Flexi cap =14000,
HDFC Balance Advantage Fund - Direct plan- Growth = 2000
Lage and Midcap Fund= 6500
Midcap Fund= 3000
Nifty Smallcap 250 Index Fund= 1000
Small Cap= 2500
Nifty 500 Momentum 50 ETF= 1000
Sector Fund ( Energy + Bussniss Cycle )= 3000
Current Corpus = 9 lakh , one home loan 8.50L ( 2 kids= 14 and 6 old)
2Cr after 15 years and 50 lakh after 10 years , plz suggest
Ans: You are already investing in multiple mutual funds. Your target corpus is Rs?2?crore in 15 years and Rs?50?lakh in 10 years. You also have a home loan of Rs?8.5?lakh and 2 kids aged 14 and 6.
Let’s assess your situation and restructure it with a 360-degree, goal-oriented, simple language plan.
? Understand Your Monthly SIP Structure
– Flexi Cap: Rs?14,000
– Balanced Advantage: Rs?2,000
– Large & Mid Cap: Rs?6,500
– Mid Cap: Rs?3,000
– Small Cap: Rs?2,500
– Nifty Smallcap 250 Index: Rs?1,000
– Nifty 500 Momentum 50 ETF: Rs?1,000
– Sector Funds (Energy + Business Cycle): Rs?3,000
Total SIP: Rs?33,000 per month. Corpus now is Rs?9?lakh.
? First Issue: Over-diversified Fund Portfolio
– You are in too many funds.
– Some of them are overlapping.
– Index and ETF investments also dilute focus.
– Sector funds and thematic funds are not suitable for goal planning.
– They are risky and not diversified.
Having 7–8 funds increases confusion, not returns.
? Second Issue: You Hold Index and ETF Funds
– Nifty Smallcap 250 Index is unmanaged and volatile.
– It tracks the index without protection.
– ETF (Momentum 50) also depends on short-term trends.
– They work only in rising markets.
– In flat or falling markets, they drop fast.
Actively managed funds are better for long-term goals.
A Certified Financial Planner can guide your allocation.
? Third Issue: Sector and Theme-Based Funds
– Sector funds are risky and cyclical.
– Energy or Business Cycle funds are for advanced investors.
– They are not suitable for education or retirement goals.
– Sectors may underperform for long periods.
– You don't need them for goal-based planning.
Better to exit sector funds and shift to core diversified equity.
? Fourth Issue: Lack of Defined Goal Buckets
– You aim for Rs?50?lakh in 10 years.
– You also aim for Rs?2?crore in 15 years.
– But the current fund setup doesn’t align clearly.
– You must split SIPs for each goal.
– Each goal should have its own mix of funds.
Without goal buckets, tracking and reviewing becomes difficult.
? Fifth Issue: No Mention of Emergency Fund
– You have a home loan to repay.
– You have school-going kids.
– But there is no emergency buffer shown.
– Emergency fund should be equal to 6–12 months’ expenses.
– Park this in liquid or ultra-short term funds.
Emergency savings protect investments from being disturbed.
? Suggested Mutual Fund Portfolio Restructuring
Let us simplify your SIP basket.
Remove these from portfolio:
– Nifty Smallcap 250 Index
– Momentum 50 ETF
– Both Sector funds
Keep and continue:
– Flexi Cap Fund
– Large & Mid Cap Fund
– Mid Cap Fund
– Balanced Advantage Fund
– Small Cap Fund (with smaller exposure)
Now divide SIPs in buckets:
For Rs?50?Lakh Goal in 10 Years:
– Large & Mid Cap Fund (Rs?7,000)
– Flexi Cap Fund (Rs?7,000)
– Balanced Advantage Fund (Rs?3,000)
Total = Rs?17,000/month
For Rs?2?Crore Goal in 15 Years:
– Mid Cap Fund (Rs?4,000)
– Small Cap Fund (Rs?3,000)
– Flexi Cap Fund (Rs?3,000)
– Large & Mid Cap Fund (Rs?3,000)
– Balanced Advantage Fund (Rs?3,000)
Total = Rs?16,000/month
This separation makes goal tracking clear and efficient.
? Continue SIPs Through Regular Plans via MFD
– Direct plans lack support.
– Regular plans through a CFP or MFD give guidance.
– Helps manage volatility and stay invested.
– Better asset allocation and exit strategy.
Emotional discipline and handholding increase wealth over years.
? Equity Mutual Fund Taxation
– Long Term Capital Gains (LTCG) above Rs?1.25?lakh/year taxed at 12.5%.
– Short-term gains taxed at 20%.
– Plan redemptions smartly to reduce tax burden.
A Certified Financial Planner can optimise exit strategy for minimum tax.
? Home Loan vs Investment
– Your home loan is Rs?8.5?lakh.
– Don’t prepay aggressively.
– Let SIPs run and grow long-term wealth.
– Only part-prepay if cash is idle.
Low-interest home loans help create tax benefits.
? Children’s Education Planning
– Elder child may need college funds in 4 years.
– Use part of your Rs?9?lakh corpus here.
– Shift Rs?3–4?lakh to a short-term debt fund.
– This keeps funds safe and ready.
Don’t keep child education corpus in equity now.
? Retirement Planning Outlook
– Rs?2?crore goal in 15 years is achievable with Rs?16k/month SIP.
– You must increase SIP every year.
– Even a 5–10% increase can improve returns.
– Your EPF/PPF can also support retirement corpus.
Combine mutual funds with PF benefits for better retirement readiness.
? Insurance Protection Review
– No mention of term insurance.
– Buy Rs?1 crore term plan now.
– You have 2 kids and a home loan.
– This is non-negotiable.
– Premium is low if taken early.
Separate protection gives peace of mind to family.
? Importance of Annual Review
– Fund performance needs yearly check.
– Some funds may need to be changed.
– Risk appetite may change.
– Goals may shift.
Annual check with Certified Financial Planner keeps your plan healthy.
? Final Insights
– Reduce the number of funds to avoid overlap.
– Exit index, ETF, and sector funds.
– Focus only on actively managed, diversified equity mutual funds.
– Make separate SIPs for each goal.
– Continue home loan EMIs, avoid prepaying.
– Build emergency fund now.
– Use regular mutual fund plans via CFP or MFD.
– Start term insurance immediately.
– Review fund performance and progress every year.
You have a solid start. A clear structure and consistent investing will achieve both your goals safely.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment
Asked on - Jul 15, 2025 | Answered on Jul 15, 2025
i am 41 old, , salary - 140000 in hand, mediclaim = 10 lakh, Term insurance = 1CR, no emergency fund ( i want to create this, but dont know how and where to invest this?)
Ans: ? Emergency Fund: Why It’s Important
– You have kids and a loan.
– You also have monthly expenses.
– Emergency fund gives peace in job loss or health issue.
– It avoids breaking mutual funds or PPF.
– It is your financial safety cushion.
? How Much to Keep in Emergency Fund
– Minimum 6 months of monthly expenses.
– Ideal: 9 to 12 months if job is risky.
– You earn Rs?1.4 lakh monthly.
– So keep around Rs?8–10 lakh in emergency fund.
Start with Rs?2–3 lakh now and build rest over time.
? Where to Park Emergency Fund
– Keep 30% in savings account.
– Keep 70% in liquid mutual funds.
– Liquid funds give better returns than savings.
– No lock-in. Withdrawal in 1 day.
– Easy to access anytime.
Don't use FD. It has penalty on early withdrawal.
? How to Build Emergency Fund Step by Step
– Start SIP of Rs?5,000–Rs?10,000 in liquid fund.
– Use your annual bonus or extra income.
– Pause other unimportant expenses for few months.
– Don’t invest emergency money in equity or PPF.
– Keep this money separate, don’t mix with other goals.
Goal is safety, not high return.
? Best Way to Start
– Begin with Rs?2 lakh in savings + liquid fund mix.
– Slowly build to Rs?8–10 lakh.
– Use a regular mutual fund plan with a trusted MFD.
– Review the emergency fund yearly.
Once ready, it will protect your full financial plan.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment
Asked on - Jul 16, 2025 | Answered on Jul 16, 2025
sir plz suggest any liquid fund for create emergency fund? further i have 5 fund in Flexi and 2 Fund in Large and Midcap, further wht if i have a single SIP either in Flexi of Large n midcap, instead of 2, and when i required 50lakh after 10 years , then i withdrawal from that sip?
Ans: Emergency Fund:
Park 30% in a savings account and 70% in a liquid mutual fund (regular plan, growth option). Liquid funds offer next-day liquidity, better than savings interest, and no lock-in.
On SIP Consolidation:
Yes, you can hold just one well-managed Flexi-cap or Large & Midcap fund instead of two. This reduces overlap. For your 10-year ?50L goal, keep investing in this fund and redeem gradually when the goal nears.
For specific scheme recommendations, please contact an MFD, CFP, or connect via the website in the signature below.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment
Asked on - Jul 22, 2025 | Answered on Jul 22, 2025
sir, how about NIPPON INDIA ETF NIFTY 50 BeES with monthly SIP of 2000k for investment , and which is better, this or MF ?
Ans: ? Difference Between ETF and Mutual Fund
– ETFs track index without active management.
– Mutual Funds are managed by expert fund managers.
– ETF returns follow index ups and downs.
– Mutual funds aim to beat the index.
– ETFs require demat and trading account.
– Mutual funds are easy to invest via SIP.
– ETFs lack advisory support.
– Mutual funds offer handholding through Certified Financial Planner.
– ETFs suit market-savvy investors.
– Mutual funds suit long-term goal-based investors.
? Disadvantages of ETFs
– No SIP in traditional way.
– Need stock market timing for buy/sell.
– Liquidity issues if low traded volume.
– No emotional guidance in tough market.
– Only passive growth, no goal planning.
? Disadvantages of Index Investing
– Index funds follow market blindly.
– No downside protection during crash.
– Can’t change stocks even if poor performers.
– High volatility in small or mid cap indices.
– Not ideal for serious long-term goals.
? Why Actively Managed Mutual Funds Are Better
– Fund manager handles volatility.
– Can change stock selection based on conditions.
– Gives better performance in sideways or falling markets.
– Good for SIP with financial planning.
– Suits goal-focused investment like education or retirement.
? Summary Answer to Last Follow-Up Question
Mutual Fund via Regular Plan is better than Nippon ETF for long-term wealth creation.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment