Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Mihir

Mihir Tanna  |1062 Answers  |Ask -

Tax Expert - Answered on Mar 17, 2023

Mihir Ashok Tanna, who works with a well-known chartered accountancy firm in Mumbai, has more than 15 years of experience in direct taxation.
He handles various kinds of matters related to direct tax such as PAN/ TAN application; compliance including ITR, TDS return filing; issuance/ filing of statutory forms like Form 15CB, Form 61A, etc; application u/s 10(46); application for condonation of delay; application for lower/ nil TDS certificate; transfer pricing and study report; advisory/ opinion on direct tax matters; handling various income-tax notices; compounding application on show cause for TDS default; verification of books for TDS/ TCS/ equalisation levy compliance; application for pending income-tax demand and refund; charitable trust taxation and compliance; income-tax scrutiny and CIT(A) for all types of taxpayers including individuals, firms, LLPs, corporates, trusts, non-resident individuals and companies.
He regularly represents clients before the income tax authorities including the commissioner of income tax (appeal).... more
Asked by Anonymous - Mar 14, 2023Hindi
Listen
Money

Hello Mihir Sir, You might be aware of domain buying/selling business, Actually My son has sold a domain and worked as broker and accordingly the transaction has been successfully completed (transaction was done thru a firm which clear path for safe deal in US and disburse the amount according to deal) against which he got a commission in USD, the same was remitted by bank , the amount is about Rs.64.00 lacs, this was the first deal which is done by him, in the coming days there may be more deals. I want to know what will be tax liabilities on this income and coming income, and which ITR shall he submit to fulfill the Income Tax requirement. Humble request to please guide me. Thanks and Regards, Rizwanur Rahman

Ans: Taxability of income will depends on several factors like residential status, business connection in India, DTAA benefit (if available), technical knowledge involved and availability of certain prescribed documents.
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8936 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Nov 26, 2024

Listen
Money
I have been allotted a Plot by authority on 25.05.2016 with a circle rate of ? 15,620.00, and i have been deposited the total amount ? 18,74,400.00 with the Hone Loan of ? 10,00,000.00. Further, authority has given me the letter in March 2024 to register the plot and pay the other charges like, Lease Rent One time, Location Charges, Sewer, Water Connection, Registration Charges etc. I have deposited all the charges of total = ? 3,37,242.00 and get registered with stap duty of ? 1,53,000.00 on 17.06.2024 and taken the possession on 18.11.2024. My total expenditure on the plot comes to ? 23,64,631.00 (Including Stamp Duty). I am planning to sell this plot on amount of ? 33,00,000.00 with the revised circle rate of ? 25,900.00. What are my tax liabilities in this transaction (LTCG or STCG) and any suggestion for exemption.
Ans: To determine your tax liability for the sale of the plot, let’s break down the situation:

Important Details from Your Case
Date of Allotment: 25-May-2016.
Date of Registration: 17-Jun-2024.
Date of Possession: 18-Nov-2024.
Total Cost of Acquisition: Rs. 23,64,631 (including stamp duty).
Sale Price: Rs. 33,00,000.
Circle Rate: Rs. 25,900 per square metre (revised from Rs. 15,620 per square metre).
The total holding period and your choice of taxation method will determine whether you incur LTCG (Long-Term Capital Gains) or STCG (Short-Term Capital Gains) and the corresponding tax liabilities.

Is the Gain Long-Term or Short-Term?
The date of allotment (25-May-2016) is generally considered the purchase date for real estate. Since you are selling the plot after holding it for more than 36 months (over 8 years in your case), your gain qualifies as Long-Term Capital Gain (LTCG).

Calculating the Capital Gains
Sale Price: Rs. 33,00,000.

Cost of Acquisition: Rs. 23,64,631.

Capital Gain: Rs. 33,00,000 – Rs. 23,64,631 = Rs. 9,35,369.

Taxation Options for LTCG (as per the updated rules for sales after 23-Jul-2024):

Option 1: Tax at 12.5% without indexation.

Tax = 12.5% of Rs. 9,35,369 = Rs. 1,16,921 (plus applicable cess and surcharges).
Option 2: Tax at 20% with indexation.
Indexed Capital Gain = Rs. 33,00,000 – Rs. 31,15,434 = Rs. 1,84,566.
Tax = 20% of Rs. 1,84,566 = Rs. 36,913 (plus applicable cess and surcharges).
Choosing the Better Taxation Option
Option 2 (with indexation) is clearly more tax-efficient in this case.
You will pay a lower tax of Rs. 36,913 instead of Rs. 1,16,921 under Option 1.
Suggestions for LTCG Exemption
To further reduce or eliminate your LTCG tax, you can explore the following exemptions under the Income Tax Act, 1961:

1. Section 54F: Invest in a Residential Property
If you use the sale proceeds to purchase or construct a residential property, you can claim exemption under Section 54F.
Conditions:
You must not own more than one house property on the date of transfer.
The new property must be purchased within one year before or two years after the sale, or constructed within three years.
The entire sale consideration should be utilised to claim full exemption.
2. Section 54EC: Invest in Specified Bonds
Invest up to Rs. 50 lakhs in NHAI or REC Capital Gain Bonds within six months of the sale.
The investment is locked in for five years and offers a safe, tax-saving option.
3. Capital Gains Account Scheme (CGAS)
If you cannot immediately utilise the sale proceeds, deposit them in a CGAS account before the filing deadline.
This allows you to keep the exemption intact while planning future investments.
Final Insights
Your plot sale qualifies for LTCG tax. The 20% with indexation option significantly reduces your tax burden.
To minimise tax, consider reinvesting under Section 54F or 54EC.
Consult a Certified Financial Planner or tax expert for tailored advice on reinvestment options and compliance with timelines.
Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8936 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 18, 2025

Money
Hi Sir, I am 45 years old. Salaried 1.6 Lakhs per month. I have two kids -Son is 15 years old and daughter is 11 years old. I would like to retire at the age of 55 and allocate 1 crores for children education and marriage. I have own house and would like to have 3 crores as retirement corpus at the age of 55. My current investments are - 40L in mutual fund , 9 Lakhs in stocks and 15 Lakhs in PF. Monthly contributing 15K in PF and having SIP of 60K per month in mutual funds. Pls advise whether the current investments are sufficient to acheive my goal. Thanks.
Ans: At 45, your commitment towards early retirement, children’s future, and disciplined saving is deeply appreciated.

Let’s evaluate your goals, current resources, and what changes you may need. This answer will help you take corrective steps and prepare a practical, structured plan.

Understanding Your Financial Vision
You wish to:

Retire at 55 with Rs 3 crores retirement corpus

Allocate Rs 1 crore for children's education and marriage

You are already:

Saving Rs 60K monthly in mutual funds (SIPs)

Contributing Rs 15K monthly into PF

Have Rs 64 lakhs accumulated already (MF + PF + Stocks)

Living in a self-owned house (no rent expenses in retirement)

These are solid and encouraging building blocks. However, the key question is — are these numbers enough?

Retirement Corpus Requirement Evaluation
Let’s begin with retirement.

You are targeting Rs 3 crores at 55

This needs to support at least 25-30 years of retired life

Your monthly income today is Rs 1.6 lakhs

Retirement expenses (without kids' education or EMIs) may be around Rs 70K to Rs 90K/month

Inflation will make these numbers higher by the time you retire

So, Rs 3 crores is a reasonable and safe retirement goal.

But let’s now assess if you are on track.

Reviewing Existing Investments and Monthly Contributions
You already have:

Rs 40 lakhs in mutual funds

Rs 15 lakhs in PF

Rs 9 lakhs in stocks

You are also:

Contributing Rs 60K/month into mutual funds

Contributing Rs 15K/month into PF

That’s Rs 75K/month of disciplined investing. Very strong effort.

Still, we must assess future growth of each instrument, taking inflation and realistic return assumptions.

Suitability of Investment Mix
Mutual Funds – Rs 40L corpus, Rs 60K SIP monthly

You’re doing well with equity mutual fund SIPs

Make sure these are active mutual funds and not index funds

Index funds lack downside protection and underperform in sideways markets

Actively managed funds provide flexibility in dynamic Indian markets

Focus on diversified equity mutual funds

You must have a mix of large cap, flexi cap, mid cap, and select sector/thematic

Avoid sectoral overexposure, stay away from new NFOs without track record

Stocks – Rs 9L

Direct stocks are high-risk and need continuous monitoring

Don’t treat this as core retirement corpus

Use stock portfolio for opportunity-based returns only

No need to increase stock exposure at this stage

PF – Rs 15L corpus, Rs 15K contribution/month

Good for stability and conservative fixed income

PF will provide a safe retirement cushion

But do not rely on PF alone for retirement corpus creation

Rate of return is fixed and may not beat long-term inflation fully

Children’s Education and Marriage Fund: Rs 1 Crore Target
Your son is 15 and daughter is 11.

So you will need:

Partial fund in next 2-3 years (son’s education)

Major amount by next 10-12 years (daughter’s education and marriage)

This means you need to create a parallel corpus of Rs 1 crore without disturbing your retirement savings.

Plan of Action:

Allocate a separate mutual fund folio for this goal

Do not mix it with your retirement investments

Choose balanced advantage, flexi-cap, and large-mid funds for this purpose

Withdraw from equity gradually once goal is near (start moving to short-term debt funds 3 years before need)

You may already be on track here if you dedicate part of the Rs 60K SIPs

But if all your SIPs are targeted for retirement only, you must either:

Increase your SIPs by Rs 15K–20K/month

OR

Allocate part of your stock portfolio and annual bonuses for kids’ goal

Evaluating SIP Sufficiency Towards Retirement
Rs 60K/month SIP in equity mutual funds for 10 years will build solid corpus only if:

Funds are actively managed by competent AMC

SIPs increase 10% every year (step-up SIPs)

You don’t stop SIPs even during market crashes

You rebalance regularly through a Certified Financial Planner

If you stay consistent, you are likely to reach Rs 3 crore, but without much surplus.

So, there is limited cushion in your current plan. You’re on track, but only marginally.

Required Adjustments for Better Safety
Increase Monthly Investment Gradually

From Rs 75K/month, try to increase SIPs by 10-15% yearly

Use salary hikes, annual bonus, or incentives to fund extra SIPs

Keep PF as it is; no need to increase PF contribution beyond current limit

Separate Goals and Tracking

Create two sets of SIPs: one for retirement, one for kids’ education

Avoid mixing funds or redeeming prematurely from retirement corpus

Avoid Index and Direct Funds

Direct funds lack advisory, tax planning, rebalancing, and behaviour control

You may miss correction opportunities or exit too late during volatility

Better to invest via regular plans with a trusted MFD or CFP

They offer active support, periodic alerts, tax strategy, and customised advice

Many investors earn less not because of bad funds, but due to bad timing and behaviour

Certified Financial Planner brings discipline and strategy in market fluctuations

Insurance and Risk Protection
You didn’t mention any insurance.

At 45 with family responsibilities, review:

Term insurance: Ensure Rs 1 crore+ coverage till age 60

Health insurance: Have Rs 10–20 lakh family floater + top-up

Critical illness cover: Optional but useful after 50

Without insurance, even the best investment plan can collapse under sudden medical or death risk.

Emergency Fund
You didn’t mention cash reserves.

Keep:

At least 6 months' expenses in liquid or ultra-short duration debt fund

Don’t keep this in equity or PF

You may use part of your PF loan provision only if very urgent

Investment Behaviour and Tax Awareness
Stay invested during downturns

Market cycles are natural

Many investors lose by stopping SIPs in bear markets

Those who stay invested enjoy strong recovery

Tax planning

Equity mutual funds LTCG: Only above Rs 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%

STCG in equity: Taxed at 20%

Debt funds: Taxed as per slab

Plan redemption accordingly with a Certified Financial Planner

Avoid real estate as an investment

Your house is an asset to live in, not a liquid financial tool

Real estate requires high maintenance, has low liquidity, and tax issues

Better to keep your future investments in mutual funds instead

Retirement Withdrawal Strategy
When you retire at 55:

Don’t withdraw entire mutual fund corpus

Keep equity portion invested and withdraw via SWP

Use bucket strategy:

First 3 years expenses in ultra short and liquid funds

Next 5 years in balanced or hybrid

Long-term part in equity

This protects you from selling during market crash

A Certified Financial Planner can set this up and track annually

Keep Reviewing Progress Every Year
Your current SIP discipline is very strong. But review:

Fund performance every 12 months

Goal progress every year

Increase SIPs gradually

Exit underperforming funds only under expert guidance

Avoid chasing star ratings or social media hype.

Key Action Points
Separate children’s corpus from retirement corpus

Increase SIPs by Rs 15K/month if possible

Avoid index and direct funds; shift to regular plans via MFD with CFP support

Keep investing during all market cycles

Maintain term and health insurance coverage

Create an emergency reserve now itself

Use a Certified Financial Planner for tracking and behaviour control

Do not withdraw from mutual funds prematurely

Review and rebalance annually

Finally
You are very close to being on track.

But only with continued discipline, increased SIPs, and expert guidance can you safely reach all goals.

You are doing far better than most. But don’t take comfort and stay static.

Make small changes now. They will give huge benefits later.

Retirement at 55 is fully possible — but only with strong control on investment behaviour and cash flow discipline. With a Certified Financial Planner by your side, you can fine-tune this further.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x