Sir/mam My son is mentally not well, though doing BPHARM. I am also 60yr, I can support 15k-20k per month for 10 yrs for his future MIS cum pension . Which scheme - Mutual fund/ NPS/ APYS. I should go for him?

Ans: Hello Nagarajan Ji! Thank you for writing to me. A hearty congratulations to You and Your Family!

For him to create a corpus of Rs.1 Crore in 7 years, he will need to invest around Rs.78,000 per month and to create a corpus of 1 Crore in 10 years, he will need to invest Rs.45,000 every month.

He can consider investing in a mix of mutual fund types like:

1-Small & Mid Cap Funds (Around 30% weight)
2-Multi Asset Funds (Around 20% weight)
3-Aggressive Hybrid Funds (Around 30% weight)
4-Flexicap Funds (Around 20% weight)

Annually steeping up his SIP will help him create the Rs.1 Crore corpus faster.

Ans: It's commendable that you're prioritizing financial planning at such a young age. Let's delve into your investment options:

• Firstly, I appreciate your disciplined approach to investing through SIPs, which is a smart way to build wealth over time.
• It's great that you're thinking ahead about your son's future education and your retirement needs.

• Considering your current investments, we can explore additional mutual fund options to diversify your portfolio.
• Diversification helps spread risk and optimize returns, essential for achieving long-term financial goals.

• When it comes to investing for your son's education and your retirement, it's crucial to align your investments with your time horizon and risk tolerance.
• For long-term goals like these, equity mutual funds offer the potential for higher returns, albeit with higher volatility.

• Regarding your query about the National Pension System (NPS) versus mutual funds, both have their pros and cons.
• NPS offers tax benefits and a structured retirement savings platform, but it comes with restrictions on withdrawals and limited investment choices.

• On the other hand, mutual funds provide greater flexibility in investment choices and withdrawal options.
• However, they lack the tax benefits of NPS.

• Ultimately, the decision between NPS and mutual funds depends on your individual preferences, risk appetite, and financial goals.
• It's essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option and choose the one that best aligns with your needs.

• As a Certified Financial Planner, I can help you analyze your financial situation and goals to create a customized investment plan.
• Together, we'll select suitable mutual funds that balance growth potential and risk for your son's education and retirement.

• Remember, investing is a journey, and it's essential to stay disciplined and focused on your long-term objectives.
• With careful planning and prudent decision-making, you can build a secure financial future for yourself and your family.

• Keep up the excellent work with your investments, and don't hesitate to reach out if you have any further questions or need assistance.
• You're on the right track towards achieving your financial aspirations, and I'm here to support you every step of the way.

Ans: Your current investment strategy is well thought out, considering various goals for your family’s future. With a monthly surplus of Rs 70,000 after closing your home loan, you’ve allocated this amount towards multiple financial goals. Let's assess each component of your plan and evaluate its effectiveness for low-risk investments while considering your children's future.

Gold ETF vs. Gold Mutual Fund
Gold ETF: Gold ETFs are cost-efficient and directly linked to the price of gold. They are traded like stocks and have lower expense ratios compared to gold mutual funds. They provide liquidity and allow you to hold physical gold in electronic form without the storage hassle.

Gold Mutual Fund: Gold mutual funds invest in gold ETFs. These funds are more accessible, especially for investors who don’t have a demat account. However, they come with a higher expense ratio compared to ETFs.

For long-term investment in gold, Gold ETFs would be a better choice because of lower costs and direct linkage to gold prices. However, both options are relatively safe for gold investments.

NPS Vatsalya Scheme for Children
You’ve planned to invest Rs 5,000 per month for each of your sons in the NPS Vatsalya scheme. Let’s analyse whether NPS is the best option for your children's future.

NPS Benefits: NPS is a low-cost, government-backed pension scheme. While it offers tax benefits, it is primarily a retirement planning tool. Since NPS locks in the corpus until retirement age, it may not be the most ideal choice for children's education or other financial needs before they turn 60.
For your sons’ future, it might be better to consider long-term equity mutual funds or child plans that provide flexibility and potential higher returns for educational needs or other significant life events. Mutual funds allow partial withdrawals and can align better with milestones like higher education or marriage.

Suggested Alternatives:

Consider equity mutual funds with a long-term horizon, which provide better growth potential for your sons' future goals.
You could also explore child education plans that offer benefits aligned with specific milestones like higher education.
Recurring Deposits (RDs) for Short-Term Goals
20K for School Fees: This allocation is prudent. RDs are safe, and since the goal is short-term, using an RD for your children’s school fees next year is a sound strategy. It ensures safety and liquidity.

15K for Family Vacation: Saving in an RD for your family vacation is a good idea for the short term. It keeps your savings safe and ensures you can use the funds when needed without risking market fluctuations.

Assessment:

For both these short-term goals, RDs are a low-risk and appropriate choice.
Mutual Fund SIPs
15K for Mutual Fund SIP: Allocating Rs 15,000 towards equity mutual funds via SIPs is a smart move for wealth creation. Equity mutual funds are suitable for long-term goals, and SIPs bring discipline and rupee cost averaging.
Since you are already investing Rs 40,000 per month in mutual funds, increasing this by Rs 15,000 strengthens your portfolio and ensures long-term growth potential. This balance between equity investments and safer options like RDs and gold is a well-rounded strategy.

Insight:

Diversifying your SIPs across large-cap, mid-cap, and hybrid funds can help manage risk and improve returns over time.
Ensure you are invested in actively managed mutual funds instead of index funds to maximize your returns, as actively managed funds have the potential to outperform in different market conditions.
Evaluating Your Current Investments
Rs 40K in SIPs: Your existing investment of Rs 40,000 per month in mutual funds shows a good focus on long-term growth. Since mutual funds offer better growth potential than traditional savings, it is a good strategy to balance risk and reward.

Rs 10K in Term Plan (SA 1.5 CR): A term plan is an essential part of any financial plan, especially for a family. Your term plan with a sum assured of Rs 1.5 crore is adequate to provide for your family in case of any unforeseen circumstances. Continue with this policy as it serves to protect your family financially.

Rs 20K in Conventional Insurance Plans: Conventional insurance plans often provide lower returns compared to mutual funds or other investment options. They usually mix insurance and investment, which results in sub-optimal returns. You may want to reconsider whether these plans align with your long-term goals. Instead, pure term insurance for protection, combined with mutual funds for growth, usually provides better results.

Rs 40K in PF & PPF: Your existing contributions to PF and PPF are ideal for low-risk, long-term saving. These schemes offer safe, tax-efficient growth. Keep contributing as they ensure stability in your portfolio.

Rs 10K in NPS: Investing in NPS for your own retirement is a sound decision, as it provides tax benefits and helps you build a retirement corpus with a mix of equity and debt exposure.

Suggestions for Improvement
NPS for Children: As discussed, NPS is not the best fit for your sons’ future. For their education and other life goals, consider investing in mutual funds or dedicated child plans instead.

Reevaluate Conventional Insurance Plans: These plans often come with low returns and high costs. If possible, shift the investment component to equity mutual funds or SIPs. You already have sufficient life insurance coverage through your term plan.

Increase SIP Contributions Gradually: Over time, as your income grows, try to increase your SIP contributions. Even a 10-15% increase every year can significantly boost your wealth over the long term, thanks to the power of compounding.

Ensure Proper Allocation for Retirement: While you are focusing on your children’s future and short-term goals, ensure that your retirement planning is not compromised. Continue contributions to PF, PPF, and NPS while allocating enough towards equity mutual funds for long-term growth.

Final Insights
Your approach is a solid mix of safety and growth, reflecting thoughtful planning. The inclusion of RDs for short-term goals, gold for diversification, and mutual funds for long-term wealth creation provides balance. However, reconsidering NPS for your children and conventional insurance plans can optimize your strategy further.

Your commitment to Rs 40K in PF, PPF, and Rs 10K in your NPS ensures long-term stability. The additional Rs 70K per month is wisely planned for both low-risk and growth-oriented goals. Keep reviewing your strategy periodically to adjust to any changes in income, goals, or market conditions.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

Ans: First of all, it’s truly admirable that you are planning for your son’s financial security well in advance. Your goals of building a sizeable corpus for your son, without him having to worry about his future, are heartfelt and achievable with proper planning.

Your combined salary of Rs. 2.4 lakh per month and monthly expenses of Rs. 1 lakh give you a comfortable margin for savings. The fact that you are focused on using your Rs. 60 lakh life savings for your son’s future and keeping the agricultural land for your retirement shows that you are clear about your objectives.

However, there are a few things to reassess in your current plan, particularly regarding your fund selection and the potential risks involved.

Reassessing Index Fund Investments
While it may seem that investing in index funds like the ICICI Prudential Nifty 50 Index Fund Direct Growth can give you exposure to the top companies in the country, this approach has certain limitations.

Disadvantages of Index Funds:

Lack of Flexibility: Index funds are passively managed and follow the market index. They cannot adapt quickly during market downturns. So, when markets fall, the fund's value can drop significantly.

No Outperformance: Index funds only aim to replicate the market performance. They don’t strive to beat the market, which can limit the potential for higher returns over time, especially over a long horizon of 25 years. In contrast, actively managed funds can outperform during bullish markets and provide better returns.

No Cushion in Bear Markets: Actively managed funds can cushion market falls by allocating resources into safer stocks or sectors when the market sentiment turns negative. Index funds, on the other hand, have to follow the index, regardless of the market situation.

Assessing Direct Funds
Direct plans of mutual funds usually have lower expense ratios than regular plans, which can translate to slightly better returns. However, there are some disadvantages, especially for long-term and large goals like the one you have for your son.

Disadvantages of Direct Funds:

No Professional Guidance: Direct plans leave you on your own to decide where and how much to invest. While this may seem cost-effective, over 25 years, professional guidance from a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) can be invaluable, especially in dealing with changing market conditions or rebalancing your portfolio.

Difficulties in Managing Portfolio: With multiple direct funds, it can become overwhelming to manage and track the performance of each one. A Certified Financial Planner can help you rebalance your portfolio periodically, ensure proper diversification, and adjust investments based on life changes or market conditions.

Potential to Miss Out on Opportunities: A qualified financial planner can identify growth opportunities, new funds, or even better-performing funds, which may be missed when managing investments independently.

Active Funds as a Preferred Choice
To build a big corpus over a long period of 25 years, actively managed mutual funds tend to perform better than index funds due to the expertise of fund managers in stock selection and timing the market cycles. Here’s why:

Better Returns Potential: Active funds, especially those with a strong track record, aim to outperform the market. Over a long period, this outperformance can result in significantly larger corpus compared to index funds.

Flexibility in Stock Selection: Fund managers can pick and choose stocks that are expected to outperform based on market conditions, industry trends, or specific company performance, which is crucial for long-term wealth creation.

Tactical Rebalancing: Active funds adjust their allocations depending on market cycles and economic changes, which can reduce downside risk and enhance returns.

Evaluating Your Fund Selection
Let’s now evaluate the current funds you’ve chosen for your son’s corpus and retirement goals.

1. Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund
Suitability: This fund provides exposure to both domestic and international markets, giving you good diversification. It’s an actively managed fund, and flexi-cap funds can adjust between large, mid, and small-cap stocks based on market conditions.

Risk & Return: The fund can offer strong returns over the long term but has higher volatility than pure large-cap funds. Given your 25-year horizon, this volatility can be managed.

2. Nippon India Small Cap Fund
Suitability: Small-cap funds have the potential for high growth but are also very volatile. Over a 25-year period, these funds can generate strong returns, but they come with the risk of significant fluctuations in the short term.

Risk & Return: Small-cap funds are best suited for aggressive investors with a long-term horizon, like you. However, consider limiting the allocation to small-cap funds due to their high-risk nature.

3. ICICI Value Discovery Fund
Suitability: This fund follows a value-investing approach, which aims to pick undervalued stocks with strong long-term growth potential. This can be a good complement to your portfolio.

Risk & Return: It’s a well-diversified fund that balances risk and reward, and can be part of your portfolio for stable, long-term growth.

4. Quant Midcap Fund
Suitability: Mid-cap funds strike a balance between risk and return. They have more growth potential than large-caps but are less risky than small-caps.

Risk & Return: Over 25 years, mid-cap funds can be a strong contributor to wealth creation. However, like small-cap funds, they are subject to short-term volatility.

Suggested Portfolio Strategy
Given your plan to secure your son’s financial future, you need a well-diversified portfolio that balances growth and risk. Here’s a more balanced approach to your investment strategy:

Recommended Portfolio:

Large-Cap and Flexi-Cap Funds (40%): These funds will provide stability and steady returns over the long term. While large-cap funds focus on blue-chip stocks, flexi-cap funds provide flexibility across all market capitalizations.

Mid-Cap Funds (30%): These funds are ideal for long-term growth and will help boost the overall corpus. However, keep the allocation to a moderate level to balance the risk.

Small-Cap Funds (20%): Small-cap funds can offer explosive growth potential over 25 years but are risky in the short term. Keep this allocation limited to avoid exposing the entire corpus to high risk.

Balanced or Hybrid Funds (10%): To add some stability to your portfolio, consider adding balanced funds that invest in both equity and debt. This will help protect against extreme volatility while providing moderate growth.

SIPs for Long-Term Growth
Since you are also planning to continue with Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) for the next 25 years, you are on the right track. SIPs will help in averaging the purchase price of units and reduce the risk of investing lump sums at market peaks.

Benefits of SIP:

Rupee Cost Averaging: SIPs ensure you are investing across market cycles, averaging out the purchase price over time.

Disciplined Investment: Regular investments over 25 years will help you accumulate a significant corpus without the emotional burden of market timing.

Retirement Planning for You and Your Wife
Although your focus is currently on securing your son’s financial future, it’s also essential to review your retirement planning. While you have an agricultural land worth Rs. 1 crore, relying entirely on it for retirement could be risky due to market and valuation changes in the future.

Consider diversifying your retirement savings into liquid assets like mutual funds and other safer instruments. A combination of equity and debt mutual funds for retirement can provide stability and growth over time.

Final Insights
You have taken excellent steps toward ensuring financial security for your disabled son. Your decision to invest a significant amount for long-term growth is well thought out. However, it’s crucial to reassess the reliance on index and direct funds and opt for actively managed funds through a certified financial planner. By diversifying your portfolio with a mix of large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap funds, you can strike a balance between risk and return.

Additionally, continuing SIPs for 25 years is a sound strategy for long-term wealth accumulation. Keep your focus on disciplined investing, and consider adding some hybrid or balanced funds to manage volatility.

Lastly, review your retirement planning and ensure you have adequate liquid assets aside from the agricultural land. This will give you peace of mind, knowing that both your son's future and your retirement are secure.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment