Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

44-Year-Old Woman Asks: Is It Wrong to Stop Supporting Demanding Parents?

Anu Krishna |1418 Answers |Ask -Follow

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Oct 08, 2024

Anu Krishna is a mind coach and relationship expert.
The co-founder of Unfear Changemakers LLP, she has received her neuro linguistic programming training from National Federation of NeuroLinguistic Programming, USA, and her energy work specialisation from the Institute for Inner Studies, Manila.
She is an executive member of the Indian Association of Adolescent Health.... more

Asked by Anonymous - Sep 27, 2024Hindi

Hello I have a strained relationship with my parents. I am 44 years old woman and married late. And now have twins who are 7 years old. Before entering this marriage, I was working and paid 50% of the earnings to my parents. And tried managing with rest 50% by paying home loan, food and others. It was very difficult but at times, i couldnnot manage on my own as the finances were tight and couldnnot save anything. Later, I took a break from work due to my love marriage and had to settle in a rural place where job opportunities were unavailable. I started a school but things did not go well and had to shut down due to covid. My money which I received from PF, gratuity all had vanished due to the school and my husband business also got into troubles and has no support from families. We were almost on roads and did not have any help. It was difficult to manage with twins. Then, i started with 5 freelancer jobs and made one lakh a month which was needed to support my family. In the interim, i got a good job at Chennai and moved with my husband. He too got a job in a start up and moved with me. His being a work from home could manage my twins while they were at home. While we started earning, again my parents started asking for money and I stopped supporting them, as my sister had started giving them money every month while i got married. My sister is well settled and runs a company abroad. I had got into a job and just settling down and did not want to take pressure again. I have my children and need to save for our retirement too. So, i started saving penny by penny. And due to not supporting my parents they do not talk to me at all. I too stopped as I thought it's better to be far with peace of mind rather than have frequent heart aches. Husband side story is that..after business got lost due to covid, his mother filed case against us stating that my husband brought loss to the business and need to step away and filed an injunction case against us. So, we could neither go to our property or restart business. As such, the case is moving and no relationship with my inlaw. But I always feel when children have holidays ...and children have been unaware of the relationship of grandparents and they yearn to be with them. They are growing up without any love of grandparents and they seem to understand. At time, I feel to help my family but I am scared as they will start squeezing me totally and I will be left with no savings. At this age, I have started to save and need it for our future. Am I doing it right

Ans: Dear Anonymous,
Oh, yes, you are thinking and doing the right thing.
You have done what needs to be done for parents when you could and if by not supporting them with money now has made them judge you and distance you, then well, what can you do?
Yes, it's unfortunate that your children don't have the opportunity to get the love and attention of their grandparents, but if you look at how immature they have been and dragging you and your husband down, it's better to keep the children away from all this drama until things settle.
Children don't need a lot of people, they just need people who love them. I am sure you and your husband are doing just that. Focus on yourselves and make it work as a family. You deserve to be at peace after all that you have gone through. SO, don't waver and keep doing what you have so far to maintain that peace of mind.

All the best!
Anu Krishna
Mind Coach|NLP Trainer|Author
Drop in: www.unfear.io
Reach me: Facebook: anukrish07/ AND LinkedIn: anukrishna-joyofserving/

Relationship3Reply

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Anu Krishna |1418 Answers |Ask -Follow

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Nov 08, 2022

Question by MB - Nov 08, 2022Hindi

I got married in 2018 and it was an arranged marriage. Everything seemed very perfect for me. But soon after things got weird as I realised my husband does not share good rapport with his own family. From day second, I felt I need to correct my husband' attitude towards his own parents. He loves me a lot and protects me from any type of problem while we were staying at my in-laws' house. But before completing 2 months we moved out and somewhere I knew there is no going back to his parents from that point. During the short 2 months stay I was told that my parents did not give me good stuff -- I mean bed, almirah and (that they) had not arranged our marriage function in the best way possible. I have seen them fighting among themselves for purchasing Maggi packets stating who will pay the price. I was told my husband who is eventually their real son contributed nothing to his sister's marriage, to their house construction and to his own marriage. I was asked to pay for the marriage album as my husband contributed nothing to his own marriage. Even after leaving their place bank payment related messages have been sent to me to pay the amount. One day after feeling helpless I asked them: If your son is having so much problem why did you marry him. They simply stated that they did it for the sake of society. The moments before leaving the house were tense. They threw a lot of tantrums -- they took the jewellery they'd purchased for me and also retained the jewellery given by my parents. I said nothing about it as those materialistic things never mattered to me. I had to take back a part of jewellery made by my parents from them as my parents wanted it back. But after leaving home they did not call to ask anything about our health or our problems with the new set up but instead called for money. They are threatening to come back if we don't talk to them on regular basis and bend their son on his knees to come back to his parents. Till some time, I was under the impression that my husband is having issues; that he is the monster who is abandoning his parents. When I learned his side of story, I realised he is not at fault completely. They never made him feel loved or accepted; and always compared him with others. They considered him as their investment plan as they are all the time cursing him for not providing any financial support without knowing at what salary he is working for, what are his monthly expenses and whether he is in a position to assist them financially.He doesn't have any good memories with his family. Still I tried to make him feel their pain to be left alone behind their only son. After leaving their house they started to abuse me on phone whenever they wanted. They cursed me and my parents for taking their son away from them. My husband is the typical Indian male who on the first night took control of my debit card as he thinks it is his birth right. He strictly told me what not to wear. Although these were major flaws in the attitude, he showed love towards me so I did also do the same. I am happy with him. But with this constant verbal abuse from his parents, I feel like I’m the one who is the culprit here. I was not ready to even extend my family with my husband but somehow I did take the decision after four years of my marriage. I am expecting now but my husband warned me to not inform about this to his parents otherwise, he will send me permanently to my parents’ house. My subconscious is shaking me in every 2 to 3 weeks that I’m the culprit here. I feel like my child will also leave me behind the way we left his parents behind. They insulted me in every possible way but I still don't want them to be left alone in their senior years like this. But I have no control over my husband he is way more detached towards them and maximum time insensitive to their problems. Also his parents always call to either abuse me or their son they did never ask us how we are if we are fine even in corona time I was positive and when they knew about they call my husband to make fun of this. Please suggest.

Ans:

Dear MB,

Too much going on in your mind all at once. Sometimes, it helps to compartmentalize.

It seems like you are being a nice human, have tried patching things between the son and his family.

Let it alone, it is unique and it’s their battle to fight. By you getting into this, it might eventually be pointed out that you are a bad wife and a bad influence on their son.

People when in distress lose sense of logic and blame everything on the external. So, you have done your bit, in vain…now stay away from their relationship.

What is meant to be, will be. Any more interference might only harm the relationship further.

As for you, when they call and abuse, kindly assert that you will not be talked to in that manner OR simply avoid their calls till the time they ask, then say: I do want our conversations to be had with respect both ways.

As for your husband taking away your debit card; it does seem his way of exercising control which he lacks with himself in relation to his parents.

He feels helpless and him taking charge of what you wear etc is his way of establishing ground rules by being a patriarch.

Please rework this soon else this will be observed by your children especially if you have a girl child.

Your meek submission is what she will learn from you.

Just like you took your streedhan back, what you feel you have a personal association and right over, kindly take it back.

His love for you does not mean that he owns you and it does not mean you need to submit.

Of course, if it is to maintain peace for the time being, alright…but over a period of time this has to change.

Enjoy the pregnancy without bringing unwanted worries that your child will also leave you etc.

Too much of commercial movies can instil these fears. Your husband and his family made this choice to harbor animosity towards each other.

Why will your child do the same with you? There is no transference. Simply, enjoy being pregnant, focus on yourself and your child.

Think good, eat good, feel good, laugh a lot and choose what who you want around you. It affects the child directly.

Please become responsible now towards your unborn child. He/she needs you.

Be with Nature a lot, listen to calming music…your baby will thank you someday for this. So smile and get on to enjoying your pregnancy.

Be happy and all the best!

Relationship

Anu Krishna |1418 Answers |Ask -Follow

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Aug 06, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 20, 2024Hindi

Hi, I got married in December 2012. Love marriage, we met in the office. I clearly told him that if I get married I would need to give one years salary to my dad as he has loan installments to pay and also told him my dad would do good wedding arrangements however no dowry should be asked. When his parents came to see me for the first time they came all prepared to finalize the relationship however we weren't aware. Me and my parents thought they are just coming to see me and the family. But when they started off with basic rituals that is when we were stunned but then went along. His father asked dowry from my dad and he was speechless but when I denied my father spoke to them and said he will bear all their expenses too but won't be able to give dowry. When I confronted my husband he said he wasn't aware that his dad will ask for dowry. We got married and when we visited his hometown his father confessed that he was not aware that me and my husband had discussed no dowry part otherwise he would not have asked my father. I was infuriated but I let it go. Soon after an year my salary started coming in and he would tranfer it in his account. I did not pay attention to it. Soon all the money was in his control. There came a situation in my family, my sister's wedding was called off by groom's end three days before the wedding and it was a shock. My husband asked us to write a letter stating all about the situation so that it can be submitted to the police. My husband kept a copy of that letter with him. During the lockdown my father asked for some monetary help from me but my husband denied to help him, and I started hating him to my core. Soon my mother in law moved in with us when my father in law expired. Since then our relationship sucked. She would always manipulate his son. I got so furious I started putting sugar in my husband's milk as he is diabetic and then later confessed it to him. Now he is threatening me of releasing that letter to my sister's husband and also has kept all the money in his control. He says he will make me feel sorry for what I did and also we are just living in my home but we have no relation and he does not talk to me. I don't want this relationship to flourish anyways but I need to know what can I do if I can get half of the assets. Please suggest what I can do.

