Motilal Oswal Defence Fund Down - Should I Exit (Harish Parikh)?

Ans: You are in a very strong financial position at 46. Your income is high and stable. You have created multiple assets like flats, lands, PPF, FD, and company stocks. You are also reducing your home loan faster by paying extra EMIs. This is very disciplined. Your expenses are under control compared to income. With the right adjustments, retiring at 55 is possible. Let me share a detailed 360-degree approach to your retirement readiness.

» present financial snapshot

– Monthly income after tax is Rs 2.9 lakh.
– Annual income including bonus is Rs 50 lakh.
– You own two flats worth Rs 2.4 crore.
– One land worth Rs 13 lakh, ancestral land worth Rs 45 lakh.
– Company stocks are Rs 30 lakh.
– PPF corpus is Rs 49 lakh.
– FD worth Rs 28 lakh.
– RD of Rs 1 lakh growing to Rs 1.3 crore on maturity.
– Home loan liability of Rs 84 lakh with insurance cover.
– Child education cost is Rs 2-3 lakh yearly for 7 years.
– Monthly family expenses are Rs 70,000.

This is a strong asset base. Your liabilities are manageable and covered by insurance.

» expense reality and future growth

Monthly household expenses are Rs 70,000 now. But in retirement, expenses will be higher due to inflation. Medical costs will also rise. Lifestyle costs may change, but essentials will grow. We must plan for at least double of today’s expenses in 10 years. This means retirement corpus must be large enough to handle rising costs for 25 to 30 years post retirement.

» importance of retirement corpus

Retirement corpus is not just wealth, it is income replacement. After 55, you may not want to depend on tuition income or new ventures. You must have a pool that generates regular income without eating into capital too fast. This ensures peace of mind and dignity. Without such corpus, even large assets may feel illiquid and unhelpful.

» asset allocation assessment

Currently your wealth is spread across real estate, debt (PPF, FD, RD), and company stocks. Real estate is bulky but not liquid. PPF is safe but returns are moderate. FD is liquid but taxable. RD maturity is strong but very long term. Company stocks are concentrated and risky. This mix needs rebalancing. For retirement, liquidity and stability matter more than just size.

» real estate consideration

You have two flats and lands. These are high in value but not easy to liquidate. Rental yield from flats is also low. So, depending only on real estate for retirement income is not advisable. Real estate is better as a backup asset, not as a primary retirement income tool.

» company stock concentration risk

Rs 30 lakh in company stock is large. If this stock is from your employer, it carries double risk—job risk and stock risk together. For retirement, diversification is key. You should gradually reduce exposure to single stock and move money into diversified equity mutual funds. This reduces volatility and increases reliability.

» PPF and FD

PPF corpus of Rs 49 lakh is excellent. It provides stable tax-free growth. FD of Rs 28 lakh adds liquidity but is taxable. These are good as safe anchors, but not enough to beat inflation for the long term. You need equity allocation for growth.

» RD maturity

Your RD maturing to Rs 1.3 crore is a big plus. It will add huge strength to your retirement corpus. But the maturity value will come later. You must plan how to invest it further for long-term growth rather than keeping only in FD.

» loan liability strategy

Your current home loan is Rs 84 lakh. You are paying extra EMIs whenever possible. This is good discipline. But since the loan is insured, you need not rush to close it early at the cost of investments. Sometimes keeping loan and investing surplus in higher growth instruments works better. A Certified Financial Planner can calculate exact balance for you.

» child education

Education cost is Rs 2-3 lakh annually for 7 years. This is already manageable from your current income. It will not disturb your retirement corpus plan much. But you must keep a separate education fund so that retirement wealth is not touched.

» retirement age and time horizon

You want to retire at 55. That gives you 9 years to prepare. Retirement may last 30 years or more. So your wealth must last from 55 to 85 or even 90. The corpus must be large enough to handle inflation, medical, and lifestyle expenses through these years.

» ideal asset allocation for next 9 years

You should aim for a balanced portfolio.
– 50 to 55% equity mutual funds for growth.
– 35 to 40% debt instruments for stability.
– 5 to 10% gold for hedge.

This mix gives growth to beat inflation and safety to protect capital.

» mutual funds as core

Equity mutual funds are best for long-term retirement building. But only actively managed funds should be considered. Index funds are not enough. They follow market blindly, rise and fall without control. They cannot outperform. Actively managed funds have professional managers. They can rotate sectors, choose quality stocks, and avoid weak ones. For retirement, this adds much needed safety and growth.

» avoid direct funds

Direct mutual funds may look cheaper. But they do not give advice or monitoring. Retirement corpus needs active review and rebalancing. Investing through a Certified Financial Planner ensures right fund choice, portfolio adjustment, and tax management. The small cost difference is worth the protection against mistakes.

» tax planning angle

Equity mutual funds:
– Gains above Rs 1.25 lakh in a year are taxed at 12.5%.
– Short-term gains are taxed at 20%.

Debt mutual funds:
– Gains are taxed as per your income slab.

PPF remains tax-free. FD interest is taxable. So, equity funds are most tax-efficient in long-term planning. A balanced mix reduces overall tax drag.

» estimated retirement corpus

With Rs 70,000 expenses today, you may need Rs 1.4 lakh monthly at 55. Over retirement years, it can grow further. To sustain such rising expenses, you need Rs 6 to 7 crore corpus at retirement. This can generate safe withdrawal income for 30 years.

» how to reach the corpus

– Invest aggressively in equity mutual funds with monthly SIPs.
– Redirect part of FD and stock money into diversified funds.
– Use RD maturity wisely, invest into retirement portfolio instead of only FD.
– Keep PPF till maturity, continue yearly contribution for tax-free safe growth.
– Maintain emergency fund of 6 months expenses in liquid funds.

With current income level, this target corpus is achievable if savings are increased.

» health and protection

Medical expenses are major risk in retirement. Take a strong health insurance cover for self and family. Even if employer provides, get a personal policy. This ensures continuity after retirement. Life insurance is less important if liabilities are covered and children are independent. But health cover is compulsory.

» lifestyle management

Expenses are reasonable at Rs 70,000 now. But in coming years, avoid lifestyle inflation. Additional surplus should go into retirement corpus, not luxury. This discipline in next 9 years will make retirement comfortable.

» withdrawal plan during retirement

Corpus must generate steady income. Strategy can be:
– Debt funds or FDs for near-term withdrawals.
– Equity funds for long-term growth to refill corpus.
– Gold allocation as hedge against crisis.
– Rebalancing every 2 years to maintain safety.

This avoids selling equity at wrong time and gives stable income.

» mistakes to avoid

– Do not over-invest in real estate for retirement.
– Do not keep excess in FD due to tax and low growth.
– Do not depend on single company stock.
– Do not stop SIPs in falling markets.
– Do not ignore inflation in planning.

Avoiding these ensures your plan stays strong.

» finally

You have already created a solid foundation with multiple assets. At 46, you have 9 more active earning years to strengthen further. To retire at 55 comfortably, you should aim for a corpus of Rs 6 to 7 crore. With disciplined savings, equity allocation, debt stability, and wise use of RD maturity, this goal is realistic. Focus on balancing assets, protecting health, and controlling lifestyle costs. Your current strength, if channelled properly, will give you a peaceful and financially free retirement.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

Ans: You have created a very good foundation for your son. At 26 years, he is already earning a healthy salary. He is also disciplined with his investments. This is an excellent start. Many people take years to start. He has started at the right time. With right strategy, his goal of Rs 1 crore in 5 years is possible. Let me share a 360-degree approach for his investments.

» present financial picture

– Monthly income is Rs 1.8 lakh.
– Monthly SIPs already at Rs 40,000.
– Monthly expenses at Rs 40,000.
– He plans emergency fund of Rs 2 lakh in FD.
– Additional Rs 70,000 is available for investment.

This shows strong surplus. His savings ratio is very high. At this age, it is a big advantage.

» emergency fund and liquidity

Emergency fund is important. Rs 2 lakh FD is a good beginning. But emergency fund should be at least 6 months of expenses. That means close to Rs 2.5 to 3 lakh. He can keep some in FD and some in liquid mutual funds. This ensures liquidity and better returns than just FD.

Emergency money must stay safe. Do not touch for other goals. This gives peace of mind.

» risk profile and time horizon

He is young and has 5 years horizon for the Rs 1 crore target. With age on his side, he can take higher exposure to equity. But we should balance risk. Goal is short term in equity terms. So we must not go 100% equity. A mix of equity and debt is safer.

For wealth creation in 5 years, equity mutual funds can work. But we must combine with debt funds for stability.

» existing sips assessment

Currently he invests Rs 25,000 and Rs 15,000. Together Rs 40,000. This is good start. If these are in equity mutual funds, then they are well placed. But he must review if these are actively managed funds.

Index funds look attractive for low cost. But they have clear disadvantages. Index funds simply follow market. They cannot outperform. They also carry market risks fully. Actively managed funds are better. They are run by experienced managers. They can select best stocks and sectors. They also reduce risk by active allocation. So continuing with good active funds is wiser.

» investment allocation for new surplus

He can invest extra Rs 70,000 per month. The allocation should be balanced:
– Around Rs 50,000 in diversified equity mutual funds.
– Around Rs 20,000 in debt mutual funds or short-term funds.

This balance reduces volatility. It also ensures steady growth.

» why avoid direct funds

Direct plans look attractive with lower expense ratio. But direct investing has hidden challenges. Without guidance, investors choose wrongly. Regular plan through a Certified Financial Planner gives professional monitoring. It ensures portfolio rebalancing at right time. It avoids costly mistakes. The extra expense is like insurance for portfolio. The long-term benefits are far higher.

» taxation perspective

For equity funds, new rules apply. If held over 1 year, gains are long-term. Above Rs 1.25 lakh, LTCG is taxed at 12.5%. Short-term gains are taxed at 20%. For debt funds, both STCG and LTCG are taxed at income slab. So he should hold equity funds for at least 1 year. This will reduce tax burden. He should also plan redemptions smartly to keep tax low.

» goal planning for Rs 1 crore

He wants Rs 1 crore in 5 years. With Rs 40,000 SIP and Rs 70,000 extra SIP, total becomes Rs 1.1 lakh monthly. With disciplined equity exposure, reaching Rs 1 crore is realistic. Returns from active funds can compound. But he should not expect straight line growth. There will be volatility. Staying invested is key.

» diversification strategy

He should spread across:
– Large-cap equity funds for stability.
– Mid-cap equity funds for higher growth.
– Hybrid funds for balance.
– Debt funds for safety.

This avoids concentration risk. It ensures smoother growth.

» review and monitoring

Portfolio must be reviewed once a year. Not more frequent, not less. Review should check:
– Fund performance compared to peers.
– Allocation balance as per goal.
– Any need for rebalancing.

If a fund underperforms consistently, it should be replaced. Otherwise, stay patient. Switching too often destroys returns.

» insurance protection

Before wealth creation, protection is must. He should take term insurance. At his age, premium will be low. Cover should be at least 15 times annual income. Also health insurance is compulsory. Even if employer provides, buy one personal cover. Emergency fund, term cover, health cover form a shield. Only after that, investments grow safely.

» behaviour discipline

Most investors fail not due to markets, but due to behaviour. He should stay calm during market falls. He should avoid stopping SIPs. He should avoid withdrawing early. He should not chase latest hot fund. He should trust the process. Patience is the biggest wealth builder.

» retirement and long-term vision

Though current goal is Rs 1 crore in 5 years, he must also plan long-term. Retirement will need a much larger corpus. Starting early gives huge advantage. Even after reaching Rs 1 crore, he must continue SIPs. Wealth creation is not one-time. It is a lifelong journey.

» tax saving investments

He can use tax saving mutual funds under 80C. These give equity exposure with tax benefit. But he must not overinvest only for tax. Tax saving is secondary. Wealth creation is primary.

» lifestyle management

His expenses are Rs 40,000 now. They will grow with lifestyle. But he should avoid lifestyle inflation eating into savings. Saving rate should always stay above 40%. This habit will ensure financial freedom early.

» asset allocation principle

Asset allocation is the engine of growth. Equity gives power. Debt gives balance. A young investor can keep higher equity. But since goal is only 5 years, some debt is needed. 70:30 ratio works well. Closer to goal, reduce equity. Increase debt. This protects the corpus.

» importance of goal-based investing

Every investment should be tied to a goal. Here, goal is Rs 1 crore in 5 years. But he may also have goals like car, house, marriage, retirement. For each, create separate portfolio. This avoids confusion. It also ensures right allocation.

» mistakes to avoid

– Do not stop SIPs midway.
– Do not chase quick returns.
– Do not depend only on FD.
– Do not take tips from friends.
– Do not mix insurance with investment.

Avoiding these mistakes is half the success.

» finally

Your son has strong base. At 26, he is already ahead. With Rs 1.1 lakh monthly SIP, disciplined investing and balance, his Rs 1 crore target in 5 years is achievable. He must stay patient, review yearly, and trust the process. He must continue beyond 5 years for bigger wealth. His early start is his biggest gift. This will give him financial freedom sooner than most people.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

Ans: You have built a strong career with your tuition centre. At 53, you are still active and productive. Your wife is also working, which adds stability. This is a great position. Many people at this age worry about job security. You are your own boss. That itself is a huge blessing. Now, the next important step is preparing for retirement. You want to know the right corpus to lead a comfortable retired life. Let me share a detailed 360-degree plan.

» current financial picture

– Your personal SIP is Rs 3,000 monthly.
– Family SIP is Rs 10,000 monthly.
– Together, investment is Rs 13,000 monthly.
– Current family expenses are around Rs 1.5 lakh monthly.
– No other personal investments are mentioned.

This gap between expenses and savings is large. At present, investment is too small compared to expenses. But you have strong earning capacity. That can be converted into savings with right planning.

» importance of retirement corpus

Retirement is not about stopping work. It is about having financial freedom. Retirement corpus is the fund that gives monthly income in future. Without it, dependence will rise. With it, you can live with dignity and choice. You need a large enough fund to cover 25 to 30 years of post-retirement life.

Expenses today are Rs 1.5 lakh monthly. They will grow due to inflation. After retirement, medical costs also rise. So your corpus must be strong enough to meet all these.

» why current savings are insufficient

Rs 13,000 monthly SIP is too low for this stage. At 53, retirement is close. You may have 5 to 7 active earning years left. That means you have limited time to build wealth. The current contribution is not enough to create required corpus. The good part is, you are still earning high income. If you increase investments sharply now, you can make up.

» action step: increase savings rate

You must increase personal SIP from Rs 3,000 to at least Rs 30,000. Family SIP also should rise from Rs 10,000 to at least Rs 40,000. Together, you must save Rs 70,000 to Rs 80,000 monthly. With this, corpus creation will accelerate.

If you continue only with Rs 13,000, the corpus will not be enough. This will create financial stress in retirement. So scaling up savings is non-negotiable.

» emergency fund and safety

Before raising SIP, keep emergency fund ready. For your family, 6 months expenses is needed. That means around Rs 9 lakh to Rs 10 lakh. This must be kept safe in FD and liquid mutual funds. This will handle sudden shocks. Only after this buffer, invest for long term.

» asset allocation for retirement

At 53, your risk appetite is moderate. Retirement horizon is short. You cannot take very high equity exposure. But you also cannot stay with only debt. Because inflation will eat away returns.

Balanced allocation is wise:
– Around 50% in equity mutual funds.
– Around 40% in debt mutual funds.
– Around 10% in gold funds.

Equity gives growth, debt gives stability, gold gives hedge. This mix will help beat inflation and still reduce volatility.

» role of actively managed funds

Many investors think index funds are enough. But index funds have clear limits. They simply copy the market. They cannot beat it. They also fall fully in crashes. Actively managed funds, run by skilled managers, can give better protection. They can rotate sectors, choose strong companies, and avoid weak ones. For retirement planning, safety and growth are both important. Hence actively managed funds are better than index funds.

» why avoid direct funds

Direct plans look cheaper. But they leave you alone in critical decisions. Without guidance, mistakes are common. For retirement planning, mistakes can cost lakhs. Regular funds through a Certified Financial Planner give better tracking. They help with rebalancing, monitoring, and tax planning. The slightly higher cost is worth the long-term value.

» insurance and protection

Retirement planning is not only about investments. Protection is equally vital. At 53, you must review health cover. Medical expenses are the biggest threat in old age. Buy a good personal health insurance, even if employer or spouse’s employer covers you. Also review life insurance. If children are financially independent, high cover is not required. But if liabilities remain, term cover should continue till they are cleared.

» reducing lifestyle inflation

Your expenses are Rs 1.5 lakh monthly. This is high. It is fine if income supports. But you must watch lifestyle inflation. Each year, expenses must not grow faster than income. Try to cut unnecessary costs. This creates space to increase investments. Remember, each rupee saved today adds security tomorrow.

» retirement income strategy

Corpus alone is not enough. You must design income flow from corpus. The corpus should give stable monthly income without losing growth. This can be managed by:
– Keeping part of corpus in short-term debt for regular withdrawals.
– Keeping part in equity funds to grow and refill.
– Periodically rebalancing between them.

This way, income flows smoothly while corpus continues to grow.

» taxation considerations

For equity mutual funds:
– Gains after 1 year are taxed as long-term.
– Gains above Rs 1.25 lakh are taxed at 12.5%.
– Short-term gains are taxed at 20%.

For debt mutual funds:
– Both short-term and long-term are taxed as per your income slab.

This means equity funds are more tax-efficient for long-term. But since retirement needs stability, debt funds are also necessary. A Certified Financial Planner can guide on withdrawal strategy to minimize tax.

» target corpus estimate

With Rs 1.5 lakh monthly expense today, inflation will double it in future. Retirement could last 25 years or more. So a large corpus is needed. The ideal range can be between Rs 4 crore to Rs 5 crore. This may look high now, but with inflation it is justified. That size corpus will support lifestyle, healthcare, and peace of mind.

» roadmap to reach corpus

– Immediately raise personal SIP from Rs 3,000 to at least Rs 30,000.
– Raise family SIP to Rs 40,000 or more.
– Build emergency fund of Rs 10 lakh in FD + liquid funds.
– Allocate new SIPs into 50% equity, 40% debt, 10% gold.
– Review portfolio once a year.
– Rebalance allocation every 2 years.

This roadmap can move you closer to retirement comfort. Even if you cannot reach exact corpus, you will reach near. That itself reduces stress.

» role of spouse income

Your wife is working. That adds strength. Her income also can support savings. If both of you together increase contributions, retirement planning will be smoother. Discuss and align both goals. Retirement is a family journey, not just personal.

» retirement lifestyle planning

Money alone is not retirement. You must also plan lifestyle. Decide where to stay, how to spend time, what hobbies to pursue. This helps in estimating future expenses better. It also ensures emotional well-being along with financial well-being.

» mistakes to avoid

– Do not postpone higher savings.
– Do not depend only on FD.
– Do not stop SIPs during market fall.
– Do not put money in insurance policies with low returns.
– Do not ignore health insurance.

Avoiding these will make the path smoother.

» finally

You are already successful in your career. At 53, retirement planning is urgent, but not too late. With strong income, you can save aggressively now. Increase SIPs, balance allocation, and secure health cover. Aim for Rs 4 to 5 crore corpus. This will give you a comfortable and stress-free retirement. With discipline and professional guidance, you will achieve it. Your efforts today will gift you and your wife peace tomorrow.

Best Regards,

K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,

Chief Financial Planner,

www.holisticinvestment.in

https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment

Ans: 1. If you are making a gift deed then it is advisable to register it in court.
2. Gifts from father is Exempt and In ITR, under the exempt income, select 'any other' and mention gift from father in description box. It should be disclosed as exempt u/s. 56 in Schedule EI of the ITR.

Vipul Bhavsar
Chartered Accountant
www.capitalca.in

Ans: Anil, The student's concern about COEP's autonomous status affecting MS abroad admission is now outdated. COEP received full university status in June 2022, becoming COEP Technological University. This resolves previous recognition issues, as degrees are now issued by a recognized university, not an autonomous college. WES evaluation is available and international universities can verify credentials directly through the university. COEP E&TC emerges as the prestigious choice with 168+ years legacy, government backing, and recent university status. However, PICT CS offers superior MS abroad prospects due to branch advantages. COEP was established in 1854 with 168+ years legacy while PICT was established in 1983 with 40+ years. COEP has government university status from 2022 while PICT has private autonomous status. COEP has top 100 engineering NIRF ranking while PICT is not in top 100. COEP has 85-90% placement rate while PICT has 90-95%. COEP offers ?8-10 LPA average package while PICT offers ?8-12 LPA. COEP has 15-20% higher studies rate while PICT has 5-8%. Computer Science significantly outperforms E&TC for international opportunities. PICT CS advantages include broader MS options in Computer Science, Data Science, AI/ML, Software Engineering. It has excellent job market abroad with high demand across all industries. It offers research versatility with extensive opportunities in emerging tech domains. It has industry connections with strong ties with global tech companies. COEP E&TC limitations include specialized scope limited to telecom and semiconductor roles. It has fewer MS programs primarily in Electrical Engineering variants. It has moderate job market with niche opportunities compared to CS. Both colleges support WES evaluation and international recognition. COEP advantages include government backing, university status, and prestigious legacy. COEP concerns include new university status may require time for global database updates. PICT advantages include clear University of Pune affiliation and established autonomous recognition. PICT concerns include private institution status and lower overall ranking. Honest student feedback reveals mixed opinions. COEP students appreciate institutional prestige but acknowledge placement packages aren't exceptionally higher than peers. PICT students consistently praise strong industry connections and placement success rates. For MS abroad aspirations, PICT CS is the superior choice scoring 8.5/10 versus COEP E&TC's 7/10. Key reasons include CS branch versatility with multiple MS program options and career paths. It has superior job prospects abroad with high demand in global tech industry. It offers excellent industry connections with better international placement opportunities. It has higher placement rates of 90-95% vs 85-90%. It has clear university affiliation with no recognition ambiguity. COEP E&TC remains excellent with prestigious legacy and university status, but CS branch at PICT provides significantly better MS abroad prospects due to branch advantages and industry alignment with global opportunities. All the BEST for a Prosperous Future!

Follow RediffGURUS to Know More on 'Careers | Money | Health | Relationships'.

Ans: CSE (core) offers the widest prospects, while CSE (AI & ML) and CSE (Data Science) give specialized edges, and IT is slightly narrower but still good.

Good luck.
Follow me if you receive this reply.
Radheshyam

Ans: Boss, chances are slim.

Good luck.
Follow me if you receive this reply.
Radheshyam

Ans: Hi,

First of all, try to overcome your fear. There is no obligation when enrolling in the course, but once you have made your decision, it's important to move forward. If you decide to leave midway, your seat will go to someone else at that institution, and other students who are also interested may suffer as a consequence.

I can sense that there is a lot of confusion in your mind regarding whether to pursue medical or engineering studies. Since you've mentioned that you are not strong in math, you might consider choosing BHMS instead of engineering.

BEST WISHES.

Ans: HI,
Yes, it is possible to secure admission to some engineering colleges in the second round of counseling. Your chances are higher for programs that are less in demand than CSE/IT, such as some less competitive options in ECE, ME, or other branches offered at institutes like JGEC, GCE&TT, or UIT. Plan yourself accordingly.
Participate actively in the counseling process to achieve your goal.

BEST WISHES.