Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Sanjeev

Sanjeev Govila  | Answer  |Ask -

Financial Planner - Answered on Mar 28, 2024

Colonel Sanjeev Govila (retd) is the founder of Hum Fauji Initiatives, a financial planning company dedicated to the armed forces personnel and their families.
He has over 12 years of experience in financial planning and is a SEBI certified registered investment advisor; he is also accredited with AMFI and IRDA.... more
Asked by Anonymous - Mar 11, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money

I have hdfc small cap, multicap, flexicap funds all direct. Since the mid and small cap segment is overheated, can I invest in hdfc nifty 250 small cap index fund and nifty 150 midcap index fund now?

Ans: As you already have investment in HDFC mid, small and flexi cap funds, we do not suggest you to start your investment in index fund.

Index fund is replica of the index and it passively managed by the fund manager. They are designed to match the market, not outperform it. So, if you're looking for explosive growth, an actively managed fund might be a better option.

As you have investment only in HDFC AMC, we suggest you to diversify your investment across the AMCs (Asset Management Company). It will help you to reduce the Concentration Risk in your portfolio and provide the necessary diversification to your portfolio.
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10848 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 29, 2024

Listen
Money
Hi sir ,please advise me iam having axis blue chip fund(G), ICICI Pru Value discovery fund(G),Mirae Asset Large cap (g),Motilal Osawal Nifty bank index fund (G),Quant active fund (G), SBI flexi cap fund , can i continue above funds ,please advise me
Ans: Evaluating Your Mutual Fund Portfolio for Optimal Performance

Your existing portfolio comprises a mix of equity and index funds, reflecting a diversified approach to investment. Let's assess each fund's performance and suitability to determine whether to continue or make any adjustments.

Analyzing Your Current Holdings

Axis Blue Chip Fund, ICICI Pru Value Discovery Fund, Mirae Asset Large Cap Fund, SBI Flexi Cap Fund, and Quant Active Fund offer exposure to various segments of the equity market, providing diversification benefits.

Motilal Oswal Nifty Bank Index Fund focuses on tracking the performance of the Nifty Bank Index, offering exposure to the banking sector.

Performance Evaluation

Evaluate each fund's historical performance relative to its benchmark and peer group. Assess factors such as consistency of returns, risk-adjusted performance, and fund manager expertise.

Consider the fund's investment strategy, portfolio composition, and expense ratio. Ensure alignment with your risk tolerance and investment objectives.

Identifying Areas for Potential Adjustment

Overlapping Holdings: Review your portfolio for any overlapping holdings or duplicate exposures across funds. Consolidate similar investments to streamline your portfolio and optimize diversification.

Underperforming Funds: Identify any funds that consistently underperform their benchmarks or peers. Consider replacing them with alternatives that offer better prospects for growth and align with your investment goals.

Asset Allocation: Maintain a balanced asset allocation across different fund categories to manage risk effectively and achieve your long-term financial goals.

Recommendations

Continue Well-Performing Funds: Retain funds that have demonstrated consistent performance, robust fundamentals, and alignment with your risk profile. These funds contribute to diversification and long-term growth potential.

Review Underperforming Funds: Evaluate underperforming funds and consider replacing them with better alternatives. Focus on funds with strong track records, experienced fund managers, and clear investment strategies.

Seek Professional Guidance: Consult with a Certified Financial Planner to review your portfolio, identify areas for improvement, and develop a personalized investment strategy. Professional guidance can help optimize your portfolio and maximize returns over time.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10848 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 09, 2024

Listen
Money
Sir, i have been investing in Large cap direct MF , shall i close them and move to largege cap index fund ? Same startegy for mid , small and mirco cap ?
Ans: Transitioning from actively managed mutual funds to index funds requires careful consideration of your investment objectives, risk tolerance, and market dynamics.

While index funds offer lower expense ratios and passive management, they may not always outperform actively managed funds, especially during market fluctuations or when specific sectors outperform the broader market.

Here's a breakdown of factors to consider:

Large Cap Funds: If your large-cap direct mutual funds have consistently underperformed their benchmark indices, or if you prefer a more passive approach with lower costs, transitioning to large-cap index funds could be an option. However, ensure you understand the implications of switching, including potential tax consequences and performance variations.
Mid, Small, and Micro Cap Funds: These segments of the market often require active management to identify promising opportunities and manage risks effectively. While index funds may provide broad exposure, actively managed funds can capitalize on market inefficiencies and deliver potentially higher returns. Evaluate the track record of your existing funds and consider consulting a Certified Financial Planner to determine the best approach based on your investment goals and risk profile.
When transitioning between funds, consider the following:

Tax Implications: Exiting existing investments may trigger capital gains tax liabilities. Assess the tax implications of switching funds and evaluate whether the potential benefits outweigh the costs.
Performance Comparison: Compare the historical performance of your current funds with relevant index benchmarks. Evaluate factors such as consistency, risk-adjusted returns, and fund manager expertise before making a decision.
Cost Analysis: Consider the impact of expense ratios and transaction costs on your investment returns. While index funds typically have lower costs, ensure that the benefits justify any potential performance trade-offs.
Diversification: Review your overall portfolio diversification and ensure that any changes align with your asset allocation strategy and long-term financial goals.
Ultimately, the decision to switch from actively managed funds to index funds should be based on a thorough assessment of your individual circumstances and investment objectives. Consulting with a Certified Financial Planner can provide valuable insights and personalized guidance tailored to your specific needs.

there are some advantages to consider direct funds, and the cost savings can be significant in the long run. However, there are some potential benefits to using a regular MFD:

Advantages of Investing Through a Mutual Fund Distributor (MFD):

Personalized Advice: MFDs can be helpful for beginners or those who lack investment knowledge. They can assess your risk tolerance, financial goals, and investment horizon to recommend suitable mutual funds. This personalized guidance can be valuable, especially if you're new to investing.
Convenience: MFDs handle all the paperwork and transactions on your behalf, saving you time and effort. They can help with account setup, SIP registrations, and managing your portfolio across different funds.
Investor Support: MFDs can be a point of contact for any questions or concerns you may have about your investments. They can provide ongoing support and guidance throughout your investment journey.


Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Moneywize

Moneywize   | Answer  |Ask -

Financial Planner - Answered on Mar 10, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Mar 09, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
I have been investing in mid-cap MFs. Shall I close them and move to index funds as market looks overheated? Same startegy for small and mirco-cap MFs?
Ans: Deciding whether to switch from mid-cap mutual funds (MFs) to index funds depends on several factors, and the current market condition (overheated or not) is just one piece of the puzzle. Here's a breakdown to help you decide:

Mid-Cap vs Index Funds:

• Risk: Mid-cap funds generally involve higher risk than index funds. Mid-cap companies are more volatile, so the fund's value can fluctuate more significantly. Index funds, by nature, tend to mirror the market, offering a more stable ride.
• Return Potential: Historically, mid-cap funds have offered the potential for higher returns than index funds. However, this is not guaranteed, and past performance doesn't necessarily predict future results.
• Management: Mid-cap funds are actively managed, meaning a fund manager tries to pick stocks that will outperform the market. Index funds are passively managed, simply tracking a specific market index.

Current Market Conditions:

Overheated Market: If you believe the market is overheated, there could be some logic in moving to a less volatile option like an index fund. However, trying to time the market can be difficult, and you risk missing out on potential gains if the market continues to rise.

Other Factors to Consider:

• Investment Timeframe: If you have a long-term investment horizon (over 5 years), you may be able to stomach the volatility of mid-cap funds. However, if you need your money in the short term, index funds might be a safer option.
• Risk Tolerance: How comfortable are you with potential losses? If you can't handle large swings in your portfolio value, index funds might be a better fit.
• Your Investment Goals: What are you hoping to achieve with your investments?

Small and Micro-Cap MFs:

The same logic applies to small and micro-cap MFs. They generally involve even higher risk than mid-cap funds but also have the potential for even higher returns. Carefully consider your risk tolerance and investment goals before investing in them.

Here are some recommendations:

• Do your research: Learn more about mid-cap vs index funds and understand the risks involved in each.
• Consult a financial advisor: A professional advisor can help you assess your individual situation and make informed investment decisions.
• Consider a diversified portfolio: You don't have to choose between all mid-cap or all index funds. You can have a mix of both in your portfolio to balance risk and reward.

Ultimately, the decision of whether to switch from mid-cap MFs to index funds is up to you. By considering all the factors involved, you can make an informed choice that aligns with your investment goals and risk tolerance.

..Read more

Latest Questions
Anu

Anu Krishna  |1734 Answers  |Ask -

Relationships Expert, Mind Coach - Answered on Nov 18, 2025

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10848 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Nov 17, 2025

Money
Dear Sir, What is the best % of SWP one can think of from Portfolio value. I am retired now and have say 1 Cr as MF and Share portfolio. I want to go for 40000 SWP per month thereby making 4.8% as SWP. If this is good to have this for 15 yrs
Ans: Your question shows great care for your financial future. Many retirees ignore this step. You have already taken a wise move. You want steady income. You want safety. You want long life for your money. These are very important points. I truly appreciate your clarity.

» Understanding your present plan
Your idea is simple. You have Rs 1 crore. You want Rs 40000 each month. This means Rs 4.8 lakh each year. That is 4.8 percent of your money. This is not very high. This is not very low. It sits in the middle range. Many retirees try for 7 or 8 percent. That can put pressure on the portfolio. Your 4.8 percent is more reasonable. It supports discipline. It keeps stress low.

Your idea is for 15 years. That is a good time frame. It gives space for your funds to grow. It gives time for market cycles. It also gives time for inflation adjustments.

» Why withdrawal rate matters
Your SWP rate decides how long your money will last. A high rate can drain funds soon. A very low rate may not support your monthly needs. Your 4.8 percent sits well. It balances life needs and portfolio health.

When you draw money from a mixed portfolio, the growth side helps refill your withdrawn money. The stability side helps reduce fall during bad years. This mix helps the SWP stay steady.

» Why a proper structure is important
A SWP is not only a monthly withdrawal. It is a full system. The system needs planning. It needs regular reviews. It needs a clear asset split. It needs a cushion for weak market years.

If you set this structure well now, your SWP can stay safe. Your money can stretch for many years. You can keep peace of mind.

» The importance of a balanced mix
Your portfolio may hold equity funds, hybrid funds, and debt funds. A clear mix reduces risk. It gives smooth cash flow. Equity gives growth. Debt gives steady flow. Hybrid gives balance.

Because you want monthly income for 15 years, you need a balance that supports steady SWP. A pure equity plan can shake too much. A pure debt plan may not grow at a good pace. A balanced mix is ideal.

» Equity funds need careful use
Some investors put large money in equity for SWP. This can work in strong markets. This can fail in weak markets. Your SWP must survive both market moods. That is why pure equity for SWP is not safe.

Also, you should prefer actively managed funds over index funds for long SWP. Index funds follow the index blindly. They do not manage risk actively. They cannot adjust to market cycles. Actively managed funds have a professional fund manager. A skilled manager helps in limiting risk in low years. This helps protect principal in SWP years. This support is not present in index funds.

» Debt funds form the stabiliser
Debt funds bring peace to the portfolio. They help during bad market years. They help the SWP stay steady. Because debt funds follow market rates, they work as the anchor. For SWP, this anchor is very helpful.

If you use direct debt funds, you must remember that direct funds need more tracking. They need active reviews by you. Many retired investors find this hard. Regular plans taken through a qualified Mutual Fund Distributor with CFP skill provide guidance. Regular plans also give handholding. This handholding helps avoid wrong exits.

» How to view your Rs 40000 monthly need
You may need some money for basic needs. You may need some money for health care. You may need some money for family support. You may need some money for personal comfort. Rs 40000 per month seems a balanced number.

It does not put too much pressure on the money. It is not a very heavy load. It fits well with a Rs 1 crore fund.

» Inflation needs attention
Inflation will rise. Costs will rise. Your need will rise. Your SWP should rise slowly over time. You cannot fix your SWP for 15 years at one number. That may reduce your buying power.

A small rise every two or three years will help you beat inflation. This rise must be slow. It must match your portfolio growth.

» Risk of sharp market falls
Sharp falls can disturb SWP. A sudden big drop in equity value can pull down your portfolio. This may cause you to withdraw when market is low. That is not good. To fix this, you need enough stability in your mix.

A proper allocation in debt funds and hybrid funds can reduce this issue. You will get smoother cash flow. You will not have to worry about market news every day.

» Role of emergency money
Please keep an emergency amount. Keep this aside. Do not include it in your SWP plan. You may need money for urgent health needs. You may need money for home needs. Emergency funds help you avoid sudden selling.

A good emergency fund gives peace. It protects your SWP from sudden shocks.

» Tax rules for withdrawals
Every SWP withdrawal may include some gains. Tax will apply based on the type of fund and the gain period. This tax can have impact on net flow. You must plan for this in your withdrawal design.

Equity fund rules:

Gains under one year are short-term. These are taxed at 20 percent.

Gains above one year are long-term. Long-term gains above Rs 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5 percent.

Debt fund rules:

Both short-term and long-term gains are taxed as per your tax slab.

This tax part should not scare you. A proper plan can reduce the tax burden. A planned SWP can help you manage gains carefully.

» Why a Certified Financial Planner helps
You may handle small things by yourself. But retirement planning is delicate. One wrong move can disturb the whole plan. A Certified Financial Planner gives a clear road map. He helps you set the best mix. He reviews the plan every year. He adjusts the plan for market and life events.

This guidance is very useful in SWP because SWP needs discipline.

» Why not consider real estate
Some retirees think of using real estate for income. But real estate needs heavy work. It needs tenant work. It needs repair work. It needs legal care. It gives lumpy income. It gives no steady flow. So it is not fit for SWP planning.

Your present goal is steady income. Real estate will not give this.

» Why not consider annuities
Annuities give fixed income. But they lock your money. They give low returns. They do not beat inflation well. They reduce flexibility. For these reasons, they are not ideal for your long-term income.

Your idea of SWP with balanced mix is better.

» Keeping your portfolio healthy for 15 years
To keep your portfolio safe for 15 years, you must follow some habits:

Review every year with a Certified Financial Planner.

Adjust asset mix if needed.

Increase SWP amount slowly.

Reduce SWP for one or two years if markets fall very deep.

Protect your money from emotional moves.

Keep a two-year buffer in a low-risk fund.

Keep your growth part running for long.

These habits help your money last for the full 15-year horizon.

» Regular review helps you adapt
Markets will change. Your health may change. Your needs may change. A yearly review will help align your plan. It will help spot issues early. It will help guide the next year’s SWP.

Without reviews, even good plans can fail.

» Why a two-year cushion helps
A cushion fund is a simple idea. Keep two years of SWP in a low-risk debt fund. This money helps you draw income even in bad market years. You will not need to sell equity in weak phases. This protects your overall money. This makes your SWP more stable.

This cushion fund is an extra shield. It supports your 15-year income plan.

» Role of diversification
Your SWP works best when your portfolio is spread well. A spread can include:

Actively managed equity funds.

Hybrid funds.

Debt funds.

This spread reduces risk. It gives smoothness. It supports long-term income.

Avoid using too many funds. Keep it simple. A small number of quality funds is better.

» How your 4.8 percent looks in practice
A 4.8 percent withdrawal rate is comfortable for a 15-year horizon. If you follow discipline, your money will not face heavy pressure. If your portfolio grows at a steady pace, your principal will not erode fast. Even if growth shifts between years, the mixed structure will protect you.

Your plan is workable. It is sensible. It is future-friendly.

» Mistakes to avoid
Here are some mistakes you should avoid:

Do not chase high-return funds.

Do not raise SWP sharply in one year.

Do not keep too much money in equity.

Do not stop reviews.

Do not shift funds often without reason.

Do not look at direct plans if you prefer guidance.

These mistakes can disturb your portfolio health. Your SWP may suffer.

» Why not use direct funds if you need support
Direct plans give lower cost. But they give no guidance. Retired investors often need guidance. They need reviews. They need discipline. A regular plan through a qualified Mutual Fund Distributor with CFP skill gives support. It prevents panic reactions. This support is valuable in low market years.

» Healthy mindset for SWP
Try to see your SWP as a long journey. It needs calm mind. It needs steady steps. It needs slow corrections. It needs patience. If you stay steady, your SWP will stay healthy. You will enjoy peace.

» Practical steps you can start now
You may start with these steps:

Set clear needs for each year.

Fix a proper asset split.

Create a cushion fund for two years.

Start SWP from a low-risk fund or hybrid fund.

Keep equity for growth.

Add small hikes in SWP every few years.

This system supports long-term income.

» How your plan supports a joyful retired life
Your plan helps you live with comfort. It gives predictable cash flow. It gives you freedom from worry. It gives you clarity. You can focus on health, family, and peace. You do not need to watch markets each day.

Your retirement life becomes balanced.

» Final Insights
Your idea of taking Rs 40000 per month from a Rs 1 crore portfolio at 4.8 percent is workable. It fits well for a 15-year horizon. It supports your income. It protects your money if you set a balanced mix. You must follow steady reviews. You must keep a small cushion. You must avoid risky moves.

With these practices, your SWP plan can stay healthy for many years. Your future can stay peaceful and steady. You have already taken the right first step. Your clarity gives your plan strong power.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Dr Nagarajan J S K

Dr Nagarajan J S K   |2567 Answers  |Ask -

NEET, Medical, Pharmacy Careers - Answered on Nov 17, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Nov 17, 2025Hindi
Career
Is it worthwhile being an mbbs only doctor in India or is pg necessary as somebody who cannot toil 24-36 hours (as is the case with hospital duties) and is not well adequate for working under somebody and then do you still have to study after mbbs to level up or will you be contented with just mbbs. Pls don't answer objectively i really need to see the real picture
Ans: Hi Dr.
Recently, I've seen many different comments on social media suggesting that finding a job after completing an MBBS is very difficult, with some graduates even working as delivery boys.

I believe MBBS is one of the few courses that allows for immediate entrepreneurship after graduation, while other fields often require additional support to start a business. Many medical shop owners are willing to provide a small space for consultations, which is not typically an option for graduates in other disciplines.

If you are financially constrained, it may be wise to stop after completing your MBBS degree for the time being. However, pursuing a postgraduate degree (PG) significantly increases your opportunities, including potential roles in the pharmaceutical industry. Without a PG, your options may be limited. It's akin to the difference between a normal grocery store and a supermarket: completing a PG can lead to positions in corporate medical hospitals.

Initially, you might consider working at a smaller practice or in the government sector before pursuing higher education. While having an MBBS degree allows you to offer consultations, having a PG provides you with more credibility and knowledge. Understand your strengths and weaknesses, and don’t worry about others—proceed based on your own abilities and circumstances.
BEST WISHES.

...Read more

Dr Nagarajan J S K

Dr Nagarajan J S K   |2567 Answers  |Ask -

NEET, Medical, Pharmacy Careers - Answered on Nov 17, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Nov 15, 2025Hindi
Career
I have passed 12th from Maharashtra state board in 2023 ( as regular candidate ) and also gave improvement exam in Feb 2024 but I am not satisfied with my result can I give 12th board exam again from Maharashtra board as a private candidate 17 no. Form ??? I am already 12th passed so Is it illegal to appear from 17 no. Form ?
Ans: Hi,
Hi, what are your future plans? Please share so I can suggest a solution for you.
best regards

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x