Home > Money > Question
Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Should I invest in stocks or build an emergency fund with my fluctuating savings?

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10375 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Aug 22, 2024

Ramalingam Kalirajan has over 23 years of experience in mutual funds and financial planning.
He has an MBA in finance from the University of Madras and is a certified financial planner.
He is the director and chief financial planner at Holistic Investment, a Chennai-based firm that offers financial planning and wealth management advice.... more
Abhijit Question by Abhijit on Jun 17, 2024Hindi
Money

I can save an amount of 3000-5000 per month apart from my regular monthly investments of Sip in mutual fund, insurance and bank RD. Where should I invest this amount since it is fluctuating in nature?

Ans: It's good to see you consistently saving. Allocating Rs 3,000 to Rs 5,000 monthly, in addition to your regular investments, can strengthen your financial future. This fluctuating amount can be strategically used to enhance your portfolio. Let's explore how you can best utilize this amount given its variable nature.

1. Building a Contingency Fund
Importance of Contingency Fund: A solid emergency fund is crucial. It provides financial security during unexpected situations like job loss or medical emergencies.

Utilizing Your Fluctuating Savings: Allocate a portion of your variable savings to build this fund until it reaches at least six months of your monthly expenses.

Placement of the Fund: Consider keeping this fund in a liquid fund or a high-interest savings account. These options offer better returns than a regular savings account while maintaining liquidity.

2. Enhancing Existing Mutual Fund SIPs
Topping Up Your SIPs: You’re already investing in mutual funds through SIPs. Consider using your additional savings to top up these existing SIPs periodically.

Flexibility with Fluctuating Amounts: Since the amount varies, you can increase your SIP contributions when you have more funds. Most fund houses allow SIP top-ups, making this a flexible option.

Preference for Actively Managed Funds: Actively managed funds often outperform the market. They are managed by experienced fund managers who can adjust strategies based on market conditions. This can potentially yield better returns than index funds, especially in a fluctuating market.

3. Investment in a Flexi-SIP
What is a Flexi-SIP?: A Flexi-SIP allows you to invest different amounts each month, depending on your cash flow. This flexibility aligns perfectly with your fluctuating savings.

Choosing the Right Funds: Since your investment amount varies, choose funds that align with your long-term goals. Avoid direct funds and instead, go for regular funds through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP). This way, you benefit from professional guidance without the hassle of constant monitoring.

Diversification: Ensure that your Flexi-SIP is diversified across different sectors and market capitalizations. This spreads your risk and enhances the potential for growth.

4. Investing in Gold
Safe-Haven Asset: Gold is considered a stable investment, especially during economic uncertainty. It’s a good hedge against inflation and currency fluctuations.

Options for Investing in Gold: You can invest in gold through Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGBs) or Gold ETFs. SGBs are particularly attractive as they offer an annual interest payment on top of the gold price appreciation.

Aligning with Your Fluctuating Savings: Since the investment in gold can be flexible, you can allocate part of your variable savings here. This is a long-term investment that can protect your portfolio during downturns.

5. Consider Debt Funds for Short-Term Goals
Debt Funds as a Stable Option: If you have short-term financial goals, debt funds could be a good fit. They are less volatile than equity funds and provide steady returns.

Systematic Transfer Plan (STP): You can invest your fluctuating savings in a debt fund and set up an STP to transfer a fixed amount monthly into an equity mutual fund. This provides the benefits of both debt and equity investments, offering stability and growth potential.

6. Utilizing Recurring Deposits (RDs)
Recurring Deposits for Safety: RDs are a safe investment option with guaranteed returns. They suit individuals who prefer low-risk investments.

Flexibility with Fluctuating Contributions: Many banks offer flexible RDs where you can vary your deposit amount. This aligns well with your fluctuating savings.

Balance with Higher Growth Options: While RDs offer safety, they don’t provide high returns. Combine RDs with other higher growth options like mutual funds to balance safety and returns.

7. Investing in a Child's Education Plan
Long-Term Goal Alignment: If you’re planning for your child’s education, investing in a specific child education plan might be beneficial. These plans are designed to meet the financial needs of education, often offering insurance coverage as well.

Regular Contributions: You can direct your fluctuating savings toward this goal. These plans often allow flexible premium payments, making them suitable for variable incomes.

Tax Benefits: Many child education plans offer tax benefits under Section 80C, adding to their attractiveness.

8. Strengthening Your Retirement Corpus
Preparing for Retirement: Since you aim to retire early, strengthening your retirement corpus is vital. This can be achieved by contributing your additional savings toward a retirement-specific mutual fund.

Retirement Planning with Variable Income: Consider using a flexible plan that allows varying contributions. This ensures that even with fluctuating savings, you consistently build your retirement fund.

Benefit of Regular Funds: Investing through a CFP can provide tailored advice, ensuring your retirement plan is on track. Regular funds offer ongoing professional management, which is crucial for long-term goals like retirement.

9. Avoiding the Temptation of High-Risk Investments
Lessons from Past Losses: Given your previous experience with losses in options trading, it’s wise to avoid high-risk investments. Stick to safer, more predictable investment options that align with your financial goals.

Focus on Steady Growth: Instead of seeking quick gains, focus on steady, consistent growth. This approach, while less glamorous, is more likely to lead to financial stability and success in the long run.

10. Regular Review and Adjustment
Importance of Regular Review: As your income and expenses change, regularly review your investments. This helps in making necessary adjustments to stay on track with your goals.

Engage with a Certified Financial Planner: Regular consultations with a CFP can provide valuable insights. They can help you adjust your strategy based on changes in your financial situation.

Flexibility in Approach: Keep your investment approach flexible. If your income increases, consider increasing your SIP contributions or exploring new investment opportunities.

Finally
Your journey towards financial stability and growth is commendable. By smartly allocating your fluctuating savings, you can strengthen your financial future. Focus on building a robust emergency fund, enhancing your existing investments, and preparing for long-term goals like retirement and your child's education. Avoid high-risk investments and keep your approach flexible. With consistent efforts and professional guidance, you’re well on your way to achieving your financial goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in
DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10375 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Feb 01, 2025

Listen
Money
I save approx 90 thousand INR per month. Where should I invest it. I don't want to keep it saving account. This I save after monthly SIP of 30000. Please advice.
Ans: You already invest Rs 30,000 per month in SIPs.

You save Rs 90,000 per month after SIPs.

You want better returns than a savings account.

A clear investment plan will help in long-term wealth creation.

Key Factors Before Investing
Emergency Fund
Keep at least six months of expenses in liquid funds.

This ensures financial security in case of emergencies.

Short-Term Needs
Identify any expenses in the next 3 to 5 years.

Use safer instruments for short-term goals.

Long-Term Growth
Invest for wealth creation.

Balance between equity and debt based on risk appetite.

Investment Allocation for Rs 90,000 Per Month
1. Equity Mutual Funds (Rs 50,000 per month)
Invest in actively managed equity mutual funds.

Diversify across large-cap, mid-cap, and flexi-cap funds.

This ensures long-term capital appreciation.

2. Debt Mutual Funds (Rs 20,000 per month)
Provides stability and diversification.

Useful for balancing equity risk.

Ideal for short-term needs.

3. Gold Investment (Rs 10,000 per month)
Gold helps in diversification.

Protects against inflation.

Invest in gold ETFs or sovereign gold bonds.

4. Fixed Income Instruments (Rs 10,000 per month)
Use PPF or fixed deposits for stability.

PPF is tax-free and offers long-term benefits.

Fixed deposits provide liquidity and security.

Additional Investment Considerations
Increase SIP Contributions
If your income increases, raise your SIPs.

This ensures long-term wealth growth.

Avoid Unnecessary Risks
Do not invest in stocks without research.

Avoid high-risk derivative trading.

Review Your Investments Regularly
Monitor your portfolio every six months.

Rebalance based on market conditions.

Final Insights
Invest based on goals and time horizon.

Equity for long-term growth, debt for stability.

Gold provides inflation protection.

A balanced approach ensures financial security.

Regular reviews improve investment efficiency.

A structured investment plan will help you grow wealth efficiently.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |10375 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Jun 05, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - May 30, 2025
Money
Hi My current SIP amount Rs97500. My current financial assets worth PMS scheme=110lac My personal stock portfolios =48.87 My mutual fund portfolio =50lac FD and savings account =15lac Term insurance= 1cr pure term+ 1cr ULIP Health insurance =15 lac+ 10lac(star &care) Rental income =53000rs per month Every month i can save 3lac after my expenses pls guide me where to invest the remaining 3lac...Myself NRI age 42working in middle Eastern country surviving with 2kids 10thstd+8th std..
Ans: You are 42 years old.

You are working in a Middle Eastern country.

You have two children in 10th and 8th standard.

Monthly income allows you to save Rs. 3 lakhs.

You are already investing Rs. 97,500 in SIPs.

Your total financial assets include:

PMS investments: Rs. 1.10 crore

Personal stock portfolio: Rs. 48.87 lakhs

Mutual fund portfolio: Rs. 50 lakhs

FD and savings: Rs. 15 lakhs

Rental income: Rs. 53,000 per month

Insurance:

Term insurance: Rs. 1 crore

ULIP: Rs. 1 crore

Health insurance: Rs. 15 lakhs (Star) + Rs. 10 lakhs (Care)

Let us now build a 360-degree strategy for the surplus Rs. 3 lakhs monthly.

Emergency Fund Planning
Maintain 12 months of total expenses as emergency fund.

Include school fees, household spends, travel costs, etc.

Rs. 25–30 lakhs can be parked as emergency reserve.

Use ultra-short debt mutual funds or sweep-in fixed deposits.

Ensure this money is highly liquid and safe.

Emergency fund gives mental comfort during uncertainty.

You may already have some allocation here from FDs.

Reassess and top up if needed.

Review and Reallocate ULIP
ULIP often has higher charges than mutual funds.

Returns also depend on insurance company performance.

These products combine investment with insurance.

Mixing both is not an efficient way to grow wealth.

If ULIP is not recent, assess current surrender value.

If ULIP performance is weak, consider surrender.

Redeploy proceeds into mutual funds via monthly STP.

This improves transparency, flexibility and performance tracking.

Mutual Fund Expansion
You are already investing Rs. 97,500 monthly in SIP.

Increase mutual fund SIP to Rs. 2 lakhs monthly.

Choose mix of large cap, multi cap, mid cap funds.

Use actively managed funds via Certified Financial Planner.

Avoid index funds due to these reasons:

No downside protection during market fall

No active rebalancing

Rigid allocation with no flexibility

Underperformance during sideways markets

No fund manager intelligence in stock selection

Actively managed funds help generate alpha over index.

They allow periodic fund review and course correction.

Invest through regular plans via qualified professionals.

Avoid direct funds unless you have full-time expertise.

Regular funds offer human support, reviews, discipline.

PMS and Stocks Evaluation
Rs. 1.10 crore in PMS is significant.

Ensure PMS is benchmarked and evaluated yearly.

Look for consistency and reasonable risk profile.

Some PMS schemes have higher drawdowns.

Discuss risk appetite with your Certified Financial Planner.

Similarly, your stock portfolio is Rs. 48.87 lakhs.

Review holdings for concentration and duplication.

Avoid investing fresh money in direct stocks now.

Instead, shift focus to mutual funds for safer diversification.

Children’s Education Corpus Planning
Higher education for 2 children in next 5–8 years.

Target corpus should be Rs. 60–80 lakhs.

Allocate Rs. 40,000–50,000 monthly for this goal.

Use a dedicated mutual fund with balanced exposure.

Choose moderate-risk funds to avoid volatility.

Rebalance yearly as goal approaches.

Shift to ultra-short debt funds two years before use.

This ensures safety from market downturn.

Retirement Planning Focus
You are currently 42.

Retirement target should be Rs. 6–7 crore corpus minimum.

Allocate Rs. 50,000 monthly for this goal.

This can be via actively managed mutual funds.

Include large cap and flexi cap funds for long term.

Plan to continue till age 55 or beyond.

Track this goal annually with performance reports.

Don't rely on property sale or pension alone.

Focus on creating a liquid retirement corpus.

Monthly Surplus: Recommended Allocation
Rs. 3 lakh surplus should be split as follows:

Rs. 2 lakh in mutual fund SIP (active, regular plans)

Rs. 50,000 for education corpus (goal-based funds)

Rs. 50,000 towards retirement portfolio

Review allocations annually with a Certified Financial Planner.

Rebalance based on asset performance and goals.

Taxation Considerations
New capital gains tax rule applies:

For equity mutual funds:

LTCG above Rs. 1.25 lakh taxed at 12.5%

STCG taxed at 20%

For debt mutual funds:

Both LTCG and STCG taxed as per income slab

ULIP maturity is tax-free only if premium is below cap.

FDs are taxable at slab rate.

Stocks attract STT and capital gains taxes.

Keep detailed record of transactions and redemption years.

Plan systematic withdrawals for tax efficiency.

Insurance Assessment
Term insurance of Rs. 1 crore is good.

You may increase to Rs. 2 crore based on liability.

ULIP insurance should not be part of your coverage.

Health insurance Rs. 25 lakhs combined is decent.

Ensure it covers NRI and India both if needed.

Add global health cover if settling abroad later.

Real Estate: No More Exposure Suggested
You already have rental income from existing property.

Do not add more real estate.

Avoid tying more money into illiquid assets.

Focus on market-based, liquid financial instruments.

Risk Management Tips
Maintain a clear goal-wise investment structure.

Set up SIPs in different goals to track separately.

Monitor PMS and stock volatility quarterly.

Use automatic STP from liquid fund to equity fund.

Don’t chase high returns or unregulated investments.

Avoid peer-to-peer lending and crypto assets.

Discuss investment changes only with a Certified Financial Planner.

Finally
Your financial base is strong and structured.

With Rs. 3 lakh monthly surplus, you are in a powerful position.

Prioritise long-term goals like education and retirement.

Avoid over-concentration in direct stocks or PMS.

Grow your mutual fund SIP and link to goals.

Eliminate underperforming products like ULIPs if needed.

Let your Certified Financial Planner review your total portfolio annually.

Focus on liquidity, diversification, and simplicity in all decisions.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Shalini

Shalini Singh  |171 Answers  |Ask -

Dating Coach - Answered on Sep 02, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Sep 02, 2025Hindi
Relationship
Hi, I am 32M. I never had any relationships in the past...One sided was there but I overcame it and focused on my work. One day in gym i came across a girl 23F, we connected on insta and started chatting. Eventually we fell in love, I know this doesn’t sound good due to the age gap. We dated, had good times and emotionally connected with each other a lot. Now while discussing something, she revealed that she is not a virgin. There was a guy in her society she met around 3 years back (when she was 19) and she was in one sided love with him. They never confessed their love to each other. And she is not in touch with him anymore it was long back. Also she said she had made out with another guy whom she met 1 month back during her classes, prior to meeting me. I was really hurt to listen all these. Like how all these things she is doing at this age. I accepted her and then we had good 2 months again. After 2 months, I got to know she was following the first guy on insta. When confronted she said she used to like to see him and his girlfriend together. She was really not in touch with the guy but she was just following him. It was hurtful to me. We had a big fight on this. They used to share intimate pics with each other too. After forcing her to tell everything about her past, she told that she used to flirt with lot of boys. First in junior college with best friend she shared intimate pics, then met with the guy she lost virginity with, then she met another friend she shared pics with. Then in last year, in classes she shared pics with friend, then again with someone and then she had a crush on some guy with whom she made out. She was connected with them on insta. Like no talks but she was following them and they followed her too. There were almost 6-7 guys she used to talk as friend and has shared intimate pics and she called it flirting. I was shocked to hear all these. I am still shocked. This is out of my mind. It is very difficult to accept that few boys have intimate pics of my girlfriend. She has been very very loyal to me since we are together. She never got this kind of love in her life. She is really super happy in this relationship. We are emotionally connected a lot. I have treated her like a child and I love her a lot. She comes from a good family. She says she has been in wrong circle and all her friends are like this only. She cried a lot and she regrets it deeply like what she has done and she wants to get out of all these. But if feel, a persons character never changes. There will be so cold moments in relationships In future, will she be able to manage herself and stay honest. I really doubt a lot. She is really good at heart like a family girl but her past is really really terrible I feel. I feel, even though I love her will I be able to accept her past. Do I deserve this ? Do my family deserve this ? But again I think of risking it all because she is really invested in this relationship and I feel very bad to break her heart. I come from a very traditional background and believe in sacred and pure form of love. But I feel I got trapped in something which I can’t leave and can’t have whole heartedly. I am not able to focus on my work and everything. It’s hurting me a lot. Should I accept her ac she is or moving on will be better for both of us, even though it might break her heart.
Ans: Why are you thinking about the past, doing so you are messing up your now.
If you trust the person then do so 100% - let it not be half-baked.
Wishing you the best.

...Read more

Nayagam P

Nayagam P P  |10720 Answers  |Ask -

Career Counsellor - Answered on Sep 02, 2025

Career
Hello sir.... I wanted to pursue ba/bsc psychology from a rci approved college but I don't have any clearity that what should be right. Since I have passed 12th in this year only I have given my cuet but my marks where not that good to get into any college I have filled the form of Calcutta University where I can get addmission through my 12th marks that is 72% overall but I didn't get into any as I'm from general category and cut offs are high.. mop up rounds are still yet to happen. But I talked there.. there are barely some colleges which are serious about teaching psychology and I don't think I can get into some good college that's why I'm thinking to take a drop I don't want to still and abhi bhi looking for some colleges which maybe have seat vacant so that I can try to get into that.. i don't have any clarity regarding which is good govt college because I can't afford private colleges whose fees is that high for pursuing psycology if I'm taking a gap year
Ans: Ayushi, With 72% in Class XII, you meet eligibility for most RCI-approved undergraduate psychology programs, which typically require 50–55% in PCM/Science or Humanities and English proficiency. The Rehabilitation Council of India (RCI) mandates that psychology graduates from approved institutions can register as professionals, so ensure the college holds RCI recognition or operates under a parent university with RCI-approved syllabi.

In West Bengal, government options are limited. The closely watched University of Calcutta offers a three-year BA Psychology through its morning shift at Ashutosh College and evening shift at Surendranath College with cutoffs often around 80% in general category. Vacancy rounds sometimes dip to 70–72%, so mop-up rounds could open seats. Rabindra Bharati University provides BA Psychology via merit; its cutoff hovers near 75%. Vidyasagar University in Midnapore and North Bengal University at Jalpaiguri offer BSc Psychology with lower cutoffs (65–70%), making them accessible.

Government colleges in Northern India include University of Delhi’s Cluster Innovation Centre and Gargi College, both offering BA Psychology admissions purely on Class XII marks. Their cutoffs range from 85–90%, so direct admission is unlikely at 72%, though invitation to waitlists in niche sections (e.g., evening courses) can occur. Banaras Hindu University’s BSc Psychology has a 70–75% cutoff in mop-up rounds. Panjab University (Chandigarh) and Punjab University (Patiala) allow 65–70% entries in BSc Psychology programs. University of Lucknow and Aligarh Muslim University also admit on board marks, often requiring 70–75%.

Affordable private institutions in West Bengal with RCI-approved curricula include St. Xavier’s College, Kolkata, which conducts its own merit list and lowers cutoffs to 72% in later rounds. Presidency University also admits psychology undergraduates through its merit list. In North India, Christ University (Bengaluru campus) and Amity University offer scholarships to board-mark entrants drops seats for those without CUET scores, but fees remain higher. DAV College, Chandigarh, and Maitreyi College, Delhi, provide BA Psychology at moderate fees (?30,000–40,000 per year) based on 12th marks.

Practical Roadmap and Solutions
Track Mop-Up Rounds and Merit Lists: Immediately monitor UC, Rabindra Bharati, Presidency, and St. Xavier’s websites daily for vacancies. Prepare scanned documents for swift online submission.

Apply to Multiple Institutes: Simultaneously apply to Vidyasagar University, North Bengal University, BHU, Panjab University, and Lucknow University in their ongoing merit-based admission windows. Their lower cutoffs increase chances.

Secure Waiting-List Positions: For high-demand colleges like Calcutta University and Delhi University, join all available waitlists, including evening programmes, which often have softer cutoffs.

Explore Evening/Shift Courses: Many reputed institutions offer evening or self-financed sections with relaxed cutoffs. Investigate Ashutosh College evening shift, DU evening courses, and PU self-financed sections.

Financial Planning for Private Colleges: Shortlist affordable options Inquire about scholarships or fee-installment plans at DAV College Chandigarh and Maitreyi College to help mitigate costs.

Bridge Courses and Summer Programs: As you finalize admissions, consider enrolling in online certificate courses in introductory psychology, research methods, and statistics from platforms like NPTEL or Coursera to enhance your portfolio.

Consider Gap-Year Strategy: If no suitable seat materializes by mid-October, plan a structured gap year focused on significantly improving CUET scores. Engage in disciplined self-study with coaching for CUET’s aptitude, English, and psychology modules.

CUET Preparation: Develop a timetable allocating two hours daily for CUET Psychology syllabus (foundations, developmental, abnormal, social, and research methods) and one hour for General English and Logical Reasoning. Use previous years’ CUET papers and take weekly mocks to track progress.

Alternate Entrance Exams: Some private universities conduct their own entrance tests (Christ University’s CUCET, Amity’s AUEET). Register for these supplementary exams to widen your admission avenues.

Mentorship and Counseling: Seek guidance from academic mentors or a career counselor to evaluate admission offers, financial implications, and long-term career trajectories in clinical, counseling, or research psychology.

By following this multipronged approach—pursuing merit-based vacancies, evening/self-financed programs, affordable private colleges, and preparing for CUET retake if required—you can maximize your chances of enrolling in an RCI-approved psychology UG programme without forfeiting a year.

Exhaust mop-up and merit-based admission options in government and reputed private colleges by mid-October, while preparing a robust CUET retake plan during a potential gap year to secure admission into top-tier psychology programs. All the BEST for a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x