Home > Career > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Can I pursue MS in Computer Science after Mechanical Engineering?

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |10853 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jan 15, 2025

Nayagam is a certified career counsellor and the founder of EduJob360.
He started his career as an HR professional and has over 10 years of experience in tutoring and mentoring students from Classes 8 to 12, helping them choose the right stream, course and college/university.
He also counsels students on how to prepare for entrance exams for getting admission into reputed universities /colleges for their graduate/postgraduate courses.
He has guided both fresh graduates and experienced professionals on how to write a resume, how to prepare for job interviews and how to negotiate their salary when joining a new job.
Nayagam has published an eBook, Professional Resume Writing Without Googling.
He has a postgraduate degree in human resources from Bhartiya Vidya Bhavan, Delhi, a postgraduate diploma in labour law from Madras University, a postgraduate diploma in school counselling from Symbiosis, Pune, and a certification in child psychology from Counsel India.
He has also completed his master’s degree in career counselling from ICCC-Mindler and Counsel, India.
... more
Asked by Anonymous - Jan 15, 2025Hindi
Listen
Career

Hello Sir, I’m back to you with a question . Sir, doing mechanical in top nits or iiits or bits, what are the possibilities to do ms in computer science. I keep hearing from everyone to go for cse to do ms cs , but my daughter prefers good college first and then cse, based on her capability it’s extremely difficult to get cse in tier1 , so she says I will do mechanical in tier 1 and do ms cs abroad. Please guide on the pros , cons Sir

Ans: Pursuing Mechanical Engineering at top-notional institutes like IIT, NIT, IIIT, or BITS or any other NIRF-Ranked Engineering It may please be noted that if your daugther performs well in 1st Year of her BE/BTech, she will be upgraded to CSE Branch (based on the Institute's Internal Sliding Policy). Colleges offer advantages such as a strong alumni network, branch flexibility, and a strong resume for MS admissions. Students can enroll in elective courses in programming, data structures, and computer applications to prepare for an MS in CS.

However, transitioning from Mechanical to CS for an MS overseas can be challenging due to the need for prior knowledge in CS principles. With more self-learning and certificates, it is possible. Additionally, CS is tough for MS admissions in the US, and students may have to create a strong profile through internships, online courses, and certifications in CS domains without a CS degree.

To ensure a seamless transition, students should select electives in programming and computer science based on their undergraduate course (if the institute allows). Online programs for courses in data structures, Python, and artificial intelligence can be found on CS-oriented sites like Coursera, edX, or NPTEL. Summer internships involving data analysis, coding, or automation projects can also be sought. Multidisciplinary initiatives like mechanical engineering automation or computational fluid dynamics (CFD) can also be explored.

If your daughter's main goal is to pursue an MS in CS, it is better to consider Tier 1 Institutes with CS or IT branches and top-tier institutes with Mechanical focus actively pursuing CS. All the Best for Your Daughter's Prosperous Future.

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careeers | Health | Money | Relationship'.
Asked on - Jan 16, 2025 | Answered on Jan 16, 2025
Listen
Thanks a lot for your most valuable inputs Sir. Her aim is to get into CS or MnC or ECE in tier 1 only. If not she wants to go till Mechanical in the tier 1’s. She is ready to take even mining in top 8 IITs and get upgraded Sir, is that a good option?
Ans: Mining Engineering? NOT Recommended.
Asked on - Jan 17, 2025 | Answered on Jan 17, 2025
Listen
Oh ok Sir, what are the lower branches we can prefer in top 8 IITs ?
Ans: IIT-Madras - Naval Architecture | Civil | Biological Science | Ocean Engineering - For Females including Supernumerary. Expected AIR between 10000 to 14500. IIT-Bombay - Chemistry - AIR: 11000. IIT-Delhi - BioTech | Civil | Production | Textile - AIR: 9000 to 11000. IIT-Kharagpur - Aerospace | Agriculture | Geology | Architecture | BioTech | Chemical | Civil | Economis | Industrial | Manufacturing | Mechanical | Metallurgy | Mining | Ocean | Physics - AIR: 10000 to 20000
Asked on - Jan 17, 2025 | Answered on Jan 19, 2025
Listen
Great info you have given Sir, big thanks. Pls don’t mind asking repeated questions Sir. What is your view on iiitdm Kanchipuram or iiiit trichy for cse or ece, we are from Chennai. Also in top 3 NITs can we opt any branches or we should ignore some branches.
Ans: Seems, you/your daughter both are more inclined towards NIT/IIIT than the Branch. Please try to avoid some branches as her long term goal is to pursue MS-CS abroad. It is also recommended to appear for 5-7 more entrance exams instead of relying only on JEE. SSN-Chennai (which also is one of the best colleges in TN) can be one of the options. COMEDK also can be applied. When time permits, watch EduJob360 recently uploaded videos on JEE / Entrance Exam Preparation Tips & Counselling Process etc.
Asked on - Jan 19, 2025 | Answered on Jan 20, 2025
Listen
Yes Sir, her aim is IITs/NITs/IIITs/BITS , other options are SSN CSE/ECE/Mech thru mgmnt quota or RVCE or BMS CSE/ECE/Mech
Ans: Good. It is recommended to directly contact the College Authorities regarding the Management Quota at this time. You may approach the admission counter or office staff, lab assistants, or librarians, ensuring to verify their ID cards, to inquire about basic information. Steer clear of third-party agents and scams.
Asked on - Jan 23, 2025 | Answered on Jan 24, 2025
Listen
Sure sir, for SSN , RVCE and BMS, management quota is through merit or is there other means too. BTW, my daughter didn’t do her mains well. Now she is focusing on board exam, jee mains left out syllabus and bitsat solely. Sir, pls share pros and cons of these 3 private colleges , that will help me a lot. Can we opt till mechanical here?
Ans: Merit is not relevant in management quota. You will be paying the capitation fee or donation. Just review the RVCE website, which makes clear the capitation fee. For CSE (Core), for instance, you will have to pay for 4 years (including capitation fee/tuition fee) roughly 68.00 Lacs. Thirty to forty percent less BMSCE than RVCE. You can try some other TN colleges too, like PSG of Coimbatore etc.
Asked on - Jan 24, 2025 | Answered on Jan 25, 2025
Listen
Sir, is it really worth to pay 68 lacs , if yes pls share few strong reasons so that it will help us to decide, even for BMS. My daughter is looking for a good campus life, infra , exposure and growth
Ans: NO.
Asked on - Jan 26, 2025 | Answered on Jan 28, 2025
Listen
Order of CSE preference is RvCe> bms> ms ramaih > pes , right sir? Also is it good to prefer AI in RVCE or core CSE in BMS?
Ans: It is advisable to choose Core CSE over specialization. By the end of the 2nd or 3rd year, your daughter can develop expertise in a specific domain by pursuing certification courses or opting for specialization subjects offered in college.

