Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Sanjeev

Sanjeev Govila  | Answer  |Ask -

Financial Planner - Answered on May 19, 2023

Colonel Sanjeev Govila (retd) is the founder of Hum Fauji Initiatives, a financial planning company dedicated to the armed forces personnel and their families.
He has over 12 years of experience in financial planning and is a SEBI certified registered investment advisor; he is also accredited with AMFI and IRDA.... more
Sanjiv Question by Sanjiv on May 16, 2023Hindi
Listen
Money

Which is better an actively managed mutual fund or a passive(index fund)mutual fund and why?

Ans: There is nothing like anything being better in general or across the board. It entirely depends on what part of your portfolio are you referring to?

Large cap funds are facing a tough ‘competition’ from Index Funds due to two main reasons. First, Large cap funds can only invest in top 100 stocks of the market as per market capitalisation and that is where Index too is. The index keeps rejigging itself based on various parameters and generally it has been seen that most of the Large Cap funds too get invested in similar good stocks, leaving hardly any difference between the percentage-wise investment of the two.

And the Second reason is the one that makes the difference – the expenses that are charged by the two. Since an Index fund is a passive one with hardly any ‘management’ being done by the fund manager except tracking the index accurately, it charges very less expenses. On the other hand, Large cap funds have active monitoring and efforts involved and hence, more charges are there.

So it is quite common for an Index fund to outperform a Large cap fund in many cases.

The same logic does not stand true for other categories like midcap and small cap where the universe of stocks to be selected is vast and most of the time, passive funds lag quite behind the active funds in selection of the right stocks.
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7101 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 06, 2024

Listen
Money
In mutual fund investments, specially for MIDCAP and SMALLCAP category , which type is better option, INDEX or Actively managed funds ?
Ans: When it comes to mutual fund investments in the midcap and smallcap categories, actively managed funds tend to be a better option compared to index funds. Here's why:

Potential for Higher Returns: Actively managed funds are overseen by experienced fund managers who aim to outperform the benchmark indices by carefully selecting investments based on in-depth research and analysis. This active management approach can potentially lead to higher returns, especially in volatile and less efficient market segments like midcap and smallcap stocks.
Flexibility and Adaptability: Active fund managers have the flexibility to adjust their investment strategies based on changing market conditions, economic trends, and company-specific factors. This agility allows them to capitalize on emerging opportunities and navigate through market downturns more effectively than index funds, which passively track predefined benchmarks.
Alpha Generation: Actively managed funds strive to generate alpha, which represents the excess return earned by the fund compared to its benchmark index. Skilled fund managers use their expertise and judgment to identify undervalued stocks, exploit market inefficiencies, and capitalize on growth prospects, thereby potentially enhancing the fund's performance and delivering superior returns over the long term.
Research and Expertise: Actively managed funds typically employ dedicated teams of research analysts and investment professionals who conduct thorough fundamental analysis, company visits, and market research to identify promising investment opportunities. This active research-driven approach enables fund managers to make informed investment decisions and construct well-diversified portfolios tailored to specific investment objectives and risk profiles.
Potential for Risk Management: In volatile market segments like midcap and smallcap stocks, active management can provide an added layer of risk management through selective stock picking, sector rotation, and portfolio diversification. Fund managers aim to mitigate downside risks and preserve capital by actively monitoring and adjusting portfolio allocations based on risk-return considerations and market dynamics.
In summary, while index funds offer cost-effective and passive exposure to broad market indices, actively managed funds have the potential to outperform benchmarks and generate superior returns through active stock selection, research-driven strategies, and skilled fund management. Therefore, for investors seeking to capitalize on the growth opportunities in midcap and smallcap segments, actively managed funds are generally considered a preferable option over index funds.

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7101 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 31, 2024

Money
In long Term investment prospective Which funds are better Active funds or Passive funds.?
Ans: In the dynamic world of investment, selecting the right type of fund is crucial for long-term growth. The debate between active and passive funds is ongoing. However, from a long-term investment perspective, active funds have distinct advantages. This analysis will elucidate why active funds are a superior choice.

Active Fund Management: Expertise and Strategy
Active funds are managed by professional fund managers who actively make investment decisions. These managers employ their expertise and in-depth research to select securities. This hands-on approach can potentially outperform the market.

Expertise Matters
Certified Financial Planners (CFPs) managing active funds bring a wealth of experience. They analyze market trends, economic indicators, and company performance. This expertise is crucial in navigating market volatility and making informed investment decisions.

Strategic Flexibility
Active fund managers have the flexibility to adjust the portfolio based on market conditions. This adaptability is vital in responding to market changes, seizing opportunities, and mitigating risks. Passive funds, in contrast, follow a fixed index, lacking this strategic flexibility.

Potential for Higher Returns
Active funds aim to outperform market indices. While this involves higher risk, the potential for higher returns is significant. Skilled fund managers can identify undervalued stocks and capitalize on market inefficiencies.

Outperformance in Volatile Markets
During market downturns, active funds can outperform passive funds. Fund managers can shift assets to safer investments or take advantage of undervalued opportunities. Passive funds, which track indices, are more likely to follow the market down.

Diversification Benefits
Active fund managers can diversify investments across various sectors and asset classes. This diversification can reduce risk and enhance returns. Passive funds, limited to the index composition, may not offer the same level of diversification.

Personalized Investment Strategies
Active funds offer tailored investment strategies aligned with investors’ goals. Fund managers can adjust the portfolio to match the investor’s risk tolerance, time horizon, and financial objectives.

Customized Risk Management
Active fund managers can implement specific risk management strategies. These strategies can protect against market volatility and downturns. Passive funds, which replicate an index, do not offer this level of customization.

Goal-Oriented Investing
Investors have unique financial goals, such as retirement planning or wealth accumulation. Active fund managers can create a portfolio that aligns with these goals. This goal-oriented approach ensures that the investment strategy meets the investor’s specific needs.

Cost Considerations: Value Over Price
While active funds often have higher management fees, the value they provide can outweigh these costs. The potential for higher returns and tailored strategies justify the additional expense.

Management Fees and Value
The management fees of active funds cover the expertise and research conducted by fund managers. This cost is an investment in the potential for higher returns. Passive funds, though cheaper, do not offer the same level of active management and strategic planning.

Long-Term Value
In the long term, the value provided by active funds can lead to significant wealth accumulation. The higher fees are justified by the potential for superior performance and personalized investment strategies.

Disadvantages of Passive Funds
While passive funds have lower fees, they come with limitations. Their inability to adapt to market changes and lack of strategic flexibility can hinder performance.

Limited Flexibility
Passive funds are bound to follow an index, offering no flexibility to respond to market conditions. This can result in missed opportunities and increased vulnerability during market downturns.

Average Market Returns
Passive funds aim to replicate market performance, leading to average returns. Investors seeking to outperform the market may find passive funds less appealing.

Disadvantages of Direct Funds
Direct funds, while avoiding distributor commissions, lack the professional guidance of a Certified Financial Planner. This can result in suboptimal investment decisions.

Lack of Professional Guidance
Direct investors miss out on the expertise of fund managers and CFPs. This can lead to poor investment choices and increased risk. Investing through a Certified Financial Planner provides the benefit of professional management.

Increased Responsibility
Investors in direct funds must manage their portfolios, which can be time-consuming and complex. A Certified Financial Planner simplifies this process, providing expert management and peace of mind.

Conclusion
In conclusion, active funds offer significant advantages for long-term investment. The expertise, strategic flexibility, potential for higher returns, and personalized strategies make active funds a compelling choice. While they come with higher costs, the value provided justifies the expense. Passive funds, though cheaper, lack the adaptability and performance potential of active funds. Direct funds, without professional guidance, pose additional risks. For long-term growth and financial success, active funds, managed by Certified Financial Planners, are the superior choice.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ravi

Ravi Mittal  |431 Answers  |Ask -

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Nov 22, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Nov 22, 2024Hindi
Listen
Relationship
A bit long story I'm 21 student preparing for medical competative entrance exam for past 3 years (21-24).2 year ago this phase I was in a long distance relationship for 4 months with a girl I met in my class .But it didn't last long due to the problems created due to distance as she couldn't understand myself and I couldn't understand herself.so there was a misunderstanding and I couldn't hold on as I was in heavy pressure by exams and financial problems.so I couldn't handle and I felt like too early and broke up with her by losing my mind.she was completely disappointed as I didn't speak to her for more than an year due to one more year preparation.i missed her very much but I didnt tell her.I missed govt seat in border mark and the same year she got into a relationship with another guy in her class.i don't blame her. But I feel like my entire life is shattered and I couldn't move on from that girl till now.I couldn't concentrate on my career too.im kind of person who is always confident in all aspects but I have totally lost my mind .I can see that in an danger situation as age is running and family pressure, everyone of my classmates are far ahead of me I couldn't withstand this situation and couldn't make proper decision in any aspect. Mam please help me out.
Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I understand your concerns. The first step is to focus on moving on; she has, and you should too. Prioritize your career, your family, and your future. Next, what has happened to your career progress has already happened. It's unfortunate, but there's no way to change that. But give yourself a second chance; work harder and achieve greater things than you even imagined before. Trust me, you are not the only person who is standing in a situation like this. Many have, and many more will. But the ones who have passed this time will give you the same advice that I did.

Best Wishes.

...Read more

Milind

Milind Vadjikar  |682 Answers  |Ask -

Insurance, Stocks, MF, PF Expert - Answered on Nov 22, 2024

Asked by Anonymous - Nov 13, 2024Hindi
Listen
Money
Sir, I am 40yrs old. Having monthly takehome salary of 1.1 lakh and rental income of 36000. My investment are 2 flats worth of 1cr. 4 plots in Bhubaneswar worth of 2crs. EPF balance 50 lakh, LIC policies worth of 16 lakhs, NPS worth of 10 lakhs. My monthly saving commitments are - EPF (employee+employer) 28000 NPS 15000 MF 7500 Gold scheme 5000 Financial burden - HL emi of 24000 Monthly expanses 50000 I would like to retire at 50. Please advise for retirement plan with life expectancy of 80yrs.
Ans: Hello;

The value of your investments after 10 years;

A. EPF Corpus+Contribution: 1.6 Cr
B. NPS Corpus+Contribution: 53 L
C. MF(sip) + Gold(sip): 25 L
D. Real estate (land): 3.26 Cr

So sum of A, C & D gives us a corpus of 5.11 Cr

Since you will withdraw NPS before 60 age 80% of corpus will go into annuity while 20% will be available to you.

So you may expect monthly income of around 21 K from annuity(42.4 L).

Balance 10.6 L get added to 5.11L taking your total corpus to ~ 5.2 Cr.

If you invest 5 Cr in a conservative hybrid debt fund and do a SWP at the rate of 3%, you may expect a monthly income of around 1.1 L(post-tax).

Add your monthly rental income of 36 K(No growth factored) and annuity income of 21 K to this and you have total monthly income of 1.67 L after 10 years.

Your current monthly expenses of 50 K after 10 years would be around 90 K and 1.6 L after 20 years.

Considering return of around 7-7.5% from the conservative hybrid debt fund you will still generate inflation adjusted return at 3% SWP after 80 years of age.

Assumptions:
Inflation rate-6%
Return from EPF-8%
Return from NPS-9%
Return from MF-10%
Return from gold-7%
Return from Land-5%
Annuity rate-6%

The spare flat is not considered in this because it will continue to yield you rental income in retirement.

Since real estate(land) returns may fluctuate over 10 years suggest to increase MF sip(6X) as a back-up, also in this case you may decide to retain & invest in NPS upto 60 age.

Of course MF returns are also not assured but you are improving the odds by backing two appreciable assets(RE & equity) over long-term.

Happy Investing;
X: @mars_invest

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |7101 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Nov 22, 2024

Money
My age 62, male, getting rental income Rs. 90k nett. Already subscribing 12.5k in PPF for the past 2 1/2 years. No other investments. My target is 5 crores in 10 years. I already have Mediclaim Rs.50 lakhs for me & wife . Please advice me what to do.
Ans: Your current financial foundation is strong and shows promise:

A rental income of Rs. 90,000 per month provides consistent and predictable cash flow. This stability can serve as the backbone for your investment strategy.

PPF contributions of Rs. 12,500 per month for 2.5 years reflect disciplined saving. However, its returns may be insufficient to achieve a high-growth target like Rs. 5 crores in 10 years.

A robust Mediclaim policy of Rs. 50 lakhs for you and your wife ensures adequate health coverage. This safeguard allows you to focus on wealth-building without worrying about medical emergencies.

Despite these positive factors, achieving Rs. 5 crores in 10 years requires a carefully crafted and growth-oriented strategy.

Defining and Prioritising Your Financial Goals
Achieving Rs. 5 crores is ambitious yet achievable with a focused approach:

Define this target as your primary financial goal over the next decade.

Break it into manageable milestones: for example, Rs. 50 lakhs every 1-2 years in cumulative investments and growth.

Prioritise high-return investments that align with your risk tolerance and financial capacity.

Optimising Existing PPF Contributions
While PPF is a secure investment, its growth potential is limited:

Returns: PPF currently offers an interest rate of approximately 7-7.5%, which barely outpaces inflation.

Contribution Review: Consider capping your PPF contributions at Rs. 1.5 lakh annually (to utilise the Section 80C benefit). This ensures that excess funds are redirected to higher-return investments.

PPF can serve as a low-risk component of your portfolio but should not dominate your investment strategy.

Building a Diversified Investment Portfolio
A diversified portfolio will provide a balance of risk and reward. Include the following components:

1. Equity Mutual Funds for Growth
Equity mutual funds are essential for achieving high returns over the long term:

Large-Cap Funds: These invest in established companies and offer stability with moderate growth. They are ideal for a portion of your portfolio to reduce risk.

Multi-Cap or Flexi-Cap Funds: These provide exposure to companies of all sizes, offering growth and diversification.

Sectoral and Thematic Funds: Avoid these unless you have a high risk tolerance and understand market dynamics.

ELSS Funds: These not only provide tax savings under Section 80C but also deliver market-linked returns.

Why Avoid Index Funds?

Index funds may offer simplicity and lower expense ratios, but they lack flexibility. They cannot adapt to market conditions or capitalise on outperforming sectors. Actively managed funds, on the other hand, have the potential to outperform the market, especially in a developing economy like India.

Start with a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) in selected funds to build wealth steadily.

2. Debt Mutual Funds for Stability
Debt funds add stability to your portfolio and reduce overall risk:

Choose funds with low credit risk and moderate duration to ensure safety and predictable returns.

Debt funds are suitable for short- to medium-term goals or as a fallback during market corrections.

Taxation Note: Both LTCG and STCG on debt funds are taxed as per your income tax slab. This should be factored into your planning.

3. Balanced Advantage Funds
Balanced advantage funds (BAFs) dynamically allocate assets between equity and debt. They:

Provide exposure to equity while minimising downside risk.

Offer a suitable option for someone nearing retirement but seeking growth.

4. Gold Investments for Diversification
Allocate a small portion (5-10%) of your portfolio to gold:

Gold serves as a hedge against inflation and currency depreciation.

Choose gold ETFs or sovereign gold bonds for ease of liquidity and better returns.

Emergency Fund Creation
Having an emergency fund is non-negotiable:

Maintain at least 6-12 months of expenses in liquid investments like liquid mutual funds or high-interest savings accounts.

This ensures liquidity for unforeseen events without disturbing your long-term investments.

Focus on Retirement Planning
At 62, balancing growth and safety becomes critical:

Estimate your monthly retirement expenses, considering inflation over the next 10-15 years.

Your target of Rs. 5 crores should primarily serve as your retirement corpus.

Allocate assets thoughtfully:

60-70% in equity funds for growth.
30-40% in debt funds for stability.
Periodically rebalance your portfolio to maintain this allocation.

Strategic Tax Planning
Tax efficiency can significantly impact your returns:

Continue using Section 80C to its full potential, including ELSS funds and PPF.

Consider the National Pension System (NPS) for an additional Rs. 50,000 deduction under Section 80CCD(1B).

Be mindful of the new taxation rules for mutual funds:

Equity Mutual Funds: LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakh is taxed at 12.5%; STCG at 20%.
Debt Funds: LTCG and STCG are taxed as per your income slab.
Consult a Certified Financial Planner to optimise your tax strategy.

Regular Portfolio Monitoring and Rebalancing
Investing is not a one-time activity:

Review your portfolio every six months or annually to track performance.

Rebalance your asset allocation periodically to align with your financial goals and risk appetite.

Stay committed to SIPs even during market downturns, as this ensures cost-averaging.

Additional Suggestions
Avoid Over-Reliance on PPF
While PPF is safe, it is not sufficient for wealth creation. Shift excess contributions to equity-based investments for better returns.

Avoid Direct Stocks
Direct equity investing requires time, expertise, and constant monitoring. It carries higher risk and may lead to losses without proper research. Instead, rely on equity mutual funds managed by professionals.

Avoid Mixing Insurance and Investments
Do not invest in ULIPs or endowment plans, as they offer suboptimal returns. Stick to pure insurance products for protection and mutual funds for growth.

The Role of a Certified Financial Planner
To achieve Rs. 5 crores, a well-crafted financial plan is essential. A Certified Financial Planner (CFP) can:

Analyse your current investments and recommend improvements.

Design a customised strategy tailored to your income, expenses, and goals.

Provide periodic reviews to ensure you stay on track.

Finally
Achieving Rs. 5 crores in 10 years is a realistic goal if you adopt a disciplined and diversified approach.

Optimise your PPF contributions and channel excess funds into higher-growth investments.

Build a diversified portfolio with equity and debt mutual funds.

Include a small allocation to gold and maintain an emergency fund.

Stay consistent with your SIPs and review your investments regularly.

Work with a Certified Financial Planner to create a personalised roadmap.

By following these steps, you can secure your financial future and meet your goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x