Dear Sir,
I am 50yrs old and may have one or two years of job.
My investment portfolio is 2.3 cr
11 Lakhs cash, 30 lakhs deposit,11 Lakhs corporate bonds,
2.5 Lakhs LIC, 7 Lakhs PPF,13 Lakhs SSY,72 Lakhs EPF,15 Lakhs SGB (203 units)
6 Lakhs icici health saver with ten lakhs health cover
55 Lakhs mf (11 funds, 22% debt, largecap 33,midcap 21, smallcap 9 ,others 18) with 30% depreciation for tax and market peak,
11 Lakhs shares with 30% depreciation for tax and market peak.
My monthly salary is 2Lakhs (1 lakh basic) after tax. Monthly expenses are 60000 Rs.
I am residing in own house with another house rented for 6k valued 50Lakhs
My kid is in tenth std.
I have no active SIP now. My employeer may for NPS next month.
Should I start a SIP in an index fund or should I park all my money in NPS.
Is my portfolio too scattered. Should I book profits in MF and move to an index fund or deposits?
Ans: You are 50 years old, potentially having 1-2 more years in your job. Your monthly salary is Rs 2 lakh, with Rs 1 lakh as basic income after tax. Your expenses are Rs 60,000, and you reside in your own home. You also rent out another house valued at Rs 50 lakh, generating Rs 6,000 monthly.
Your investment portfolio consists of:
Rs 2.3 crore in investments
Rs 11 lakh cash
Rs 30 lakh fixed deposits
Rs 11 lakh in corporate bonds
Rs 2.5 lakh in LIC
Rs 7 lakh in PPF
Rs 13 lakh in SSY
Rs 72 lakh in EPF
Rs 15 lakh in SGB (203 units)
Rs 55 lakh in mutual funds with 30% depreciation for tax and market peak
Rs 11 lakh in shares with 30% depreciation for tax and market peak
Rs 6 lakh in ICICI Health Saver with Rs 10 lakh health cover
Your employer may contribute to NPS soon, and you are considering starting a SIP in an index fund. You want to know whether your portfolio is too scattered and if you should book profits in mutual funds and move into safer options like deposits.
Let’s go step by step.
Portfolio Analysis
Your portfolio is well-diversified, but there is some room for simplification. Let’s evaluate your current holdings:
Cash and Fixed Deposits: Rs 11 lakh in cash and Rs 30 lakh in deposits are reasonable for liquidity. However, deposits don’t beat inflation over time. Consider shifting a part of these funds to higher-yielding options.
Corporate Bonds and LIC: Your Rs 11 lakh in corporate bonds offer decent returns but carry credit risk. LIC policies offer low returns. It may be worthwhile to evaluate the benefits of continuing LIC, considering the low returns. A Certified Financial Planner can help assess the surrender value and suggest better options.
PPF and SSY: These are safe and tax-free long-term instruments. They serve as a good part of your retirement and child’s education corpus. Continue holding these.
EPF: With Rs 72 lakh, your EPF offers stability and tax benefits. It's a strong foundation for retirement planning.
Sovereign Gold Bonds (SGB): Rs 15 lakh in SGB (203 units) is a solid hedge against inflation. Keep this as part of your portfolio for the long term.
Mutual Funds and Shares: You have Rs 55 lakh in mutual funds across 11 schemes and Rs 11 lakh in shares. With 30% depreciation for tax and market peak, your equity exposure is subject to market volatility. Let's dive into these categories for a detailed understanding.
Mutual Fund Portfolio Assessment
Your mutual fund portfolio is diversified across large-cap (33%), mid-cap (21%), small-cap (9%), debt (22%), and others (18%). Having exposure to large, mid, and small caps is good for growth potential. However, 11 funds can make the portfolio scattered and harder to manage.
Key Insights on Mutual Fund Portfolio:
Actively Managed Funds Over Index Funds: You’re considering starting a SIP in an index fund. However, index funds simply mirror the market and don’t offer the flexibility of active management. In actively managed funds, professional fund managers make strategic decisions to outperform the market. Over time, this approach can offer better returns, especially in volatile markets.
Regular Funds Over Direct Funds: If you're investing in direct mutual funds, you miss out on personalized advice. Regular funds, through an MFD or a Certified Financial Planner, provide ongoing guidance, performance tracking, and portfolio adjustments. This can help you stay on track with your financial goals.
Booking Profits: Considering the market volatility and potential peaks, booking partial profits in your mutual fund portfolio could be wise. However, instead of moving completely into safe options like deposits, consider a mix of debt mutual funds for stability and equity mutual funds for long-term growth. This will balance your risk and reward.
Shares: Managing Depreciation
Your Rs 11 lakh in shares has depreciated by 30%. Rather than panicking, assess whether these stocks still have long-term growth potential. If they are fundamentally strong, holding on to them could allow for a market recovery. If the fundamentals are weak, consider exiting and reallocating those funds into more stable investments like mutual funds or bonds.
Should You Invest in NPS?
Your employer may soon start contributing to the National Pension System (NPS). NPS is a good retirement planning tool as it offers tax benefits and helps accumulate a pension corpus. However, NPS has a long lock-in period until the age of 60, and part of the withdrawal is taxable. Given your existing corpus in EPF and other investments, you could limit NPS contributions and focus more on investments that offer better liquidity and tax efficiency.
SIP Decision: Is an Index Fund Ideal?
While you are contemplating starting a SIP in an index fund, it may not be the most effective strategy for your retirement planning. Here's why:
Disadvantages of Index Funds: Index funds offer market returns, but they cannot beat the market. In volatile or down-trending markets, index funds may underperform. They also lack the flexibility that actively managed funds provide, where fund managers make decisions based on market trends and opportunities.
Benefits of Actively Managed Funds: Actively managed funds have the potential to outperform benchmarks. Fund managers make informed decisions to protect your capital and seek growth opportunities. This is especially important when you are nearing retirement and cannot afford significant market downturns.
You should consider a mix of actively managed funds rather than relying solely on index funds.
Health Cover: Adequacy and Enhancement
Your current health cover is Rs 10 lakh through ICICI Health Saver. This is good, but with rising healthcare costs, you may want to consider enhancing your health cover to at least Rs 25 lakh. Health emergencies can severely impact your retirement corpus if you don’t have adequate coverage.
Emergency Fund
Your Rs 11 lakh cash reserve serves as an emergency fund. This is sufficient for now, given that your monthly expenses are Rs 60,000. Aim to keep at least 6-12 months’ worth of expenses as an emergency fund. Any excess cash can be invested for better returns.
Child’s Education Planning
Your child is in 10th standard, and you’ll need to start planning for their higher education soon. The Rs 13 lakh in SSY and Rs 7 lakh in PPF are good instruments for this. However, depending on the cost of education, you may need to build a larger corpus. Consider supplementing these investments with child-focused mutual funds or equity funds with a horizon of 5-7 years.
Final Insights
You have built a strong portfolio, but there are areas where you can improve:
Simplify your mutual fund portfolio: Reduce the number of schemes and focus on actively managed funds rather than index funds. Booking some profits may be wise, but don’t move completely into safe assets like deposits.
NPS Contribution: Contribute to NPS but don’t park all your money there. You need liquidity and flexibility, which NPS lacks.
Shares: Hold on to fundamentally strong stocks or exit weak ones. Reallocate those funds into more stable options if needed.
Health Cover: Consider increasing your health insurance to safeguard your retirement corpus against medical emergencies.
Child’s Education: Build a dedicated corpus for your child’s education through long-term investments.
By taking these steps, you can align your portfolio for steady growth, manage risk effectively, and ensure a comfortable retirement in the next few years.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment