Hi Sir, Iam 44 and have the below funds from 3 years
1) icici pru multiasset fund
2) icici pru value discovery fund
3) icici pru thematic advantage fund
4) hdfc 30 focus fund
my question is
1) should i continue sip 20000 P/M for the next 3 years in all the above fund.
2) should i invest in midcap fund? if yes can u suggest me any hdfc midcap?
thanks
thanks
Ans: At 44, you are at a very important stage of your financial life. You still have time to grow your wealth but need to focus more on protection, risk control, and clear goal planning.
Your discipline in investing Rs. 20,000 every month for 3 years is good. That is already Rs. 7.2 lakhs invested so far. You also seem to prefer a single AMC which makes review easier. Let's evaluate your investment choices and your future path.
Fund Choices Review – Strengths and Gaps
You are investing in these four funds:
ICICI Pru Multi Asset
ICICI Pru Value Discovery
ICICI Pru Thematic Advantage
HDFC Focused 30 Fund
Assessment:
You have a mix of multi-asset, value style, thematic, and focused equity
That is some diversification, but with overlaps and some concentration
All funds are from large AMCs, which is safe
These funds are active in style, which is good
They are managed by expert fund managers
You are not investing in index funds. That is correct
Index funds only copy the market. They don’t beat it
They offer no protection in volatile markets
You also avoided direct funds. That is wise
Direct funds give no guidance or regular review
Regular funds with a Certified Financial Planner help with tracking and changes
You need help in knowing when to switch or hold
Evaluation of SIP Continuation
You are investing Rs. 5,000 each in four funds. Total Rs. 20,000 per month.
Key Observations:
You have already stayed for 3 years
That means you crossed one full market cycle
All these funds are equity-heavy
Three more years of SIP is a good plan
But the future allocation needs to match your goals
Simply extending SIP without goal clarity is not safe
You should not just look at past return
Instead, match each fund to your need
Action Plan:
Yes, you can continue Rs. 20,000 SIP
But review which fund supports which goal
Multi-asset is good for medium-term goals
Value fund can support retirement with patience
Thematic fund is high-risk. Keep exposure limited
Focused fund is fine but may be volatile
Thematic Fund Caution
Thematic funds invest in specific sectors
If that sector is weak, fund may underperform
Returns will be very up-and-down
Don’t put more money here unless you understand the theme
Better reduce SIP in this fund
Shift that SIP to a balanced or midcap fund instead
This makes the portfolio more stable
Should You Invest in Midcap Fund?
This is your next question. Yes, midcap funds can be added.
But first check:
Are your basic goals funded already?
Do you have term and health insurance?
Is your emergency fund ready?
Are you clear about retirement target?
Only after all this, add new risk-oriented fund
If your base is strong, then midcap is good for growth. But keep in mind:
Midcap funds are more volatile than largecap
They give better return only over 7+ years
Not suitable for short-term goals
You must stay invested even during downturns
HDFC Midcap Fund is one option.
It is an actively managed fund
It suits investors with high risk tolerance
You can start with Rs. 3,000 to Rs. 5,000 monthly
Increase if you see good behaviour in the fund
Don’t expect returns every year
Midcaps move in cycles. Long patience is key
Suggested Fund Positioning
Here is one simple way to allocate your Rs. 20,000:
Rs. 5,000 – Multi Asset (medium-term goal)
Rs. 5,000 – Value Discovery (retirement corpus)
Rs. 5,000 – Focused Fund (long-term wealth creation)
Rs. 5,000 – HDFC Midcap Fund (new SIP for growth)
Stop new SIP in thematic fund and switch that amount here
This gives better balance. It also reduces portfolio risk.
Goal Mapping for Better Clarity
At 44, you need clear goal-linked planning.
Break your goals into three:
Short-Term (3–5 years): Travel, child’s college, house repair
Medium-Term (5–10 years): Child’s higher education
Long-Term (15+ years): Retirement, child’s wedding
Match funds to these goals:
Multi-asset fund for short to medium term
Value and focused funds for long-term needs
Midcap for wealth building and retirement booster
If you don’t link funds to goals, you may exit early during panic. That destroys wealth.
Asset Allocation Is Important
All your funds are equity-based. That is risky if not planned well.
Suggestion:
Keep 15–20% of portfolio in debt instruments
Use ultra-short mutual funds or FD for that
Equity should be 70–80%, not full 100%
Balanced investing keeps emotions under control
Talk to a Certified Financial Planner for proper allocation review
Insurance Protection
You didn’t mention about term or health insurance. That’s very important.
Take the following steps:
Buy term insurance of at least Rs. 1 crore
Cover should be for 60 years of age
Don’t mix insurance and investment
Avoid ULIPs, endowment or money-back plans
They reduce return and give low cover
Also take health insurance of Rs. 5–10 lakhs
Don’t rely only on employer health policy
Emergency Fund Readiness
If you don’t have an emergency fund, build it now.
Keep 6 to 9 months of expenses in a separate bank or liquid fund
Don’t keep it in the same place as investments
Don’t use mutual funds for emergency
FD or liquid fund is better for this
This gives peace during job loss or health issues
Tax Impact Awareness
When you sell equity mutual funds:
Long-term capital gain above Rs. 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%
Short-term gain is taxed at 20%
For debt funds, gain is taxed at your slab rate
So, don’t churn funds often. Long holding is tax friendly.
Behaviour Management Is Key
At this stage, fund selection is only part of the story.
Don’t panic during market fall
Stay focused on goals
Don’t redeem during dips
Review your portfolio once in 6 months
Avoid frequent switching of funds
Work with a Certified Financial Planner to avoid emotional decisions
Don’t track NAV every day
Monitoring and Future Steps
Keep a separate paper or file for each goal
Write the SIP amount and purpose
Add expected amount needed and timeline
This keeps you accountable
Update fund performance every 6 months
If a fund lags for 2+ years, review with planner
Don’t stop SIP just because market falls
What You’re Doing Right
Regular SIP of Rs. 20,000 is a good habit
Investing in active funds is a smart move
Avoiding index and direct plans is wise
Staying invested for 3 years shows discipline
Thinking about adding midcap shows growth mindset
You are asking the right questions
Finally
You are on the right path.
You have built good habits already.
Now bring more structure and goal linking.
Add a midcap fund only if your foundation is ready.
Reduce thematic exposure unless you understand it deeply.
Don’t chase past returns. Stick to plans.
Focus on your goals, not the market.
Protect yourself with insurance and emergency fund.
Review SIPs every 6 months with a Certified Financial Planner.
Be patient. Your wealth will grow.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment