Hi, I have a question about the expense ratio in mutual funds. I have invested in direct mutual funds both Parag Parikh ELSS (expense ratio - 0.69%) & Parag Parikh Flexi Cap (expense ratio - 0.57%). I have invested 25000/- each in both funds,...

Hi, I have a question about the expense ratio in mutual funds. I have invested in direct mutual funds both Parag Parikh ELSS (expense ratio - 0.69%) & Parag Parikh Flexi Cap (expense ratio - 0.57%). I have invested 25000/- each in both funds, one of my friend suggested to invest in any one of the funds as this will affect the returns for in longer period, and I am planning to invest for another 10 years in both funds. Question: Is it okay to be invested in both funds, I'm aware that the funds overlap, but I want to check on the expense ratio difference in the cost for 10 years. Can you please help me understand the calculation so that I can make a better decision? Expense ratio is calculated for the amount that I invest, either I invest 50k in one of the funds or split 25k each in both funds having a difference of 0.12% in expense ratio. How much of this will affect the end corpus and how is that I can calculate for the other mutual funds that I'm currently investing in? please suggest me on this.

Ans: You're absolutely right, even a small difference in expense ratio can affect returns over time. Here's how to analyze your situation and the impact of expense ratios:

Impact of Expense Ratio on Returns:

The expense ratio is a percentage of your investment deducted annually to cover fund management fees. A lower expense ratio means more money stays invested and has the potential to grow through compounding.

Calculating the Cost Difference:

Annual Cost Difference: Multiply the expense ratio difference (0.12%) by your total investment amount (25000 + 25000 = ?50,000). So, 0.12% * ?50,000 = ?60 per year.

Cost Difference over 10 Years: Multiply the annual cost difference (?60) by the number of years (10). This gives you ?600 as the total expense ratio cost difference over 10 years.

Is ?600 Significant?

While ?600 might seem small, it's crucial to consider the power of compounding over 10 years. Let's say you earn an average annual return of 12%. Here's a simplified comparison:

Investing in Both Funds: Your total return after 10 years would be impacted by the expense ratio difference of ?600. There's a chance you might have slightly more if you invested in the single fund with the lower expense ratio.

Investing in One Fund: This scenario eliminates the expense ratio difference, potentially leading to a slightly higher return due to slightly more money compounding over time.

Making an Informed Decision:

Diversification Benefit: Both Parag Parikh ELSS and Flexi Cap represent different fund categories (ELSS & Flexi Cap). Holding both provides diversification, which can help mitigate risk.

Expense Ratio vs. Diversification: The diversification benefit of holding both funds might outweigh the small cost difference in expense ratios.

Consider Overall Portfolio: Analyze your entire investment portfolio. If you have other diversified funds, then holding both Parag Parikh funds might be redundant.

Calculating for Other Funds:

Use the same method mentioned above. Find the expense ratio difference between the funds you're comparing and multiply it by your investment amount to get the annual cost difference. Then multiply by the number of years you plan to invest.
Recommendation:

It's difficult to definitively say whether consolidating is best. Here are some options:

Maintain Both Funds: The diversification benefit might be valuable. Track the performance of both and re-evaluate if one consistently underperforms.

Consolidate: If you have other diversified funds, consider consolidating to the fund with the lower expense ratio.

Invest More in Lower Expense Ratio Fund: Increase your investment proportionally in the Parag Parikh Flexi Cap (lower expense ratio) to potentially gain a slight edge over time.

Consulting a Financial Advisor:

A financial advisor can analyze your entire portfolio, risk tolerance, and goals to provide a personalized recommendation.

Ans: Your decision to invest Rs 15,000 per month in mutual funds is a great step toward building wealth. However, there are a few points to consider to ensure you are optimizing your investments and achieving your financial goals.

Let’s review your portfolio in detail:

Portfolio Overview
Motilal Oswal Midcap Fund – Rs 2,500 per month
Quant Mid Cap Fund – Rs 1,500 per month
ICICI Prudential Bharat 22 FOF – Rs 1,500 per month
Nippon India Large Cap Fund – Rs 3,000 per month
JM Flexi Cap Fund – Rs 3,000 per month
Quant Small Cap Fund – Rs 3,000 per month
Tata Nifty 200 Alpha 30 Index Fund – Rs 500 per month
These investments total Rs 15,000 per month, and it’s commendable that you have allocated funds across various categories, including large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap, and sector-specific funds. However, there are key areas to evaluate to help you optimize returns and manage risks.

Disadvantages of Direct Funds
Since you are investing in direct plans, it's important to be aware of a few limitations:

No Financial Guidance: Direct plans do not come with any personalized advice from a Certified Financial Planner. This could mean missing out on crucial insights and market trends that could boost your returns.

Lack of Market Knowledge: If you're not constantly tracking markets, you may miss out on strategic shifts. A professional fund distributor can guide you to take timely actions.

Overlooking Tax Efficiency: Direct plans do not provide any tax-efficient strategies. An expert's input can help minimize tax liabilities and maximize post-tax returns.

Given these limitations, I would recommend switching to regular funds through a Mutual Fund Distributor (MFD) with a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) credential. This will ensure professional guidance and better long-term returns.

Disadvantages of Index Funds
Your portfolio includes an index fund (Tata Nifty 200 Alpha 30 Index Fund). While index funds have low expense ratios, they come with their own set of challenges:

Lack of Flexibility: Index funds cannot adjust to changing market conditions. In a volatile market, this can result in lower returns compared to actively managed funds.

No Market Timing: An index fund simply follows the index, regardless of individual stock performance. Active funds, on the other hand, can exit underperforming stocks and reinvest in better opportunities.

For these reasons, I recommend focusing more on actively managed funds, where fund managers can provide better growth potential by actively selecting stocks and rebalancing portfolios based on market conditions.

Analysis of Your Current Mutual Funds
Now, let's analyze your specific fund choices and provide suggestions on how to refine your portfolio:

1. Motilal Oswal Midcap Fund – Rs 2,500 per month
Analysis: Midcap funds can offer higher returns than large-cap funds, but they also come with higher risk. Since you already have a significant allocation in midcaps, ensure that your risk appetite aligns with this investment.
2. Quant Mid Cap Fund – Rs 1,500 per month
Analysis: This is another midcap fund, and you are currently allocating Rs 4,000 in total toward midcaps (Motilal Oswal Midcap Fund and Quant Mid Cap Fund). While midcaps provide good growth potential, it’s essential to maintain a balanced portfolio by adding other asset classes.
3. ICICI Prudential Bharat 22 FOF – Rs 1,500 per month
Analysis: Bharat 22 FOF is a thematic fund that invests in public sector companies. While these funds can perform well during certain periods, they come with high concentration risk. If you are investing for long-term wealth creation, it might be wise to diversify your allocation rather than relying on sector-specific funds.
4. Nippon India Large Cap Fund – Rs 3,000 per month
Analysis: Large-cap funds provide stability and steady growth. Nippon India Large Cap Fund is a good choice for balancing your overall portfolio risk. Large-cap funds are essential for a well-rounded portfolio as they offer lower volatility than mid and small caps.
5. JM Flexi Cap Fund – Rs 3,000 per month
Analysis: Flexi-cap funds invest in large, mid, and small-cap companies, offering diversification. This fund could help reduce the risk in your portfolio, as it can invest across market capitalizations based on market conditions.
6. Quant Small Cap Fund – Rs 3,000 per month
Analysis: Small-cap funds can provide high returns, but they also come with the highest risk. While it's good to have some exposure to small caps, ensure you are not overly exposed to this segment.
7. Tata Nifty 200 Alpha 30 Index Fund – Rs 500 per month
Analysis: As discussed earlier, index funds have limitations, and I recommend shifting this amount to an actively managed fund for better growth potential and flexibility.
Areas of Improvement and Suggestions
Overlapping Funds: Your portfolio has an overlap in the midcap space (Motilal Oswal Midcap Fund and Quant Mid Cap Fund). While it's good to diversify, having too many funds from the same category can lead to duplication and reduce your overall returns. You could consolidate your midcap exposure into one well-performing fund.

Balanced Risk: You have allocated a significant portion of your portfolio to mid and small-cap funds, which are higher risk. To balance this, consider increasing your investment in large-cap or flexi-cap funds, which provide more stability and lower risk.

Reduce Sector-Specific Exposure: ICICI Prudential Bharat 22 FOF is a thematic fund with a high concentration in public sector companies. It might be a good idea to reduce your exposure to sector-specific funds and invest in diversified equity funds instead.

Increase Flexi Cap Allocation: Flexi-cap funds provide diversification across market capitalizations. By increasing your allocation to JM Flexi Cap Fund, you can better balance the risk and returns in your portfolio.

Reconsider Index Fund: Since index funds lack flexibility, I recommend shifting the Rs 500 currently allocated to Tata Nifty 200 Alpha 30 Index Fund to an actively managed large or flexi-cap fund. This will help you achieve better returns over the long term.

Tax Considerations
When selling equity mutual funds:

Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG): Gains above Rs 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.

Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG): Gains made within three years are taxed at 20%.

Keep these tax rules in mind when planning to exit or rebalance your portfolio, as taxes can impact your overall returns.

Final Insights
Your mutual fund portfolio is a good start, but it requires some fine-tuning to optimize growth and manage risks better. Consolidating your midcap exposure, reducing sector-specific funds, and avoiding index funds can help you achieve more balanced growth. Shifting to regular funds through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) can also provide expert guidance to further optimize your investments.

By following these adjustments and maintaining a disciplined investment approach, your portfolio can deliver strong returns over the long term.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment