Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8513 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 02, 2025

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
karthikeyan Question by karthikeyan on May 01, 2025
Money

Dear sirs good day, i have invested about 8.4 lakhs in KOTAK FLEXICAP FUND-DIIRECT GROWTH & 3.4 LAKHS IN KOTAK EMERGING EQUITY FUND DIRECT PLAN. For now stopped SIP in both. Could you pl advise is it worth to continue SIP any one of above if yes which one? or to remdem or leave it as it is or to do STP from one to another?. Thanks in advance.

Ans: Your investments show a good level of financial discipline.
It is important now to evaluate them carefully.
Let us explore from all angles to guide you right.

Overview of Your Investments
You have invested Rs. 8.4 lakhs in a flexi-cap equity mutual fund.

You have also invested Rs. 3.4 lakhs in a mid-cap equity mutual fund.

Currently, SIPs in both funds are stopped.

Performance and Risk Understanding
Flexi-Cap Equity Mutual Fund
This fund invests across large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap stocks.

It gives broad diversification across sectors and companies.

These funds are more stable in down markets than pure mid or small caps.

Ideal for moderate to long-term investors who want steady growth.

Lower volatility compared to mid and small-cap funds.

Mid-Cap Equity Mutual Fund
This fund invests in medium-sized companies with high growth potential.

It has more risk and more reward possibilities than flexi-cap.

Suitable only if your risk appetite is high and time horizon is long.

Short-term performance can be very volatile.

These funds do well in bullish markets, but fall faster in corrections.

Key Observations on Your Investment Mix
Your major portion is in the flexi-cap fund.

Mid-cap exposure is much smaller, which is good for risk control.

You have diversified across fund types, which is smart investing.

Now, decisions should be based on your future goals and time horizon.

SIP Decision – Continue or Not?
Should You Resume SIP in Flexi-Cap Fund?
Yes, flexi-cap funds suit long-term investors with balanced risk profile.

They give exposure to multiple segments of the market.

SIPs help in rupee cost averaging during market ups and downs.

It is a better choice to restart SIP in this fund.

Continue if your goal is 5+ years away and you want moderate risk.

Should You Resume SIP in Mid-Cap Fund?
Not advisable unless your risk tolerance is high.

Past returns are strong but risk is much higher.

Avoid fresh investments if goal is short-term or if markets are volatile.

You can hold your existing investment and wait for long-term growth.

Don't resume SIP unless you’re very confident with market movements.

What About STP (Systematic Transfer Plan)?
STP works best when moving from low-risk to high-risk funds gradually.

Both your funds are equity-based with high volatility.

Doing STP between them won’t reduce your risk.

No strong advantage in switching from one equity fund to another here.

Better to keep your funds where they are, based on your goals.

What Should You Do Next?
Review Your Financial Goals
What is your investment time horizon?

Is it for retirement, education, home, or wealth creation?

Match the fund types with your goals.

Equity funds are best if your goal is 5 years or more.

Avoid touching these funds for short-term needs.

Assess Your Risk Profile Again
Can you tolerate market ups and downs?

Mid-caps can fall 20–30% in a bad year.

Flexi-caps are slightly safer but still volatile.

Review your mental comfort with losses during down cycles.

If you feel uncomfortable, reduce equity exposure slowly.

Important Note on Direct Mutual Funds
Direct funds charge lower expense ratio.

But they come with no professional support.

No monitoring, no guidance on when to switch or rebalance.

Mistakes in choosing or staying in wrong fund can harm returns.

Investing through a trusted MFD with CFP qualification is safer.

They give timely advice and personalized portfolio reviews.

Long-term value comes from right guidance, not just lower fees.

Better to use regular plans through qualified planners.

Taxation Angle (If You Sell)
If you sell within one year, 20% tax is on short-term gains.

If you sell after one year, gains above Rs. 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.

Mid-cap funds may have more capital gains if held long.

Check holding period before selling to avoid unnecessary tax.

Better to wait for long-term status before any redemption.

Portfolio Rebalancing – Is It Needed?
Rebalancing is needed only if your goals or risk profile change.

Your mix now is around 70:30 flexi to mid-cap.

That is reasonable for a balanced investor.

Only rebalance if you add new goals or want to reduce risk.

No need for urgent switching or reshuffling at this point.

When to Consider Redemption
Only if your goal is approaching.

Or if you need the funds for any emergency.

Else, stay invested and allow compounding to work.

Redemption should not be based on market noise.

Base it only on your personal financial plan.

Suggested 360-Degree Approach
Resume SIP in flexi-cap fund for long-term growth.

Hold mid-cap investment and let it grow over time.

Do not shift money between these funds via STP.

Review your goals, risk profile, and investment horizon regularly.

Avoid using direct mutual funds to get the right guidance.

Use a certified financial planner for long-term investment health.

Keep your emotions away from short-term market moves.

Focus on your goals, not on recent returns.

Finally
You have done a good job by investing early and diversifying.

Now it’s time to take the next step smartly.

A systematic and goal-oriented strategy works better than reactive moves.

Continue with discipline and professional support.

Let your portfolio grow quietly with time and patience.

Keep monitoring your portfolio with a certified planner’s help.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8513 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 29, 2024

Listen
Money
I am investing in following funds through SIP 1. HDFC top 200 Regular Growth since 2010 Rs. 3000 2. ICICI PRUDENTIAL LARGE & MIDCAP FUND GROWTH SINCE 2014 Rs. 2000 3. BANDHAN FLEXICAP FUND-GROWTH SINCE 2011 Rs. 2000 4. BSL FRONTLINE EQUITY FUND - GROWTH SINCE 2010 Rs. 3000 (STOPPED SIP IN 2020) 5. MIRAE ASSET BLUECHIP FUND - GROWTH SINCE 2021 Rs. 2500 6. HDFC FLEXI CAP - GROWTH SINCE 2022 Rs. 5500 PLEASE ADVICE ME WHETHER I SHOULD CONTINUE WITH THESE FUNDS OR EXIT. I FURTHER WANT TO INVEST Rs. 15000 MORE. PLEASE SUGGEST WHETHER I SHOULD INCREASE SIP AMOUNT IN THESE FUNDS OR START SIP IN NEW FUND
Ans: Assessing Your Mutual Fund Investments and Planning for the Future

Your portfolio demonstrates a disciplined approach to mutual fund investing over the years. Let's evaluate your current holdings and chart a course for future investments.

Analyzing Existing SIPs

HDFC Top 200, ICICI Prudential Large & Midcap, and Bandhan Flexicap Funds have been part of your investment journey for several years. These funds offer exposure to different market segments, providing diversification benefits.

BSL Frontline Equity Fund, while stopped in 2020, has a long track record of performance. It's essential to review the reasons for discontinuing this SIP and assess whether it aligns with your current investment strategy.

Mirae Asset Bluechip Fund and HDFC Flexi Cap Fund, initiated more recently, contribute to diversification and may offer growth potential.

Evaluating Performance and Suitability

Review the performance of each fund relative to its benchmark and peer group. Assess whether the fund manager's investment approach and strategy align with your risk tolerance and investment objectives.

Consider the consistency of returns, risk-adjusted performance, and fund management quality. Additionally, evaluate the fund's expense ratio and turnover ratio to ensure cost-effectiveness.

Deciding Whether to Continue or Exit

Continue SIPs in funds with consistent performance, robust fundamentals, and alignment with your investment goals.

Consider exiting funds that consistently underperform their benchmarks or peers, have experienced significant changes in fund management, or deviate from your risk profile.

Planning Additional Investments

Given your intention to invest an additional Rs. 15,000, consider the following options:

Increase SIP amounts in existing funds with proven track records and growth potential. This approach maintains continuity and capitalizes on the strengths of your current portfolio.

Explore new funds that complement your existing holdings and provide exposure to underrepresented sectors or asset classes. Conduct thorough research and seek professional advice to identify suitable options.

Seeking Professional Guidance

As a Certified Financial Planner, I recommend conducting a comprehensive portfolio review to ensure alignment with your financial goals and risk tolerance. Regular monitoring and periodic adjustments are essential to optimize your investment outcomes.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8513 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 25, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 24, 2025
Money
Hi Ramalingam Sir, First of all thank you for your replies for my previous queries. I am 41 yrs old private employee earning 1.5 lakhs per month. I and my brother combined constructed a house 5 years back by taking joint loan of 59lakhs with 9.1 interest (floating)for 21 years. We both are paying 50k per month. 25k each. Till now not much principal got reduced. We have opened one joint account and adding some amount of 4k (each 2k) every month and thinking to pay as principal amount at end of year. I don't feel it is good idea but we are not getting any idea. Could you please give us suggestion on how to pay this loan as much as early.? Thanks in advance
Ans: You have done a great thing by co-owning and sharing a loan. It takes planning and commitment. Paying a long-term loan early needs careful steps. A focused strategy will help you save interest and reduce stress.

Below is a complete 360-degree solution. This will help you close the loan faster and stay financially safe.

1. Understanding Your Current Loan Structure

You and your brother took a joint home loan of Rs. 59 lakhs.

Interest is 9.1% (floating). That’s quite high.

You both are paying Rs. 25,000 each, totalling Rs. 50,000 monthly.

The loan tenure is 21 years.

After 5 years, principal reduction is still very low.

This is because in early years, interest eats most of EMI.

Your method of saving Rs. 4,000 monthly to prepay annually is good in spirit.

But in action, it may not create much impact.

Let us explore a better plan.

2. Step-by-Step Review of the Issue

Your interest rate is 9.1%, which is high today.

Loan is 5 years old, so around 16 years are left.

You have already paid around Rs. 30 lakhs in EMIs.

Still, the loan principal hasn’t reduced much.

This means you are in the heavy-interest zone.

Time is the biggest cost here.

Faster principal reduction will save a lot of interest.

You can’t just depend on small yearly prepayment.

3. First Action – Review and Refinance the Loan

First, check your current loan outstanding.

Check your repayment schedule from bank or netbanking.

See how much of EMI is going to interest.

Now consider transferring the loan to a new bank.

Many banks now offer home loans around 8.3% to 8.6%.

A 0.5% difference may look small.

But it can save lakhs over remaining years.

You and your brother must compare 3–4 lenders.

If new bank is ready, shift to a lower rate.

No harm in reducing tenure while transferring.

Even 2–3 years cut in tenure saves a lot.

4. Revisit EMI and Tenure

You are paying Rs. 25,000 monthly.

This may be within your budget.

If yes, try to increase EMI by Rs. 2,000–Rs. 3,000 per head.

Higher EMI cuts principal faster.

Lower tenure means lesser interest burden.

Use the new EMI wisely by combining refinance and increased payment.

Avoid extending the loan tenure again.

If possible, reduce tenure instead of EMI.

5. Rethink the Annual Rs. 4,000 Saving Approach

Saving Rs. 4,000 monthly in joint account is okay.

But idle money doesn’t grow.

Interest in bank account is very low.

Instead, invest this Rs. 4,000 in a short-term debt mutual fund.

Use regular plan through MFD with CFP credential.

Direct plans may look cheaper but lack support and rebalancing.

With regular plan, you get better advice and ongoing help.

At year-end, redeem and prepay lump sum against principal.

Debt funds offer better growth than savings account.

Tax efficiency is also better if used wisely.

6. Create an Emergency Buffer Separately

Prepaying is good, but emergency safety is more important.

Before aggressive prepayment, build a safety fund.

Keep at least 3–6 months of EMI and expenses as emergency fund.

Use liquid mutual funds for this.

This protects your EMI even if job or cashflow is hit.

Avoid using your loan prepayment savings for emergencies.

Keep the two goals separate.

7. Avoid Prepayment from Retirement Corpus

Never touch EPF, PPF or long-term savings for loan prepayment.

That may create future income problems.

Let those assets grow for your retirement years.

Housing loan can be managed with better cashflow planning.

Prioritise steady investments over aggressive prepayment from retirement corpus.

8. Align Investments and Loan Closure Together

If you want to clear the loan faster, balance it with investment goals.

You can run SIPs and prepayment both side by side.

Divide monthly surplus into three:

Some for SIPs in active mutual funds.

Some for yearly lump sum prepayment.

Some for emergencies.

This keeps wealth creation, risk cover, and debt reduction in sync.

Don't stop SIPs completely just to prepay faster.

Mutual funds give long-term growth and liquidity.

9. Tax Benefit Assessment

Home loan offers tax deductions on interest and principal.

You both are eligible for 80C (principal) and 24(b) (interest) benefits.

Check if you are using full benefit.

But don’t keep loan just for tax saving.

Interest outgo is more than tax saved in most cases.

It is better to close loan early and then invest that EMI.

You get better peace of mind and cashflow freedom.

10. Use Bonuses and Extra Income Smartly

You may receive bonus, incentives, or yearly hikes.

Use a fixed portion of that money to prepay loan.

For example, 40% of bonus goes to loan, 40% to investments.

Remaining 20% for personal spending.

This method helps in faster loan closure.

But keeps your future goals also on track.

11. Communicate and Review as a Team

You and your brother are managing the loan together.

That’s a great responsibility and effort.

Keep monthly reviews and open communication.

Review the bank statement, interest paid, and outstanding.

Every prepayment reduces total interest burden.

Celebrate milestones like Rs. 5 lakh principal paid off.

It will keep both of you motivated and united.

12. Don’t Buy More Real Estate Now

Your existing home is already a big commitment.

Avoid investing in second property.

Real estate has poor liquidity and low regular returns.

Maintenance cost, property tax, and legal risk are high.

Don’t stretch finances with multiple loans.

Build wealth through financial assets instead.

13. Take a Certified Financial Planner’s Help Once a Year

Every year review your plan with a Certified Financial Planner.

Check how much principal is left.

Plan SIPs, investments, and prepayment in right proportion.

Review life and health insurance too.

A CFP helps you align your goals with numbers and strategies.

14. Insurance Protection Check

Ensure you and your brother both have term insurance.

This secures the loan liability.

If something happens to one person, the other isn’t burdened.

Term plan is low-cost and covers only risk.

Avoid policies that combine insurance and investments.

15. Track Your Progress Annually

Make a simple tracker in Excel or diary.

Note EMI paid, principal reduced, balance left.

Mark each prepayment.

It motivates and helps fine-tune future decisions.

Share the sheet with your brother too.

Finally

You both have made a good effort so far.

The first five years of a loan are toughest.

Now is the best time to take control.

Don’t let the high interest eat your future savings.

Use a mix of refinance, EMI increase, short-term fund, and lump sum payments.

Don’t compromise on long-term investments and insurance.

Keep your goals clear and emotions away from decisions.

Your loan can be closed 5–7 years early with these changes.

That will free up cash for future dreams and peace of mind.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8513 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 25, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 25, 2025
Money
Hi, I am 52 and working in a Central Government job. My gross salary is around 2.5lacs. My husband is 53 yrs old and working in a pvt company. His take home is 4.2l per month. We have two flats worth 1.7cr each which are currently in use. We have another flat worth 2.5cr. Apart from this we have a farmhouse land worth 80l and some ancestral property worth 50l. We have two children, elder daughter in final year of degree and wants to pursue higher education abroad. Son is 18 and has taken admission in Btech this year. His monthly expenditure including everything will be around 60 thousand. Apart from this we have a monthly expenditure of 1L and due to husband ongoing health issues considerable expenditure on treatment around 1l we both have around 1.5 cr in epf, 30l in stocks and 8l on sip. Also 6vl each in ppf Due to health issues, husband want to able to continue his job long and has to take premature retirement. What should be our future investment plans. Kindly guide
Ans: You have worked hard and saved well. Your current asset base is strong. Your financial situation now needs a clear, future-ready plan. Let’s assess, realign, and plan forward with clarity and balance.

Here is a detailed 360-degree solution designed just for your needs.

1. Understand the New Phase

You are entering a key transition stage in life.

Your family income may reduce soon.

Medical costs are rising steadily.

Children’s higher education will need big money.

Retirement is also nearing.

Hence, your money must now work smarter.

2. Current Income and Expenses

Monthly family income is around Rs. 6.7 lakhs.

Household and son’s expenses are Rs. 1.6 lakhs monthly.

Medical treatment adds Rs. 1 lakh per month.

So total regular outflow is Rs. 2.6 lakhs monthly.

This leaves you a surplus of Rs. 4.1 lakhs now.

However, post-retirement, husband’s income may stop.

Then surplus may drop to Rs. 0.9 lakhs per month.

This calls for adjusting investments wisely.

3. Children’s Higher Education Planning

Your daughter wants to study abroad soon.

Expenses may go beyond Rs. 40–50 lakhs easily.

Please don’t redeem retirement corpus for this.

Instead, plan to liquidate from equity-based assets.

Start a step-by-step Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP).

You may also liquidate part of your flat worth Rs. 2.5 crore.

If needed, consider an education loan partially.

This keeps your retirement fund safe.

4. Husband’s Premature Retirement

This needs realignment of your financial plan.

Ensure a minimum of 5 years expenses are protected.

This means Rs. 1.6 lakhs x 60 months = Rs. 96 lakhs.

Keep this amount in low-risk debt mutual funds.

Avoid taking this from EPF or PPF.

Use proceeds from one flat if necessary.

SIPs must continue, but evaluate rebalancing based on income drop.

5. Medical Contingency Planning

Your husband’s treatment cost is high.

Medical inflation is rising rapidly.

Ensure both of you have health insurance.

Prefer a Rs. 25–50 lakh family floater with super top-up.

Do not depend only on employer health cover.

Keep an emergency fund of Rs. 10–15 lakhs separate.

This can be in liquid or ultra-short debt mutual funds.

6. Retirement Planning for Both

You are 52 and still employed.

Retirement age may be around 58–60 years.

That gives you 6–8 years of active income.

Use this period to build a strong retirement fund.

Don’t withdraw EPF or PPF till maturity.

Consider contributing more in mutual funds through SIPs.

Keep retirement corpus in low-cost, diversified active funds.

Don't shift funds into annuity options.

Post-retirement, plan a SWP from mutual funds for income.

Try to build a retirement corpus of Rs. 3–4 crores.

This will give Rs. 1–1.25 lakhs income monthly.

Include spouse’s expenses, inflation, and medical needs.

7. Existing Real Estate Assets

You have three flats. Two are for your use.

The third one is worth Rs. 2.5 crores.

Avoid holding it just for value appreciation.

Use it strategically for daughter’s education and corpus building.

Avoid further real estate purchases now.

Real estate is not liquid.

It doesn’t give regular income.

It has high maintenance and poor tax efficiency.

Your real estate exposure is already high.

8. Existing Investments Analysis

EPF and PPF total is around Rs. 1.62 crores.

Stocks worth Rs. 30 lakhs add moderate risk.

SIPs are Rs. 8 lakhs value currently.

Continue SIPs in well-diversified active mutual funds.

Prefer regular plan with guidance from MFD with CFP credential.

Direct plans don’t suit every investor.

Regular plans offer rebalancing, review, and advice.

Stocks are fine, but not for short-term needs.

Try not to add more unless you have time to review.

Mutual funds offer better diversification and control.

Ensure debt-equity mix is rebalanced annually.

9. Tax Planning and Investment Efficiency

EPF, PPF are tax-free on maturity.

Mutual fund gains are taxable.

LTCG on equity funds above Rs. 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%.

STCG is taxed at 20%.

Debt fund gains are taxed as per your slab.

Plan redemptions smartly to reduce tax burden.

Avoid too many redemptions at once.

Spread them across financial years.

Get Form 26AS checked every year.

Don’t buy insurance for tax saving.

10. Cash Flow Planning Post-Retirement

Husband’s income may stop soon.

Your income will continue till 58 or 60.

Use your salary to fund most expenses till then.

From age 60, use SWP from mutual funds.

Add rental income if any in future.

Avoid bank FDs for monthly income.

They have low returns and poor taxation.

Instead, use a ladder of debt funds for short-term needs.

Equity mutual funds for long-term growth.

11. Insurance Cover Check

Check your term insurance if still active.

If not, you may not need one now.

Your asset base is strong.

Focus more on health insurance.

Take a separate critical illness cover too.

Medical costs can deplete savings quickly.

Review nominee details in every policy.

12. Estate and Will Planning

You have significant real estate and investments.

Children will inherit eventually.

Prepare a registered Will soon.

Mention who gets what clearly.

Include mutual funds, EPF, PPF, stocks, property.

Assign separate nominees for each asset class.

This avoids future disputes and confusion.

Discuss openly with your children.

13. Investment Behaviour Going Forward

Keep emotions out of investment decisions.

Don’t redeem when markets fall.

Follow asset allocation method strictly.

Every year review the plan.

Rebalance mutual funds once a year.

Reinvest redemptions wisely.

Don’t increase real estate holding further.

Don’t fall for hot stock tips.

Avoid policies combining insurance and investment.

Finally

Your current position is strong.

Your focus should be on protection and preservation.

Avoid risky investments now.

Plan each goal with a dedicated fund.

Keep enough liquidity for health and education.

Create predictable income sources post-retirement.

Work with a Certified Financial Planner yearly.

Review goals, returns, risks and expenses every year.

Stay disciplined and goal-oriented.

Your family’s financial future will remain safe.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x