Ans: Dear Anonymous,
Since you have decided not to stay within the marriage, the best recourse would be to seek legal advice and move ahead. He/She will advice you on assets split, custody etc.

All the best!
Anu Krishna
Mind Coach|NLP Trainer|Author
Drop in: www.unfear.io
Reach me: Facebook: anukrish07/ AND LinkedIn: anukrishna-joyofserving/

Relationship

Kanchan Rai |463 Answers |Ask -Follow

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Dec 07, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 05, 2024Hindi

I am 39 and married for 11 years now, my husband doesn't support me financially at all. My salary is more than him but I bought house my own and paying all EMIS, looking for all household expenses and also paying school fees and other expenses for my son. My husband looks after only his parents, spend all money on them. Earlier we used to live together in inlaws house but they have spending habits for luxury, cloths, food etc even though my husband earns very less and my father in law retired with no income they were not ready to compromise on their spending habits. Whatever they had received after their retirement they entirety spent on their daughters marriages with no money left. When I got married they asked for my salary and used to give them. Mine and my husband salary was not enough for them so they sold house without informing me, I insisted them to buy at least small house but did not agree and kept on spending money on their lavish life, foreign trips, food, cloths etc. also helped daughters to buy house, maintenance and their childrens study. But did not let their son live life as ask him to pay rent for their house, household and maintenance expenses and they spend their money on their own luxury. They asked for my salary even though they have money and just spending for luxury and not even thinking for our future. When I denied to give salary, they asked me leave their house and made me difficult to live with them doing harrasment and taunts so I decided to leave and buy new house.Now I am living with my son separately, when my husband came to know about my new house he came to stay with us by not even paying single rupee to me. I asked him several time for money he only pays one or two thousand saying I don't have money at all to give you. Not taking care of son, his studies, school fees, do not help me in anything. My in laws keep doing his brain wash against me so that he will not support me financially or anyway. He always listens to his parents and sisters. There is no husband wife relationship at all between us. Not sure how to deal with it.

Ans: First, recognize and honor the strength it has taken to come this far. Buying a home, raising your son, and managing the weight of these challenges on your own are significant accomplishments that reflect your resilience and determination. That said, a marriage is meant to be a partnership, and it’s clear that your husband’s lack of financial contribution and emotional support has created an imbalance that’s unsustainable.

It’s important to look at the patterns in your relationship with clarity. Your husband’s decisions seem to be heavily influenced by his family, and this loyalty, while not inherently wrong, appears to come at the expense of his commitment to you and your shared responsibilities. The fact that he contributes so little financially and emotionally while benefiting from your efforts shows a lack of fairness and respect in the relationship. His parents’ behavior and expectations have added further strain, undermining your marriage and creating an environment of resentment.

You may want to consider having a clear and honest conversation with your husband. Express how his actions—or lack thereof—are impacting you and your son. Frame the conversation not as a confrontation but as a plea for understanding and change. However, if he remains unwilling to acknowledge or address these issues, it’s worth reflecting on what staying in this relationship means for your emotional well-being and future.

Seeking professional support, such as individual counseling, can provide you with a safe space to explore your feelings, gain clarity, and develop strategies for managing this situation. A legal consultation might also be helpful to understand your rights and options, especially if you’re considering separation or seeking financial accountability from your husband for your son’s needs.

Above all, focus on what you need to feel secure, respected, and fulfilled—not just as a wife, but as a person. Your son is observing how you handle these challenges, and by prioritizing your well-being and standing up for fairness, you’re also modeling strength and self-respect for him. Whatever steps you decide to take, trust in your ability to make decisions that align with your dignity and values. You deserve a life where your efforts are met with partnership and mutual care.

Relationship

Latest Questions

Ramalingam Kalirajan |7376 Answers |Ask -Follow

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Dec 31, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 30, 2024Hindi

Best investment option ULIP or Mutual Fund

Ans: Understanding the differences between ULIPs (Unit Linked Insurance Plans) and mutual funds is essential to make an informed choice. Below is a detailed explanation from a Certified Financial Planner's perspective.

What Are ULIPs?
ULIPs are hybrid products offering life insurance and investment. A portion of the premium goes towards life insurance, while the rest is invested in various funds, such as equity or debt.

Key Benefits of ULIPs
Dual Purpose: Provides life insurance coverage along with potential investment growth.

Tax Savings: Premiums are eligible for tax deductions under Section 80C. Maturity proceeds may also be tax-free under Section 10(10D), subject to conditions.

Compulsory Discipline: The five-year lock-in period ensures disciplined long-term investing.

Major Drawbacks of ULIPs
High Costs: Includes multiple charges such as premium allocation, fund management, and mortality costs. These charges reduce overall returns.

Complexity: Understanding ULIP charges and performance can be confusing due to a lack of transparency.

Limited Fund Choices: Investment options are restricted to funds offered by the insurer.

Lower Returns: High costs and fund limitations may result in below-average returns compared to mutual funds.

What Are Mutual Funds?
Mutual funds are pure investment products that pool money from investors and invest in equity, debt, or a mix of both, depending on the fund type.

Key Benefits of Mutual Funds
Variety of Options: Mutual funds offer options like equity, debt, hybrid, and sector-specific funds to suit different financial goals and risk profiles.

Transparency: Investors can track fund performance, portfolio holdings, and expense ratios.

Low Costs: Mutual funds generally have lower charges compared to ULIPs, making them more cost-effective.

Flexibility: You can switch funds, adjust SIP contributions, or redeem investments anytime (subject to exit load).

Higher Returns: Over the long term, mutual funds tend to deliver better returns due to active management and lower costs.

Major Drawbacks of Mutual Funds
No Insurance Coverage: Unlike ULIPs, mutual funds are purely for investment and do not provide life insurance.

Tax on Gains: Gains from mutual funds are taxed based on the holding period and type of fund.

Comparative Analysis of ULIPs and Mutual Funds
Objective
ULIPs aim to provide both life insurance and investment returns.
Mutual funds focus solely on investments, leading to better fund management.
Transparency
ULIPs are less transparent due to their complex fee structures and limited fund details.
Mutual funds are highly transparent, offering regular updates on performance, portfolio composition, and costs.
Costs
ULIPs have high charges, including mortality, administration, and fund management costs. These significantly reduce returns.
Mutual funds are more cost-efficient, with lower expense ratios and no hidden charges.
Returns
ULIP returns are moderate due to high costs and limited fund options.
Mutual funds offer potentially higher returns due to professional fund management and diversified investment choices.
Flexibility
ULIPs have limited flexibility, as you are restricted to funds offered by the insurer.
Mutual funds provide greater flexibility, allowing you to switch funds, adjust investments, and even redeem partially.
Lock-in Period
ULIPs have a mandatory lock-in period of five years.
Mutual funds are more flexible, with no lock-in period except for tax-saving ELSS funds, which have a three-year lock-in.
Tax Benefits
ULIP premiums qualify for tax deductions under Section 80C. The maturity proceeds are tax-free under Section 10(10D), provided conditions are met.
Mutual funds offer tax benefits only for ELSS funds under Section 80C. Gains are taxable, as per the holding period.
Why Mutual Funds Are a Better Option
Focused Investment Approach
Mutual funds concentrate solely on investments, ensuring professional management and efficient fund allocation.

Higher Returns Potential
The absence of high charges allows mutual funds to deliver better returns over the long term.

Flexibility and Control
Mutual funds allow you to choose or switch between funds based on market conditions or financial goals.

Cost-Effective
Mutual funds are more cost-efficient due to lower expense ratios compared to ULIPs.

Why ULIPs May Not Be Suitable
High Charges
ULIPs have various charges that reduce your net returns. This makes them less attractive compared to mutual funds.

Limited Fund Options
You are restricted to investing only in the funds offered by the insurance company. This limits diversification.

Complexity
The structure of ULIPs, with their multiple charges and insurance components, makes them difficult to understand and monitor.

Final Insights
Mutual funds are the better investment choice for long-term wealth creation due to their focused investment strategy, flexibility, and cost-efficiency. ULIPs, on the other hand, are best avoided unless you specifically need life insurance along with investments.

For life insurance, consider a term plan, and for investments, focus on well-managed mutual funds. This combination will help you achieve your financial goals more effectively.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

Money

Mayank Chandel |1957 Answers |Ask -Follow

IIT-JEE, NEET-UG, SAT, CLAT, CA, CS Exam Expert - Answered on Dec 31, 2024

Question by Nancy - Dec 29, 2024Hindi

Sir mera naam nancy hai or mere aadhar card,obc ncl certificate and 10th certificate and birth certificate mei Mera naam nancy h but 12th certificate mei Mera naam nacny hai or maine improvement ka form bhara hua hai or 8 mahine se cbse ko name correction ka application diya hua hai but abhi tak naam shi nhi hua hai toh kya mujhe admission time koi dikkat aayegi iit mei

Ans: Hi Nancy,
You may be asked to submit an affidavit. Also keep all the documents ready with you showing you have applied for the correction of name to CBSE and it is taking time. Also pursue strong follow-ups with authorities and try to keep everything on records. Always take a receiving copy while writing any letter or application.

Career

Mayank Chandel |1957 Answers |Ask -Follow

IIT-JEE, NEET-UG, SAT, CLAT, CA, CS Exam Expert - Answered on Dec 31, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 29, 2024Hindi

I have 3 gaps between 12th and btech cse as i was preparing for neet in those gap years. Unfortunately i couldn't crack neet.Will these gaps years affect during on campus placements??

Ans: Hi
Your gap years will not significantly affect your placement prospects as long as you can convincingly present your story and demonstrate that you’ve made the most of your B.Tech journey. Stay focused on building a strong profile, and you’ll have a good chance of landing desirable opportunities. Be Honest & Explain your NEET preparation journey during interviews. Emphasize the hard work, dedication, and discipline involved in preparing for such exams. You were trying for Govt. MBBS seat only.

Build a strong academic record during your B.Tech years to demonstrate your technical competence.
Work on practical skills like programming, software development, and problem-solving through internships, projects, and certifications. Participate in hackathons, coding competitions, or other extracurricular activities to showcase your proactive attitude and create a strong CV.

Career

Dr Rajiv Kovil |18 Answers |Ask -Follow

Diabetologist - Answered on Dec 30, 2024

Question by Sumukh - Nov 07, 2024Hindi

What Are ACP Guidelines for Diabetics? why aren't they accepted by Indian Medical Authorities ?

Ans: ACP is a body like many other bodies across the globe

Health

Dr Rajiv Kovil |18 Answers |Ask -Follow

Diabetologist - Answered on Dec 30, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Aug 16, 2024Hindi

Hello I am suffering sugar since last 16 years. Earlier my fasting blood sugar was 220-230. I have taken medicine regularly. But now my fasting blood sugar is 320-350. Actually I am in more stress. How can I manage my blood sugar level.

Ans: You need a lot of evaluation

Health

Dr Rajiv Kovil |18 Answers |Ask -Follow

Diabetologist - Answered on Dec 30, 2024

Question by Vidhya - Aug 16, 2024Hindi

My mother has both blood pressure and sugar.Her sugar level before food is normal and after food it is between 120 to160.Occasionally she gets severe sweating and giddiness which improves after half an hour.Could you please tell is what might be the reason Any life style changes which you suggest

Ans: It can be low sugars she needs investigations amd a cgms

Health

Dr Rajiv Kovil |18 Answers |Ask -Follow

Diabetologist - Answered on Dec 30, 2024

Question by Lavanya - Aug 11, 2024Hindi

My age is 40, I am a female. My fasting blood sugar value is 105 and HBA1C value is 6.3 percentage so I am in a pre diabetic stage should I have to take any medication or should I have to maintain diabetic diet for this ?

Ans: You should try to get or normal with a strict lifestyle for 6.months.if it doesn't change you should start meds

Health

Dr Rajiv Kovil |18 Answers |Ask -Follow

Diabetologist - Answered on Dec 30, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Nov 30, 2023Hindi

In Jan-23 I started losing weight. On blood test my HbA1C was 13%. My dietician advised me routine diet along with some exercise.Now after 10 months, I did blood test and to my surprise my HbA1C came down to 5.6%. Now tell me how I can sustain this level for a longer period?

Ans: Yes withbregukar meds and exercise and weight loss you maintain this

Health

Dr Rajiv Kovil |18 Answers |Ask -Follow

Diabetologist - Answered on Dec 30, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 29, 2024Hindi

What are the food necessary for sugar patient

Ans: Green vegetables, salads, pulses and fruits

Health

Dr Rajiv Kovil |18 Answers |Ask -Follow

Diabetologist - Answered on Dec 30, 2024

Question by Shankar - Dec 21, 2024

Hello Doctor, I'm 78 my orgasm breaks and ejection is delayed. I have frequent micturition. I have Diabetes and Hypotension. I take medicines prescribed by my Physician. I have ED also Please advice me about EP.

Ans: This will require a hormonal assessment before one can prescribe any meds

Health

See more questions »