Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Omkeshwar

Omkeshwar Singh  | Answer  |Ask -

Head, Rank MF - Answered on Sep 19, 2022

Mutual Fund Expert... more
Ankit Question by Ankit on Sep 19, 2022Hindi
Listen
Money

I'm 38 years old and have been investing since 7 years. I have accumulated 35 lakh in my MF portfolio. Presently I'm investing in following funds/ govt schemes monthly:

1. Nippon small cap- 25000

2. SBI small cap- 10000

3. Parag parekh flexi cap- 15000

4. Mirae asset emerging bluechip- 14000

5. Quant Absolute fund- 14000

6. Sukanya samridhi- 4000 

7. PPF- 40000( present corpus 60 lakh)

I intend retiring after 7 years at the age of 45. I am expecting to achieve a corpus of Rs 3 crore including both MF and PPF.

Kindly advice sir if my investments are in line or do I need to do something else.

Ans: PPF: corpus will be Rs 1 crore

SS: Corpus Rs 4 lakh

MF: Corpus will be Rs 1.45 crore

Total in next 7 years will be nearly Rs 2.5 crore.

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8111 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Apr 12, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Apr 03, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
I am 50 working professional. Below is my MF portfolio . 1. Parag Parikh Flexi Cap Fund 2.6 lakhs + 10K SIP 2. PGIM India Midcap Opportunities Fund 1.85 L Value + 5K SIP 3. Quant ELSS Tax Saver Fund 80K 4. Axis Small Cap Fund 1.85 Lakhs Value + 5K SIP 5. Axis Gold Fund 75K Value + 5K SIP 6. Canara Robeco Bluechip Equity Fund 70K 7. Quant Multi Asset Fund 50K 8. SBI Magnum Income Fund 50K 9. ICICI Prudential Equity & Debt Fund 50K 10. Quant Active Fund 50K 11. ICICI Prudential Bluechip Fund 25K I want to build a retirement corpus of 2 crore in 10 years. I am planning to invest around 50K every month. Plus i have. surplus of 4Lakks which i want to invest in few of the MFs above. Planning to exit Canara Robeco bluechip and Axis Small cap soon. Please suggest if any changes you want me to do.
Ans: Given your goal of building a retirement corpus of 2 crores in 10 years and your current portfolio, here are some suggestions:

Increase SIP Contributions: Consider increasing your SIP amounts in high-performing funds like Parag Parikh Flexi Cap and PGIM India Midcap Opportunities Fund, which have shown good potential for long-term growth.

Review and Consolidate: Evaluate the performance of all your funds and consider consolidating your portfolio to fewer, well-performing funds to simplify management and potentially enhance returns.

Focus on Quality: Prioritize funds with strong track records, consistent performance, and experienced fund management teams. Consider adding large-cap and diversified equity funds for stability and balanced growth.

Asset Allocation: Ensure a balanced asset allocation across equity, debt, and gold funds based on your risk tolerance and investment horizon. Reallocate surplus funds strategically to maintain a diversified portfolio.

Regular Review: Monitor your portfolio regularly and make adjustments as needed based on changes in market conditions, fund performance, and your financial goals.

Consider consulting with a financial advisor for personalized advice tailored to your specific circumstances and goals.

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8111 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 11, 2024

Listen
Money
I am 42 years salaried person investing in MF through SIP from 2014 current corpus is 37 Lakhs in MF. My Current SIP's amount is rs 22000 PM as follows- 1. Nippon Small cap - 2000, 2. Mahindra manulife midcap fund - 7000, Mahindra Manulife Small cap - 4000, PGIM Midcap opportunities Fund - 3000, Quant Flexicap fund - 6000. SIP increasing every year by 5% to 10% No Home loan, term insurance 55 lakhs, medi-claim 10 lakhs, PF & VPF accumulation Rs 16 lakhs. I want to create a good corpus of Rs 6 - 7crore for retirement at 58 years of age. Please suggest if any change required in investment amount or funds.
Ans: It's commendable that you've been consistently investing in mutual funds through SIPs for several years, laying a strong foundation for your retirement. Let's evaluate your current investment strategy and make adjustments to align with your retirement goal.

Your portfolio reflects a diversified mix of small-cap, mid-cap, and flexi-cap funds, which offer growth potential over the long term. However, given your goal of building a substantial corpus for retirement, we may need to reassess your asset allocation and make some adjustments.

Firstly, let's review your SIP amounts and consider increasing them gradually to accelerate wealth accumulation. Since your SIPs increase by 5% to 10% annually, this incremental growth can boost your investment corpus significantly over time.

Consider reallocating some of your SIP amounts to funds with a proven track record of consistent performance and lower volatility. While small-cap and mid-cap funds can offer higher returns, they also come with increased risk. Diversifying across large-cap funds or balanced funds can provide stability to your portfolio.

Moreover, review your overall asset allocation to ensure it remains aligned with your risk tolerance and investment objectives. While equity investments offer growth potential, it's essential to balance them with fixed-income securities like debt funds or PPF to mitigate risk.

Given your age and retirement horizon, periodically reassess your investment strategy and make necessary adjustments to stay on track towards your goal. Consider consulting with a Certified Financial Planner to develop a personalized retirement plan tailored to your needs and aspirations.

In conclusion, by fine-tuning your investment strategy, increasing your SIP amounts, and maintaining a disciplined approach, you can work towards achieving your retirement goal of building a corpus of Rs 6 - 7 crores by the age of 58.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8111 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jul 11, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Jun 28, 2024Hindi
Money
Dear Sir, I am 55 years old working in private company. I am investing in following MF monthly, Nippon Small Cap - 10000, Axis Small cap - 10000, HSBC Mid Cap - 10000, ICICI Equity & Debt - 15000, Franklin India Prima fund - 15000, HDFC Balanaced Advantage - 20000. My current MF value is Rs. 1.34 Crores. Apart from this i have invested in Stocks - 36 Lac, PF - 45 Lac, NPS - 22 Lac, FD - 35 Lac. I have taken Health Insurance. I require around 40 Lac for my daughter marriage. 1. I want to know whether my MF portfolio is good to continue or any changes to be made for better return. 2. I will be retiring in 3 years. How i need manage my funds / invest further to achieve 5 Crores retirement fund.
Ans: You've done a commendable job with your investments. Balancing between mutual funds, stocks, PF, NPS, and FDs is impressive. Your dedication to securing your daughter's marriage fund and planning for retirement shows foresight and responsibility. Let's analyze and optimize your portfolio for the best possible returns.

Current Mutual Fund Portfolio

Your current mutual fund investments are diversified across various categories. This includes small cap, mid cap, equity & debt, and balanced advantage funds. Each type serves a unique purpose, balancing risk and return.

Small Cap Funds

Small cap funds have high growth potential but come with significant risk. Your investments in Nippon Small Cap and Axis Small Cap Funds are great for high returns over the long term. Given your proximity to retirement, it might be wise to reduce exposure to mitigate risk.

Mid Cap Funds

Mid cap funds like HSBC Mid Cap offer a balance between risk and return. They can provide substantial growth but are less volatile than small cap funds. Keeping a portion in mid cap is sensible, but consider reducing the allocation as you near retirement.

Equity & Debt Funds

ICICI Equity & Debt Fund provides a balanced approach, combining equity growth and debt stability. This fund type aligns well with your nearing retirement, offering moderate risk and steady returns.

Balanced Advantage Funds

HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund adjusts its allocation between equity and debt based on market conditions. This adaptability is beneficial for reducing risk while aiming for reasonable growth, making it suitable for pre-retirement phase.

Evaluation of the Portfolio

Diversification and Risk Management

Your portfolio is well-diversified across different fund types. However, considering your retirement in 3 years, a higher allocation towards stable, low-risk investments would be prudent. Shifting from high-risk small and mid cap funds to more stable options can protect your corpus.

Performance and Returns

Active funds have the potential to outperform the market. Your selection of actively managed funds is excellent. Regular monitoring and occasional rebalancing can enhance performance. Consult your Certified Financial Planner (CFP) for personalized advice.

Strategies for Future Investments
Risk Reduction

As retirement approaches, prioritize capital preservation. Gradually move funds from high-risk to low-risk investments. Consider increasing allocation in debt funds and balanced advantage funds. These provide stability and consistent returns.

Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP)

Implementing an SWP post-retirement ensures a steady income while keeping your investments growing. Plan withdrawals from your corpus strategically to balance between immediate needs and long-term growth.

Power of Compounding

Continue leveraging the power of compounding. Even conservative investments can grow significantly over time. Start transitioning funds early to maximize compound interest benefits while minimizing risks.

Managing Your Other Investments
Stocks

Your Rs 36 lakh in stocks should be evaluated for risk and return. Diversify across stable, high-dividend stocks to generate regular income. Consider reducing exposure to volatile stocks.

Provident Fund (PF)

Your PF of Rs 45 lakh is a substantial and safe retirement corpus. Continue contributions and leverage tax benefits. This fund provides a secure foundation for your retirement.

National Pension System (NPS)

With Rs 22 lakh in NPS, you have a tax-efficient retirement tool. Continue maximizing contributions. NPS offers a mix of equity and debt, providing growth with stability. Consider shifting allocation towards safer options as you near retirement.

Fixed Deposits (FD)

Your Rs 35 lakh in FDs ensures liquidity and safety. Continue using FDs for emergency funds and short-term needs. They offer guaranteed returns, aligning well with your low-risk strategy.

Planning for Your Daughter's Marriage
Marriage Fund Allocation

You need Rs 40 lakh for your daughter’s marriage. Keep this fund in low-risk, highly liquid investments. Short-term debt funds, FDs, or high-interest savings accounts are ideal. Avoid equity exposure for this goal due to market volatility.

Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)

If you haven't already, consider SIPs for a targeted marriage fund. SIPs in debt funds or balanced funds can help accumulate the required amount steadily. Regular contributions will build a substantial corpus by the time needed.

Achieving Your Rs 5 Crore Retirement Goal
Rebalancing Your Portfolio

Shift focus from high-risk to low-risk investments. Increase allocation in debt funds, balanced advantage funds, and other stable options. This transition should start now to align with your retirement timeline.

Increasing Contributions

Maximize your contributions to PF and NPS. Both offer tax benefits and long-term growth. Utilize any available tax-saving schemes to boost your retirement corpus.

Professional Guidance

Regularly consult your CFP. Their expertise will help you navigate market changes, optimize your portfolio, and ensure you stay on track towards your Rs 5 crore goal.

Regular Review

Conduct annual reviews of your portfolio. Adjust based on performance, market conditions, and your changing needs. Stay informed about economic trends and investment opportunities.

Final Insights
You've built a robust and diversified portfolio. Transitioning from high-risk to low-risk investments as you near retirement is crucial. Protecting your capital while ensuring steady growth will help achieve your Rs 5 crore retirement fund.

Stay disciplined with your investment strategy. Regularly consult your CFP for personalized advice. With careful planning and smart adjustments, you can secure a comfortable and financially stable retirement.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8111 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jan 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jan 09, 2025Hindi
Listen
Money
I am 39 and My in-hand salary is 90K and additional rental income of 15k from my house (loan free), which will start from next month. My current monthly expenses are around 50K. I have PPF balance of 14 lakhs and a PF (including VPF) balance of 10 Lakhs, contributing 1.5 Lakhs to PPF annually and 2.3K to PF and 10.2K mothly to VPF respectively. Also have an FD of 1.5 Lakhs. I am new to MF and have started investing since last April. My MF balance is 1.23 lakhs, details of which are as ICICI Prudential Nifty 50 index fund - 5000 p.m. Parag Parikh Flexi cap fund - 2000 p.m. Quant Small cap fund - 2000 p.m. UTI Nifty 500 value 50 index fund - 2000 p.m. ICICI Prudential Bharat 22 FOF scheme - 1500 p.m. ICICI Prudential Retirement Fund - Hybrid aggressive - 3000 p.m. Looking for advise for two questions : 1. what will be the decent retirement corpus. my investment horizon is long term, around 22 years. looking to accumulate around 6-7 crores. is it possible.? 2. My MFs are underperforming, do I need to change any allocation. ?
Ans: With a long-term investment horizon of 22 years, accumulating Rs 6–7 crores is achievable. It requires disciplined savings and strategic asset allocation.

Assessing Current Investments
You contribute regularly to PPF, VPF, and MFs, which is commendable.
Your existing corpus of Rs 25.23 lakhs (PPF, PF, FD, and MF) gives a strong start.
Rental income adds flexibility for investment, as it is a steady source.
Required Corpus and Growth
A corpus of Rs 6–7 crores in 22 years is realistic with consistent investing.
Equity investments can provide high growth for your long-term goals.
Fixed-income instruments (PPF, PF, FD) ensure stability but may need rebalancing.
Suggested Allocation for Corpus Growth
Allocate higher portions to equity for compounding and inflation-beating growth.
Continue PPF and VPF contributions for stability and tax benefits.
Increase equity MF investments gradually to balance the portfolio.
Improving Your Mutual Fund Portfolio
Your MF portfolio needs evaluation to align with your goals and risk tolerance.

Issues with Current Portfolio
Two index funds and a Bharat 22 FOF reduce your growth potential.
Index funds offer average returns, which underperform actively managed funds.
Actively managed funds can provide better returns with professional management.
Recommendations for Portfolio Adjustment
Exit index funds and Bharat 22 FOF. Redirect these amounts to high-performing equity funds.
Keep Parag Parikh Flexi Cap for its strong track record and diversification.
Retain Quant Small Cap for long-term growth potential, but monitor volatility.
ICICI Prudential Retirement Fund is acceptable, but evaluate its performance periodically.
Benefits of Actively Managed Funds
Active funds are managed by experienced professionals who aim to outperform benchmarks.
These funds adapt to market conditions and maximise growth opportunities.
A Certified Financial Planner can help select funds aligned with your goals.
Disadvantages of Index Funds
Index funds simply mirror the market and lack flexibility in stock selection.
They underperform in volatile markets as they cannot avoid poor-performing stocks.
Actively managed funds are better suited for long-term goals like retirement.
Taxation and Investment Planning
Review taxation rules to minimise tax liabilities on your returns.
Equity MF LTCG above Rs 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%; STCG is taxed at 20%.
Debt funds are taxed as per your income slab, reducing post-tax returns.
Steps to Achieve Rs 6–7 Crore Corpus
Invest an additional Rs 15,000–20,000 monthly from your rental income in equity MFs.
Increase your SIPs annually by 10–15% to match income growth.
Maintain diversification across large-cap, flexi-cap, and small-cap funds.
Avoid over-allocation to low-growth instruments like FD and Bharat 22 FOF.
Monitoring and Reviewing Portfolio
Review your portfolio with a Certified Financial Planner every year.
Rebalance allocations based on performance and market conditions.
Exit underperforming funds and shift to better options when necessary.
Final Insights
Your goal of Rs 6–7 crores is attainable with disciplined investing and portfolio adjustments. Increase focus on equity funds for long-term growth while retaining stable instruments like PPF and VPF. Monitor your portfolio and seek professional guidance for optimal results.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |550 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Mar 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 02, 2025Hindi
Listen
Relationship
Hello sir/ma'am...i am a girl of 21 yrs and my bf 24yrs.We met each other through an online friendly chat app.Since 1yr,we r chatting,video and voice calls.He told me,he loves me and wanna marry me.I too liked him and I took the matter to my parents and they agreed for our marriage also.I made him talk to my parents.He didn't still let this matter know to his parents.Recently,without my permission..my cousin sis took his insta id and chatted with him like an unknown girl for fun.She created an account in insta and sent a request to him n he accepted that request and continued chatting with her.She told him like she saw his profile and interested and so given a request.He was asking her for voice call,video call,but she didn't accept.She sent some other picture when he insisted her pic and later he asked her "do u like me" for which she funnily replied love at first sight and love you.He told her he want to express his love to her in voice call and later he too proposed..she showed all those screen shots to me. I am broken.I questioned him what is all this?...for which he replied...he just chatted to find out whether that account was a fake account or real account...but,the screen shots were showing something different..when my cousin called him bro..he was very upset and scolded her too. Now,he saying he thought it's a fake boy id and wanted to make fun of and even fought with me saying i don't trust him and without his acceptance..i gave his id to my cousin..but,i havent given.. He is saying he wanted to test whether it is a fake or a real account and so he made fun off and didn't mean it and that too just chatting it is n not to take it seriously and he loves me much.. I am confused after this whether to proceed for marriage..he isthe first guy and love in my life...should i believe him or let him go or should i give him one more chance?..please give u r advice..thank you
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I am so sorry that you are in this situation. While I can't make a decision for you, I can help you by pointing out how this looks like from an outsider's perspective- your BF's interactions with this profile do not really support his claim of "just testing if it's a fake account." It seems like he was interested in chatting and continuing the flirty conversations. This does not mean he is in love with the person behind that online profile, but it surely looks like he can go behind your back for some thrill.

Trust and honesty are two very important things in a relationship, and if you are planning on getting married, this is not a good start. Moreover, his getting angry at you upon confrontation is a red flag- he tried to gaslight you.
It's your choice whether you want to leave or give him another chance but before you make a decision in haste, ask yourself-
1) If he loves you, would he flirt with someone or even chat with a stranger for entertainment?
2) Would you do the same to him?
3) Is he taking responsibility and asking for forgiveness?
4) Can you trust him completely after this or would you always keep wondering if he is cheating on you?
Once you answer these honestly, I think you will know what's the right thing to do.

Hope this helps.

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8111 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Mar 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Mar 17, 2025Hindi
Money
I am 39 years old and my wife is 38 working and my son is 7 years. I earn 35LPA my wife 15LPA. I started with zero as from a young age I took care of my parents by paying tuition and funded by my education. I completed engineering and started paying off my education loan from my first day of work. 2015 I got married and in 2016 we bought our first house. I moved my parents there and I take care of them they are financially dependent on me and I have a 4L health insurance for them. The first house is now worth 55L and I have paid off this loan. We built our 2nd house its worth around 1.2 crore and I have a loan of 70 lakhs left. I have a plot worth 30L which I have bought. I have 40L in MF and stocks, I do SIP of 1Lakh per month ( XIRR was good at 20% but now it's at 13%). I have 20L in gold and 10L in EPF. I have a 1cr term insurance and I do Jeevan umang of 4L per year started last year and Jeevan tarun for my son for 1.5L per year started 2 years ago and I have 40k of Jeevan anand started in 2011 for 25 years. My fear : My parents were dependent on me, and I had nothing to fall back on when I started my career. I do not want to be the same for my son. I want to be financially self-reliant when he starts his career and his life. I want to ensure that he doesn't worry about us when he starts his work life or if he wants to start a business, he has the freedom to do so. I have 15 years left in my career. I want to make sure my wife is also secured if I am not around. My questions is what can I do more to ensure we are financially well off?
Ans: You earn Rs. 35 LPA, and your wife earns Rs. 15 LPA.

You support your parents financially and have Rs. 4L health insurance for them.

Your first house is worth Rs. 55L and is fully paid off.

Your second house is worth Rs. 1.2 crore with a Rs. 70L loan.

You own a plot worth Rs. 30L.

Your investments include Rs. 40L in mutual funds and stocks.

You invest Rs. 1L per month in SIPs.

You have Rs. 20L in gold and Rs. 10L in EPF.

Your term insurance is Rs. 1 crore.

You have investment-linked insurance policies.

Your goal is financial independence for yourself and your family. You want to ensure your son does not have financial burdens when he starts his career.

Strengths in Your Financial Planning
You have built wealth despite challenges.

Your high savings rate helps in wealth accumulation.

Your SIPs give long-term compounding benefits.

Your first home is debt-free, providing stability.

Your gold holdings offer liquidity in emergencies.

Your EPF provides retirement security.

Your term insurance gives financial protection.

Areas That Need Improvement
Your insurance-linked policies are not wealth creators.

Your home loan is a major liability.

Your gold holdings may not generate high returns.

Your current insurance cover may not be enough.

Your parents’ health cover might be inadequate.

Your son’s education and future needs require better planning.

Steps to Strengthen Financial Security
Increase Term Insurance Cover
A Rs. 1 crore cover is low given your income and liabilities.

You should have a cover of at least 15 times your annual income.

Increase your term insurance to Rs. 2.5 crore for full protection.

Ensure your wife has her own term cover as well.

Reassess Your Insurance-Linked Investments
Traditional insurance policies offer low returns.

They do not provide inflation-beating growth.

Surrendering them and shifting to mutual funds is a better option.

This will give higher returns and better flexibility.

Pay Off Your Home Loan Strategically
Your home loan balance of Rs. 70L is a major liability.

Focus on repaying it within the next 5-7 years.

Increasing EMI payments or making part prepayments can help.

Avoid extending the tenure to reduce interest burden.

Optimise Your Mutual Fund Investments
Your SIP of Rs. 1L per month is a strong wealth-building tool.

XIRR of 13% is still a good return for long-term investing.

Ensure your portfolio has a mix of large-cap, flexi-cap, and small-cap funds.

Actively managed funds will help in capturing market opportunities.

Avoid index funds as they limit potential gains.

Strengthen Your Parents’ Health Insurance
Rs. 4L health cover for them may not be enough.

Increase their health insurance to Rs. 10L with a super top-up plan.

This will prevent financial stress in case of medical emergencies.

Plan for Your Son’s Education and Future
Higher education costs are rising rapidly.

Start a dedicated mutual fund portfolio for his education.

Avoid insurance-linked child plans as they offer poor returns.

SIPs in equity funds can provide high returns over 10-15 years.

Ensure flexibility in investments to support his career or business plans.

Secure Your Wife’s Financial Future
Your wife should have her own investments independent of you.

Ensure she has adequate insurance and retirement savings.

Consider joint ownership of assets for financial security.

Encourage her to invest in equity mutual funds for wealth creation.

Retirement Planning and Wealth Creation
You have 15 years left in your career.

Focus on accumulating at least Rs. 10-12 crore for retirement.

This will ensure financial independence and a secure future.

Continue SIPs and increase them whenever income grows.

Diversify into debt funds for stability in later years.

Systematic withdrawal plans (SWP) will help manage post-retirement cash flow.

Finally
Increase your term insurance for full protection.

Reallocate funds from low-return insurance policies to mutual funds.

Focus on clearing your home loan early.

Strengthen health insurance for your parents.

Create a dedicated fund for your son’s education.

Ensure your wife has financial security even in your absence.

Keep investing for long-term wealth creation and retirement security.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8111 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Mar 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Mar 17, 2025Hindi
Listen
Money
Hello Sir - I have taken a HDFC Unit Linked pension plan in 2008 and the fund value is approx. 49 lakhs. The policy matures in 2030 and allows for commutation of 1/3rd of fund value (with mandatory annuity for balance 67%). My HDFC Life Relationship manager is suggesting that he will transfer the proceeds of this fund to a new HDFC Smart life pension plan (via surrender of old policy and immediate reinvestment as single premium in the new policy) for a term of 5 years. At the vesting date, I will be allowed to remove 60% of the fund value as tax free commuted pension and will need to take annuity only for remaining 40% of fund value. This is beneficial for me (since tax free commutation will be 60% instead of current 33%). In such a case, will the surrender of old policy and immediate reinvestment into new smart pension plan be a taxable transaction in India? I have claimed 80CCC benefits for part of premiums paid in the past. HDFC has informed me that the surrender value will not be taxable as no amount is received by me and the full amount is reinvested into the new policy (HDFC will also not do TDS). Is this correct? Thanks for your advice.
Ans: You have invested in a unit-linked pension plan since 2008.

The current fund value is Rs. 49 lakhs.

The plan matures in 2030.

As per the policy, you can withdraw 33% tax-free and the rest must be used for annuity.

Your relationship manager is suggesting surrender and reinvestment into a new pension plan.

The new plan allows 60% tax-free withdrawal instead of 33%.

You need to evaluate whether this switch is beneficial from a taxation and financial perspective.

Taxation on Surrender of Old Pension Plan
Pension plans under section 80CCC get tax benefits during investment.

If you surrender, the surrender value is taxable as per your income slab.

HDFC claims that no tax will apply as the amount is reinvested directly.

However, as per income tax laws, surrendering a pension plan leads to taxation.

Even if reinvested, the surrender value is added to taxable income.

Since you have claimed 80CCC benefits, surrendering can result in tax liability.

Misconception About Tax-Free Transfer
HDFC is not deducting TDS, but that does not mean no tax is due.

Income tax liability exists even if the amount is not received in hand.

If tax authorities later verify, you may face penalties or additional taxes.

You need written confirmation from HDFC and a tax expert’s opinion.

Evaluating the New Pension Plan Offer
The new plan allows 60% withdrawal instead of 33%.

The remaining 40% must still go into annuity.

Annuity income is fully taxable every year.

The new plan has additional charges, which can reduce returns.

The lock-in period of 5 years restricts flexibility.

If your goal is wealth creation, better options exist.

Should You Switch to the New Plan?
The tax-free withdrawal of 60% seems attractive, but consider the surrender tax.

If you are in the highest tax bracket, surrendering can be costly.

Locking funds in another pension plan reduces flexibility.

Instead, investing in mutual funds can give higher returns and better control.

You can withdraw systematically without annuity restrictions.

Reinvesting in a pension plan limits future financial choices.

Better Alternatives for Retirement Planning
Instead of shifting to another pension plan, consider equity mutual funds.

Mutual funds allow withdrawals with lower tax impact than annuities.

Debt mutual funds provide stability while maintaining flexibility.

Systematic withdrawal plans (SWP) help manage retirement income efficiently.

Combining equity and debt investments gives better post-retirement security.

What Should Be Your Next Steps?
Consult a tax expert before surrendering your pension plan.

Get written confirmation from HDFC on taxation treatment.

Compare annuity income vs. mutual fund withdrawals for retirement.

Ensure flexibility in withdrawals rather than locking into another pension plan.

Build a diversified portfolio that balances risk and liquidity.

Finally
Surrendering your pension plan may trigger tax liability.

Reinvesting in another pension plan may not be the best financial decision.

You need flexibility and better returns for retirement.

Mutual funds offer tax-efficient and high-growth alternatives.

Evaluate all options before making a final decision.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8111 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Mar 19, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Mar 17, 2025Hindi
Listen
Money
I am investing 1.5lack in sbi smart wealth plan for 7 years. My policy term 12 years. Is it a good plan for good return,2 years completed,fund value 2.7lack,Should this policy be continued? kindly guide me
Ans: You are investing Rs. 1.5 lakh per year in an insurance-cum-investment policy.

The policy duration is 12 years, with a premium payment term of 7 years.

You have completed 2 years, and the fund value is Rs. 2.7 lakh.

You want to know if you should continue this policy.

Insurance-cum-investment plans are not the best for wealth creation. You need to evaluate whether this plan aligns with your financial goals.

Issues with Insurance-Cum-Investment Plans
High Charges: These plans have high fees in the initial years. This reduces actual investment returns.

Low Returns: The returns are usually 4%-6%, lower than equity mutual funds.

Lock-in Period: You are required to stay invested for a long term, with limited flexibility.

Poor Liquidity: Withdrawing funds before maturity may result in high penalties.

Mixing Insurance and Investment: Insurance should provide protection, and investment should focus on growth. A combined product does not serve either goal efficiently.

Performance of Your Policy So Far
You have invested Rs. 3 lakh so far (Rs. 1.5 lakh per year for 2 years).

Your current fund value is Rs. 2.7 lakh, which means a loss of Rs. 30,000.

This is due to high charges deducted in the early years.

Even if the fund performs better in future, the charges will continue to impact returns.

You must decide whether to stay invested or move to better alternatives.

Should You Continue or Exit?
If wealth creation is your goal, this plan is not the best option.

If you need insurance, a pure term insurance plan is more cost-effective.

You can surrender the policy and reinvest the amount in mutual funds for better growth.

The surrender charges may reduce your corpus, but over the long term, mutual funds will give better returns.

Alternative Investment Options
Equity Mutual Funds: These provide better long-term growth than insurance plans.

Balanced Advantage Funds: These funds manage risk while giving decent returns.

Debt Mutual Funds: Suitable if you need stable returns with lower risk.

PPF or EPF: If you want a safe and tax-free investment option.

Reallocating your money into these instruments will give better returns and flexibility.

Tax Considerations on Surrendering
Surrendering before 5 years will add the maturity amount to your taxable income.

If you exit after 5 years, the amount will be tax-free.

The earlier you surrender, the higher the impact, but staying invested will continue to reduce your returns.

Consult a tax expert if required, but in most cases, switching to a better investment is more beneficial.

What Should Be Your Next Steps?
If your goal is wealth creation, surrender the policy and reinvest in mutual funds.

Buy a separate term insurance plan for financial protection.

Avoid future investments in such insurance-linked plans.

Build a diversified portfolio for long-term financial security.

Keep reviewing your portfolio annually to ensure you are on track.

Finally
Insurance-cum-investment plans do not generate high returns.

Your policy is already showing negative growth due to high charges.

Consider surrendering and shifting to a better investment strategy.

Always keep insurance and investment separate for better financial growth.

Make future investments in mutual funds and other flexible options.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x