Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

SWP for a 20 Lakh Investment: Seeking Guidance from a 48-Year-Old Reader

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9854 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Apr 17, 2025

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
Girish Question by Girish on Apr 16, 2025Hindi
Money

How the SWP works? Is it safe to invest in SWP for 20 lakhs, please help me to understand and what are risk involved.

Ans: Wanting regular income from investments is a practical and necessary goal. A Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) is one powerful option. It helps you withdraw money monthly from your mutual fund investments. But before you commit Rs. 20 lakhs to SWP, let’s study it from every angle.

Let us understand how SWP works, its safety, usefulness, and risks—clearly and completely.

 

 

What is SWP in Simple Words?

SWP is a feature in mutual funds.

 

It allows you to withdraw a fixed amount every month.

 

The money comes from your own investment in the fund.

 

The remaining amount stays invested in the fund.

 

That balance keeps growing with market performance.

 

It is the opposite of SIP. SIP adds money. SWP gives money back to you.

 

 

How Does It Work in Practice?

Suppose you invest Rs. 20 lakhs in a mutual fund.

 

You set up a SWP of Rs. 25,000 per month.

 

Every month, Rs. 25,000 is credited to your bank account.

 

This continues until you stop or your investment runs out.

 

The remaining capital continues to earn market returns.

 

If the fund performs well, your capital may grow despite withdrawals.

 

If the fund performs poorly, your capital may reduce faster.

 

 

Where Should You Invest for SWP?

Choose equity-oriented hybrid or balanced mutual funds.

 

These funds aim for stable and moderate growth.

 

Avoid high-risk funds like small-cap for SWP needs.

 

Avoid pure debt funds too. They may not beat inflation.

 

Select actively managed funds only.

 

Index funds are not suitable here.

 

Index funds have no human control. They just copy markets.

 

In falling markets, they provide no cushion.

 

Actively managed funds adjust risk and protect capital better.

 

A Certified Financial Planner can help choose suitable funds.

 

 

Is SWP Safe for Rs. 20 Lakhs?

SWP is not a separate product. It is a feature.

 

The safety depends on where your money is invested.

 

The fund's performance decides the return and capital safety.

 

If you choose well-managed funds, SWP becomes more reliable.

 

If you withdraw too much too soon, it becomes risky.

 

So, withdrawal amount must match the fund’s return capacity.

 

A Certified Financial Planner will help you set the right withdrawal rate.

 

 

What Are the Benefits of SWP?

You get regular income every month.

 

This is useful for retired people or families needing cash flow.

 

It is more tax-efficient than FD interest.

 

In equity funds, after one year, gains up to Rs. 1.25 lakh are tax-free.

 

Gains above Rs. 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5% only.

 

In FDs, the full interest is taxed as per your slab.

 

SWP gives better control over taxation.

 

You also decide how much and when to withdraw.

 

It does not lock your capital like annuities.

 

You can stop or change the amount anytime.

 

Your remaining capital still grows.

 

 

What Are the Risks Involved in SWP?

The biggest risk is market performance.

 

If the fund performs poorly for long, capital may reduce faster.

 

Withdrawing more than the return rate leads to capital erosion.

 

In early years, if there is a market crash, returns can fall.

 

This is called sequence of return risk.

 

If you panic and stop the SWP, you may lose long-term gains.

 

Therefore, fund selection and amount choice must be done carefully.

 

Do not withdraw too much from equity funds.

 

Stick to 5% to 7% withdrawal of the corpus per year.

 

Rebalance the portfolio annually with the help of a Certified Financial Planner.

 

 

How is Tax Calculated on SWP Withdrawals?

Tax is only on the gain portion, not the full withdrawal.

 

For equity funds, if held more than one year:

 

    • Gains up to Rs. 1.25 lakh in a year are tax-free.

    • Gains above that are taxed at 12.5%.

 

For withdrawals within 1 year, 20% tax on short-term gains.

 

For debt funds, entire gain is taxed as per your income slab.

 

Tax is deducted only on capital gain, not total SWP amount.

 

This makes SWP more tax-friendly than FD interest.

 

 

How Does SWP Compare With FD Interest?

FD interest is fixed but fully taxable.

 

SWP offers flexibility, better post-tax returns, and capital appreciation.

 

FD interest stays flat. SWP can grow if fund performs well.

 

FD locks your capital. SWP keeps your capital liquid.

 

FD maturity must be renewed. SWP can continue for years.

