LIC Jeevan Anand: Poor Performance - Surrender or Loan?

After a long time, we realised the poor performance of LIC Jeevan Anand ???? If we surrender we end up with loss, if we continue it will be at poor performance, So, will it be a good Idea ???? to take a loan by pledging the policy and invest the proceeds for better return, so that we can save loss and continue the policy as well as paid up policy. The interest cost will be 9.5% to 10% pa with no EMI commitment and flexible repayment with minimum of ?.50 and even if we don't pay it will be adjusted against maturity . Please post a light on this to go with.

Ans: Your intention to optimise returns while preserving your LIC policy is thoughtful. Let’s analyse your proposed approach comprehensively.

Challenges with Continuing the Policy
Low Returns: LIC Jeevan Anand traditionally delivers returns between 4%-6%. This does not match inflation-adjusted returns needed for long-term growth.

Opportunity Cost: Continuing the policy locks capital in a low-performing investment, missing higher returns elsewhere.

Surrendering the Policy
Immediate Loss: Surrendering early often results in a financial loss due to penalties and lower surrender value.

Lost Insurance Cover: Surrendering ends your life insurance, which might impact your family's financial safety.

Loan Against the Policy
Taking a loan against the policy can be a balanced approach. Let’s break it down:

Advantages of Policy Loan
Preserves Policy Benefits: The policy remains active, and you avoid surrendering it.

Low-Interest Rate: Policy loans have lower rates (around 9.5%-10%) compared to personal loans or unsecured loans.

Flexible Repayment: You can repay on your terms. If unpaid, it adjusts against the maturity or surrender value.

Access to Capital: You can reinvest the loan amount in higher-return investments, offsetting the policy’s poor performance.

Challenges with Policy Loan
Interest Burden: The interest rate of 9.5%-10% is higher than some secured investment returns, especially if the market underperforms.

Risk of Non-Repayment: Unpaid loans reduce the maturity or surrender value. This might impact the total financial benefit.

Investment Discipline Needed: Returns depend on reinvesting prudently. Poor decisions or market volatility can lead to losses.

Investment Options for Loan Amount
If you proceed with this plan, careful reinvestment is essential.

Equity Mutual Funds for Growth
Allocate a majority to actively managed equity mutual funds. These outperform inflation and generate higher long-term returns.

Avoid index funds. Actively managed funds provide better protection during market downturns.

Balanced Portfolio
Allocate 70%-80% to equity mutual funds (large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap).

Invest 20%-30% in debt mutual funds or hybrid funds for stability.

Focus on Your Goals
Align investments with specific financial goals like retirement, children’s education, or wealth creation.
Steps for Implementation
Assess the Loan Amount Needed: Borrow only what you plan to invest. Avoid over-leveraging.

Consult a Certified Financial Planner: They will guide investment choices based on your risk tolerance and goals.

Track Performance: Regularly review the performance of your investments and adjust when needed.

Plan Loan Repayment: Even if repayment is flexible, try to clear the loan systematically to reduce the interest burden.

Final Insights
Your idea of leveraging a loan against LIC Jeevan Anand is a middle ground. It allows you to continue the policy while investing for better returns. However, it requires financial discipline, monitoring, and strategic reinvestment.

Consult with a Certified Financial Planner to design a customised plan aligned with your long-term financial goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

Ans: Sir, from the details shared, it's clear that you have a well-thought-out approach for managing your LIC policies and potential loans. You have multiple traditional LIC policies maturing over the next five years, each with a sum assured of Rs 1 lakh, along with bonuses and loyalty additions. You plan to pledge these policies for a loan of Rs 5 lakhs, which will be repaid with the maturity benefits over five years.

As a disciplined bachelor with no financial or family commitments, your intention is not to create a legacy but to use this capital for your future income needs through SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan). This reflects careful planning, and I appreciate your disciplined approach towards managing your finances at this stage of life.

Let’s break this plan down step by step and provide insights on its feasibility and alternative options.

Key Considerations for Taking a Loan on LIC Policies
Loan Interest Rate: You are planning to take a loan at 10% per annum with no EMI commitment and interest payable half-yearly. This means that your interest will keep accumulating, and you'll need to ensure the maturity benefits are enough to cover the outstanding loan and interest.

Interest Payment: The key here is that interest needs to be paid regularly. Not paying interest would result in compounding, which could lead to a higher loan burden over time. Even though you plan to pay off the loan using the maturity proceeds, it's important to evaluate if the total maturity value will be enough to repay the full loan amount and accumulated interest.

Reduced Death Benefit: As you rightly noted, in case of any unforeseen events, the death benefit for your nominee would reduce because of the outstanding loan. Since you do not have family commitments, this might not be a major concern, but it's still something to keep in mind.

Avoiding Locking Capital: By availing the loan now, you are trying to avoid locking your capital for five years and aiming to earn higher returns in mutual funds during this period. This strategy could potentially yield better returns than the interest cost, provided you invest in suitable equity funds with a higher growth potential.

Let’s now move on to the part about using this Rs 5 lakh effectively over the next five years.

Investment in Aggressive Equity Mutual Funds
Since you are not looking for immediate liquidity and are comfortable with market risks, equity mutual funds are a good option for long-term growth. The key to growing your capital aggressively is selecting funds that have a proven track record in terms of consistent performance and strong fund management.

Here’s how investing in aggressive equity mutual funds can benefit you:

Potential for Higher Returns: Over a five-year period, equity mutual funds tend to outperform other investment avenues. Funds that focus on small caps, mid caps, and sectors with high growth potential can give better returns compared to traditional investments like FDs or bonds.

Diversification: Aggressive equity funds typically invest in high-growth companies across various sectors, offering you the potential for better returns while spreading your risk.

Power of Compounding: By investing this Rs 5 lakh in equity mutual funds, you can benefit from the power of compounding, especially if you stay invested for the full five years without withdrawing. The longer you remain invested, the better your chances of achieving your target returns.

Market Volatility: While aggressive equity funds can offer high returns, they are also subject to market fluctuations. This is why it is important to choose funds that have performed well even in volatile market conditions. You should be prepared for some short-term volatility and focus on the long-term growth potential.

Now, let's evaluate whether taking this loan and investing it in aggressive equity funds is a prudent decision.

Loan vs. Investment Returns: A Practical Assessment
Interest vs. Potential Returns: The key factor here is whether the returns from your investment in aggressive equity funds will outpace the interest you are paying on the loan. While the loan is at 10%, equity mutual funds have historically provided returns in the range of 12-15% or even higher over the long term.

Risk Management: While equity mutual funds have the potential to offer higher returns, there is always the risk of capital loss due to market volatility. You must be comfortable with this risk, especially since you are planning to use these funds for a SWP after five years.

Time Horizon: Your time horizon of five years is relatively short for aggressive equity funds, but it’s still long enough to potentially see good returns, provided you stay invested and the market performs well. If you were planning for a longer horizon, such as 7-10 years, the risk would decrease further.

SWP Setup After Five Years: Your plan to set up a SWP after five years is a smart way to create a regular income stream. By the sixth year, you can start withdrawing from the accumulated capital, using it to support your monthly expenses.

Potential Risks and How to Mitigate Them
Market Fluctuations: Equity investments can be volatile in the short to medium term. If the markets face a downturn at the time of withdrawal, it could affect your SWP income. To mitigate this, you could gradually move a portion of your equity investments into safer instruments (like debt funds) as you approach the fifth year.

Interest Payment Discipline: Even though there is no EMI commitment, the loan’s interest needs to be paid regularly. Skipping these payments can cause the loan to balloon due to compounded interest. Ensure you have a mechanism to pay this interest either from your savings or from other sources.

Liquidity Needs: Since you are investing for five years, ensure you don’t need to access this money before then. Equity investments should not be liquidated prematurely, especially during a market correction.

Alternatives to Taking a Loan
Before finalising this decision, consider alternatives to taking a loan. Since you don’t require this Rs 5 lakhs for immediate use, you might want to avoid paying interest altogether by simply waiting for the policies to mature over the next five years.

Direct Investment from Savings: Instead of taking a loan and paying interest, you could consider investing smaller amounts from your savings into aggressive mutual funds over the next five years. This would reduce the burden of paying interest while still allowing you to benefit from market growth.

Partial Investment: Another option is to take a smaller loan amount (perhaps Rs 2-3 lakhs) and invest it in equity mutual funds. This way, you reduce your interest payment while still benefiting from potential capital appreciation.

Ideal Equity Mutual Fund Selection Criteria
When selecting equity mutual funds, focus on funds that meet the following criteria:

Consistent Track Record: Look for funds that have consistently performed well over the last 5-7 years, even during market downturns.

Experienced Fund Managers: Funds managed by seasoned professionals tend to navigate market volatility better, giving you a sense of security.

Sectoral Allocation: Check whether the fund invests in high-growth sectors such as technology, healthcare, and consumer goods, which are likely to perform well over the next few years.

Expense Ratio: Choose funds with a reasonable expense ratio. High expense ratios can eat into your returns over time.

Final Insights
In conclusion, taking a loan on your LIC policies and investing it in aggressive equity mutual funds could be a good strategy for capital appreciation over the next five years. However, it comes with its risks, especially the interest burden and market volatility.

By investing in carefully selected equity mutual funds, you can potentially earn higher returns that outpace the loan interest. However, ensure that you are comfortable with the market risks and the discipline of interest payments.

If you prefer to avoid the interest cost altogether, consider alternative strategies such as investing smaller amounts regularly from your savings. This could give you peace of mind while still allowing you to benefit from market growth.

In either case, equity mutual funds can be a powerful tool for growing your wealth, provided you invest with a long-term view and in line with your risk tolerance.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/holistic_investment_planners/

Ans: Understanding Your Current Situation

You are a central government pensioner aged 64 years.

Your monthly pension is Rs 80,000.

You have a car loan of Rs 5.26 lakhs outstanding.

You also have a personal loan of Rs 3.05 lakhs outstanding.

Together, your loan outstanding is Rs 8.31 lakhs as of May 2025.

Your car loan EMI is Rs 17,900, which will end in May 2028.

Your personal loan EMI is Rs 7,748, which will end in July 2029.

Your current monthly EMI total is Rs 25,648.

You want to take a new personal loan of Rs 9.21 lakhs for 6 years.

The interest rate for this new loan is 11.65%.

With this new loan, your EMI will be Rs 17,839.

This will reduce your monthly EMI outgo by Rs 7,809.

You plan to use the extra money saved for urgent needs of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.5 lakh.

Your spouse is a homemaker and you have children in higher studies.

Your personal savings are not encouraging.

Your main source of income is your pension.

Let us assess if this new loan will be beneficial for you.

Assessing Your Current Loan Burden

Your existing loans have EMIs totalling Rs 25,648.

This EMI is a significant portion of your pension income.

Paying Rs 25,648 from Rs 80,000 leaves you with Rs 54,352 for living.

Your personal expenses, family needs, and children's education costs must be managed with this.

You mentioned urgent need for Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.5 lakh.

Taking a new loan might help you handle this immediate requirement.

But it is important to check if this new loan reduces your stress in the long run.

Evaluating the Proposed Loan Swap

You plan to take Rs 9.21 lakhs as a new personal loan.

The EMI for this loan is Rs 17,839 for 6 years.

Compared to your current EMI of Rs 25,648, you will save Rs 7,809 monthly.

The new loan will consolidate your existing two loans into one loan.

This will help you manage your EMIs better.

Your cash flow will improve with the monthly savings.

The Rs 7,809 monthly saving can be used for your immediate family needs.

This will also help you in meeting urgent expenses.

Analysing the Interest Costs

While this new loan helps monthly cash flow, total interest paid may increase.

You will be extending your loan tenure to 6 years.

Over 6 years, you may pay more interest compared to the original loans.

The longer tenure increases total cost.

But because your monthly EMI burden is lower, you might find it more comfortable.

You should consider if paying more interest is acceptable to you for immediate relief.

Balancing short-term comfort with long-term interest cost is key.

Alternatives to a New Loan

Let us also explore if there are other ways to reduce your loan stress.

Check if you have any savings in fixed deposits or recurring deposits.

If you have old insurance policies, you can check if loans can be taken on them.

If you have PPF or other small savings, partial withdrawal might help.

This can help you avoid taking a new loan.

It may reduce your total interest cost in the long run.

However, avoid breaking long-term retirement savings like PPF fully.

Reviewing Family Support and Additional Income Sources

Discuss with family members if they can support you temporarily.

Children or relatives may be able to offer a temporary loan.

This might be cheaper than a bank personal loan.

Explore if there are small part-time jobs you can do to boost income.

Even small extra income can reduce reliance on loans.

Emergency Fund Planning

You mentioned personal savings are not encouraging.

It is very important to create an emergency fund.

Emergency fund can help avoid new loans in future.

Even Rs 1 lakh set aside will help meet sudden needs.

Try to save at least 10% of your pension in a monthly plan.

Start small, but be consistent to build up this safety net.

Considerations on Current Expenses

Review your current monthly expenses carefully.

Identify any unnecessary spending you can cut down.

Even Rs 1,000-2,000 cut in expenses will add up over time.

The money saved can go into a monthly emergency fund.

This is very important as you are already retired.

Debt Consolidation Loan Impact

Taking the Rs 9.21 lakh loan is one way to reduce EMI stress.

It gives you monthly relief of Rs 7,809.

It also meets your urgent need of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.5 lakh.

But remember the total interest cost will be more over 6 years.

This is a trade-off between monthly comfort and total interest.

Role of a Certified Financial Planner

Working with a Certified Financial Planner can help you review your full financial picture.

A Certified Financial Planner can help you plan your cash flow.

They can help you create an emergency fund step by step.

They can also assess if the new loan is really best for you.

They will work with you to reduce your total debt burden over time.

They will suggest strategies to pay off debt faster.

Certified Financial Planners offer unbiased, expert advice for your goals.

360 Degree Financial Planning Approach

Let us take a 360 degree view of your situation:

You are retired with a steady pension.

You have two loans already.

You need Rs 1 to Rs 1.5 lakh urgently.

Your monthly EMI is very high compared to your pension.

You are considering a new personal loan to reduce EMI stress.

You also have family obligations and children’s education to consider.

Your spouse is not earning, so you are the sole breadwinner.

Emergency fund is not strong.

New loan will give relief now, but at higher total cost later.

If you have any insurance-cum-investment policies, check if surrender is wise.

Sometimes, surrendering and moving to better plans can give higher returns.

Avoid real estate investments at this stage.

They are not liquid and may create more burden.

Loan Repayment Discipline

Once you take the new loan, keep your EMIs regular.

Never miss payments to avoid penalties and credit score damage.

If you get any extra income, use it to part prepay the new loan.

Prepaying loan early will reduce total interest paid.

Even small part prepayments help in reducing your burden.

Insights on Emotional Stress and Financial Health

Carrying loan burden can create emotional stress.

Reducing EMI outgo helps you sleep better at night.

It gives peace of mind and freedom to meet daily expenses.

But remember to plan so that this does not become a long-term cycle.

Taking new loans repeatedly to repay old ones can become a habit.

Work to break this cycle with budgeting and planned saving.

How to Build Future Financial Security

Pension income is steady. Build a small saving plan from it.

Use monthly savings to build an emergency fund of Rs 1 lakh first.

Once emergency fund is built, focus on paying loan faster.

After loans are cleared, direct that EMI amount to monthly investment.

Mutual funds through a Certified Financial Planner can help grow savings.

Avoid direct investing or risky options that you may not understand well.

Certified Financial Planners give regular reviews to adjust for your needs.

Final Insights

Your idea to take a new personal loan to close old loans is understandable.

It will give you monthly relief of Rs 7,809.

It also helps you manage urgent needs of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 1.5 lakh.

But it increases total interest paid over 6 years.

Think if the relief in EMI is worth the higher total interest.

Explore help from family, partial withdrawals, or other support first.

Avoid real estate or risky investments now.

Work to build a small emergency fund over time.

Start a disciplined repayment plan and monthly savings plan.

Talk to a Certified Financial Planner to get a clear 360 degree plan.

This will give you comfort now and security for the future.

Your financial well-being is very important, so take it step by step.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment