhs more in future.

On maturity in 2040, expected return will be around Rs. 12 to 14 lakhs.

That gives you less than 5% return yearly.

Against that, your credit cards or personal loans are eating 18% to 36%.

You are borrowing at 36% and investing at 5%. It is a huge mismatch.

It is not wise to keep such a policy when under high debt pressure.

Also, keeping it does not help in your credit score recovery.

It only blocks your cash flow for the next 15 years.

If You Are Emotionally Attached to the Policy
Some people feel emotional about LIC policies.

They may feel security or trust due to LIC brand.

But emotional decisions don’t work well in money matters.

Make decision based on logic, not emotions.

You can always restart investment later with better options.

But your debt needs urgent solution today.

Steps to Surrender the Policy
Visit the LIC branch where the policy was issued.

Carry original bond, ID proof, cancelled cheque, and surrender request form.

Request surrender value statement. Ask for exact amount.

Submit the request in writing and get acknowledgement.

You will get amount by NEFT in 7–10 working days.

Once received, use it immediately to reduce your highest-interest loan.

What to Do with the Surrender Proceeds
Don’t spend the amount. Use it only for loan repayment.

Target the most painful loan first – credit card or loan app.

Next, use the freed-up monthly Rs. 3,000 for loan EMIs.

Recalculate your EMI burden after that.

This will reduce your stress and improve CIBIL score.

Don’t reinvest this money now.

Focus only on debt elimination till your income becomes stable.

Final Insights
Your decision to question this policy is smart.

Most people don’t review old policies. You have taken a right step.

Surrendering this LIC policy now is a wise choice.

It gives cash today and saves money in future.

It helps you reduce debt faster and gain control over money.

Once your situation improves, you can start better investments.

Don’t feel guilty for surrendering. It is a practical step, not failure.

Financial planning is about making right choices at right time.

And this is the right time for that decision.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP

Chief Financial Planner

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

Ans: You have made a proactive step by reviewing your existing insurance-cum-investment plan. That reflects responsibility and financial awareness at an early stage of your life. Many investors delay such evaluations. But you’ve started early, and that is always rewarding in the long term.

Now, let us analyse your LIC Jeevan Umang (Plan 945) from a 360-degree lens.

» Understanding Your LIC Policy’s Nature

– This is a non-linked, with-profits, whole-life insurance plan.
– It offers life cover for the entire life and survival benefits after the premium-paying term.
– After 20 years of paying premiums, you will start getting yearly income for life.
– Also, on death or maturity (after age 100), your nominee or you will get lump sum money.

» What You’ve Paid So Far

– Commencement was on 28/07/2022.
– You have likely paid 2 full premiums of Rs 66,386 each.
– You may have paid the third instalment recently or it is due soon.
– Total payment so far is roughly Rs 1.32 lakh to Rs 2 lakh, depending on instalments completed.

» Surrender Value at This Stage

– LIC policies like Jeevan Umang build surrender value slowly in the initial years.
– No surrender value is available in the first 2 policy years.
– After 2 years, Guaranteed Surrender Value (GSV) is offered.
– In your case, since the policy just completed 2 years, GSV would be applicable.

– The surrender value is typically around 30% of total premiums paid (excluding GST, rider premium).
– In your case, expected surrender value can be Rs 35,000 to Rs 45,000.
– The amount is low because of LIC’s long-term structure and heavy allocation to initial charges.

» Should You Surrender the Policy Now?

– Surrendering early gives very low value.
– But continuing may lock your money in a sub-optimal product for 20 years.
– Let us explore this from multiple angles before deciding.

» Returns Expectation from LIC Jeevan Umang

– Internal Rate of Return (IRR) in Jeevan Umang is usually between 4% and 5%.
– This return is over the long term (20+ years) and includes bonuses.
– Bonuses are not guaranteed. They depend on LIC's future profits.
– Even in best-case scenarios, returns don’t beat inflation.

– For a young person like you, a 4% return does not create wealth.
– Mutual funds or other investment-focused tools offer better compounding potential.

» Drawbacks of Continuing Jeevan Umang

– Low liquidity: You cannot access your money for 20 years.
– Low returns: Earnings won’t outpace inflation or meet future goals.
– Opportunity cost: Better growth assets are available, especially at your age.
– Locked-in commitment: You must pay Rs 66,386 yearly for 20 years. That’s Rs 13+ lakh over time.

– If you miss premiums in between, policy may lapse or benefits reduce.
– Risk cover is also modest, compared to standalone term plans.

» Do You Need Life Insurance Right Now?

– At 27, you may or may not have major dependents.
– If unmarried and no major financial liabilities, insurance may not be urgent.
– When needed, pure term insurance gives high cover at low cost.
– For example, Rs 1 crore term cover may cost Rs 8,000–10,000 yearly.
– Compare that to Rs 66,386 for limited life cover in Jeevan Umang.

» What If You Invest the Same Amount Elsewhere?

– If you invest Rs 66,386 every year in a diversified mutual fund, returns can be far superior.
– Over 20 years, assuming conservative 10% return, the corpus may reach Rs 38–40 lakh.
– That’s significantly more than what Jeevan Umang can deliver.
– Mutual funds are flexible and liquid. You can pause, increase or redeem as needed.
– You stay in control of your money.

» Actively Managed Mutual Funds vs LIC

– Mutual funds are meant purely for wealth creation.
– LIC plans mix investment and insurance, which dilutes both.
– You get transparency, flexibility, and higher return expectation in mutual funds.
– Active fund managers dynamically rebalance based on market conditions.
– This agility is absent in traditional insurance plans.

» Why You Should Avoid Direct Mutual Funds

– Direct plans may seem cheaper due to lower expense ratio.
– But without expert guidance, wrong choices can ruin returns.
– Lack of goal alignment, poor rebalancing, or overexposure are common risks.
– A Certified Financial Planner (CFP) partnered MFD can help guide your journey.
– Regular plan investors get personal advisory support at no extra effort.
– This ensures correct fund choice, periodic reviews, and disciplined investing.

» What To Do After Surrendering Jeevan Umang

– Surrender the policy to avoid locking funds in a low-yield plan.
– The surrender amount may be small, but the future savings can be large.
– Use future Rs 66,386 annual amount in a diversified mutual fund SIP.
– Create a target-based portfolio based on your long-term goals.
– Get a pure term plan if insurance is needed. Keep it separate from investments.

– Build emergency fund for liquidity.
– Keep health insurance in place for protection.
– Align all financial moves to future goals, not just product features.

» Handling Emotional Attachment with LIC

– Many investors hesitate to exit LIC due to legacy, family belief, or peer advice.
– But financial decisions must serve your goals, not legacy systems.
– Being loyal to LIC doesn’t mean staying in unsuitable products.
– A professional and independent outlook is better than emotional dependency.

» Final Insights

– You’ve started financial introspection early, and that’s commendable.
– Your LIC Jeevan Umang is better suited for those needing low-risk, long-term assurance.
– It does not match the return expectations or flexibility needs of a young earner.
– Surrendering now, though slightly loss-making, frees you for better options.
– That gives you long-term control, agility, and compounding advantage.

– You can rebuild faster with the right mutual fund SIP strategy.
– Keep protection and investment separate always.
– Choose regular plans and consult a qualified CFP for best results.
– Focus on goal-based investments, not product-oriented approaches.
– This step today will make a huge difference to your financial future.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment