Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

NPS vs UPS: Which is Better for a Central Govt. Employee with 10 Years Left?

Milind

Milind Vadjikar  |1207 Answers  |Ask -

Insurance, Stocks, MF, PF Expert - Answered on Apr 12, 2025

Milind Vadjikar is an independent MF distributor registered with Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI) and a retirement financial planning advisor registered with Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA).
He has a mechanical engineering degree from Government Engineering College, Sambhajinagar, and an MBA in international business from the Symbiosis Institute of Business Management, Pune.
With over 16 years of experience in stock investments, and over six year experience in investment guidance and support, he believes that balanced asset allocation and goal-focused disciplined investing is the key to achieving investor goals.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Apr 04, 2025Hindi
Listen
Money

M a central government employee under nps with 10 more years of service i would like to know which is better option NPS or UPS. Plsss

Ans: Hello;

The main plus point of UPS is guaranteed benefit i.e. 50% of last drawn salary as pension.

And this pension has Dearness allowance component so your retirement income is pegged to inflation.

However you will need to carefully assess the pro's and con's of each system and take a call. My advice will be for UPS.

Best wishes;
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Nitin

Nitin Narkhede  |63 Answers  |Ask -

MF, PF Expert - Answered on Sep 11, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Aug 26, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
Hi Mr. Vivek, i would like to seek ur advice regarding the central government announcement relating to the pension scheme. Which among the 2 pension schemes is more beneficial NPS or UPS. I am eagerly waiting for your financial advice on the above matter.
Ans: Dear Vivek,
Thank you for your query regarding the recent pension scheme announcement. Let’s understand the key differences between the National Pension System (NPS) and the newly introduced Universal Pension Scheme (UPS) and find out which might be more beneficial for you.
National Pension System (NPS) NPS is a government-backed retirement savings scheme where you contribute regularly during your working years, and the funds are invested in a mix of equity, corporate debt, and government bonds. Upon retirement, you receive a portion of the accumulated corpus as a lump sum, and the rest is used to purchase an annuity that provides a regular pension. Let’s see what are Tax Benefits Contributions to NPS are tax-deductible up to Rs 1.5 lakh under Section 80C and an additional Rs 50,000 under Section 80CCD(1B), making it attractive for tax-saving purposes. The returns on NPS depend on market performance, as it invests in equity and debt instruments. Historically, the average return has been between 8-10%, making it a relatively high-return pension option. If you see 2023 the returns are between 16 to 20%. There is Flexibility to choose your own asset allocation (equity vs. debt) or opt for auto-allocation based on your age and risk profile. For Withdrawals At the age of 60, you can withdraw 60% of the corpus tax-free, while 40% is used to purchase an annuity, which provides a regular pension. For premature exit is only possible after 5 Years after registration. you can withdraw entire amount if corpus is below 2.5 Lakh. If corpus is beyond 2.5 lakh then you can only withdraw 20% and balance 80 % to be invested to buy annuity.
In case of Universal Pension Scheme (UPS) it is a recently introduced pension scheme aimed at providing retirement benefits to all citizens, including those in informal sectors who may not have access to other retirement schemes. It is designed to ensure that every citizen has a basic income after retirement. For Contribution: UPS is likely to have lower contribution requirements compared to NPS, making it more accessible to those with lower incomes or irregular earnings. The scheme promises universal coverage, meaning it is open to all citizens, regardless of their employment status. UPS may offer fixed or modest returns, more similar to a traditional pension plan, and less focused on market-linked investments like NPS. The scheme is likely to be simpler to manage, with fewer choices regarding asset allocation and investment decisions. Under the UPS, the assured pension will be the average basic salary + DA drawn in the previous 12 months before superannuation. This would mean that government employees, at retirement, will get 50% of the average of the last 12 months' salary + DA.
Which One Is More Beneficial?
If You’re Seeking Higher Returns and Flexibility then NPS would be a better option as it allows for market-linked returns (higher than most traditional pension schemes) and gives you control over your investment choices. It’s ideal for those who want to accumulate a larger retirement corpus.
If You Want Simplicity and Universal Access then UPS could be a good choice for individuals looking for an easy-to-understand, universally available pension scheme with a stable income. It is designed to cater to a broader section of the population, especially those in informal jobs or without regular retirement savings.
For Tax Benefits: NPS offers significant tax benefits under Section 80C and 80CCD, which may make it more attractive if you’re in a higher tax bracket.
For Lower-Income Individuals: UPS may be more beneficial due to its accessibility and potentially lower contribution requirements.
It’s important to assess your long-term goals, income, and risk tolerance before making a decision. If you need further clarification or help choosing the best scheme for you, feel free to reach out.
Best regards,
Nitin Narkhede
Founder & MD, Prosperity Lifestyle Hub https://Nitinnarkhede.com
Free Webinar https://bit.ly/PLH-Webinar

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |8320 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Sep 03, 2024

Money
Sir, as the government has introduced the UPS, which has caused a dilemma, i e. investment in which one of the two NPS, UPS, will be a better option, if I am planning to invest for my children, age 23, (doing his 4th year MBBS) and 18 yrs (doing his 12th standard) that can give better returns.
Ans: Investing for your children’s future is a commendable goal. With the government introducing the Universal Pension Scheme (UPS) alongside the National Pension System (NPS), it’s natural to weigh your options. The goal here is to find an investment that will not only secure their future but also maximize returns.

In this context, considering mutual funds as a primary investment vehicle may be the most effective strategy. Mutual funds can offer greater flexibility, potential returns, and the ability to meet specific financial goals for your children, aged 23 and 18.

Understanding the NPS and UPS
National Pension System (NPS)
NPS is a well-known government-backed pension scheme. It offers a mix of equity, debt, and government securities. The returns from NPS are market-linked, meaning they depend on the performance of the underlying assets. NPS also comes with tax benefits under Section 80C and 80CCD(1B) of the Income Tax Act.

Pros of NPS:

Tax Benefits: Investment in NPS offers tax deductions.

Long-Term Growth: NPS allows for disciplined retirement savings.

Partial Withdrawal: NPS permits partial withdrawals for specific needs.

Government-Backed: Being a government-backed scheme, it’s secure.

Cons of NPS:

Lock-In Period: The investment is locked until retirement, with limited withdrawal options.

Lower Equity Exposure: The maximum equity exposure in NPS is capped at 75%.

Annuity Requirement: A significant portion of the maturity amount must be used to purchase an annuity, which offers lower returns.

Universal Pension Scheme (UPS)
The recently introduced UPS is designed to provide universal coverage, catering to a broader demographic. Like NPS, it’s market-linked but with potentially more conservative investment options.

Pros of UPS:

Broader Coverage: Aimed at providing pension coverage to all.

Government Support: Backed by government initiatives.

Cons of UPS:

Lower Returns: Likely to be more conservative, with lower equity exposure.

Limited Flexibility: Similar to NPS, with a long lock-in period.

Why Mutual Funds Stand Out
Flexibility in Investment
Mutual funds offer a range of options, from equity funds to debt funds, catering to various risk appetites. For your children, considering their age and future financial needs, mutual funds provide the flexibility to adjust the investment strategy as they grow older.

Advantages:

Customizable Portfolios: You can choose funds that align with your children’s risk profile.

Liquidity: Mutual funds are more liquid, allowing easy access to funds when needed.

Diversification: Mutual funds offer diversification across different asset classes.

Higher Potential Returns
Compared to NPS and UPS, mutual funds, especially equity funds, have the potential to deliver higher returns. Over a long-term horizon, equity mutual funds can outperform other investment options due to their exposure to the stock market.

Equity Mutual Funds:

Growth-Oriented: Ideal for long-term goals like funding education or purchasing a home.

Variety: Includes large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap funds, each with its growth potential.

Debt Mutual Funds:

Stability: Provides stability with lower risk, suitable for conservative investors.

Interest Rate Dynamics: Debt funds can take advantage of changing interest rates for returns.

Why Not NPS or UPS?
Lock-In Period Constraints
Both NPS and UPS come with significant lock-in periods, restricting access to funds until retirement age. This could be a drawback if your children require funds for education, starting a business, or other life events before they reach retirement age.

Impact on Liquidity:

NPS: Limited partial withdrawal options only for specific reasons.

UPS: Likely to follow similar restrictions as NPS.

Annuity Requirement
A significant downside of NPS, and likely UPS, is the annuity purchase requirement. Upon maturity, a large portion of the corpus must be used to buy an annuity, which generally offers lower returns. This reduces the flexibility to use the accumulated wealth as per the individual’s needs.

Annuity Constraints:

Lower Returns: Annuities typically provide lower returns compared to mutual funds.

Limited Usage: The annuity locks in the amount, providing a fixed income, which may not be sufficient to meet inflation-adjusted needs.

Disadvantages of Index Funds
While index funds are popular for their low costs, they may not be the best option for achieving higher returns. Index funds merely replicate the market index, offering no potential to outperform the market.

Key Points:

No Outperformance: Index funds only match market returns.

Lack of Active Management: Index funds lack the advantage of professional fund management, which can potentially add value through stock selection.

Benefits of Regular Funds Through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP)
Investing through regular funds via a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) offers several advantages. A CFP can help you navigate the complex investment landscape and select funds that align with your goals.

Advantages:

Professional Guidance: A CFP provides expert advice tailored to your needs.

Regular Monitoring: Regular funds managed by a CFP are closely monitored and adjusted based on market conditions.

Long-Term Strategy: A CFP can help devise a long-term strategy that adapts to life changes, ensuring your investment remains aligned with your children’s needs.

Mutual Funds for Children’s Education
Equity Mutual Funds for Long-Term Goals
For your 23-year-old child, currently in the 4th year of MBBS, equity mutual funds can be an excellent choice. With a longer investment horizon, equity funds can help build a substantial corpus by the time they start their career or pursue higher studies.

Considerations:

Aggressive Growth: Focus on funds with a strong track record in equity markets.

Diversified Portfolio: Invest in a mix of large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap funds.

Balanced Mutual Funds for a Moderate Approach
For your 18-year-old child, balanced mutual funds can be a safer yet growth-oriented option. These funds invest in a mix of equity and debt, providing stability with the potential for growth.

Advantages:

Reduced Risk: Balanced funds lower the risk by including debt securities.

Steady Growth: Provides a steady growth potential suitable for education funding.

Evaluating Risk Tolerance
Understanding your children’s risk tolerance is crucial in deciding the right investment strategy.

For the 23-Year-Old:

Higher Risk Appetite: At this age, they can afford to take more risks with a greater focus on equity.

Long-Term Horizon: The longer investment horizon allows for recovery from market downturns.

For the 18-Year-Old:

Moderate Risk Appetite: A balanced approach with both equity and debt is advisable.

Shorter Horizon: As they approach higher education, a mix of stability and growth is ideal.

Final Insights
Investing in mutual funds offers flexibility, potential for higher returns, and customization based on your children’s needs. While NPS and UPS have their benefits, they come with significant limitations such as lock-in periods, lower equity exposure, and annuity requirements.

For your children, mutual funds provide the best opportunity to maximize returns, meet future financial needs, and adapt to changing circumstances.

By working with a Certified Financial Planner, you can ensure that your investments are managed professionally, with regular monitoring and adjustments, helping you stay on track towards your children’s financial goals.

Finally, prioritize a diversified approach, balancing risk and reward, to secure a bright financial future for your children.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Latest Questions
Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |4488 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on May 06, 2025

Career
Sir , i got 67000crl rank and 20000obc rank in jee mains . I also got 18000 rank in vit. I am also going to write cusat, met and bitsat , i think i might not crack jee advance . i am hoping to pursue mechanical or electrical, Could sir kindly tell me its scope. From my current options which college should i choose among GFTI,s North east nits, VIT, MET, BITSAT for me to develop a good career
Ans: Rohan, considering your JEE performance, disregard BITSAT as it requires a minimum score of 250 out of 390 for admission into Mechanical Engineering or Electrical branches. Designate CUSAT as your primary selection if your Home State is Kerala and you qualify for OBC Category consideration. Compile a list of 4-5 esteemed colleges affiliated with CUSAT that possess commendable placement records. Secondly, prioritize GFTIs and North East NITs over alternatives such as VIT and MET. Regarding GFTIs and NITs, it is prudent to examine the placement records of the past three years and assess them prior to selecting preferences in JoSAA. Consider MET as your final alternative. Here is a step-by-step guide for predicting your chances of admission into NIT, IIIT, or GFTI following the JEE Main results.

Step 1: Collect Your Key Details
Before starting, note down the following details:

Your JEE Main percentile
Your category (General-Open, SC, ST, OBC-NCL, EWS, PwD categories)
Preferred institute types (NIT, IIIT, GFTI)
Preferred locations (or if you're open to any location in India)
List of at least 3 preferred academic programs (branches) as backups (instead of relying on just one option)
Step 2: Access JoSAA’s Official Opening & Closing Ranks
Go to Google and type: JoSAA Opening & Closing Ranks 2024
Click on the first search result (official JoSAA website).
You will land directly on JoSAA’s portal, where you can enter your details to check past-year cutoffs.
Step 3: Select the Round Number
JoSAA conducts five rounds of counseling.
For a safer estimate, choose Round 4, as most admissions are settled by this round.
Step 4: Choose the Institute Type
Select NIT, IIIT, or GFTI, depending on your preference.
If you are open to all types of institutes, check them one by one instead of selecting all at once.
Step 5: Select the Institute Name (Based on Location)
It is recommended to check institutes one by one, based on your preferred locations.
Avoid selecting ‘ALL’ at once, as it may create confusion.
Step 6: Select Your Preferred Academic Program (Branch)
Enter the branches you are interested in, one at a time, in your preferred order.
Step 7: Submit and Analyze Results
After selecting the relevant details, click the ‘SUBMIT’ button.
The system will display Opening & Closing Ranks of the selected institute and branch for different categories both Home State (HS) i.e. State you belong to & also Other State (OS).
Step 8: Note Down the Opening & Closing Ranks
Maintain a notebook or diary to record the Opening & Closing Ranks for each institute and branch you are interested in, separately for HS & OS Categories for a quick reference.
This will serve as a quick reference during JoSAA counseling.
Step 9: Adjust Your Expectations on a Safer Side
Since Opening & Closing Ranks fluctuate slightly each year, always adjust the numbers for safety.
Example Calculation:
If the Opening & Closing Ranks for NIT Delhi | Mechanical Engineering | OPEN Category show 8622 & 26186 (for Home State), consider adjusting them to 8300 & 23000 (on a safer side).
If the Female Category rank is 34334 & 36212, adjust it to 31000 & 33000.

Follow this approach for Other State candidates and different categories.
Pro Tip: Adjust your expected rank slightly lower than the previous year's cutoffs for realistic expectations during JoSAA counseling.

Can This Method Be Used for JEE April & JEE Advanced?
Yes! You can repeat the same steps after your April JEE Main results to refine your admission possibilities.
You can also follow a similar process for JEE Advanced cutoffs when applying for IITs.

Want to Learn More About JoSAA Counseling?
If you want detailed insights on JoSAA counseling, engineering entrance exams, preparation strategies, and engineering career options, check out EduJob360’s 180+ YouTube videos on this topic!

Hope this guide helps! All the best for your admissions!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know more on 'Careers | Health | Money | Relationships'.

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |4488 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on May 06, 2025

Career
what are the college options i can look up to at 91.8% in jee and 1.21 lakh crl
Ans: Valerica, Providing precise admission chances for each student can be challenging. Some reputed educational websites offer ‘College Predictor’ tools where you can check possible college options based on your percentile, category, and preferences. However, for a more accurate understanding, here’s a simple yet effective 9-step method using JoSAA’s past-year opening and closing ranks. This approach gives you a fair estimate (though not 100% exact) of your admission chances based on the previous year’s data.

Here is, How to Predict Your Chances of Admission into NIT or IIIT or GFTI After JEE Main Results – A Step-by-Step Guide.

Step-by-Step Guide to Check Your Admission Chances Using JoSAA Data
Step 1: Collect Your Key Details
Before starting, note down the following details:

Your JEE Main percentile
Your category (General-Open, SC, ST, OBC-NCL, EWS, PwD categories)
Preferred institute types (NIT, IIIT, GFTI)
Preferred locations (or if you're open to any location in India)
List of at least 3 preferred academic programs (branches) as backups (instead of relying on just one option)
Step 2: Access JoSAA’s Official Opening & Closing Ranks
Go to Google and type: JoSAA Opening & Closing Ranks 2024
Click on the first search result (official JoSAA website).
You will land directly on JoSAA’s portal, where you can enter your details to check past-year cutoffs.
Step 3: Select the Round Number
JoSAA conducts five rounds of counseling.
For a safer estimate, choose Round 4, as most admissions are settled by this round.
Step 4: Choose the Institute Type
Select NIT, IIIT, or GFTI, depending on your preference.
If you are open to all types of institutes, check them one by one instead of selecting all at once.
Step 5: Select the Institute Name (Based on Location)
It is recommended to check institutes one by one, based on your preferred locations.
Avoid selecting ‘ALL’ at once, as it may create confusion.
Step 6: Select Your Preferred Academic Program (Branch)
Enter the branches you are interested in, one at a time, in your preferred order.
Step 7: Submit and Analyze Results
After selecting the relevant details, click the ‘SUBMIT’ button.
The system will display Opening & Closing Ranks of the selected institute and branch for different categories both Home State (HS) i.e. State you belong to & also Other State (OS).
Step 8: Note Down the Opening & Closing Ranks
Maintain a notebook or diary to record the Opening & Closing Ranks for each institute and branch you are interested in, separately for HS & OS Categories for a quick reference.
This will serve as a quick reference during JoSAA counseling.
Step 9: Adjust Your Expectations on a Safer Side
Since Opening & Closing Ranks fluctuate slightly each year, always adjust the numbers for safety.
Example Calculation:
If the Opening & Closing Ranks for NIT Delhi | Mechanical Engineering | OPEN Category show 8622 & 26186 (for Home State), consider adjusting them to 8300 & 23000 (on a safer side).
If the Female Category rank is 34334 & 36212, adjust it to 31000 & 33000.

Follow this approach for Other State candidates and different categories.
Pro Tip: Adjust your expected rank slightly lower than the previous year's cutoffs for realistic expectations during JoSAA counseling.

Can This Method Be Used for JEE April & JEE Advanced?
Yes! You can repeat the same steps after your April JEE Main results to refine your admission possibilities.
You can also follow a similar process for JEE Advanced cutoffs when applying for IITs.

Want to Learn More About JoSAA Counseling?
If you want detailed insights on JoSAA counseling, engineering entrance exams, preparation strategies, and engineering career options, check out EduJob360’s 180+ YouTube videos on this topic!

Hope this guide helps! All the best for your admissions!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know more on 'Careers | Health | Money | Relationships'.

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x