
Hi Sir,
I have been investing in mutual funds through SIPs for the last 2 years in my mother’s and father’s accounts. Kindly review my portfolio and advise whether these funds are suitable for achieving around 12%–15% annual returns if I continue for the next 2–3 years.
Below are my current SIP investments:
Mother’s Account – Total SIP: ₹46,000/month
HDFC Large & Mid Cap Fund – ₹10,000
HDFC Focused Fund Reg (G) – ₹5,000
HDFC Mid Cap Fund Reg (G) – ₹15,000
Bandhan Small Cap Fund – ₹5,000
ICICI Pru Value Fund (G) – ₹1,000
ICICI Pru Manufacturing Fund – ₹5,000
ICICI Pru Equity & Debt Fund – ₹5,000
Father’s Account – Total SIP: ₹35,000/month
HDFC Large Cap Fund (G) – ₹5,000
HDFC Mid Cap Fund Reg (G) – ₹15,000
ICICI Pru Equity & Debt Fund – ₹15,000
Please suggest:
Whether the portfolio allocation is good.
If there is too much overlap in HDFC funds.
Whether I should reduce/add any fund categories.
If this portfolio is suitable for a next 2–3 year investment horizon. Because i am thinking to buy a flat after selling these Mutual funds.
Thank you.
Ans: You have built a reasonably diversified portfolio and your SIP discipline is appreciable. But your investment horizon of only 2–3 years changes the entire risk assessment.
» Main Concern – Investment Horizon
Your portfolio is heavily equity-oriented
Equity mutual funds are more suitable for 5–7 years or longer
For a 2–3 year goal like buying a flat:
Expecting 12%–15% annual return is optimistic
Market volatility can affect your corpus at the wrong time
So your current portfolio carries higher risk for this goal.
» Portfolio Review – Overall
Positives:
Exposure across large, mid, small, value and hybrid categories
Hybrid fund adds some stability
SIP investing discipline is very good
Concerns:
Too much concentration in mid-cap oriented funds
Multiple HDFC funds may create overlap
Small-cap and sector/thematic exposure increases volatility
» Overlap in Funds
Yes, some overlap may exist among:
Large & Mid Cap
Focused Fund
Mid Cap Fund
Many quality stocks can repeat across these funds.
This may reduce diversification benefit.
» Manufacturing Fund – Be Careful
Sector/thematic funds are cyclical
They may perform well only during specific market phases
For a short-term goal like flat purchase:
High thematic exposure is risky
» Suggested Direction
For a 2–3 year horizon:
Gradually reduce exposure to:
Small cap funds
Sector/thematic funds
Excess mid-cap concentration
Increase allocation towards:
Hybrid funds
Short duration debt-oriented products
Balanced allocation
This helps protect your flat purchase corpus.
» Important Practical Point
If market correction happens near your withdrawal time:
Your flat purchase plan may get delayed
You may be forced to redeem at lower valuations
So capital protection now becomes more important than aggressive return expectation.
» Better Strategy Going Forward
Continue SIPs for now
But gradually shift part of accumulated corpus to safer assets as goal approaches
Do not wait till last minute to derisk
A phased transfer approach is safer.
» Finally
Portfolio is decent for long-term wealth creation
But slightly aggressive for a 2–3 year flat purchase goal
12%–15% return expectation over short period may not be realistic consistently
Reduce small-cap and thematic exposure gradually
Increase stability-oriented allocation as you move closer to property purchase
Your discipline is strong. Only the asset allocation should now match the timeline of your goal.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.linkedin.com/in/ramalingamcfp/