I am 37 years old. Currently due to some family situation I have moved to the outskirts of Mysore. I am currently living on rent here,monthly rent of 15000. I plan to live here for atleast 6-7 years. Should I continue living on rent here or purchase a house here. The house is approximately 45 lakhs. Does it make sense to invest that money in a house here? I have a few mutual funds that I can redeem and surrender a few polices to fund the house. Is it worth buying the house or continue to live on rent.
Ans: You are 37, staying on rent in Mysore outskirts, and considering buying a house worth Rs. 45 lakh. You may use your mutual funds and also surrender insurance policies to fund this house. You plan to live here for 6–7 years.
Let’s assess this carefully from a 360-degree perspective.
We will look at your plan from different angles—cost, liquidity, flexibility, mental peace, future goals, and long-term impact.
Time Horizon is Medium-Term
Let’s first look at your expected stay duration.
You are planning to stay here only for 6–7 years.
This is not a permanent home. So the decision is medium-term.
Buying a house makes better sense only if stay is 15+ years.
For 6–7 years, flexibility is more important than ownership.
After 7 years, you may move to another city or house.
Rental Cost vs. Ownership Cost
Now let us look at your current rent and compare that with home costs.
Current Situation:
You pay Rs. 15,000 rent per month. Annual rent is Rs. 1.8 lakh.
You have no EMI or ownership burden.
Maintenance is taken care of by the landlord.
If You Buy House Worth Rs. 45 Lakh:
You will block a large amount of capital.
If you buy with full payment, you lose liquidity.
If you take a home loan, EMI will cross Rs. 35,000+ monthly.
Property tax, maintenance, and repairs will be extra.
Exit cost later is very high due to stamp duty, registration, broker fee.
Resale after 6–7 years is uncertain in Tier-2 outskirts.
What You Lose By Buying the House
You may feel proud owning the house, but it comes with many costs.
You will redeem mutual funds to fund the house.
This disturbs your long-term goals like retirement or child education.
You may also surrender insurance policies.
Surrendering policies early gives you very low value.
You lose compounding benefits of mutual funds and insurance cover.
You lose liquidity and financial flexibility for next few years.
If your family situation changes again, you may feel stuck.
What You Gain By Staying on Rent
Renting is not a waste. It helps you stay financially strong and flexible.
You keep your investment corpus intact.
You continue SIPs and grow wealth for future.
You can move easily if family needs change again.
You face zero resale stress later.
You avoid property maintenance and local legal hassles.
You don’t have to liquidate mutual funds or surrender policies.
You stay mentally peaceful with more cash flow.
Value of Mutual Fund Investments
Your mutual funds are working hard behind the scenes.
SIPs and lump sum in mutual funds create long-term wealth.
You can keep growing funds for 10–15 years.
They are liquid and can be withdrawn partially anytime.
Returns are market linked, but far better than land or rent savings.
Equity funds especially beat inflation if you stay invested for 7+ years.
Don’t disturb your compounding unless there is an emergency.
Policy Surrender: Risk and Loss
You mentioned that you may surrender policies.
If they are ULIPs or moneyback/ endowment types, they don’t create wealth.
Please surrender those and reinvest in mutual funds.
But if they are pure term plans, please do not stop them.
Protect your family risk first before creating assets.
Do not surrender policies just to buy a temporary house.
Get guidance from Certified Financial Planner on which policy to stop.
Property in Outskirts is Illiquid
You are staying in the outskirts, not a prime city location.
These areas have slower appreciation.
Buyer interest is low when you want to sell.
Resale after 7 years may not cover even your cost.
You will pay stamp duty and broker commission while buying and selling.
Property is not easy to price. Rates are not standard.
Emotional Comfort vs. Financial Clarity
Buying gives a sense of control, but may create new stress.
You may feel you are “wasting” money in rent.
But the real waste is locking money in wrong place.
After 7 years, you will again have to decide what to do with house.
Emotional safety should not hurt long-term financial health.
If the house was for lifetime use, buying could be considered.
Plan Based on Goals, Not Emotion
Let us look at your future plans.
You are 37 now. Retirement goal may be 50 to 60.
You need growing investments to meet that.
Family situation may change in 6–7 years again.
You may move for job, marriage, or children's education.
Buying the house blocks your power to respond to changes.
Renting keeps you light, flexible, and financially strong.
Create a Goal-Based Strategy Instead
Use your funds for purposeful goals, not for dead assets.
Continue your SIPs in equity and hybrid mutual funds.
Keep emergency fund of 6–8 months in liquid funds or FD.
Allocate separately for retirement and medium-term needs.
Review your policies with a Certified Financial Planner.
Shift your insurance-linked investments to mutual funds over time.
Buy a permanent house when you are sure of long-term location.
Don’t Break Compounding to Buy a Temporary Home
Compounding works only if you stay invested.
The longer you stay invested, the more your money multiplies.
Withdrawing mutual funds now slows this entire journey.
Rs. 45 lakh house may give 3–5% annual growth at best.
Same Rs. 45 lakh in mutual funds can double in 7–8 years.
Think 10 years ahead, not just today’s rent.
Tax Benefit Misconception
People think buying house gives tax benefit.
Tax benefit on loan is useful only if you take home loan.
If you buy by paying from savings, there is no tax benefit.
Even with loan, tax saving does not make the house profitable.
Final Insights
You are at the right stage to grow wealth fast.
Buying a Rs. 45 lakh house now for 6–7 years is not the right move.
Continue living on rent. You can change if life changes again.
Let your mutual funds work silently in background.
Surrender ULIPs or other insurance-investments, but not term insurance.
Stay focused on retirement, emergency, and long-term comfort.
Buying house in Mysore outskirts may create a fixed cost and headache.
You don’t need to own a house to feel safe.
Own financial freedom instead. That will give you real peace.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment