i wish to purchase new car i10, should i purchase the same through own money or should i take a vehicle loan from bank and the money own by my to be kept as FDR or liquid mutual fund
Ans: It’s a good sign that you’re thinking before buying a car. You’re not rushing into it. That shows maturity and smart thinking.
We will now evaluate own money vs vehicle loan — from every angle.
Understanding the Nature of a Car Purchase
A car is not an investment.
It is a consumption asset, not a growth asset.
It depreciates every year. Its value goes down, not up.
So the cheaper the total cost, the better for your wealth.
Option 1: Use Own Money Fully
Pros
No interest cost. You save on total expenses.
You are free from monthly EMI pressure.
Car becomes fully yours from day one.
No need to deal with bank, forms, hypothecation etc.
Cons
Your liquid money reduces.
You may not have enough cash for emergencies.
Opportunity loss if you had invested that money.
Option 2: Take Vehicle Loan & Keep Own Money in FDR or Liquid Mutual Fund
Let’s evaluate this with care.
Vehicle Loan Pros
You can preserve your savings for emergencies.
EMI can be budgeted monthly, if income is stable.
Some banks offer competitive interest rates.
Vehicle Loan Cons
You will pay interest on a depreciating item.
Loan adds to your monthly obligations.
You must pay insurance, EMI, fuel, and service together.
FDR and Liquid Mutual Funds give lower returns than loan cost.
So you will likely lose more in interest than you gain.
Let's Compare: Interest Rate vs Investment Return
Vehicle loan interest is usually 9% to 11% per year.
FDR gives around 6% to 7% before tax.
Liquid mutual funds give 6% to 7.5% on average.
So you pay more to the bank than you earn from investment.
Tax on interest or gains reduces actual return further.
This means taking a car loan and investing your own money leads to net loss.
Best Option for You: Smart Compromise Approach
Let me share a wise solution.
Don’t use full own money. Don’t take full loan either.
Instead, pay 70–80% from own funds.
Take a small car loan for the remaining 20–30% only.
This keeps EMI low and retains some liquidity.
You reduce interest cost and also keep Rs.50,000–Rs.1 lakh aside.
Park that in liquid fund for any urgent need.
Repay this small loan fast in 1–2 years.
Only Take a Car Loan If:
Your job income is stable.
You already have 3–6 months emergency fund ready.
You don’t have big loans running now.
You can pay EMI without affecting savings.
You commit to close the loan early.
Avoid This Mistake:
Never buy a more expensive car because loan makes it “feel affordable.”
Loan should not expand your car budget.
Whether you buy with loan or cash, pick a simple car within limits.
i10 is a wise, middle-ground choice. Good thought.
Tax Angle (If Business Use)
If you are using the car for business, vehicle loan interest may be tax-deductible.
But for personal use, there is no tax benefit.
So do not take loan just for imagined tax saving.
Final Insights
A car is a need, not an investment.
Using your own money fully keeps things simple and cheap.
Taking a full car loan and investing the money gives net negative return.
Best option is a split approach — pay major part from own funds.
Take small loan only if needed and close it early.
Always keep emergency money aside before buying.
Avoid emotional buying or overbudget cars.
Your financially balanced approach is very appreciable.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment