30 year old with loan dilemma: Invest more or pay off debt?

Ans: You're 30 years old and actively investing in mutual funds (MF), stocks, and cryptocurrency, with a SIP of Rs 20,000 per month. You're also considering increasing your SIP to Rs 40,000. You have a loan of Rs 24 lakhs at an interest rate of 8.60%.

Before making a decision, it's important to take a close look at your financial situation.

Loan Repayment vs. Increased SIP
Interest Rate on Loan: The interest rate of 8.60% on your loan is moderate. Paying off this loan will give you a guaranteed return equivalent to this rate. This is because every rupee you repay saves you from paying 8.60% in interest.

Expected Returns on Investments: Investments in mutual funds, stocks, and even cryptocurrency can potentially give you returns higher than 8.60%. However, these returns are not guaranteed and carry a certain level of risk.

Risk Appetite: Your ability to handle financial risk plays a crucial role in this decision. If you're comfortable with some volatility and risk, you may choose to invest more. However, if you're risk-averse, clearing your loan may provide peace of mind.

Debt-Free Living: Being debt-free is a huge financial relief. Clearing your loan would remove the burden of monthly EMI payments. This would free up more of your income for other purposes in the future.

Assessing the Impact of Increasing SIP
Long-Term Wealth Creation: Increasing your SIP to Rs 40,000 will likely accelerate your wealth creation. If the market performs well, you could see significant growth in your investments over the years.

Power of Compounding: By increasing your SIP, you're leveraging the power of compounding. This could result in exponential growth of your investments in the long term. Even small increments in SIP can have a substantial impact over time.

Diversification Benefits: By increasing your SIP, you can potentially diversify more into different funds, reducing overall risk. A well-diversified portfolio can help balance out market volatility.

Weighing the Emotional and Psychological Aspects
Debt Stress: Carrying a loan can be mentally taxing. The pressure of owing money can sometimes outweigh the potential benefits of investing. Clearing your loan can relieve this stress and give you financial freedom.

Investment Uncertainty: The stock market and other investments are inherently unpredictable. There might be market corrections or downturns, and this could affect your returns. If this uncertainty worries you, paying off the loan might be the better option.

Confidence in Investment Strategy: If you have confidence in your current investment strategy and believe in the potential of your chosen funds, increasing your SIP can be a sound decision. But ensure you’re ready for the ups and downs of the market.

Analytical Insights: Pros and Cons
Increasing SIP Pros:

Potentially higher long-term returns.
Leverages the power of compounding.
Greater diversification opportunities.
Increasing SIP Cons:

Market risk and volatility.
Continued loan repayment obligation.
Loan Repayment Pros:

Guaranteed savings at 8.60%.
Debt-free living.
Reduced financial stress.
Loan Repayment Cons:

Opportunity cost of not investing more in the market.
Slower wealth accumulation in the short term.
Impact on Your Future Financial Goals
Early Loan Repayment: If you prioritize paying off your loan, you may achieve a debt-free status sooner. This could open up more opportunities for investment in the future, as all your income will be available for wealth creation.

Increased SIP for Future Growth: If you choose to increase your SIP, you're aiming for larger growth in your portfolio. This could help you reach financial goals like retirement, buying a home, or funding education more quickly.

Considerations for Making a Decision
Current Financial Stability: Assess your current financial situation. Do you have an emergency fund? Are you able to comfortably meet your monthly expenses while increasing your SIP?

Life Stage and Goals: Consider your life stage and financial goals. If you have major life events coming up, like buying a house or planning for children’s education, these will influence your decision.

Loan Tenure: The remaining tenure of your loan is crucial. If you have a long tenure left, paying off the loan early might make more sense. However, if the tenure is short, focusing on investment might be more beneficial.

Final Insights
Balanced Approach: You might consider a balanced approach, where you increase your SIP but also make occasional extra payments towards your loan. This way, you can grow your investments while gradually reducing your debt.

Emergency Fund Importance: Ensure you have an emergency fund before committing to either option. This fund should cover at least 6 months of expenses, providing a safety net in case of unexpected financial needs.

Consult a Certified Financial Planner: Though you are well-informed, it could be beneficial to discuss your situation with a Certified Financial Planner. They can provide personalized advice based on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and current financial status.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in