Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Gaurav

Gaurav Mohta  | Answer  |Ask -

Answered on Oct 26, 2022

Chandru Question by Chandru on Oct 26, 2022Hindi
Listen
Money

I took Home Loan from HDFC and Top up loan (For that Home loan). I closed the Main Home loan. Can I do balance transfer to other Lender for the Top up Loan (Only Top up Loan which is not Mortgage)? 

Ans: A top up loan by definition is a loan given by your lender over and above your regular home loan for additional expenses incurred. Since your current lender has lent it to you on the basis of your creditworthiness and payment history, a balance transfer in this case will not be possible.

Only a home loan borrower can apply for a top up loan. Instead, you can take a personal loan if the amount is smaller.

If you close your existing home loan plus top up loan and need some funds for some use, you can apply for a loan against property separately from another lender. This option will be suitable for a larger amount and a longer tenure. 

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10876 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Feb 21, 2025

Listen
Money
Do I change my Lap loan to Home Loan? In 2015 I took a Home Loan on from Karnataka Bank then I took Top-up in 2017. But in 2021 For extra top-up I convert my home loan into LAP now I'm financially stable now, did I convert my loan from LAP to Home Loan. Is it possible ?
Ans: Yes, converting your Loan Against Property (LAP) back to a Home Loan is possible, but it depends on your bank’s policies. Here’s what you need to consider:

Key Differences Between LAP and Home Loan
Interest Rate: LAP usually has a higher interest rate (10-14%) compared to a home loan (8-9%). Converting to a home loan may reduce your interest burden.

Loan Tenure: Home loans offer longer tenures (up to 30 years), whereas LAP has shorter tenures (up to 15 years).

Tax Benefits: Home loans offer tax benefits under Section 80C and 24(b), but LAP does not.

Purpose: Home loans are meant for property purchase/construction, while LAP is for general financing needs.

Conversion Feasibility
Bank Approval: Karnataka Bank must agree to convert your LAP back to a home loan. Banks usually allow this if the original purpose was home-related.

Property Usage: If the LAP was taken for personal needs (not business), banks may consider converting it.

Documentation: You will need to submit fresh home loan documents, including income proof and property papers.

Alternative Options
Home Loan Balance Transfer: If Karnataka Bank does not allow conversion, transfer your LAP to another bank as a home loan for a lower interest rate.

Prepayment Strategy: If your financial condition has improved, consider prepaying the LAP instead of converting.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10876 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 14, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 13, 2025
Money
Hi All, I need your valuable suggestion, please help. I am 45 years and I have a homeloan of 16L with EMI 16.7K/month ( remaining 52 months to end) and 23L homeloan topup EMI of 35K ( 93 months remaining to pay). I want to take topup loan of 25L, so is it good to close the homeloan and take topup or how to proceed. Would like to close all the this loans by next 5 years. Kindly suggest.
Ans: Your current financial standing reflects disciplined planning and a proactive approach towards debt management and investments. Let's delve into a comprehensive analysis to guide your decision on whether to prepay your home loan or continue with your current strategy.
Your Current Financial Picture
Your Age: 45 years

Home Loan Outstanding: Rs. 16 lakh

Home Loan EMI: Rs. 16,700 per month (52 months left)

Top-up Loan Outstanding: Rs. 23 lakh

Top-up Loan EMI: Rs. 35,000 per month (93 months left)

Considering New Top-up Loan: Rs. 25 lakh

Your Goal: Close all loans within the next 5 years

Understanding Your Core Objective
Your goal to become debt-free in 5 years is bold and focused.

Planning is the key to achieve this without hurting your other financial goals.

The idea of taking a new top-up loan needs careful assessment.

Should You Take a New Top-Up Loan?
Taking a Rs. 25 lakh top-up will increase your monthly EMI load.

It can increase your financial stress and delay complete loan closure.

Top-up loans might come at a higher interest rate.

Avoid new debt unless absolutely needed for urgent purposes.

You should first assess why you need this extra loan.

If it is for consumption or regular needs, avoid it completely.

If it is for repaying another higher-cost loan, evaluate alternatives.

Evaluate Home Loan Prepayment
Loans are useful, but they carry interest which eats into your savings.

Closing loans early helps save big on interest.

You can pay small extra amounts every year to reduce tenure.

Focus on the loan with the highest interest and longest tenure.

Your top-up loan of Rs. 23 lakh with 93 months should be the first priority.

Re-structure EMIs Instead of Top-Up
Avoid taking a fresh Rs. 25 lakh loan.

Instead, consider restructuring your current EMIs if income flow is tight.

Some banks allow step-up EMI or tenure adjustment.

It will keep your total loan under control.

Discuss this clearly with your lender before acting.

Smart Loan Repayment Strategy (Next 5 Years Plan)
Aim to repay the top-up loan faster using extra income or annual bonus.

Try part payments every 6 months or once a year.

Avoid touching emergency funds or retirement funds.

Control new expenses to free more cash towards debt.

You can cut expenses that are not urgent for next 2 years.

Avoid buying new car, gadgets, or travel on EMIs.

Investment vs Loan Repayment – Which is Better Now?
If your investments give lower returns than loan interest, focus on repayment.

If your mutual funds are earning 9%, and your loan is 8%, you can balance.

But most importantly, check your risk capacity before investing more.

Do not invest heavily in share market if debt is very high.

Emergency situations can create problems if you are over-invested.

Use a slow and steady approach – part prepay, part invest.

Avoid stopping all investments – keep a minimum SIP running.

Maintain Emergency & Insurance Before Prepayment
Always keep 6 months’ household expenses in liquid form.

Don’t touch emergency funds to prepay loans.

Make sure you and your family have sufficient health insurance cover.

Also check if you have a term life cover of 10–15 times your annual income.

Loan repayment is good, but not at the cost of security.

What About Mutual Fund Investing?
If you have SIPs, continue them in small amounts.

Don’t stop all long-term investments for repaying loans.

Mutual funds give better long-term returns if held for 7+ years.

But stay away from index funds if you are not tracking them well.

Actively managed mutual funds handled by Certified Financial Planners give better risk-adjusted returns.

Direct mutual funds look cheap, but lack ongoing support.

Investing through MFDs with CFP background ensures long-term advice.

You get portfolio review, tax support, and goal-based adjustments.

Avoid direct funds unless you have full time to track, review, and rebalance.

Don’t Touch Long-Term Investments or Retirement Corpus
PPF, EPF, NPS, or other long-term products should not be withdrawn now.

If you use these to repay loan, you hurt your retirement peace.

Future corpus will be small, and you may depend again on loans.

Treat long-term savings as non-touchable.

Build short-term cash surplus from salary or business profit.

5-Year Practical Action Plan
Year 1–2: Avoid new loans. Start part-prepaying the 23L top-up loan.

Year 2–3: Increase EMI or part-payment on 16L home loan if top-up balance reduces.

Year 3–4: Reduce lifestyle costs. Channel savings towards both loans.

Year 4–5: Close the bigger loan. Wind up the smaller loan fully.

Post 5 Years: Loan-free life. Full focus on investments and retirement planning.

Mental Peace and Confidence
Being debt-free gives freedom and strong peace of mind.

Avoid the trap of more top-up loans. It delays financial independence.

Plan well and stay consistent in actions.

You don’t have to be fast. You have to be disciplined.

Even one prepayment each year will reduce years off your loan.

You are only 45. Still 15 years to build wealth peacefully.

Don’t rush. But don’t delay either.

Finally
Taking a top-up of Rs. 25 lakh now will increase debt pressure.

Instead, reduce existing loans with regular part-payments.

Maintain health and life insurance covers.

Continue small investments to build long-term wealth.

Avoid emotional financial decisions.

Balance repayment, savings, and investment step by step.

With a proper 5-year plan, you can close all loans without any extra stress.

You will then enter your 50s debt-free and wealth-focused.

That will give peace, pride, and protection to your entire family.

Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP
Chief Financial Planner

www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10876 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Dec 09, 2025

Money
Im aged 40 years and my husband is aged 48 years. We have one son aged 8 years and daughter aged 12 years. We both are in business. What should be the ideal corpus to meet their education at the age of 18 years for both children? Present business income we can save Rs.50000 pm
Ans: You are thinking early. That itself is a smart step. Many parents postpone planning and later struggle with loans. You are not in that situation. So appreciate your approach.

You asked about ideal corpus for higher education. Education cost is rising fast. So planning early avoids financial pressure later.

You have two kids. Your daughter is 12. Your son is 8. You have around six years for your daughter and around ten years for your son. With this time frame, you need a proper structured plan.

» Understanding Future Education Cost

Education inflation in India is high. It is increasing year after year. Even professional courses are becoming costly. College fees, hostel fees, books, digital tools and transportation also add cost.

You need to consider this inflation. Higher education cost will not remain at today’s value. It will grow.

So if today a standard undergraduate program costs around a few lakhs, in six to ten years the cost may go much higher. That is why estimating corpus should consider this future cost.

You don’t need exact numbers today. You need a target range to plan. A comfortable range gives clarity.

» Typical Cost Structure for Higher Education

Higher education cost depends on:

– Private or government institution
– Course type
– City or abroad option
– Duration

For engineering, medical, management or technology courses, cost goes higher. For government colleges the cost is lower but seats are limited. Private colleges are more accessible but expensive.

So planning based only on government college assumption may create funding gaps. Planning based on private college range gives safer margin.

» Suggested Corpus for Both Children

For your daughter, considering next six years gap and inflation, a target range should be higher. For your son, you have more time. So his corpus can grow better because compounding works more with time.

For a comfortable education corpus that covers most course possibilities, many families plan for a higher number. It gives flexibility to choose better college without stress.

So you can aim for a larger goal for both children like this:

– Daughter: Target a strong education fund for next six years
– Son: Target a similar or slightly higher fund for the next ten years because future costs may be higher

You may not need the whole amount if your child chooses a less expensive route. But having extra cushion gives peace.

» Your Savings Ability

You mentioned you can save Rs.50000 monthly. That is a strong saving capacity. But this saving should not go entirely to a single goal. You will also need future retirement planning, emergency fund and other life goals.

Still, a reasonable portion of this amount can be allocated towards education planning. Some families divide savings based on urgency and time horizon. Since daughter’s goal is near, she may need a more stable allocation.

Your son’s goal is long term. So his part can stay in growth asset for longer.

» Choosing the Right Investment Style

A long term goal like your son’s education needs equity exposure. Equity gives better potential for long term growth. It beats inflation better than fixed deposits.

But for your daughter, pure equity can create risk because goal is nearer. Market fluctuations may affect final corpus. So she needs a balanced asset mix.

So investment approach must be different for both.

» Asset Allocation Strategy

For your daughter with six year horizon:

– Higher allocation to a balanced type category
– Some allocation to equity through diversified categories
– Step down equity allocation in final three years

This structure protects capital in later years.

For your son with ten year horizon:

– Higher equity allocation at start
– Continue systematic investing
– Reduce risk allocation gradually closer to goal period

This helps growth and protection.

» Avoiding Wrong Investment Products

Parents often buy traditional insurance plans or children policies for education. These policies give low returns. They lock money and reduce wealth creation potential.

So avoid purely insurance based products for education goals. Insurance is separate. Investment is separate. This separation creates clarity and better growth.

If you already hold any ULIP or investment insurance product, it may not be efficient. Only if you have such policies then you may review and consider if surrender is needed and reinvest in mutual funds. If you don’t have such policies, no need to worry.

» Role of Actively Managed Mutual Funds

For long term goals, actively managed mutual funds offer better flexibility and expert management. They are designed to outperform inflation. A regular plan through a mutual fund distributor with CFP support helps with guidance. They also track your goal and give advice in volatile phases.

Direct funds look cheaper on expense ratio. But they lack advisory support. Long term investors often make emotional mistakes in direct investing. They stop SIPs or switch wrong schemes. So advisory backed investing avoids costly behaviour mistakes.

Index funds look simple and low cost. But they only follow the market. They don’t protect during corrections. There is no strategy or research. Actively managed funds adjust holdings based on market research and valuation. For life goals like education, smoother growth and strategy are needed.

So regular plan with advisory support helps you avoid unnecessary emotional decisions.

» Importance of Systematic Investing

A fixed monthly SIP gives discipline. It also benefits from market volatility. When markets fall, SIP buys more units. In rise phase, the value grows.

A structured SIP helps both goals. For daughter, SIP should shift towards low volatility funds slowly. For son, SIP can run longer in growth-oriented funds before reducing risk.

Your contribution amount may change based on future business income. But start now with whatever comfortable.

» Protecting the Goal With Insurance

Since you both are running business, income stability may fluctuate. So ensuring life security is important. Term insurance is the right option. It is low cost and high coverage.

This ensures child’s education is protected even if income stops.

Medical insurance also matters. A medical emergency should not break education savings.

» Reviewing the Plan Periodically

A fixed plan is good. But markets and life conditions change. So review once every twelve months.

Points to review:

– Are SIPs running on time?
– Is allocation suitable for goal year?
– Any need to shift from equity to safer category?
– Any tax planning advantage needed?

But avoid checking portfolio every week. Frequent checking creates stress.

» Education Goal Withdrawal Plan

As the daughter’s goal comes close:

– Stop SIP in high risk category
– Start shifting profit to debt type fund over systematic transfers
– Keep final year money in safe option like liquid category

Same formula should be applied for your son when his goal approaches.

This protects against last minute market crash.

» Emotional Side of Planning

Education is an emotional goal. Parents feel pressure to provide the best. But planning removes fear.

Saving consistently gives confidence. Having a plan helps avoid panic decisions. It also brings clarity of future expense.

This planning sets financial discipline for your children as well.

» Taxation Factors

When redeeming funds for education, tax rules will apply. For equity fund withdrawals, long term capital gains above exemption are taxed at 12.5% as per current rules. For short term within one year, tax is higher.

For debt investments, gains are taxed as per your tax slab.

So plan the withdrawal timing to reduce tax.

Tax planning near goal year is very important.

» What You Can Do Next

– Start separate investments for each child
– Use SIP for disciplined investing
– Choose growth-oriented asset for son
– Choose balanced and phased investment approach for daughter
– Review allocation yearly
– Protect the goal with insurance cover

Following these steps helps achieve the target corpus smoothly.

» Finally

You are already thinking in the right direction. You have time for both goals. You also have a good saving frequency. So you can build a strong education fund without stress.

Your children’s future will be secure if you continue with a structured and disciplined plan.

Stay consistent with your savings. Make investment choices carefully. Review and adjust calmly over time.

This journey will help you reach your ideal corpus for both children.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10876 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Dec 09, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 09, 2025Hindi
Money
Hi Sir, Regarding recent turmoils in global economic situation and trends, Trump's tariffs, relentless FII selling, should I be worried about midcap, large&midcap funds that I have in my mutual fund portfolio? I have been investing from last 4 years and want to invest for next 10 years only. And then plan to retire and move to SWP. I'm targeting a 10%-11% return eventually. And I don't want to make lower returns than FD's. Is now the time to switch from midcap, laege&midcap to conservative, large, flexi funds? Please suggest.
Ans: You have asked the right question at the right time. Many investors panic only after damage happens. You are thinking ahead. That is a strong habit.

You also have clarity about your goal, time horizon and expected returns. This mindset will help you handle market noise better.

» Current Market Sentiment and Global Events
The global economy is seeing stress. There are trade decisions, tariff announcements, and geopolitical issues. Foreign institutional investors are selling. News flow looks negative.
These events can cause short term volatility. Midcaps and small caps usually react faster during these phases. Even large caps show some stress.
But markets have seen many crises in the past. Elections, governments, conflicts, pandemics, financial crashes and tariff wars are not new events. Markets always recover over time.
Short term movements are unpredictable. Long term wealth creation depends more on patience and asset allocation.

» Your Time Horizon Matters More Than Market Noise
You have been investing for 4 years. You plan to invest for the next 10 years. That means your remaining maturity is long term.
For a 10 year goal, equity is suitable. Midcap and large and midcap funds are designed for long term investors. They are not meant for short periods.
If your time horizon is short, it is valid to worry about downside risk. But with 10 more years ahead, temporary volatility is normal and expected.
Short term fear should not drive long term decisions.

» Should You Switch to Conservative or Large Cap Now?
Switching based on panic or temporary news is not ideal. When you switch now, you lock the current lower value permanently. You also miss the recovery phase.
Large cap and flexi cap funds offer stability. But they also deliver lower growth potential during bull runs compared to midcaps.
Midcaps usually fall deeper when markets drop. But they also recover faster and often outperform in the next cycle.
Switching now may protect emotions but may reduce long term wealth creation.

» Target Return of 10% to 11% is Reasonable
Aiming for 10%-11% return with a 10 year investment horizon is realistic.
Fixed deposits now offer around 6.5% to 7.5%. After tax, the return becomes lower.
Equity funds have potential to generate better returns compared to FD over a long tenure. Midcap allocation contributes to this return potential.
So moving fully to conservative funds may reduce your ability to beat inflation comfortably.

» Impact of FII Selling
FII selling creates pressure on the market. But domestic investors including SIP flows are strong today. India is seeing strong structural growth.
Retail investors, mutual funds and systematic flows act as stabilizers.
FII selling is temporary and cyclical. It is not a permanent trend.

» Economic Slowdowns Create Opportunities
Corrections make valuations reasonable. This can benefit long term SIP investors.
During downturns, your SIP buys more units. During recovery, these units grow.
This mechanism works best in volatile categories like midcaps.
Stopping SIP or switching during dips blocks this benefit.

» Midcap Cycles Are Natural
Midcap funds move in cycles. They have phases of strong growth followed by correction. The correction phase is painful but temporary.
Every cycle contributes to future upside. Staying invested during all phases is important.
Many investors exit during downturns and enter again after markets rise. This behaviour produces lower returns than the mutual fund performance.

» Role of Portfolio Balance
Instead of exiting fully, review your asset allocation. You can hold a mix of:
– Large cap
– Flexi cap
– Midcap
– Large and midcap
This gives stability and growth potential.
Midcap should not be more than a suitable percentage for your age and risk tolerance. Since you are 36, some meaningful midcap exposure is fine.
If midcap exposure is very high, you can reduce slightly and move that portion to flexi cap or large cap funds slowly through a systematic transfer. Do not do a lump sum shift during panic.

» Behavioural Discipline Matters More Than Fund Selection
Market cycles test investor patience. Consistency in SIP and holding through declines builds wealth.
Most investors do not fail due to bad funds. They fail due to fear-based decisions.
Your approach should be systematic, not emotional.

» Do Not Compare with FD Frequently
FD gives predictable return. Equity gives volatile but higher potential return.
Comparing FD returns every time the market falls leads to wrong decisions.
FD is for safety. Equity is for growth. They serve different purposes.
Your retirement plan and SWP plan depends on growth. Only equity can provide that growth.

» Should You Change Strategy Because Retirement is 10 Years Away?
Now is not the time to exit growth segments. You are still in accumulation phase.
When you reach the last 3 years before retirement, then reducing equity exposure step by step is required.
At that stage, a glide path helps preserve gains. That time has not yet come.
So continue building wealth now.

» Market Timings and Shifts Rarely Work
Many investors try to predict markets. Most of them fail.
Switching based on news looks logical. But news and market timing rarely align.
Staying consistent with your asset allocation gives better results than frequent changes.

» Portfolio Review Approach
You can follow these steps:
– Continue SIPs in all categories
– Avoid stopping based on short term fears
– If midcap allocation is above comfort level, shift only small portion gradually
– Review allocation once in a year, not every month
This structured approach prevents emotional decisions.

» Tax Rules Matter When Switching
Switching between equity funds involves tax impact.
Short term capital gains tax is higher.
Long term capital gains above the exemption limit are taxed at 12.5%.
Switching without purpose can create avoidable tax leakage.
This reduces your compounding.

» When to Worry?
You need to reconsider only if:
– Your goal horizon becomes short
– Your risk appetite changes
– Your allocation becomes unbalanced
Not because of headlines or temporary corrections.

» Your Retirement SWP Plan
Once your accumulation phase is completed, you can shift to:
– Conservative hybrid
– Flexi cap
– Balanced allocation
This will support a smoother SWP.
But this transition should happen only closer to the retirement start date. Not now.

» SIP is Designed for Turbulent Years
SIP works best when markets are volatile. The hardest years for emotions are the most powerful for compounding.
Your long term discipline is your strategy.
Do not interrupt it.

» What You Should Do Now
– Stay invested
– Continue SIP
– Avoid panic selling
– Review allocation once a year
– Use a steady plan, not reactions
This will help you reach your target return range.

» Finally
You are on the right path. The current volatility is temporary. Your 10 year horizon gives enough time for recovery and growth.
Switching right now based on fear may reduce your future returns. Staying invested and continuing SIPs is the sensible approach.
Your goal of better return than FD is realistic. Equity can deliver that with patience.
Stay calm and systematic.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

...Read more

Radheshyam

Radheshyam Zanwar  |6739 Answers  |Ask -

MHT-CET, IIT-JEE, NEET-UG Expert - Answered on Dec 09, 2025

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x