I have 8 crore property loan shared with my brother. We live in a joint family and run a manufacturing business that generates around 1.2 crore annual profit. Apart from this, I have 85 lakh invested in equity mutual funds through SIPs, 40 lakh in debt mutual funds, 25 lakh in large-cap stocks, and 15 lakh in gold ETFs as a hedge. I also hold 50 lakh in fixed deposits for emergencies. A portion of my income is reinvested in expanding our business, and I'm considering buying a 3 crore commercial property in the next two years. Given my high debt obligations and diverse investment portfolio, should I focus on loan prepayment or continue aggressive investments for long-term growth?
Ans: You have built a strong and diversified financial position. Your balance between business, investments, and contingency funds shows discipline. At the same time, an Rs. 8 crore loan is a significant commitment. The decision between prepayment and aggressive investment should be made after looking at liquidity, returns, and risk tolerance.
» current financial position overview
– Annual business profit is Rs. 1.2 crore, giving high cash flow.
– Equity mutual funds: Rs. 85 lakh.
– Debt mutual funds: Rs. 40 lakh.
– Large-cap stocks: Rs. 25 lakh.
– Gold ETFs: Rs. 15 lakh as hedge.
– Fixed deposits: Rs. 50 lakh for emergencies.
– Loan: Rs. 8 crore shared with your brother.
– Considering Rs. 3 crore commercial property in next two years.
» assessing loan prepayment vs. investment
– Compare your loan interest rate with expected investment returns.
– If investment return after tax is higher than loan rate, investment may win.
– If loan rate is higher, prepayment saves more.
– But also consider emotional comfort and risk reduction from lower debt.
– Large debt can create stress in downturns, even if income is strong.
» impact of your business income
– Your manufacturing profit is steady and sizable.
– This allows you to handle EMIs without pressuring investments.
– Part of profit is reinvested in the business, which can give high returns.
– However, business returns can be cyclical, so personal portfolio stability matters.
» risk concentration from property loans
– An Rs. 8 crore property loan ties you to long-term repayment.
– Property market value can fluctuate and liquidity is low.
– This creates concentration risk if much of your net worth is in real estate.
– Reducing loan over time lowers both interest cost and this concentration.
» evaluating your current investments
– Your equity mutual funds are well-sized for long-term growth.
– Actively managed funds can adapt to market shifts better than index funds.
– Large-cap stocks give direct exposure but come with higher volatility than funds.
– Debt funds give stability and liquidity for short to medium-term needs.
– Gold ETFs provide inflation hedge and diversification but are not growth assets.
– Fixed deposits give safety and quick access for emergencies.
» role of liquidity in your decision
– You have Rs. 50 lakh in FDs and Rs. 40 lakh in debt funds for liquidity.
– This is healthy and covers any business or family emergency.
– But buying a Rs. 3 crore commercial property will reduce liquidity.
– Ensure you keep at least one year’s loan EMI and expenses in liquid assets.
» effect of upcoming commercial property purchase
– The new purchase will add more debt if not fully funded from profits.
– This increases fixed obligations and reduces flexibility in downturns.
– Before committing, assess combined EMIs from current and new property.
– Avoid over-leverage even if rental income is expected.
– If possible, delay or scale down property purchase until current loan reduces.
» structured approach to balance growth and debt reduction
– Continue investing in equity mutual funds for long-term wealth creation.
– Allocate some surplus each year to partial loan prepayment.
– This gradually reduces interest outgo without stopping growth.
– For example, 60% of annual surplus to investments, 40% to loan prepayment.
– As loan reduces, you can tilt more towards investments.
» mental and strategic benefits of lowering debt
– Lower debt gives peace of mind in uncertain times.
– It also improves credit profile and borrowing power for business expansion.
– Reduced EMIs increase future free cash flow for investments.
– Even if investments give higher returns, risk-adjusted comfort matters.
» taxation aspects in decision making
– Equity mutual funds LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%.
– STCG on equity funds is taxed at 20%.
– Debt mutual funds are taxed at your income slab rate.
– Loan prepayment gives no tax benefit unless interest is deductible.
– So, compare post-tax investment returns with loan rate.
» importance of annual review
– Review your business cash flow, loan balance, and investments yearly.
– If business slows, increase prepayment for safety.
– If markets are low, lean more towards equity investment.
– Keep a flexible approach rather than a fixed rule.
» legacy and family security planning
– Maintain sufficient insurance to cover outstanding loan share.
– This protects your family from liability in case of uncertainty.
– Keep a clear record of all investments and property holdings.
– Estate planning through a Will avoids disputes in joint family setups.
» finally
Your financial strength allows you to manage both growth and debt reduction. By balancing investments with partial prepayment, you can lower risk without losing long-term compounding benefits. Keeping adequate liquidity and avoiding excessive new property debt will give you flexibility. Over the next decade, this approach will steadily reduce liabilities and grow your net worth with confidence.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment