Hi, My in-hand salary is 120000, I am investing 40000 per month in SIP. 12000 rent, 20000 household expenses, 10000 kids school expenses, 20000 other expenses. I have a 40000 of premium in LIC per year. I am looking for buying a house, it cost around 70 lakh, what I can do please suggest me, I don't have down payment with me other than 10 lakh in mutual funds. Please suggest me what I can do. Go for new house with using investments or better stay in rented house.
Ans: You are earning Rs. 1,20,000 monthly. Your SIP investments are Rs. 40,000. Your rent is Rs. 12,000. Household and personal costs add up to Rs. 50,000. You also pay Rs. 40,000 yearly LIC premium. You are planning to buy a house worth Rs. 70 lakh. You only have Rs. 10 lakh in mutual funds as savings. You are unsure if buying is the right step now.
This is a very practical question. It’s good that you are evaluating before acting. You are already saving a solid 33% of income monthly. That is rare and very responsible. You also manage to balance kids' school fees, rent, and regular expenses. Let’s take a 360-degree view of your finances before deciding.
Cash Flow Snapshot: Where You Stand Today
Let us break down your monthly cash flow to get a complete view.
In-hand Salary: Rs. 1,20,000
SIPs: Rs. 40,000
Rent: Rs. 12,000
Household Expenses: Rs. 20,000
Children's School Fees: Rs. 10,000
Other Expenses: Rs. 20,000
Total Outgo: Rs. 1,02,000
Balance Left: Rs. 18,000 monthly
So, after expenses and SIPs, your savings buffer is only Rs. 18,000.
This remaining amount is too low to afford any EMI at this stage. A loan EMI for Rs. 60 lakh house loan will easily be Rs. 50,000+ monthly. This will create heavy strain.
Reviewing the House Buying Plan
You are planning to buy a house for Rs. 70 lakh. You have Rs. 10 lakh in mutual funds. This is your only source for down payment.
Let’s look at possible scenarios if you proceed with buying.
Minimum Down Payment
For Rs. 70 lakh house, lenders need 15-20% down
This means you need Rs. 10.5 to 14 lakh upfront
You only have Rs. 10 lakh. It is not enough.
Using your mutual fund savings will fully exhaust your reserves.
This is risky. It leaves no emergency fund. It leaves no flexibility.
Home Loan EMI Burden
Rs. 60 lakh loan means EMI of Rs. 50,000–55,000 per month
Your monthly surplus after current SIPs and expenses is only Rs. 18,000
You will need to stop SIPs and even reduce household spending
That will hurt long-term wealth building. You may also default during job loss or salary cuts.
Emergency Fund Risk
Using your entire Rs. 10 lakh mutual fund for down payment is very risky.
You will have zero backup for medical or job issues.
That is not advisable at this stage of life with kids' needs.
LIC Premium: Should You Keep or Exit?
You pay Rs. 40,000 per year to LIC. Please check if it is a traditional endowment or money-back plan. If yes, you may be earning low returns (around 4-5%).
These policies are not suitable for wealth creation
If you have held them for more than 5–6 years, check surrender value
You can consider surrendering and reinvesting the proceeds in mutual funds
Term insurance is better and cheaper for protection
But only make this switch after guidance from a Certified Financial Planner.
Staying in Rented House: Benefits at Present
Let’s compare if you continue in rent instead of buying now.
Your current rent is only Rs. 12,000. It is low and manageable.
You are able to invest Rs. 40,000 in mutual funds every month
You are building long-term wealth steadily
You are avoiding big EMI pressure and mental stress
Right now, this is more financially stable. Renting is not bad when it lets you invest and grow wealth. Owning a house is a good dream. But timing must be right.
Mutual Funds: Why You Must Continue Them
You are already investing Rs. 40,000 monthly. This shows discipline.
Please do not break these mutual funds for house buying.
Why?
These funds are working toward your long-term wealth
You get compounding benefits with time
Redeeming them early will lose growth
Using them for down payment will reduce your investment power
Your mutual funds are like a personal wealth engine. Do not break the engine for a one-time need.
Also, avoid direct funds without expert guidance. Direct funds have no help from MFDs. If market falls, you may not know what to do. Regular plans through Certified Financial Planners offer guidance. This helps protect your capital.
Actively managed funds are better than index funds. Index funds only copy the market. They can’t protect during big crashes. Active fund managers adjust portfolios. That protects your goals better.
If You Still Want to Own a House
You may still have a strong desire to own. That is understandable. But instead of rushing, follow this phased approach.
Step 1: Build Your Down Payment First
Target saving Rs. 15–20 lakh for down payment
Start a separate SIP for this purpose
Invest Rs. 20,000 per month toward this goal
Choose debt and balanced mutual funds for this
It will take 4–5 years to build this fund. This is safer than loaning now.
During this time, you continue renting and investing.
Step 2: Increase Emergency Fund
Keep 6 months' expenses as buffer
For your case, build Rs. 3–4 lakh in liquid fund or bank RD
This helps handle job loss or medical emergency
Don't proceed with big EMIs before this buffer is ready.
Step 3: Review Home Plan After 4–5 Years
By then:
Your income will likely rise
Your SIPs will grow wealth
You may have Rs. 20 lakh ready for down
You can afford smaller loan
EMI will fit within your budget
This gives more peace of mind. You don’t compromise kids’ future or your own retirement.
Retirement and Children’s Future Goals
Please remember:
Kids’ education costs grow very fast
Your retirement needs are also big and long-term
If you buy a house now, you will cut your SIPs
This weakens retirement and children’s goals
You are still young. You have time to grow wealth through SIPs. Don’t rush to buy a house by sacrificing your financial future.
Stay invested. Grow your SIP. After 5 years, evaluate again with your Certified Financial Planner.
Tax View on Mutual Fund Redemptions
If you sell mutual funds now:
Equity fund gains above Rs. 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5% (LTCG)
Gains below 1 year are taxed at 20% (STCG)
Debt fund gains taxed as per income slab
Selling mutual funds means paying these taxes. You also lose future growth.
It is not the right time to exit.
What You Should Do Now – 360° Plan
Here is a full plan based on your goals and current stage.
Stay in rented house for next 4–5 years
Don’t use current mutual funds for house buying
Start new SIP for house goal: Rs. 20,000 monthly
Keep current SIPs for wealth creation
Build emergency fund up to Rs. 4 lakh
Review LIC plans with a Certified Financial Planner
Surrender low-return plans, if suitable, and invest better
Upgrade term and health insurance for full coverage
Review your cash flow yearly with your Certified Financial Planner
This plan balances your dreams with your responsibilities. You protect your future. You keep kids’ goals safe. You buy a house when truly ready.
Finally
Right now, avoid buying house with loan
Continue your current rent and SIPs
Start a fresh SIP for house fund
Build a buffer before big EMI decisions
Keep investing for children’s and your future
Don’t redeem mutual funds now
Revisit house goal after 4–5 years
Take support from a Certified Financial Planner regularly
You are already doing many things right. Keep this discipline. Stay patient. Your house dream will become real at the right time—without risk to your goals.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment