Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Ask Our Gurus
Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11485 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Oct 16, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 15, 2026
Money
I am a 50 year old widow, and have a 21 year old daughter. She is currently pursuing her internship (10 k per month). I earn 1 L 20k every month and receive my husband's pension of 1L 20 k every month that will reduce to 88 K after 9 years.I have invested in SIP of 10 k per month in ICICI Value Discovery Fund - Growth through an agent. I am not sure if it was a right decision. She said it will be a SWP from 2035 onwards and 15k will be amount of withdrawal. And also another 10k per month SIP in ICICI India Opportunities Fund Growth. Both were started in Feb 2025. Please advise me if this is a right investment for me or not. How do I stop this autodebit and what will be the tax implications if I stop these SIPs and redeem the amount. It would be great if you could guide me - I am intimidated by numbers. Thanks a lot.
Ans: Thank you for sharing your situation so openly. You have been managing your family finances while supporting your daughter, and it is understandable to feel unsure when investment decisions involve complex numbers.
The good news is that you do not need to understand every technical detail to make sound financial decisions. Your investments should give you clarity, flexibility and peace of mind.
» 1. Are Your Current SIP Investments Right for You?
You are investing Rs.20,000 every month in two mutual funds. Both investments started in February 2025.
– Your income and your husbands pension together provide a strong monthly cash flow today.
– However, your pension will reduce after nine years. Your financial plan should prepare for that change well in advance.
– Your daughter is 21 and may need support for higher education, career development or other important goals.
– At age 50, you should balance long-term growth with financial safety. Investing only for returns is not enough.
Mutual fund SIPs can be useful for long-term goals. But the right investment depends on your existing savings, monthly expenses, emergency funds and future needs.
» 2. Is the Promised SWP of Rs.15,000 from 2035 Reliable?
An SWP, or Systematic Withdrawal Plan, allows you to withdraw a fixed amount from your mutual fund at regular intervals.
However, the Rs.15,000 monthly withdrawal mentioned by your agent is not guaranteed income.
– Your investment value in 2035 will depend on the amount invested, market performance and expenses.
– If withdrawals are higher than the portfolio can support, your investment may reduce over time.
– Mutual fund returns are not fixed like pension income or bank deposit interest.
– A withdrawal of Rs.15,000 per month does not mean that the fund will generate Rs.15,000 as profit every month. Part of the withdrawal may come from your invested capital.
Please ask your agent for a written projection showing the estimated investment value in 2035 under different return assumptions. Treat it as an illustration, not a promise.




» 3. Should You Stop the SIPs or Continue?
My suggestion is not to redeem both investments in a hurry. First, separate two decisions: stopping future monthly investments and withdrawing the money already invested.
– You can stop future SIP instalments without redeeming the units you already own.
– If your monthly income comfortably covers your household expenses, you may continue investing for long-term goals, provided the funds suit your risk level.
– If you are uncomfortable with these investments, stopping the SIPs temporarily while reviewing your finances is a reasonable option.
– Do not continue only because your agent has suggested an SWP from 2035. Your plan should suit your needs, not just a future withdrawal illustration.
» 4. How to Stop the Auto-Debit
You can stop future SIP instalments by contacting the mutual fund company or the platform through which the SIP was registered.
– Check your latest mutual fund statement to confirm the scheme names, SIP amounts and registration details.
– Contact the mutual fund company or your agent and request cancellation of both SIP registrations.
– If the SIPs were registered through your bank mandate, ask your bank how to cancel the relevant recurring debit mandate as well.
– Obtain confirmation that both SIPs and their auto-debits have been cancelled. Do not assume that cancelling the bank mandate automatically cancels every SIP registration.
Stopping the SIP does not automatically sell your existing mutual fund units. You can retain those units and decide what to do later.
» 5. What Are the Tax Implications if You Redeem?
Since you started investing in February 2025, the tax depends on the purchase dates of the units, the redemption date and the profit or loss on the units sold.
For equity-oriented mutual funds, the general current rules are:
– Units held for 12 months or less: short-term capital gains are generally taxed at 20%.
– Units held for more than 12 months: long-term capital gains above the annual aggregate exemption of Rs.1.25 lakh are generally taxed at 12.5%.
– If you redeem at a loss, there may be no capital gains tax on that transaction. Eligible capital losses may be set off or carried forward subject to tax rules.
Each SIP instalment is treated as a separate purchase for tax purposes. An exit load may also apply to some units, depending on the scheme rules and holding period.
You do not pay capital gains tax merely because you stop future SIP instalments. Tax generally arises when you redeem units and realise a taxable gain.
» 6. A More Suitable Financial Plan for You
Your pension and salary provide a good starting point for planning. However, your husbands pension will reduce in nine years, so preparing for that change is important.
I would suggest the following priorities:
– Maintain an emergency fund to cover essential household expenses and unexpected needs.
– Keep money required for your daughters education or other near-term goals in suitable, lower-risk investments.
– Review your retirement savings and estimate your expenses after your pension reduces.
– Continue equity mutual fund investments only for goals that are several years away and can tolerate market ups and downs.
– Review your life and health insurance needs, existing savings and any other liabilities before deciding how much to invest every month.
You do not need to choose investments based on complicated return projections. A simple plan linked to your monthly expenses and future goals can work well.
» 7. What I Need to Know Before Suggesting the Next Step
Please share just these three details:
– Approximately how much do you spend every month on household expenses, including any support for your daughter?
– Do you have any bank deposits, PPF, EPF or other savings apart from these two SIPs?
– Is your main goal to build retirement savings, provide for your daughter, or generate monthly income from 2035 onwards?
With these details, it will be easier to assess whether you should continue both SIPs, stop one, or change your investment approach. There is no need to panic or redeem everything immediately.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
AMFI-Registered MFD – ARN 4188
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/
(more)
How It WorksClick to Know
Ask any question about Health, Relationships, Career or Money.
To submit your question, Register/Login using your email ID and mobile number.
When our Expert answers your question, you will receive an alert on your email/mobile phone.
Search the RediffGurus website for questions posted by other users and read the answers given by our Experts.
FAQs
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

x