However, if she has a strong inclination toward specialized fields like AI, ML, or Data Science and possesses a solid foundation in Mathematics, she may consider specialization. Regardless of her choice, continuous skill enhancement during and after graduation will be essential for long-term success.
Asked on - Feb 12, 2025 | Answered on Feb 12, 2025
Listen
Sir, my daughter was able to get only 89.3 in her 1st mains attempt. Now she is focusing on boards , BITS , UGEE, Comedk , SSN alone.
Ans: Good. She can allocate at least 20-30% of her time to Entrance Exam preparation alongside her Board Exam. Keep BITS as her last option, as she will need a minimum score of 260 for CSE branches. Focus more on 2nd JEE Attempt & COMEDK/UGEE. All the BEST.
Asked on - Feb 12, 2025 | Answered on Feb 13, 2025
Listen
She is scared to focus more on mains , instead she wants to focus on BITS saying she has got more time, also cbse board prep will more help for bits and competitive exams too. Focusing fully on bits and competitive exams from now on won’t it help to get CSE or 260 marks Sir?
Ans: She can, but has to smartly & strategically prepare for BITS.
Asked on - Feb 26, 2025 | Answered on Feb 26, 2025
Listen
Please guide how to Siir
Ans: Review Mistakes & Complex Questions: Your daughter should revise all the wrongly answered, complicated, lengthy, and difficult questions she has encountered over the past 2-3 years.
Concept & Formula Revision: Regularly revisiting key concepts and formulas will strengthen her understanding and recall.
Mock Test Practice: She should continue attempting online and offline mock tests, especially those structured similarly to BITSAT.
Time-Bound Practice: Solving time-bound mock tests from the past 10 years will significantly boost her confidence and exam readiness.
Analyze Mistakes: Most importantly, she must thoroughly review all incorrectly answered questions from her mock and practice tests to understand and rectify her mistakes effectively.
Asked on - Mar 12, 2025 | Answered on Mar 13, 2025
Listen
Sure Sir, except CS all board exams are over, she has started preparing solely for BITSAT. What’s your view on LPU Punjab for CSE to rely as last option if we don’t get CSE in Tier 1 and Tier 2 colleges. Please guide Sir
Ans: Lovely Professional University (LPU), located in Punjab, offers a comprehensive educational experience with modern infrastructure, diverse academic programs, and strong placement opportunities. However, if your daughter is based in Southern India, where multiple reputed institutions are available, you may want to carefully evaluate whether LPU is your daughter's preferred choice.

If securing admission in Tier 1 or Tier 2 colleges is not an option, LPU can be considered as an alternative, depending on your daughter's course preferences and career goals. It’s always advisable to research faculty, curriculum, industry exposure, and overall student experience before making a final decision.
Asked on - Mar 19, 2025 | Answered on Mar 20, 2025
Listen
Ok sir, we want to keep it next to SSN, RVCE,BMS and before VIT and SNU , Hope it’s a good decision?
Ans: Yes. Smart Decision.
Asked on - Apr 04, 2025 | Answered on Apr 04, 2025
Listen
Hi Sir, Hope you are doing good. My daughter has completed her jee mains 2nd session, has done well. She is confident in getting 140 marks Sir, what would be her approx percentile and what colleges and courses can she can get. I know it’s early to ask, but I’m curious to know the current situation so that to plan private exams accordingly, please help Sir
Ans: Scoring 140 marks in the JEE Main April session generally corresponds to a percentile range of approximately 95.5 to 97.6. Based on this performance, it's likely that her COMEDK rank could fall below AIR 1000. This significantly boosts her chances of securing admission into one of the top three engineering colleges in Bengaluru.
Asked on - Apr 04, 2025 | Answered on Apr 05, 2025
Listen
Ok Sir, she may get Mechanical engineering at NIT trichy or cse at Iiitdm Kanchipuram I think. In such case which is best along with rvce cse.
Ans: Prefer NIT-T-ME.
Asked on - Apr 13, 2025 | Answered on Apr 13, 2025
Listen
Sir, We checked the answer keys that for released for jee mains 2nd session, getting very bad score, looks like it’s tough to get qualified for Advanced being in General category. Now our full focus is on UGEE, Bitsat, SSN , Comedk and LPU. Please give some guidance and also about the management quota and amount in RvCE , BMS/Ramaiah for CSE .
Ans: MQ Seat is very costly in RVCE, followed by BMS & MSRIT. Let him appear for COMEDK. Hope he will score below 2K Rank.
Asked on - Apr 13, 2025 | Answered on Apr 14, 2025
Listen
Sir, if she scores below 2k , can we get cse in rvce?
Ans: NO. RVCE needs below AIR-400 in COMEDK. Can try for BMSCE or MSRIT. But based on her performance in her JEE-April Session, chances are more she will score below AIR-500. However, have BMSCE & MSRIT as back-up options. If you wish and possible for you, can have SNUCEE (Shiv Nadar University Entrance Exam) as one more option. Last date for 5th Phase Exam is 29th April & 6th Phase is 11th May 2025. Please check its website.
Asked on - Apr 14, 2025 | Answered on Apr 17, 2025
Listen
Sir, we have applied for SNU entrance, but they don’t have only IOT but not CSE.
Ans: It has a lot of campuses. Check what programs each campus offers.
Asked on - Apr 22, 2025 | Answered on Apr 23, 2025
Sure, how about doing BPharm at Bits, how can we enhance our profile other than core pharma side.
Ans: Please elaborate on your question. The 2nd part of the question is not clear.
Asked on - Apr 23, 2025 | Answered on Apr 25, 2025
Sir, how about taking BPharm in BITS Pilani, please share your inputs on the scope of this branch, what other career options she can choose other than core pharma by taking bpharm.
Ans: B.Pharm Program in BITS Pilani offers excellent industry exposure through their Practice School internship model. Graduates from BITS are well-placed in top pharma, biotech, and healthcare companies. The program prepares students for higher education pathways like M.Pharm, MBA (Pharma/Healthcare), MS abroad, or PhD in pharmaceutical sciences. Beyond core pharma roles, students can explore non-core career options such as healthcare data analytics, regulatory affairs, pharmacovigilance, MBA (Pharma/Healthcare Management), patent law, clinical research management, medical writing, and entrepreneurship in health-tech or wellness startups. If your daughter has an interest in biology, chemistry, and healthcare innovation, and wants the flexibility to move into management, tech, or global roles, B.Pharm from BITS Pilani is a smart and versatile option.
Asked on - Apr 27, 2025 | Answered on Apr 28, 2025
Sir, excellent inputs which gives big confidence . How about PESU ring road Bangalore, based on her jee main score she may get cse I think sir.
Ans: STRONGLY RECOMMENDED. No. 1 University in Karnataka. Records of successful placement. 0% ragging until 2024. However, hostel food will be below average or average, which is pertinent to nearly all colleges with the exception of those that charge an exorbitant fee, such as BITS.
Asked on - May 05, 2025 | Answered on May 09, 2025
Thank u Sir. Currently my doubt is to choose core CSE since everyone are running behind it or should she choose ECE or Electronics& Computer engineering which is evergreen one. At this point she is confused on she doesn’t want only coding part if cse or tough curriculum part if ece. As I said before she mostly will do MS but couldn’t confirm at this moment. Currently she is capable of getting CSE at VIT Chennai ( just as a back up) cat 1 or 2. Please clear our confusions Sir.
Ans: It’s a good idea to keep VIT as a backup option. Before confirming admission, make sure to check VIT’s refund policy in case you decide to withdraw your seat. As COMEDK is scheduled for tomorrow, it’s advisable to give it her best shot and aim to secure admission to one of the top 3-4 colleges through it. All courses have their own merits and demerits, Madam. Due to technological advancements and the changing job market, most courses will require continuous skill upgrading. Let your daughter complete all her exams first. Then, based on her scores, location preference, college reputation, and placement records, shortlist around 3-4 colleges. Finally, choose the one that aligns best with her academic goals and future prospects.
Asked on - May 11, 2025 | Answered on May 12, 2025
Sir, she has got CSE AI+ML Cat2 at VIT Chennai, we are blocking it as a safer option. She wrote her comedk , it was difficult and much lengthy I believe, with such tough cutoffs not sure whether she can get in top 3 comedk colleges . With her 89 percentile what can she get in PESu sir? MET and Bits are pending, your opinion on MET Manipal or Bangalore as back up option compared to VIT Sir?
Ans: It’s great that you have secured a seat in VIT Chennai - AI & ML.

Regarding COMEDK, apart from the top options like RVCE, BMSCE, and MSRIT, you may consider DSCE (Dayananda Sagar Main Campus), CMR, and BIT. These colleges also offer good opportunities.

With an 89 percentile, getting into the PES University Ring Road (Banashankari) Campus may be challenging. However, admission to the Electronic City Campus is possible, though it may not be the most recommended option.

For BITS, the cut-off for high-demand branches typically ranges from 290 to 320 out of 390 marks. The BITSAT exam is moderately difficult, positioned between JEE (Main) and JEE (Advanced), with a higher number of questions and limited time, requiring efficient time management.

As for MIT, it is known for its good infrastructure and placement records, supported by a strong NIRF ranking. However, it might not be ideal for everyone. It is advisable to visit the campus personally, interact with current students, and gather feedback on various aspects before making a final decision.
Asked on - May 23, 2025 | Answered on May 24, 2025
Sir, she has secured 2970 rank in PES based on JEE, what branch and campus she will get , also what options are best to opt for ? Also share how campus life and academics in PES will be, can we consider it on top of VIT or MIT CSE ?
Ans: With a rank of 2970 in PES University admission, your daughter is likely to secure a preferred branch like CSE or ECE at the RR Campus, which offers excellent academics, infrastructure, and vibrant campus life. PES is known for its updated curriculum, experienced faculty, and strong placement network, although recent hiring has seen some fluctuations. Compared to VIT and MIT Manipal, PES generally offers comparable or better academic rigor and placement opportunities, along with a more active campus culture. Considering all factors, PES University is a strong choice for engineering aspirants, especially for those seeking a balanced environment of academics, extracurriculars, and industry exposure.
Asked on - May 28, 2025 | Answered on May 29, 2025
Thanks a lot sir, my daughter has scored 85 in comedk, what rank is expected and what college and course can we expect in first round. Also , any chance of getting cse in rvce/bms/msrit in any rounds ?
Ans: Before answering to your doubt, just wanted to suggest that you prefer only RR Campus of PES (NO Electronic City/Other Branches). Good campus but food will be average/below average only. Now regarding her COMKED Score, With a COMEDK score of 85, your daughter’s expected rank is around 12,000–15,000. Admission to CSE in top colleges like RVCE, BMSCE, and MSRIT is unlikely in the first round, as these close below rank 10,000. With 85 marks in COMEDK (rank ~10,000–11,000), admission to CSE in top colleges like RVCE or BMSIT is unlikely. However, good chances exist in reputed colleges such as Bangalore Institute of Technology, Dayananda Sagar College of Engineering, PES University, Acharya Institute of Technology, CMR and Ramaiah Institute of Technology for branches like ECE, IT, Mechanical, and Civil. Being flexible with branch choices and participating in multiple counselling rounds will improve admission prospects. Fill out maximum number of choices of preferred colleges/branches in COMEDK Counselling Process.
Asked on - Jun 06, 2025 | Answered on Jun 07, 2025
Sure Sir. Her PES jee rank is 2972 and rank is 3055. Like you suggested , we visited Manipal campus and happy with everything in Manipal. This year onwards there is no option in choice filling on any specialisations in Manipal, so I think no of cse seats will be more. My daughter is aiming CSE in Manipal main campus , is there chances in first round or do we need to wait for further rounds. Also in PES we need till ECE in RR campus, is it possible in any rounds? Also pes team said if we are not opting the seats that is given and want to go for next round, we might lose the allotted seat and also can’t expect our desired seat in upcoming rounds. Please give us clarity on how it works and what should we do?
Ans: With a MET rank of 3,055, securing CSE at MIT Manipal in the first round is unlikely (2024 Round 1 cutoff: ~1,633), but feasible in later rounds as cutoffs typically drop by 30–40% by Round 3. For PES RR ECE, your PES JEE rank of 2,972 aligns with 2024 cutoffs (~3,000–3,200), making it accessible in early rounds. However, declining a PES seat to wait for Manipal risks losing both, as PES does not guarantee seat retention across rounds. Prioritize PES RR ECE if institutional reputation and location matter, or hold for Manipal CSE in later rounds if branch preference is critical, accepting potential vacancy risks. Confirm if Manipal allows intra-campus sliding post-allotment to upgrade branches without losing the initial seat.
Asked on - Jun 10, 2025 | Answered on Jun 11, 2025
Sir, my daughter has got MIT Manipal CSE in 1st round ( they have clubbed all specialisations to the core CSE ) , also got PES ECE RR campus. As you know she has VIT Chennai CSE AIML with her. We are planning to migrate to Bangalore for a better lifestyle, career and for my daughter’s college. We want her to have an overall growth in both academics and other co curriculum and extra curriculum activities. Same time she wants to pursue MS abroad in future. You have been my personal mentor for last 1.5 years on this regard. Now please help me to choose the best for my daughter which in turn is for ourselves too. Money is not a big concern on this regard. This is my personal request, please don’t share it publicly Sir
Ans: Order of Preference: PES ECE for holistic growth, followed by VIT AIML for specialization, or MIT CSE only if confident in managing academic pressure & please note its culture/non-academic atmosphere, which might not be suitable for some students.
Career

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |10853 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on May 30, 2024

Listen
Career
Hello experts!! My daughter has appeared in her 12 board examinations this year and wants to pursue Engineering in her career. She scored 94 percentile in JEE mains and preparing for JEE advance. She still has BITSAT and IISER exams to appear at. To be on the safer side, we has applied for a seat at SRM, VIT and Thapar also. She has been alloted CS at SRM main campus and CS (AI and ML) at VIT Chennai. Now, the confusion is whether we should opt for SRM/VIT or wait for BITS, JEE advance and Thapar results. Also, please clarify is she persues CS (AI and ML) at VIT, will she be eligible to apply for Masters in main CS stream.
Ans: Mr. Amit,

Congrats to your daughter who scored 94 percentile in JEE Main.

Please note the following:

As far as the 94 percentile in her JEE Main is concerned, the All India Rank is between 60 to 70000 and it might be difficult for her to get admission into any one of the reputed IITs for CS Branch (or) getting a decent rank through JEE Advanced. So, chances are very less here.

Now coming to other options, compared to VIT, SRM is the better-ranked University as far as Southern India is concerned, with good job placement records, especially from SRM Main Campus at Kattankulathur in Chennai.

Regarding BITSAT Entrance Exam, it is slightly more difficult than JEE Advanced due to more questions candidates have to attempt with less time. So, if your daughter scores around 330 out of 390, then she will be able to get admission into CS.

As far as IISER is concerned, it offers Research-based Programs. It considers JEE Main Score & conducts its own Entrance Exam. However, it is suggested only if your daughter is interested in RESEARCH and secondly, he has to choose the right stream option. As she has to do a lot of Research, IISER will be more stressful, compared to Engineering Programs. If she is confident, she can go ahead with IISER.

Regarding Thapar University, as around 85% of UG Students got placed in 2023, your daughter can try this University as one of the best options.

Your daughter can pursue Master in CS, after completing her CS (AI & ML) with most of the Universities / Colleges both in India & Abroad.

Hope I have clarified all your doubts, Mr. Amit.

If you need any other clarifications / have questions, please ask me.

With Best Wishes from RediffGURU for your Daughter.

Nayagam PP
EduJob360
https://www.linkedin.com/in/edujob360/

..Read more

Latest Questions
Kanchan

Kanchan Rai  |646 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Dec 12, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 07, 2025Hindi
Relationship
Dear Madam, I was a bright student during my school days and my plan was to become a civil servant but that did not succeed even after several attempts. With the advise of my brother i went ahead and pursued Masters at a normal university in Sydney. I did internship and continued staying with my job though it wasn't my field of study. After that what came as a shock was my brother's divorce. We don't know what is the actual issue till date but I tried a lot to fix the gap by talking to his ex-wife but they were very orthodox. I couldn't see my brother suffer because he had planned and arranged so much for her. I had no choice then so i try to harm his ex-wife by spoiling her reputation thinking she will come back for him. In the mean time i got married to a girl who was her relative too thinking my wife can help us in some case but she turned out to be completely in the opposite direction. She was probably convinced by my brother's ex-wife or their relatives that she is not coming back. Even then my brother tried to go meet his ex-wife through many channels. My wife did not help him at all in any aspect. Finally the divorced happened and everything ended. Now we have sought several proposals but nothing seem to be a good fit for him. Most of the girls whom we met on matrimonial sites are fake profiles with something hidden or falsely represented. I would say my brother escaped all this. But we are worried about his life now as he is already in his 40's and he seem to be struggling for a good job and finance. He is very picky probably but doesn't talk much to all of us. Sometimes he even says the game is over so no point looking at a second marriage. My wife and he fought once when he visited us because she didn't want him in our house and she created a fight putting me in the front. After that he stopped coming to our house or see us or talk to us. Things even gets worse sometimes when her brother comes and visits us and stays at our house which my parents don't like. My parents argue that your brother was not allowed to stay for few months then how come her brother is allowed for several months. What kind of partiality is that? I feel i could not do anything for him despite the fact that he is my only brother. He is good at heart and looked after me when i went abroad financially and even came to meet me few times. I tried to send him money, gifts but he is still the same. He communicates with our parents but not with me nor my wife anymore. Kindly give us a good advise.
Ans: Your brother’s distance is not a rejection of you. It is his way of protecting himself. He went through a difficult marriage, an emotional collapse, and then watched people around him — including you — react out of desperation to fix things for him. Even though your intentions came from love, he may have associated those actions with more pain and pressure. When a person has been wounded, silence feels safer than conversation. His withdrawal simply means he is tired, not that he dislikes you.
You also need to understand that the guilt you are carrying is heavier than it needs to be. You tried to intervene in his marriage because you wanted to protect him, not because you wanted to cause harm. Looking back now, with more maturity and clarity, you see the mistakes, but at that time, you were acting out of fear and love. This is why it’s important to forgive yourself instead of punishing yourself over and over.
The conflict between your wife and your brother only added another layer of stress, because it forced you into choosing sides. Your wife reacted emotionally, your brother pulled away, your parents questioned the imbalance — and in the middle of all this, you lost your sense of peace. But their disagreements are not failures on your part. They are the natural result of people operating from insecurity, fear, and past hurt.
What needs to happen now is a shift in your role. You cannot continue trying to solve everything for everyone. You cannot carry your brother’s marriage, your wife’s fears, and your parents’ judgments all at once. It’s time to step out of the role of rescuer and step into the role of a grounded, calm brother who offers presence, not solutions.
Rebuilding your bond with your brother will not come from pushing proposals, sending gifts, or trying to fix his life. It will come from offering him emotional safety. A simple message, expressing that you are sorry for any hurt, that you care for him, and that you are available whenever he feels ready, will speak louder than any effort to arrange his future. Once you send such a message, the healthiest thing you can do is give him space. Sometimes relationships repair themselves in silence, when pressure is removed.
And for yourself, healing begins when you stop believing that every problem in the family rests on your shoulders. You have given more than enough over the years. Now you deserve emotional rest. You deserve peace. You deserve to feel like a brother, not a crisis manager.
Your brother may take time, but distance does not erase love. When he feels safe, he will come closer again. Your responsibility is not to force that moment, but to make sure you are emotionally steady and ready when it happens.

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10881 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Dec 12, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 11, 2025Hindi
Money
Dear sir This is regarding my mother's financials. She is 71 years old and she earns a pension of 31k p.m. She has FD's worth 60 lacs and earns interest income of Rs.25k. I wish to know if we can buy mutual funds worth 10 lacs by diverting funds from FD for better returns. She owns a house and does not have house rent commitment . She is currently investing 10k p.m in SIP . Now the lump sum investment of 5 lacs each is intended to be done in HDFC balanced advantage fund Direct Growth and ICICI Prudential balanced advantage fund . Please advise
Ans: You are caring about your mother’s future.
This shows deep responsibility.
Her financial base also looks strong today.
Her pension gives steady cash.
Her FD interest gives extra safety.
Her home is secure.
Her SIP shows healthy discipline.

» Her Present Financial Position
Your mother is 71.
Her age makes safety a key priority.
But some growth is also needed.

She gets Rs 31000 pension each month.
This covers most basic needs.
Her FD interest adds Rs 25000 per month.
So her total monthly inflow is near Rs 56000.
This is healthy at her age.

She owns her house.
She has no rent stress.
This gives great relief.

She has FD worth Rs 60 lakh.
This gives safe income.
She also runs a SIP of Rs 10000 per month.
This is a good step.
It keeps her connected to long-term growth.

Her total structure looks balanced.
She has safety.
She has income.
She has some growth exposure.
She has low liabilities.

This is a very stable base for her age.

» Understanding Her Risk Level
At age 71, risk must be low.
But risk cannot be zero.
Zero risk pushes money into FD only.
FD return stays low.
FD return sometimes falls after tax.
FD return often stays below inflation.

This reduces future buying power.
Inflation in India stays high.
Medical costs rise fast.
Home repair costs rise.
Daily needs rise.
So some growth is needed.

Balanced exposure gives stability.
Balanced allocation protects both sides.
She should not go too high on equity.
She should not avoid equity fully.
A middle path works best at this age.

Your idea of shifting Rs 10 lakh for growth is fine.
But the type of fund must be chosen well.
The plan must also follow her age.
Her risk must be respected.

» Impact of Growth Options at Her Age
Growth funds move with markets.
Markets move up and down.
These swings can disturb seniors.
But some controlled equity helps fight inflation.

Funds with mix of equity and debt help.
They adjust risk.
They protect capital better.
They manage volatility better.
They offer smoother experience.
They suit senior citizens more.

So a mild growth approach is healthy.
This gives better long-term value.
This gives inflation protection.
This reduces long-term stress.

Still, the fund choice must be careful.
And the plan style must be guided.

» Concerns With Direct Plans
You mentioned direct funds.
Direct funds seem cheap.
But cheap is not always better.

Direct funds give no guidance.
Direct funds give no review support.
Direct funds give no risk matching.
Direct funds need constant study.
Direct funds need skill.
Direct funds need time.

Many investors think direct plans save money.
But small savings can cause big losses.
Wrong choices reduce returns.
Wrong timing reduces gains.
Wrong exit increases tax.

Regular plans bring professional support through MFDs with CFP credentials.
They offer yearly reviews.
They track risk closely.
They guide corrections.
They support crisis moments.
They help in asset mix.
They help keep emotions stable.

This support is very helpful for seniors.
Your mother will not need to study markets.
She will not need to track cycles.
She will not need to worry about volatility.
She can stay calm.

So regular plans may suit her better.
The small extra fee is actually buying professional hand-holding.
This hand-holding protects wealth.
This reduces mistakes.
This brings long-term peace.

» Her Liquidity Need
At age 71, liquidity matters.
She must access money fast during emergencies.
Medical needs can arise.
Health cost can be sudden.
She must be ready.

FD gives quick access.
This is useful.
So FD should not be reduced too much.

Shifting Rs 10 lakh is acceptable.
But shifting more may reduce comfort.
She must always feel safe.
Her emotional comfort is important.

So Rs 10 lakh is the right level.
It keeps major FD corpus safe.
It keeps growth exposure controlled.

This balance supports her peace.

» Her Current SIP
She puts Rs 10000 per month in SIP.
This is positive.
This brings slow steady growth.
This builds long-term value.

She should continue this SIP.
She may reduce it later based on comfort.
But she should not stop it now.
This SIP adds inflation protection.
This SIP builds a small buffer.

A continuous SIP helps smooth markets.
It builds confidence.

» Income Stability for Her
Her pension covers needs.
Her FD interest adds comfort.
Her SIP invests for future needs.
Her home saves rent.

So she has stable income.
Her life standard is maintained.
Her risk level can stay low.

Her monthly cash flow is positive.
Her needs are covered.
So she need not worry about returns too much.
But a little growth is still healthy.

» Should She Shift Rs 10 Lakh From FD?
Yes, she can shift Rs 10 lakh.
This does not hurt her safety.
This does not shake her cash flow.
This supports inflation protection.

But the fund must be right.
The plan must match her age.
The risk must stay low.
The allocation must stay controlled.

A balanced strategy is better.
Smooth returns suit seniors.
Moderate risk suits her age.

Still, the fund must be in regular plan.
Direct plan may cause long-term risk.
Direct plans place the heavy load on the investor.
At her age, this stress is avoidable.
Regular plans give smoother support.

» Why Not Use the Specific Schemes Mentioned
The schemes you named are direct plans.
Direct plans give no support.
Direct plans leave all decisions to you.
Direct plans leave all risk checks on you.

Also, each fund has its own style.
Each adjusts differently.
You must check suitability.
You must review them yearly.
This needs time and skill.

For her age, this is not ideal.
A simple, guided, regular plan works better.

Also, some funds change risk levels fast.
Some increase equity without warning.
Some change style in market shifts.
This can disturb seniors.
She must stay with stable funds.
She must stay with guided models.

This protects her long-term peace.

» The Role of Actively Managed Funds
Actively managed funds suit Indian markets.
India grows fast.
Sectors rise and fall fast.
Many companies grow fast.
Many also fall fast.

Active managers study these shifts.
They adjust quicker.
They avoid weak sectors.
They add strong businesses.
They protect downside.
They enhance upside.

Index funds cannot do this.
Index funds copy indices.
Indices carry weak companies also.
Indices carry overpriced stocks.
Indices do not avoid bad phases.
Indices cannot change weight fast.
So index funds give no defensive shield.

Actively managed funds work harder.
They try to reduce shocks.
They try to smooth volatility.
This suits seniors more.

So an active regular plan through an MFD with CFP credentials is better for her.

» Tax Angle on Mutual Fund Redemption
Capital gain rules matter.
For equity funds, long-term gains above Rs 1.25 lakh have 12.5% tax.
Short-term gains have 20% tax.
Debt fund gains follow your tax slab.

Senior investors must plan exits well.
They must avoid excess tax shock.
They must stagger withdrawals.
They must redeem only when needed.

A guided regular plan helps avoid tax mistakes.
Direct funds offer no such guidance.

» Her Emergency Preparedness
At her age, emergency readiness is key.
She must have quick cash.
She must have easy access.
Her FD base helps this.

She has Rs 60 lakh in FD.
This is strong.
She should keep most of this.
Maybe an emergency bucket of Rs 5 to 10 lakh must stay fully liquid.

This brings peace.
This prevents panic.
This avoids forced redemption.

» Family Support System
You are involved.
This protects her retirement.
You can offer emotional help.
You can offer decision help.
This support makes her financial life safe.

Family support keeps stress low for seniors.
She will feel secure.
She will stay calm during market changes.

» How Her Future Years Can Stay Stable
She needs comfort.
She needs safety.
She needs liquidity.
She needs some growth.
She needs health cover.
She needs emotional peace.

A control-based plan helps:
– Keep most money in FD
– Keep some in balanced mutual funds
– Keep SIP running
– Keep money easily accessible
– Keep risk low
– Keep asset mix simple
– Keep tax impact low
– Keep reviews yearly

This keeps her retirement smooth.

» Built-In Protection for Senior Life
Her plan must also protect future risk.
Medical cost may rise.
Home repairs may occur.
Occasional family support may be needed.

So she must:
– Keep cash bucket
– Keep healthy insurance
– Keep documents updated
– Keep financial papers organised
– Keep digital and physical files safe

This brings long-term safety.

» Withdrawal Strategy
She may not need withdrawals now.
Her income covers expenses.
But she may need money in later years.

She should follow a layered method:

Short-term needs from FD

Medium needs from balanced funds

Long-term needs from SIP corpus

Emergency money from liquid FD

This spreads risk.
This avoids sudden losses.
This protects her capital.

» Assessing the Rs 10 Lakh Transfer
This transfer is fine.
But it must not go to direct plans.
It must go to regular plans.
Guided plans reduce mistakes.
Guided plans suit seniors.

Split into two funds is fine.
But avoid too much complexity.
Simple structure reduces stress.
Easy structure improves clarity.

So two regular plans through an MFD with CFP credentials is ideal.

» Final Insights
Your mother has a strong base.
Her pension is stable.
Her FD pool is healthy.
Her home reduces cost.
Her SIP adds growth.

Adding Rs 10 lakh into balanced mutual funds is a good idea.
But shift to regular plans with expert guidance.
Direct plans are not suitable for seniors.
They bring more risk.
They bring more complexity.
They bring more stress.

Regular plans bring reviews.
Regular plans match risk.
Regular plans reduce mistakes.
Regular plans suit her age.

Her future looks stable with this mix.
Her life can stay comfortable.
She can enjoy her senior years with peace.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10881 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Dec 12, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 12, 2025Hindi
Money
Hi, I am 53 years with a wife and two children. My total savings comprising of MF, Shares, PDF,EPF, NPS & FD are approx. 3Cr. Our current monthly outgoing including SIPs is approximately 100000. Will the above savings amount be sufficient to sustain for the next 20 years?
Ans: You have managed to build Rs 3 Cr by age 53.
This shows steady discipline.
Your savings mix also looks balanced.
Your family seems stable.
Your cost control also looks fair.
This gives a good base for the next stage of life.

» Your Current Position
Your savings stand near Rs 3 Cr.
Your monthly outflow is near Rs 100000.
This includes your SIP amount also.
Your family has four members.
You have two children.
Your wife is with you.
You have a mixed pool across MF, shares, PF, EPF, NPS, and FD.
This mix brings both growth and stability.
This gives you a good base.

Your age is 53.
You have around 7 to 12 working years left.
This period is crucial.
Your decisions now shape the next 20 years.
Your savings rate also matters.
Your cost control also shapes the future.

Today’s numbers show you have a good foundation.
But sustainability depends on many factors.
We must study inflation, spending pattern, growth pattern, tax, risk level, health cost, and cash flow flexibility.

» Understanding the Cash Flow Stress
Your family spends around Rs 100000 today.
This includes SIP.
After retirement, SIP will stop.
But living costs will continue.
Costs increase each year.
Inflation can eat cash fast.
So we must ensure growth in wealth.
Slow growth can stress the corpus.
Fast growth brings more shocks.
So balance is key.

Rs 3 Cr looks large today.
But 20 years is long.
Inflation reduces buying power.
Medical costs also rise.
Family needs also shift.

Your money can last 20 years.
But it needs correct planning.
Blind use of the corpus will not help.
Proper flow matters.
Proper asset selection also matters.
You need steady growth.
You need low shocks.
You need stable income.

» Role of Growth Assets
Many families fear growth assets.
But growth assets are needed today.
Inflation is strong in India.
If money stays in FD only, it suffers.
FD return stays low.
Post-tax return stays even lower.
FD return does not beat inflation.
FD cannot support long-term plans.

Mutual funds bring better growth.
Actively managed funds bring better research.
They allow expert judgement.
They can handle market swings better.
They study sectors and businesses.
They adjust the portfolio.
They aim for more consistent returns.
This helps protect wealth.

Some people choose direct plans.
But direct plans need full time study.
They need skill.
They need discipline.
Most investors do not have the time.
Wrong choices can reduce returns.
Direct plans give no guidance.
Direct plans can reduce long-term peace.

Regular plans through an MFD with CFP credential give better support.
They help with reviews.
They help with corrections.
They help with rebalancing.
They help manage behaviour.
They save time and stress.

You already have MF exposure.
This is good.
You should keep this path.
Active fund management will help long-term stability.

» Role of Safety Assets
You have EPF, PPF, NPS, FD.
These give safety.
They give peace.
But they give lower return.
Too much safety reduces future income.
A mix of both is needed.

Safety assets give steady income.
But they do not grow fast.
They cannot support 20 years alone.
So balance must be kept.

» Assessing the Sustainability for 20 Years
Rs 3 Cr can support 20 years.
But it depends on:

Your retirement age

Your spending pattern

Your ability to reduce costs

Your asset mix

Your growth rate

Your inflation level

Your health cost

Your emergency needs

If your core expenses stay in control, your corpus can last.
If you invest well, your corpus can support you.
If you avoid panic, your wealth will grow.
Your children may also get settled.
Your own needs may reduce.

The key is proper planning.
Without planning, the corpus can shrink fast.
With planning, it will last long.

» Inflation Impact
Inflation is silent.
It eats buying power.
Costs double every few years.
Food rises.
Health rises.
Daily life rises.
School fees rise.
Lifestyle rises.

If your money grows slower than inflation, you lose power.
So growth assets must be part of the plan.
They help beat inflation.
They help protect lifestyle.
They help support long-term needs.

This is why active mutual funds stay useful.
They bring research-driven decisions.
They help fight inflation better.
They stay flexible.
They move with the economy.

» Evaluating Your Retirement Readiness
You stand near retirement zone.
You still have some working life.
You still earn.
You still save.
Your income supports your SIP.
This is good.
This is the right stage to improve planning.

Your SIP amount builds future cash.
Your insurance must be proper.
Your emergency fund must be strong.
Your health cover must be strong.

You have PF and NPS.
These give safety.
They bring stability.
They give steady return.
But they do not give high return.
Growth will come from MF and equity.

Your retirement readiness depends on:

Cash flow plan

Growth plan

Insurance plan

Medical cover plan

Long-term income plan

Withdrawal plan

When all parts align, you will stay secure.

» Withdrawal Strategy for the Future
When you retire, cash flow must stay smooth.
You cannot depend on FD alone.
You cannot depend only on EPF.
You cannot depend on one asset class.
You need a mix.

Your withdrawal should come from:

Some from safety assets

Some from growth assets

Some from periodic rebalancing

This helps you avoid panic selling.
This helps you maintain stability.
This protects your lifestyle.

Tax must also be managed.
Tax on equity MF has new rules.
Long-term gain above Rs 1.25 lakh has 12.5% tax.
Short-term gain has 20% tax.
Debt MF gain follows your tax slab.
These rules shape your withdrawal plan.
You must plan redemptions wisely.

» Health and Family Factors
Health cost is rising in India.
Hospital bills rise fast.
Health shocks drain savings.
So good health cover is needed.
Family needs must be studied.

Your children may still need some support.
Their education or marriage may need funds.
These costs must be planned early.
You should not dip into retirement money.
Clear planning avoids stress.

Your wife also needs future support.
Joint planning is better.
Shared decisions help discipline.

» Need for a Structured Review
A structured review every year is needed.
Your income may change.
Your savings may rise.
Your spending may shift.
Your goals may change.
Your risk level may shift.
Your family needs may change.

Review helps you stay on track.
Review helps catch issues early.
Review helps you correct mistakes.
Review brings peace.

A Certified Financial Planner can guide reviews.
This support builds confidence.
This reduces stress.
This brings clarity.

» How to Strengthen Your Position
You already stand strong.
But you can still improve.
Here are some steps to make your 20 years safer.

Keep your growth-safety mix balanced

Increase your SIP when income allows

Avoid direct plans if guidance needed

Use regular plans for proper support

Avoid real estate due to low returns

Increase your emergency fund

Improve your health cover

Avoid ULIP and mixed plans if you ever have them

Review your EPF and NPS allocation

Track your spending carefully

Plan for yearly rebalancing

Keep enough liquidity for short needs

Keep boredom decisions away

Stay invested even in tough times

Trust long-term compounding

Each step adds stability.
Your family will feel safe.

» Building a Strong Future Income Flow
Income must not come from one basket.
Income should come from:

MF SWP

PF interest

FD ladder

NPS withdrawal in a slow way

Equity redemption in a planned way

This spreads risk.
This spreads tax.
This spreads stress.

Staggered withdrawal helps peace.
Your money grows even while you spend.
Your corpus stays healthy.

» Maintaining Low Stress in Retirement
Retirement should be peaceful.
Money stress should be low.
Good planning ensures this.

Keep clear communication with your family.
Keep your files organised.
Keep your goals updated.
Keep calm during market swings.

Your corpus can support you.
Your strategy will shape your peace.

» Final Insights
Your Rs 3 Cr corpus is a strong base.
Your age gives you time to improve more.
Your monthly spending is manageable.
Your asset mix supports your future.

But planning is needed.
Cash flow must be aligned with inflation.
Growth assets must stay active.
Safety assets must be balanced.
Withdrawal must be planned wisely.
Health cost must be covered.
Risk must be contained.

With proper planning, your wealth can support the next 20 years.
Your family can live with comfort.
Your lifestyle can stay stable.
Your future can stay safe.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Reetika

Reetika Sharma  |423 Answers  |Ask -

Financial Planner, MF and Insurance Expert - Answered on Dec 12, 2025

Money
Dear Sir, I am 60 yrs and just superannuated. I have no pension and the spread of corpus is as follows; - MF & Shares portfolio value is around 1 Cr. SWP of 40000/month initiated. But SIP of 20000/month is also on for next six months - FDs in bank is around 3. Cr and are in Quarterly pay-out interest - PPF of 20 Lac - RBI Bond of 16 lac half yearly interest pay out - PF 90 Lac not withdrawn so far as I can extend this with 1 yr. - Few SA pension 63000 per year Please do suggest if the above can give me expenses to meet 2.5 Lac/m for next 20 yrs Best regards,
Ans: Hi Deepa,

Overall your total networth is 5 crores (including PF, FD, MF, binds etc.) - we will break it into 4 crores (which can be used to fund your retirement) and 1 crore for emergencies.
If invested correctly, this 4 crores can fund you for 20 years and not more than that. You need to invest 4 crores so that they fetch you around 11-12% XIRR to fund your monthly expenses. Also withdraw your PF, liquidate 2 crores from FD and reinvest entirely.

Take the help of a professional who will design your portfolio keeping in mind your monthly requirements for the next 20 years.

Hence please consult a professional Certified Financial Planner - a CFP who can guide you with exact funds to invest in keeping in mind your age, requirements, financial goals and risk profile. A CFP periodically reviews your portfolio and suggest any amendments to be made, if required.

Let me know if you need more help.

Best Regards,
Reetika Sharma, Certified Financial Planner
https://www.instagram.com/cfpreetika/

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x