I have paid 30 lakhs at 6 lakhs annually in SBI smart privilege LP for 5 years. It is complete now as on date. Is it worth to continue in it or withdraw and invest in MF for good returns in 3 years

Ans: Hello Debasish. Your portfolio report sounds good. I can see that 100% of the investments are in SBI AMC. Hence, will suggest AMC-wise bifurcation for future investment. You can reshuffle the current SIPs or start investing in AMCs like ICICI Pru, Nippon, Parag Parikh, etc. AMC diversification is also required in your portfolio.

Ans: You have a Unit Linked Insurance Plan (ULIP) with SBI Life - Smart Privilege LP, which you started in 2017. You paid Rs. 6 lakhs annually for five years, totaling Rs. 30 lakhs. The current value of your policy is Rs. 72 lakhs. Your allocation is 70% in Midcap, 5% in Balanced Fund, 20% in Equity Growth Fund, and 5% in Top 300 Fund.

You aim to receive Rs. 75,000 monthly. Let's explore whether it's better to continue with the ULIP or switch to Mutual Funds with a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP).

Performance and Structure of ULIPs
ULIPs combine insurance and investment. Your policy has done well, growing from Rs. 30 lakhs to Rs. 72 lakhs. This growth indicates a good performance. ULIPs offer life cover, which provides financial security to your family in case of your untimely demise.

The charges in ULIPs include premium allocation, fund management, mortality, and policy administration. These charges can impact returns over the long term. Despite these charges, your policy has performed admirably.

Evaluating Mutual Funds with SWP
Mutual Funds are solely investment products, without an insurance component. They typically have lower charges compared to ULIPs. Actively managed Mutual Funds allow flexibility and can be tailored to meet your risk profile and investment goals.

A Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) allows you to withdraw a fixed amount regularly from your Mutual Fund investment. This can provide a steady monthly income. With an SWP, you can plan for Rs. 75,000 monthly withdrawals.

Risk and Return Assessment
You mentioned that you are not worried about risk. Both ULIPs and Mutual Funds can be tailored to match your risk appetite. In your ULIP, 70% is in Midcap, which is high-risk but high-reward. A similar allocation in Mutual Funds can potentially yield better returns due to lower costs.

Mutual Funds provide diversification and professional management. You can choose a mix of Equity, Balanced, and Debt funds to match your risk profile. With the right selection, Mutual Funds can outperform ULIPs over the long term.

Tax Implications
ULIPs have a tax advantage under Section 80C for premiums paid and Section 10(10D) for maturity proceeds. Mutual Funds also offer tax benefits, particularly Equity Linked Savings Schemes (ELSS) under Section 80C.

However, the tax treatment on withdrawals differs. Withdrawals from Mutual Funds are subject to capital gains tax. Long-term capital gains (LTCG) on equity funds are taxed at 10% above Rs. 1 lakh. Short-term capital gains (STCG) are taxed at 15%.

For debt funds, LTCG is taxed at 20% with indexation, and STCG is taxed as per your income slab. It's essential to consider these tax implications when planning your SWP.

Costs and Charges
ULIPs have higher costs due to the insurance component and various charges. These charges can eat into your returns over time. Mutual Funds have lower costs, primarily the expense ratio. By investing through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP), you can benefit from professional advice and potentially better fund selection.

Direct Mutual Funds have lower expense ratios than regular plans. However, investing through a CFP can provide personalized advice, which can enhance your returns and help in achieving your financial goals.

Liquidity and Flexibility
Mutual Funds offer better liquidity compared to ULIPs. You can redeem your Mutual Fund units partially or fully at any time. ULIPs have a lock-in period, typically five years, limiting liquidity.

The flexibility in Mutual Funds allows you to switch between funds without charges, unlike ULIPs which may have switching charges. This flexibility can help you adapt your portfolio to changing market conditions and personal circumstances.

Benefits of Staying with ULIP
Your ULIP has performed well, doubling in value. Continuing with the ULIP can provide continued life cover and potential tax benefits. If you value the insurance component and the current performance, staying invested might be beneficial.

However, consider reviewing the fund performance periodically and reassess the charges. If the charges start to outweigh the benefits, it might be time to consider switching.

Transitioning to Mutual Funds
Switching to Mutual Funds with an SWP can provide a steady income and potentially higher returns due to lower costs. Here's how you can proceed:

Evaluate Your Goals: Ensure that Rs. 75,000 monthly is realistic based on your corpus and expected returns.
Select Funds Carefully: Choose a mix of equity, balanced, and debt funds to match your risk profile.
Plan Withdrawals: Set up an SWP to provide the desired monthly income. Review and adjust periodically.
Consult a CFP: A Certified Financial Planner can help optimize your portfolio and ensure it aligns with your goals.
Transition Strategy
If you decide to switch, do it gradually to avoid market timing risks. Redeem your ULIP in phases and invest in Mutual Funds systematically. This strategy can help mitigate market volatility.

Ensure that your new investments are diversified. A mix of large-cap, mid-cap, and debt funds can provide stability and growth. Regularly review and rebalance your portfolio to stay aligned with your goals.

Final Insights
Your ULIP has done well, and it offers insurance cover and tax benefits. However, the high charges can impact long-term returns. Mutual Funds with an SWP offer flexibility, potentially higher returns, and lower costs.

Evaluate your goals, risk profile, and tax implications carefully. Consult a Certified Financial Planner to help make an informed decision. A gradual transition to Mutual Funds can provide the desired monthly income and better long-term growth.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP

Chief Financial Planner

www.holisticinvestment.in

Ans: It’s great that you are taking steps to understand and improve your investments. You have invested Rs 6 lakhs per year in the SBI Life Smart Privilege policy, with a total investment of Rs 18 lakhs over three years. The current fund value is Rs 19.9 lakhs.

This policy invests in 70% bond funds and 30% bond optimiser funds. Now, they suggest shifting to a 100% mid-cap fund.

Understanding the Current Fund Performance

Your investment has grown from Rs 18 lakhs to Rs 19.9 lakhs in three years. This indicates a modest return. The current fund allocation in bond funds and bond optimiser funds typically yields lower returns compared to equity funds. This might be why the growth has been slower than expected.

Disadvantages of Mixing Insurance with Investment

It’s crucial to understand that insurance and investment serve different purposes. Insurance is meant for protection, while investment is for wealth creation. Mixing these often leads to suboptimal results for both.

Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) like the one you have, combine insurance with investment. The charges involved can be high, and the returns may not be as attractive compared to other investment options like mutual funds.

Considering the Shift to Mid-Cap Funds

Mid-cap funds have the potential for higher returns. However, they also come with higher risk. The suggestion to move your investment to a 100% mid-cap fund could improve your returns but will also increase volatility. Since you have a lock-in period of five years, you cannot withdraw without penalty until then.

Exploring Mutual Funds as an Alternative

Mutual funds can be a better investment option for wealth creation. They offer a variety of funds catering to different risk profiles and investment goals. If you plan to withdraw your investment after five years, you can consider mutual funds for your future investments.

Benefits of Actively Managed Funds

Actively managed funds are overseen by professional fund managers who aim to outperform the market. These funds can provide higher returns compared to passive funds like index funds, which only track a market index.

Fund managers of actively managed funds perform thorough research and analysis to select stocks, adjust the portfolio based on market conditions, and capitalize on investment opportunities. This active management can result in better performance, especially in volatile markets.

Disadvantages of Index Funds

Index funds aim to replicate the performance of a specific index. While they have lower management fees, they lack the potential for higher returns. Index funds are limited to the stocks within the index and cannot exploit opportunities outside the index. Additionally, index funds cannot outperform the market; they can only match the market's performance, minus the fees.

Disadvantages of Direct Funds

Investing in direct funds without professional guidance can be risky. Without expert advice, you might make poor investment choices. Regular funds through a Mutual Fund Distributor (MFD) with a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) provide the advantage of professional advice. This can help in selecting the right funds, monitoring your investments, and making necessary adjustments.

Evaluating Your Options Moving Forward

Stay Invested in the Current Policy:

Consider staying invested in the current policy until the lock-in period ends.
This avoids penalties and makes use of the current investment.
Shift to Mid-Cap Funds:

Moving your existing investment to 100% mid-cap funds could improve returns.
Understand the associated risks and be prepared for higher volatility.
Plan for Post-Lock-In Investments:

Once the lock-in period ends, plan to withdraw and invest in mutual funds.
Consider a diversified portfolio based on your risk tolerance and financial goals.
Planning Your Mutual Fund Investments

When the lock-in period ends, and you consider investing Rs 30 lakhs in mutual funds, follow these steps:

Assess Your Risk Tolerance:

Understand your risk tolerance level.
Choose a mix of equity and debt funds based on your risk profile.
Set Financial Goals:

Define your financial goals, such as retirement, children's education, or buying a house.
This helps in selecting the right funds.
Diversify Your Portfolio:

Diversify across different types of mutual funds, such as large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap, and debt funds.
This spreads the risk and maximizes returns.
Consult a Certified Financial Planner:

Seek professional advice from a CFP.
They can help design a personalized investment plan, monitor your portfolio, and make necessary adjustments.
Building a Diversified Mutual Fund Portfolio

Large-Cap Funds:

Invest in large-cap funds for stability and moderate returns.
These funds invest in large, well-established companies.
Mid-Cap and Small-Cap Funds:

Allocate a portion to mid-cap and small-cap funds for higher growth potential.
These funds invest in medium-sized and smaller companies, which can offer higher returns but come with higher risks.
Debt Funds:

Include debt funds for stability and regular income.
These funds invest in fixed-income securities like bonds.
Balanced or Hybrid Funds:

Consider balanced or hybrid funds that invest in a mix of equity and debt.
These funds offer a balanced approach with moderate risk and returns.
Regular Monitoring and Rebalancing

Regularly monitor your mutual fund investments to ensure they align with your financial goals. Rebalance your portfolio periodically to maintain the desired asset allocation. This involves selling some overperforming assets and buying underperforming ones.

Building Good Financial Habits

Develop good financial habits to achieve long-term financial goals. These include:

Living Within Your Means:

Avoid overspending and live within your income.
Saving Regularly:

Save a portion of your income regularly.
Automate your savings to ensure consistency.
Avoiding High-Interest Debt:

Stay away from high-interest debt like credit card debt.
Investing Wisely:

Make informed investment decisions based on your risk tolerance and financial goals.
Importance of Financial Education

Enhancing your financial literacy empowers you to make informed decisions. Learn about different investment options, market trends, and financial planning strategies. This knowledge helps you take control of your financial future.

Engaging with a Certified Financial Planner

A Certified Financial Planner can provide valuable guidance. They offer personalized advice, help you design a comprehensive financial plan, and assist in selecting suitable investments. Engaging with a CFP ensures that your investments align with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Considering Tax Implications

Understand the tax implications of your investments. Different investments have different tax treatments. For example, long-term capital gains from equity mutual funds are taxed at a lower rate than short-term gains. A CFP can help you design a tax-efficient investment strategy.

Final Insights

You have made a significant investment in the SBI Life Smart Privilege policy. The returns have been modest due to the fund allocation. Considering a shift to mid-cap funds could improve returns but also increases risk. Once the lock-in period ends, consider diversifying your investments into mutual funds.

Engage with a Certified Financial Planner to create a personalized investment plan. Regularly monitor and rebalance your portfolio to stay aligned with your financial goals. Enhance your financial literacy to make informed decisions. Developing good financial habits and staying disciplined will help you achieve your long-term financial goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

Ans: At the age of 64, it is important to carefully assess the effectiveness of your financial strategies. You have been investing Rs. 2,00,000 annually into the SBI Life Retired Smart Policy since 2019. Now that your last premium has been paid in September 2024, the key question is whether you should continue with this policy or shift to other investment options like mutual funds. Let’s evaluate this from various perspectives to guide you in making an informed decision.

Understanding Your Policy Structure
This policy is a ULIP (Unit-Linked Insurance Plan), which offers life cover as well as investment benefits. However, ULIPs often have a high-cost structure, including premium allocation charges, fund management fees, and mortality charges, especially in the early years of the policy. This affects the overall returns.

Now that you have completed five years of premium payments, you might have overcome the high initial costs. Let’s break down the key factors:

Premium Paid: You have paid Rs. 2,00,000 annually for 5 years, which amounts to Rs. 10,00,000 in total.

Policy Period: It is a 10-year policy, and you are halfway through. You still have 5 years remaining.

Returns: ULIP returns are linked to the performance of the funds you are invested in, which could be either equity, debt, or balanced. These returns vary, and ULIPs typically do not outperform mutual funds due to higher costs.

Let’s now weigh the pros and cons of continuing with your policy.

Benefits of Continuing the SBI Life Retired Smart Policy
There are a few advantages to staying with the current policy, especially since you have already paid 5 years of premiums.

Life Insurance Coverage: The policy provides life cover, which can be a key benefit if you do not have adequate life insurance coverage. However, at the age of 64, the need for life insurance generally reduces unless you have dependents.

Completion of Lock-in Period: You have completed the lock-in period, so you can exit without penalties if needed. You also avoid the heavy initial charges that were already deducted in the early years.

Tax Benefits: The premiums paid provide tax benefits under Section 80C, and the maturity proceeds could be tax-free under Section 10(10D), subject to conditions. However, these tax benefits alone may not justify continuing the policy if the returns are subpar.

Disadvantages of Continuing the SBI Life Retired Smart Policy
On the flip side, there are several reasons why continuing with the policy might not be the best decision for you.

High Charges: ULIPs come with several charges, such as fund management fees, mortality charges, and policy administration fees. These charges reduce the overall return on your investment. Mutual funds, in comparison, tend to have lower fees, especially if you invest through a certified financial planner.

Limited Flexibility: In a ULIP, you are limited to the funds offered by the insurance company. These funds may not have the same performance or diversity as mutual funds managed by top fund houses. Actively managed mutual funds have a proven track record of generating superior returns over the long term due to the expertise of professional fund managers.

Mediocre Returns: Most ULIPs deliver lower returns than mutual funds, primarily due to their cost structure. You might have experienced average growth in your policy, which could affect your retirement planning.

Lack of Liquidity: ULIPs typically do not offer liquidity until the end of the policy term, whereas mutual funds provide better flexibility, allowing you to redeem funds when needed.

Exploring Mutual Fund Investments
Switching to mutual funds could be a better strategy at this stage, given that you’ve completed 5 years in the ULIP. Here are the advantages of transitioning to mutual funds:

Higher Returns Potential: Actively managed mutual funds have consistently outperformed ULIPs due to their lower cost structure and professional fund management. You can invest in funds that suit your risk profile, whether equity, hybrid, or debt funds.

Better Flexibility: Mutual funds offer the flexibility to switch between different types of funds based on your financial goals. This flexibility is lacking in ULIPs, which have a rigid structure.

Low Costs: Mutual funds, especially through a certified financial planner, have much lower expense ratios than ULIPs. This ensures that a larger portion of your investment goes toward earning returns rather than paying fees.

Tax Efficiency: With the new tax rules for mutual funds, long-term capital gains (LTCG) on equity mutual funds above Rs. 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%, while short-term capital gains (STCG) are taxed at 20%. Debt mutual funds are taxed according to your income tax slab. Despite these tax implications, mutual funds may still offer better post-tax returns compared to ULIPs.

Disadvantages of Index Funds and Direct Funds
While you might be tempted to explore index funds or direct mutual fund investments, they have certain limitations.

Index Funds: These funds replicate market indices like Nifty or Sensex. However, they do not offer the potential to outperform the market. Actively managed funds, on the other hand, have the ability to generate higher returns by capitalising on market opportunities. Given that your policy period has another 5 years, you may benefit more from actively managed funds than passive index funds.

Direct Funds: While direct funds have lower expense ratios than regular funds, they may not be ideal for everyone. Without professional advice, it can be challenging to choose the right funds and manage your portfolio effectively. Investing through a certified financial planner ensures that you receive expert advice, helping you achieve better long-term results.

Should You Surrender the Policy?
Given the analysis above, surrendering the SBI Life Retired Smart Policy and reinvesting in mutual funds could offer you better returns, lower costs, and more flexibility. However, it is important to consider the following before making a decision:

Surrender Charges: Check if there are any surrender charges applicable to your policy. If these charges are high, you may want to wait until the policy matures to avoid any penalties.

Tax Implications: While the premiums paid are eligible for tax deductions, the maturity proceeds might also be tax-exempt. However, surrendering the policy could lead to tax implications, so it’s important to consult with a certified financial planner to understand the tax impact.

Alternative Investment: If you decide to exit the policy, mutual funds offer a diverse range of options tailored to your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Final Insights
In summary, your decision to continue or exit the SBI Life Retired Smart Policy depends on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment strategy.

The policy has provided life insurance coverage and tax benefits, but its returns may be limited due to high charges.

By switching to mutual funds, you can potentially achieve higher returns, lower costs, and better flexibility for your remaining investment horizon.

Avoid index funds and direct funds in favour of actively managed mutual funds through a certified financial planner to get the best results for your retirement planning.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment