Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help
Harsh

Harsh Roongta  | Answer  |Ask -

Answered on Dec 24, 2019

Vishnu Question by Vishnu on Dec 24, 2019Hindi
Listen
Money

I have booked a flat in Amrapali Dream Valley Noida Extension - Great Noida (West) under 80:10:10 subvention plan (No EMI till possession) in the year March, 2016.

Builder becomes defaulter and stopped the work in 2016 itself and not paying interest EMI to the bank as well.

Bank and its lawyer both issued notices to me to recover all pending money which builder has not paid.

I paid all pending money with all pending interest with penalties to bank and started paying EMI 1.5 years back and the same is paying till date.

The Honourable Supreme Court transferred the same project to NBCC for completion and to be handed over to home buyer according to a scheduled plan.

But till date no development work has started and looks very uncertain that we do not know when we will get the possession? And there is no place where we can know about the development of the project.

Should we continue paying EMI to bank without any surety, whether we will get the flat or not? What would be repercussion, if we stop paying EMI to bank?

Please advise what should I do? Really confused!

Ans: Please do not stop paying EMI to the bank unless the SC order has allowed you to do so. Your credit history will be spoiled if you stop paying the bank without backing from the court.

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.
Money

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11484 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on May 21, 2024

Listen
Money
I purchased a flat under-construction in the year 2016. Till now I have not got the flat some dispute happen among the builder. The project matter is under court. I am paying huge emi bank is not ready to me listen they say if you do not pay emi your credit score will hamper what to do
Ans: I understand this is a frustrating situation. Here are some steps you can take:

Regarding the Flat:

Review your Sale Agreement: This document outlines the terms of your purchase, including timelines for completion and any delay penalties the builder may owe.

Form a Flat Buyer Association: Connect with other buyers facing the same issue. A united front holds more power when dealing with the builder or legal proceedings.

Track Court Proceedings: Stay informed about the court case's progress. This might influence your next steps.

Explore Legal Options: Consult a lawyer specializing in real estate disputes. They can advise on pursuing compensation or withdrawal from the project depending on the court case and agreement.

Regarding the Bank Loan:

Negotiate with the Bank: Explain the situation and present copies of the court case documents. They might offer a temporary pause or restructure your EMI plan.

Consider Loan Against Property (LAP): If you own another property, explore a LAP to pay off the existing loan and avoid credit score damage. However, this is a complex financial decision, so consult a financial advisor.

CIBIL Dispute Resolution: If the bank reports a default despite your efforts, you can raise a dispute with CIBIL, the credit bureau, explaining the situation.

Here are some additional resources that might be helpful:

Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA): https://rera.goa.gov.in/ (if your city falls under RERA)
Consumer Forum: You can file a case against the builder for delayed possession.
Remember, this is a complex situation, and the best course of action might depend on the specifics of your agreement, the court case, and your financial situation. Consulting a lawyer and potentially a financial advisor can provide tailored guidance.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

..Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11484 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Dec 31, 2025

Money
I have stuck with a property possession default by a builder,. in Bengaluru , for the past 12 years. The. building is not ready ; and showing no signs of getting ready too , very soon. The builder is only giving empty sop chatgpt responses.The nationalised bank is deducting my EMIs without fail. I am losing money on: EMI/ source of rental income (due to property. ot being ready) n also sufferring mental agony. Can I file a case on : Builder/Bank too , ask for stopping EMI without affecting my CIBIL, hefty compensation for loss of income as also Mental Agony ? pls advice.
Ans: Your patience through this long delay shows strength and resilience.
Facing uncertainty for twelve years is emotionally exhausting.
Your concern is genuine and deserves a structured response.
You are not helpless in this situation.
Several legal and financial paths are available.

» Understanding Your Situation Clearly

Property possession delayed for twelve years.

Builder shows no visible construction progress.

Builder gives repetitive and vague assurances.

Bank continues EMI deductions regularly.

No rental income received till date.

Mental stress and financial strain are ongoing.

» Key Issues Involved

Builder default on possession obligation.

Financial loss due to EMI payments.

Opportunity loss of rental income.

Mental agony caused by uncertainty.

Bank’s role in continuing EMI deductions.

» Builder’s Legal Responsibility

Builder promised possession within a defined period.

Delay beyond reasonable time is deficiency of service.

Twelve years delay is excessive and unjustifiable.

Builder is legally accountable for such delay.

Repeated false assurances worsen the violation.

» Your Right As A Homebuyer

You are treated as a consumer under law.

Delay in possession is a recognised grievance.

You can seek refund or possession with compensation.

Mental agony is a valid compensation head.

Loss of rental income is claimable.

» RERA Applicability Assessment

Bengaluru projects fall under Karnataka RERA.

RERA applies if project registration exists.

Even older projects can be covered under conditions.

Delay beyond committed date is punishable.

Compensation and interest can be ordered.

» Remedies Available Under RERA

Seek refund with interest.

Seek possession with delay compensation.

Claim penalty for non-compliance.

File complaint online with documents.

Proceedings are relatively faster.

» Consumer Court Route

Consumer forum accepts such cases routinely.

Builder delay qualifies as service deficiency.

Mental agony compensation is recognised.

Rental loss can be claimed with proof.

Proceedings may take longer than RERA.

» Civil Court Option

Civil suits handle complex contractual disputes.

Time frame is usually longer.

Legal costs are higher.

Used when other forums are unsuitable.

» Criminal Complaint Aspect

Cheating applies if intent to deceive existed.

Evidence of fraud is required.

Police complaints increase pressure.

Criminal route should be used carefully.

» Builder’s Empty Assurances Impact

Repeated false promises strengthen your case.

Written communications are valuable evidence.

WhatsApp and emails should be preserved.

Brochure and agreement terms matter.

» Compensation For Mental Agony

Courts recognise prolonged stress.

Twelve years delay qualifies strongly.

Compensation amounts vary by forum.

Facts and documentation influence outcome.

» Compensation For Loss Of Rental Income

Courts allow notional rent claims.

Local market rent evidence helps.

Banker EMI statements support loss calculation.

Builder agreement clauses are examined.

» Can EMI Be Stopped Legally

EMI obligation is separate from builder default.

Bank loan is a contractual liability.

Bank is not responsible for construction delays.

EMI stoppage is legally difficult.

» Risk Of Unilateral EMI Stoppage

Stopping EMI affects CIBIL immediately.

Penalties and interest will accumulate.

Recovery actions may start.

This option is not advisable.

» Can Court Order EMI Suspension

Some courts grant temporary EMI relief.

Relief depends on case merits.

Orders are rare but possible.

Legal representation is essential.

» Can Bank Be Made A Party

Bank can be included as respondent.

Relief against bank is limited.

Banks follow loan contract strictly.

Courts rarely penalise banks.

» Bank’s Duty Perspective

Bank disbursed loan based on approvals.

Bank fulfilled contractual obligation.

Builder default does not cancel loan.

Hence bank liability is minimal.

» Strategy Regarding Bank EMIs

Continue EMI payments to protect CIBIL.

Maintain clean credit record.

Use legal route against builder.

Seek compensation instead of EMI stoppage.

» Mental Peace Consideration

Financial stress affects decision quality.

Structured action reduces anxiety.

Legal clarity brings confidence.

You regain control through process.

» Documentation You Must Organise

Builder buyer agreement.

Payment receipts to builder.

Bank loan agreement.

EMI statements.

All builder communications.

» Evidence Strengthening Tips

Preserve original brochures.

Capture site photos periodically.

Record possession promises timeline.

Note construction inactivity periods.

» Time Limitation Awareness

Delay cases usually considered continuing cause.

Twelve years delay still qualifies.

Legal forums accept such complaints.

Do not delay further action.

» Financial Planning During Litigation

Maintain emergency fund.

Avoid emotional financial decisions.

Keep investments separate from dispute.

Do not liquidate long-term assets hastily.

» Emotional Wellbeing Aspect

Long disputes cause fatigue.

Legal counsel support is important.

Family support matters greatly.

Avoid constant negative exposure.

» Parallel Negotiation Option

Legal notice may trigger settlement.

Builders act under legal pressure.

Written settlement protects rights.

Avoid verbal commitments again.

» Settlement Versus Litigation

Settlement saves time.

Litigation ensures accountability.

Choose based on builder response.

Never compromise without legal review.

» Tax Angle On Compensation

Compensation taxation depends on nature.

Rental loss compensation may be taxable.

Interest compensation tax treatment varies.

Proper advice is required later.

» Avoid Common Mistakes

Do not rely on verbal promises.

Do not stop EMI emotionally.

Do not delay legal action further.

Do not sign revised agreements blindly.

» Role Of Certified Financial Planner

Help you plan cash flows during dispute.

Protect credit profile.

Align litigation with financial goals.

Provide calm, objective guidance.

» Hope And Practical Reality

Many buyers have succeeded legally.

Courts increasingly favour homebuyers.

RERA strengthened buyer protection.

Persistence often brings results.

» Action Oriented Next Steps

Consult a property litigation lawyer.

File RERA or consumer complaint promptly.

Continue EMI payments meanwhile.

Claim compensation aggressively.

» Final Insights

Builder default is legally actionable.

Compensation for delay and mental agony is possible.

EMI stoppage without court order is risky.

Bank liability is limited.

Legal route offers relief and accountability.

Structured action restores control and confidence.

You deserve justice after twelve years.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

..Read more

Latest Questions
Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11484 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Oct 13, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 10, 2026
Money
I am a 54 year old male working abroad. I have below investments. I have below investments so far: PPF 55 lakhs,EPF 36 lakhs, MF (total cumulative) 5.5 crores ,Employee superannuity+gratuity 14.5 lakhs, NPS 17 lakhs Monthly MF SIP ongoing 2 lakhs Company FD 10 lakhs Gold 16 lakhs. I am well covered in life insurance as well as medical insurance. My question is 1) My wife is getting a one time windfall of Rs .80 Lakhs as part of her share in her ancestral property. a)Pls guide me on how to invest this money b) what are the ways to save on tax eg. rbi relief bonds etc? c) if rbi relief bonds how much is the maximum limit d) beyond that limit where should i remaining balance?
Ans: Thank you for sharing your investment details. You have built a substantial investment portfolio through regular investing. The key now is to invest your wifes Rs.80 lakh windfall in a tax-efficient manner without adding unnecessary risk.

» Assessment of Your Current Portfolio

– Your existing investments are spread across mutual funds, EPF, PPF, NPS, company deposits and gold.

– Your mutual fund corpus is already substantial, with an ongoing SIP of Rs.2 lakh per month.

– Therefore, the entire windfall need not go into equity mutual funds. Your decision should depend on your retirement age, expected expenses, tax residency and the level of risk you are comfortable taking.

– Since you are working abroad, your residential status under Indian tax laws is important. The tax treatment of your investments and interest income can differ based on whether you qualify as a resident, NRI or RNOR.

» 1. How to Invest the Rs.80 Lakh Windfall

First, keep the money in your wifes name if she is the legal recipient of the ancestral property proceeds. Maintain proper documents showing the source of funds.

Consider dividing the money into three broad purposes:

– Safety and liquidity: Keep a suitable amount in bank deposits or other low-risk instruments for emergencies and expenses expected in the next few years.

– Stable income: Consider suitable government-backed or high-quality fixed-income options, after checking eligibility, taxation, lock-in and withdrawal rules.

– Long-term growth: Invest a portion in diversified, actively managed equity mutual funds if the money is not required for at least 7–10 years.

Since your existing mutual fund corpus is already Rs.5.5 crore, avoid putting the entire Rs.80 lakh into equity without reviewing your overall asset allocation. Your present equity exposure may already be sufficient for your retirement goals.

» 2. Can You Save Tax Through RBI Bonds?

It is important to distinguish between tax-saving investments and investments that offer safety or regular interest income.

RBI Floating Rate Savings Bonds are generally considered for investors seeking government-backed interest income. However, they are not a tax-saving instrument.

– Interest earned is taxable according to the applicable income tax rules.

– Investing in these bonds does not automatically provide a deduction under Section 80C.

– The bonds have a seven-year maturity period for ordinary individual investors, with premature encashment permitted only under specified conditions for eligible senior citizens.

– Interest rates are reset periodically, so the income may change over time.

Hence, these bonds can be considered for the safety and income portion of the portfolio, but not as a way to reduce tax on the windfall itself.

» 3. What Is the Maximum Investment Limit in RBI Bonds?

– There is no maximum investment limit in RBI Floating Rate Savings Bonds.

– However, these bonds are available to eligible resident individuals and HUFs. If your wife is an NRI, she would not be eligible to invest in these bonds under the current eligibility rules. Confirm her residential status before proceeding.

– The interest rate for July–December 2026 is 8.05% per annum, payable half-yearly. The rate is reset periodically.

– The maturity period is seven years, and liquidity is limited. Premature encashment is allowed only for eligible senior citizens after the specified lock-in period.

Therefore, these bonds may suit the stable-income portion of your wifes portfolio, provided she is eligible and can accept the lock-in.

» 4. Can You Save Capital Gains Tax on the Ancestral Property?

This is an important point to clarify before investing the money.

– If your wife received the property through inheritance, the inheritance itself is generally not taxable as income.

– However, if the ancestral property was sold and Rs.80 lakh represents her share of the sale proceeds, capital gains tax may arise. The taxable gain is not necessarily the entire amount received.

– Depending on the facts, Section 54EC capital gains bonds may offer tax relief when eligible long-term capital gains arise from the sale of land or a building.

– The maximum investment eligible for this exemption is Rs.50 lakh, subject to the applicable conditions and timelines. The investment must generally be made within six months of the transfer.

– These are different from RBI Floating Rate Savings Bonds. Section 54EC bonds are meant for eligible capital gains exemption, whereas RBI Floating Rate Savings Bonds provide taxable interest income.

If the property has already been sold, please check the sale date immediately. The deadline for claiming an exemption may be important.

» 5. Where Should You Invest the Remaining Amount?

If your wife is eligible for Section 54EC bonds and has sufficient eligible capital gains, up to Rs.50 lakh may be considered for that purpose.

The remaining amount can be allocated based on your financial goals.

– Bank deposits or other suitable fixed-income investments for short-term needs and capital safety.

– High-quality fixed-income instruments for the portion meant to provide stability.

– Diversified, actively managed equity mutual funds for long-term growth, if your overall portfolio review shows that additional equity exposure is appropriate.

Do not invest in a particular product only because it offers a tax benefit. Consider liquidity, taxation, maturity and the purpose of the investment.

» 6. My Final Assessment

Your family already has a strong investment base. At age 54, retirement planning, tax efficiency and asset allocation deserve more attention than simply maximising returns.

Before investing the Rs.80 lakh, please clarify these three points:

– Is the Rs.80 lakh received from an actual sale of ancestral property, or has your wife received the property itself as her share?

– Is your wife an Indian resident or an NRI for income-tax purposes?

– When was the property sold, if a sale has taken place?

These details will help determine whether capital gains tax applies, whether Section 54EC bonds are suitable, and how the remaining money can be invested efficiently.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

AMFI-Registered MFD – ARN 4188

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/

...Read more

Ramalingam

Ramalingam Kalirajan  |11484 Answers  |Ask -

Mutual Funds, Financial Planning Expert - Answered on Oct 13, 2026

Money
my father is 75 years old and my mother is 70 years old, she has stent in the heart, can you recommend which is the best health insurance policy for them. thanks
Ans: Thank you for sharing your parents details. Having health insurance at this age is important, especially when your mother has a heart stent.

» Health Insurance for Your Parents

– At 75 and 70 years, getting a new health insurance policy may be difficult. Premiums can also be high, and some insurers may not accept the application.

– Your fathers health condition and your mothers heart history will be considered during underwriting. Since your mother has a heart stent, the insurer may impose waiting periods, exclusions or other conditions.

– Do not choose a policy based on premium alone. Check the coverage, room rent limits, co-payment, disease-wise limits and claim conditions carefully.

» What You Should Check Before Buying

– Look for a senior citizen health insurance policy that accepts applicants of their ages and offers reasonable hospitalisation coverage.

– For your mother, disclose the heart stent procedure and all related medical details honestly. Ask the insurer in writing whether future cardiac treatment will be covered and from when.

– Check the co-payment clause. If the policy has a 20% co-payment, you may have to pay 20% of eligible hospital expenses yourself.

– Check pre-existing disease waiting periods. Existing heart conditions may not be covered immediately.

– Check whether the policy has limits on ICU charges, room rent, specific treatments or the total amount payable for certain illnesses.

» Consider These Alternatives

– If your parents already have health insurance, check whether it can be continued or enhanced. Keeping existing coverage may be more useful than buying a new policy.

– Check whether they have any employer-sponsored, government-sponsored or other eligible health coverage.

– If new insurance is unavailable or too costly, maintain a separate medical emergency fund. This will help meet hospital expenses not covered by insurance.

» My Assessment

At their ages, I would first check existing insurance and its continuation options. Then compare new policies based on actual coverage and exclusions.

For your mother, written confirmation about cardiac coverage is especially important. Do not assume that a policy will cover heart-related treatment simply because the insurer accepts her application.

Please share these three details for a more suitable assessment:

– Do your parents currently have any health insurance? If yes, what is the sum insured?

– Which city do they live in?

– Does your mother have any other medical conditions apart from the heart stent?

With these details, we can narrow down the available options and identify the most practical way to protect your parents from large medical expenses.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

AMFI-Registered MFD – ARN 4188

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/

...Read more

Krishna

Krishna Kumar  |430 Answers  |Ask -

Workplace Expert - Answered on Oct 12, 2026

Asked by Anonymous - Oct 12, 2026
Career
In my office, there are times when a colleague gets stuck with some work or makes a mistake, and I try to help them so that the work gets completed on time. Sometimes, I even put my own work aside to help them because I feel that we should support each other as a team. But when I am busy with my own tasks and need some help, the same colleagues are not always available. They may say they are busy or ask me to manage it myself. I don’t want to stop helping others because of this, as I feel it is important to maintain good relationships at work. At the same time, I sometimes feel that people take my helpful nature for granted, and my own work gets delayed because of it. I also worry that if I start refusing to help, my colleagues may think I have become selfish or uncooperative.
Ans: Dear

Very good question.

Few things let's get it clear. Each one is hired for a particular role and deliverables and they are paid for that.

You are hired first to do your work and deliverables assigned to you. Helping colleagues with their work, while letting your work aside is akin to not doing your responsibility.

My suggestion would be first focus on your work, if someone approaches you with a help and assistance for their work, you can provide them with guidance but do not end up doing their work.

If you are in the midst of your work and someone approaches you, you can politely yet firmly tell them that you are in mids if an important work and once done you will call them. DO NOT set aside your work for someone else. Remember you are working in a corporate world and not some social charitable organisation where any one can do everyone's work.

Hope this helps. All the best.

Warm Regards
KK

...Read more

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Close  

You haven't logged in yet. To ask a question, Please Log in below
Login

A verification OTP will be sent to this
Mobile Number / Email

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to

Resend OTP in120seconds

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus
Sign up

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

Enter OTP
A 6 digit code has been sent to Mobile

Resend OTP in120seconds

x