Home > Money > Question

Sign In | Create an account

Language:

Now in हिन्दी too

Need Expert Advice?Our Gurus Can Help

Tejas Chokshi | Answer |Ask -Follow

Tax Expert - Answered on Jun 12, 2023

CA Tejas Chokshi has over 20 years of experience in financial planning, income tax planning, strategic and risk advisory, banking and financial products and accounting and auditing.
He is an information system auditor, a forensic auditor and concurrent bank auditor.
Chokshi, who has a master’s degree in management, audit and accounting from Gujarat University, has completed his CA from the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India.... more

Question by Lalit on Jun 09, 2023Hindi

Money

Sir, I am having long term gain of 524352 and Short term Gain of 932400 and F&O loss of 512352. No other income. Pls advise how my tax liability would be calculated.

Ans: To calculate your tax liability in India based on the provided information, we need to consider the tax rates for long-term capital gains (LTCG) and short-term capital gains (STCG), as well as the treatment of losses from Futures and Options (F&O).

Long-term capital gains (LTCG):

LTCG on shares is taxable at a rate of 10% if the gains exceed Rs. 1 lakh.
In your case, the LTCG is Rs. 524,352, which is below the threshold of Rs. 1 lakh. Therefore, tax is payable on the LTCG @ 10% of Rs. 424,352 = Rs. 42435/=
Short-term capital gains (STCG):

STCG on shares is taxable at the applicable income tax slab rates.
Assuming you fall under the highest income tax slab rate of 30%, the tax on STCG would be calculated as follows:
STCG tax = STCG * tax rate
= 932,400 * 30%
= 279,720
Losses from Futures and Options (F&O):

F&O losses can be set off against both long-term and short-term capital gains.
In your case, the F&O loss is Rs. 512,352.
Since you have both long-term and short-term gains, you can set off the F&O loss against these gains.
Calculating the tax liability:

Net Short-term Capital Gains (STCG): 932,400

F&O Loss: -512,352

Taxable Short-term Capital Gains: 932,400 - 512,352 = 420,048

Tax on Short-term Capital Gains: 420,048 * 30% = 126,014.40

Total Tax Liability:
Tax liability = Tax on Short-term Capital Gains
= 126,014.40

Long term capital = 42435=20

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information to be as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision.

MoneyReply

You may like to see similar questions and answers below

Mihir Tanna |1005 Answers |Ask -Follow

Tax Expert - Answered on Feb 23, 2023

Question by Harikrishna - Feb 23, 2023Hindi

Money

I have an income around Rs. 7.5 lakh from services abroad.(working in foreign countries). and earned a Short-term capital gain of 5.1 lakh & Longterm capital gain of 2 Lakh. Have home loan , insurance . how much tax i should pay ?

Ans: Salary received for employment exercised outside India will be taxable in India only if person resident of India. Salary income is taxable as per slab rate. Tax on Capital gain will depend on nature of capital asset which is transferred.

10% on LTCG above 1 lakh (On sale of Equity shares/ units of equity oriented fund)
20% on other LTCG

15% on STCG on STT paid transactions
slab rate in case of other STCG

Mihir Tanna |1005 Answers |Ask -Follow

Tax Expert - Answered on Jan 01, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Dec 31, 2024Hindi

Money

My short term capital gains listed shares and equity mutual funds is Rs 3,00,000 and salary 1,80,000 Total 4,80,000 From 1-4-24 to 31-3-25 How much tax I have to pay I am 52 years Mohan Satpal

Ans: Your income is below 7 lacs and gross tax liability will be 16380. Under new tax regime, you are eligible for rebate upto 25000. However matter is litigative. As per recent judicial decisions, rebate is available even against income taxable as per provisions of 111A.

Accordingly, in my view, tax liability will be Zero

You can calculate tax liability from income tax calculator available at https://eportal.incometax.gov.in/iec/foservices/#/TaxCalc/calculator

Latest Questions

Milind Vadjikar |995 Answers |Ask -Follow

Insurance, Stocks, MF, PF Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 10, 2025Hindi

Money

I am 51 single, divorced and have one little sister who is 32. Recently I lost my job, and I am not in the mood to search for a new one. I am in the process of making arrangement to fulfill my monthly needs. I am holding the NPS which has a small corpus of 5 lacs in tier 1 and 45k in tier 2. Now I want to completely exit from the NPS. Now I must compulsorily accept the 20% withdrawal and 80% annuity. I have a few queries below. 1. Should I consider buying 100% annuity. 20% withdrawal does not make sense 2. Should I consider putting 1.5 lacs more to enhance the annuity (The corpus will become 7 lacs approx.). 3. Should I consider taking out the annuity on a yearly basis (Please explain Its pros and cons), since it offers more benefit. 4. Should I consider the Shriram life insurance. 5. Will it be safe to consider Shriram life insurance for life long future annuity. It offers the highest annuity. 6. Should I consider Annuity for Life with ROP - Subscriber will get annuity for lifetime and on death of the Subscriber, payment of annuity ceases & 100% of the purchase price will be returned to the nominee(s). The annual offer is 49,063.00 (7.01%) 7. Should I consider Annuity for Life without ROP - Subscriber will get annuity for lifetime and on death of the Subscriber, payment of annuity ceases, and no further amount will be payable. The annual offer is 58,112.00 (8.30%)

Ans: Hello;

Point wise answers to your queries as given below:

1. Yes.
2. Yes.
3. If you do monthly annuity the rate will be lower but you get monthly payouts. In yearly the rate will higher but only one shot payment per year so it depends on your preference.

4. Cannot comment on suitability of xyz firm.

5. Consider an insurer which has good capital adequacy, growing profitable business, preferably listed, reputation of the owner/group apart from decent annuity rates on offer.

6 & 7. My suggestion would be to opt for annuity for life with ROP to your nominee. Ultimately it is your call.

Please have adequate healthcare insurance cover.

Best wishes;

Milind Vadjikar |995 Answers |Ask -Follow

Insurance, Stocks, MF, PF Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 10, 2025Hindi

Money

Dear Sir, I seek your guidance regarding a financial matter related to a VIP trading account operated through a WhatsApp group. There are numerous VIP trading accounts in WhatsApp groups, including those associated with UPSTOX, particularly under Mr. Milan Vaishnav and Ms. Pallavi Gandhi. I invested ₹20 lakhs in this account; however, I have not seen any progress in terms of trading or withdrawals. Additionally, they are now requesting further investments for block trading and IPO participation. Given these circumstances, I would like to know if I can recover my funds with the assistance of Cyber Crime and SEBI. Your advice on the appropriate course of action would be highly appreciated. Looking forward to your response..

Ans: Hello;

General Comments:

This tendency to get rich quickly(nothing wrong with it) is okay but in that quest people make terrible mistakes and realize their loss when it is almost too late.

Only appropriate way to get rich in a short time is to start your own business and scale it up fast. It needs smart hardwork and little bit of luck. We have many start-up founders in their early thirties already multi millionaires. Let's leave lottery, FNO, ancestral wealth etc , out of purview.

Specific Comments;

You must complain to the Police and SEBI/RBI urgently to recover your capital.

Do not fall for such gimmicks henceforth.

Best wishes;

Inderpaul Singh |7 Answers |Ask -Follow

Leadership Coach - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Question by Manan - Jan 18, 2025

Career

I graduated with a BBA in 2022, and since then, I’ve been on a thrilling two-year adventure at an MNC. But guess what? I decided to resign in March 2024 because, you know, who doesn’t love a little drama at work? Now, I’ve managed to burn through all my hard-earned savings like a pro, and here I am, utterly confused about my future. Sometimes I think about leaving India—maybe for studies or just to escape and do some mindless job somewhere. Other times, I dream of retreating to the most remote corner of India and living off the grid. I’ve always been pretty good with technology, snagged a degree, and even racked up some work experience. But now? I’m completely lost on where to start over. I’ve scoured countless articles and advice columns, but they’ve been about as helpful as a chocolate teapot. I’m just looking for that life-changing advice that seems to be in short supply. Turning 24 this year!

Ans: Hello Manan,
My simple advice to you would be to get back to some job while you can continue to ponder over your long term goals/passion/pursuits.
Sitting idle (with no funds) at home won't help & it is not going to do any good to your career/life plans.
Simultaneously you can continue to do introspection & chalk out a proper plan as far your larger life goals are concerned.
Say you earnestly wish to pursue higher studies than you need to get yourself these answers 1) Why you need a higher degree in first place ? 2) Will it help you to get job/career of your choice? 3) If yes, then shortlist some relevant good courses & start exploring admit process etc. 4) Meanwhile do account for funds that will help you to time your break from the job (savings, loans etc.)
Likewise ask yourself questions for each option you have in mind & be honest in responses, that will help you to zero on your real aspiration & then do the proper detailing/planning. This may entail some compromises in short term but will certainly pave your way to achieve long term goals.

Best of Luck!

Major Inderpaul
HR Expert, Life & Relationship Coach

Inderpaul Singh |7 Answers |Ask -Follow

Leadership Coach - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Question by Ganpati - Dec 31, 2024Hindi

Career

I am currently working as a General Manager civil projects, Looking to change for the job but during interview its facing some difficulties like fluency in English. What is solution over it? I am technically very strong but due to this problem my confidence level getting down. Please suggest me.

Ans: Hello Ganpati,
While I understand that most interviews are conducted in English and fluency does help in getting good impression. However, unless job under consideration demands so, lack of it should not deeply hamper your chances if you are otherwise competent & able to present so in a different language.
In fact, most sensible interviewers do ask the language comfort of interviewee & even interviewee is free to express that upfront.
Having said that, since English happens to be the most common medium of communication at workplaces, a decent hold will certainly do no harm to your overall career prospects otherwise. Hence I suggest that you do not limit this to the interview rather make a concerted effort to improve your language skills in general. There are ample online/offline options available nowadays to groom such skills.

All the Best !

Major Inderpaul
HR Expert, Life & Relationship Coach

Dr Dipankar Dutta |754 Answers |Ask -Follow

Tech Careers and Skill Development Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 10, 2025Hindi

Career

Hello dear sir, I gave the 12th state board exam in 2024. I have given jee main three attempts I haven't given jee advanced exam yet . I have got less percentage in 12th , So will I have two more attempts for JEE Advanced? after doing 12th from state board and CBSE board?

Ans: Your question is not clear to me. Yes you can give JEE exam three times.

Ravi Mittal |526 Answers |Ask -Follow

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 08, 2025

Relationship

I am a married man of 47 years old having one child.Recently I have developed strong emotional soulmate type feeling towards a girl who is just 19 years old.I just met her twice.Since then she is always in my mind.I chat with her.Sometimes she blocked me then after my request she unblocked me.I feel she avoids me.Whenever she needs me then she contact me.She rarely respond to my phone calls.What should I do.I tried my best to forget her but can't.Even if I think I should marry her in future.I feel no life without her.I feel I have met with my soulmate.Please give me strong advice effective for u harmful future.

Ans: Dear Anonymous,
What do you mean by "marry her in the future?" Aren't you already married? Are you planning on divorcing your wife? Because that's the only way you can marry this person you have only met twice and is also barely an adult.

I would suggest focusing on your marriage and your kid. If necessary, speak to your wife and figure out what's lacking in your marriage that you are seeking romantic feelings outside of it. You can even consider seeing a marriage counselor. Doing what you are doing without your partner's knowledge isn't moral.
Hope this helps.

Ravi Mittal |526 Answers |Ask -Follow

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 08, 2025Hindi

Relationship

Hi i have been in a relationship for 4 years nd i want to marry him but my parents are not accepting even if I no job at all now nd they want to keep my pic in a matrimony website want should I do

Ans: Dear Anonymous,
It is truly important for all, regardless of their gender, to have financial independence. So, I would first suggest you focus on getting a job. And then you might have more strength in your proposal to marry the person you love, and even your parents will know that you can take care of yourself in case the alliance does not go well. I know it hurts you that your parents are not considering your feelings, but I urge you to understand that they are doing everything in your best interest.

Hope this helps.

Ravi Mittal |526 Answers |Ask -Follow

Dating, Relationships Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 08, 2025

Relationship

Me and my girlfriend we both are in relationship from about last 2 years (almost). After such a long time I got to know that she had 2 relationships before me that too she didn't told I got to know it by third person she was sexually involved too (not intercourse but yes other things with one of them)... When I asked her that why you didn't told anything to me before she said she was scared that if she'll tell it to me so I'll leave her and she really did not wanted that... She was scared to loose me. And she was still in contact with that guy and when I asked her that why you were still in contact with him (it's been around 3 years they got separated) so she says that she is like that only... She can't deny anyone because of her soft hearted nature but she did not had any feelings for him. She also said that once she even went to meet him when he requested to meet and also on the same she claims that her soft hearted nature has done that she wasn't able to deny. I loved her too much but now all these things are hurting me like anything. (She is my first relationship before her i never had anyone)

Ans: Dear Anonymous,
I understand that you are hurt and the complexities of the hearts might be difficult sometimes to grasp. The first reason for your sorrow, her past relationship, and the fact that she was physically intimate with them is not completely justifiable. Though I understand that you feel hurt because she did not disclose it to you, still it should not matter so much as to ruin your present relationship. And whether she will open up about such sensitive details is actually up to her. It has nothing to do with how much she loves you or trusts you. Please understand that.

Now coming to the next thing, the fact that she is still in touch with them and has even met one of them, that is slightly concerning. It would have been okay if she did that openly- please understand that I am not saying she should have asked for your permission, but rather discuss the same with you. Moreover, in a relationship, it is also important to understand how much your partner is comfortable with- goes for both men and women. If you are uncomfortable with her relationship with her exes, she should consider that. I would have said the same if the table was turned. I suggest you have a clear conversation with her and express how you feel about this situation- depending on how she reacts and how the conversation goes, you both can think about the next step.

Hope this helps.

Archana Deshpande |100 Answers |Ask -Follow

Image Coach, Soft Skills Trainer - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Question by Mugundu - Feb 08, 2025Hindi

Career

What are all the 5 soft skills

Ans: Hi!!

This was my article in Rediff on world Youth Skills Day.... hope this helps !

https://www.rediff.com/getahead/report/world-youth-skills-day-5-skill-lessons-for-you/20240715.htm

All the best!!

Mihir Tanna |1005 Answers |Ask -Follow

Tax Expert - Answered on Feb 10, 2025

Asked by Anonymous - Feb 01, 2025Hindi

Money

Hi Samkit, I am planning to shift to new tax regime. Could you please let us know if the salary paid to driver or the fuel expenses are considered in new tax regime?

Ans: Salary paid to driver and fuel expenses by employee, reimbursed by employer was never part of income. Said reimbursement was not an income if car is used purely for official purpose and car is owned by employee.

See more questions »

DISCLAIMER: The content of this post by the expert is the personal view of the rediffGURU. Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related document carefully before investing. The securities quoted are for illustration only and are not recommendatory. Users are advised to pursue the information provided by the rediffGURU only as a source of information and as a point of reference and to rely on their own judgement when making a decision. RediffGURUS is an intermediary as per India's Information Technology Act.

Video Reply
Audio Reply

WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
Copy link

Delete

Close

Dear User, You have not registered yet. Please register by filling the fields below to get expert answers from our Gurus

Sign up

email

uname

mobile no

Country Code

Mobile number

By signing up, you agree to our
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

Already have an account?

LOGIN

x