 

FD income stops when capital ends. SWP may continue even longer.

 

In inflation terms, FD income loses value. SWP may protect against inflation.

 

 

Should You Invest Rs. 20 Lakhs in SWP?

Yes, if you want steady monthly income.

 

Yes, if you don’t need the whole amount immediately.

 

Yes, if you invest in the right mutual fund category.

 

No, if you expect guaranteed income like FD.

 

No, if you cannot handle short-term fund fluctuations.

 

No, if you plan to withdraw high amounts monthly.

 

 

Tips to Make Your SWP Investment Strong

Choose hybrid equity funds, not pure equity or debt funds.

 

Use regular plans through a Certified Financial Planner.

 

Direct plans lack personalised advice and regular review.

 

MFDs with CFP credentials track markets and help in changes.

 

Avoid index funds. They don’t protect during market falls.

 

Active funds give better control and management.

 

Start small SWP first. Increase later if fund performs well.

 

Monitor performance every year with your planner.

 

Avoid withdrawing during deep market crashes.

 

Let the capital stay longer to recover and grow.

 

Rebalance every year. Shift gains to safe funds when needed.

 

 

Can SWP Be a Retirement Plan?

Yes, many retired investors use SWP.

 

It is a flexible, tax-efficient income source.

 

SWP protects principal if managed properly.

 

It also adjusts to your changing cash needs.

 

Unlike pension plans, you keep full control.

 

You can stop or increase SWP anytime.

 

You can leave the remaining amount for your family.

 

 

What Happens to Remaining Amount After SWP?

The remaining money stays in the mutual fund.

 

It continues to earn returns from the market.

 

You or your nominee can redeem the balance any time.

 

It is not locked. It stays liquid.

 

Capital not used becomes part of your legacy.

 

You can also use it to increase monthly SWP later.

 

Or withdraw lump sum for emergencies.

 

 

Finally

SWP is a very smart tool. It gives you peace, flexibility and tax benefits. But it needs careful planning. It is not risk-free. But with right fund, right amount and right advice, the risks reduce.

Use actively managed mutual funds. Avoid index funds. Avoid direct plans. Work with a Certified Financial Planner. They will guide, monitor and adjust when needed.

SWP is not just about monthly income. It is about freedom, control and dignity in retirement. Rs. 20 lakhs can give strong support for your goals.

Choose wisely. Plan clearly. Review regularly.

 

Best Regards,
 
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
 
Chief Financial Planner,
 
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9854 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Sep 19, 2024

Money
Mr Vivek Lala, Good Morning. Can you please tell me , 1) where all the places we can invest in SWPs. 2) Is there any age limit for SWP. 3) Is there SWP facility in NPS also?.4) Any upper ceiling limit to invest in SWP?. Thank you.
Ans: A Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) is a facility offered by many mutual funds. It allows investors to withdraw a fixed sum from their investments at regular intervals. Let’s dive into each part of your query to provide detailed insights.

1. Investment Options for SWPs

SWPs are primarily associated with mutual funds. Here are the various options where you can invest through SWPs:

Debt Mutual Funds: These are one of the most popular options for SWPs. They provide stability, with low-risk returns.

Equity Mutual Funds: SWPs can also be done in equity mutual funds. This option is riskier, but it can offer better returns in the long term.

Hybrid Mutual Funds: These funds combine equity and debt, offering balanced risk and returns. SWPs in hybrid funds can help diversify risk.

Balanced Advantage Funds: These are dynamic funds that shift between equity and debt based on market conditions. SWPs in these funds could provide more stability.

Notably, SWPs are not available in direct equity, bonds, or other such traditional investments. They are mainly associated with mutual funds. It’s a simple and flexible option for generating regular income.

2. Age Limit for SWPs

There is no age limit for investing in an SWP. Whether you are young and looking to generate additional income, or you are in retirement, anyone can opt for SWPs. You can start an SWP at any stage in your life, as long as you have a mutual fund investment.

For young investors, it can be used to fund specific needs like education, travel, or other personal expenses. For retirees, it acts as a regular source of income to meet living expenses.

3. SWP in National Pension System (NPS)

Unfortunately, there is no SWP facility available in the NPS. The NPS is structured differently from mutual funds. It is a pension scheme meant for long-term retirement savings. The withdrawals from NPS are governed by specific rules, and it doesn’t offer the flexibility that SWPs do.

NPS provides partial withdrawal options, but these are limited. Upon maturity, you can withdraw 60% of your corpus, but the remaining 40% must be used to purchase an annuity. So, NPS does not have the same withdrawal flexibility as SWPs in mutual funds.

4. Upper Ceiling Limit for SWPs

There is no upper ceiling limit for investing in SWPs. You can invest as much as you want in mutual funds and set up an SWP accordingly. Your SWP amount depends on the size of your corpus and the returns it generates.

However, it’s crucial to be cautious. Withdrawing more than the returns can eat into your capital. Therefore, it is advisable to carefully calculate how much you wish to withdraw through SWP to ensure that your capital lasts for the desired period.

Advantages of SWPs

Here are the key advantages of opting for SWPs:

Regular Income: SWPs provide a steady and regular stream of income.

Tax Efficiency: SWPs in equity and hybrid funds are more tax-efficient compared to traditional income sources like Fixed Deposits.

Customisation: SWPs allow you to customize the withdrawal amount and frequency.

Flexibility: You can start or stop an SWP anytime. You can also increase or decrease the amount as needed.

Capital Protection: SWPs allow you to withdraw just the returns, protecting your capital.

Disadvantages of SWPs

Despite the advantages, there are a few downsides to SWPs:

Capital Erosion: If your withdrawals exceed the returns, your capital could reduce over time.

Market Risks: In equity-based SWPs, market fluctuations can impact returns, especially if you’re withdrawing regularly.

Lower Returns in Debt Funds: Debt funds provide stability but generally have lower returns compared to equity funds.

Comparison: SWPs vs Direct Investments

Some investors prefer direct mutual fund investments. However, direct plans, while having lower expense ratios, lack professional advice. Certified Financial Planners (CFPs) have extensive market experience and can tailor investments according to your goals and risk appetite.

Direct funds are usually opted by those who understand markets well. However, many investors lose potential returns by making emotional or uninformed decisions. That’s where regular funds managed by an MFD with CFP credentials can provide significant benefits. The guidance of a professional can ensure that your investments stay aligned with your goals and market conditions.

Why Actively Managed Funds are Better than Index Funds

If you’re considering mutual funds for SWPs, actively managed funds are a better option compared to index funds. Here’s why:

Market-Beating Potential: Actively managed funds have the potential to outperform the market, while index funds can only mirror the market returns.

Professional Management: Actively managed funds are run by experienced fund managers who actively adjust portfolios to seize opportunities and mitigate risks.

Customisation and Flexibility: Active funds allow fund managers to customize portfolios according to changing market conditions, unlike index funds which are rigid.

While index funds offer low-cost investments, they don’t offer the flexibility and potential growth that actively managed funds do.

No Ceiling on SWP Investments

As mentioned earlier, there is no ceiling on the amount you can invest in SWPs. However, you must consider how much you are withdrawing monthly. Over-withdrawing can erode your capital.

A Certified Financial Planner can help you plan an optimal withdrawal amount. They will ensure that your corpus is not depleted quickly while generating consistent returns.

Final Insights

SWPs are an excellent way to generate regular income, especially for retirees or those looking for a steady cash flow. The flexibility and tax benefits make it an attractive option for many investors.

You should remember, though, that SWPs in equity funds carry market risks, while debt funds offer stability with lower returns. A balance between the two, or opting for hybrid funds, may offer a safer bet for long-term withdrawal plans.

Lastly, avoid direct and index funds if you prefer peace of mind and professional management. By investing through a Certified Financial Planner, you can make sure your investments are aligned with your long-term financial goals, especially if you are considering SWPs.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9854 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Oct 21, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 19, 2024Hindi
Money
Hi Sir, I am 41 years. I have 50 lakhs cash, i want to do swp this amount to get 70k monthly from march 2025. Could you please suggest me how to proceed in this case?.. Thanks
Ans: You are looking for a solution to generate Rs 70,000 monthly using a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) from Rs 50 lakhs starting in March 2025. Let's explore a few options that will balance regular income needs with potential growth, all within a safe risk framework. Since you have around 5 months until March 2025, it’s important to plan now.

Below is a comprehensive analysis that will help you achieve your goals.

Understanding Your Objective
You have Rs 50 lakhs to invest.

You need Rs 70,000 monthly starting March 2025.

You are 41 years old, which means you have a long financial horizon and can afford a mix of growth and safety.

Medium risk tolerance.

To ensure the monthly withdrawal of Rs 70,000 doesn’t deplete your capital too quickly, a balanced approach is required. Let's consider mutual fund options suited for a medium-risk profile.

Why a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP)?
SWP allows you to withdraw a fixed amount every month while the rest of your investment continues to grow.

This approach avoids keeping the entire amount in a low-interest product like an FD, where inflation will erode the real value.

With SWP, you also get tax efficiency. Your withdrawals are partially treated as capital gains and partially as a return of capital, reducing the tax burden.

Importance of Asset Allocation
Asset allocation is critical to meeting your monthly income needs without depleting your corpus. In your case, you need:

Regular income to start in March 2025.

Growth potential to ensure the capital lasts long-term.

Here’s how you can structure your allocation:

Equity-Oriented Hybrid Funds (60% allocation): These funds provide a mix of equity and debt exposure. They offer the potential for higher returns while keeping risk in check. Equity exposure ensures long-term growth, while the debt portion provides stability.

Debt-Oriented Hybrid Funds (40% allocation): These funds have a higher debt exposure but still provide some equity exposure for growth. The debt portion ensures regular returns and reduces volatility.

This mix gives you both stability and growth to meet your withdrawal goals.

How to Invest
Step 1: Invest the Lump Sum
Since you need to start the SWP in March 2025, the first thing to do is invest the Rs 50 lakhs. You can split this across equity-oriented and debt-oriented hybrid funds. The reason for hybrid funds is that they are less volatile than pure equity funds but still offer growth potential.

Split the Rs 50 lakhs as:

Rs 30 lakhs in equity-oriented hybrid funds.

Rs 20 lakhs in debt-oriented hybrid funds.

The idea is to get the best of both worlds — growth from equity and stability from debt.

Step 2: Set Up the SWP
By the time you start the SWP in March 2025, your investment will have had a few months to generate some growth. The returns from these funds should help in providing your desired monthly withdrawal without depleting the capital too fast.

You can set up an SWP for Rs 70,000 per month. It’s important to keep an eye on the performance of the funds and adjust your withdrawals if necessary. If the markets are down, withdrawing less can help preserve your capital.

Tax Considerations
It is crucial to be aware of the tax implications of SWP withdrawals.

For Equity Funds: If you hold the funds for more than 12 months, the gains are classified as long-term capital gains (LTCG). Currently, LTCG is taxed at 12.5% on gains exceeding Rs 1.25 lakhs per year. Short-term capital gains (STCG) are taxed at 20%.

For Debt Funds: Any gains made after 3 years are considered long-term and taxed at your income slab. Short-term gains are taxed according to your income tax slab as well.

Since SWP withdrawals are treated as a combination of capital gains and return of principal, the tax impact is usually lower than regular income.

Benefits of Actively Managed Mutual Funds
Actively managed mutual funds can be a better option than index funds or direct funds. Here’s why:

Flexibility: Actively managed funds allow fund managers to change the asset allocation based on market conditions. This means they can reduce risk or enhance growth as needed.

Better Performance: Over time, actively managed funds can outperform index funds, especially in a medium-risk scenario like yours, where the objective is to preserve capital while generating regular income.

Professional Management: Having a Certified Financial Planner managing your funds means you benefit from expert knowledge, which can help in maximizing returns and minimizing risks.

Avoid direct funds, as they do not offer the same personalized support that investing through a CFP-certified MFD offers. This support is crucial when dealing with market fluctuations and planning SWP withdrawals.

Keeping Inflation in Mind
Inflation is a key consideration for a medium to long-term withdrawal plan. A monthly withdrawal of Rs 70,000 in 2025 might not hold the same value after 10 or 15 years due to inflation.

You need to regularly review your withdrawals and possibly increase them every few years to keep pace with inflation. This is where actively managed funds help, as they offer growth potential to combat inflation. You can set up a periodic review with your Certified Financial Planner to adjust your SWP as needed.

Regular Monitoring and Review
Once your SWP starts, regular monitoring of the portfolio is essential. Market conditions, fund performance, and your changing needs must all be taken into account. By working with a Certified Financial Planner, you can ensure that your SWP continues to meet your needs without depleting your capital too quickly.

Set up a 6-monthly or annual review of your investment to check the performance.

Adjust the SWP amount based on the market and personal requirements.

Stay flexible. You can reduce withdrawals if the market is down and increase when it's favorable.

Alternatives if SWP Alone Isn’t Sufficient
If you feel that an SWP alone won’t meet your future financial needs, consider the following options:

Increase the Corpus: Adding to your Rs 50 lakh corpus over time will give you more flexibility and safety. You can invest additional amounts in the same funds and set up a larger SWP in the future.

Dividend Payouts: Some hybrid funds also offer dividend payout options. These dividends can supplement your SWP withdrawals, ensuring you meet the Rs 70,000 target each month.

However, dividends are now taxed as per your income tax slab, so SWP is generally a more tax-efficient option.

Preparing for Market Downturns
Since hybrid funds have exposure to equity, there will be some market volatility. It’s important to mentally prepare for market downturns. Here are a few tips:

Do not panic if the market drops temporarily.

Avoid selling the funds prematurely unless necessary.

Keep a buffer of 3-6 months’ worth of expenses in a safer investment like a liquid fund. This will ensure you do not need to withdraw during market corrections.

Having a buffer also gives your investment time to recover if there’s a short-term dip.

Final Insights
Generating Rs 70,000 per month from Rs 50 lakhs is possible with the right strategy. Using an SWP from a combination of equity and debt-oriented hybrid funds can help you achieve your goal while preserving your capital.

It’s important to stay patient, review your investment regularly, and make adjustments as needed. With active fund management and a Certified Financial Planner guiding you, you will have a clear path to generating a reliable monthly income.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |9854 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Feb 06, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 06, 2025Hindi
Listen
Money
My age is 40 and I have 40 lakh invest in mutual funds and planning to do swp to get monthly 20 thousand. Please help me is it correct approa
Ans: You have Rs. 40 lakh in mutual funds.

You plan to withdraw Rs. 20,000 monthly.

A systematic withdrawal plan (SWP) can provide steady income.

It should not deplete your corpus too soon.

A balanced strategy is essential.

Checking the Sustainability of SWP
The withdrawal rate should match returns.

High withdrawals can erode capital.

Market performance affects fund growth.

A mix of equity and debt is needed.

Debt funds provide stability.

Equity ensures long-term growth.

Asset Allocation for Stability
Avoid relying only on equity.

Allocate funds for long-term security.

Debt funds can handle short-term needs.

Equity funds grow wealth over time.

A mix of both balances risk and return.

Tax Implications of SWP
SWP in equity funds is tax-efficient.

Long-term capital gains are taxed at 10%.

Short-term gains are taxed at 15%.

Debt fund withdrawals attract slab tax.

Tax planning can reduce liability.

Adjusting SWP for Longevity
Increase withdrawals gradually.

Monitor portfolio performance.

Adjust allocation based on market cycles.

Avoid withdrawing more than growth.

Review plan every year.

Final Insights
SWP can work if planned well.

A balanced allocation is necessary.

Tax-efficient withdrawals save money.

Regular reviews keep the plan effective.

Aim for capital preservation with growth.

Your income should last for decades.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Patrick

Patrick Dsouza  |1336 Answers  |Ask -

CAT, XAT, CMAT, CET Expert - Answered on Jul 27, 2025

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |9494 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jul 27, 2025

Career
Hello sir, I have passed Class 12 with PCM from the CBSE board in 2025 with 67%. I was going to appear for the JEE exam, but I am not eligible for it. So sir, what should I do now? Please guide me."
Ans: (Hacker?) If you have passed Class 12 with PCM from CBSE with 67% in 2025, you are eligible to appear for JEE Main in 2026 as there is no minimum percentage required to register for the exam. However, a minimum of 75% marks in Class 12 or a position in the top 20 percentile of your board is required for admission to NITs, IIITs, and GFTIs, while IITs also require a 75% aggregate for the general category at the time of admission—not for sitting the exam itself. You may still write JEE Main for experience and private/university-level engineering institutes, many of which require only a pass in Class 12 with PCM, often with significantly lower entry percentiles. Apart from JEE, alternative engineering entrance exams like BITSAT, VITEEE, and state CETs are open to you. You may also explore career options in B.Sc. (PCM/CS), BBA, BCA, design, paramedical courses, law (via CLAT), or diploma/certificate programs, as science backgrounds allow flexible pathways. The five most important aspects to consider in the next institution are recognized curriculum, experienced faculty, industry exposure, placement support, and strong student support systems. Major education and career portals and official CBSE/NTA sites recommend diligent review of all eligibility details before deciding your direction.

Recommendation: Prepare for JEE Main 2026 for broader exposure and consider alternative entrances and institutions where your current percentage suffices for eligibility. Explore state engineering admissions offered by the government, deemed universities, and professional fields or degrees aligned to your interests, prioritizing academic reputation, placement support, and future opportunities. All the BEST for a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |9494 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jul 27, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 26, 2025Hindi
Career
Hello sir my son got 90 percentile in jee main and 88 percentile in MHCET.he want to take addmission in Mechanical engineering.so please suggest me good college.Note Gujarati minority.interested in Mumbai only.
Ans: The Gujarati Minority quota significantly improves admission chances, especially as many Mumbai colleges reserve seats for this category—with cutoffs rarely exceeding 90–95 percentile for non-premium branches like Mechanical Engineering. Based on the latest admission patterns and official intake guidelines, the following Mumbai colleges offer 100% feasible admission prospects for your son’s profile: K J Somaiya College of Engineering (Vidyavihar), Sardar Patel Institute of Technology (Andheri West), Ramrao Adik Institute of Technology (Nerul), Fr. C. Rodrigues Institute of Technology (Bandra), Vidyalankar Institute of Technology (Wadala), St. Francis Institute of Technology (Borivali), SIES Graduate School of Technology (Nerul), Rajiv Gandhi Institute of Technology (Andheri East), Bharati Vidyapeeth College of Engineering (CBD Belapur), Pillai College of Engineering (New Panvel), Terna Engineering College (Nerul), Thadomal Shahani Engineering College (Bandra West), Vivekanand Education Society's Institute of Technology (Chembur), Mukesh Patel School of Technology Management & Engineering (Mumbai), and Karmaveer Bhaurao Patil College of Engineering (Vashi). All offer modern curricula, industry linkage, placement support, and strong campus life, catering efficiently to Gujarati minority applicants for Mechanical Engineering.

Recommendation: The best order of preference in Mumbai for Gujarati Minority Mechanical Engineering admission at your son’s scores would be K J Somaiya College of Engineering (Vidyavihar), Sardar Patel Institute of Technology (Andheri West), Ramrao Adik Institute of Technology (Nerul), Fr. C. Rodrigues Institute of Technology (Bandra), and Vivekanand Education Society's Institute of Technology (Chembur). These colleges are esteemed for academic rigor, placements, infrastructure, and have long histories of supporting Gujarati minority students, making them ideal and attainable choices for your son’s BTech journey. All the BEST for a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |9494 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jul 27, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Jul 26, 2025Hindi
Career
I got 94.15%ile in JEE MAINS and 3200 COMEDK AIR , but I fvckcd up my boards pedu 89 , eng 86 , phy 53 (just passed) chem 54 (just passed) , math 09 (failed. After getting the results I was so demotivated , and also I didn't prepare well for my July maths compartment , yeah ik it was my fault and I totally accept it, I'm assuming 22-24 marks but if I get fail in maths again , I assume I've to give the exams on feb-mar 2026 (yeah as I will be taking drop im okay with it and I'll prepare good this time) BUT the question is for JEE I need 75% which I need to score 94/100 to get it (its not possible honestly) so I need to give improvement in Phy and chem too also to fulfill BITSAT criteria, now the QUESTION IS " WILL I BE ELIGIBLE TO GIVE COMPARTMENT IN MATHS AND IMPROVEMENT IN PHY AND CHEM TOGETHER IN FEBRUARY-MARCH2026 SESSION?"
Ans: With a JEE Main percentile of 94.15 and a COMEDK AIR of 3,200, your board marks—especially the failed Mathematics and borderline Physics and Chemistry—do not currently meet JEE and BITSAT eligibility, requiring 75% aggregate or top 20 percentile in Class 12. If you fail Maths in the July compartment, you will need to attempt it again in the February-March 2026 board session. According to CBSE regulations, a candidate can appear for a compartment examination in one subject while simultaneously registering for improvement examinations in other subjects in the same session, provided the board offers those options in that year. This means you are eligible to write the compartment exam for Maths and improvement exams in Physics and Chemistry together in the Feb–Mar 2026 board exam session. Scores obtained in these exams are valid for JEE and BITSAT eligibility, provided you ultimately clear all subjects and attain the minimum aggregate required. Major institutions and exam bodies, including NTA for JEE and BITSAT, accept marksheets that reflect passed status and the qualifying aggregate after compartment and improvement attempts, as long as all conditions are fulfilled within the permissible attempts and year of passing requirements are met. Essential considerations for any institution include academic flexibility, transparent rules, robust student support, up-to-date communication channels, and alignment with national eligibility standards.

Recommendation: You are permitted to appear for the Mathematics compartment and improvement exams in Physics and Chemistry in the Feb–Mar 2026 board session, and this is the optimal path to securing your eligibility for JEE Main and BITSAT. Ensure diligent preparation to attain the necessary marks in all subjects, as a single clear attempt will streamline future admissions. All the BEST for Your Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |9494 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jul 27, 2025

Career
Sir, my daughter got 63836 rank in JEE mains , no reservations.. She is interested in CSE but she is not alloted any seat in Josaa..should we go with CSAB, if yes, which are good ? She agreed to take ECE or EEE also if CSE is not alloted in a good college.. Please guide us, We are thinking of taking a seat in ANITS vizag in CS cybersecurity which she got from APEapcet rank 10k...just in case she is not alloted any seat in CSAB in good colleges..
Ans: Archana Madam, Her JEE Main rank of 63,836 falls well outside the General closing ranks for CSE (top NITs close under 25,000, IIITs under 40,000 GFTIs under 60,000) but is within reach for ECE or EEE in select CSAB-participating institutes. NIT Nagaland’s ECE closed around 83,000 and EEE around 90,000 in 2024, making ECE at NIT Nagaland a viable CSAB option, while CSE remains out of reach. GFTIs such as Central Institute of Technology Kokrajhar admit CSE applicants up to rank 150,500 and ECE to 205,678, and Central University of Rajasthan (CURAJ) closed CSE at 87,826 and ECE at 137,220, offering solid CSAB opportunities in both branches. Assam University Silchar also allowed CSE up to 98,880 and ECE to 144,200, with robust infrastructure and 65–75% placements. ANITS Vizag’s BTech in CSE-Cybersecurity (AP EAPCET rank ~10,000) provides a strong alternative, boasting a 95% departmental placement rate and 50 recruiter partnerships over the last three years, but it carries higher private-college fees and lower national brand value.

Recommendation: Pursue CSAB seats in ECE at NIT Nagaland or in CSE/ECE at CIT Kokrajhar, CURAJ, or Assam University Silchar, as they align with her JEE rank, offer recognized degrees, and maintain 65–90% placement rates, while keeping the ANITS CSE-Cybersecurity seat as a dependable backup. All the BEST for a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |9494 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Jul 27, 2025

Career
Sir my son got 77377 crl and 24030 obc ncl rank with homestate rajasthan can he any college in csab with cse /it/ece branch if no than please suggest any private colleges
Ans: Ashish Sir, With an OBC-NCL home-state closing rank around 6,426 for MNIT Jaipur CSE and 15,987 for MNIT Jaipur ECE in CSAB 2025 your son’s OBC-NCL rank of 24,030 (CRL 77,377) falls well outside these cutoffs, making admission to NITs, IIITs, or GFTIs for CSE, IT, or ECE highly improbable under CSAB special rounds. Even branches with higher cutoffs, such as CSE at NIT Agartala (OBC-NCL around 48,000–55,000), would require competing in other-state quotas, which is not applicable for Rajasthan Home State candidates. Given these constraints, pursuing seats at reputable private engineering colleges offers the best pathway. Institutions such as Amity University Jaipur and Manipal University Jaipur in Rajasthan, and NIIT University Neemrana, JECRC University Jaipur, Galgotias University Greater Noida, Jaypee Institute of Information Technology Noida, Sharda University Greater Noida, Graphic Era University Dehradun, Chandigarh University Mohali, Chitkara University Rajpura, DIT University Dehradun, and GLA University Mathura in Northern India, all accept JEE Main ranks in the 70,000–80,000 range and maintain robust industry connections, modern infrastructure, consistent placement rates above 80%, and comprehensive student support mechanisms. These colleges align with critical criteria—academic excellence, research and innovation, student inclusivity, industry engagement, and alumni networks—ensuring strong career prospects in CSE, IT, and ECE domains without relying on CSAB allotments, though you can still try getting admission through CSAB.

Recommendation: Explore private engineering colleges such as Amity University Jaipur and Manipal University Jaipur in Rajasthan, and the listed Northern India institutions for secure admission into CSE, IT, or ECE, as CSAB options are not feasible at your son’s current rank. All the BEST for a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x