Good Return and Low Risk Policy: What's Best for a Person with an Existing Policy?

Ans: The SBI Life Retire Smart is a Unit Linked Insurance Plan (ULIP) marketed as a pension plan. It invests your premium in equities and debt-oriented funds managed by SBI Life, aiming to provide retirement benefits in the form of an annuity. This review will help you determine if the SBI Life Retire Smart Plan is a good investment for your retirement.

Key Features of SBI Life Retire Smart Plan

This ULIP is designed as a retirement plan and differs from conventional ULIPs. Key features include predefined investment strategies and maturity benefits. For example, if you start this plan at 35 with a 25-year term, paying Rs 1,00,000 annually, your premium will be invested in three different funds under the "Advantage Plan" strategy.

Fund Options and Allocation Strategy

The Retire Smart Plan offers a predefined asset allocation strategy, named the "Advantage Plan." This strategy invests more in high-risk, high-return equity funds in the early years and reallocates to safer funds as the policy matures. This approach aims to balance growth potential with stability over time.

Death Benefits

The death benefit is the highest of the fund value plus terminal addition or 105% of the total premiums paid. Terminal addition is 1.5% of the fund value on the date of death. The nominee can receive the death benefit as a lump sum or use it to purchase an annuity. However, the death benefit does not include a sum assured, making the risk cover minimal.

Maturity Benefits

The maturity benefit is the highest of the fund value plus terminal addition or 101% of the total premiums paid. While the policy guarantees 101% of the premiums paid, the actual return is subject to market performance. The guaranteed maturity benefit may not be sufficient given the potential for higher returns in long-term equity investments.

Analysis of Returns

Guaranteed Returns: If the policy generates an annual return of 4%, the effective annual rate of return (IRR) is approximately 3.62%. After deducting charges, the actual return is even lower.
Higher Returns Scenario: If the policy generates an annual return of 8%, the IRR is around 7.4%. After charges, the actual return is less than 7.4%. Given the 25-year investment horizon, this return is not attractive considering the equity risk.
Comparison with Alternatives

PPF vs. SBI Life Retire Smart

PPF Investment: Investing Rs 1,00,000 annually in PPF for 25 years could provide substantial returns. Assuming the current PPF interest rate of 7.1%, the corpus at the end of 25 years would be approximately Rs 68.7 lakhs.
Tax Benefits: PPF offers tax benefits under section 80C and has the EEE (Exempt-Exempt-Exempt) status. The returns are risk-free and backed by the government.
ELSS vs. SBI Life Retire Smart

ELSS Investment: Investing in ELSS funds could yield an annual return of around 12%. Over 25 years, Rs 1,00,000 invested annually could grow to approximately Rs 1.33 crores, after accounting for 10% long-term capital gains (LTCG) tax.
Flexibility: ELSS investments offer greater flexibility and the potential for higher returns compared to ULIPs. Additionally, ELSS investments provide tax benefits under section 80C.
Surrender and Reinvest Strategy

Considering the low returns and high charges of the SBI Life Retire Smart Plan, it is advisable to surrender the policy after the 5-year lock-in period. You can then reinvest the proceeds into mutual funds.

Reinvestment in Mutual Funds: By investing in diversified mutual funds, you can achieve better returns. Equity mutual funds, in particular, offer significant growth potential over the long term.
Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP): During retirement, you can opt for an SWP from your mutual fund investments. SWPs provide regular income by allowing you to withdraw a fixed amount periodically, ensuring a steady cash flow.
Pros and Cons of SBI Life Retire Smart

Pros:

Offers both insurance and investment benefits.
Provides a predefined investment strategy for risk management.
Cons:

High charges for premium allocation and policy administration.
Limited flexibility in fund selection.
Minimal risk cover and guaranteed returns.
Verdict

The SBI Life Retire Smart Plan may not be the best choice for retirement planning. The guaranteed returns are low compared to potential returns from PPF and ELSS. For conservative investors, PPF plus a term insurance plan is a better option. For those with higher risk tolerance, ELSS plus a term insurance plan offers greater growth potential.

Overview

You have an SBI Life Insurance Policy Retire Smart - LP with a sum assured of Rs 10 lakhs, paying an annual premium of Rs 1 lakh since March 2019. With five premiums paid, the current fund value is Rs 5.70 lakhs. You have the option to close the policy after 5 years without penalty. Considering your age of 74 years, the decision should focus on maximizing your retirement funds.

Assessment of Current Situation

Premiums Paid: Rs 5 lakhs
Current Fund Value: Rs 5.70 lakhs
Policy Tenure Completed: Almost 5 years
Your fund has grown modestly, providing a return slightly above the total premiums paid. Given your age and the need for a stable income, it's crucial to evaluate options that ensure financial security and better returns.

Decision After 5 Years

1. Surrender the Policy

After completing 5 years, you can surrender the policy without incurring any penalty. This would be a strategic move considering the limited growth observed in your fund value.

Benefits of Surrendering the Policy:

Avoid Future Charges: ULIPs like this have various charges, including premium allocation, policy administration, and fund management fees, which can eat into returns.
Better Investment Opportunities: You can reinvest the proceeds in more lucrative and less costly investment options.
2. Reinvest in Mutual Funds

After surrendering the policy, consider reinvesting the proceeds into diversified mutual funds. Mutual funds typically offer better returns compared to ULIPs due to lower costs and more focused investment strategies.

Recommended Investment Strategy:

Diversified Equity Funds: Suitable for potentially higher returns, balancing risk with growth opportunities.

Balanced Funds or Hybrid Funds: These funds invest in a mix of equities and debt, offering a balance between growth and stability.

Debt Funds: For conservative investments, providing stable returns with lower risk.

3. Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) for Regular Income

Once reinvested in mutual funds, you can set up a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) to ensure a regular income. This is particularly beneficial for retirees, offering a steady cash flow while keeping the remaining funds invested for potential growth.

Advantages of SWP:

Regular Income: Fixed amount at regular intervals (monthly, quarterly).
Tax Efficiency: Only the capital gains portion of the withdrawal is taxed.
Flexibility: You can adjust the withdrawal amount based on your needs.
Steps to Implement the Plan:

Surrender the Policy: Contact SBI Life to process the surrender after completing the 5-year term. Ensure you understand the procedure and any documentation required.

Evaluate Mutual Fund Options: With a Certified Financial Planner, choose a mix of mutual funds suited to your risk tolerance and income needs.

Set Up SWP: Once the funds are invested, set up an SWP to provide a regular income.

Conclusion

Considering the limited growth in your current ULIP and your age, surrendering the SBI Life Retire Smart Plan after 5 years is a prudent decision. Reinvesting the proceeds into mutual funds and opting for an SWP can provide better returns and a steady income stream, ensuring financial stability in your retirement years. Always consult a Certified Financial Planner to tailor the strategy to your specific financial situation and goals.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

Ans: I appreciate your trust in seeking financial advice. Let’s dive into your financial situation and plan a robust strategy for your future.

Your Current Financial Landscape
You have a well-diversified portfolio with investments in mutual funds, fixed deposits, gold, and insurance. Here’s an overview:

Home: You own a home in Nagpur worth Rs. 75 lakhs.

Mutual Funds: You have invested Rs. 4 lakhs in mutual funds as a lump sum in December 2023. Additionally, you have been doing SIPs of Rs. 30,000 per month for the last year.

Fixed Deposits: You have Rs. 10 lakhs in fixed deposits with HDFC Bank at a 7% interest rate.

Gold: You have invested Rs. 14 lakhs in gold bars.

Insurance: You have a TATA AIA ULIP plan with an annual premium of Rs. 1.5 lakhs, currently in its second year of a five-year term. Additionally, you have a monthly LIC policy with an annual premium of Rs. 80,000.

Future Plans: You plan to increase your SIP to Rs. 30,000 per month from July 2024. You are also considering a term plan with an annual premium of Rs. 1.75 lakhs for the next 10 years, offering a cover of Rs. 2 crores until the age of 85.

Evaluating Your Investments
Mutual Funds
Mutual funds are a fantastic way to grow your wealth over the long term. They offer the benefits of professional management, diversification, and the power of compounding.

Advantages of Mutual Funds:
Diversification: Mutual funds invest in a variety of securities, reducing risk.

Professional Management: Experienced fund managers make investment decisions on your behalf.

Liquidity: You can easily redeem your investments when needed.

Flexibility: With options like SIPs, you can start with a small amount and increase it over time.

Power of Compounding
Compounding is the process where the returns on your investments generate their returns. The longer you stay invested, the more your money grows. This is why starting early and staying consistent with your SIPs is crucial.

Actively Managed Funds vs. Index Funds
Actively Managed Funds:

Fund managers actively select stocks to beat the market.
Potential for higher returns than index funds.
Regular reviews and adjustments based on market conditions.
Index Funds:

Passively track a specific index like Nifty or Sensex.
Lower expense ratios, but often lower returns compared to actively managed funds.
Lack of flexibility to adjust to market changes.
In your case, actively managed funds might offer better growth potential.

Regular Funds vs. Direct Funds
Regular Funds:

Invest through a Certified Financial Planner (CFP).
CFP provides personalized advice and ongoing support.
Slightly higher expense ratio due to advisory fees.
Direct Funds:

Invest directly with the fund house, bypassing a CFP.
Lower expense ratio but lack of professional guidance.
Suitable for experienced investors with time to manage their portfolios.
Given your busy career, regular funds through a CFP could provide valuable support and expertise.

Fixed Deposits
Fixed deposits are safe and offer guaranteed returns. However, their growth potential is limited compared to mutual funds. Given the current inflation rates, FD returns might not keep pace with the rising cost of living.

Gold Investment
Gold is a good hedge against inflation and market volatility. However, it doesn’t generate regular income. It’s essential to balance your portfolio with growth-oriented investments like mutual funds.

Insurance Plans
ULIP Plan
ULIPs combine investment and insurance. They have higher costs due to insurance charges and fund management fees. You have already completed two years out of five. It might be beneficial to surrender the plan after the lock-in period and reinvest in mutual funds for better returns.

Term Plan
A term plan is essential for risk cover. Ensure the cover amount aligns with your family’s financial needs. A Rs. 2 crore cover until age 85 is a prudent decision, providing long-term security.

LIC Policy
LIC policies offer traditional savings with insurance. However, the returns are generally lower than mutual funds. It might be worth reviewing this policy and considering surrendering it to reinvest in more lucrative options.

Strategic Recommendations
Enhance Your SIPs
You are planning to increase your SIP to Rs. 30,000 per month. This is a smart move. SIPs instill financial discipline and benefit from rupee cost averaging. Here’s how to optimize your SIPs:

Diversify: Invest in a mix of large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap, and sectoral funds.
Review: Regularly review your portfolio with your CFP.
Increase: Gradually increase your SIP amount as your income grows.
Rebalance Your Portfolio
Mutual Funds: Increase your allocation to equity mutual funds for higher growth.
Fixed Deposits: Consider reducing your FD holdings and reallocating to mutual funds.
Gold: Maintain your gold investments but avoid further additions.
Insurance: Focus on pure term insurance for risk cover.
Long-Term Wealth Creation
Retirement Planning
Start planning for retirement early. Aim to build a corpus that supports your lifestyle and healthcare needs. Here’s how:

EPF and PPF: Maximize contributions to these tax-free retirement schemes.
NPS: Consider the National Pension System for additional retirement savings.
Equity Funds: Allocate a significant portion to equity funds for long-term growth.
Children's Education
If you have children, plan for their higher education expenses. SIPs in mutual funds can help build a substantial corpus over time.

Emergency Fund
Maintain an emergency fund covering 6-12 months of expenses. This provides financial stability during unforeseen events. Your fixed deposits can serve this purpose.

Tax Planning
Optimize your investments for tax efficiency. Utilize tax-saving instruments like ELSS, PPF, and NPS. Seek guidance from a tax advisor to minimize tax liability.

Risk Management
Adequate Insurance
Ensure you have adequate health insurance for your family. Consider critical illness and accident covers. Your term insurance plan should provide sufficient risk cover.

Asset Allocation
Maintain a balanced asset allocation based on your risk tolerance and financial goals. Regularly review and rebalance your portfolio to align with changing market conditions.

Regular Review
Regularly review your financial plan with your CFP. Adjust your investments based on your life goals, market conditions, and financial situation.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls
Emotional Decisions: Avoid making investment decisions based on market emotions.
Over-diversification: Don’t invest in too many funds; it dilutes returns.
Ignoring Inflation: Ensure your investments grow faster than inflation.
Final Insights
You have a solid foundation with your current investments. Enhancing your SIPs, optimizing your portfolio, and strategic planning will ensure robust growth and financial security. Keep an eye on market trends, stay disciplined, and regularly review your plan.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

Ans: Hello;

My suggestion would be to opt for an adequate term life insurance and invest through mutual funds and NPS for other goals.

But if you are keen about ULIP only then you may select the insurer/plan of your choice or as advised by your insurance advisor.

However in the Ulip plan have 80% allocation to pure equity funds and balance 20% to debt funds to beginwith and tweak it over time as you grow older(nearing policy maturity date; ~ 30 years later) so by the time the policy is about to mature your equity allocation should be 40% or less.

Happy Investing;

Ans: Hello;

Request you to elaborate policy term, payback(regular and final), annual premium and your age.

Traditional insurance policies never provide return higher then 5.5-6% and you seem to be claiming 8% return.

Any which way coupling insurance with investment is a blunder of mammoth proportions.

People get carried away with words like guaranteed, profit sharing, bonus rather then rationally trying to estimate the rate of return from such undesirable investments.

I reserve my final comment on this until you furnish me with the above requested details.

Thanks;